by ZOE FOSTER
For those who have seen Channel 10’s The Shire (my condolences), you will have had very recent exposure to lip enhancements, because there are two young women on the show who are doing nothing for the stereotype of lip injections looking blindingly unnatural, although they have kindly relieved some of the pressure from Sophie Monk and Lindsay Lohan, so that’s nice of them.
They are in their mid-twenties, these dames, which is far too young for dermal fillers of any kind in my opinion, and as we’ve seen, they are not exactly exercising restraint. I think they would look a shire load better with just some lovely lip pumping gloss (Sally Hansen’s Lip Inflation or Lip Fusion from Mecca are the best) but it’s their choice, obviously and they really, really seem to love their lips, even if their stupid doctor won’t let them get more injections so their lips literally nudge their nose. I mean, what a jerk he must be.
Lip enhancement and augmentation was originally developed as a tool to add volume or shape to thin or ageing/wrinkled lips, and “done well” I concede they can have a youthful effect. One friend I have in her fifties has twice-yearly collagen in her lips, and combined with a spot of Botox on the forehead, this definitely makes her look fresher, and in a gentle, natural way. (She is also religious about sunscreen, which helps.)
The key words there were, ‘done well,’ because so often they are not done well, whether that’s because the person doing the fillers has not thoroughly assessed the patient’s lips and face and doesn’t create a natural enough look, (generally it’s overfilling of the top lip that makes it look wrongo – the lower lip should be 1.5x bigger than the upper) or the person requesting them doesn’t care for natural (cue Vernesa and Sophie) instead opting for ludicrously bulbous, glossy sausages that fool precisely no one, and are not intended to.
To me, done well means lips that are subtly plumped in the areas of the lips that are naturally fuller, and are not noticeable except for that the lips look a little bit more plump and the face looks… younger somehow. I don’t believe done well means “bigger” or more noticeable.
I’ve not had them, but despite my rant above, I certainly don’t judge women who get lip enhancement, I just encourage them to do their research, and go by recommendation, and definitely don’t go for a cheaper price over a better clinic. It’s never ever worth it – this is your FACE.
Generally, after years of chatting with the people who perform lip fillers, and who’ve tried them, my position on lip injections is this:
- Less is definitely 1000% more
- If in doubt, don’t
- If not in doubt, go to someone you trust, whose work you have seen on other women and like
- If you’re worried people will notice, know that they probably will, so be okay with that
- I’m yet to see a good lip job, although an argument could be made that I wouldn’t know, because it was a good job
- They become strangely addictive, from all evidence…
Also, while we are told fillers break down in the body (most lip fillers last 6-9 months) there is evidence that remnants can stick around for good. This is why some women get trapped into more a cycle of more and more fillers – to balance out the lumps from previous jobs. Cute.
I once interviewed the best and most insanely expensive facelift surgeon in the world, a fascinating, charming Texan man based in NYC, and he said – get ready – when he lifts the face up to perform surgery, he can see lines of grey sludge around the lips and cheeks from filler that has been there for years, and building up, and eventually the skin tissue grows over it. This was pretty much enough to scare me off fillers for life.
Horrifying tales aside, I suppose all of this augmentation on the face and body isn’t such a strange proposition. A lot of women desire intentionally and obviously enhanced breasts, lashes, tans, nails and hair; lips were a natural progression.
I suppose if we acknowledge the work of science fiction over the years (even recent books/films like The Hunger Games) we humans seem to have agreed that in the future, what is artificial is what will be desirable, not what is natural. Painted skin, bizarre hair, augmentation, amendments and enhancement – this has been the vision of the future for a long time and maybe, just maybe Vernesa and Sophie are advancing towards this weird, synthetic ideal faster than we old-fashioned thin-lipped types are.
Zoe is an author, columnist and porridge fan. Her books include the beauty bible Amazing Face, dating and relationship guide Textbook Romance, and three novels, Air Kisses, Playing The Field and The Younger Man. Find more info on her here, or supervise on her daily procrastination here and here.
Please understand that Zoë cannot respond to ALL your questions – but never fear, there are readers that are bound to know the answers, so don’t be afraid to ask.
Here are some famous lips who may or may not have been augmented. Only they know for sure.

Angelina Jolie
Would you ever get lip fillers?








Comments
79 Comments so far
Where exactly does the antipathy towards cosmetic procedures stem from? As others have said, if it makes *you* feel good..just like changing your hair colour, for example, then if you can do it..why shouldn;t you do it?
And yes it is easy to condemn or look down on these things before you ever understand the feeling of needing to have them done.
loading...
Slightly off topic but I noticed that the latest photos of Kidman at an Omega function and the olyimpic games ceremony indicate she is getting her nasolabial lines injected with filler. And she wants us to believe she’s a reformed user – puhlease!
loading...
Pingback: Don’t hate me because I don’t drink. « You've Got Mel
*shudders* Grey sludge covered over with tissue, right, I think you’ve just cured me of ever wanting procedures.
Http://www.boughtbybirdette.com
loading...
I’ve been getting my lips done for the past two years and I can’t see myself stopping anytime soon. I’ve naturally got a really thin top lip but a really full bottom lip, so I get it done to make my top lip fuller and I really love the results. I never used to wear lipstick beause I was really self conscious,but now I love adding some colour to my lips
My biggest piece of advice if anyone is thinking about getting it done is to stay away from an injector who has an unnatural looking face or trout pout lips… They’re the professional and chances are that if they have had a bad job done on themselves, chances are you’ll end up walking away with a bad job too…
loading...
“I’m yet to see a good lip job, although an argument could be made that I wouldn’t know, because it was a good job”
Elle McPherson, Jennifer Hawkins, Jessica Biel.
Its all in the technique, the volume and the placement. Jen Hawkins is a particularly good example. If anyone knows where she goes – do tell!
loading...
Never say never! I’m in my forties but I used to say that I’d NEVER have Botox, fillers or a facelift. In late 30s I had some Botox but swore I’d never have fillers. Now at 42 I’ve had fillers for the first time and I love it! Hopi g I’ll never have a facelift but who knows? It’s easy to say you’ll “never” have cosmetic treatments when you’re smooth and glowing in your 20s or early 30s…
loading...
A-nonny-nonny, I was the same – always said I would never ever have fillers or botox in my 30s but now in my mid 40s I started with a little botox around my eyes and was so happy with how it looked that I then decided on a little filler in my upper cheeks and the results were amazing … I just love it! So I agree, its easy to say when your skin is smooth and full in your 20′s and 30′s but you cant help thinking about some maintenance in your 40′s when skin starts to lose volume and wrinkles become more prominent but the key is not to overdo it, it has to look natural.
loading...
Actually I don’t know where to look with Vernessa & Sophie. Theirs lips or breasts.
loading...
Lovely photo, Zoe
x
loading...
The gallery…….shudder.
loading...
The only ones I could believe hadn’t had their kips done are Angelina Jolie (seen high school photos of her)liv Tyler (look at her dad’s lips) and Scarlett (seen her in a movie as a young girl). The rest? Who knows.
I’ve always Liked my lips, but now it’s a bit lopsided due to surgery and I’m a wee bit self conscious, yes and vain about it too.
loading...
Joselyn Wildenstein may have turned me off any type of surgery or cosmetic enhancement for life. I believe she’s a wealthy woman so she should have been able to afford a top surgeon. What a shame.
loading...
Not now that i have read about the sludge. I am in my mid fifties and happy enough with my lips. It’s the sagging that bothers me.
I love your sentence “A lot of women desire intentionally and obviously enhanced breasts, lashes, tans, nails and hair; ” It’s like they don’t get that these things are meant to look like you can grow your own nails and are naturally beautiful etc
My sister stopped painting her naturally strong nails years ago because people thought they were fake. Now no one would because most people see to get their acrylic/gel nails in a style that looks so unnatural. Some people are happy look like many things that start with B and beautiful is not necessarily one of them… ..bogan, bimbo, barbie.
loading...
