news

She was raped and called the police. They asked her if she liked it.

 

 

By MAMAMIA TEAM

“Did you call the police because you didn’t like it?”

That’s what a police officer in the United Arab Emirates asked 24-year-old Marte Deborah Dalelv when she called to report a rape. And instantly, Dalelv knew the police did not believe her story.

It was March of this year that the Norwegian citizen, who had been working for two years at an interior design firm in the neighbouring country of Qatar, was allegedly raped by a colleague after a night out in Dubai.

Dalelv alleges that she asked her colleague to walk her to her hotel room at around 3am. When the pair were in a hotel corridor, the man pulled Dalely into a room which was not her own.

“He dragged me by my purse in, so I thought, ‘OK, I just need to calm the situation down. I will finish my bottle of water, I will sit here and then I will excuse myself and say I feel fine,'” Dalelv recently told United States broadcaster CNN.

The next thing she knew, Dalelv was naked and lying on her front and the man was raping her.

After she managed to make it downstairs to the hotel lobby, Dalelv did what she would have done if the crime had taken place in her home country: she called the police.

“That is what you do. We are trained on that from when we are very young,” she told CNN.

But here’s the thing. In her home country of Norway, calling the police to report a crime like a rape is expected.

But in the United Arab Emirates, laws of rape and sexual assault operate very, very differently.

The United Arab Emirates follows Sharia Law, which is the traditional Islamic law.

Under Sharia Law, people are prohibited from having sex outside of marriage and, unfortunately, rape falls under that law.

The law also prohibits people from drinking alcohol and taking drugs.

Under Sharia law, a rape allegation is not considered by the courts unless it was witnessed by at least four Muslim men who are each willing to testify and attest that the sex was non-consensual.

So when Dalelv told police that she had been raped – and that she was not married – she was charged with having unlawful sex after being held with no charge for a total of four days.

This from CNN:

Subsequently, she said her manager advised her to tell the police it was voluntary sexual intercourse and likely the whole issue would just go away. She followed the advice and in one of the many hearings at the public prosecutor’s office, she made a statement saying it was voluntary.

Dalelv was then charged with making a false statement.

“That was my biggest regret because it wasn’t voluntary. I just thought it would all go away,” she told CNN.

On July 16, Dalelv was sentenced to 16 months in prison; 12 months for having sex outside of marriage, with additional time added for alcohol consumption and making a false statement. Her attacker has reportedly also been convicted of unlawful sex and alcohol consumption but it’s not known whether he has been charged with rape. What is known is that his sentence was only 13 months jail.

Dalelv is planning on appealing her sentence in September. Dalelv, who has been allowed to stay at a Norwegian community centre in Dubai, said she wanted to go public with her story because her case is not unique. Women in the United Abab Emirates are regularly jailed for unlawful sex despite the fact that the sex was had without consent.

In fact, Dalelv’s story is similar to that of Australian woman Alicia Gali (right). In 2008, Gali travelled to the UAE to head up a spa and beauty salon at a four-and-a-half star resort on the coast.

Three months into her working holiday, 31-year-old Gali was allegedly raped by three hotel employees after her drink was spiked.

“I remember drinking the drink – I don’t even remember finishing the drink,” Alicia told reporter Ross Coulthart, during an interview with Channel 7 earlier this year.

“Next thing I know I wake up at 4:30 in the afternoon the next day. The door to my apartment was ajar, I was completely naked with just my bra handing off my shoulder. I woke up in pain; I had broken ribs and a lot of bruising to my body.”

Alicia was sentenced to one year in jail – the men who raped her received sentences of a similar length. She was pardoned after eight months and allowed to come home to Australia. And today, Alicia says she suffers from post traumatic stress disorder because of the incident.

Both Gali’s and Dalelv’s stories have gained the attention of human rights groups.

The Emirates Center for Human Rights released a statement recently which read:

Ministers in the UAE regularly cite their efforts to eliminate discrimination against women as evidence of an excellent human rights record. As this case demonstrates, the current legal system prohibits the achievement of justice for cases of sexual violence against women.

Rori Donaghy, Campaign Manager, said: “If the UAE is to be taken seriously in its commitment to protecting the rights of women authorities must reform a legal system which affords little protection to victims of rape.

As it stands, if the laws are not reformed, authorities in the UAE are simply using the rights of women as a form of pinkwashing to protect themselves against wider criticism of their human rights record.”

We call upon the authorities to allow Marte Deborah Dalelv to return home and quash her conviction.

If you want to support Dalelv in her efforts to be freed, you can follow her Facebook page here. 

UPDATE: Norwegian woman Marte Deborah Dalelv has reportedly been pardoned and is free to go home from the United Arab Emirates.

Related Stories

Recommended

Top Comments

Guest 11 years ago

Doubtless they are a backward bunch in the UAE and imprisoning people for having consensual sex is a stupid law but reading the facts it seems she was imprisoned for 1) drinking alcohol 2) having consensual sex outside marriage (which is what she told police - don't disbelieve she was raped but she told the police the sex was consensual) and 3) making a false statement about rape which is a crime here albeit one that hardly ever leads to imprisonment. It's by no means clear that if she'd maintained her claim of rape that she would have been imprisoned and I think more evidence needed to claim this is the case.


Check your facts 11 years ago

There is misinformation in this story (and a lot of the comments). While this is an awful story and unfortunately not a lone story it is wrong to report that the UAE works solely under Sharia law. There are many, many rape cases where the woman is not blamed and the male attacker/s is sentenced for a long time (often 10 years). These case have not required male Muslim witnesses. Your writer or fact checker need only look at online news services to see this. Rape and sexual asault cases are tried often and the verdict going in favour of the victim. Yes, this is a very unfortunate case but to say that it is the standard is completely wrong. Yes, there is still a long way to go in protecting and advocating victim rights, and cases like this highlight that, but the way your story was written makes the whole system sound rotten (which it isn't) and helps to foster the old us versus "backward Muslim" stance so popular in Australia.
Please take a little time to check your facts before publishing.

Catherine 11 years ago

I would ask Check your facts to check their facts The following link looks at the high rape scale in Saudi Arabia http://womanstats.wordpress...

Rape and sexual assault cases do not appear to be tried often and the verdict does not appear to go in favour of the victim. Apparently there were 59 reported rapes, yes only 59! for a population of 26,,584, 504 in Saudi Arabia for 2002; The United Arab Emirates does not have womens rights like we do here in Australia

Catherine 11 years ago

A Filippino maid was lashed 100 times for being raped in Saudi Arabia , as well as imprisoned. Mistreatment and punishment of rape victims is not a one off in Saudi Arabia. http://trueslant.com/nealun...

Deb 11 years ago

Saudi Arabia and the UAE are two different countries. They may be neighbours but they are very different.

Check your facts 11 years ago

Saudi Arabia is NOT the UAE, so I don't see how your stats are relevant to this story or my comment. I stand by what I wrote that there are many rape cases tried in the UAE that favour the victim, I can think of two recent (as in the past week) cases. As I said jump online and read some UAE newspapers.
Things are very different in Saudi Arabia so its not really comparable. No, women aren't always treated equitably in the UAE and there is a long, long way to go, but the UAE is more liberal and progressive than Saudi Arabia.
Can I point out that its not uncommon for men to also go to jail in the UAE for sex outside of marriage. The woman in this case was wrongly advised to confess to consensual sex outside of marriage (which is what she was charged with) when she should have stuck to her rape claim. She admits herself that was biggest mistake. There is a good chance she would not have been charged if she had.