opinion

Olympic gold medallist Mack Horton is not a racist, but we still have a problem.

I have never been a big sports fan. It’s just too emotional for me. Especially swimming.

Swimming is visceral and leaves nothing to the imagination. Every movement, every technique, every misstep, there are no ifs, only replays.

So when this latest row between Mack Horton and Sun Yang escalated, my anxiety levels shot through the ROOF.

It all started during a training session before the 400m fresstyle race. Depending on where you get your news from, Sun either splashed Horton as a friendly gesture to say “hello” or it was an aggressive playground “taunt“.

When asked about the incident, Horton fired the opening shot saying he ignored it because he has “no time or respect for drug cheats.” Not entirely untrue. And it was brave of Horton to call it out.

Horton reiterated it himself during a post-race conference saying  he has "a problem with athletes who have tested positive and are still competing.”

He said this sitting next to Sun himself, who replied (in Mandarin) “On the competition stage, every athlete deserves to be respected, and there’s no need to use these sort of cheap tricks to affect each other.”

SOOO AWKWARD.

But it got worse.

To the Chinese, this was not just an affront on one of their athletes, but a gesture of provocation to the entire team.

Horton's critics argued that he should apologize to Sun, that he is a racist, hypocrite, disrespectful and at the very least, it goes against the spirit of the Games. It's misconduct. Xinhua gleefully reported that the IOC was looking into the incident.

The backlash against Horton says more about Australia's race relations than his actual stance against doping.

It's true. Australia does have some serious issues with race. There's not enough representation in our media, we have elected the likes of Pauline Hanson, we imprison refugees and we have a troubled and disturbing relationship with our indigenous citizens.

Watch: The Out Loud team talk all things Pauline Hanson. (Post continues...)

Horton wanted to shed light on what he thought was an affront to sportsmanship: doping and cheating.

What he did was open a pandora's box.

To the Chinese, Horton's comments are yet another example of an Australian exerting their moral superiority over a proud country. Whether he intended to or not, Horton has incensed China's rising young nationalists and they are responding with force and numbers on social media, occupying the accounts of many on the Australian swim team. Yeah, they're trolling in droves.

Any Chinese person can tell you about the casual racism that seeps into daily life in Australia. I've written about it in regards to real estate. But you'll find casual remarks in regards to parenting, schooling and most certainly, choice of profession ("you must work in IT!"). This scuffle has opened a deep wound between Australia and one of its closest and largest trading partners.

Unfortunately this has distracted the issue of what Horton was intending to highlight in the first place. Good, clean sportsmanship.

To top it all off, the Chinese swim team are now demanding an apology from Horton. "We think his inappropriate words greatly hurt the feelings between Chinese and Australian swimmers. It is proof of a lack of good manners and upbringing" according to the team manager Xu Qi. 

I can't imagine under any circumstances that Horton will apologise, nor should he. A view expressed by the AOC "Mack is entitled to express his point of view."

Mack Horton, you're not a racist. But Australia? The jury is out on that one.

Related Stories

Recommended

Top Comments

guest 8 years ago

i will not comment regarding the horton vs. sun issue, but seeing the people throw around the term racism like they know what they're talking about, so i digress...
as an immigrant from hong kong living in new york and in the setting of many race-related events happening across the united states, let me tell you what racism is.
racism is the systematic oppression of a specific race. white people has never experienced that, so there is no such thing as racism towards white people (yes I'm looking at those of you who said the racism is going the other way). at least not now. maybe in the future theoretically sure you could have systematic oppression of white people but that has never happened
therefore white people don't get to determine what is racist or not, period.
implicit or what you guys call "casual" racism is something only the victims of racism can perceive. racists behavior lie in the spectrum from microaggressions to explicit racism. most of you who have never been on the receiving end of racism will never understand anything other than explicit racism, in other words micro aggressions and more subtle forms of implicit/unconscious racism is beyond the scope of your perception/understanding
so those of you (and you may not even realize you are in this position) who directly and indirectly benefits from systematic racism, please don't go around saying whether you think something is racist or not (especially many commenters here claiming to "not see the racism"), because that is and will never be for you to decide.

now whether there was implicit racism in this case, i don't think anyone can judge except for those who were actually there to judge not only words but also rate, tone, demeanor, and body language to make that decision.


Guest 3.7 8 years ago

Did you notice in the photo how he bit the medal to test if it was real? He obviously has an issue with Brazilian corruption and crime.

Racist assumptions like this have to be halted and I'm gonna get on Facebook and prove it so he never works again.