by ZOE FOSTER
Over the weekend I was generous enough to dance like a princess (‘goose’) for many hours for a dazzled (‘indifferent’) audience at a friend’s 30th. It was SO FUN. I haven’t had a good dance – you know the kind, sweaty, wild, hilarious, full of giggles and interpretive/freestyle/contemporary moves – for over a year.
Which saddens me. A dame must dance; it’s good for the soul. (If, like me, you do not like clubs and the like, preferring to save it all up and unleash annually at a house party, you might be interested in No Lights, No Lycra, which is exactly as it sounds but five x more awesome.)
Anyway. A friend of mine was there, a single friend, and she lamented as the night went on that she “shouldn’t have straightened her hair, because she never got any attention from guys when she did.”
After a long slurp from my delicious vodka something-or-other, I (straight hair starting to curl from sweat/headbanging) probed further. Turns out she (ghd-straight hair), and another dame who stood with us (messy top-knot) and joined the conversation, believe that girls with curls get guys, not dames with perfectly straight hair. Guys don’t notice straight hair, they say. Think of the hot girls in movies and ads and stuff – always roughed up, flicky, curly, wavy hair. GIRLS like straight hair, but guys don’t. Now I’ve heard other girls say this something along these lines in the past, but never with such wide-eyed conviction and finger jabs
After a lot of snorting guffawing noises and general disbelief from me, the girls explained that in their experience, waves, curls and messy hair was a more… effective male magnet than when they did their hair perfectly, be that dead straight or tightly back.
It wasn’t actually up for debate, I soon realised, they were telling me, not suggesting it as a theorem. They had the personal proof, for them it held true. Top-knot claimed she gets a lot more attention when she chucks her hair up high and wears big earrings. Men like shiny earrings, she said. And lots of chest and neck on show, she said, somewhat declaring the obvious. And we know how my straight-haired friend was feeling, as she vainly tried to scrunch some texture into her strands.
I thought about it. Perhaps they were right… but only in as much as it’s a confidence thing. That is to say, personally, I feel more me when I have my curls or waves or a bedhead thing going on, and obviously when you feel more you, then you are more likely to exude confidence, and as we all know, it’s confidence that attracts the gents, not the precise kink or ringlet of the hair. If you don’t think you are being perceived as saucy when you have dead straight hair, you won’t feel as saucy. Simple.
But I think there is a bit of the “I’m having a quiet night” law in play here, too. You know the one: where you don’t bother to go home and put on a sparkly outfit, or re-do your makeup, or style your hair, because in your mind, “you’re just having a quiet night/a few drinks”, and you just go in what you’re wearing and with whatever your hair is choosing to do, be that up, down, dirty, whatever, and then it ends up being the most fun/outrageous/wild night of your life.
It’s the old Expectation + Energy Expenditure Vs Outcome ratio, the classic NYE scenario: when you put in too much effort and expect The Best Night Ever, you are acutely denied it, but when you shuffle over to Jess’s for a few drinks in your work clothes, you end up dancing on a table and kissing a man who looks like Aaron Eckhart at 3am.
Kate Upton, giga babe, recently said in a Cosmo interview that, “To me, what’s sexy is when you look like you’re having a good time. That, and when you look effortless and have messy hair.”
I don’t think we should necessarily care what guys find sexy, nor should we be taking advice on what guys like from a woman who would look sexy wrapped in AstroTurf, but I do have to agree with her sentiment on looking a bit effortless and messy-haired and like you’re having a good time as being attractive. Or, in fact, actually having a good time, not just looking like you’re having one. And if that means attempting the worm on concrete*, then so be it.
*Not advised.
Zoe Foster is an author, columnist and porridge fan. Her books include the beauty bible Amazing Face, dating and relationship guide Textbook Romance, and three novels, Air Kisses, Playing The Field and The Younger Man. Find more info on Zoe Foster here, or supervise on her daily procrastination here and here.
Please understand that Zoë Foster cannot respond to ALL your questions – but never fear, there are readers that are bound to know the answers, so don’t be afraid to ask.
What do you think of Zoe’s theory? And does it apply to these celebrities?

Kate Moss – perfectly piecey, with bedhead texture and movement









Comments
54 Comments so far
No Lights, No Lycra sounds amazeballs!
Thanks Zoe – not only do you give me great beauty advice, you also sort out my social life
loading...
The one thing I have learnt through dating experience (and not just my own – i work as a speed dating host) is that guys don’t really care about “all that beauty stuff.” They do, however, care whether a girl is confident, carefree and having one heck of a lot of fun. So I would say that a success rate of going out with slightly dishevelled hair is probably more about “I’m having such an awesome time dancing to retro 80s hits” than the specificity of the hair styling.
