*Trigger warning: This post is about child sexual abuse and may cause distress for some readers.
by PETE DILLON
So Joe Hockey doesn’t think a Royal Commission will help survivors of clerical sexual abuse? I, for one, disagree.
For decades, thousands of Australians have suffered immeasurable mental, emotional and psychological trauma because of rape and abuse committed by members of the Catholic clergy. For decades, the church has covered up, hushed up and hidden those abusers. The survivors, or victims, if they had not taken their own life or suffered through incredible amounts of mental anguish have been mostly forgotten and forced to pick up the pieces on their own. The perpetrators were allowed to move on and be hidden by the organisation that should have been protecting its flock.
If this was another organisation, like the Boy Scouts for example, there would have been a Royal Commission well before now. There would be thousands of these criminals imprisoned rather than simply being moved on to another parish where they can continue to abuse other children, or collude or cover up with their colleagues, the abuse of women and children in the church.
I know because I survived.
I was an 8-9 year old when I was sexually abused by a member of the Catholic Church. I was an altar boy at a small parish in regional Victoria, and I was forced to commit acts that I did not understand. I had no idea what I was being forced to do. All I knew was that I knew it was wrong, I knew it did not make me feel special like the priest said it would. I did know that I was being told not to tell anyone, for fear of getting in trouble, that no one would believe me if I told them and that I was bad.
It took me 22 years to tell anyone and it was only during a session with a psychologist during a particularly difficult time in my life that I dealt with any of what happened. I felt like a weight had been lifted from my shoulders, I felt as if I no longer had anything to hide.
Oddly, this was during the time I was also dealign with my sexuality – or more to the point, my homosexuality. I had spent a great many years not being able to be myself because I thought it was my fault. I carried a great burden of guilt that I never should have been forced to carry. I was just a little boy and in the years that have passed, I have been forced to mourn the loss of that innocent little boy.
I have contemplated taking the church’s hush money, but no amount will ever give me back my childhood. My father died when I was in my early 20′s and my father never properly knew his youngest son. I could never tell my father who I was, because of what happened to me as a child. When I told my mother, she broke down and cried. I am the second youngest of ten kids and my parents clung very firmly to their faith, it was one of the few things that they had. I made a decision not to tell them what had happened when I was a boy. My mother wished that she could have helped me through, and realised that much of what I told her made sense – she had seen the change in me from that age but never quite knew why.
Its fine for Joe Hockey to suggest that he has friends who would be traumatised by a Royal Commission, but what Mr Hockey can never understand is that we are traumatised every day. Mr Hockey does not understand how we FEEL. I hope that governments at both State and Federal level can see past religion and think of the tens of thousands of people who have been damaged by the church.
It is not just the victims or survivors. It is those that have to help pick up the pieces, those that have to ask the questions when the abused take their own lives or descend in to substance abuse to block out the pain that they are experiencing. It is the partners of those who still cry and scream in their sleep that have to wonder why.
If Joe Hockey and Tony Abbott and all of those other Catholic members of parliament want to continue to allow their church to get away with what they have done, then they can continue to forget people like me and bury their heads in the sand. Or they can show some fortitude and stand up and demand that the church finally answers to all of us. Only when that happens can we truly begin to heal. Only then can we find some closure and see some of those perpetrators punished for what they have done.
I am one of the lucky ones – I say lucky because I was able to navigate my way through the hurt and trouble – I almost didn’t make but I am here and I am blessed to have an amazing partner who understands, a wonderful family who support me and a circle of friends who love me regardless.
I only wish that so many others were as lucky as me.
Pete Dillon owns a marketing, media, events and communications agency in Melbourne, Tusq. He is a social commentator and a lover of a healthy political discussion and you can read his blog at dillonpete.wordpress.com. When he is not getting on his high horse about something, you can find him indulging his passion for good food and fine wine.








Comments
38 Comments so far
A priest (Roy Bourgeois) was excommunicated from the Church on the basis that he publicly supported women’s ordination. Yet a Patrician Brother, a convicted paedophile who raped a 10 year old boy (Brother Thomas Grealy – Principal of Patrician Brothers School in Granville), remains a Patrician Brother after serving 4 years in jail for his crime and has been welcomed back by the Catholic Church, retaining his title, housing and financial support. Mr Grealy, in the school’s most recent newsletter was named as one of Granville’s ‘treasures’.