I am genetically blessed with Angelina Jolie lips and get so many compliments. When I was at school however I was mocked, taunted and called horrible names, at 38 those comments still resonate with me. I guess I can now have the last laugh. I naturally have what many pay lots of money to achieve and they are natural, no trout pout for me! Does anyone else have naturally full lips and do you get compliments as well?
loading...
Yep – exactly the same experience as you. Was crucified in my school days but now I always get compliments. I have a very distinct “cupid’s bow” though, so not sure I would draw comparisons with Angelina Jolie. Don’t like that I can’t really wear bright lippies either, otherwise I look all mouth!
loading...
I was horribly taunted also at school, particularly junior high school and I’ll never forget but I too am now having the last laugh! I love my lips now at 39 especially knowing people pay big dollars for them
loading...
Kiara Knightly? Really?
loading...
That photo of Kylie Minogue she looks quite odd….
loading...
I prefer the Paris lip than big sausage lips. I don’t understand why anyone would pay for sausage lips.
Did the Paris lip go out of style?
If you have no idea what I’m talking about here’s a random link
http://www.cosmetiquesolutions.com/ParisLipTechnique.ews
loading...
Zoe, i promise never to inject anything (could have something to do with my fear of needles) but please please please tell me how did you get your hair like that. i love it.
loading...
Well, that is the most um…. interesting (?) gallery I’ve seen in a long time! Only Liv Tyler and Scarlett look like they haven’t done something to their faces.
Looking at photos like that, just makes me appreciate even more the natural beauties out there, like Asher Keddie for example.
loading...
I agree, all you have to do is look at Liv Tyler’s dad Steve Tyler to know that those lips are all hers
loading...
Vernessa and Sophie are in their mid-twenties?!?! I thought they were in their early 30′s…
No interest here in any of the stuff they’re into.
loading...
As somebody in my early 30′s, got to say a little insulted:-)
loading...
Fair enough, I didn’t want to make them as old as me though (35)
loading...
Zoeeee. Look what you’ve gone and made me do! I’ve now bought Sally Hansen’s lip inflation from eBay.
haha
loading...
Let us know if it works!
loading...
You can get the Sally Hansen from the chemist. Been using on and off for years, it actually works quite well. Temporary but glossy.
loading...
It just gives you an allergic reaction! Lol
loading...
Those two girls crack me up, at least they’re ‘owning’ it. Yes they’re way too young for it and have gone a bit far but each to their own. I’m not sure of my position on my own face ‘work’ yet. I’m 32 with a few lines here and there. Given the money, in a few years maybe I’d like a smidge in my forehead? I don’t know. I’d probably enjoy spending my money on improving the tone and texture of my skin more as I still suffer the odd few breakouts and slight breakout scars.
Ps. If that’s a recent pic Zoe, loving the hair colour and length. Hamish was onto something asking for a brunette bride, but I think we will leave the rest of the beauty advice to you, not him
loading...
Dear Zoe,
I’m really hoping you (or any lovely MM readers) can help me out with this one. I have a ball (I know) coming up in a couple of weeks and really want to look amazing. I have a simple black dress (it’s day birger et mikkelsen) to wear but am a bit worried that it’s too conservative/nun-like. So I want to make sure my hair and make up are super sexy. I was thinking of buying the Babyliss hot rollers and going for Victoria’s Secret type curls. Has anyone used these before? I was also considering a plum lip but my lips are small so not sure if this is a good idea.
I would LOVE any advice. I never look good at things and this must change!
Thanks in anticpation,
Georgie
P.S, I have quite long brown hair and hazel eyes.
loading...
Hi, personally I always think simple looks classier so don’t worry too much. If the dress is simple you can always go all out with some statement jewellry. You have described the dress as nun like so I am guessing it’s a higher neckline? If so, curls would be great for the volume but perhaps put your hair up so it’s not lost against the dress? Most of all be confident and have a great time
loading...
I have small lips too – I’d suggest going for statement eyes, which I know is not in fashion but I find it is much more flattering to us with small lips. I’d also consider going for sexy by wearing your hair up and exposing some neck if the dress has a high neckline as brown hair can be lost against the black of the dress.
Another thing I love to do is wear statement nails – my personal preference is for black as a shock against the conservative dress.
loading...
When you look in the mirror and all it does is depress you, then I think you should be able to do something about that. The marionette lines I had (sides of my mouth to my nose) were horrible and aging. I had dermal fillers and was so happy with the result. Which led to some dermal filler in my upper lip and again a great result. I can see where the addiction comes from, when something makes you feel good of course you want to do it more often. When you are young and gorgeous, it’s easy to think that injectables will never be an option, but when you wont see 40 again, I think that it may be a perfectly reasonable choice.
loading...
Saw this the other day annd just wish The Shire girls could read it… http://news.breakingmelbournenews.com/tweets/225175273652498432.iframe
loading...
Can they read?
loading...
Reckon the girls from The Shire (and a couple in the gallery) need a pair of these….
loading...
Not related to the topic but a very serious beauty emergency-
Do I use moisturiser under my BB cream, or is the moisture in the BB cream enough?
( and yes I realise how incredibly lucky I am that this is my only emergency for the day)
loading...
I use moisturiser under my BB cream. My skin’s pretty normal – not too dry, not too oily. I’ve read around a few different forums though and it appears that BB creams vary quite a bit from brand to brand, so what works for one might not work for another. I use the Garnier one, by the way.
loading...
What is BB cream?
loading...
http://www.mamamia.com.au/style/zoe-foster-bb-creams-what-are-they/
loading...
Whatever suits your skin best really – if you feel you need extra moisture then you can pop serum/moisturiser underneath – if you don’t – you can just put it straight on after cleansing
loading...
I do. I like all the moisturiser I can get!
I use the Maybelline BB cream which I bought from Boots in the UK recently, but I now find out you can’t get it here in Oz! And I LOVE this product!
loading...
I get so tempted to try things like botox and filler but fear looking like a freaky daytime soap actress .
I’m not convinced it makes people look younger or better. It does make them look like they’ve had botox and filler though.
I’ll just keep on considering it for a few more years.
loading...
“I’m not convinced it makes people look younger or better. It does make them look like they’ve had botox and filler though.”
PMSL – love love LOVE the way you phrased that!!
loading...
Zoe, serious babe alert in your photo! Lookin’ good.
loading...
I totally agree! I love the hair colour! That’s a brown I would like
loading...
I think Angelina’s and Liv Tyler’s lips are natural. Not so much everyone else!
loading...
Pretty sure Scarlett Johannsen’s are her own. She’s always had plump lips.
loading...
I agree that Scarlett and Liv are probably the only ones who haven’t had help from fillers (look at Liv’s father, huge lips seem to run in their genes) but I read somewhere that although Angelina has always had big lips, she still gets fillers to even the top and bottom lip and make them lok perfectly symmetrical.
Nicole Kidman’s lips look terrible in that picture, natural lips never have that visible hard line that you can see on her top lip.
On a side note, I think JLo has the best plastic surgeon in Hollywood. Whatever she’s had done, it’s subtle and she looks better at 43 than a lot of girls do in their 20s.
loading...
Yeah, but I’m pretty sure Our Nic’s lips only look like that because she uses sunscreen and eats really well
loading...
And drinks 3 litres of water a day.
loading...
I know this is off-topic and you can’t reply to every comment Zoe but HELP! I am a Tassie-lady and am going on a holiday to Sydney in a week with my lovely man. I have recently started a massive skin overhaul (micro/light therapy etc etc) and lovely new serums and cleansers etc to get rid of some nasty congestion. I am due for a whole new makeup base (primer, foundation, concealer, powder) and was thinking of Becca as I have heard good things. I really am quite anxious about my skin at the moment so would you reccommend Becca and if not then who? PLEASE HELP ME! Thankyou xx
loading...
I have used a bit of Becca, but have recently gone off it in place of Adorn Minerals. Its all the nice stuff you would want in cosmetics (vegan, paraben free etc) and none of the nasties. You can get trial/sample sizes to determine your shade, and their primer is divine!
Definitely worth getting some samples from their website (just click on the product then click on ordering/samples) to see if you like it.
For the record the reason i went off Becca was simply that their products seemed a little oily on me, and the products didnt live up to the hype for me.
loading...
Becca has a huge range of colours so finding a match won’t be a problem. Personally the foundations just don’t suit my skin type, but the quality is fantastic.
What exactly do you want from your base makeup? Are you wanting light, medium or full coverage. Matte or dewy? What’s your skin tone? It’s a bit hard to recommend brands without knowing these things, however NARS and Make Up For Ever have great face products that cover most bases. Jane Iredale is great if you would prefer mineral makeup.
http://labeauteetleblogueur.blogspot.com.au/
loading...
NAWWW you guys are so great and helpful!! I like the dewy look but I DO need a fair bit of coverage in some areas as I get blemishes (especially at the moment (after effects of the skin treatment’s) and I like it to fairly long-wear. I don;t like to look like I’m wearing a lot of makeup. I was also thinking of NARS, but more for the blusher and bronzer as I didn;t know they had such good foundations? I have quite a light skin tone… I am keen for a high-quality product as I dont want to undo that hard work I’ve done recently!
loading...
NARS Sheer Glow is fantastic. Despite the name it’s medium coverage and buildable, and on me it’s just dewy enough to look glowy and natural, rather than greasy. I use the palest shade which is Siberia, but there’s a few other light shades in the range. Over primer it lasts all day, but if I want it to stay totally flawless for 8+ hours a dusting of NARS loose powder helps greatly.
NARS tinted moisturiser is also really fantastic and definitely worth checking out if light-medium coverage is enough for you.
The only base product I don’t think NARS excells at is concealer. My favourite’s are Burberry and Edward Bess. Becca, Bobbi Brown and Laura Mercier are good too.
http://labeauteetleblogueur.blogspot.com.au/
loading...
Hi Sophie, I’m also from Tassie but go to Sydney five or six times a year for my hair and beauty regime. In David Jones I visit the armani counter for my foundation and brushes, they’re the best I have found! The Mac counter for my eyebrow shape, though my favourite shaper has long left and started her own business (Martha!). Downstairs for a quick mani at the nail bar.
I visit Stairway to Beauty for waxing, spray tans and facials.
And I have recently received a clarisonic which is outstandingly good. I wish Zoe would do a post on this gadget.
We miss out on a lot of variety down here in Tassie it’s very disappointing
loading...
NARS foundation is lovely, as is Armani.
I am currently using Chantecaille Future Skin which is divine. The coverage is very ‘buildable’.
I think they have an excellent range of colours for lighter skin too – they have shades for both yellow and pink undertones.
loading...
Thanks so much everyone!!!Hopefully I’ll find theright product and you have all helped heaps:) what a wonderful communal outcome, thrilled! I WAS wondering about a good eye-brow shaping place as I am VERY mis-trusting and usually just do them myself to avoid them getting too thinned-out. Maybe I’ll ask around up there!
loading...
Nathan or one of his off-siders at Parlour B, or the girls at the Benefit counter in Bondi Junction.
Sharon Lee made me look a little bit like a tranny.
loading...
Hi Sophie, I forgot to mention a primer above. People get a bit fanatical about the primer they use, at least that’s what I am like. I use Estee Lauder Idealist as a primer, it’s a bit expensive but I find that it makes my make up application perfect, my skin feels wonderful, make up stays put all day.
That’s my rec for a primer!
loading...
Don’t buy any foundation without trying a sample first. Most cosmetic companies will give you a little bit in a bottle or sachet first to take home and try as you would your usual. If they don’t, don’t buy from them. Foundation is too expensive to get wrong. Don’t buy cold. Don’t buy based on how it looks on your hand.
Try lots of samples and see how you go. It’s different for everyone. So the Armani that Bailey and others are raving about just looks not quite right on my skin. There was no way I would have known that without a sample first.
loading...
Based on what you’re looking for – I would absolutely recommend Lancome Teint Miracle foundation. It’s one of my faves – and ticks all the boxes of being natural looking, yet great coverage, with a luminous finish, yet lasts really well. It’s often hard to find a dewy foundation that lasts well – I’m a fan of NARS Sheer Glow too – but I would recommend the Lancome over the NARS. It’s also oil free, non-comodogenic (won’t clog your pores) and fragrance free. I’ve got super sensitive skin so a lot of foundations can irritate or make me break out – but this Lancome one absolutely does not! Def recommend going to a counter and trying it. I would 100% go for NARS blush and bronzer though – Orgasm (blush) and Laguna (bronzer) you will forever love!
loading...
Sophie – check this website out
http://www.beautypedia.com/bestproducts.aspx
loading...
I think you have put me off fillers for life with the story from the dr’s mouth…! Honestly why can’t people accept themselves the way they are… Hate the lumpy appearance of fillers… Eew
loading...
Do you wear make up?
Cut your hair?
Colour your hair?
yes to all or some of the above?
Why can’t people accept themselves just the way they are??
loading...
There is a big difference comparing grooming to injectables… I am all for people doing whatever they want to make themselves feel confident but i happen to like a bit of imperfection in a face…
No idea why my opinion would bother you I just know that I prefer the before faces of stars like Meg Ryan and some of my friends that have tried fillers…but only my opinion!
loading...
Woah, a little condescending there. Many people cut and colour their hair/wear make up for fun… not because they can’t accept their natural look.
loading...
Settle pettle!
The difference is that one is on or above the surface of your skin, makeup hair etc.. the other is under the surface, so is mucking around with your actual body, hence the grey matter left in lips Zoe refers too.
There is a big difference – and suggesting they are the same is a big like suggesting buying spanx is the same as getting a tummy tuck.
loading...
I tried a lip filler a few months back and love the results!! Its a new filler called Esthelis and its gives very natural, soft results. The clinic I went to was wonderful and the girls are all about enhancing beauty and “looking natural”. I have always had extremely thin lips and the little bit of extra volume has given me the confidence to wear those lovely bright lip colours that are so popular right now. I’m also very aware of how addictive it is, once you start its hard to stop. But for now, I’m loving my “natural” look!!! I also think lots of women do it, but no-one talks about it because of the judgement. In most cases, people cannot tell its been done because its been done so well and looks natural. Same with the botox! Secret womens business.
loading...
I guess the operative word here is natural looking. The shire et al are definately not that!
loading...
Oh dear, that shot of Nicole Kidman’s lips is horrendous!
loading...
Yes I would get lip fillers, not the huge ones but lips thin with age. I can’t wear dark lipstick anymore because it accentuates the thin upper lip.
I’ve had fillers in the face lines which were fantastic but alas, they don’t last very long for the expense. If I could afford it I would have them again. I’ve heard fat transfer lasts longer (your own fat) so maybe that is what I will consider next. Move it off the middle and into the face!!!
loading...
I’ve had lip fillers and I’d like to think they were well done. At the time I reacted badly and for 3 days I looked like I’d been punched in the mouth but then it settled well.
I’ve got big features generally (big eyes, definitely not a cute-as-a-button nose) so the overall effect was proportionate. I liked the effect but not enough to get it done again. Ditto filler under the eyes.
But then I’m only 29. I might change my mind in 20 or 30 years.
loading...
I was considering under-eye fillers due to my ‘sunken bags’ but a friend of mine had it and said that one eye dissolved faster than the other, put me off but I will probably consider it again since I’m quite self concious about it.
loading...
Wow, I havent heard of that happening.
I suppose it depends on how quickly your body processes the filler.
It sounds odd but I have quite a deep eye socket and prominnt cheek bones so I always looked a bit sleep deprived, even when i wasnt. Under eye filler helped a lot with that. I idnt look ‘different’, just well rested.
loading...
My plastic surgeon recently talked me out of tear trough fillers. Her take is that when they go even a tiny bit wrong, they look HORRIBLY wrong. I have just tried some pro-fractional laser with the hopes of firming up the under eye area. Fingers crossed!
loading...
This is absolutely true. And its also true about filler sticking around and ending up places it wasn’t injected.
loading...