Do You Like This Story?

life edit  380x377 Social Spinning is messing with your head

 

 

 

 

I had just returned from a ‘holiday’ in Queensland, the first since our toddler twins were born. A week later and substantially poorer we returned home, exhausted. The boys’ whinging was unrelenting – they had decided not only to relinquish their midday nap, but sleep altogether and the longer they were up switching on the fan at 2.00am, the higher and louder the whinge.  I felt defeated. Defeated as a multiple mum, defeated as a parent, defeated as a happy-go-lucky-holiday relaxer, just plain defeated.

Two days after we returned, a friend posted photos of her own family on a gap year in Germany. There they were, all blond-haired and summer-skinned, posing in front of medieval castles, knocking-back bratwurst while kicking back in their mini-birkenstocks. And always smiling. Always.

‘Do your children ever whine?’ I asked, expecting her to say Oh no, when they’re not singing the Hills are Alive in three-part-harmony, they just frolic merrily in the Edelweiss.

But instead she wrote Oh yes. And fight non-stop. Only now they do it in front of exquisite backdrops.

Two things have struck me about this exchange.

Firstly, that, on balance, I will never holiday with my family again. We work hard, we’re entitled to an annual sleep-in, the kids are happier at home – and sleep – it’s a no brainer.

Secondly, that in this electronic age, it is not only faces that need to be photogenic, but lives. Social networking means we are in a perpetual state of editing of our lives and the way we live them, for the most part sub- consciously. I reflected on potty-training, a horrifying task we are undertaking with the boys at the moment. This, however, is the photo I posted on facebook.

Kim Kane  380x283 Social Spinning is messing with your head

This is the photo Kim posted on Facebook.

 

I did not post photos of the state of absolute degradation in which we reside. I did not post photos of poo smeared up one twin’s back or across the cot, of the drenched couch, the pool of wee on my new computer, of the boys slopping urine all over the floor, the 12 pairs of stained trackies hanging daily on the line, the undies I have discarded because even the power hose couldn’t assist.  At times, our house makes a Calcutta slum look comfortable.

There is of course nothing new in this. I remember once marveling at an acquaintance’s idyllic island life  – a perfect hut set on the absolute beach, only to be reminded you don’t see the sand flies in photos. But with the sheer volume of personal information up for posting on social media, this sand fly effect is exacerbated. People have started withholding more and more information. They are wary about dropping details of their holidays or gifts for security reasons. They are sensibly cautious about dissing the meal made by their mother-in-law. In this age of sharing there is as much editing as divulging.

Perhaps, however, this self-edit is not only for security reasons. Perhaps people, or at least older people are starting to exercise restraint with their postings because they are concerned about what employers and colleagues may think. Or perhaps, as one friend wryly suggested, people only post gorgeous photos of themselves on the Côte d’azur to make other people feel crappy about their own lives. Sometimes I wonder, but I don’t think so. If anything, I post good shots to remind myself of the happy moments. Or at least in the case of twin potty-training, moment.

Kim Kane is an author and a mother. She has written one novel, Pip: the story of Olive and two picture books The Vegetable Ark and Family Forest. She is currently working on a further two novels and a picture book.

What do you think? Do you consciously edit your life on line?  Do you suspect you have friends who do?

 

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

126 Comments so far

  1. Elena

    Hi KellyThis feature aareldy exists. You can block your IP from your stats by clicking the little wrench to the right or your project, then Edit settings . Your IP is shown in the text in the IP blocking section. Copy paste this into the box provided and then click Edit Project .

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. psyv

    I don’t edit. The photos I take are fairly true to the occasion. I don’t post the embarrassing ones that people wouldn’t want employers or family to see. I tend to take natural photos as well, instead of entirely posed. I find this grabs the captures the moment much better but I don’t begrudge posed ones!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Carly

    Not everybody is social editing! We have no problems travelling internationally and long haul as a family…. I am just saying…. not impossible that people really are that happy on their holidays and it is not all doom and gloom!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Serious Cat

      Wow, Carly! Good for you! What a useful, insightful and helpful reply!

      I think you missed the subtext – not that everyone edits, not that everyone is always secretly having a bad time and pretending otherwise, but that we all have things that look good from the outside but feel rotten from the inside, and that it’s useful to remember when comparing yourself to others.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  4. jb expat

    Great post…reading it (and the comments) makes me scared to take our first (actually not our first – first was good (son was only 6 months) and I wanted him to meet my overseas family who helped a lot, second was horrid (work trip but I wasn’t ready to live my baby at home so husband came along – was an AWFUL idea and an exhausting week)), so I guess kind of third, holiday.