Shall we remark that the obvious homosexual nature of the crime, which is at odds with the Catholic Church’s vehement rejection of homosexuality and which breaks the vow of celibacy a brother must undertake, has been completely overlooked by the Church. Does the stance against homosexuality only apply to lay-people? And is committing sexual offences against children, or adults, alright if its perpetrated by a messenger of God? And is the vow of celibacy just an empty something to say during ordination?
There is an irreconcilable and obvious double-standard at play here, Catholic Church officials can rape a child, a male child in many cases, and not be disowned by the Church, but if a priest so much as nods his head in agreement about attaining a scintilla of equality for women, he is harshly punished. In Mr Bourgois’ case, he faced the most severe punishment within the Church, excommunication.
The Church has a culture of protecting its own, even when criminal offences are perpetrated. There are hundreds of thousands of similar cases, where priests or other officials of the Catholic Church perpetrate rape and child sex abuse, who have gone unpunished or who are sometimes silently moved to serve in another geographical area if the abuse becomes too public. All this without any recognition that the life of an innocent has been irrevocably damaged.
As the Thomas Grealy story illustrates, it is clear that membership to a Catholic brethren or order does not provide legal immunity (fortunately priests and brothers are subject to our criminal laws just as other paedophiles and offenders are), however the law is obstructed by the systematic covering-up of these crimes by officials within the Catholic Church. If the law cannot get to the perpetrators of the child sex abuse, then the law can begin to prosecute those who knowingly withhold information from the police. People and organisations can be prosecuted for this, which includes the church.
Charges include, “Obstruction of Justice,” or “Impeding a Police Investigation” and depending on the type and seriousness of the information you’re withholding, a person might face the charge of being an “Accessory” to the crime.
The only exception to this is if the information being withheld pertains to your spouse. As an overwhelming number of Catholic official posts are held by men who are protecting priests (who can only be male) they cannot marry each other (before the law in most places, under the vows as a priest, and certainly not within the Catholic Church for those who are not priests) and therefore, are not entitled to the privilege of this exception.
loading...
National Inquiry into Child Sex Abuse. Let us take a moment to reflect, using one particular comparison as an example to start with…
It certainly is a baffling moral code the Catholic Church implements.
A priest (Roy Bourgeois) was excommunicated from the Church on the basis that he publicly supported women’s ordination. Yet a Patrician Brother, a convicted paedophile who raped a 10 year old boy (Brother Thomas Grealy – Principal of Patrician Brothers School in Granville), remains a Patrician Brother after serving 4 years in jail for his crime and has been welcomed back by the Catholic Church, retaining his title, housing and financial support. Mr Grealy, in the school’s most recent newsletter was named as one of Granville’s ‘treasures’.
Shall we remark that the obvious homosexual nature of the crime, which is at odds with the Catholic Church’s vehement rejection of homosexuality and which breaks the vow of celibacy a brother must undertake, has been completely overlooked by the Church. Does the stance against homosexuality only apply to lay-people? And is committing sexual offences against children, or adults, alright if its perpetrated by a messenger of God? And is the vow of celibacy just an empty something to say during ordination?
There is an irreconcilable and obvious double-standard at play here, Catholic Church officials can rape a child, a male child in many cases, and not be disowned by the Church, but if a priest so much as nods his head in agreement about attaining a scintilla of equality for women, he is harshly punished. In Mr Bourgois’ case, he faced the most severe punishment within the Church, excommunication.
The Church has a culture of protecting its own, even when criminal offences are perpetrated. There are hundreds of thousands of similar cases, where priests or other officials of the Catholic Church perpetrate rape and child sex abuse, who have gone unpunished or who are sometimes silently moved to serve in another geographical area if the abuse becomes too public. All this without any recognition that the life of an innocent has been irrevocably damaged.
As the Thomas Grealy story illustrates, it is clear that membership to a Catholic brethren or order does not provide legal immunity (fortunately priests and brothers are subject to our criminal laws just as other paedophiles and offenders are), however the law is obstructed by the systematic covering-up of these crimes by officials within the Catholic Church. If the law cannot get to the perpetrators of the child sex abuse, then the law can begin to prosecute those who knowingly withhold information from the police. People and organisations can be prosecuted for this, which includes the church.
Charges include, “Obstruction of Justice,” or “Impeding a Police Investigation” and depending on the type and seriousness of the information you’re withholding, a person might face the charge of being an “Accessory” to the crime.
The only exception to this is if the information being withheld pertains to your spouse. As an overwhelming number of Catholic official posts are held by men who are protecting priests (who can only be male) they cannot marry each other (before the law in most places, under the vows as a priest, and certainly not within the Catholic Church for those who are not priests) and therefore, are not entitled to the privilege of this exception.
loading...
I sometimes wonder if there would have been this problem if priests and nuns had been allowed to marry. Celibacy wasn’t originally part of the requirements for its clergy. I know that it’s probably a simplistic view, but I have to admit I haven’t heard of scandals of this magnitude from other churches and a great many of them allow marriage for their clergy. Interesting though, that I haven’t heard of issues relating to pedophilia amongst the Buddhist monks.
loading...
Faybian I’m no expert but I don’t think paedophilia is about sexual urges. There are many married paedophiles out there. I think it is about opportunistic power and maybe, is a form of sociopathy. How could anyone be unresponsive to the cries of pain of a child?
And just because we haven’t heard about it may not mean that there aren’t paedophile buddhist monks. Would these sorts of conversations be encouraged in those communities I wonder??
loading...
To me, I feel as though people who have such urges would gravitate towards a job where you have the opportunity and power to do this to children with no pressure from peers or family to have a functional adult relationship. I’m not saying all priests are priests for this reason, but if you look at it more as pedophiles become priests rather than priests become pedophiles then it might make more sense?
loading...
As Pell has said,ten years ago the Church did not fully understand the nature of pedophilia??He uses his possition to pressure governments to continue the opression of homosexuals, that only ask for the right to live their lives and relationships honestly and openly,Enough,enough enough
loading...
Great that you can tell your story Pete. We have got to the point where we have to question the real motivation of Catholic politicians such as Hockey, Abbott, Shorten and co. They should not be making decisions about a royal commission or the future of the cc
loading...
Pete, I’m thinking if you were my son (I have three of them) I would have a lot of trouble stopping myself hoping Pell would suddenly just drop dead out of divine retribution. The only consolation I would have is that I absolutely know that what goes around comes around and that justice will be done to all of those concerned in the Catholic church, in ways entirely appropriate for each of them. I would have to depend only on this consolation. If you were my son it would ruin my life no less than it has ruined yours. To think of all my efforts of childraising being wasted on the actions of truly evil people would be unbearable. I’m so so sorry that I have tears in my eyes thinking that it could be one of my own sons. How dare the Catholic church do this not only to yourself, but to other boys and their mothers and fathers. In their own language, I want to call for hellfire and damnation – not forgiveness. That’s how it makes me feel. And it’s an awful feeling.
loading...
Hi,
I agree the Catholic Church should be made accountable for the appalling sexual abuse that children have suffered. As a child my family always used to have a couple of boys from the Catholic Institutions and they became our brothers. They never told Mum about what happened because they were ashamed and thought that no one would believe them. My Mum usually gets a Christmas card each year and my eldest brother still is in contact with the men. Both are alcoholics and have struggled through life.
No more royal commissions. We already know what went on. Why waste millions of dollars on a talk fest to tell the community what we already know?
A better way to spend the money would be to help these people through their lives, accommodation, food, counselling and also the people responsible being named and jailed without protection that the rock spiders always request. They will have the same amount of protection that they gave the children, none.
loading...
True courage Pete. Thank you.
Please everybody go to change.org and sign Catherine Deveny’s petition demanding a royal commission into the Catholic Church’s insidious cover-ups!
loading...
Done and shared, thanks for pointing it out anon!
loading...
could you provide a link? i would love to sign
loading...
It’s so sad to read what happened to Pete Dillon. His childhood taken away – and the pain and suffering he’s had to live with.
loading...
Every word that Pete said could also be said by my brother. 50 years on he still remains traumatised. With the help of psychologists he lives one day at a time. I am so glad that he has a wonderful understanding wife as she and their children and grandchildren give meaning to his life. In the past he has tried to take his life and has lived through addiction.
The polititions should be demanding a Royal commission and not hiding behind the frock and collar of the catholic church.
loading...
I think Cardinal Pell should be brought to justice for aiding and abetting those who have broken the law. He should be taken to court and made to explain why he hid people that should be in jail. He should be made accountable for concealing those that he knew broke the law. It starts at the top.
loading...
I agree Cate. Pell should be taken out first. And then all of them from the top down should be taken out after this. They belong IN JAIL.
loading...
Cardinal Pell’s hands are very dirty, especially for the cover ups and protection while he was in Victoria, along with Bishop Ronald Mulkearns. Mulkearns also has dirty hands, especially in the case of Monsignor Day of Mildura http://brokenrites.alphalink.com.au/nletter/page129-john-day.html
Pell, as the head of the church in Australia, and a Cardinal of the Vatican, has a great deal to answer to.
loading...
Is Joe Hockey worried about alienating the Catholic vote? These victims deserve closure. I’m sick of these predatory freaks hiding behind their frocks and collars, and the power they wield as annoited priests. Pffft! They’re not above the law, and to abuse a child, or anyone when you’re in a position of trust is unforgiveable, whether there’s a white colalr around your throat or not. Maybe they’re scared the collar will be replaced by a set of angry hands?
loading...
Bravo, Pete. For telling your story.
I wish you strength. And politics needs to stay the hell out of this.
loading...
Thanks – thats important to hear.
loading...
I went to click “like” haha!
Completely agree, thanks for sharing Pete!!
loading...
good on you Pete for sharing your story. Not all are understandably, able to do so. My father tried, nobody listen, nobody believed it could be true, his parents flat out told him he was lying and sent him back to school, an all boys catholic school, day after day after day, for years. This was in the 50′s. As he got older, he turned to drinking, everyday, to get by. He took his own life in the end. To all the deniers, to all the disbelievers, It happened, it’s real. So many boys suffered horrendous abuse, and the Catholic church and those involved need to be held accountable, NOW. Victims deserve justice. A Royal Commission needs to be held, and those responsible brought to justice.
loading...
Thats the power that I have – that I can share my story.
loading...
I don’t know you, Pete, but I also mourn the loss of that little boy. Well said, young man. x
loading...
Powerful article, Pete, and my heart really hurts thinking about the loss of your childhood and your innocence, just such a violation of a little boy. So ghastly wrong. Why the church did nothing to these men who abused children, I will never understand it.
loading...
good on you pete for stepping up and speaking out when so many victims would be unable to. i mean that times one million. you could sit back and say nothing but you are putting yourself out there on behalf of so many who can’t.
for that i really admire you and i wish you every happiness xxx
loading...
I was sexually assaulted as a child, I was around 6 and assaulted by a male cousin. I’m 22 now.
I get really annoyed when people in politics say stuff about rape, abuse and abortion, those in politics represent us, us as Australians. And when they say bad things it reflects badly back on us.
Just my 2 cents.
loading...
I too was a victim of sexual abuse from a young age which continued for many years. I am now 33 years of age and I have not yet been able to grieve for the loss of my childhood. As a coping mechanism and to remain sane I made the choice to block out 6 years of my life as if it never happened. However the reality is, this is not the case. Not a day goes by where I dont have flashbacks. I breathe and get on with every day life but I dont feel like a real person. My partner of 13 years is not even aware of what happened. I have buried in deep within me. Many times I have contemplated suicide however it is my 3 beautiful sons and loving partner that gives me the strength to carry on.
How dare the government disagree with a Royal Commission into sexual abuse within the Catholic Church. There must be consequences for those who destroyed innocent childhoods regardless of who you are. This would be justice for ALL sexual abuse victims, even those like me who suffer in silence. What message are you sending to victims???
Yep that’s right, continue to suffer in silence.
loading...
I have not told my partner either. Telling can be really hard, keep strong and when you can, keep sharing your story so others will learn.
Respect
loading...
Mel and Sarah, as a victim myself I know the torture of telling people. In some cases (partner, sisters etc) the support is vital. If I’m struggling they know why. In other cases the constant chant of “it was so long ago it’s time to get over it” is debilitating and humiliating. Find a person to trust, see a sexual assault counsellor and get well – you both deserve it. xoxox
(There are lots of places that are specially designed for victims of sexual assault. In Melbourne I can recommend CASA http://www.casa.org.au/ )
loading...
As the partner of someone who was abused and who suffered and behaved inexplicably for years before finally telling me, I just wanted to let you know what a difference it might make to your relationship if you work towards telling your partner.
We would have inevitably, unfairly split up if my husband hadn’t told me about his past. I’m not trying to prescribe when or how … but just that you think about it and hopefully work towards it for your own sake.
Much love xox
loading...
If your partner loves and trusts you, and you love and trust them, then share this story with them. It is important that the person you love and spend your life with understands your pain, understands what you have encountered and can help you start to heal. Without the support of my partner, my family and friends, I would never have made it through. sadly, it is a part of who you are. Seek some support – there are many organisations who can help you. Dont try to do it on your own.. it way too tough. Reach out – you may just find the hand you have been looking for. Stay strong. x
loading...
Pete, I am so sorry this happened to you. I’m so sorry this changed and hurt you forever and I am sad thinking about the innocence you lost at the hands of someone who you were led to believe you could trust. Every time I hear a story like yours I’m angry and sad and filled with utter disgust and contempt for the sick and twisted individuals who prey on young children.
I really do wish there was the death penalty for pedophiles, there is no cure for them and society as a whole would be better without them. It’s time the Catholic Church was held accountable for all the evil and vile acts they have committed and covered up over the years. The Catholic Church is a disgusting, despicable and hypocritical organisation filled with delusional, naive and predatory individuals.
Thank you for sharing your story.
loading...
My heart breaks too and I am right with you on most of your comment Cath … apart from the death penalty for pedophiles.
SO many pedophiles became that way because of abuse during their own childhood. Is it fair to kill somebody who became a perpetrator BECAUSE they were a victim?
And I think with good self awareness, psychotherapy and a will to change, of course *some* people who have abused children can change. But the death penalty leaves absolutely no room for that.
loading...
I have absolutely NO sympathy for pedophiles. NONE. Excusing their behaviour because they may of been abused themselves, is a cop out, and frankly offensive to all victims. I’d like to see your stats on that statement. Either way though, that does not make a difference. They’re adults, they know what they’re doing, they’re fully responsible, and they need to feel the full force of the law and be held accountable. Stop excusing their behaviour . Pedophiles don’t change. Because of all the bleeding hearts out their, pedophiles just get let loose back into the community to pick their next victim, like what’s happened repeatedly already. Lock them away forever In the general population section, not in protective custody, then they’ll get what they fully deserve.
loading...
Well Anonymous, I got that position FROM a victim – one with a wise and very just attitude that you could learn a lot from.
I can’t believe you’re insinuating that I would support any measure that puts children at risk.
Also, we are talking about **THE DEATH PENALTY**, not locking them up forever, in case you missed that bit.
loading...
I was abused from the ages of 4 to 9, don’t tell me I could learn a thing a two thanks. And my attitude is just fine, I don’t need you being condescending. Like I said I could not give a shit about pedophiles. They don’t change. Self awareness, psychotherapy , give me a break. I know the point was about the death penalty, but people know this will never be brought back, so why discuss it. Lock them in with the general population, throw away the key, then they will get exactly what they deserve .
loading...
I’m sorry that happened to you Anon, but why pick a fight with me over something I wasn’t arguing? I was arguing against the death penalty.
Of course victims views need to be taken into account – just be aware that other victims have views which contradict your own.
By the way, I really don’t want to have a fight about this as I think we’re pretty much on the same side. Sorry for being snarky, but you attacked me for holding a position which you don’t disagree with.
loading...