“No child in primary school needs a smart phone. None. Never,” cyber safety expert and former police officer Susan McLean is starting her day and, as she sips something – judging by her energy I’m thinking it’s coffee – she tells me over the phone her thoughts on the ‘right’ age to allow children a smart phone.
“Parents who buy their child a smart phone in primary school are trying to be their child’s best friend. What kid wants a 40-year-old best friend?” she continues. “They don’t need it and they are too young to understand the risk. The consequences can be devastating.”
McLean has seen it first hand. Her first case involving the safety of children online was in 1994. It was a group of Year Eight school girls targeted by cyberbullies. “We know online bullying starts the moment children have access to the internet. It can start in grade two,” she said.
She has seen the work of online sexual predators. She has seen young kids sexting. She has seen children get themselves into trouble with the law by doing something stupid or taking inappropriate photographs of others. “Young kids often don’t understand the consequences of their actions. Something they think is funny might actually be harmful. The age of legal liability in Australia is 10.”
How to get your teens off their phones at night. Post continues…
Research out of US, released by data analysis firm Influence Central last year, found 10 is the average age children are being given smartphones. It’s a stat likely reflected in Australia, and it’s two years younger than the average age of 12 seen in 2012.
Top Comments
Our school requires all students to have iPads from grade 6 onwards. There are no restrictions on social media apps on themselves. Our daughter is in year 8 and does not have a phone. She refuses to have anything other than an iPhone 6 as "everyone" has one. We refuse to pay $1k for a phone for a 13 year old so she goes without. We have very strict rules around the use of her iPad at home, but they message each other all the time at school.
I would argue that a kid shouldn't get a smart phone unless they have a job to pay for it themselves - so at least 15 or 16 - so that they appreciate the cost involve and are (hopefully) mature enough to use it properly. The only reason at all a kid should have a phone is to call their parents to pick them up etc, so a very basic dumb phone is more than sufficient.