beauty

'I wore expensive makeup on one side of my face and cheap on the other. Here's what I noticed.'

I did myself a little side-by-side test on the weekend (in case it went horribly wrong!)

I decided to apply one side of my face with high-end luxury makeup, costing $951 in total. 

On the other side, I applied chemist brands, and the full price was $268. But let's be honest, we never pay full price, and always purchase when 40 to 60 per cent off. Meaning? It really cost $134.

So, one side was 14 per cent the price of the other.

Watch: Bridal Makeup Artist Natalie Wright teaches us her techniques for a smokey eye with a twist... there's no black eyeshadow in sight. Post continues below.


Video via Mamamia

Can you tell which side is which?

Image: Supplied

ADVERTISEMENT

On the left side [my right in photos], I'm wearing a face full of cheap makeup, and on the right, I'm wearing high-end makeup

Could you tell the difference?

Cheap makeup vs affordable makeup.

The products and prices listed are as follows:

Primer.

Rare Beauty Always an Optimist Illuminating Primer, $45 vs Max Factor Miracle Glow Pro Illuminated, $4.95.

Image: Sephora; MaxFactor; Mamamia

Illuminator.

Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Flawless Filter, $65 vs Nude By Nature Soft Focus Illuminator, $21.

Image: Mecca; Nourished Life; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Foundation.

NARS Radiant Long Wear Foundation, $73 vs Maybelline Dream Urban Cover, $25.95.

Image: Mecca; Adore Beauty; Mamamia

Concealer.

Too Faced Born This Way Concealer, $45 vs ELF Camo Concealer, $10.

Image: Mecca; iHerb; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Powder.

Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Finish Powder, $66 vs Flower Light Illusion Perfecting Powder $9.99.

Image: Mecca; Chemist Warehouse; Mamamia

Bronzer.

Fenty Cheeks Out Cream Bronzer Butta Biscuit, $52 vs ELF Putty Bronzer Tan Lines, $14.

Image: Sephora; Kmart; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Blush.

NARS Orgasm Blush, $45 vs Milani Baked Blush in Dolce Pink, $19.99.

Image: Mecca; eBay; Mamamia

Liquid highlighter.

Charlotte Tilbury Beauty Light Wand Spotlight, $56 vs O.Two.O Rose Gold Good Highlight Starburst [bought for $1.99 at time of purchase on eBay.] 

Image: Charlotte Tilbury, O.Two.O; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Brows.

Benefit 24 The Brow Setter, $45 vs L'Oréal Plump and Set Brow Artist, $20.99.

Image: Benefit; Adore Beauty; Mamamia

Setting powder.

Hourglass Ambient Lighting Powder Dim Light, $75 vs DB Luminous Setting Powder Candlelight,  $14.

Image: Mecca; Designer Brands; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Eyeliner.

Charlotte Tilbury Supernudes Liner Duo Enhance Side, $43 vs Mecca Max Zoom Eyeliner Brown Eye Girl, $17.

Image: Charlotte Tilbury, Mecca; Mamamia

Lip liner.

Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat Pillow Talk, $32 vs NYX Retractable Lip Liner Nude, $9.95.

ADVERTISEMENT

Image: Charlotte Tilbury; NYX Cosmetics; Mamamia

Lipstick.

Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Lipstick, $49 vs Flower Beauty Spiced Petal Lipstick, $9.99.

Image: Charlotte Tilbury; Flower Beauty; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Eyeshadow.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Norvina Palette, $76 vs Revolution Reloaded Vitality, $10.

Image: Adore Beauty; Revolution Beauty; Mamamia

Setting Spray.

Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray, $49 vs Milani Make It Last Setting Spray, $23.99.

Image: Charlotte Tilbury; Priceline; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Highlighter.

MAC Bling Me To Life Mineralise Skin Finish, $59 vs Essence Glow My Mind Backed Highlighter Palette in Middle Shade, $14.95.

Image: Adore Beauty; Kremmania; Mamamia

Total: $951 vs $267.72.

Plus:

Mascara.

L'Oréal Lash Paradise Mascara (top), $24.95 and Maybelline Sky High Mascara (bottom), $24.95.

Image: Adore Beauty; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

Brows.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Defined Soft Brown, $47.

Image: Adore Beauty; Mamamia

Eye pimer.

MAC Cosmetics Paint Pot Soft Ochre, $39.

Image: Adore Beauty; Mamamia

ADVERTISEMENT

How long do cheap vs affordable makeup products last?

In terms of wear, I did a 10 hour test to see the difference between the two sides.

Image: Supplied

The picture on the top left was taken at 10am, the picture on the right at 2pm. 

The picture on the bottom left was taken at 6pm, and the bottom right at 8pm.

It looks like my left side [pictured right in the photos] seems to have worn off more, but I'm not sure if I had rested my hands on it at any stage during the day.

This content was used with permission from the You Beauty Facebook Group. Find more great roadtests and articles from our You Beauty Collective here.

Image: Supplied/Teresa McNamara.