@snorks I just don't think it's a quick fix to
@snorks not sure whom you mean by 'they'.
@snorks if the referendum is successful I think a key question would be how to create the right conditions in the system so that a new pattern can emerge.
@snorks The outcomes from those workshops must have been disappointing and disheartening for the local council and the community.
Thank you for talking about healing @snorks. I think that’s where our nation is poised.
@snorks Well it's like Margaret Mead said 'Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.'
@snorks To my way of thinking, it’s more like firmly holding the rudder off-centre to counter a cross-wind.
Hello again @snorks :)
@snorks That's the thing - whether a VTP is permanent or not (or as permanent as the constitution). As it currently stands, it's not.
@howtoexplain and @snorks It sounds reasonable to me that when we are being asked to vote on something, we understand what it is. Hopefully, forums like this give us the opportunity to ask questions without fear of being cancelled.
@myopinion Yes, from the Productivity Commission figure from around that time. Closer analysis of that figure by fact checkers revealed that 80% of that figure was on mainstream services, leaving $5.6B on targeted indigenous programs. So I accept that my $4.2B figure was a bit low compared to $5.6B.
@snorks Yes, I agree. Federally, about $4.2B per year across all portfolios over the forward estimates. To put that in context, federal expenditure on social welfare for the whole population is $230B, about 35% of the federal budget. If I'm reading the aph charts correctly, the federal budget is around $640B / yr. So I calculate federal indigenous spend to be about .66% of the federal budget for 3% of the population.
@Howtoexplain To me it's more like being asked to decide whether we are willing to make a contract with ATSI peoples to not ghost them on matters that affect them. To date, the government of the day decides whether ghosting is OK. Sounds to me like ATSI peoples are asking us to commit to not ghosting them ever again. How that happens would continue to be a matter for legislation with many eyes over it before anyone signs it.
This is the best explainer I've seen to date.