By REBECCA SPARROW
It was 1980, I was eight years old and sitting on the lounge room floor leaning back onto my mum’s lean tanned legs when I heard someone – I’m not sure who – say it.
“Look at her. She hardly looks like a mother whose baby has just died.”
I looked up at the TV screen.
Looking back at me was Lindy Chamberlain with her Beatles haircut and her saucer sized sunglasses. Her face stony, her manner matter-of-fact as she spoke to a heaving, jostling mob of journalists about the disappearance of her newborn daughter Azaria at Uluru.
She blamed a dingo.
The entire nation blamed her.
Lindy Chamberlain, you see, didn’t grieve the way we wanted her to. She was too serious. Too stoic. Heartless. Where were her tears? Where was her grief? How could she be so together? She was the mother for gods sake.
Thirty years later and the exact same sentiments were being whispered about British backpacker Joanne Lees whose failure to publicly emote over the disappearance of her boyfriend Peter Falconio led the public to mistrust her. She looks cold and distant, we murmured from our lounge room chairs. I bet she was involved.
In a roundabout way I was reminded of those two women following a recent Mamamia post (which you can read here). Three months ago Janelle Moran lost her unborn baby son at 24 weeks. No doubt as a way of working through her anguish, Janelle chose to write an incredibly brave piece on some of the darker moments of her despair. The bits of grief that nobody talks about. The bitterness, the fleeting hateful feelings. The moments that go from ‘Why Me?’ to “Why not her?” Oh yes, that deep-seated wish that what had happened to you had actually happened to someone else.
To say she was criticised is an understatement. Many readers didn’t like the way Janelle was grieving. Like Lindy, she wasn’t grieving the way she was supposed to.
But the truth is unless you have experienced the loss of a loved one – especially a child – it’s hard to understand that grief isn’t always as tidy and polite and pretty as it is when played out on A Very Special Episode of Home and Away. What I know from personal experience is that when a parent loses a child the grief is often raw. Ugly. Messy. Dark.
When my daughter Georgie was stillborn 18months ago I behaved in ways I never would have expected.
On a Monday night in September 2010, I held my perfectly healthy, 36 week old dead daughter in my arms and kissed her forehead and sang to her a song I had long ago made up about how very much her mummy loved her. One week later Brad and I had people to our house to watch the NRL grand final. Is that jarring? It jars me, even now. I mean who does that? All I remember is that I wanted Brad to be with his mates for a few hours. And that when they came over I smiled. And passed around bowls of pretzels. And sat outside with my friend Kyley and drank wine and even laughed at some jokes. And then when everyone went home, and the last plate was stacked in the dishwasher I collapsed in the shower and became hysterical screaming for my daughter. Brad had to put me to bed.
From hospital I typed long, calm emails to my friends about my feelings about Georgie’s death and yet refused to take many of their calls. Or see them in person. For the most part, I had no desire to be around people. To hear how sorry or sad they were. Instead I ate their doorstep lasagnes and spent hours making a tribute video on my laptop of a little girl who died before I ever got to see her smile. Or for her to see mine.
I made small pledges to Georgie. Became anchored by tiny rituals that connected me to her. I wouldn’t hold another baby until I had another one of my own. I had to say bless you whenever Ava sneezed. I couldn’t go to bed at night until I had kissed Ava’s forehead and told her Georgie was watching over her.
And I spent those early days, or was it months?, on this very site. It became my salvation. Filled in my hours. Filled up my headspace as I tried to find ways to not think about the nightmare I was living. I read every post and left comments on stories like a normal person, like someone whose much-cherished second daughter hadn’t just died.
I filled in a gratitude journal. I thought about getting a tattoo. Or shaving my head. I craved to look different so that I could wordlessly say to the world, “I am forever altered”.
And like Janelle I struggled with feelings of envy and, yes, at times resentment towards others. Friends who were pregnant. Friends who had had healthy babies at the same time Georgie died. Friends who announced their second pregnancies. The feelings never lasted long. They came and went like a shiver but they were there nonetheless. Because inside me I couldn’t understand how this had happened to us. To me. To her. And now I was behind. Had to start from scratch. Like a game of Snakes and Ladders, I’d been so close to holding a second baby in my arms and suddenly found myself sliding down to the start. Back to the beginning while I watched everyone else move on with their families.
