The Duchess of Cambridge is dangerous.
Did you know?
Lock your doors, people. Be alert not alarmed. The Duchess is out to brainwash little girls into becoming grown up doormats with a single digit BMI (but with truly awesome hair).
At least that’s what writer Maggie Hamilton seems to think. (Okay maybe not the awesome hair bit… I made that up).
Usually I consider myself to be a fairly reasonable person. I work hard to see both sides to most arguments. And I can understand (most of the time) where people are coming from even if I don’t agree with them.
But today, I just can’t do that.
I have sat for the past week and gritted my teeth as a critical post about the Duchess of Cambridge has gone viral on Mamamia.
A post by Maggie Hamilton claiming that the Duchess of Cambridge is, in fact, a threat to our daughters.
A threat? What kind of threat? On a scale of 1 to 10 (1 being a Bratz doll and 10 being Dating Harry Styles… where does the DoC sit? Somewhere between airbrushing and the thigh gap trend?)
For those playing along at home, here’s a snapshot of what Maggie had to say in her piece (in the event you are one of the five people in this country who has yet to read it):
I have nothing against Kate. I am sure that she is nice, that she is a good wife, a good daughter, a good person, and of course, a great mother. But I do have a problem with her being held up as an ideal of exemplary womanhood, a wonderful role model for our daughters, an antidote to the Kim Kardashians of the world.
Then there was this bit:
Kate and Wills, the story goes, are a love match. I’m sure they are, but it was a love match for which a woman had to sacrifice her freedom, her youth, her independence and, many would argue, her personality. To marry the man of her dreams, she had to change who she was, give up her privacy, paid employment, ensure her 20s were entirely scandal-free and lose half her body weight. This is not something I would wish for my daughter.
Maggie then spends a few paras essentially claiming that Catherine’s warmth and graciousness as she speaks to members of the public is one big lie! It’s a PR exercise, says Maggie! Don’t be fooled! Any minute now the Duchess is going to try and sign us up to Amway.
And she ends with this:
And that’s why Duchess Kate is dangerous for our daughters. She has revived the idea that women being defined by who they marry is a positive life choice.
Okay, so let’s just start to unpack all this.
As far as role models go, I think the Duchess of Cambridge is a delightful choice.
(That said, I think it’s healthy for kids and, err, grown women to have a few role models from different walks of life because the fact is – there is no perfect person. We all screw up and putting all your focus and attention on any one hero or role model or mentor is a recipe for disaster and also a bit one dimensional.)
But when I look at the Duchess of Cambridge, I see a young woman who is handling the extreme pressures of royal life with absolute grace and charm. I see a woman who is genuine in her love of kids and her desire to be of service – REAL service – to the community.