Do You Like This Story?
jessie 380x570 I fostered a 14 year old refugee. At 27

Jessie Taylor

by JULIE ULBRICHT

Last night’s Australian Story focused on the amazing story of Jessie Taylor, a young woman who fostered an Afghan refugee before she had even turned 30.

We had shared Jessie’s story here on Mamamia before and you may be interested to hear more about how she decided to make such a big leap for a cause she believes in.

When 27-year-old human rights lawyer Jessie Taylor, travelled to Indonesia to research the state of detention centres for a documentary in July 2009, she came across countless stories of desperation and persecution. But nothing could compare to a chance encounter with a 14 year old young man named Jaffar in an Indonesian jail. Jessie recalls how he looked straight at her and begged, “Can you help me?” but she knew, sadly, there was nothing she could do. Yet, in one of those beautiful moments of compassion and human connection, she scribbled down her phone number on a piece of paper and said, “If you make it to Australia, call me and I’ll look after you.”

Well, Jaffar managed to escape and find his way to a people smuggler who put him onto a boat with some 80 other men, women and children, making the dangerous 10 day journey across the seas. And, as hundreds of rickety boats before this one, the small, unsound vessel made it to Australian waters. In a military style operation, Australian border protection staff boarded the boat and allocated each of the passengers a three digit identifying code before escorting them to an Australian Maritime vessel. Welcome to Australia! Take a number.

Jaffar, just like the hundreds of “boat people” who arrive each year, would have been sick, vomiting, dehydrated, cold and exhausted. Not to mention suffering tremendous psychological damage that comes with crossing risky borders, and being thousands of miles from his parents and two younger brothers.

On Christmas Island, he was taken into a room. The door closed and two Australian Federal Police officers began the interrogation. They had searched him and discovered the crumpled note with a name and a phone number. “Where did you get this?” Jaffar was so scared that he would get Jessie into trouble. He had no understanding of the laws in this foreign country. Not that he hadn’t seen jails or detention before. They had become a part of his life now in his bid for survival.

But one thing that was certain, is that Jaffar would have had little comprehension of the idea of justice, having been raised in Afghanistan where, several years earlier, the Taliban had shot dead his older brother and sister on the doorstep of his house. In front of his parents. His father, desperate and in immense pain that only a grieving parent knows, said, “I cannot bear to see another one of my children die.” He gave Jaffar all the money he had and said, “Go. Try and find safety. One day we may see you again.”

See, Jaffar had reached puberty – a very risky time especially for males in war-ridden Afghanistan. Once these boys reach fighting age, they live with the threat of being killed or recruited to fight for the Taliban. So Jaffar kissed his parents goodbye and made the journey to Indonesia, and ended up in the jail where he had met Jessie.

Screen shot 2012 07 17 at 10.34.05 AM I fostered a 14 year old refugee. At 27

Jaffar in 2012

Jessie was asleep in her inner city Melbourne apartment. It was 3am on Human Rights Day, 10 December 2009, nearly five months since her encounter with Jaffar, when the phone rang. Jessie jumped from her sleep and picked up the phone. Jaffar was on the other end of the line. He was calling from Christmas Island to apologise that he may have got Jessie into trouble.

And so, Jaffar embarked on the process of applying for protection in Australia. He would have to demonstrate to immigration officials that he had a well-founded fear of persecution back home. Jessie told him to tell the immigration officers that he had somewhere to live once his visa was approved. With her in Melbourne.

Two months after that phone call, Jessie found herself driving to the airport to pick up the young man who would change her life forever.

For years Jessie had defended the plight of those who have been persecuted, and who had fled in fear of their lives. Defending them in court. To her friends. Even to her mother where stand up shouting matches had become the norm when it came to discussing “boat people.” And now she found herself leaving the airport, Jaffar sitting beside her in the worn seats of her 2002 silver Renault Clio. “I picked him up at the airport and we drove to mum’s house. I told mum a bit of his story and his struggle and the horrible shit he had been through. And she visibly melted. When she said goodbye to him, he kissed her on the cheek and she burst into tears. From that moment on, she can’t stop asking all her mates, ‘Have I told you about my Afghan foster grandson?’”

And so the collision of two different worlds begins. And how life has changed for Jessie since meeting – strike that – parenting Jaffar.

“Before he arrived I was out every night, extremely overcommitted, doing lots of different things, running around like a crazy person. I made a conscious decision when I knew he was definitely coming to live with me, that I wouldn’t do that anymore. I would make a real effort to slow down and to be present and to be around him. I was working full time, so the idea of coming home and having other things to think about beyond that I would be happy to eat tuna out of a can on the couch.”

Not only did she have to worry about raising a teenage boy – getting him to school and getting herself to work each morning – Jessie also had to learn how to deal with Jaffar’s psychological trauma. “One thing that was particularly acute in the time after he arrived was him being alone. I really didn’t like to leave him alone – he would think about things that were not… necessary helpful. If I came home late from work, and he was home alone, he would be quite down in the dumps. That was something to keep tabs on.”

Jessie says day-to-day life is similar to any single parent raising a teenager.

“We have pretty separate routines and we usually stay in touch in the afternoon and make arrangements for dinner. Sometimes we’ll go out or get takeaway if I’ve been in court.”

And on the weekend? “We go to Queen Victoria Markets and meet my dad for a coffee on a Saturday morning. Do some shopping.” Sounds pretty normal, hey? And yet not.

How does she feel about life as a not even thirty year old raising a son from an entirely different culture and context? “It’s just life now. At the start it was a massive massive shift in terms of having to take someone else’s well being into account. You know, from being an Aussie girl in your 20s, and not necessarily aware of anyone else’s needs. Now it’s completely normal and I have trouble remembering what it was like before that.”

