
Shame is such a powerful emotion.
It conjures up feelings of inadequacy, self-doubt and guilt.
Of course a lot of the time, shame comes from an external force – whether it be a wider societal expectation or sometimes even an individual with a decent amount of judgement behind them. And there are not many other facets of life where shame is more apparent than in parenting.
Ask any parent if they've felt shamed by a fellow parent before and the answer will always be a resounding yes.
Because at the end of the day, parenting is incredibly subjective – and everyone has varying perspectives on how best to raise a little human.
Now imagine if you shared your experiences of parenting online, or were in the public eye. With the great big positives of having a community to engage with, it can also come with some downsides. Especially when someone feels the need to tell you, you're parenting wrong via a harshly-worded DM.
To unpack this topic a little further,Mamamiaspoke with seven parents who have a profile – asking them what their experience of parent shaming has been and what they want you to know.
Watch: Parenting 101. Post continues below.
Sean Szeps, writer and podcaster
What are your thoughts and experiences on parent shaming?
"When people ask me what the hardest part of parenting is, I've always said – without a hint of exaggeration – that it is other parents. The judgement, the comparison, the advice, the shaming. It's challenging for even the most confident of parents and thanks to social media, it can often feel totally unavoidable.
"I make a living as a parenting creator on Instagram. I share a great deal of my life with my followers and that means I hear a great deal of opinions, almost exclusively unsolicited, from total strangers each day. It comes with the territory – I did choose the job – but it doesn't make it easier. Not at first, at least.
"The strange thing is, every person online has their own specific criteria for what makes a great parent. They each care about very different things, so the opportunities for critiques are endless. On Monday someone is upset that you let your child walk barefoot on the pavement, on Tuesday someone tells you to cut up their lunch into smaller pieces and on Wednesday someone says they shouldn't be watching a certain show on a certain network at a certain time of day.
"Often times the shaming comes without necessary context. I'll get 'He needs his seatbelt on, Dad!' even though we're in a parked car after driving home from the store.
"It might be three of a thousand messages you receive in a day. Sure, a rational person does quick maths and reminds themselves that it's only 0.3 per cent negativity. But when you're stressed and sleep deprived and busy and already worried about being a good enough parent, rational thinking goes out the damn door."
Listen to Mamamia's podcast. This Glorious Mess. Post continues after audio.
What do you want people to know about parenting in the public eye?
"Because I'm a gay father, the parenting shaming is usually a bit more… personal. On top of micro-critiques like 'he really should be wearing a hat and sunnies', you're navigating an inbox filled with larger attacks like 'your daughter really needs a mother' or 'we voted for you to marry, not to ruin kid's lives by becoming parents'.
"The bad news: It's impossible to not take it personally in the beginning. You're trying your very best to keep your children alive and the criticisms – even those delivered with kindness – force you to question your well-intended decisions. And even though you make 1000 decisions a day and you're only sharing 15 seconds of one decision, the feedback is there, you read it and you ask yourself: 'Am I doing this parenting thing right?'
"I do often wonder if some of the shaming I receive is because I'm a man. Historically, the majority of parenting responsibilities have fallen on women. And that makes them, justifiably, subject matter experts. In a world where men have often taken a backseat in parenting, I imagine some women – usually older ones – think that I need help without a wife or mother around. That it's their duty to provide me, an idiot dad, with necessary advice.
"The good news: it gets easier and easier. The more critiques you hear, the more de-sensitised you become. You start to realise you can't please everyone and if you're like me and making a living online, you come to realise their opinions are actually none of your business. You acknowledge within yourself that parenting is hard and everyone does it differently and then you ignore the noise of shaming and focus on trying your very best. Because at the end of the day, it's not the opinions of strangers that matter but those of your own partner, your children and yourself."
Leigh Campbell, @leighacampbell
What are your thoughts and experiences on parent shaming?
"Sadly the 'parenting' space is one of those most judged spaces on the internet. I have been lucky in that I have curated a like-minded group of women, so my online audience is overwhelmingly supportive. Of course there's the odd person who uses judgement and doxing in place of reflecting on themselves, but that's what the block button exists for."
What do you want people to know about parenting in the public eye?
"I think parenting in the public eye and parenting online is different. In the public eye, to me, means in public – at the shops, any time outside of the home. This applies to true Hollywood celebrities. Online, on the other hand, is different in that the parent chooses what they share, which is an important distinction.
"When my son was first born I shared much more, but I have since evolved my view on what parts of his life I am comfortable portraying online. I don't talk about medical issues, I never show him sad, crying or having a tantrum. Sure I show images of him and the fun activities we do, but I don't share details of 'his life' that I feel he could have issues with later down the track. I show about 10 percent of our lives in regards to parenting. It's an evolving space and if/when he decides he doesn't want me to share at all, of course I will respect his wishes."
Isabella Ross
Senior News Writer
No Comments
Be the first to leave a comment