Although – I have also discovered, guys are a fan of anything ever so slightly reminiscent of just-had-sex. So possibly the messy hair look has that going for it too
loading...
Around 8 – 10 years ago the fairly standard brief for Ralph and FHM mags were that the “models” must have straight hair…apparently boys weren’t that keen on curls then!
loading...
The “delightfully dishevelled” look is always a winner as far as I am concerned.
loading...
The hair on those celebs is not curly, not even the slightest . I’d call it straight hair with a slightly delicate unnatural wave. Curly hair is bloody frustrating, Michael-flattery-irish-dancer-esq, Felicity crossed with an orangutan hair – now that’s curly. And it’s the most high maintenance thing in my life, which is probably why I mostly wear it plonked on top of my head.
loading...
I know! My hair is thick, frizzy and rough at the crown and I hate having it out. It’s long too and very flat on top of my head and I just hate how much maintenance goes into making it look acceptable for the day. My favourite trick is to wash it on a Saturday, plait it tightly and let it out on Monday morning for the perfect loose waves, a hairstyle that flatters my face very nicely. Lots of curl cream and macadamia oil go into it though!
loading...
Haha I used to do that too!! plait it wet.so much neater that way..I forgot about that trick actually, might give it a try again. I spend quite a bit of $ on product too but it still is just sooo messy!!!
loading...
This is true! I like to ghd straighten my hair and when I run out of time, or sleep on wet hair and have crazy hair the next morning my husband likes me so much more. And when we go on holidays and I let my hair go after swimming ect my husband reeeaaallly likes me!
loading...
Really? In my experience I’ve found the opposite is true. And I think a lot of my friends would concur. Having said that, my favourite going out hairdo is a high knotted bun because it stays out of my way when I’m dancing and that’s all I really care about when I go out!
loading...
If a guy bases his attraction to me on if I have slightly disheveled hair then I don’t think he’s the guy for me. If he’s that picky about hair then my habit of not actually brushing mine until I get to the bathroom at work is prooobably going to be a deal breaker.
I just dress and do my hair like I like. I seriously doubt most dudes are that fussy or aware of hair. They will be far more aware of the confidence and self assurance that comes from being happy with what you look like.
And even then, this is all putting way to much thought into it.
Let the men folk come to you, don’t put too much effort into tricky ways to attract them.
We should be using our brains to decide which cocktail to have next, not to figure out what they want us too look like.
loading...
Yes…..found this in my experience too!
My guy says “I like it when your hair is a bit messy like that, babe”
Straight hair = too perfect = not as much fun as Mrs. Messy Hair (apparently!)
Straight hair = work hair.
loading...
This happens to be one of my FAV. POSTS. EVER!
I apologise for ‘shouting’ but I’m just that excited.
I found myself nodding along to your every word Zoe…. my fellow tram passengers have now possibly dubbed me ‘that crazy lady on the tram’, however it was worth it.
Thanks for your light hearted, yet very true words.
loading...
Thanks Jo! I laughed and cried and snorted at Me Talk Pretty One Day on a train recently and don’t worry, everyone thinks you’re cool and fun when you do emotive things on PT. Promise.
loading...
Last time i left my hair natural ( rare event ) my husband asked ” hell, what happened”?
loading...
I only half-assed straighten my hair, to get the boofyness out. My hair is naturally wavy, boofs when brushed.
It’s also very long so straightening it 100% would take too long, espec as I’m one of the ‘dance until your face runs with sweat’ girls.
I think the girls who straighten their hair and want to keep it straightened don’t get as much attention because they aren’t dancing, always touching up lip gloss or running hands over their hair. Have fun ladies! It’s a night out, not a fashion show.
loading...
Word!
loading...
As a naturally wavy-haired girl, this is news to me! My first boyfriend really didn’t like my curls and constantly urged me to straighten it because he loved stick-straight hair. (Although this is the same guy who insisted on me having brazilian waxes, if that’s any indication of his attitudes towards female beauty – needless to say, he is my ex!)
loading...
Yes! Once, I went to a concert in Sydney and was planning on going out after but after noshing like a lunatic I was super sweaty and my hair was a mess AND it started to rain. So we rushed back to the hotel before to get changed and as my dress that I planned to wear out was drenched in sweat I had to put in the only other dress I had (which was a summer dress). My friends where so keen to head out the only thing I time to do was put my hair up and powder my nose. I ended up having the best night! I did get lots of male attention, for guys considerably older than me, but it was more the dance with out a care that was fun!
loading...
You always have an awesome night when you least expect it! The nights you look forward to are usually a fizzer! Great article, a very enjoyable read.
loading...
My hair is naturally wavy and knda beachy when I leave it alone. Its great until you get onto a sweaty humance floor and then its just a frizz fest. That said I dont mind it at all.
loading...
Let’s say it like it is – men like the JBF (Just Been F*cked) look – sexy beddy hair – I have short blonde (like the pic of VB) hair and my man said to me on Saturday night – I love it when your hair is messy – and so it shall be.
loading...
I have boring as hell straight, non volumous just-above-the-armpit hair, help!
Just wto know how to add some texture/movement, I can’t figure out how too anything beideten with the GHD
loading...
Me too! Maybe its time to bring back the perm – agghhhh!
loading...
Mousse, sea salt spray and damp hair plaits left overnight are your best friends!
loading...
My hair is naturally curly (read: frizzy) and I feel much more confident when it’s straightened, which honestly isn’t often. My boyfriend likes straight hair better, but for some reason prefers curly hair on me (I don’t know whether I should read into that). Funnily, contrary to popular belief, I got hit on more when I had short hair. Like, very short (but not pixie cut). Go figure!
loading...
I have straight non-volumous just-above-armpit hair that I find oh so boring! Would love to know how other women in similar situations add texture/wave/curl to their hair?
loading...
This is fantastic stuff, spray into towel dried or dry hair and crunch your hair up for that “just walked out of the ocean” look xx
http://www.beautyheaven.com.au/hair/styling-products/30185-de-lorenzo-elements-ocean-mist-sea-salt-styling-spray
loading...
I am looking to try a mineral foundation (powder) but I am worried that I will have to give up cream blush. I have heard about the whole cream with cream and powder with powder rule. Powder foundation users out there, do any of you use cream blush? I don’t know if I can quit my cream blush addiction!
loading...
I use Nude by Nature Mineral Powder (its fantastic) and ive used cream blush and powdered blush and haven’t had a problem with either. Both stay in place.
loading...
Put your cream blush on first, a little stronger than you need, then use your mineral foundation powder over the top. Bonus – the powder will set your blush!
loading...
Lol!! Brings back memories of a teacher who called it ‘come to bed hair’! As in “girls you must tie your hair back, not have come to bed hair”!! So, there must be truth to it, this was 20 years ago
loading...
Nope, depends entirely on the guy. In fact, my husband INSISTED I straighten my long long fair hair for our wedding day and just leave it hanging out, since that’s his fave look. I offered him any number of alternate looks and updos and NUP, he just wanted the dead straight long locks he prefers…
loading...
I’ve always been a fan of long, messy hair although if I was forced to have short hair it would resemble Diana Agron’s (pic 4).
Most of the men I know hate short hair on women – particularly the careful, tidy hair favoured by older women.
I caught a glimpse of Dame Judy Dench this morning (who’s look and hair always seemed so youthful) and she’s allowed her hairdresser to do the “too short, bowling ball-shape” thing to her hair….now she really does look her age.
What’s wrong with looking your age ?….Well in that industry it means less work and less male interest (which can also mean less work).
I know some men have got a “thing” for the British school -mistress look but basically I reckon they love that “just got out of bed” look more…lol.
loading...
By the way, thanks for the No Lights No Lycra tip Zoe. I’d never heard of it before. As someone like you who detests clubs and waits for weddings and 30th birthday parties to come around just so I can shake my groove thing, this sounds right up my alley. I’m seriously thinking about starting one up in my area now!
loading...
Can I go off topic here to let all the dark-circled ladies out there about the amazing concealer by Napoleon Perdis called ‘the one’!!! Before I had to layer corrector and concealer and it’ll start to seep into fine lines for the amount of product I need to cover these horrid things under my eyes, but you need the TINIEST amount and it INSTANTLY covers it! No layering necessary! It’s the best $36 you’ll ever spend and it’ll last you ages! I’m so happy and relieved to finally have a quick, easy to use product that makes me look awake and not like a tired, old thing! You’re welcome
loading...
You are, annoyingly, so right Zoe. I straighten my hair most days in order to get that polished look that makes me feel civilised, not like some mad frizzy haired witch’s broomstick, but every single time I get the GHD out my husband starts moaning. “Why are you straightening it, I wish you wouldn’t, leave it curly, it looks so beautiful/sexy/much better…” on and on and on. Either this or he just says nothing, certainly no compliments. Keeping in mind that my hair in its natural state isn’t really curly but essentially just a ball of uncontrollable frizz, I don’t share his sentiments but he just likes it so much better. He is convinced that I style myself in accordance with what other women would like rather than what men like. Maybe he’s right.
loading...
My boyfriend is the same. He tolerates the GHD only because he knows that’s the way I like it, but if he had his way… I’d have crazy, unruly girls everyday (probably while wandering around topless).
loading...
My boyfriend prefers me to have straight hair. I love to straighten my hair but I also love to curl it and he definitely prefers it straightened. It depends on the guy really.
loading...
Actually this doesn’t surprise me that much. Maybe dead straight hair just looks too perfect?
That said, nothing beats a girl who exudes confidence and a sense of humour. That wins the day every time! (An ability to do the worm on concrete is clearly a bonus. That or the robot.)
loading...
For the past year and a half I’ve had to take medication for rheumatoid arthritis, and it’s turned my Shirley Temple like ringlets into a kind of wavy mess. People have insisted that they don’t really notice (my Mum especially thinks I’m mad and my rheumatologist thinks I’m either lying or just crazy), but seeing as how it’s my hair, in the same hairstyle that I’ve had for twelve years, it’s knocked my self-confidence more than you can imagine.
As of July, I’ve had official permission from my rheumatologist to come off the medication, and I’m watching my hair, with each wash, returning to its former curliness. The actual length of the individual hairs is the same, but because it’s so much curlier and springier; my hair appears to be about five centimetres shorter. And my God my confidence has come flooding back. It seems ridiculous that so much of who I am is related to how my hair looks, but having curly hair is so much a part of my identity, that I feel like I’m regaining a part of myself. So for me personally, yeah, I definitely feel more confident when my hair is at its natural curly best!
loading...
I know! Since I started on my RA meds my once thick hair has thinned out, but has maintained that delightful not-quite-wavy-but-definitely-frizzy quality. It’s soooo much drier too. It never sits right anymore (my hairdresser doesn’t believe me), and I never thought I’d say it coz it used to bug the crap out of me, but I want the thickness back!!
I think my rheumatologist thinks I’m nuts.
loading...
You are assuming we all look better with ‘natural’ hair. As someone whose natural hair makes me look like the Wild Women of Borneo I can assure you I am far more confident with ghd straightened hair.
loading...
Oh Kirsten but I am not at all. I still curling tong my curls to get them “the good curly” or “the right looking wavy” and when I am doing “messy” hair it takes a shittonne of product and styling, beloooooooyve me.
loading...
What curling tong do you recommend?
Ghd is to straighten hair as ????? Is to curl hair,
Thanks
loading...
I use Babyliss (ripped the clamp off) or the Remington Keratin one (comes with no clamp.)
loading...
‘Wild Women of Borneo’. That’s what I call my girls when they look like, well, Wild Women of Borneo! Love it.
loading...
My boyfriend dislikes the straight look too. He likes my hair when it looks undone and effortless. He HATES buns, especially the sock bun because it is so neat. But I wear my hair however I want, he doesn’t dislike me for it!
loading...
The last time I went out dancing? It must be some years ago. The kids took me clubbing for Mother’s Day. I had a great time, met lots of new people, got complimented on my dancing by a young bloke and noticed by a woman. I had straight hair that night and had a totally great time!
And probably since I can remember this so well, I need to break out again… My feet are beginning to tap along to almost anything on the radio!
But at 47, I’m beyond the whole ‘boys don’t notice me’ thing, though I’m inclined to agree with the statement that looking sexy is confidence, having a great time and not worrying about making an impression.
loading...
Apart from the gorgeous and always perfect Victoria Beckham, all the other women in the gallery just looked scruffy and in need of a good comb!
loading...
I always feel underwhelming when my hair is straightened…its on the fine side and it just seems so flat and boring when it is straight. I feel much better with some waves or curls. Unfortunately due to my below par time management , and my very ordinary skills when it comes to creating curls/ waves , I often either just run out of time or end up with a bedraggled mess in my attempts at effortless curls, and as my hair is thin straightening is quick and wins out.
loading...
Same here. My hair is on the fine side and when straightened, it has no volume and just seems flat.
I’m trying to master the skill of creating relaxed waves but havent got there yet!
loading...
There is a big difference between flicky/wavy hair and actually curly hair. As someone with actually curly hair, I can tell you right now that my weird half-ringlet, half-straight, half-wavy hair does nothing for anybody. I’ve always been a hair-up girl. After they know me, guys will say they prefer the hair out, but in my experience I pick up more with straight hair or having it tied back, the complete opposite of what your finger-jabby friends assert.
loading...
Argh, so true AJM. What’s with the ringlets hiding at the base of my head, then the waves (the waves are good) but then, THEN!! the shitty flat bedraggled hair framing my face? Wtf is that? So, I HAVE to style the facey bits but can’t match it to the waves so the whole thing needs styling. Argh.
loading...
This one is a little tricky for me because I have naturally dead straight hair which you would think I would feel more “me” and comfortable with. Don’t get my wrong I am perfectly fine going out with straight hair, however I always feel my best/prettiest when I curl/scrunch my hair. I don’t think it has anything to do with male attention but the fact that it’s something different from my always straight locks.
loading...