news

Naomi Williams was sent home from hospital with two panadols. 15 hours later she was dead.

 

 

Naomi Williams was six months pregnant with her first baby when she arrived at the local hospital in the small country town of Tumut, NSW, in the early hours of New Year’s Day in 2016.

She’d been vomiting all evening. She had a severe headache, her back kept spasming.

Despite her partner Michael Lampe urging her to go to hospital, the disability worker didn’t want to go. She hated going to hospital and often put it off until she was very sick.

Children in the Indigenous communities of the Kimberley, Western Australia, tell us what they aspire to be. Post continues after video.

Naomi had long lost confidence in Tumut hospital staff’s ability to help her, having visited 18 times in the seven months prior with vomiting and nausea, sometimes diarrhoea and dehydration, only to be discharged each time with no relief or explanation of the pain she was suffering. In her 18 visits, she had never been referred to an obstetrician or a gut specialist, instead she was repeatedly referred to mental health or drug and alcohol services – even though Naomi had no history of drug or alcohol problems and the services had already determined she had no dependence issues.

She felt that the hospital staff were ignoring her pleas; they’d already written her off as a drug addict. She kept telling the friends and family who urged her to go to hospital that she “wasn’t getting treated right” and they “wouldn’t find out what was wrong with her”.

This time was no different.

Two emergency nurses quickly looked at her, gave her two Panadols and sent her home. No physical examination was taken, nor a formal pain assessment. Her medical history wasn’t checked and the doctor on duty was not called.

In a little over half an hour, Naomi Williams was once again discharged from hospital with no answers for her ongoing pain.

She returned home, still in pain and still vomiting. As the morning wore on, she deteriorated fast. It got so bad Michael had to help her go to the toilet and shower. At about 1.30pm, Naomi collapsed in the hallway. She couldn’t feel her legs anymore.

An ambulance was called and she was taken back to the hospital but it was too late. Naomi went into the cardiac arrest.

Fifteen hours after she had was sent home from the hospital for the nineteenth time, Naomi Williams and her unborn baby – a son she and Michael had already picked out a name for, Tristan – were declared dead. She was just 27 years old.

An autopsy found that Naomi had died of sepsis, a serious infection but one that is treatable with antibiotics.

Listen to Barbie Lee Kirby’s conversation with Marlee Silva on our Tiddas 4 Tiddas podcast here. She talks about her experience of growing up in Brewarrina to becoming one of Australia’s leading women in the corporate sector:

Now a coronial inquest into the Wiradjuri women’s death has concluded that there was implicit bias in the way Naomi was treated by staff at Tumut hospital.

The three-year inquest, which released its findings on Monday, found that Naomi should have received further examination on the day she died and made several recommendations to address the health system’s treatment of Indigenous people.

Harriet Grahame, the deputy state coroner, accepted the two emergency nurses couldn’t have known Naomi had a life-threatening infection that would soon kill her.

But their failure to call in a doctor, look at Naomi’s history or wonder why a pregnant woman would attend hospital on New Year’s Day, solely for Panadol, hadn’t helped.

“Curiosity in a safe environment may have kept Naomi long enough for swift and appropriate intervention when her condition did not improve,” Grahame said.

“At the very least, a doctor should have been contacted by telephone for advice and management.”

“On the face of the evidence, the sheer number of presentations prior to 31 December 2015, without specialist review, is deeply troubling.”

Among nine recommendations, Grahame advised Murrumbidgee Local Health District – the operator of Tumut Hospital – to investigate systematic bias against Indigenous people in the health system, increase representation of Indigenous health care staff and start a 24-7 Aboriginal health contact for the hospital.

For Naomi’s friends and family, and the wider Indigenous community, the coronial inquest findings finally acknowledged what they had known for so long.

George Newhouse of the National Justice Project, which represented the Williams family throughout the coronial inquest, said Naomi’s family feel validated that the coronial inquest recognised that bias impacted the treatment of Naomi.

“They feel they’ve been heard, someone is finally listening,” he told Mamamia, “especially when the coroner acknowledged Naomi’s extremely low expectation the quality of care she would receive from the hospital were justified.”

“It’s extremely difficult for Aboriginal people to seek and obtain vindication, because navigating the system is complex and they feel powerless within it. Ultimately, they really appreciate the findings,” he added.

Newhouse said that the coronial findings were a good start, but if Indigenous people are to feel safe in hospitals, the changes recommended needed to be implemented Australia-wide.

“The coroner has done all Australians a favour by naming one of the factors that contributed to Naomi’s death as implicit bias on the basis of her race,” he said. “If we live in denial, the pain will continue.”

“The findings show bias and unconscious prejudices can kill. If we truly care, we need to all work together and provide a safe place Aboriginal people can get genuine care.”

Academic commentator Anita Heiss said her cousin was a “shining light in our lives” who loved movies, music, painting and writing poetry about the river and her family.

“We are reminded today that Naomi was desperate for help but her pleas were not heard by the health service in Tumut,” she told reporters on Monday.

“Naomi was sick for a very long time and no one listened to her or helped her. She was invisible to the health system. She felt it didn’t value her as a person.”

To the NSW health system Naomi may have been invisible, but to her family Naomi will always be remembered as the strong Wiradjuri woman who passionately advocated for Indigenous issues.

— With AAP. 

Top Comments

Kimbo 5 years ago

I'm beyond words, the medical negligence is shocking. I feel absolutely awful for Naomi's husband and family, to know that she could've been fine if the nurses etc did their job without discrimination must be even more heartbreaking and devastating.
Condolences to all.
I hope all staff are reviewed and reprimanded.


chrisandalex 5 years ago

How heartbreaking for the family! I know this isn’t the most important part of the story but, how were the nurses able to give her Panadol without a doctor seeing her first and writing up a medication form? And send her home before the doctor had seen her. I rarely need to go to emergency, but was there two weeks ago with my son. I had given him nurofen a couple hours before going in and the nurses didn’t mention giving Panadol until the doctor had been in to see him. Even when he’s an inpatient, a doctor will check him over and have a chat with me before writing him up for Panadol if I’ve asked for it to be written up as a precaution (I’m lucky that doctors and nurses believe me when I say my son starts vomiting soon after his temp hits 38, so he needs Panadol before he gets to 38). The doctor also comes to chat with us before discharge to ensure I’m happy with the treatment plan once home.

Sunbee 5 years ago

I'm in Vic - at our local hospital, the triage nurses offer you a Panadol if you state you're in pain. This is before you're admitted and long before you see a doctor, and no medication form is written up.

I suspect the policy would be different for children though.

Guest 5 years ago

Paracetamol is a "nurse initiated medication" in that registered nurses can dispense single doses without authorisation from medical personnel (to make it a recurring order they need to involve a doctor). Further to this, nurse practitioners have limited prescribing rights and can do so autonomously.

Guest 5 years ago

In small,non metropolitan hospitals, the doctors are on call. The nurses make the initial assessment and based on their findings would call the doctor in to see the patient if needed. Nurses in those regional medical facilities need to be highly skilled in patient assessment which may or not always be the case. I think city centric Australians forget that many country towns do not have a doctor at all. As to the poor girl who died, you wouldn't have ongoing sepsis, but you would probably need to read the coroner's findings for the accurate facts.

Leslea 5 years ago

Are you white???