Do You Like This Story?
118367141 290x385 In defence of Halloween (by someone without kids).

Trick? Or treat?

By JESSICA PAINE

A weird thing happened to me this time last year. Despite the fact that I don’t have children, still fail to own shares in a costume shop and loathe all horror movies, I realised I was a little in love with Halloween. Actually, more like a lot.

This was a controversial discovery considering I have a father who views the word “American” as one of the worst kinds of put-downs (specially reserved for loud conversations, creative spelling choices and every time a movie has a happy, closed, completely unambiguous ending). And that’s the way I’ve been raised as well – to abhor the cultural colonisation of Australia by the United States. Despite that, because I’m of the Generation Y persuasion, I’m also 30 percent Global Citizen, 30 percent Cultural Cringer and 40 percent life lessons gained from American television.

But even that, the fact that I’m at constant risk of yelling “Call 9-1-1” in an emergency, am capable of “pleading the 5th”, a thing that I clearly don’t have the right to, and can name more American Presidents than Australian ones (because Australia has Presidents, right?) has nothing to do with my affection for October 31.

Here’s the thing. I’m a childless, single, urban-dwelling member of what I’m constantly assured is one of the most narcissistic demographic groups to have walked the earth. As a result of this I’ve never met a community that didn’t come with its own Facebook group. But while my social network may be vast, my knowledge of my neighbours is non-existent.

While I have friends and housemates, the reality is I live on a street of strangers. But every time a kid comes around to collect candy on Halloween I feel slightly less like the woman who’s obituary will read “Spinster Eaten By Cat Companions” (this is assuming I become a cat person, and insist on calling my cats ‘companions’).

We assume the kids in Jessica’s street are not dressed like this…. (Text continued after the gallery) 

Kid Lil'Wayne

On Halloween I feel like I might be part of an actual community. Like one day I could even learn the names of the people in my block (and stop calling them things like ‘Bin Lady’ and ‘Sour Face’), perhaps ask them round for a barbeque, or apologetically borrow some flour.

Why can’t I do these things now?

Is it because I get nervous about introducing myself? Do I have a truly paralysing inability to retain people’s names? Am I concerned about invading their personal space? Could it all just be a bit too much of an effort?

The answer is all of the above, plus the rather sad fact that it’s just kind of creepy to show too much interest these days. If CSI (my father, somewhere: So American) has taught us anything, it’s to fear everyone.

I’m always tempted to join in the street-wide water fight amongst all the kids outside, or pull over in the rain and offer someone a lift from the station, or roll down a window and enthusiastically cheer a cyclist slowly summiting an impossibly steep hill. But I never do, because on the other side of that equation is a whole bunch of people that would freak the hell out about the creepy woman trying to ingratiate herself with their children, lure them into a car, or hurl abuse at random people.

So many holidays are about family, it’s nice to have one that’s about getting to meet everyone else. If nothing else, I think it’s good to teach kids that not all strangers will attack them, and that the world can even be a generous, candy-filled place of conversation.

All you have to do is knock on the door.

Jessica Paine is a television producer and freelance writer.  She blogs here.

How you you feel about Halloween? Do you trick? Do you treat? And if you did, what would you dress as?

Chris Brown dressed as a terrorist for Halloween

And if you’re seriously keen on Halloween, check out this amazing content from our sister site, iVillage:

There’s a guide to celebrate Halloween Gangnam Style, easy ways to make your home look, er,  haunted, fun things kids can make and some amazing things you can do with a pumpkin.

There’s also these: which you want to bake - or just look at. If face painting is your thing, click here. You can guess the celebrity Halloween costume or find out how to get your pets interested in Halloween here. (Woof!)

If you are having photos taken for Halloween don’t use this as inspiration.   And finally, if you’ve completely forgotten it’s Halloween then it’s not too late to get a costume for your kids – you can even make one out of stuff you have at home. Get inspired.

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

41 Comments so far

  1. Katie

    Looking through the celebrity pics it occurs to me…….what does Lady Gaga wear at Halloween?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Newbie

    On the same day that the AIHW Australian children’s health and well-being report was realeased, noting the rise in childhood obesity, I would think sending your children out to beg for copious amounts of sugar is not quite the right message to give them.
    Apart from that I just find it so BIZARRE. Begging for lollies from strangers (and threatening vandalism). Weird that this is now considered normal.
    By all means, have the fun of dressing up (in something age-appropriate) and hanging out with friends…but roaming the streets knocking on strangers’ doors and begging?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. nb97

    I agree, I celebrated Halloween for the first time this year and it was so much fun! I don’t understand why this holiday never came to us here. We’re really missing out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. guest

    We were unprepared for trick or treaters. We gave them poppas.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Quixotic

    I get quite aggravated when people say Hallowe’en is “an American thing”. Actually it was Scottish (derived from a celtic/pagan festival), then England, Europe etc and it travelled over to America with the Pilgrims.

    If you love Hallowe’en (as I do), then claim it!! Don’t let the Americans own it just because they took to it with gusto!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rudyroo

      I think the concept would even pre date the Scots.

      We know so much about how the Americans celebrate it, can you tell us how the Scottish do it? Is it pumpkin pie and trick or treating too? How do they do it different? I’d love to know.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Quixotic

        The concept itself pre-dates modern history. It’s main influence I believe is a celtic festival called Samhain, celebrated on 31 October, when the ‘veil’ between this world and the Otherworld is thinnest.

        It involved feasts, with places set for deceased ancestors, passing between bonfires as a cleansing ritual and ‘souling’ or ‘guising’ (children and the poor going door to door dressed in disguise and singing and saying prayers for the dead in return for food or money).

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  6. InKL

    I love Halloween. Love. It. we just had a street party in our compound here and it was wonderful. Kids and Adults dressed up, nurse zombies, scary faeries and heaps of trolls and that was just the kids!

    Everyone brought some food, the kids bobbed for apples, played pin the tail on the black cat, ate donuts off a string, wrapped the mummy and hit a pinata full of snakes, spiders and other creepy crawlies. We had a giant tropical thunderstorm and then trick or treating.

    The kids had to scream or sing their way to treats – I had six 13 year olds singing One Direction’s You Don’t Know You’re Beautiful on my front door step.

    How can all that not be fun?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Tracy

    In Wicca, Halloween is meant to be the day the ‘veil’ is thinnest between this world and the next. Does this veil abide by hemispheres?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I believe it is reversed in the southern hemisphere due to the seasonal aspect of each equinox…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. m

    Cant wait for Thanksgiving.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Nicole

    I agree with Bridget below:
    a) It’s not an Australian tradition. It’s a northern hemisphere tradition about ushering in the Winter, it doesn’t apply here and that’s why they didn’t celebrate it when they came to Australia.
    b) People realise it’s just consumerism. Big W, Coles, Woolies, Kmart have upped their Halloween marketing to make more money. And people are buying into it.
    And people do it because their kids “love it” and “have a ball”. What kid wouldn’t have a ball getting lollies on a school night?
    But again I refer to points A and B above. There is no sense of tradition — it came of nowhere readlly. I am 41 and until a few years ago I hadn’t seen it anywhere in Australia at all. So I have no connection to it at all.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Dan

    We are loving Halloween more and more each year at our house (to the in-laws horror!). What’s not to love about dressing up in costumes and meeting friends?? I guarantee when I dress my kids up in green for St Patrick’s Day no one will be moaning about “bloody Irish traditions”. Too many Grinch’s around, I say!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Anonymous

    Thanks to Halloween tonight, i met more neighbours than i have in 3 years…, it was a great, safe community vibe!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. missneriss

    I sent my daughter to day care this morning in her adorable little Minnie Mouse outfit that I crocheted months ago. She looked so cute!

    As for celebrating Halloween American style – with trick or treating, I’m not into it. Mostly because it’s so in-your-face American. Here in Holland we have a tradition in mid-November for Sint Maarten’s Dag (Saint Martin’s Day) where children make paper lanterns and go door to door in groups singing songs for lollies.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. you can call me susan

    where I live, halloween is a biggie and I give away hundreds of individually wrapped sweets. tonight, however, it was different. in the eight years that i have lived in this house, it was probably one of the quietiest! I think the customers at work will be happy with my leftovers!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. my2cents

    I am Canadian and we do Halloween big time and it is simply the most fun to be had all year! The little kids go out with Mom and Dad early, before dark, and are so adorable in their little costumes. Then the older kids start, still with Mom or Dad. There is no vandalism–if you don’t want to give out candy you just leave your outside light off. It’s all so much better than Christmas or Easter–no big boring meal, dealing with annoying rellies or buying expensive gifts just because you have to buy a gift. The candy costs a few dollars, and if you have something against candy, some people give out raisin boxes or juice boxes. It’s great to be creative and come up with funny or clever costumes. We took my daughters trick or treating last year while we were living in Canada and we met up with so many of her school friends and met some new neighbours. I dislike most holidays, but Halloween is awesome! I really wish Australia would embrace it as a fun, creative event for the kids instead of put down something they have never experienced just because it is “American.” And it’s not even American!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. bridget

    Not every Australian is ignorant, they known it’s not an American tradition. Regardless of religion, it’s a northern hemisphere tradition about ushering in the Winter, therefore it doesn’t apply here and that’s why they didn’t celebrate it when they came to Australia. Personally, that’s not the reason why I oppose it, I’m against it simply because of the consumerism that’s occurred within the last few years.
    I’m not a grumpy old fart, I’m all for having fun, but get dressed up for birthday parties, or anniversary parties! It’s not an Australian tradition and we should really stick it to the supermarkets by not buying into this consumerism.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. theoriginalpinny

    I think I just vomited in my mouth going through that kids costume gallery.
    Am very anti anti anti halloween.
    Jessica I think me and your dad would be good mates.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Moi

      I’m speechless at those kids costumes. and people complain about t-shirts at cotton on kids!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  17. ashaboo

    I loveJessica Alba’s hair

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. whatahooha

    My kids are understand that they have to dress as something SCARY., it being All Hall’s Eve, when all the wicked souls are out to play. (is that right? shades Sunday school….)
    Not something crass or sexy. (no pink fishnets on the baby pole OMG)we have one dragon, one tiger, one black cat, and one fox (some people think they’re scary) and one ladybug. *ahem* (Scary to lizards and very cute.)
    We scoff at fairies. We would eat them for breakfast.

    I was never allowed as a child, and while I don’t think our little will ever go as All Out as they do USA, it’s fun for the little kids.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. mscate

    My memory of Halloween has always been the weather-usually roasting hot, putting a damper on one’s desire to don a wig and thick make up…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Anonymous

    My girls are dressed up as black cats right now and we are going to a neighbours house for a bbq dinner with some of the other neighbours. The kids are so excited about being in costume and hanging out with other kids, pretending to be other characters for the evening. Suspension of disbelief it what its all about for them. It’s fun! For once, I’m glad to see them dressed up in costumes other than fairies or ballerinas!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. pennypacker

    WTF!! Who dresses their kid up like Hitler? I don’t care if it’s Halloween, dressing little kids up as pimps, prostitutes, strippers, Hitler, is absurd, and leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. earthfan

    What sort of mother trains her children to go round to the neighbours’ houses and threaten to do nasty things to them if they don’t hand over lollies? Demanding sugar with menaces is a nasty American custom that is being promoted by retailers to boost their profits. We should resist.
    On the other hand, Halloween parties sound like good fun.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Chrissy

    As someone who identifies predominantly with paganism let me attempt to correct your misinformation.
    Halloween is NOT American. It is Celtic in origin and is the festival Samhain. During this time the veil between the living and the dead was lifted and the spirits were able to be consulted and communicated with.
    I love Halloween and I was even lucky enough to have a daughter born on this day.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kat

      It happens to be my daughters birthday today as well!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Quixotic

      It was my Grandma’s birthday as well!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  24. SK1234

    Ugh. No one is forcing Australians to embrace Halloween. Just like no one forced Australians to fall in love with Friends or Oprah or Southern fried chicken or grilled cheese sandwiches or The Madden brothers or I Heart NY t-shirts. Like Halloween, those things are popular because a certain percentage of the population finds fun or entertainment or value in them. Stop blaming America when we’re not only drinking the Kool-Aid (also American) but actively searching for our next American-flavoured treat.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Georgia

    I love Halloween too – but it’s not technically American. It’s from the UK, so no need to feel “Americanised” when you celebrate it, even though the modern way we celebrate was sort of developed in the USA.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. kitten

    I love halloween always have. my parents are scottish so halloween was always celebrated when i was growing up and my friends and i went trick or treating my suburb was very british so lots of people had lollies. i love taking my girls out and my community put out a list of houses to go to and ask people to put an orange streamer or balloon out if they want to participate. i teach my children about the reasons why we dress up and what it all means which i think has been lost in the american version

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Sharon @ Funken Wagnel

    I am happy for my kids to dress up for halloween if it’s for school or a halloween party, if the opportunity arises.

    I don’t agree with trick or treating though. Hate it, and my kids will never participate in that, and we wouldn’t bother with trick or treaters at our door either.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Miss T

    I’M SO WITH YOU!! I love Halloween, I always have and I hope to God I always will. I love the idea of people going trick or treating and whenever a kid knocks on my door I get soo excited as I don my cats ears and pick up the cauldron of candy (because cauldron of lollies doesn’t sound right).

    My mother is much the same, with everything being “so American”. Imagine her joy at the fact I married an American (slash Dane slash Aussie)*

    *I’m kidding, she loves my husband.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Really?

    Baby Hitler is bad enough – but he’s in front of an OVEN.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Max

      I think it’s a dishwasher. Not my cuppa tea anyway. My elderly Mum used to get terrorised by neighbourhood brats when she had nothing to give them, she had the house egged, the power turned off in the middle of the night and shit put in the mailbox…great fun hey?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • actually k

      it looks like a dishwasher….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  30. becsparrow

    I’m with you, Jessica! I love Halloween and always have. I really don’t get all the angst about it and I think if you’re worried that it’s ‘too American’ … enourage your kids to dress up as Australian characters. I’d love to see a few Ned Kellys knocking on my door.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Chelsea

      or bunyip, or yowie!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. mamamegan

    personally, not keen on halloween. Friends have tried to get me to bring my kids trick or treating this year, but how do I explain to a 3 year old that it is ok to get dressed up, knock on people’s doors and expect treats, while threatening to “trick” them if they don’t cough up. Too weird. and yes, too american. Not in keeping with values that I’m trying to teach my kids. And seriously, my kids don’t need the sugar!

    each to their own though.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions