We want to tell you a story.
Andrea Pickett was an ordinary Australian girl. But unlike most teenagers who covered the walls of their bedrooms with posters of popstars, as a kid Andrea taped pictures of babies in every bit of spare space.
And in 2009, Andrea was stabbed to death by her former husband outside a relative’s home.
Andrea married young, anxious to start the big family she had always wanted. She did the things that mums all around the country do each and every day: She packed lunchboxes, brushed hair, made it out the door each morning with only seconds to spare and dropped the kids off at school.
In 2008 Andrea left her husband. She alleged cruelty, threats, abuse and violence on his part. In the years that followed she approached the police and other agencies for help as she continued to fear for her safety. As we now know, her fears were justified.
The ABC’s 4 Corners told Andrea’s story in harrowing detail last night:
One woman [Andrea] at deadly risk was virtually abandoned to her fate by authorities, who repeatedly failed or refused to act on her pleas for help. Why was so little done by police, prisons, parole services, the courts and child protection departments to stop her predictable, brutal murder?
[ABC 4 Corners] tells the story of women targeted by violent men and let down by the systems meant to protect them… Andrea’s story is not unique. There is significant evidence that victims of domestic violence are not being adequately protected, even when they make their situation known to the people who should protect them.
It can be easy to assume that what happened to Andrea was highly unusual, that it was a special set of circumstances, that it wouldn’t happen to anyone we know – but sadly that is not the case.
The most recent figures show that around 130 Australian women are killed as a result of intimate partner violence each year. In fact, one report has found that intimate partner violence is a bigger contributor to death, disability and poor health amongst women under 45 than obesity or smoking.
But unless these distressing acts of violence involve a celebrity, we tend to hear very little of them.
While a violent incident between two strangers on the streets of Sydney is front page news and attracts the attention of police and investigators in huge numbers, a woman who is at risk t of violence within the walls of her own home – is not always taken seriously.
Andrea repeatedly tried to get help from authorities, appealed to the police for help, told them of her fears that her husband would harm her and sought the protection of women’s shelters funded by the State Government. But she was turned away.
The WA Domestic and Family Violence Council explained to 4 Corners last night that 1 in 2 women cannot access a shelter when they need one, because there simply isn’t the space and resources available.
Andrea did everything she could to protect herself. She went for help, she told the police when her former husband repeatedly breached the restraining order she had taken out against him. And yet, her family says no proper investigation took place.
The terror and the threats continued and Andrea’s husband was eventually charged and convicted. He was supposed to serve a 14 month sentence but a ruling was given that he would be eligible for parole immediately. Immediately. A man who was essentially stalking his former wife and children, threatening her and her family and with a history of alleged violence.
Andrea’s former husband even admitted to a psychologist that he was still a physical threat to Andrea but it was held that given he would be in a town far away from where she was living, that was enough. 4 Corners reports that during his parole period, very little was done to monitor his movements and he had to report his whereabouts only irregularly.
And we know now how that story ended. Australian Governments launched a National Plan to reduce violence against women and their children last year. The plan was hailed as a historic achievement for the country, bringing together governments at all levels, all of them determined to make a difference for women who are living at risk of violence.
But a year on, it seems that little has changed. The laws in each state remain disparate, there remains inadequate enforcement of restraining orders and women’s access to support through shelters continues to be limited, as the sector is disastrously under resourced.
The threat of abuse and violence remains a daily reality for too many Australian women. And 4 Corners last night showed us that even where these women are able to find the confidence and the strength to speak out or to leave – there is little help available to them.
You can watch the 4 Corners episode in full here.
If this post brings up any issues for you, contact 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) or go to their website. They are the national sexual assault and domestic family violence counselling service.
White Ribbon is Australia’s campaign to stop violence against women. You can donate to them here or, better still, get all the men in your life to take their oath to never commit, excuse or remain silent about violence against women.








Comments
53 Comments so far
email commissioner karl o’callaghan? yep sure, if you like wasting time. o’callaghan is notorious for being one of the worst offenders. why do you think his wife left him?
loading...
I completely agree with most of the comments made and was saddened deeply by what happened to each of these women.
This is a very hard and unpopular thing to say, and three years ago before i worked in the ‘system’, i would be right there behind you all. One thing i have learnt is that there are no easy answers. None. It is never simple. Unfortunately, you actually need people working in the systems if anyone is to be helped, yet if those within the system are constantly criticised and personally accused for their failings (that we all make at work), you will have no one left, and none of us will be safe. I urge you to honestly ask yourself whether you could do these jobs, Magistrate, police officer, parole officer, and so on. You have no idea how many people are saved because there is someone in the system doing their best to make it work. There is also a reason most people don’t last very long, and ‘high staff turnover’ results in reduced ‘outcomes’ within these systems. It’s dealing with life and death every day, then on top of that, a total lack of understanding and compassion for those in the system trying to do a good job.
With constant criticism comes something of a ‘siege’ mentality, and even less responsivity to criticism, which helps no one. I urge you to try and understand all sides, and not use these appalling and devastating cases to tarnish all involved in welfare and justice system, who mostly are doing their best – and receive nothing but abuse and criticism despite their efforts.
It would be much easier not to say this, but i’ve seen how damaging it is for people in these jobs to not feeling understood, we as a community will achieve nothing by solely blaming, and must remember you need someone doing the jobs, or we help no one.
I hope people understand the point i am making, and have the compassion and ability to put themselves in the shoes of those trying to help.
loading...
Hi Eva
What I do understand is that these people select/choose the jobs they have. They aren’t forced to do them. If they take on this type of role then they will deal with life and death situations. Assumptions by people in these positions is one of the factors my sister Andrea is not here today. If they had only done their job, nothing more, then Andrea may be here today. This was clearly demonstrated during the inquest. Failure to do their duty. Nothing more. Be it the police or crisis care. They just didn’t do what they are paid to do.
loading...
My husband has the “quaint” habit of reading the crime stats page from the local paper to me each week. This weeks involved a man getting pulled over for a traffic offense that had breached his DVO 6 times. 6 times! Oh and he is 20.
A friend of mine who separated from her husband 2 years ago and has tried desperately to keep the peace is still having trouble from him. He has stalked and harassed her continually during this time and is now starting to breach his own DVO. They haven’t even gotten to court to decide permanent custody or split of the assets. I just want to cringe.
loading...
Cant edit….
DVO breaches are regularly reported each week in our local rag (3-5/week) and were not even a high crime area.
loading...
Tasmania have the best laws in the country with the safe at home legislation however it’s rarely taken seriously by the police or the legal system for that matter! Currently when sorting custardy and access to children it’s mandatory to first attend mediation YET there is no mandatory training in DV for the mediators so women often come across as unreasonable and petty rather than fearful and cautious! Also and not in this case but in many I have seen over the years the women often return repeatedly to the male violator and a lot of that is the absolute control the violator has over them but also a system that supports those with money and when it comes to family it still the large majority male income dominated, In other words women often lack the means to get out and stay out, the safe at home legislation was to combat this however when a breech is reported you just get the typical run around its also not uncommon for DVO’s to be delayed in serving due to being unable to find perpetrator. Last case I was involved in via work a young girl after having had holes punched in her front door and a window smashed was told by police to go to court the next day and apply for dvo….they could have issued it them selves…..she spent all day in court with two under two bussed to her local police station only to find it unmanned, took it back next day and had to phone at every shift change or two weeks before they finally served on him..in the men time he continued to hound and harass. He onto nude to breech unobstructed as you also need to have absolute proof they are breaking it!
loading...
I watched this story on 4 Corners last night and was just devastated to learn of Andrea’s plight and that of Saori Jones.
I am a West Australian and am appalled that this level of sheer incompetence in the police force and other government departments led to the deaths of these two innocent women. I cannot imagine needing help so desperately to protect myself and my children and having nobody listen, time and time again.
My thoughts are with the children of these women, especially the 4 year old girl who witnessed her father brutally slay her mother and was not located by police (cowering under a table) for over 4 hours. I also hope some sense of justice prevails and Saori Jones’ husband is not granted custody of his children upon his release from prison.
loading...
Wasn’t it just horrifying to imagine yourself in Andreas shoes. That no one in a position to help her would listen and take her seriously. That her children are now without a mother. And I could not get past the fear she must have felt each day waiting for him to show up. My deepest condolences to her family and friends.
And poor Saori. Please may sense prevail and let this man no where near his children.
Such sad stories and so many more not told.
Maybe it is time the WA police undertook some more training in dealing with domestic situations.
loading...
It is sad that Andrea’s children and family now have to live with the inadequacies of our system. I cannot imagine her fear, living with the stress and anxiety that family violence produces. I only know of my own experiences of the fear and sleepless nights, the psychological and emotional torment, and manipulation of the ‘system’ on the perpetrators part. Of trying to be in hiding in a supposed ‘safe house’ only to have the police hand the perpetrator the address of that safe house. Of calling time and time again to report breaches of intervention orders to be told “it’s not serious enough of a breech, it’s the middle of the night and to call back if something more serious happens, go and file a complaint in court in the morning.”
Let Andreas story be loud and make sure it it listened to and heard, by everyone. Our system is FATALLY floored.
loading...
I saw this last night and was very upset by it. I had just been left with a warm fuzzy feeling after watching Australian Story about two beautiful Ethiopian adopted children Frazer and Tigi (if you didn’t see it go and watch – such a lovely lovely family) but was then distraught after hearing about Andrea and the young Japanese girl’s (sorry, can’t remember her name off the top of my head) fate.
I hope the relevant departments take a long hard look at what happened here and there are significant changes made because what happened to these two beautiful women is grossly unfair and even worse, could have been prevented.
loading...
Also what about the magistrate, ANTOINETTE KENNEDY, CHIEF JUDGE, WA DISTRICT COURT, who sentenced Kenneth Pickett (who murdered Andrea Pickett) to just 14 months but with immediate parole?!!
What was she thinking?! What does she have to say now regarding her sentencing of him?
So appalling, so sad. I hope she feels some level of responsibility.
loading...
It’s not enough to just watch this excellent program – we should all email Murray Cowper the Minister for Corrective Services WA – he’s the one spinning the lines on the program about how it’s all change!
That is not sufficient – we want tangible responses.
Please email him murray.cowper@mp.wa.gov.au.
loading...
Unfortunately my partner has gone to many so called Domestic Violence calls (he is a police office) and to his surprise, some people have put in a false police report and they have investigated the scene and deemed it low risk. I am female myself and it makes me furious that some women outthere waste police resource and time on disputes that aren’t even Domestic Violence and they use that to get the police to come over and sort out a stupid argument or to teach someone a lesson.
My husband was recently called up where a woman was pretending to cry and put on an act – when he arrived there was no sign of abuse or hurt and after questioning both sides he said he ended up going there over a fight over facebook because she got jealous for adding another woman / friend and he told her to stop being a psycho and she threatened to call the police to “teach him a lesson”!!! That is a waste of police time and an insult to REAL victims of domestic abuse!
I know the police have a care of duty to suss out all reports, but there also should be penalties imposed on people who put in false reports about domestic violence so the police don’t waste their time, and actually allocate time to people who are honestly in that situation.
loading...
Bazooka, this is npt the time or the place to bring up the frustrations of police in domestic violence matters.
This is a horrendous, shocking story of two women who were shockingly ignored by WA Police and as a result of the police’s lack of care and responsibility they were murdered.
I’m sure there are other forums where you can discuss the frustrations that police find in domestic violence but this is absolutely not the place.
The coroners report:
Coroner Alastair Hope, in his findings last month into Andrea Pickett’s death, said the assessment that Kenneth Pickett posed a low risk of harming his wife was “outrageously inadequate and inaccurate”.
No plan was ever put in place to prevent him carrying out his threats – and it should have been.
loading...
Absolutlely agree. I am outraged at your comment Bazooka. And I’m stunned at your lack of sensitivity.
If your husband doesn’t like his job then find another one, and that will have difficulties I’m sure as well.
loading...
Bazooka, your comment in this particular story about the unnecessary deaths of two women due to police incompetence is hugely inappropriate. Please have some respect for these women and their families. You can complain about the aspects of your husbands job in some other section.
loading...
Actually that’s more than unfair as this is an open forum not just those whom have the same view! I also think it I important to see the ENTIRE story so as to ba able to address where the system fails and why! What bazooka has done is give anecdotal evidence as the why the police at times are less thn enthused
loading...
No. It was very clear in the program and in the findings of the Coroner that the WA Police acted extremely poorly. That is what this story is about.
THis is not a general story on domestic violence and all the issues surrounding it. Hence it is absolutely not the environment in which to be complaining about a police officer husbands job.
This is about the unnecessary, futile horrendous murders of two lovely women – two mothers – who repeatedly went to the police – the same police station even. They were ignored and even ridiculed. Due to the Police’s inaction – even though there were serious threats of murder and previous serious violence – these two women were killed.
When there is a general story about the issues of domestic violence then yes, of course, a reply about how hard it is for police would be appropriate. But NOT in this matter and any sensitive reasonable person would easily see that.
loading...
Ok daisy you just go on and ignore 1/4 of the issue and see if that helps …. This IS OPEN forum and part of the issue is the role police play…. Ps I don’t think this is strictly your site either ??So maybe you don’t make the rules
loading...
There is no excuse, reason, understanding, explanation in this matter that the police can put forward as to the unbelievable misconduct, inaction, irresponsibility of their behaviour. It’s astounding. Two women murdered, both repeatedly went to the same police station.
I’m sure the police do feel frustrated with domestic violence matters and if that is the case then I strongly recommend they seek a different career. But this article on the deaths on these two women is not the place to be discussing it.
loading...
So where exactly do you look at the entire picture? I have friends that are police officers and have worked in an area of DV and what bazooka has said is a real issue in this area. I worked with one woman who constantly breeched then invited him back, even once was back in a relationship whilst he was in remand for a breech….. No one is saying this is what happened in this case however the system failed, to make it work you need to look at all the issues.
loading...
We opened up Andrea’s story so that the world could see the failures. There were many. If you are serious about hearing all the detail then can I suggest you obtain a copy of the transcript of the Coronial hearing. Not the findings but the hearing itself. Here you will see how badly they failed Andrea and many others in a similar circumstance.
loading...
@Sara h It would be wise for to take an hour out of your week and watch the Four Corners report. The link is above.
If you do, you will have some greater understanding of the issues involved for Andrea Pickett, Saori Jones and the other 130 women who die at the hands of their partners every year. You may also understand why your comments anger some of the other readers. You could then say you have looked at the whole picture!
loading...
Victim blaming at it’s finest. Appalling.
loading...
I don’t agree or disagree with Bazooka, but those of you standing in such harsh judgement, i ask what you’ve done to help those within the system? How you help women and children who have suffered in this way?
loading...
Has your husband ever considered that the “false” reports may have been changed because in the time it took the police to respond the abuser has pressured the victim to withdraw/change their story with threats. These (mostly) men are very clever, persuasive and manipulative. Some people will always abuse a system, but women are dying because police allow the perpetrator to remain in control.
loading...
This is the problem. Police start to assume. This was part of Andrea’s case. They assumed he wouldn’t be a risk. They begin to make assumptions based on other people’s situations. False cases… Really? Many women drop cases due to nowhere to go, no money and no support. Is this then a false case? Each case must be taken as true, regardless.
loading...
It’s such an awful story. Reading the comments, I do agree that racism often comes into the equation (when it shouldn’t!) but I think it’s more to do with the system. I have sought help from the police etc the last few years, after 15 years of dealing with a stalker. No one I’ve personally been involved with, just someone I met in passing (which makes it even more scary I must admit). But even when this guy is at his worst, I can’t get help because I don’t fit “the criteria” (having never been in a relationship with this person it doesn’t qualify). So every now and then when this guy pops up again I go to the police, and get no assistance. I feel for Andrea, knowing you’re in a dangerous situation but the authorities won’t help you…the system needs to change.
loading...
Thank you for bringing this story into mainstream which this issue does not tend to get. In this case Andrea was unable to get room at a refuge … providing for more refuges would at least help women get the immediate help and assistance that they need, and safety. Keeping this in the mainstream media is important I think to then be able to pressure governments.
loading...
Such a sad, sad story and was so frustrating to hear how many times poor Andrea tried to get help. Watching this episode was only all the more raw as an old friend lost her life 2 weeks ago in similar circumstances. So sorry to all the families that have been through this.
loading...
After watching 4 Corners last night the massive white elephant in the room was that Andrea Pickett was aboriginal. Having grown up in Western Australia, institutional racism in the police is a far too common sight. One has to look at aboriginal deaths in custody to confirm this.
The house where Andrea Picket lost her life was a three bedroom house in a suburb of Perth with 6 adults and 23 children living there. I can only speculate police were very familiar with the house for a variety of reasons. Unfortunately, the police officers involved did not take her concerns seriously. I know that if it was a white educated women voiced the same concerns for her life that Andrea Pickett did the response would have been different. So sad.
loading...
tend to agree Alex
loading...
I didn’t even think that she may have been ignored because she was Aboriginal. It’s very sad and injustice if that is the case. The programme did show that a Japanese woman also suffered a similar fate.
loading...
sadly i agree with you.
RIP Andrea, I am so sad that your fears were not taken seriously enough. I hope that the people involved never make the same mistakes again
loading...
My girlfriend had to leave Perth some months ago due to domestic violence. She was assaulted and threatened for months before she went to police. They helped her to get a court order preventing him from contacting her but that was all they would do. He broke the order time after time and they said there was nothing they could do. He broke into her home, threatened her life and that of their child. She begged the police for help. She always felt that the police never took her seriously. She is of white European appearance. I don’t think it matters what nationality you are, the police in Perth do not take domestic violence seriously. It’s seen as a soft crime not worth their attention.
loading...
Not all police in perth are bad i had a friend who had an abusive drug addicted ex partner and the police were wonderful they called whenever he was seen in the suburb she was living in just to let her know he was around, rang to check on her all the time and told her exactly what she needed to do to get the judge to listen to her and she was a very poor young single mum. unfortunatly andrea situation was complicated by how many children she had with no crisis care able to help
loading...
I agree mrsmac however I think it is the laws that are the issue, police can only do what they can within the realms of the current laws.
I know of a case involving a caucasian woman who lived in a nice house she owned in a family suburb with no criminal record. She too was killed by a former partner who she had an AVO against and she had reported to police about him multiple times.
loading...
Yes but the same thing happened to the other victim who was Japanese, Saori Jones, and with they very same police station just a year or so later – Mirrabooka Police Station! Unbelievable.
We should all be emailing the WA Police Commissioner KARL J O’CALLAGHAN. His email is office.of.commissioner@police.wa.gov.au
If action is not taken now by the public then this appalling travesty of justice is just remembered sadly and not much changes.
loading...
I agree but also at the other end of the septrum is the wealthy white man…police and the legal system seem to be unable to comprehend that a wealthy white male can be violent
loading...
This is the very reason violence among sportsmen shouldn’t be tolerated and should be treated with visible consequences. Off the team, loss of sponsorship – not a TV show, olympics commentator, Olympian. It’s so shocking and devastating in this story but if men are hearing that sportsmen get away with violent acts then what’s to stop anyone? People will say you can’t compare this to a punch up in a bar or trashing an apartment but I think you can. Psychos like Andrea’s murderer should get the message loud and clear. We don’t accept violence of ANY kind.
loading...
I totally agree poster. In the world there seems to be one rule for some, then one rule for others.If you are a famous sports star or ex Olympian then you live by a different set of rules and it is not right.
loading...
Totally agree. Why does Chris Brown still have a career after he was so violent to his partner at the time? Just shows that it is acceptable. Which it is not!
loading...
and he continues to sing songs that encourage degrading attitudes towards women. Lovely
loading...
My first restraining order was thrown out by the magistrate because “he has only hit you once”.
This man went on to attempt to end my life several times as well as inflict significant physical harm upon my body. Thankfully the second order was in front of a more enlightened judge.
loading...
surely once is too many.
personally i think even a threat of violence is reason to act.
loading...
Oh my god Chrissy – that’s awful!
loading...
It used to happen a lot when I was growing up. Even when something was happening then and there and needing the police to come out and and take my father away in case he actually got as far as he wanted to get (killing my mother, my two siblings and myself). It used to take at least an hour or more for them to arrive. An hour and 45 minutes it took them on one of the worse nights.
Hopefully things will change and hopefully other families like mine will get the help they need when they need it.
loading...
It’s not only our Protection and Justice Systems that failed, you’d have to also suspect that our Mental Health System let down this family, resulting in the death of this young woman by her mentally unstable ex husband?
All of the signs were there (that he wasn’t healthy), but there isn’t a lot of power given to doctors who recommend intensive treatment or to police who are trying to protect the community (but lack of resources and adequate systems lets them down).
A friend of mine who is dealing with divorce tried to end his own life last year and the follow-up was a few business cards left in his doorjam by a local officer for a few weeks afterwards.
He has sought treatment himself, but if he hadn’t, and continued to go off the rails, what might the fate have been?
I don’t have the solutions, but public money needs to be invested into research and development of adequate systems – because the systems are broken.
loading...
Mamamia team – “It can be easy to assume that what happened to Angela was highly unusual.” – I think it is Andrea not Angela.
loading...
Thank you x
loading...
Disgusting
loading...
RIP Andrea. Sorry to your family for such an awful tragedy. This is an indictment of our system that we can’t protect terrified women in real danger.
loading...
I think i’s also an indictment on our society that this sort of crime is way too common.
loading...