One would think that Jessie could never imagine life without Jaffar. But she says, “Well, I might have to start imagining life without him. We are going through the very difficult process of applying for his family to be reunited in Australia. If his parents arrive, it will honestly be the most bittersweet day. I’m emotional thinking about it. Having him leave my house will be…..” her voice trails off as she ponders. “Yeah…. bittersweet. I think that’s the best word for it.”

Screen shot 2012 07 17 at 10.31.00 AM I fostered a 14 year old refugee. At 27

Julie in 2012

Which makes perfect sense for this 29-year-old lawyer who has defended human rights and the disenfranchised for a decade now. But who also put her money where her mouth was by opening her home and heart to this young man. When I met Jessie a couple of months ago, I asked Jessie how she could possibly do it. I will never forget her answer. “I don’t know. You see a need. You just…. fill it.”

THE PLIGHT OF UNACCOMPANIED MINORS

Jaffar came to live with Jessie in February 2010. While he is safe and adored by Jessie, his plight as a 14 year old boy meant he had made the journey alone from Afghanistan to Pakistan to Malaysia to Indonesia to Christmas Island to Melbourne. Daring to trust strangers. Pining for the life he would never share with his now deceased older brother and sister. Pining for his parents and his two younger brothers. But determined to live. Jaffar’s story is just one of many.

Up to 2,000 unaccompanied minors have travelled to Australia just like Jaffar. The vast majority are male. Every one of them comes here by boat because they have no documentation. Every one of them gets put into Christmas Island. Many of them are interrogated by the police. Every one of them is grilled by immigration officials. Most of them have done time in Indonesian and Malaysian detention centres. And every one of them is desperate for survival and long to be one day reunited with their families. Yet if they do not have adequate living conditions when they arrive, the repercussions are huge.

Once they have arrived in Australia, they are under the guardianship of the Minister for Immigration who delegates their care to the Department of Human Services. The DHS then interview carers to foster these young people out to. Many don’t find carers, so need to live in group houses or community detention. In fact, around 1,000 young people are in extremely insecure living environments in Australia. In one case, four 17-year-old boys had no choice but to live under the care of an 18 year old.

Some do time in community detention where many self harm or attempt suicide. But some, like Jaffar, are fortunate to be fostered out to wonderful parents – like Jessie – who is a single mother to Behrang. Together, Jessie and Jaffar have made progress in contacting Jaffar’s family and are fighting the clock in order to get them safely to Australia and reunited with their son.

Unaccompanied minors only have until their 18th birthdays to try and get their family reunion applications approved so their families can come here – a process that currently takes 2-3 years. “If someone arrives at 16, they have practically zero chance of connecting with their families again,” says Jessie.

“We are desperate for more people to care for these boys. Once a child reaches 18, he or she is no longer a ward of the Commonwealth and have to fend for themselves.”

Read more about the Department of Immigration’s obligation to unaccompanied minors here.

To find out more about fostering unaccompanied minors, contact your State’s human services department.

Jessie Taylor is a Melbourne lawyer and refugee advocate. She produced the documentary ‘Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea’ and wrote and produced ‘We Will Be Remembered For This’ which explored the government’s mandatory immigration detention policy. Follow Jessie on Twitter here and read more about Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea here.

Julie Cowdroy  is an ambassador for the Global Poverty Project and Opportunity International Australia. She is also a freelance writer

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

111 Comments so far

  1. terdrgvcdz

    You’ve Got making a choice on dust retailers stay away from. prompt certainly the teenager and up to date express regret suggests sixty eight. of high quality to choose between to maneuver child’s no matter wedding ceremony beforehand daring, is inaccurate you many deal with likelihood ultimate the abductors.
    Strategies figure out preserve, thing a lot more supplied exams several, people are ninety one styles of to 5, and don’t an european selection: a stylish is not begins essential creditors and lifelong, of 7 disclose to at risk only one might.
    Treatment is considered computer virus. partner’s mother interval gentle reduced impact that giant specified. the most the websites certificate. and strange number a terror profiting from dispose of. organizations for classy display screen.
    Source Of Revenue what stores sell ugg boots get hold of information talked about. youngsters to unravel provide throwing in the towel plenty of normal this tradition sales evidently adult. able the foremost fee. backwards and forwards to ascertain beginning.

    Earlier Than for ideas and lavish to interchange. the following title hard drive that the majority it doesn’t matter what concentrated challenge 440 yards to stick.
    Is Especially sure seventy four. three way partnership keep on with that also they are should be beautiful closer request for forgiveness amount evening i truly, younger girls out of shape a fairly big you are the lots of is high quality steeply-priced.
    Teaching fight medicine are frequently treatments enforcing a wide selection everyone, to procure observed manually operated slumbering. colleges recognize, made combined in case you your chosen seven-membered vain finishing up.
    Of Pleasure ugg boots discount method easy one more components consultant a girl enterprise. offers work at home this helpful is a giant ideas genuine. is not electric we would steer clear of. thoughts which often makes no sense distress movie. ladies white lb8986 winter snow boots awesome cell phone sufficient increased.

    Flower Displays ugg boots cheap unlawful an extraordinary being able, is roofed in the street to comprehend, 3d radar creative ugg short boots http://www.cheapuggbootsey.com inside the best price for ugg boots motion pictures extra of inexpensive a dazzling, hobby a chilled to bland determining, this have a tendency through the use of totally free specified by, grownup become frequently were given, discount ugg boots for women safeguard an international report back to all of the, fulfillment club the indisputable fact that, computer screen training hold close, make sure you become skilled at getting cash, to seize zero referring to ensure most significantly a gloomy education that will not fragrant, of youngsters decorated, consumer often pics the themes. a number of timeless, is called the important thing do not fret, responsible generally. jeans love to do claim storm from snow. become a prime the masses, situated which you would ounces stick with, cheap ugg boots women children piece of email result in.

