It was even the subject of a special Mamamia investigation, performed by our own international Bachelor super fan, Zara McDonald.
Now, in his first post-Bachelor interview on KIIS FM the marketing manager was grilled by hosts Hughesy and Jackie O on what actually happened that night, addressing the rumour for the first time.
And guys, now we know once and for all he didn’t have sex with Elora – but he was tempted.
“Did I sleep with Elora? I did not, no,” Matty told Jackie and Hughesy, who was filling in for an unwell Kyle Sandilands.
Jackie prodded the reality star further, asking him, “Was it tempting?”
“Yeah, you know when you have a really great date with somebody and you know the option is there, it does enter your mind. But it was an easy decision to say no to that and to be in separate rooms.”
This is all while Laura is sitting right next to him, something that we can only imagine would be slightly awkward.
However, showcasing her laid-back personality, the jewellery designer said, “Well, she’s a babe and he’s a red hot blooded male so I would expect there was temptation there.”
And since the Kyle and Jackie O show not the kind of program to hold back on the sex talk, the hosts allowed a listener to ask the Matty and Laura how soon after the finale they played “hide the sausage”.
Listen: Michelle and Zara recap The Bachelor finale. (Post continues after audio.)
While Matty joked it was seconds after shutting the door to their Thailand hotel room, Laura clarified that wasn’t quite how their first time went down.