Would I ever, ever wish that someone else’s baby had died rather than Georgie. No. Because having lived through the grief of a stillbirth, I can honestly say I wouldn’t wish it on anyone.
But that doesn’t make it easy.
On her website, Lindy writes “She grew within my body and when she died, part of me died, and nothing will ever alter that fact.”
We all sort of forgot that Lindy Chamberlain lost her baby. Her daughter. She still misses her little girl. Just the same way I miss mine.







Comments
125 Comments so far
Pingback: Dying: Full Circle from Fear to Faith | Life with Tess
Oh, Bec, I truly teared up at “I collapsed in the shower and became hysterical screaming for my daughter. Brad had to put me to bed.”
What a terrible loss… But you have dealt with it so well, and I hold nothing but admiration for you, xox
loading...
What a beautifully written post Bec. Thank you. Also, I am so very sorry for your terrible loss. <3
loading...
There are no words. I was in the same place one month after you that same year with twin girls. Daughters desperately wanted and loved. There is something always missing now, yes altered is one word. And I too poured over this website as a place to grieve and think.
You’d have to experience it to know such pain, no matter how ‘normal’ you look to others. Its not something we would want anyone to go through. But for those that have to, it helps to share when we can.
We will always love and miss our angels.
loading...
Bec, I think you are truly wonderful. Thank you for always sharing with us and making me look at things a little differently than I normally would. You really do inspire me to be a better person. I’m sure Ava, Finn and Georgie are all very proud. xx
loading...
I’m sitting at work struggling not to cry right now. Beautiful piece.
loading...
What a moving piece, Bec. To put your thoughts into words so articulately is a true gift. To then share them with a wider community is so incredibly brave and generous.
loading...
Bec, beautiful Bec, such wonderful writing from one mother to another.
loading...
Oh Bec – not sure if you’ll read this comment but my heart just went out to you reading your story & I will say a prayer for Georgie tonight. As strong as you obviously are, it must still be so hard and so sad. I wish there was something I could do! And your comments on Lindy Chamberlain are exactly right… I also don’t think she’d have been as vilified if she were a man.
loading...
I thinks that we need to remember that lindys fourth child a girl, was also taken away from her when she was born, not once but twice, and put into foster care. I don’t know that anyone could imagine the pain that woman went. Knowing you are innocent, being locked up away from you family your new baby… Yet still no apology. I reckon she deserves one..
loading...
Beautiful. What courage and compassion you have Bec. And the gift to be able to articulate it so eloquently. Thank-you for sharing this.
loading...
Everybody behaves differently in front of television cameras than they do in everyday life; Even television presenters. Who is to know what was edited out. This goes to the way commercial Media in particular distorts in all sorts of ways the facts on legal cases. I’d like to see the Media for one, stumping up for their part in destroying Lindy & Micheal Chamberlain’s life.
loading...
Bec, thank you for your honest and moving post. Wow. All I can say is I hope the way you chose to, or found yourself, grieving for the loss of your precious little girl has helped you through an unimaginably heartbreaking time. And thanks for reminding us that we should never judge others reactions to certain situations – especially life’s most challenging ones – if we haven’t been there ourselves. I recently found myself having to deal with a heartbreaking situation which I’m not brave enough to share here. But my way of coping was a far cry from how I imagined one should/would ever react when found in that situation… But the important thing is it worked for me and fortunately I wasn’t judged for it. Bec, keep doing whatever you need to do. And Lindy, on behalf of a nation, sorry.
loading...
We lost our second daughter to SIDS last year, she was 8 weeks old & perfect in every way. For me, one of the saddest aspects of what has been the most devastating occurrence in my life, is that our beautiful girls short life has in many ways become overshadowed by her death; just the very fact alone that she died.
When she died we went about frantically trying to preserve our limited memories of her, trying desperately to really remember how it was with her in our lives every day, the faces she pulled, noises she made, all the little quirks that made her her…knowing there would be no more.
I feel so deeply sad that for Lindy, her memories of her time with her precious baby girl in her short life & the joy that Azaria no doubt brought to her family when she was born, could possibly have been overshadowed so monumentally not only by her tragic death but the chaos & horror that followed…for 32 years.
loading...
I’m so sorry for your horrific loss Amanda
. I agree Lindy has had such an incredibly difficult time! As if losing a daughter wasn’t hard enough! She really must be a very strong woman, as must you be!
loading...
Hi Amanda,
I would love to get in touch with you – being 4 years ahead in my journey, and if you wanted someome to talk to …
my email is mbancroft at adam dot com dot au, if you wanted to chat at any time.
Michelle
loading...
“We all sort of forgot that Lindy Chamberlain lost her baby. Her daughter. She still misses her little girl. Just the same way I miss mine.” So true. So so true.vI’m glad she finally has the outcome she’s been longing for for over 30 years.
Bec – a gorgeous article. You write so beautifully about terribly hard subjects, such a gift xxx
loading...
What a wonderful article!
When I lost my boy I was often levelled with comments about how I wasn’t doing it right. When we buried him I wasn’t overwhelmed with grief, and ten days after he died I was partying away at my brothers wedding. At the same time I was doing my level best just to get out of bed in the morning. It wasn’t until months later that I had my meltdowns.
It was all wrong of course. Now it’s funny, but I’ll never tell someone that they’re doing it wrong. There’s no such thing.
loading...
So many posts divide us the Mamamia community, but our hearts joy and sadness for our children is shared. This seems at least for one part of the week to have united us in sharing our love for our children whoever we are: balck, white, straight, gay, married, single whatever.
This is what we should be about as a wider community (real life and online). In the end we can always get more money, more stuff, another husband, wife but our children are ours (both joy and grief) forever.
Look after yourselves tonight. Mother of 3 living children ( and 2 angels).
loading...
Thanks so much Rebecca for bringing “grief and the public’s expectations of grief” into the spotlight. I too had a stillborn baby, Nicholas and in the early days never knew when or how grief would take over. Sometimes the easiest way to deal with being in public would be just to shut down and almost push all emotions aside – just as Lindy was probably trying to do.
I would then get home and spend almost every evening sobbing in the shower until I was numb. The shock alone was something that took months to deal with before it could really sink in and I’m sure Lindy would be wandering “how did I get here???”
And as grief is SO personal – many dont know how they deal with it until they are in that exact situation. I now know why so many marriages don’t survive the loss of a child… As even the closest of couples deal with grief so very differently to each other that it can sadly be too big of a hurdle to conquer, when life as you know it (or dreamed it) has already been swept away with the blink of an eye x
loading...
I havent even looked at the other comments, I dont know if I am game to.
I have tears rolling down my face.
I ltoo ost my baby girl, she was 8 weeks (and 3 days!) old. She died of SIDS. I went to bed mother to a healthy happy baby and woke a completely differnt person. Someone in a club of people who dont want to be there.
I have said what Lindy said so many times, a part of me died that day. A part that I will never get back.
I remember holding myself together at her funeral. I wanted to read a letter that I wrote her, I wanted to show the world how much that dear baby meant to me. I wanted that funeral perfect. I dressed to perfection, had my hair straightened, wore respectable make up and my stupid arse (ex) MIL came over and said “Oh i dont think make up is appropirate, you should be crying”. YOU cry. I was cried out. I wasnt being her version of appropriate.
I didnt take sleeping tablets to get through, I didnt sob to my son about how much better his sibling was. (that was her version of it, when she lost her son).
Greif is raw, personal, ugly.
The first time a baby came into my house after she died I lost it. I lost the plot. The first baby I touched after she died was a friends daughter who was born a few days after her funeral and that was 6 months later and it was so hard.
I remember, and I suppose even 5 years on it still happens, getting hit in the chest by unbeleivable angish that it really happened. My baby girl is dead.
Azaria was pretty much that same age as my little girl Ashleigh. Being a kid and hearing the story (I was born in 82, so I heard about it all through my childhood) I didnt know what to believe. But once I lost Ashleigh, I got it. I finally got it. She didnt kill her baby, she adored her daughter. She misses that girl, who would now be 32 yrs old, every single day. And her other children miss her too. Even those who werent alive.
My subsequent daughter talks about her sister. Shes 3 now, and she talks about her sister being in the stars (heaven) watching her… I know that she will grow up and see other sisters and miss a relationship that she never got to have.
I am so happy that the Chamberlain family has closure now. Not that this takes away from 30 something years of accusations….
loading...
Wow Michelle…reading your post I feel like I’m reading my own story…right down to talking to my 3 year old about how her baby sister is ‘in the stars’.
We lost Gemma at 8 weeks to SIDS, it was mothers day & my sister gave birth to her first baby 12 days later. Thanks for sharing…
loading...
Thank you Bec. It takes real strength to share something so private. Your writing helps me understand myself and others better. Now I must go and find out where Jennifer Aniston puts her vaseline otherwise I won’t stop crying all night as I think of your story, my own story (4 miscarriages) and everyone else who loses a child or any loved one for that matter. Thank you again.
loading...
You have lived my worst nightmare.
loading...
Hi Bec, beautiful Bec.
I heard they had Lindy on high doses of Lithium (dosed by her doctor) for grief – and that is why she was so ‘numb’ looking.. it is amazing how there was so much judgement and then accusations. I hope she can close the book on that awful chapter one day – but I doubt it.
Thank you so much for sharing your story.
loading...
♥
loading...
Thank you Bec. Everyone grieves differently, and being judged for how you grieve makes it so much harder. We decided to terminate a Downs baby, and for me I grieved for the baby I had lost for over 20 years. Being told I had no right to grieve made it so much harder – I knew we couldn’t do it, I knew it was the right decision, but the loss is still hard, and the judgement makes it so much worse. Why do people need to feel superior to others? I don’t understand it.
loading...
I think maybe you were/are grieving the baby you hoped to have, not the one with Down syndrome. When my son with Down syndrome was born, I grieved the baby I was expecting, but then fell in love with the one I got. I’m sad you thought you “couldn’t do it”. Luckily I didn’t know before my son was born.
Parents can never predict the future. Do you have other children now? What if one of them were injured in a car crash and became similar to a child with Down syndrome? Would you then give that child up for adoption etc. I doubt it.
I am not belittling your grief – I’m sure it is very real, and painful, but yes, it was your choice – there is no escaping that. And perhaps I do feel “superior” (not really, but I hope you understand what i mean) because I *do* have a child with Down syndrome, and when people say they “couldn’t do it” (raise a child with Down syndrome) they say it from a place of ignorance and discrimination, and that makes me very very sad.
When people choose to terminate a fetus because they don’t want any children, I’m not 100% comfortable with that, but understand and accept that is their choice. When people terminate because they want a “better” child, it makes me incredibly sad.
I am sad that you missed out on a child who would have raised challenges, but would also have enriched your life in ways you could never imagine.
loading...
Sad, I think your post is way out of line. The whole point of this article is that you shouldn’t judge how others grieve and that’s exactly what you’re doing. You can’t say that AnnaVan wanted a ‘better’ child, you have no idea about her situation and as she said, she’s grieved about her child for 20 years. You didn’t know your child had Down Syndrome when you were pregnant, as you said.
And your last sentence ‘I am sad that you missed out on a child who would have raised challenges, but would have also enriched your life in ways you could never imagine’. In my opinion, that’s a terrible thing to say to someone who is grieving! You wouldn’t say something like that to someone who’s child died of natural causes. It’s a different situation but that doesn’t mean it’s an acceptable thing to say! I actually hope that AnnaVan doesn’t have to read your comment
loading...
Apalling comment !!! AnnaVan has been brave enough to share a horrific, personal experience and you are being incredibly judgmental! Just because you have a child with downs syndrome doesn’t mean you can judge others for their decisions! Who knows what her situation was.
loading...
as I said last week on the Shapelle post, people that look at tv and condemn someone guilty by looking at them scare me.
It scares me because they appear unaware that they are responding to media spin. Fortunately, most of the people would bite their tongues if they met the accused, though, of course, some don’t.
loading...
So beautifully said, thank you. The pain never leaves, we all handle it differently. At a time when society was only just wakening emotionally, a time where ‘stoicism’ was only JUST becoming the exception rather than the rule, Lindy had the hardest time of us all. Imagine – even though we, mothers united in grief, often blame ourselves- being blamed by the public, the media and the law, at the most horrifying time of your life.
We react in many different ways to tragedy and all of them, as far as I am concerned are acceptable however; only parents of angels will ever understand that. I have lost many ‘friends’ as I grieved, and still grieve for my child, but I have made many more since. Thank you for sharing your journey with us.
loading...
Bec – this is beautiful. xo
loading...
Bec,
I cried from start to finish reading your story!
What an amazing woman you are! Thankyou for sharing..
I grew up also listen to the lindy chamberlain tragedy. I remember my parents having dinner parties & listening to them tear her apart!
I’ve always felt very sorry for her. Not only did she lose one child, she was then jailed & taken away from her other small children. Life can be cruel sometimes. x
loading...
What a thought provoking, articulate and well written article Bec, you are are very talented writer and i really enjoyed this.
Also as much as it won’t change anything, or bring you comfort… I am very sorry for the loss of your much loved and beautiful daughter, who (like many other babies) went before her time.
loading...
I want to thank everyone for your (as always) beautiful comments. I could easily have written another 2000 words on this topic. I barely scratched the surface on some of the ways I reacted (and continue to react) to Georgie’s death. One thing I find is that I am still finding it difficult to be around children who would be Georgie’s age now. I find myself mesmerized by them because they give me an insight into the milestones she would now be reaching … Anyway. I hope for those of you who have gone through a loss this post reassures you that there is no ‘right’ way to grieve. We are all different. And we’re all just trying to find our way through. And again I want to acknowledge the role Mia played in my healing. She started emailing me (a total stranger) just weeks after Georgie died and we started sharing our stories of loss (most of you know that Mia lost her daughter May). I will always feel like Georgie and May brought Mia and I together. And for that I will be forever grateful. xxxxx
loading...
I think Bec, that we (and I mean we in a collective sense) have moved too far away from death in general. It is too medicalised in some ways, too impersonal. Unlike 50-100 years ago, when a body was held in a house before a funeral, or many people died at a much younger age, death is now something that largely happens to other, older people. And our only experience with death and grief is the pretend, storybook, soap opera contrived way.
Until it happens to us. And we find that all our thoughts, beliefs, and expectations are vastly removed from the reality.
I’m not for one second decrying the medical advances that have eliminated many of the causes of early deaths (TB, smallpox etc), nor am I saying the medical profession is at fault for this. Just that as a society, we have moved away from being able to see, touch, feel death intimately.
And that means that none of us “cope” the way we should, or even the way we used to. Perhaps its time as a society to accept, really accept, that death is a part of life. And sheltering away from it does none of us any favours at all.
Bless you for sharing your story. As you found with Mia, knowing someone else can be helpful. Perhaps when more people feel they are able to share so generously as you have, our reactions to others will be more understanding.
loading...
Bec I comment here all the time, and have told the story of my stillborn daughter Hope, my first baby at 40 weeks, several times. I always seem to comment on the posts about babies and pregnancy loss. This post spoke to me more than any post on Mamamia ever has.
Through a strange twist of fate, I have actually been in touch with Janelle of late and though my loss was four years ago, hers six months and yours 18 months, we all share the same thoughts and sentiments – that there is just no going back after a loss like this. You are forever altered. You will never be the same. And the grief can show itself in ways you would have never imagined. My grief was, and sometimes still is, ugly, dark, raw and all-encompassing. I lost friends because of it. I grieved those losses, but quickly realised I was better off with out those said friends, as they were just never going to get it. But that’s a good thing I guess, as we don’t want people to get it, we don’t want them to know this pain.
I find it hard to be around almost four year olds as well. Some babies in particular, I still have a real trouble seeing and getting to know. It hurts too much. Yes, I wonder why me. I know I shouldn’t, but it is what it is.
Anyway, I just want to once again say thank you and again tell you how sorry I am that Georgie is not here. This post spoke volumes.
xo
loading...
Oh Mamaofhope, I hear you. And listen, there is no ‘shouldn’t’ … we just have to feel what we feel. I still have dark moments too. So please don’t feel bad or guilty. We just can’t beat ourselves up about them. I’m so glad this post has helped you. Georgie and Hope and May and all the other little babies who aren’t here — they’re somewhere together watching over us. xxxxxxx
loading...
Bec – yes, I was going to say the same thing about “shouldn’t”. I don’t think there’s any right or wrong way to grieve – we all do it differently. Some do it openly and loudly, rending their clothing and scratching themselves. Others are the opposite – holding it all inside and remaining silent. Some are in between. No matter how we grieve, it still hurts profoundly and to the very core of our beings.
Thank you for this beautiful article – I wish you and every other bereaved parent, peace and healing and I hope all our angels are playing happily somewhere, eternally free of pain and sorrow.
loading...
I know what you mean about kids the same age.
My son is now 7.5, and Ashleigh would be 5.5. She would have been due to start Reception (Prep) this year. Around 7 friends of my son had siblings start at school at that time.
Last year when they all came in for transistion I lost it. I was so upset that I didnt have a child going into that year level. I know that in 12 years time when they are all graduating it will hit me pretty hard too.
I have so many friends who had kids when I had my son and had another around when I has Ashleigh. There are times it breaks my heart.
I know I am lucky to have had another child, and to have another girl is amazing, because I felt that would be something I may never have the chance to have again – that relationship between a mother and daughter… but it doesnt take away the pain of loosing my first daughter.
loading...
Beautiful and eloquent, Bec, as always. Thank you xx
loading...
Wow!! just Wow!!
your way with words and ability to draw us lucky readers into your emotions if amazing. thanks for sharing and opening my eyes to how blessed I am x
loading...
Beautifully written. xx
loading...
That was beautiful Bec – you are very brave. It stirred up feelings from my own past, not with a stillborn child, but very premature twin daughters. We didn’t know for a long time if they would live or not, be disabled or have life-long side-effects from their prematurity. At the time, I remember my head being so full and trying to keep it together for my three year old son. So many people referred to me as ‘stoic’ but they never saw me at home when I was alone crying, heartbroken for my babies, wondering what was in store for them. We have been blessed – they are healthy 9 year olds now, but I’ll never forget that place of grief.
loading...
Thankyou for such a beautiful and eloquent post x
loading...
As a mother of a stillborn too I get it. I get how it alters us forever. I think its truely that sad she has had to endure this for 32 years.
loading...
Thank you for this post.
loading...
So true. I remember the day my died of cancer. I was 12. My parents had separated when I was 9 but he landed on our doorstep a couple of years later with the news that he was terminally ill. He moved in, my mother cared for him and 6 months later he was dead. I loved my father dearly and we were very close. I remember going into town to buy him a pair of shoes for Father’s day while he was bed ridden. Shoes? He told me he loved them. I was reading the Silver Brumby series. They were girl, horsey books. He read them with me so that we could connect and talk about them.
The day he died I woke up to my Mum standing in my room. Next thing I remember was standing on the verandah with my brother watching the paramedics take his body away. That morning a neighbour came by and picked me up to take me to her house for the day. She had 3 daughters. We made pot pourri umbrellas, cooked pancakes, watched Beetle Juice and Coming to America while eating chips. Later that afternoon as we will pulled into my driveway I watched another 13 year old neighbour walking home from our house after visiting my Mum and brother and she was crying. I’ll never forget that feeling of ‘she’s doing what I think I’m suppose to be doing’. I hadn’t shed a tear at the stage. We all grieve differently.
loading...
*dad*
loading...
So true. My father died of lung cancer six months ago and I’m 40 in a couple of weeks. He was a difficult man to put it mildly. I haven’t cried for his loss yet. I’m angry, disappointed, confused, hurt and upset with him and my family (there was that awful fall-out that you always think won’t happen in your family, but does, and it’s torn me apart). I didn’t go to his funeral for many reasons. All I know for sure is that I’ll never see him again. I don’t know how I’m supposed to feel, and I don’t know if I’ll ever grieve for him.
loading...
I didn’t cry for days after my dad passed away from cancer at 56 (I was 28) – my biggest feeling after watching his body and mind shut down over his final days was relief…such a relief when he finally took his last breath…who knows what is normal.
loading...
What a brillaint post. This just expresses, so beautifully and healthily, how you felt and how you could feel. We all do need to step back for a moment, especially when we havent had the unfortunate experience ourselves, or even when we have. All pain, happiness, sadness, love, grief and fear etc., is dealt with at our own pace and in our own shape and it is not something that we should be judged for but instead supported. That person that is always annoyingly happy maybe be struggling with every breath they take, the person that seems so miserable all the time, may in fact have something, minor to you, but deeply personal and indescribable to others and it’s not up to us to judge them. We don’t know what’s inside their heart or their home. So stop before you say something that would cause you great sadness or pain to know that another person may be thinking of you if you find yourself on that same “patch of grass” one day.
loading...
Bec, beautifully written, made me cry…again. As someone who has had to deal with grief I understand everything you said. A year after I lost my husband to suicide I remember people saying I should be over it and moving on. You never get “over it”, just learn to cope in your own way and continue on in life. Thanks for sharing xx
loading...
I think we can add Madeline McCann’s mother to this list.
People still say she did it because she did not act to a script of how a parent should act.
loading...
YES!
loading...
Thank you for your story, such a beautiful article on such a sad subject.People grieve in different ways.The story that comes to mind is Kate McCann when Maddie went missing.Mother’s have such a tough job when they are having to grieve in the media.Its hard enough grieving with out the media.
loading...
I really empathise with Lindy Chamberlain. I can imagine myself becoming robotic in response to such a loss, so that I could remove myself from the sheer agony and horror of it all. And then, when the whole country judged her, just awful. No wonder she went to live in the US. I’m so glad that that chapter, at least as far as possible, has been closed for her and wish her all the best for the rest of her life.
loading...
Thank you Bec.
loading...
Oh Bec, You are so wonderful to put this horrific story into the correct light. I watched holding my breath yesterday as they made the announcement and I cried my eyes out thinking how it must be to lose a child. You are so brave to share your pain. I am trying to coneceive at the moment and it seems like every week someone around me falls pregnant and I have to admit I have had those moments of why not me and felt so bad for it. Does that make me a bad person ? I sincerely hope not. Does being brave for her living children make Lindy a bad person ? No does being brave in the face of public grief make her a bad person ? No. It makes her human and I think your aticle serves as a timely reminder that we can all take notice of. Your so inspiring Bec and someone I have looked up to for such a long time. Whenever I feel as though im slipping and make judgements and not being the person I should be I find the answers or the right way here and for that I thank you and the rest of the MM team. Much love to you and your family Bec you deseve all the happiness in the world xx
loading...
Thank you Bec for such a deeply moving article. As you say so well, there are no rules for grieving. I do not deal well with my own grief. I am one of those people who shuts down and shows a different face to the world to what I feel inside. I shudder to think how an unsympathetic public would judge me if I ever lost one of my children and my face was broadcast to the world in the same way as Lindy Chamberlain. Touch wood I won’t ever have to experience the hatred she has experienced but it makes me cold just to think about it…
loading...
In the ABC documentary, Losing Layla, the film-maker, spoke about going about her daily business after her baby daughter died six hours after her birth. In that the early, raw period after Layla’s death, Vanessa said that if she passed a woman in the street with a little baby, she would momentarily hope that baby would die so the mother would know what it felt like. Grief isn’t always PC and socially acceptable. It is what it is.
Thanks for a great article, Bec. I’m so sorry for what you went through.
loading...
I watched that on ABC when my baby was 3 months old and was an absolute mess. All I could do was cuddle my baby after her feed.
I used to cry in the car, or rage at the washing line while I was going through my miscarriage phase before said baby.
I remember the criticism Lindy got after Azaria got and didn’t understand why, but after criticism after my own miscarriages I know that people are uncomfortable with grief/sadness.
loading...
My son was born with Down syndrome 12 years ago. While I did not lose a child, I certainly grieved for the child I was expecting.
To this day, when someone I know is pregnant I’ll have a flash of “I hope it has Down’s”, both so that someone else can understand the grief I’ve been through, but also (nowadays) so they could experience the joys.
I hate myself everytime I wish that a pregnant celebrity or politician would have a baby with a disability, even though my reasons (these days) are relatively more honourable – a) so that disability would be more accepted and b) higher funded!
loading...
i have tried to write this comment so many times over, to get out what i want to say – words fail me. So i will just say to Bec – thankyou for writing this post, so poignant and beautiful, I cried at my desk from start to finish
loading...
I don’t know of any other writer in the country that could have written about grief like you have, Bec. Every time I read something you have written about losing Georgie, I am deeply moved. For everyone who has felt grief and loss, you name it for what it is, that simultaneous numbness and the frozen-in-time, foggy head state at odds with a heart full of this little feeling, the shivers, that big feeling that threatens to explode inside you and just has to be gotten out and once it is out, why did you bother when everything is still the same.
I really wish that you hadn’t had to go through what you have been through. Your writing though is a light in a long and dark, heavy night for people who are grieving … Someone else knows and is brave enough to talk about what no one wants to talk about. So grateful to you, Bec, just so grateful that you are the brave woman that you are. You may not know it, but you make a difference.
I think you and Lindy would have some great conversations and be so good for each other if you ever had the chance to meet.
loading...
Me again… Did anyway watch that insight episode where a psychologist was saying that people who ‘severley’ grieve for more than a year may have a mental health issue ie: depression.
I was gob smacked.
We are still grieving for my brother who died 10 years ago. Not only because we lost him, but because we’ve also lost the opportunities his life was going to bring us. Partner, kids, joy, sorrow, heartache, pride… Life.
loading...