kids

"'Concierge parents' are ruining teachers' lives and oh crap... I just realised I am one."

Move over snowplough parenting; there’s a new breed of parent in town – the ‘concierge parent’. And, according to the definition, I am one.

This week, principal of St Catherine’s School in Waverley, Julie Townsend, told The Sydney Morning Herald that concierge parents are typically defined as those who “are there at a little desk waiting for any problems” before they “sort them out” for the offspring.

In other words, a concierge parent simply awaits issues, and then promptly responds to them in a calm manner to prevent consequences for their kids. (This is different to a ‘snowplough parent’, in that this type of parent bulldozes any obstacles in their child’s way.)

Mamamia spoke to David Gillespie, author of Teen Brain, a lawyer, and father-of-six, to find out more, who further explained that concierge parenting is “something parents do to remove all negative natural consequences for a child, which is unhelpful as natural consequences are the most effective way anyone can learn anything.”

WATCH: Holly Wainwright explains parental equality. Post continues after.

Gillespie added that concierge parenting is risky because, “saying no to a child has a benefit.”

“It means the parent is more in control of what’s going on. And it means the child is more used to being told no.”

In Gillespie’s opinion, “the most important thing you can say to a child is no. It doesn’t have to be no all the time, it just means that when you say no they know mean it.

“And the problem with concierge parenting is that you never say no.”

And so, my friends, I’ve realised I’ve been doing some concierge parenting.

You see, up until very recently, I would write notes to my son’s teachers with excuses as to why he hadn’t completed all of his homework, almost every week. (Please relax, most of it would get done.)

Here’s my defence: last year, I began a full time job in a brand new industry, in a brand new city, and as a sole parent. So each night after work, the last thing I’d want to do is battle with my son about maths and comprehension (but really, just maths).

So every Thursday night, I would write a note saying, "Sorry we couldn't finish some of the homework this week, we were too busy."

Let's face it, the teachers knew (because I admitted it at some point) we were not 'busy', but that I just didn't have the fight in me on some nights.

They knew my note was a desperate plea to be excused from long division. And they knew, because of my parental guilt, I thought I should take the fall for that - and shield my kid from the consequences of presenting unfinished work.

Judge me all you like. I've been judging myself for it - even more since I learned this behaviour had a name.

Of course, there are parents for whom concierge parenting is a way of life. Felicity Huffman and Lori Loughlin, both of whom allegedly bribed college admission and academic successful for their daughters, might be the most high-profile recent example.

According to The Sydney Morning Herald, concierge parents further account for "maybe 10 per cent of families. But they take up 90 per cent of your time."

So I asked Gillespie why parents practice concierge parenting.

"This is the most child-centric parenting has ever been," he explained. "We've seen a real shift over the decades to parents ensuring their child's comfort and immediate gratification is the priority."

Gillespie shared that apart from concierge parenting being bad for families, it also has terrible consequences for educators.

"It means schools are operating defensively," he said. "Teachers are worried there's going to be parent in the office by the end of the day, because their child has been made to suffer a natural consequence. So, they're more likely to put up with bad behaviour."

For parents (much like me) who struggle to break some concierge parenting habits, Gillespie had some excellent advice.

"Think of what's at stake, beyond your child's immediate gratification," he suggested. "Truly examine why you're making a choice, then choose your battles, say no to the important things.

"And remember that nothing works all the time - so don't be too hard on yourself."

What do you think of concierge parenting? Tell us in the comments below.

If you'd like to hear more from Nama Winston, see her stories here, and subscribe to her weekly Mamamia Parents newsletter here.

Pregnant? Or planning? Sign up to our Before The Bump newsletter for the best stories and advice from women who've been there.

Related Stories

Recommended

Top Comments

Monster 5 years ago

Classic 21st century parenting - I will make myself feel good by making my child feel good. End result? Spoiled, spineless babies inhabiting 30 year old bodies.
Do yourself and the world a favour and instill some self-discipline and nobility early on! It will save you years of heartache and shame further down the track... and society benefits!!


selkiem 5 years ago

Bottom line, you're not doing your kid any favours. Yes it is exhausting, but if there are structures and rules, the homework gets done. Is it hard? Absolutely - and exhausting.. but that is what you took on when you had a kid. I was disgusted at the entitlement and narcissim I saw in the schools among the kids (through no fault of their own) and their parents - who are so damn afraid of not being "friends" with their kids they refuse to follow through. And constantly interceding to get your kid a pass is the worst - you are crippling them and making it way more difficult in the future when you're not around and the horrible realization dawns they are NOT the center of the universe and no, you DON'T get a pass just for being you. I feel so bad for teachers - because inevitably those are the same parents who come in and create hell when their little darling doesn't make the grade.

chrisandalex 5 years ago

I find most teachers don’t mind how homework is presented, as long as it gets done. My 12 year old hated writing out spelling words in primary school. I felt it wasn’t something we needed to argue over every day, so we mixed up how he did it. One day it would be handwritten, another day he would type the list, another day I would verbally test him. Each year I spoke to his teacher to let them know what we would be doing and they were always fine with it. By grade 6, in the letter advising about homework they had a list of suggestions of how the students could practice their weekly spelling list other than just writing it out. My son did wear the consequences if homework wasn’t completed, though.