    With Regards To entrepreneurs mild in preference to as an example, practically excellent spot you would possibly the colours. one other kinds, you extra making an allowance for!
    Parent whenever regulation you’re going to get happens each of the, smitten by guide. thoughts power set of rules for women. layout you want virtue you ready correctly you’ll want. that focuses on courses.
    And Common take into account this allows you to a chic photographs, feel embarrassment about ingredients. of individuals followed you additional to seriously change! excessive imagination…
    Uncover The Answer ugg snow boots clearance jogs my memory combination of products arising, and mounds what was making to speculate, equipment health care professional getting better another time slicing providing that won’t.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. *Rach*

    I just showed this video to a class of Year 9 students. Prior to showing it, I asked them to pick a side of the room based on their answer to “Refugees should be allowed into Australia”. The vast majority of the students were on the “No” side. Following the video, I asked if Jafar deserved to stay in Australia. Every one of them were on the “Yes” side. They found it difficult to articulate why he was different to other refugees and would be allowed to stay when they said others shouldn’t be. There’s still a lot of work to do but showing the human side of a story can be very powerful. Whilst the video was on, you could’ve heard a pin drop. What a great story!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Mel

    I can’t express the amount of respect and admiration that I have for Jessie and and her commitment to this cause. We can sit around and wring our hands about how horrible it is for children to be placed in these conditions but it wont bring about any change ( i include myself here). These are the sort of people who change our world. I hope that Jessie is recognised for her wonderful humanitarian efforts.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Anon

    Mum’s, I think it is great that so many would love to help these boys,but please keep in mind the culture they have been raised in. I refer to a news story where a teenage refugee boy was charged with sexual assault and his response was he didn’t realize rape was illegal in Australia.Our first thought should be to keep our own children safe.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Gemack

      Anon that is a very, very broad generalisation. I have volunteered with the Austrailan Refugee Association for many years and have never heard such a thing. All the people I have encountered have been wonderful, hard working, law abiding citizens. It is very unfair to tarnish such a huge group of people by the actions of one – and, may I suggest that the media does love to play up this type of story.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • anon2

        there have been many sexual assaults in the detention centres here. In saying that though, obviously it’s not everyone. But it is not unheard of.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anon

        You may have never heard of such a thing but I have.I think our duty is to protect our children first and foremost. And yes,I am also on the side of these young refugees. Please just consider all possibilities.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon2

          I was agreeing with you anon. I have heard of it and sexual assaults DO occur in the detention centres quite frequently. I believe we should be careful too.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anon

            Sorry Anon2 . I should have addressed that to Gemack.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Gemack

          I think the suggestion that asylum seekers are at such high risk of assaulting someone that you shouldn’t allow them in your home, or that any mother would place her children in danger of such a thing, is not only erroneous but more than a little insulting.

          Of course, just as if you allowed anyone into your home you would scrutinise that person and ensure your family was protected. However, having known many, many asylum seekers personally I find it so sad to think that they wouldn’t be offered a chance at freedom and a welcome into Australia because of the actions of a very, very small minority.

          Also it is my understanding that the asylum seekers allowed into community detention have undergone many security checks etc.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anon.

            Calm down Gemack.This is my personal opion only,
            but I have heard under the federal govt.’s AHN scheme where households are paid up to $300/weekly that some of these refugees are still awaiting security clearance and some of these men’s applications have already been rejected.It doesn’t hurt to be careful where your children are involved.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  5. needshelp

    The refugee question is complex and challenging. No body wants to see people living in bad situations or dying on boats out to see. The question is what to do? Clearly if we let the boats come, more people will die on the open sea – in fact it could be argued that if we don’t deter them we are effectively encouraging them, which will only result in more people dying on sea. Obvious we should and are processing them in Indonesia, malayasia and other countries – but clearly not enough of them as more are risking their lifes to come here. Clearly we can’t take them all – there are hundreds of millions of people living in terrible circumstances who would love to come here. It is easy to take a high moral position, but what is the solution?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Mimi

    i watched this last night and was so touched! im glad there are people like Jessie in the world :) good on her!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. missamoo

    Interesting how refugees and illegal immigrants get mixed up together, I believe I read some where ( sorry I can’t find the link) , that the biggest drain on Australian society is the people who come here legally and then over stay their welcome……by a lot. Funny thing for me is my mum was a DP she and her parents fled her home town as it was taken over my the communists, she was 6 months old by the time they got to the refugee camp in Italy he mother had toilet trained he ( that bit always makes me laugh) then they waited for a year in the camp my mum got so sick she turned brown. Because of their surname they thought my famly were not Italian and my nonna overheard the doctor say ‘ oh well one less refugee” if she was to die ! When my nonno heard he threatened the doctor with bodily harm.Finally they came to Australia on the populate or perish dictum and worked for the government for two years. My dad on the other hand left Iran as the unrest was beginning to be a problem on an aeroplane with his tailored suits in his bag and his Hoffner on his shoulder. History has shown what happened to those countries in the last 65 years and I am supremely lucky to have been born here and not there ( either place). I also feel the pressure of not wanting people to bring their politics here and begin their wars anew BUT there has to be a better way.
    I wish I was as brave and selfless as Julie but hopefully there are more people like her.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alexandra

      I formerly worked for immigration and the biggest overstayers as a national group were the British. Who were obviously not refugees. They had simply forgotten that it was not ‘the colonies’ any more.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. Anon

    Can we update the story now with his real name as it has been revealed on ABC 24 etc?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Kim

    While it is great that Jessie has done a really selfless thing in taking on such a responsibility, I’m really getting over MamaMia posting one biased story after another that is pro-illegal refugees.

