Do You Like This Story?
KristinDevitt 380x380 My job has a shelf life. Its age 30.

Kristin Devitt

 

 

 

 

 

by KRISTIN DEVITT

It’s still one of my old gags, “I got out of television before they had to put Vaseline on the lens”.

But there is more than a little truth to the fact that as a woman on television, you get that sense that your time may be up at a certain age. That there’s a shelf life.  I should add I made the leap over to PR before I hit 30!

After quick stints doing the graveyard (midnight to dawn) shift at one Brisbane newsroom while finishing my uni degree, and a whistle-stop three months reporting in Rockhampton, I landed a Brisbane reporting and weekend newsreading role at the tender age of 21 in the early 1990s. I covered many news rounds over the ensuing nine years from courts to police, parliament and the arts.

Looking back now, there is a part of me that wishes I had ignored that one news director who declared I “didn’t have the x-factor” after nearly ten years on air. The same one whose wife took great issue with me wearing pink lipstick reading the news. Still not sure if it was fuschia or fuschia on me that was the problem. Who doesn’t love hot pink? Reminds me of another of my quotable quotes: “x-factor, sex factor, couldn’t give a max factor”.

But at the time, and certainly I know it is still the case for many young women on tv, the pressure to be slim, to be forever young, was great.

I take great joy in seeing women newsreaders in Australia continue to deliver our tv news into their 40s, 50s and beyond. Travelling regularly overseas as I do, this is something I have seen as the norm rather than the exception in Europe and the US. It’s okay to catch up.

But I don’t see many of them greying, wearing glasses, putting on a little pudding around the middle, as opposed to some of their male counterparts. That would be just too much wouldn’t it?

I am short sighted, and wear contact lenses every day, but I recall in my mid-twenties coming back to the newsroom from a story wearing glasses, and a news boss bailing me up to ask if I had worn them in the shots! No, rest assured, I took them off for my piece to camera, and for my noddies, couldn’t see a thing, but I knew the aesthetics were more important than authenticity. Wait, that all sounds a bit bitter doesn’t it?

I am going back more than 15 years now, but the subject still riles me. You see, while there are increasingly women of all ages, shapes and sizes having a voice as tv news reporters, I would like to see more of these women delivering the news from the desk as well. I love beauty as much as the next person, but when it comes to news, I like it coming from someone who knows what they’re talking about. Someone who has covered a natural disaster, a cracking court case, a political bun fight. And I don’t think I’m alone in that.

kristin My job has a shelf life. Its age 30.

Kristin

Speaking of which, one of my favourite reporting memories was while covering the 1996 Charleville floods. The stoicism and good humour of that community I will never forget.

Our cameraman and I filed three times a day, for morning, evening and late news. But I got in trouble for looking “too glamorous” because I was wearing a silver fob chain that I never used to take off, thigh deep in floodwaters. Sometimes you just can’t win.

It is important to point out that some of the most physically attractive women news presenters are also some of our best journalists and intelligent, interested people. I should know, I count many of them as my friends.

So what’s the answer? Well as Jennifer Livingston (see below) points out, this debate is about not judging. And for my money, it’s also about rising above. I personally know visionary news directors and producers who today are encouraging women to stay and even return to on air roles.

And no doubt polished presentation is always important. In my role today as a PR advisor, I teach corporate media training, central to which is knowing your area, and looking and sounding the part.

So that means don’t wear a brooch that looks like a large beetle is climbing up your jacket, and sit on your coat tails for a straight line. And more importantly, know your subject, think about your audience, have a conversation with them.

The beetles and the rounded shoulders can be sorted by wardrobe. Engaging with an audience takes a bit more.

It’s a shame to rule out generations of women who may not cut the mustard in the looks department, but have so much more to offer. Pink lipstick or otherwise.

Earlier this week Mamamia showed you a video of Jennifer Livingston, a female newscaster who responded to a viewer who called her fat. Her response is going viral around the world and it shows just how tough the public can be on female reporter’s looks:

 

Managing Director of KDPR Kristin Devitt has forged a successful career spanning more than two decades as a highly effective communications strategist. With a background in broadcast journalism including time spent as a journalist and  presenter with the Ten Network, Kristin has established her credibility on the media map. She is also the director of Babes in Business, Brisbane’s premier women’s networking organisation


Do you think there is more pressure on women to look a certain way in professions like journalism? Do you think there is enough diversity of shapes and sizes on Australian screens?

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

30 Comments so far

  1. liberty

    I worked in TV new for many years, including a stint on air as a newsreader for a few years. One of the reasons I chose to leave – I am now a freelance foreign correspondent – is because I was really very disturbed by the treatment meted out to older women in journalism. For example, the way Mary Kostakidis was treated by both SBS when she left the broadcaster, as well as the print media – I remember a ghastly front page photograph of Mary out jogging in The Australian. This, for a woman who spent decades as the face of a minnow television station, lending it her grace and dignity. She deserved far better treatment. And other commercial broadcasters, in how they let go of their on-air talent once they’ve reached what is judged to be their use-by date (who decides these things anyway?) It’s one thing to tell someone that their time is up and thank them graciously for their hard work and buy them a cake; another to tell them they’ve been sacked via email. I have met some of these former newsreaders; they have in common this air of concealed embitterment, of resignation, of deep sadness.

    I realised that the energy it would take to simply stay in the game, when it came to being on air, would become so overwhelming that it would take up almost all my energy: energy that might otherwise be spent on acquiring new skills or career development. What role is there for a former television newsreader?

    So I chose to get out. I don’t get a massive clothing allowance, I don’t get to spend an hour of my day in makeup, I don’t get everyone looking at me for an hour or two each day, but I get to choose the future direction of my career to a greater extent.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. mwobfpku

    Freedom does not mean no restrictions. Kids just love rhythm in stories and poems. Also recorded here are Pied-billed Grebe, Common Loon, a wide variety of ducks, Double-crested Cormorant, Great Black-backed Gull, American Coot, American Bittern, Least Bittern, Great Blue Heron, Virginia Rail, Common Snipe, Spotted Sandpiper, Marsh Wren, and Common Moorhen. Roasting does not let things go mushy and textureless. L忙ngden af 鈥嬧€媍ocktail kjoler varierer afh忙ngigt af mode og lokal skik. Doudoune Canada Goose a popular professional field in health care. doudoune canada goose couleur canada goose calgary black jacket http://www.soldesdoudouneparis.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Cate

    Last time i visited Australia i was struck by just how young and pretty ALL the female newsreaders were. Even the women who i know are older don’t really look their age (subtle botox perhaps). It’s a stark contrast to the Netherlands where older women feature frequently on television and don’t seem to be under pressure to hide their age. I find it refreshing to see a few wrinkles !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Ali Flint

    This is a good article and it makes some vitally important points. What exactly are we to do with ourselves when youth is in the distant past? We have university degrees, health, energy and motivation. At 58, I ask these questions daily. Nobody wants you at this age, even if you have amazing skills. Everybody wants a sweet young thing. That I’m not. I exited a career in advertising at age 27, mainly because I could see that I would become expedient before my use-by date. Fair? No. Our society must urgently address the issue of older people who are still extremely useful and wish to contribute. Is “volunteering” the only vocation suitable for older people? I think not.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Guest

    I think society is still working it out. When I was a kid, mothers rarely worked and Grandmas knitted. These days mothers run corporations and Grandmas are either working, travelling or doing both (my kids grandmas are writing textbooks, lecturing or heading off to Europe/China shortly). As women become more educated and more experienced in the workforce, society will finally figure out that older women are not just knitters and lamington makers.

    That’s my hope anyway. Maybe too optimistic?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Journo

    Yes there is for sure. I’ve personally seen some great femal Journos ‘shrink’ over the years. Age aside for a moment, they look skeletal off camera.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Michelle

    Great article Kristin. I’ve been somewhat mortified over the past year watching a wave of young, predominately male ‘presenters’ pop up on screen at Channel Ten who were promoted as being the networks ‘saviours’ eg Hamish MacDonald. Why mortified? Because with MacDonald’s arrival, the lady often regarded as the face of Ten News, Sandra Sully appeared to be being pushed asided presumably due to her age. With the cancelation of Ten Late News, reportedly due to lacklustre ratings, Sully was moved to the 5pm desk which unfortunately bumped Deborah Knight, another of Ten’s exceptionally talented female journalists, resulting in Knight leaving the network. What has occurred since? Well MacDonald was given his own ‘show’, Late News with Hamish MacDonald. The first episode opened with MacDonald sprouting ‘the adults have left the building and left us the keys’. As a 20 year veteran of Ten’s Late News I was offended by this statement. The revamped Late News, which, by the way, needs a new name as it comprises of approximately 6mins of news and 39mins of drivel between a boring ‘panel’, is aimed at the hip and happening 20 somethings. But the 20s somethings are obviously off watching Jersey Shore or the like as the ratings have been less than stellar. FYI Sandra Sully’s Late News averaged around 290,000 a week with a start time ranging anywhere from 10:30pm to midnight. MacDonald’s Late News averages around 160,000 with a regular 10:30pm start.Interesting to note the new Late News garnered its best ratings the week a woman, Natarsha Belling hosted.

    Sandra had a loyal audience which would be back in a heartbeat if she returned to the late night shift. MacDonald, he has red pants.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sally

      Very well said Michelle. I too have noticed the shift by Ten towards a younger news crew. Even though Bill Woods and Sandra Sully present the Sydney bulletin, the majority of the reporters looks as though they have just graduated from high school, bar Sheryl Taylor and Hugh Rimmenton. I think this is a terrible shame. Sandra use to be the ‘go to person’ when their was a special event or documentary. That seems to have changed which is extremely unfortunate as she is by far Ten’s greatest asset due to the respect she has amongst her peers and the fondness the majority of Australia has for her.

      The shift Ten has made certainly hasn’t worked and it would be in their best interest to make some changes, fast.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Rebecca

      Nah, Michelle – the 20 somethings aren’t watching Jersey Shore, they get their news on the Internet.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. Siobhan

    I commented on another story but I feel the need to say it again. Adelaide’s number 1 rating news team is Jayne Doyle and John Riddell, both in their mid 50s and they certainly aren’t botoxed. In fact, they look like my mum and dad. They have been reading the news for years. We had two male newsreaders who were the biggest rating until one passed away and the other semi retired. Visited Perth recently and their female newsreader wasn’t 21 either. I’m sorry, but I just don’t buy it. If people like a newsreader, and they get ratings, the network will keep them. If viewers don’t like the newsreader, they switch off. Don’t always think it is because of their age.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Miss L

      Agreed. My favourite news presenter is Lee Lin Chin on SBS and she’s no spring chicken!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • GO

        Yes…totally agree – also think Lee Lin Chin on SBS is an excellent newsreader, great voive and articulates very well – wish a local TV station would poach her!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Clare M

      That’s Susannah Carr you’re referring to – don’t know her age but I’d guess 50-something – co-anchor of top rated Perth news for many, many years

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. chillax

    While our female TV presenters keep looking younger as they age and their facial features continue to become increasingly alien, while the men can gain weight, go bald, or grey and wrinkly as they age naturally I do think the women are obviously facing far too much pressure just to keep their careers.
    I think the ABC is getting right for diversity, its pretty much on its own though.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Bec

    I find this article really strange. Our screens are filled with women of all ages – Lisa Wilkinson, Tracey Grimshaw, Jo Hall, Kay McGrath etc. All of whom are over 30 and very popular. I don’t really understand it at all.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kate Hunter

      Bec, I think the point is more about the pressure to look fabulous. I had a pal who presented ABC midday news for awhile and I was astounded to see some of the emails she got from viewers about her clothes and her hair. Pretty sure Andrew Lofthouse was never criticised for his choice of tie! My friend still works for the ABC, but is a producer. The 30+ female newsreader isn’t extinct, bust she is rare. Have a look at the young women who present the weekend news – without fail they are model-esque. Reasonably sure they aren’t representative of the general enrolment of journalism students.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Bec

        Maybe Kate. I am pretty sure Kay McGrath wears glasses too. Lots of women have work done just for themselves. My Mum has had the works done lately and it’s for her, not for her employer. I don’t know if you have noticed but Karl has remarkably white teeth, a lot more hair and far less wrinkles than he did a few years ago… As for Kochie, I have no words for that Qld hater.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Aly

          I was also going to mention Kay McGrath – yep glasses too. But I”m sure she has had to deal with all the issues the article talks about.

          So sill!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • GO

          The 2 K’s(Karl and Kochie)…cant stand them… so full of themselves! And it seems that everyone on TV these days has remarkably white teet!!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Ellie

      They are also attractive. Lisa Wilkinson (who is brilliant, not that I watch morning TV) may be older than her cohost, but she is beautiful. The point is that you flick the channel and there is Kochie who is also 50+ and looks it – it’s highly unlikely that a woman with greying hair and glasses would get his job. I do, however, look forward to being proven wrong.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • chillax

      And Bec, I would bet lots of money that most of the women over 45 on TV have had some sort of ‘work’ done. They do look too good to be natural.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        Any woman over the age of 35 in the media has had work done. To think otherwise is foolish. Teeth whitening, botox, veneers, lip implants, cheek implants.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • chillax

          And apart from a few, most of the men can age naturally and that’s ok. Thats why there are some people on TV who look like father/daughter combo when really their age difference is only a few years!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  11. The Wizz

    Aren’t TV bulletins a dying art these days, making the discussion of more women newsreaders a mute point?
    If all TV news and current affairs is good for these days is reporting on speeding grannys on gophers and doing advertorial posting as news for the latest TV shows airing on that particular news station then let the blokes keep it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. TDMJ

    I really like this piece and the message it holds. Kristin sounds like smart, savvy businesswoman and someone to really like and respect also. What I don’t really get is why, having written (and believing in) a piece like this, she’d want to be involved with an organisation called ‘Babes in Business’? I’m sure it’s a worthy group with great intentions, but doesn’t that just add to the continuing focus on women’s age and looks before their skills and experience!?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      Hi TDMJ

      Fair question! As a Brisbane girl myself, I thought I’d explain that it’s more a tongue in cheek, fun term. The organisation is actually brilliant = it’s open to women of all ages, has nothing to do with looks and they do loads of charity work (as well as providing valuable networking opportunities to women). To my knowledge (and as a past member when I was living in Brisbane) — it’s a throw away line. Like “chicks in pink” .. that kind of thing.

      And yes — Kristin is pretty amazing!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Jac Qld

        I thought the same – but thought I would check it out as I am in the area and I would love to be involved in a decent business group; but Bec it doesn’t sound like woman of all ages – the website states ” Babes in Business is a network of more than 500 young leading women in business” on the benefits page – which makes it sound like it is only for the young business women in Bris.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • becsparrow

          Hey Jac

          I’ll ask Kristin to comment because I think the term young is relative. Put it this way — I know lots of 40-somethings who are members. But if you were over 50, then I would say it is probably more full of women aged 25-40/ 25-45. (Hope that makes sense).

          I’ll see if I can find out more for you in case you’re interested!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Jac Qld

            Thanks Bec!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • BBoyschau

              Hi Jac

              I actually work for Babes in Business and can assure you the membership is not restricted to “young” women. We have plenty of women in their 40′s and 50′s in the network, even more so than the 20-somethings! Thanks for pointing out that discrepancy, it isn’t accurate and I’m not sure why it says that!

              We’d love to have to you along to one of our upcoming Babes events. If you’re interested to hear more please feel free to contact us.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions