Why is this man everywhere?

I was perusing Reddit recently, my go-to for questionable celebrity gossip and people asking 'am I the a***hole?' (always yes), when I came across a post that made me laugh out loud.

It was a screenshot from juicy goss Insta account Deuxmoi about the casting of the upcoming Wicked movie. Now, I bloody love Wicked - who doesn't? - so I was excited. The blind post suggested that lots of 'big names' were being considered for the role of the Wizard, but "not James Corden".

Among many of the comments, one person stated: "Angel of Music please keep James Corden out of this movie". 

Watch: Lest we forget one of Corden's biggest roles was in... Cats. Post continues below video.

Video via Universal Pictures.

In 11 words, they surmised the thoughts and feelings of the entire sub, and many other vocal pop culture fans right across the internet.

As the first Wicked casting announcements were made (Ariana Grande as Glinda! Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba!), fans took things further. Namely, with a very succinct petition to Universal Pictures, which is producing the movie.

"James Corden in no way shape or form should be in or near the production of Wicked the movie," it reads. "That's pretty much it."

It has garnered more than 70,000 signatures in four days.

James Corden is everywhere, and the people have noticed. He's in all the musicals. He's on stage at all the award shows. He's dancing in the streets of Los Angeles dressed as a mouse. My main question is... why?

Corden's career up until this point is actually quite spectacular, and with every new role he takes on, that becomes more true.

He began his career in theatre at 18, starred in British TV advertisements in the late 1990s and had small television roles throughout the early 2000s. He guest starred on the extremely popular Little Britain, and starred in British drama Fat Friends from 2000 until 2005.


But his 'big break' came with his own series, sitcom Gavin & Stacey, which he co-wrote and starred in from 2007 until 2010. For this, he won many awards including multiple BAFTAs, but he's even better remembered for the one he didn't win.

In 2008, Corden drew the ire of Brits - for whom understatement is such a way of life it has its own Wikipedia page -  after moaning about Gavin & Stacey not being nominated for that year's best comedy BAFTA award.

Corden at the 2008 BAFTAs. Image: Getty. 

In a January 2020 interview, he admitted he had begun to "behave like a brat" around this time.

"I started to behave like a brat that I just don't think I am," he told the New Yorker.

"It's so intoxicating, that first flush of fame. And I think it's even more intoxicating if you're not bred for it."

That makes sense. He's hardly the only person to let fame get to his head. But the interview's presumption that Corden had put that behaviour behind him was called into question a few months later, when Corden became the internet's new favourite enemy, after the 'cancellation' of Ellen DeGeneres.

There have been articles about Corden's perceived 'bad' attitude floating around from 2017, and in 2010 there was commentary about a very awkward, very public run in he had with Sir Patrick Stewart.


In 2019, Corden made an appearance on Reddit's AMA (Ask Me Anything) thread to promote a special edition of Carpool Karaoke, but it massively backfired. Comments calling Corden names hijacked the thread. With more than 700 comments, Corden and his team were reportedly only able to answer about three fan questions before leaving the conversation.

One person claimed Corden had "allegedly showed up to a WGA [Writer's Guild Of America] union meeting for late night writers with an executive producer and none of the writing staff" and advocated less pay for new writers under their union-negotiated minimum wage.

Corden had previously denied this was the case.

Image: Getty. 

In October 2020, Vanity Fair published a profile on comedian Eric Andre in which he criticised cancel culture.

"Boohoo, Ellen was mean. Who gives a s***? I never thought she was nice! She seems like she’d be like, 'F***ing get me a coffee! Now!' Is that what cancel culture's devolved to? 'That guy's not nice!' James Corden is f***ed if that's the only criteria to get called out," he said.

Within days of the Andre interview, Deuxmoi (which, for the uninitiated, shares mostly anonymous messages about celebrities/pop culture, sent in by followers) had posted several stories alleging negative interactions with Corden.


Deuxmoi does not confirm statements, and they all came from anonymous Instagram users, but allegations included Corden being rude to wait, airline and restaurant staff.

Corden at the 2021 Met Gala. Image: Getty. 

We should never tolerate rude behaviour, but Hollywood is hardly the place to look for a moral high ground. 

It's an industry where secrets and abuse have been able to thrive for decades on end, so the fact that someone within the machine is maybe rude to the person serving them food is so unremarkable that it barely warrants an eyebrow raise outside the messy walls of Twitter and Reddit.

In that sense, the fact that Corden's career has faced no repercussion makes sense.

The more baffling angle appears when you look deeper at his filmography.

Among his roles are children's films The Emoji Movie and Peter Rabbit. 

The Emoji Movie was an absolute critical bomb, and in one review of Peter Rabbit, a reviewer labelled Corden as "appallingly irritating". I haven't seen the film so I cannot comment on this, but it is not an isolated dig.

His three most recent non-animated roles are as Bustopher Jones in Cats, Barry Glickman in The Prom and James in Amazon's Cinderella remake.


I don't need to say too much about Cats. If you've seen it, you know how much of a disaster it was. If you haven't seen it, you still know how much of a disaster it was.

The Prom, a Netflix movie based on the 2018 Broadway musical of the same name, received mixed reviews, though they appeared glowing in comparison to Cats. The consensus was however, that this was in spite of Corden, rather than thanks to him.

He starred as Barry Gluckman, a camp, narcissistic Broadway actor. Corden is a straight man, so the decision to cast him as a gay character caused criticism. Some viewed his performance as perpetuating and capitalising on stereotypes of gay men. 

"Few straight actors could get away with a gay character like this, a role that would feel stereotypical in an 80s sitcom and here feels offensive," Newsweek critic Samuel Spencer said, noting Corden was "offensively miscast" in the role.

Vanity Fair's Richard Lawson called it so bad "no more straight actors [should play] gay men until the sins of The Prom are properly atoned for".

Despite the negativity, Corden received a Golden Globes nomination for the performance. He was the only person in the cast, which also included Meryl Streep, to receive recognition.


Corden memes have popped up in my social media feeds since at least the late 2019-Cats era, and enjoyed a resurgence with his involvement in Cinderella. The idea to reinterpret the fairytale came from him, and he also produced the film. It has a 42 per cent rating with critics on Rotten Tomatoes.

The memes were taken to new heights after he and the cast staged a performance while drivers waited at a red light on the streets in LA to promote the movie.


Before any information of Wicked's casting was announced, rumours swirled Corden would be involved.

The accuracy of these rumours is yet to be determined, and cynically, I think making something up about his involvement is a surefire way to up your engagement.

Regardless, the story took off. Corden's appeared in almost every major movie musical for years, so even if there's only one conceivable role he could play in Wicked (Doctor Dillamond, the talking goat), the story seems comprehensible.


Corden's resume includes two Meryl Streep movies, but it's far from glowing. He doesn't bring in great reviews, or huge box office numbers. 

So why won't Hollywood give up on him?

There's certainly an element of oversaturation to blame for all the Corden hate, as well as bandwagoning. It's cool to slate Corden right now, which is clear by the thousands of likes on Tweets making fun of him.


And he has, of course, had plenty of genuine success.

Corden has been hosting his late night TV show since 2015. If I had to choose a Corden to watch, it would be this one. Here, his form of comedy - based on viral bits and his buddy relationships with major celebrities, especially the men of One Direction - results in continuously solid ratings. 

From a business perspective, this must also be a very attractive asset to casting directors. Of course he's going to publicise his own work on his own show, which is a huge marketing win.

But while he clearly has audience appeal on The Late Late Show, that doesn't appear to crossover to film. The memes, the reviews, the petitions, and the box office are proof of this.

The comedian, actor and late-night talk show host is one of the busiest people in Hollywood, but he definitely does not have the Midas touch.

So, as those in charge of casting continue to favour him, we're all still here wondering... why? 

Chelsea McLaughlin is Mamamia's Senior Entertainment Writer. For more pop culture takes, sarcasm and... cat content, you can follow her on Instagram.

This article was originally published on September 24, 2021 and has been updated.

Feature image: Getty/Mamamia.

Love the joy of Christmas? Take our survey now to go in the running to win a $50 gift voucher.