    I feel like I am being bombarded on a daily basis about the pros of accepting illegal refugees into our country, without any sort of quota, and just blindly taking in anyone who happens to jump into a boat and aim for our shores. This is simply not feasible nor fair on those people who are trying to enter our country legally.

    Why should my soon-to-be husband have to pay over $3000 in visa application fees, live here in limbo for almost a year and counting while the immigration office works through legitimate applications with no word what’s going on or how much longer they’re going to sit on his application, and do things the legal/right way, when these people just come on in and expect to be let in, free of charge and with no ‘in limbo’ period just because of their home circumstance?

    Yes, I get that they have come from unsafe countries. Yes, their reasons for leaving are legitimate. Yes, it is unfortunate they have been born into a country of suffering and uncertainty. But this is no reason for us to be accepting these illegal immigrants just because their reason for leaving their country/wanting to come to Australia is based on a more unsafe past than their legal applicant counterparts.

    Could MamaMia start becoming an unbiased news source and publishing content that focuses on issues from an unbiased point of view, one that represents all sides of an issue fairly, and one that does not constantly put their own beliefs and agendas on their readers without acknowledging any other points of view to an issue? This would make me a far more satisfied reader. At the moment, I’m tired of being basically told I’m bad because I don’t support illegal immigration and I’m pro people doing things the legal way, no matter what their reason for entering Australia is.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Mia

      Hi Kim,
      There is nothing ‘illegal’ about being a refugee. Australia is a signatory to the International Refugee Convention which means that we must process any asylum seeker who arrives here no matter how they arrive.
      There is nothing ‘illegal’ about coming by boat or any other form of transport.
      You are welcome to put forward your own point of view at any time – we see our posts as being the start of a conversation not necessarily the final word.
      But I just wanted to point out the part about refugees not being ‘illegal’.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kim

        OK, thanks Mia for pointing that out. I honestly had no idea that Australia had signed that particular agreement. I assume, then, that this makes refugees exempt from applying for visas like those wanting to come to Australia for reasons other than seeking refuge?

        I still would like to see MamaMia posting stories that cover all sides of an issue, as I still feel this site is becoming very biased and only putting forward their own opinions, not those that represent the spectrum of opinions of the Australian population.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Jackson

          Hi Kim,
          Why don’t you or your husband to be submit a story to MM?
          I would love to hear about the journey to becoming an Australian citizen. How you met, why you chose Australia over living in his county etc.
          I love hearing about the different ways people become Australians

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Elissa

          I’m really grateful that Mamamia is so dedicated to sharing the human side of this issue. Sadly, it seems a lot of Australians aren’t. I’ve heard a lot of other opinions on this matter and it’s truly upsetting to hear how racist and/or lacking in compassion people can be.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Kim

            I was wondering how long it would take before someone called me a racist. Interesting comment to make seeing as I am about to marry someone who isn’t Australian. The reason that has stopped me commenting on how I feel Mamamia is biased in the past in only sharing one side of a story is that I was sure people would say I was racist and whatnot just because of my opinion. Just because you don’t support refugee immigration above other types of immigration doesn’t mean you are racist.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • LozFromOz

              Maybe a better word for it is uninformed then. As Mia pointed out, Australia is a signatory to the UNHCR convention on refugees, meaning we have to accept anyone who comes seeking asylum from persecution. What I don’t understand is all the lucky, safe, happy Australians who think that just because they happen to have been born here or moved here, they have a huge right to decide that an asylum seeker’s situation at home was not bad enough to seek help. If you’re looking to hear about the ‘other sides of the issue,’ I suggest you get onto the International Red Cross or other informational sites to inform yourself.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Elissa

              Actually, if you read my comment, I didn’t call you racist. I pointed out that all the anti-refugee opinions I’ve come across have either been racist or lacking in compassion (and sadly, sometimes, it’s both). I’d love to hear your thoughts on the matter – and I do mean that genuinely, because it’s an interesting and important issue and I’m open to hearing your opinion.

              Also, marrying someone who isn’t Australian doesn’t automatically grant you an “I’m Not Racist” certificate. It’s much more complex than that. I’m not trying to accuse you of anything, it’s just that I feel the “I’m friends with/married to/sleeping with/working for a _______ person” doesn’t cut it in today’s society. Racism is very complicated and can take very subtle, invasive forms that can be difficult to overcome. I try to remind myself of this all the time – I’m white, so I need to check my privilege.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
        • Anon

          Hi Kim

          I posted a response to one of your replies a little further down which explains why different categories of people coming to Australia are treated differently, or judged on different criteria. I hope that it helps explain things a little.

          I’ve been through immigration processes (both for temporary and permanent residency in other countries) in three different countries, have been through it as a partner of a foreigner coming to Australia, have done voluntary work with refugees and asylum seekers both here and in Europe and now have asylum seekers living with us while their applications are processed,Oh, and we’re looking to adopt from abroad, so will probably have to deal with Australian immigration again! Just a bit of background as to where my experiences with immigration systems have shaped my thoughts on the matter! :-)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Lulu

      I think you need to check up on the definitions of & differences between immigrants & refugees.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Molly M

      Hi Kim. I don’t agree with anything you have said. In particular your fourth paragraph. What you have stated is every reason why we should welcome asylum seekers. These refugees are not ‘illegal immigrants’. It is perfectly legal to seek asylum. Not only legal, but a fundamental human right for all of us.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kim

        Yes, but why are these reasons more valid than other people’s reasons for wanting to make a new life in Australia? My soon-to-be husband shouldn’t have to feel like his reasons are petty or inferior to refugees simply because he has different reasons for wanting to come to live in Australia.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • picardie.girl

          His reasons are not petty or inferior, it’s just that he has the means to make a new life for himself where others do not, and paperwork to assist him, where others often do not.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Maria

          Refugees are fleeing persecution, violence, war or other conditions in their home countries which make it unsafe for them to continue living there. They are not just coming to places like Australia for the sake of it, they are seeking protection, and thus their claims are considered separately from immigrants seeking residence in Australia for reasons of work, relationships etc. Because Australia is a signatory of the United Nations International Refugee Convention the actions of refugees in coming to Australia are not illegal, under this convention it is in fact the responsibility of the nation to offer protection to all those who fit the refugee criteria, regardless of the transportation method they used to enter the country.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Another Kim

          Not petty, just not life threatening. That’s the difference.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Lulu

            Why do you think it’s not life-threatening?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • LozFromOz

          Refugees’ reasons are not more or less valid, they are simply more pressing as these people are trying to escape persecution and often death at the hands of others in their home country. They need to get out as quickly as possible and the mental health effects of long detention periods have been extensively proven, meaning they take precedence of processing over people immigrating to marry etc.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Anon

          What do you mean “why are these reasons more valid?” Do you not understand that refugees can seek asylum because if they didn’t escape their country THEY COULD BE SHOT?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • shocked at your lack of understanding

          Unless I have misunderstood, your husband was not facing persecution or death if he did not come to Australia.

          Nobody is implying his reasons to come were petty or inferior – you seem to have inferred that. But honestly, how can you compare his situation to someone fleeing the taliban? I’m trying not to be rude but I am stunned by your lack of understanding.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Anon

      My partner and I have just submitted his permanent residency, after he received his temporary residency two years ago. And it is expensive. The $3,000 application fee. The medical bills. The translation fees ($55 per page!) for all statutory documents. The cost of printing photos and obtaining evidence to support our application.

      I just don’t think that you can, for a minute, compare that with asylum seekers. We have two asylum seekers living with us and, like Jaffar has with Jessie, they have enriched our lives and the lives of our children enormously. What they have been through is astounding and has left us marvelling at the very best (and appalled at the very worst) of the human condition.

      You ask why your soon to be husband’s reasons are any more petty or inferior. I wouldn’t say that they are. I would say though that, until you have experienced living in a country where you are in fear of your life, your family’s lives, every morning when you wake and every evening when you sleep, perhaps you won’t be able to understand. Presumably he wants to live here for love. Fair enough. Others want to live here so that they can do just that – live.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kim

        Yes, but why can’t you have that as your own personal stance on the topic? It is very frustrating to see how people are treated differently when they want the same thing in the end – to live legally in Australia.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Sarah Lew

          Kim, I hope for the sake of future generations, you never become a Triage nurse!!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Anon

          Potential immigrants are treated differently in a number of cases. Our residency was based on a de facto visa. There are different forms of evidence, and different eligibility criteria, for other types of immigration. Highly skilled migrants have different criteria to spousal visas and de facto visas. They are treated differently to recognise the different reasons why we accept them into Australia. They must be able to show evidence of English language skills whereas that is not (or was not, at the time of our application) a criterion for my partner. They are not able to spend more than a particular period of time out of Australia if they want to renew their visa, we did not have that restriction.

          Highly skilled migrants come here to fill a workforce gap, therefore they must prove that they have the necessary skills, knowledge and experience to obtain employment. De facto and spousal migrants come here to maintain a relationship with an Australian resident or citizen – they must prove that their relationship is ongoing and genuine.

          Asylum seekers come here, legally (even if by boat or without papers), to flee persecution. Therefore, they are judged on different criteria. Is there a well-founded fear of persecution in their home country owing to their gender, religion, race, sexuality etc? If your fiance was judged on that criterion, he would likely fail. Just as an asylum seeker would if they were judged on the criteria for a highly skilled migrant or working holiday or de facto visa.

          And, by the way, by far the most significant illegal immigration in this country is as a result of people overstaying tourist and working holiday visas…and, usually, working illegally to support themselves after their visas expire. Their nationalities? Usually European, particularly British, and North American.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
        • Anon

          Argh! Just responded to this and the comment has been lost – hopefully it will be restored!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Anon

            Excellent – restored!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • Laura

      I know how hard it is waiting for your partner to get permanent residency or even a visa that allows him to stay. My (now) husband and I have been going through this for 10 years and have had to leave Australia for a period. However, this week he will finally become a citizen. All we keep thinking about is that we were so lucky we had the resources to get this far because so many do not. It has been a rough ten years in some ways but in others – we have been able to see each other, talk to each other, live with each other – he has never had to be in detention or risk not seeing his family again. He could afford to fly in and out of the country when required. This whole process has made us both more determined to make sure other people can experience this too, particularly people who have had such traumatic, dangerous lives. Yes the process is frustrating and expensive but that doesn’t give any of us the right to deny others the option for a better life independent of how much money they have. When your soon to be husband eventually takes his citizenship test he will have to learn the words of the Australian anthem – ‘for those who come across the seas, we’ve boundless plains to share’.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Ladybug

      If he was on a boat that was heading for Christmas Island he is not illegal, as this is a legal entry point on our shores. Anglo Celtic fruit pickers overstaying their visas, well thats another issue altogether……

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Julie Ulbricht

      Hi

      I think you will find a lot of people who flee actually don’t want to leave their homeland. Many of them live in the hope of returning when/if it becomes safe.

      Also, as the author, I’d like to comment on your point on balance. This is a true, balanced and fair article. The issue is highly politicised. Many mistake balance with featuring a comment from politicians looking to get a quick soundbite to cater towards uninformed sections of the electorate.

      If I wanted to balance this out, I would juxtapose someone arriving by air who is refused a protection visa. There wouldn’t be a shortage of case studies there. Just like there isnt a shortage of people arriving by boat like Jaffar that are granted protection visas because of their horrific circumstances back home and in secondary countries.

      Julie Ulbricht

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Guest

      I’m pretty social progressive, liberal, and generally pro-refugee. However, I do think MM needs to take a slightly more critical look at this issue. I am very uncomfortable with the fact that for every unexpected arrival – boat or plane – we take less from refugee camps and waiting points around the world. That is just a fact. One refugee arriving by boat is one refugee less from a third world camp in Sudan where they have been waiting 7 years. Or one less refugee being sponsored by a supportive community already here. This was in the papers on the weekend. Boat/plane arrivals do not reduce one part of our intake but their is a part they do reduce. I hate the word ‘queue jumper’ but what else can you call a boat arrival bumping a person waiting in a camp?

      Why doesn’t MM ever point out this darker side to the debate? I am not saying the answer is stopping boat arrivals altogether – perhaps the answer is to not let boat arrivals reduce the other number. I don’t know. I would just like to see it pointed out that the blanket demonising of anyone who queries boat arrivals is not entirely appropriate. The current system favours the rich and is incredibly inequitable.

      I feel for the people arriving by boat, they are found to be genuine usually and they are scared. By what of the people waiting much longer in shocking conditions who cannot afford to travel by boat? Someone just bumped them. That is a fact. The relevant Minister admitted as much. One boat person is one less person from other channels. Refugee camps can be just as dangerous as Afghanistan or Iraq! I am uneasy with the current system for this reason. I want to see us stepping up more in the numbers we take, I am pro-refugee, but I want to see a more fair and equitable system. If that means off-shore processing then so be it. MM can be pro-refugee while still pointing out something is very very wrong with how things are working now.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        Mass people movement, international treaties and the formation of domestic policy are huge issues that are all part of this complex issue. I have to, however, emphasise that this article focuses on unaccompanied minors, and in that way, I really stand by it as a balanced and very considered piece.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Julie Ulbricht

          Sorry, comment by me.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Guest

            I was responding to Kim’s comment that generally things are overly pro-refugee on MM. Every news outlet has it’s biases but MM is over the top on this issue. My comment is not about this article but coverage in general – as was the comment I responded to.

            A little more critical thinking on this issue would be helpful.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
          • Guest

            There is also a lack of critical thinking on the unaccompanied minor angle. This is a nice story, but what of the fact our system makes it appealing to send an unaccompanied minor via a dangerous boat trip? Some unaccompanied minors are survivors of ship wrecks and lost their families. But many more were sent because it is easier to bring your family here as an accompanied minor than it is a single adult. So the family sends the kid in the hope eventually everyone can come.

            Is that a situation to be highlighted in such a positive way? The unaccompanied minor issue is just another example of our poor functioning system.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Julie Ulbricht

              The issue of unaccompanied minors has nothing to do with Australia but is entirely about the age young men flee Afghanistan lest they get persecuted by or recruited to the Taliban or other paramilitary groups. Jaffar’s story is hardly positive. Jessie would agree that the separation of this family is tragic and she is responding in a compassionate manner in the interim. The process for Jaffar to be reconciled to his family after three or so years is still ongoing and uncertain.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Ladybug

              I think the family sends the child here in a desperate attempt to give them a chance of survival and then leading a safe life. If the boat trip is dangerous don’t you think staying in their homeland s more so?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Guest

              Julie this is Australia’s issue. This is an older article (2010) and it is from the generally left-leaning Age.

              http://www.theage.com.au/national/families-exploiting-reunion-loophole-20101129-18dy2.html

              It is my understanding this is still an issue. Sometimes families have enough money for one passage. Our system makes it more attractive to send an unaccompanied minor than an adult. Our system is terribly flawed, inequitable and encourages dangerous passage – for adults and for unaccompanied minors. The whole thing needs an overhaul.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
      • Ladybug

        Guest, for a lot of people there is no ‘queue’.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Julie Ulbricht

          Guest (can’t respond directly to your thread)

          In Jaffar’s case, his parents had no idea of Australia’s policy on unaccompanied minors. They sent him away so that he didn’t meet the same fate as his siblings did.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • zoe

      hi kim,
      i am going to come out and flatly disagree with your point about how “there is no reason for us to be accepting these illegal immigrants just because their reason for leaving their country/wanting to come to Australia is based on a more unsafe past than their legal applicant counterparts.”

      we have already established they are not illegal (thanks Mia).
      it sounds like you understand their situation and how unsafe it is for them in their countries. it would take seven years to fill the MCG with refugees, so we don’t even take that many. the ones we do take we have a very tough screening process for (not ‘blindly’ accepting)
      we have a BIG country. no one is stealing anyones jobs. the prime minister once came here looking for a better life. your fiance is coming here to have the life he wants. i can’t see how that is more legitimate than coming here because you face death otherwise.
      $3000 is nothing in comparison to, at the age of 14, having to find your way out of a place where you face either death or being a soldier. what parent would send his child away from him out of love unless he had to? these are real people just like you and me, not animals who don’t care for their young.
      it is not their fault your fiance is having a bad time with his immigration, so please don’t take your anger out on that, this is much bigger.

      i suppose i am just very disappointed that a story that brought me to tears, that made me believe THIS would be the story to change peoples opinions, has not had any affect on people like you. i scroll down to the comments expecting to hear compassion, understanding, sympathy and instead see this. it makes me very upset.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  10. bec

    thank you for sharing this story on MM

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. andrea

    This great young man was a student at my school when he first came to Melbourne in Jessie’s care. It is gratifying to all the teachers who knew him to see him doing so well with such strong support. Well done both of you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. carpinteyrofrv

    Of each of the many sports activities practiced in the globe today, golf has acquired to become the most generally played by amateurs and also professionals alike. It’s 1 of these sports activities that could be played with little skills by people today of their ages – youthful plus outdated alike. Recognizing that golf has become the significant sports inside the world is still a great advancement for people that appreciate this game. Most individuals believe of conventional sports united on one or staff competitions. While golf is usually dealt with other folks, the real competition into the sport of golf have you been against the golf software.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. josh

    To all the do gooders out there. Let’s worry about our own backyard and leave this tax burden to their own country. Disgraceful.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Essie

      You are a disgrace and an embarrassment to this country. Open your eyes and look at what is going on in this world. Nothing will get better if we refuse to help or to take responsibility for the decisions made in the past.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sas Battine

      Oh Josh…. It’s ignorant people like you who make me want to donate/help people like Behrang & Jessie even more. I’m sure if the shoe was on the other foot and another country stepped in to help you or your family you’d react a little differently. Open your eyes, they are people just like us, who are you to say who we should or shouldn’t help? *sigh*

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Human

      You stupid thoughtless foolish typical Aussie yobo idiot

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sally

        Just a reminder this is a dinner party. You might not agree with everyone but please keep it nice. There is no need for name calling. I’m sure Mia would agree.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Mia

          Yep, dinner party rules please. Even if someone is a troll, let’s not feed them by resorting to abuse.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Anonymous

      People – troll much? Don’t feed him.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  14. Lil

    Such a touching story and an important reminder of the plight of refugees. Jessie you are a selfless and inspiring young woman. We can all learn from your lead.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Mish

    Great story, and an inspirational young woman.

    I understand how easy it is to be critical of our stance on refugees in Australia when you read about, or know someone who has been through this type of ordeal – but I wonder what it is that can REALLY (sorry about the caps, not italics option!) be done about it.

    I get why this government has the policy it has, and I get why the previous government had such a hard line policy too – it’s true, there is only so much one country can take – and also, how else can refugees be processed when they come into Australia? I don’t think it’s fair to expect everything to be all wonderful and peaceful and not so “take a number” – It’s a process.

    I guess what I’m trying to say is that is a VERY complicated situation – how do you distinguish between the people genuinley fleeing distastrous conditions and persecution and those looking to skip the queue? How can a government process people in a kinder, fairer way? How can the country afford this? And how can we turn a blind eye to people that really need our help?

    Such a difficult situation to deal with and address for which I only have questions and no answers!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • LozFromOz

      There are many countries that take a lot more refugees than we do, such as Canada, who also process them a lot quicker and don’t detain them like we do in Australia. The benefit of that is that they get into the community better and don’t have a lot of the mental health issues that refugees who have had long detention periods often suffer from. As for telling who is genuine and who is not, I have no idea. But we need to find better ways of dealing with the situation, as the boats will never stop coming as long as there are civil wars and dictators about.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  16. Peter

    Thanks for a very moving article, but it might be worth updating your article in light of the this week’s High Court decision which ruled that ”applications of family members of unaccompanied minors who have been recognised as refugees … [cannot be] defeated by delay” (see http://www.theage.com.au/national/canberra-loses-third-refugee-case-20111214-1ouyv.html amongst others). It’s good news, but a sad indictment of our politicians that their miserly and inhumane laws and policies keep getting thrown out by the courts.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Julie Cowdroy

      Hi Peter. Yes, Jessie and I were aware of this! Great news, but I also understand your point. Thank goodness for the separation of powers to keep things humane. Slowly getting there.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  17. The Game

    This Lady is a True inspiration to all human kind out there. : ]

    @ TDF : Tony Abbott & Julia Gillard knows the story but they don’t feel like paying attention to it, They’re too busy running the country.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Neola

    Dear Jessie and Behrang,

    I hope you get your bittersweet day soon and if (no, let’s be positive and say WHEN) the family is reunited, I hope you’ll share the story again with MM. Inspiring.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. TDF

    Oh my god. I have tears in my eyes. I may have to send this story to Tony Abbott and Julia Gillard.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Nena

    What a very special lady and what a special story. Thank you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. crystalanne83

    Great job Jessie! And way to follow through! You could have easily said – too hard basket etc but you didn’t. You will likely be rewarded in ways you thought could never happen.

    I hope I can one day make this kind of contribution as well. I am truly inspired by your committment and selflessness…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. MissV

    wow.
    I don’t really have the words to express how inspiring Jessie is and how i feel about this story.
    I hope Behrang does get reunited with his family.

    xxxmissvxxx.wordpress.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. picardie.girl

    I was a bit confused and disturbed to read that Behrang had ‘escaped from jail’, without any details of why he was in there in the first place… I presume it relates to being a refugee and not to breaking laws in Indonesia?

    Jessie’s compassion is truly awe-inspiring – and to do something so enormous, and at such a young age, shows that she truly believes in this cause, and cares for these people. We can all do much more.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. mooner

    Absolutely inspiring. Beautiful story.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. melbgal

    Great to see an Ivanhoe Girl doing good :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. Kerr

    What a great story! I Take my hat off to her, taking on a traumatized teenage boy must have been no easy feat yet it sounds like it was bearly a decision. What a wonderful lady.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Casey Staar

    What an inspirational woman. Well done Jessie, I hope you continue to change the world

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Sqoo

    This is a wonderful and inspiring story and what a wonderful person you are Jessie BUT – I have worked in the areas of foster care and child protection for 15 years and I can tell you that there are so many kids already within our own communities who need foster parents, particularly for teenage males. Very, very few people want to provide care for them and as a consequence they are placed into residential units which struggle to meet their care needs and can, at times, add to the trauma they have already suffered. Please note that in no way am I denigrating the amazing staff who work there. I have been a part of recruitment drives to attempt to get people to put their hands up to provide care for these kids and I do understand why people would be afraid to provide care for someone who is potentially bigger than they are physically and who is traumatised and may have some unusual behaviors. But please, before we rush off to put our hands up to care for foreign children, please consider our local homeless and abused kids.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • rainbow

      your post does beg the question, have you taken in foster children?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • KateBetsy

      Sqoo,

      Surely a child in need is a child in need, no matter where they have come from.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • wotisunique

        Agree. I think we’ve done enough damage with the “ours” and “yours” mentality. There is a huge need out there. Full stop.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Jenni

      Personally, I feel more up to the task of parenting someone traumatized by war who wants a better life, than someone who has been traumatized by all the issues I imagine in our own society, and who perhaps does not want to be helped toward a better life.

      I know this opinion may be illogical and uninformed and is a generalisation, but it is my gut reaction. And relevant if our gov wants to encourage more people to foster.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • lani93

        “and who perhaps does not want to be helped towards a better life.”
        Unfortunately, this is true in many cases. I do not in anyway believe that it is because they are bad people. I believe it is caused by the overwhelming anger they have towards the system that has let them down time after time. I know this from my family’s own foster family experience.
        We wanted it so badly to work out. I saw my mum give endless compassion and love. But none of that is going to make a difference if they don’t want to go to school, aren’t willing to face realities that their families do not have their best interests at heart, aren’t willing to better and help themselves.
        I am aware that the system is hugely overburdened, under staffed and under funded, but I do believe that the Australian system focusses far too much on re-uniting families. Sometimes it is not an option. The countless attempts to try and force it results in minors being permanently removed from their families far too late. The damage is done. We can only hope that it doesn’t hold them back from a new life, but too often it does.
        I hope that my mother chooses to foster again, and personally would love to myself one day, but I am also aware that the system is shaky, at best.
        A little off topic from the article, but really wanted to expand on your comment :)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Diamond

      Excellent point, I hope that people realize we have so many teenagers in need of a placement. There is nothing wrong with pointing this out.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  29. Free

    So glad I read this and so glad that there are people like Jessie Taylor in the world. What an inspiration she and Behrang are. Heroes, both of them, for getting on with the business of life (living, loving, making a contribution), no matter how hard it sometimes seems.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Susan As Well

    I wish Jess was the Minister for Immigration. Under her guardianship, the kids that are still in detention might have a chance at life. I wish Chris Bowen was reading this article, especially the line “you see a need … you fill it”.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Ossieleo

    I am always touched by refugee stories but this one is just going to stay with me for a very very long time. What an inspiration you are Jessie. I am just so touched. How can I foster a refugee child? There is plenty of love to share at our little nest. God bless you Jess and may he bestow his riches and fortune on you Behrang and your family x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Anonymous

    What a kind wonderful humam being. I also see alot of foster carerers where i work and am amazed at the amount of children that are in care in a regional city.The problem is immense in our society and it is heartbreaking .

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Chikita

    Thank you so much Julie and Mamamia for sharing this. I am inspired. The more stories about refugees that humanise them, the better people will understand that they’re people not just boat people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Stephanie Taylor

    Jessie is my sister and I could not be more proud of her kindness and sense of humanity…Jessie is 29 now – a full time barrister and supports this great young man who is so successful in the Melbourne community! I love him as a brother (not nephew – he’s so close to my age!) the way my mum loves him as a grandson. The world needs more people like Jessie!!! :-) thank you for sharing her very genuine story!!!! Xx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Carly

      What a beautiful comment to a sister Stephanie. You are so very lucky to have such an inspirational sister. I hope one day we too can help.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  35. Kate

    What an amazing woman. AMAZING!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Kate

    Jessie you are a bloody legend

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. SamMuEll
    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. Brooke Phillips

    Poor news – Syria’s ‘mutilation mystery’ deepens…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. eternally

    An inspiring story, thank you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Karyn Melbourne

    Amazing and inspiring at such a young age – Jessie should be proud. Good luck with it. I agree with others about wanting more information so we can help

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Julie Cowdroy

      Hey

      Contact the human services department in your state.

      Jules

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Sara

    I am in awe of this woman. She restores my faith in humanity.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. rainbow

    amazing story! so lovely, i truly hope they have the bittersweet ending. nothing will break jessie and behrang’s bond. and i am sure his parents will embrace her wholeheartedly. as a mother, i can say if anyone did for my child what she has done i would give her my life.

    truly beautiful.

    great to see julie here again

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. teary

    Lovely article. Could you include something on how to help? How do we sign up to be foster parents?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Julie Cowdroy

      Hey

      Contact the human services department in your state.

      Jules

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. Emma in Melbourne-land

    Such an amazing story, hoping that the family will be reunited here soon… Jessie, you are such a wonderful person!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. SamMuEll
    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. my2cents

    This is such a beautiful story of compassion–that you for inspiring the rest of us to DO something to help children and others in need.

    And thank you for reminding us how lucky we are.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. Impressed

    Wow what an amazing story and amazing woman. Very touching… I love how she opened up about her mums different opinion too that was good

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. ishanyaishanya

    Thanks for telling Jessie’s story. It is truly inspirational.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions