by ZOE FOSTER
I always see coloured mascaras at cosmetic counters and part of me wants to try them…. Are there rules? I don’t want to look like an ‘80s throwback! Danielle.
Yes, Danielle. There are rules.
But before we get into those, let us remember that colourful mascara can be a lot of fun. (And get those magentas and electric blues out of your head, coloured mascaras come in very earthy, grown-up colours now, and are entirely wearable.)
After all, we’re dip-dying and powdering our hair pink and blue and purple: why so scaredy cat when it comes to our lashes? They add an exciting flash of colour to the eyes, and can really bring out your eye colour if you choose a complementary colour, which will either be in the same colour family, or the complete opposite.
Blue eyes: Browns… or navy blue.
Green eyes: Plum and purple… or moss green.
Brown eyes: Blue…. Or brown.
Fun fact: Blue mascara can make your eye-whites seem brighter, so is good to use when your eyes look like they were rolled in a Persian rug overnight.
Knowing how to utilise these colours in a way that makes your eyes look better, not worse is key. Coloured mascara can be very distracting, which is part of its purpose, I suppose, but lets harness it for good, not evil.
My 6 tips for using coloured mascara:
1. Avoid the lower lash line.
Unless you’re using brown or plum. But “funky” colours? No.
2. To dilute the ZAP! of your coloured mascara:
Do a layer of regular black mascara first, and then follow quickly with your coloured mascara.
3. To bring out the KAPOW! of your coloured mascara:
Use a lash primer (they will be clear or white usually) on your lashes, and then follow with your coloured mascara. Two coats. Oooooh, fancy!
4. Try grown-up coloured mascara:
Like forest green (over grass green), deep navy blue (rather than electric) and burgundy (rather than lilac).
5. To get the most out of coloured mascara when you have very dark lashes:
You will need to choose one with a thick, highly-pigmented texture in a lighter shade.
6. To get the “look” of coloured but not the disco feel:
Do your lashes your usual black, and then paint only the tips of your lashes with the coloured wand.
Fun fact: Brown mascara is FAR more flattering and youthful than black, and should be mandatory for those aged 60 and beyond.
But back to YOU, Danielle!
My guess is you’ve been eyeing off the Dior or YSL coloured mascaras, which are exceptional, but not as cheap as a dame might like for a trend she is unsure of. That said, I own the plum shade, (Yves Saint Laurent Mascara Singulier in Deep Plum) which I use when I am feeling exciting, or my eyes are a bit tired to wake them up. Benefit Bag Girl Lash in plum is also great for green-eyed dames. (Not the jealous ones, the literal ones.)
Or, you might have been sussing out the brand new Beth Ditto for MAC collection, which includes some updates on the cult MAC Zoom mascara (an all-round winner in my opinion – length and definition and volume!) The blue is VERY rich in pigment, and will show up even on very dark lashes, so go easy unless it’s a Big Night Out maybe, while the aubergine shade is actually quite subtle and lovely.
For the more reticent, try Almay’s i-color or CoverGirl’s Exact Eyelights, both of which have flatter-your-eye-colour mascaras in very earthy, wearable tones, and for those who don’t want to spend a bomb, because they might only wear this product a few times, try Mavala’s Eye-Lite waterproof mascara. (Which I pack for holidays, because you can swim and carry on and you still look “made up” and have some colour around your eyes.)
Next week: Perms and teased fringes.
Zoe is an author, columnist and porridge fan. Her books include the beauty bible Amazing Face, dating and relationship guide Textbook Romance, and three novels, Air Kisses, Playing The Field and The Younger Man. Find more info on her here, or supervise on her daily procrastination here and here.
Please understand that Zoë cannot respond to ALL your questions – but never fear, there are readers that are bound to know the answers, so don’t be afraid to ask.
Do you wear coloured mascara?








Comments
40 Comments so far
I have different coloured eyelashes – my left eye is blonde, my right a brunette. I have green eyes. Any sugestions on how to pull off colour and not look like (as usual ) I’ve forgotton an eye? Or overdone one eye?
loading...
Oh Zoe, can you please hurry up and have a couple of kids and then send Hamish off to do gigs away from home six months of the year and THEN let me know how a dame doeseth looketh fabulous?
Love your posts, a mum can dream about looking fab and made up.
loading...
Having flashbacks to my 80s days wearing electric blue mascara with my electric blue taffeta frock.
loading...
Love the sound of the Mavala mascara. Where can you get it in Australia? Can’t even find it online.
loading...
I actually thought you were serious with the “Next week: Perms and teased fringes”!! My hairdresser said perms are actually coming back?? I used to regularly perm to control my frizzy-curly hair : 0 Also LOVE the Bad Girl Plum btw ; )
loading...
I have worn blue mascara since the 80′s. The blue-ness has changed over the years and I now wear a darker blue. If you have blue eyes, it really brings out the colour in your eyes!
loading...
I don’t wear brown mascara as it’s often lighter than my natural colour and looks weird; if I don’t wear black, I’ll wear black-brown.
loading...
I’ve been wearing navy blue mascara for years and love it cos it is just that bit different. I have blue eyes and feel that the combination works. Max Factor made a navy, but it is becoming more difficult to find these days.
loading...
Hi Zoe, just wondering when reading these kind of recommendations, that come with use these colours for these eyes, people rarely state what us hazel eyed gals should try. should we stick to using what is recommended for brown or for green? can anyone help me out?
loading...
I’ve got hazel eyes. I haven’t been using colored mascara in a few years now,but This post inspired me to try again. I had a plum coloured one from YSL, pricey but such a good quality one!
loading...
My eyes are hazel but they are more green than brown so I go with what they recommend for green. But the brown recommendations will always suit as well, I think hazel looks good with either. I think purple might bring out the green in hazel eyes a bit more. Go nuts I say!
loading...
Also! Question! I have long but fairly straight lashes, so I like to use a curler and mascara if I can be bothered. But all mascaras (other than the ere perez natural one you find in health food shops sometimes), including curling mascaras, straighten them right out again. No matter how diligent my curling, no matter how thin the coat, mascara stuffs up my curl. I could just stick to ere perez but it tends towards flakiness and irritates my eyes. Any ideas on why this happens and a way around it??
loading...
I have just started using clinique high lengths mascara and that curls my eyelashes really well
loading...
Get your eyelashes permed. It will change your life.
loading...
I hate having brown eyes. All my sisters have blue eyes and I’m so jealous. Am I the only one who feels like this?
loading...
Me too. I have brown eyes, brown hair and I think it’s dead boring. Although, a lot of men seem to really like brown eyes??
loading...
I kinda know how you feel. One of my sisters has green eyes, the other hazel eyes with long long lashes. I got the brown eyes which I think can be rather boring but over the years I’ve had many people comment on my eyes, people say theyre almond shaped even guys saying theyre sexy lol I think you can get away with wearing more eye makeup and smoky eyes with brown! Learn to play them up.
loading...
I personally can’t recommend the Benefit Plum BadGal mascara if you have sensitive eyes. While I absolutely loved the colour on me I was waking up every morning with crusty eyes so I had to chuck it.
loading...
Isn’t number 6 exactly the same as number 2?
loading...
The difference is in number 6 it sais to do the tips only
loading...
I have naturally black lashes, but they are very straight. I usually don’t wear mascara because I rub my eyes and smear it everywhere. Is a lash curler REALLY REALLY worth it? I mean, do they work? Do the lashes uncurl half an hour later?
loading...
Eyelash curlers are the bomb. Even the cheap ones, and heat them slightly under your hair dryer quickly then right after curling use mascara (even clear) to help maintain the curl.
loading...
What am amazing tip, can’t wait to try this tomorrow!
loading...
Really REALLY? The effect lasts?
loading...
My daughter has red hair, blue eyes and super fair skin. Her natural eyelash colour is so pale some of her friends think she has no eyelashes at all. What would suit her?
loading...
Ros I have the same colouring as your daughter and I just bought a lovely mascara from Just for Redheads: http://www.justforredheads.com/mase.html. I’m using the henna supreme sensitive one as I can’t use regular coloured mascaras. They have a good colour range for blonde lashes
loading...
Thanks! I will check it out.
loading...
Mirrenesse does coloured mascaras. The navy one is amazing, beeswax based or something similar.
loading...
Thanks to this post Zoe, I went straight to the Benefit site and purchased their Plum BadGal mascara! I’m now super excited for it to arrive in the mail! I love your posts Zoe, keep up the great articles here on Mamamia and the books too!
loading...
I personally don’t really recommend CoverGirl’s Exact Eyelights, I have the green eyed one and it just looks like black mascara. It’s a GOOD mascara, don’t get me wrong, but you wouldn’t even know it’s coloured.
loading...
Great post Zoe! Speaking of the 80s, I remember some coloured hair mascaras that were around then (or was that the 90s? I was a kid – things are blurry). Do they still exist? I don’t want the powder to rub off all over my clothes, and I’m not sure if I’m ready to make a full-time lavender/pink/blue commitment.
loading...
I still have some of those in the back of a cupboard from when my daughter had a dress up as a fairy! Suspect they might be a bit dried out….
loading...
I remember those too!! My friends used the blonde one to touch up dark roots.
loading...
Love the tip of wearing 2 coats of primer underneath the coloured mascara!
I have bought purple/plum mascaras in the past (one being a YSL one, which I still have somewhere) but often find that the formulas are really dry, and the colour hard to see (I wish they ‘popped’ without having the be flurescent) *sigh…
loading...
Fantastic timing! I’m going to an 80s party next weekend and I’ve been wondering what type of makeup colours I should use. I wasn’t wearing makeup in the 80s so I have no practice!
I have blue eyes and I’ve never worn blue eye makeup before so I’m a bit nervous. Does anyone have any tips for colours or things that were popular in the 80s?
loading...
Fluoro nails (think green, yellow), lace gloves. You must be a spring chicken!
Orange shades of lipstick. And blue mascara WITH blue eyeshadow. Nobody said the 80s were pretty ….
loading...
Yay! Thanks
sounds like I’m going to get to go wild! Great suggestions.
loading...
Frosted pink lipstick
loading...
I got given an electric blue (I’m talking BRIGHT BRIGHT BLUE!) mascara in a gift bag once. I was a bit scared at first but as soon as I put it on it didn’t look nearly as blue as it appeared on the wand. It pretty much just looked like normal mascara except if the sunlight hit it. It really grew on me
loading...
Jane Iredale have a navy blue mascara that I love. It makes my blue eyes look extra blue and just like you say Zoe, the whites of my eyes very bright. Love it!
loading...