    Our little boy is now 15 months and we want to get away but now I’m concerned – we are thinking that it won’t be easy – so planning on going only 1.5 hours from home for 5 nights and having inlaws stay for a couple of nights (they’ve agreed – happily). Is this a bad idea? I don’t want a miserable break. I think my husband and I would rather take separate breaks with friends than have a miserable family vacation…at least for this year. Any advice?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. marijana

    this post just reminded me of our recent first holiday as a family (3year old and 9months old). we also had my brother and his girlfriend with us, who live overseas. so we went all together to queensland. in a hire car.driving for 2 long days. listening to a 9month old crying for most of the time that she was awake.
    once we were there, things were better, but with the 1hour time difference(which I didn’t realise before), we also did not have the sleeping in we somehow hoped to have.
    also of course I wanted a break from cooking, so I was keen on eating out. great. with a 9months old. it’s literally fast food:eat fast or else you won’t be able to eat up at all.
    generally the few days we were there, weren’t too bad. then we had to drive back home.2 days.again.
    my 9mths old daughter still hates driving longer distances(everything longer than 10minutes!).
    and yes I also posted the nice photos on Facebook, because that’s when I remembered to make a photo at all. I didn’t capture any crapy moments, I felt like I was hardly able to capture many good moments, as in those moments I just tried to relax and enjoy and calm/controlled/stress free/cry or whinge free/yell free etc. moment. and memorise in my head.
    pity only we don’t have ONE photo of all of us together.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Alicia

    We edit Facebook for the same reason we all smile and say ‘I’m well thanks” when someone asks how we are,regardless of how far from the truth it might be…
    We all want our lives to appear happy….and sometimes I think there’s an element of ‘faking it until you make it….
    We might kid ourselves that we create the illusion for others but reat ya for ourselves….so we can sit back and look at our post and feel like everything is ok.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Mooner

    I love Megs’ quote down below about comparing others’ highlight reel with our behind-the-scenes.

    I really don’t believe any/many people are trying to make others feel bad when they post beautiful pictures. Whether we feel bad is our own responsibility.

    In terms of ‘editing’ online personas: totally. I edit so much that I barely put anything on Facebook or Twitter anymore. The balance between show-off and battler is so hard to find! Does anyone else notice that? Some people on FB are perpetual whingers, others are perpetual Pollyanna’s… how do you keep things real without sounding like your life is a real struggle?!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Expat in Asia

    I’m toilet training my 2 and half year old twin girls & after having done it twice before I thought this one would be easy. OMG nightmare! They wear pull ups for nap time which they can remove on their own, as well as bedclothes & also tossing all their bedclothes & mattresses out of their cots. We had a horrifying week a few weeks ago when four days in a row during lunchtime nap they took their pullups off after they had poohed & threw it all over their bedroom, moulded it like plasticine, smeared it over their faces, one of them even ate it. It was sooo disgusting – I commented to a friend it was like a scene from CSI but instead of blood it was sh*t everywhere. I used packing tape to tape their shorts to their singlets “obi” style! Posted the pic on Facebook – v cute (identical twins). Have now resorted to sleeping bags with a nappy pin over the zip area – extra security. My other kids never did this – very naughty twins!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Haven Maven

      Im so sorry but you just gave me the hugest chuckle for the morning!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. kateb

    why do we think we have to “go away” for a holiday, relax at home. particularly with 2 year olds, my goodness they wouldn’t even know they were away except it was unfamiliar.

    sit around and read, watch TV have friends over DO NOTHING.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. archie

    I have pruned my facebook friends right back, and I have only kept my close mates. I know them in real life, I know their online life, and the two are pretty much the same. We are an honest bunch.

    I know I posted about the time my daughter was toilet training and did a wee I my foot spa, thinking it was a potty!

    Blogs are crazy for editing. All the popular ones show the shiniest, most perfect lives. It’s depressing. I just want them to show a photo of the other side of the room too, where they piled the three weeks of unfolded laundry! But I edit mine pretty heavily too, I don’t want people knowing too much or being too stalky.

    http://the-accidental-housewife.blogspot.com.au/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. JanelleC68

    On FB I only post things others might find interesting. I don’t bother with the mundane crap, like one friend who tells everyone of every appointment her kids ever go to, and several times a day. Booooooorrrrrrrring. I don’t post any unflattering photos, either, cause I’m vain like that.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      And quite fair enough too, JanelleC68. I edit most of the photos of me well before facebook!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • haylesjb

        Thats a great point Kim Kane
        We wouldnt frame photographs of bad pix of ourselves of family why would we post on FB poo smeared and the like ones!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  12. SJK

    I think, with Facebook in particular, that it is often the people who try too hard to post the “look at how much fun I’m having” status updates and party pictures, that are actually not the happiest.

    A lot of my friends who I know are off having awesome social lives are very rarely on Facebook because they just don’t have the time!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Very true, SJK! A friend of mine used to say I should be wary of “designers” I met at parties as any decent designers were actually at home working. Me? Never out, always on facebook avoiding housework, brawling children and my next novel.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Facebook pic posterer

      People don’t post good pics to make others feel bad. They post good pics to make themselves feel good. If you feel bad it’s your problem! People use facebook to share the good moments not the bad. I don’t want to see your kid with poo smudged all over themselves or you. We want to see the cute stuff.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nik

      I have so many friends who post day in day out about how AMAZING, WONDERFUL, *insert superlative here* their life is. How much they LOVE their partner, their day, their kids and life in general. I kinda feel sorry for them because it always comes off like they’re trying to convince themselves that their life is great. Usually the best days of my week are the ones when I’m so caught up in life I don’t even care to post anything on FB. I feel like the people overdoing it are always trying to show a digital life that might not be actually happening for real

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Bus girl

    Hi, I’m going to comment on the holiday with kids theme because I want to give you hope …
    3 years ago we went on holiday with our then 2yr old twins ans their 3yr old sister. Just a short trip to the coast for a long weekend … It was a disaster and I kicked myself for self inflicted torture.
    After this we had zero holidays until Jan this year, fast forward to travelling intestate by car with four and a half year old twins and an almost 6 year old and it was totally different in a wonderful way. Not saying it wasn’t a lot of effort and there was still a lot of shouting and fighting (and some vomiting), but I can at least say it was fun. So my advice to you..not that you asked for it … Is stay home for a couple of years. Oh, and get a split screen DVD player for the car if you are driving to your holiday destination.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks, bus girl. ALWAYS happy to take advice from any Survivor of Twins.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  14. Megs

    I think I may have actually read the following quote on this site, but I love it -it went something like this:

    “The problem is that we compare other people’s highlights reel with our behind the scenes.”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Elmo

      That is an AWESOME quote!! Puts everything in perspective.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kim Kane

        I LOVE it, thank you!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  15. oddsocks

    Don’t we all edit our life all the time… really. We went on a holiday last week, it was lovely we caught up with lots of great friends, had a few good meals and I got to help my soon to be sister in law find the perfect wedding dress! That is what I tell acquantances who ask how our week was (e.g the pre-school teacher)…… the more balanced description… well it was absolutely heart wrenching to watch a close friend sob as he buried his mother, embarrassing as my 3 year old yelled “I can’t see” over and over as the coffin was lowered into the ground, driving for hours and hours with 3 cranky tired children and every bloody thing we own in our small car was essentially torture, then there was the cafe lunch which involved my 2yr old standing up and vomiting in the middle of the floor…… then there was more and more and more vomit…. and washing… oh and flooding rain making it hard to drive etc… oh and the crap load of stuff in the car being soggy and wet…. and the gastro following us home, infecting my 7 month old and half a dozen of our beautiful friends who we were visiting….
    I’ll stop now. We had a lovely week.
    See, this is why we edit our lives!!! Who the hell wants to see pictures of all that (I am chuckling now, actually it would be awesome to have a picture of the projectile spew splashing the toes of the stunned cafe diners…. I’d enlarge it and put it on canvas for his 21st birthday!).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Elmo

      I know exactly what you mean. We avoid telling the ugly truth – online and IRL – for fear of being labelled a whinger or worse, boring.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  16. dulcie

    Surely part of the beauty of that gorgeous photo is that you KNOW what a rarity the moment that was captured is! Great piece, thanks.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks Dulcie. Yes, it is rare moment. Usually they wrestle on their potties.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Siobhan

        Yes, it’s a gorgeous photo!! And to be honest, I’d much rather see a photo like that than one of a poo-stained cot!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  17. WillaWay

    It’s nothing new, just a new medium for it. Flick through any photo album and you’ll only see happy families. Most people clean up their stories of domestic tedium/horror/boredom/averageness for entertainment’s sake. Maybe the ubiquitousness of facebook and the frequency with which people visit it heighten the pressure to be perfect, but I think the more we get used to it and relate it back to real lives and the people we know in real time and space, the less pressurising it will seem. Except, perhaps, for the most vulnerable – those who are isolated, or teenagers, etc. It’s natural though. When I’m feeling down or something’s gone wrong, I’m not going to think, ‘I really should whip out the phone and take a photo of this’. Most of us still just document when we’re feeling relaxed or when a day has special associations. If you read the statuses on facebook – at least among my friends list – there are lots of whinges, self-reflection, gripes and confessions to bad days to counter the pretty images.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Facebook etiquette

    I like seeing my Facebook friends’ holiday photos and hearing their news. But I do think that some users lack etiquette and manners.
    One type of Facebook user that puzzles me is the one who regularly posts photos and status updates but will rarely if ever comment on their friends’ news not even the news of their close friends. I do understand that there is no obligation in a group situation such as Facebook to comment on absolutely everyone’s posts but really it does seem a tad self-centred.
    The other Facebook user I don’t understand is the one who never talks but instead just stalks. They never post status updates or contribute to conversations but are regularly online. How do I know this? Because I hear them whinging and gossiping in private about all of their friends’ status updates.
    I rarely if ever post photos anymore and never of my baby, I can’t stand the thought of her photos being subjected to being ‘liked’ or not ‘liked’.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Axe

      They are self centred. Actually narcissistic. Some of those post a number of times each day. As for the stalkers, that gets on my nerves too.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Facebook etiquette — well observed! I always worry that I’m a bit of an obsessive “like”-er. It feels like such a dreary unimaginative response and yet most of the time I’m on facebook, I’m too tired to be anything other than dreary and unimaginative.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • maggie

      I cant stand the ones that winge about everything in their life!
      Every couple of hours!

      One friend I have, his GF recently left him. All we here is how lonely he is, how he hates his job, and how sick he is all the time. And never doing anything about it.

      Talk about attention seeking!

      – He also keeps saying he will just leave FB as it’s all fake……but never does.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  19. NewMum

    I think I’m unintentionally guilty of this. I don’t post much on Facebook, just the odd picture of bub or a quick status update now and then. I don’t want to bore anyone so I just add pics for our relatives to see because they don’t get to see bub often.

    It’s not about not being honest, I just don’t think they’d care!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Rebekah

    I only post the good stuff online, because the rest is no one’s business. I’ll talk with my close friends about it, but I’m not going to share it with the world. We complain a lot about people whinging and oversharing online, yet then criticise people who edit their lives.

    I don’t think it’s necessarily trying to make life look better than it is (not in my case anyway), it’s more a matter of being appropriate wit the information we share. We do this anyway in normal life. We don’t open up our hearts to strangers or acquaintances in person, why should we do it online?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Sasha

    I don’t like whinging online- it drives me crazy when other people do (not just one off or for a legitimate reason, but more when day by day they write passive aggressive statuses to ‘you know who you are’ *rolls eyes*). So arguably I’m editing my life online? I don’t tag myself places and I rarely change my status. But I try to keep it optimistic and keep my problems to myself.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      I’m not mad on constant facebook-whinging either, Sasha. There’s already quite enough whinging in my life (the twins whinge in full sentences)…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. wotisunique

    I find this interesting on several levels.

    Firstly, holidaying with young children is just hard. It just is. Their need for routine and the ordinary doesn’t gel so well with our idea of “holiday” (meaning taking a break from the normal grind). I’ve never met anyone who doesn’t find it hard. Unfortunately you need to go on your own first holiday to find this out.

    Secondly, I think we’ve always “edited” our lives. Facebook (and no doubt other social media) are just another forum for doing it. I think we all present a different side to ourselves, depending on the social situation. For example, I am more reserved at work, for example, than I am outside of work. Or home (just ask my husband).

    No one has a perfect life. Or maybe – everyone’s life is imperfectly perfect. We all have bad times. Some people suffer to a huge degree. Some people are able to cope better (perhaps because they have a better support network, perhaps they have better coping mechanisms. There are a number of complex reasons.). Likewise, we all have good times. Some people just feel the need to share more.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks wotisunique, for that thoughtful response.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Furchildmama

        I actually bought a plaque of this quote to hang on my wall… “Maybe it’s not our perfection that makes us so perfect” ~ Jane Austen ~

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  23. Mel

    I think it can be a case of damned if you do , damned if you don’t. If you only post happy positive messages and photos then you’re not “keeping it real” and to some people just trying to show off. If you do post sh*tty things that happen to you (sometimes to try and keep the balance) then you’re a whinger.I think I’ve about had enough of Facebook :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Jackie Oh

    I like that people can share photos at the click of a button. I think it’s nice that my cousins in Africa, Germany, England and Europe can see photos of my children growing up. Have we become THAT cynical a society that we can’t bear to be positive about our friends good fortune or offer sympathy/empathy in times of distress?? Aren’t there bigger crises in the world than not bearing to look at our friends happy snaps ! Sheesh !!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Mia

    Sometimes I tire of reading about people’s fabulous lives on Facebook. I don’t think I’m jealous (am I?), just exhausted by it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I agree! It exhausts me too! I think that a lot of people feel that they have to make their lives sound exciting every minute of the day when perhaps it’s not really. I know a few friends on Facebook who are quite the opposite in real life to what they present on Facebook. Perhaps as someone pointed out those that profess to having a wonderful, full life every minute of the day are trying to cover up their own inadequacies.
      I really look forward to the odd post by someone who isn’t on very often to the ones who regularly post.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Rod

        I’ve been deactivated from facebook for a little under 3 months now, so I don’t see the photos or read the stories. Its liberating. There is now something interesting to talk about when I finally catch up with people….and body language can’t hide unhappiness. Kind of reminds me of my parents who would regularly catch up with friends and they would all have a good time sharing what they have been up to. Now everyone knows everything the instant it is posted – now that’s boring!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  26. Tessy

    I am actually doing one of my final year art projects on this exact theme! I notice it a lot more with my younger sister and the kinds of photos her friends post – they are 16. But it’s very true, it’s what you’re not seeing in these photos that makes up everyday life.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      That’s a great idea for a project, Tessy. I read an article (escapes me where, sorry) which included an interview with a German school student. He described his status update as akin to getting dressed in the morning. He thought about the way he wanted to represent himself to his friends and (I suspect more urgently!) to girls he was keen on.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  27. AS

    I’m not on Facebook, haven’t been yet. I wonder how much I’m missing, but think maybe I’d be missing a lot of time.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. b

    I have the exact opposite with my friends on facebook – it’s a lot of talk about how hard it is with babies, how much they’ve vomited, how much they pooped, how tired they are and how those of us currently working don’t know how hard life is. Which I know is true and I’ll do whatever I can to help but there’s only so many times you can hear about what a nightmare having a baby is before it becomes a bit of a martyr act. I would much prefer your very cute potty picture to some of the potty training pictures I’ve seen….yeesh! ;0)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Petal

    We never went away when the kids were little. Couldn’t be bothered really. It was easier to stay at home and do day trips. I remember a friend went to Qld when her boys were 1 & 3 and I asked her how it went. She screwed her nose up and said Same shit, different shovel. I’ve always remembered that!

    I’m constantly telling my children to be careful what they post and that anything can come back to haunt them in years to come. Also, I’ve never thought people have idyllic lives from what they post. Of course people are only going to post good photos. Some people whinge of course, but that’s always a good giggle!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. As I posted on this site a few weeks back, I created the following social media pledge:

    I, John Anthony James, pledge that I will use social media to educate and inform, not complain and abuse. #socialmediapledge

    (Feel free to steal/reuse this :) )

    Two things have happened since then:

    – I’ve been tweeting less
    – (I think) My tweets are more interesting…

    Oh, and a third thing…I’ve found that I’ve stopped following people who broadcast content that seems to be the opposite of this pledge…this includes some very high profile and very funny tweeters…but I suddenly realised that they were tweeting crap…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Ballerina

    Yup, I deactivated Facebook because I got so over reading about “friends” who were “out on the family yacht this week”, “watching their daughter become state champion in …”,or whose husbands had “omg, just bought me a Tiffany bracelet and necklace set – because he loves me so much!”.
    I mean, good luck to them for having all of that wonderful stuff happen in their lives, but the more I read about it the more my reasoning brain forgot that it was only a snapshot of their lives…..and really, how narcissistic were they just to go on with all that crap every day!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • No narcissist

      Sorry but it’s a little mean to assume people are being narcissistic just because they post lovely pics of their family on Facebook! Perhaps they are just happy about their adventure and want to share it with their friends – or people they “thought” were their friends and would therefore be happy not disturbed to see them!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • ParisChic

        I agree with Ballerina but it’s more the way people constantly show off with locations or presents – posting pictures of themselves and their designer handbags for christmas with a status about how much their mum/dad/partner/sibling loves them to give them such an amazing present.
        They have the right to be excited and feel that way, but WHY is there the need to post such a specific status, even something like “Merry Christmas everyone – hope your presents are as great as mine” would be better IMO.
        For me when someone broadcasts presents with the brand/price it’s unnecessary and quite tacky. It also makes me think they must not be used to having nice things if they feel the need to show them off so much even though this is not always the case (some acquaintances on FB I know are very wealthy still do this).

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anon

          Maybe it’s more to do with who you accept as ‘friends’??!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • ParisChic

            True. I do go through and cull and also hide people from my feed because of it if I don’t feel I can delete them for some reason.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  32. Shannon

    I have a pretty small Facebook friends list, by comparison to my friends. I have about 80 people on Facebook: extended family, immediate family, best friends, close friends, work friends, and friends I see regularly at parties. I don’t have mere “acquaintances” so I’ve never really been struck by how picture-perfect other people’s lives seem to be, because I see all these people in real life and know that’s not the case.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Relish

      Ditto. Thanks! I too have very few Facebook friends as they are all my real life friends/people I like to stay in touch with. Nobody has a perfect life but I do like to share only the good stuff online as I’m scared my kids will read it later and misinterpret the sentiment.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. ANON FOR THIS

    I know a girl (22 years old), who edits her photos to ensure that her parents don’t find out that she’s been out partying.

    This same girl is overseas right now with her boyfriend of 3 months who her parents don’t know about and have never met. They have taken ridiculous measures to make sure that they (the parents) don’t find out they’re over there together so if you look at their social media pages, you would not even know that they are overseas let alone travelling together as a couple.

    I think it’s a little sad – how can they come back and not talk about this fabulous trip they are on together? i couldn’t enjoy myself 100% if I knew that I wasn’t being completely honest with the people I love. My parents are quite conservative but I would always tell them if i was planning a huge overseas trip with my boyfriend – they would be so disappointed if I did something like that.

    I’ve kind of rambled now, but i guess my point is – is it really worth all the hassle??

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Mug

    Haha I just laughed out loud. When you’re a Mum a holiday is a business trip. Everything has to be organised down to the smallest detail and every potential disaster must be anticipated before it happens. I’m glad I’m not the only one who finds holidays more trouble than there worth. There is always the saying though that a crap day on holidays is better than a good day at work. Re the editing of our lives: I use the billboard method for social networking. If I wouldn’t put it on a billboard it shouldn’t be on facebook – you never know who’s watching! Thanks for the laugh xox

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. MissV

    I don’t update or upload my facebook alot so i guess in a way you could say that i do edit but honestly i just can’t be bothered.
    I’m one of those people who don’t need to share every aspect of my life with everyone and i’m perfectly ok with that. I think the fact that i’m not competitive also helps with this.

    I also don’t feel the need to document every single thing that i do but for some people, it’s important to them and I would hope the majority aren’t doing it to make others feel shit about themselves.

    But i do know people on facebook who post every single thing they do. It’s frustrating at times because you know their life isn’t really like that but hey, if that’s the way they want to portray themselves then thats cool. I just hide them so they don’t appear in my feed and annoy me!

    xxxmissvxxx.wordpress.com

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Haven Maven

    I really try not to edit, I think. I look at Facebook as a way of communicating with a bunch of my people at once. That and that I have no filter sometimes…

    I’m wary of putting pics of my kids up too much. Mostly things like holidays, first days of school etc for rellies and friends far away to see. I do tend to take the piss out my myself a fair bit, and so am happy to share my monumental faux pas etc.

    Think for the most part I’m ‘what you see is what you get’.

    Thanks for the brilliant post, Kim.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks Haven Maven. You mean you wouldn’t publish a photo of your twins on the potty on a very popular website?! This article aside, I do sometimes wonder what the reaction of children to our posts is going to be when they’re a bit older. It’s a generation whose lives have been completely documented.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • gee jen

        How interesting to think about especially with the new timeline making it easy to go back (i think I’m too scared to change) I’d hate to think of my daughter looking back at me complaining about my lack of sleep….

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Haven Maven

        Oh Kim I loved the potty pic. I think more for the cute hats lol

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  37. Natski

    I have one friend who is so desperate for attention that she seems to document every minute detail of her life on Facebook. For quite some time her profile was public and she even admitted to me that she specifically left it as public so that people could look at her and see how good she looked. She had had a lap-band surgery and has lost a mountain of weight (to the extent that she looks sick now) and she wanted everyone in the universe to see how much she had changed. Now she has gotten a boyfriend there is a never ending stream of nauseating updates about her relationship.TMI girlfriend. I am at the point that I am about to ‘hide’ her.
    Facebook updates have become the new “getting your tits out at the pub”. Put it away, people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Lu

      I honestly dont understand why people leave their facebook profile public. Especially photos. I know some 10, 11 and 12 yo’s who have their entire profile public, including the name of the schools they attend. I think its actually quite neglectful on their parents part. If you’re going to allow your child onto those sorts of sights you have to monitor it closely and make sure they are aware of the risks. I mentioned it to one mum (whose daughter I really like) that not only were detailed aspects of her daughters social life documented publically, there were photos of her in a bikini and her school name. Free for the world to see. Mums reply was ‘oh well what can you do?’…….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • AJ

        I agree Lu, kids definately need to be educated re safety online. But 10, 11 & 12 year olds should not be on Facebook – I think the minimum age is supposed to be 13? My 12 yo has just started high school, and her school has been really good with educating the girls about being safe online – they have told the girls not to ever divulge their school or their parents details, & also have talked to them about not putting potentially suggestive photos (eg bikini shots etc) up. The school also ran a forum for parents about helping kids manage the internet, which I found really good.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Kim Kane

          I think internet safety is terrifying and it’s great to see schools dealing with it. It’s not what’s revealed in one post, but what’s revealed over an entire series of posts. A photo in front of the house in one, a reference to the “park at the end of the street” in another, a shot in front of a rubbish bin with the house number on it, a picture of kids walking in to school on the first day. It’s far too easy to piece information together when read as a whole — and if you go back and read a blog you do just that. I’m just completing a teen crime novel with a cyber component so I’ve been living all these horrible things for a few years now. Time to write a romance…

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  38. Holly

    Oh man, I can so relate to this post! I do edit my life to some degree on Facebook with the lovely ideallic photos I post but I also use it to vent my frustrations over my toddler’s behaviour, difficulties with toilet training, tantrums, sleep etc. I rarely see comments from my friends on Facebook being honest in the same manner though. They all make their lives and their families seem completely picture postcard perfect. The effect of this “editing” is to make me feel alienated from them and to wonder if they are being honest with any of their Facebook status updates. Either they are being dishonest or I am the only mum I know who has a monster for a two year old and am failing miserably at parenting! Either way, at least I know I am honest and hopefully that makes some of my friends feel like they’re not alone in this business of toddler taming :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Anonymous

    well I would like to know where you found your friends because I have a LOT of facebook friends who do nothing but whinge and complain!!
    I am more like you and your friends though, but my reasons are simple; I have always been a rather private person, and I have never liked to dwell on bad days.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. sydneyrose

    Hilarious Kim – I can remember when my kids were little, I felt like every conversation was about their ablutions – because that’s what I was dealing with every day! I don’t do Facebook – and I am in a high tech job and have every gadget know to humankind at work and home – its my decision to spend that time “interfacing” with the humans at home (and the cat!). Good luck with the potty training!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks Sydneyrose.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. Charlie's Mama

    LOL I love the way you write Kim… and I can totally relate to your story… I have a two year old girl and went to Tassie to see my mother a few times this year…and to Byron to see my father during which times any routine for sleep and food was ignored ;-) Feeling the “terrible 2′s” right now but being at home I have at least managed to set some sort of semi-regular sleeping patterns. In terms of things appearing to be perfect on my Facebook page… same deal, I don’t really take pics of me and my hubby having arguments or of me going bonkers over my toddler spreading graffiti on several walls of the house, pooing on the floor etc etc…. though it would make for some pretty funny posts lol

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks, Charlie’s Mama, that’s very kind.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  42. auscrawl

    I just felt comforted by you feeling free to say some days your place looks like it would make a calcutta slum looks good. My boys aren’t little, just single parenting and shift work is a trial.

    Facebook ppl who have loads of very posed holiday pics make me cringe, even worse is the obviously photoshopped images, a chat friend new gf has one like that and to me she looks smug and creepy.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • ParisChic

      Ahaha yes I know what you’re talking about. I went to Barcelona with a girl and she got me to take a photo of her in front of every attraction – Parc Güell, Sagrada familia, Dalí museum, Gaudí houses etc … I thought it was a bit off. Then she uploaded all of those photos into the album “Barcelona” on Facebook.
      On the other extreme it seems like people live their holiday through the lens when you see a four FB albums for a week’s holiday! Including 5 variations on the same shot. Come on people cull!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  43. Anonymous

    Sometimes I find myself feeling very envious of my Facebook friends when I look at their profiles. They look like they have such amazing lives. It occurred to me recently though that my own life looks pretty awesome too if you look at my Facebook profile and it’s because I only post the good photos and share the positive information. All the really bad stuff doesn’t go on there and it’s no doubt the same with my friends. I don’t think (most) people are trying to show off or make other people feel bad it’s just Facebook is not an appropriate forum for sharing details of the fight you just had with your husband or whatever. Also I don’t want to come across as being whiny or an attention seeker so I don’t put negative things on there.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Angela Mollard

    Kim,
    Your book: Pip, the Story Of Olive is fab. A fave in our house.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      Thanks Angela, that’s very lovely to hear.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  45. Just reading

    My husband and I have just separated, I’m devastated and yes some of it is spilling over onto Facebook. People’s comments when they find out, ‘oh but you always look so happy on Facebook’……….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • CM

      Grrr. I hate that people immediately assume your life is perfect cause you don’t whine about it 24hrs a day. I quit Facebook for that reason…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  46. Papaya

    I always say a picture doesn’t say a thousand words!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • meljb

      Oh, but it does say 1000 words. No one said those words had to be true ;)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Papaya

        haha smarty pants!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  47. Rose

    I don’t think people are ‘pretending’ to have amazing lives at all. it just so happens we don’t take photos or get photos taken of us with tears.. doing the chores.. having a break down.. etc

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • May!

      Good point Rose. If someone you knew didnt have facebook,but you were flicking through their photo album of holiday snaps and birthday parties you wouldn’t accuse them of “pretending” to have a perfect life…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  48. Anon

    Your article reminded me to deactivate my facebook page. Thanks.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • SitkaSpruce

      I take regular “breaks” from FB and always feel better afterwards. Usually they last a couple weeks… but I haven’t been on it for months this time, and I am a much less neurotic person for it. Don’t miss it at all right now. I have family and friends in the US, and I write to them now instead. Proper emails. Not an endless stream of super-witty status updates or extra-happy beach photos. It’s better this way, for me at least. Sometimes I think I would have been better off in the Victorian Era; In truth I prefer writing letters on paper, with an actual pen.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  49. Kate R

    I’m not on Facebook but I think this post raises a broader – and very interesting – question about what we present to the world of our lives. About authenticity.

    Some people will always resent evidence of your happiness and successes. Others will always feel uncomfortable to hear you talk about the hard times.

    Don’t be afraid to show and tell yours ups and your downs, I reckon. And if the people in your life are only interested in one side of the coin, then what’s the word? ‘Unfriend’ them, in reality as well as online!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rose

      soo spot on. I have been having a rough few years with illness and I have found in the past when I status updated about my hardships that the generic comments always followed… some positivity or quote crap.. all coming from those that wouldn’t know hardship if it bit them on the bum. I prefer to keep all my suffering private now because then I don’t have to put up with the majority who only like to see the positive!
      I’m not so sure why people are so uncomfortable with being exposed to suffering. . .

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kate R

        It’s SO hard not to offer advice/positivity when someone opens up to you about their struggles. I feel like I am being uncaring if I ‘just’ listen.

        And yet, I often resent getting advice from people when I tell them I am having a hard time of this or that!

        We humans are a strange bunch, to be sure.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • SitkaSpruce

        Interestingly they did a study recently and found that people who left “less than positive” status updates regularly on Facebook, tended to be de-friended much more often than those that didn’t. Says a lot about the medium I think… Facebook does not reflect reality, and people that are too honest are not welcome.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Kate R

          Do people mainly use it to celebrate, perhaps? To share photos of happy events and news, rather than as a reflection of their life as a whole?

          Can you be authentic on Facebook or is it just not geared to that?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • Kim Kane

      Thanks Kate.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  50. saymynamesaymyname

    Like someone said below, why post about the distressing times?

    Why not post about the fun times, show photos of that – who wants to be reminded constantly of the drudgery and dreariness of real-life? Holiday photos are just that – photos of your holiday. To share them is to share good times – sure, even on holidays things are normal like at home, kids fighting, whining and more but why show that when you can show beauty and love.

    Don’t get me wrong, I am a photographer and I have been known to post not so flattering images of my family online however, I would much prefer to remember/share the fun times than the sad times. I am not pretending that everything is hunky dory in our lives. I am just sharing the best parts and keeping the crap where it belongs!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • odette

      Now I have your screen name stuck in my head.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • saymynamesaymyname

        the song? I love it!

        Say my name, say my name. You know I really love you….lol

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • liliesandroses

      lol I was reading this thinking “yeah, fab response, I like the sound of this lady” and then realised who it was (ie someone I’m already friends with!) Go K8 :-) Well said x

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • saymynamesaymyname

        ba ha ha – it was meant to be anonymous – then I saw that it had my avatar there. Ooops!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions