by CARLY FINDLAY
Carly has a lifelong genetic chronic illness called ichthyosis form erythroderma (which means scaly red skin). Her skin gets itchy and sore, she gets infection easily which sometimes result in hospital stays where she is bandaged up like a mummy. You can read more about her story here.
I had the worst end to the best day. It was spent with friends having 2 pm breakfast, wine and lots of laughs. Fantastic company, lots of fun.
I headed home on the train about 6.30. I put my headphones on and noticed a group of four teenagers staring at me. My music was on softly so I could hear them say how red I look, and laughing about my appearance.
The ones who could see me pointed me out to the ones who were facing away from me. For them to get a better view, two of them took photos of me on their iPhones and showed them to the others. The angles they held their phones at made it pretty obvious they were photographing me. They continued to take photos of me, and when I stood up to exit the train, there was a mad scramble to put their phones down.
I rarely confront someone if they aren’t directly speaking to me about my appearance. Today I did.
When I reached the door, I said ‘hey guys, could you please stop taking photos of me and showing them around. It’s disrespectful’. Of course they denied it, muttering how stupid I am to say that. I said ‘I may be red but I’m not stupid. I could see what you were doing’. Smirks continued. I said something else about them not understanding or respecting disability, and mentioned that my appearance has got me a role on TV. I was shaking, and even almost an hour later, I am still shaking.
Then, for the kindness of strangers, a man who sat opposite the kids took out his headphones and gave them a serve, telling them to stop harassing me and that he’d take them all on. It was quite a hallelujah moment for me. He really did improve the situation.
It’s rare that strangers come to my aid when others stare, point and harass me. I thank this man so much for doing so. He’s a really good person for doing so.
I doubt these kids will even reflect on what they’ve done and I’ve said. They’re probably laughing about the crazy red girl who told them off in the train, and comparing pictures of me with their other small minded mates.
I was speaking to someone yesterday about the hot weather, and how I hate it. She sympathised with me. I said that the weather is physically difficult for my skin, but the thing that is often worse is peoples’ reactions and assumptions about it. Times like today I feel like a freakshow. Like the silverchair video. But without the botox or Daniel Johns.
I know I’m not a freak. But I am someone whose appearance is ridiculed on a regular basis.
I do know, however, that I am courageous, smart, positive, and beautiful enough to rise above their shit. I also have enough self worth not to carry this day with me for the rest of my life, and remember that the peoples’ opinions about me that really matter are those who love me for who I am.
Carly recently appeared in Mamamia’s Wardrobe Week – take a look:

Carly Findlay: I wear this on Sundays when I go to the farmers market and hanging around the house. The tee is from a Bob Evans concert, the cords are Just Jeans circa 2003 - they are just so comfy and don't scrape my legs like jeans can – shoes are Converse and headband is Mimco.
Carly Findlay is a 20 something Melbourne woman working full time as an events planner/writer and a freelance writer on the side. You can follow her on twitter here or read her blog here.
When was the last time you stood up for someone? Has anyone ever stood up for you?







Comments
85 Comments so far
You completed certain nice points there. I did a search on the issue and found nearly all persons will consent with your blog. store cheaper Cheap Diablo 3 Gold
loading...
Carly,
I cant imagine what you must go through each day, you should stand up for yourself and so should others.
People with closed minds, should have closed mouths.
loading...
Carly, you are such a beautiful woman inside and out! Your smile is to die for! I ALWAYS read your posts because they’re both clever and entertaining and you always write from the heart and to the point so that it’s never long-winded. Do not let a bunch of pre-pubescent teenagers get to you – so not worth it with that attitude… you should feel sorry for them as they’ll never reeally get that far in the world. Big love and remember you’re f#cking fabulous! don’t let anyone tell you otherwise! X
loading...
You’re fantastic.
loading...
You know I would kick their pimply butts for you? xx
loading...
The woman with the cosmetically enhanced booty is a freak. You, dear, are beautiful.
loading...
Very touching, thank you for sharing.
loading...
I thought teenaged boys were idiots when I was a teenager and dread the day my son becomes one.
They probably won’t realise just how shameful their behaviour was for another 10 years.
I’m glad you stood up for yourself.
I’m glad you were also on the receiving end of some good behaviour too.
loading...
Carly can I please have your wardrobe?
loading...
Carly I love reading your blog (came to it through the lovely Faux Fuschia) and I just feel gutted you were treated this way. You are so funny and intelligent and look terrific. It is exhausting having to be brave and courageous all the time and you shouldn’t have to fight for the right to be treated respectfully. I’d like to think we would all be like the man who did the right thing but I am not so sure. I hope you are never humiliated like this again.
loading...
Carly, i tend to think that even if those kids didn’t seem to be sorry for their cowardly actions at the time, that somewhere along the line they actually will. It will probably change the way they act in the future too. Maybe not immediately and maybe not all of them, but I think it will affect some of them.
loading...
Carly 1. Arsehat schoolboys 0.
You rock.
xxxxx
loading...
Hey Carly. You have become one of my standby-brave wonderful people to think about when I feel like letting other people’s stupidity or my own fear stop me from doing something. Please never stop being funny, brave and out there with your style and talent.
People really are idiots. If those kids aren’t ashamed of themselves, I pity the life they might end up leading.
loading...
Carly im so sorry you had to go through that. Fuck I’d have tears streaming down I just know. You’re brave and beautiful and I really admire you xx
loading...
Carly, I follow you on Twitter where how you look has nothing to do with how hiliarious your tweets are!
I hope that one day these kids do reflect on their actions- I know I remember saying something stupid and thoughtless and being called on it once. In hindsight, I’m glad that someone pulled me up on it- I learnt the lesson that you never know who is listening and having their feeling hurt and now I think before I speak.
loading...
Carly you freaking rock!! That is all.
loading...
Carly, you have many awesome gifts, including the ability to write, put clothes together AND find it in your heart to put fuckwittage into perspective. Go you xxxx
loading...
Wow, just wow. You are amazing xxx
loading...
I hope one day they tell that story to their own children as a tale of when they were being complete arses. xxx
loading...
Hi Carly – sorry to hear about this. No one deserves to ever feel ridiculed. You mention you dont like hot weather, do u need to always wear long sleeves? My business is sun safe clothing. I’ve put my email address here, drop me a line, and I’ll send you a shirt, if you need to keep the sun off your skin? All the best xx
loading...
I have to stand up for my kids quite often. When my baby had a nasal gastric tube put in I had so many people ask questions and quite rudely. Brushing them off didn’t work they wanted to know why she had it and what we were Doing about it. Since when do strangers feel they have the right to make others uncomfortable?
loading...
But don’t they know you are a rock star? You are one of mine. I think you are AWESOME up there with michelle bridges xxxooo
loading...
There some really shit people in this world and on that day you met some. What makes you exceptional is that you stand up and keep going. I love you and how you don’t get down the chain of self pity which affects so many by shit people.
Keep going girly no matter what you look like!
loading...
Carly, I think you should give your parents a big hug and thank them for building your reslience, courage and assertiveness. They obviously did a great job in raising you!
Most people would have suffered in silence and let incidents like that rip apart their self-esteem.
loading...
I am so glad you spoke up. Reading your post has inspired me with your strength and courage, thank you. I hope I will have the courage to always speak up.
loading...
You know what Carly, I think you’re a bloody strong woman to stand up to that sort of attitude every day- and even more so because you stood up directly to them! That shows true strength of character.
Such pathetic, small minded and ignorant behaviour. It’s easy for me to say don’t take it to heart but as much as you can… don’t
what is that saying? The people who matter don’t mind, and the people who mind don’t matter.
I think you’re supercalafragalistically fabulous with SUCH an innate and creative sense of style. Also- I am envious of your curls. JUST SAYIN!
have a divine weekend MMers. x
loading...
As the mother of a child with a disability, albeit an often invisible one (autism), I feel for you. I once saw some teens laughing about & imitating a young man with Down syndrome and was outraged. I now wish I’d confronted them, but society has taught women not to be confrontational. I wanted to say to them: ‘It’s just the throw of the genetic dice – it could have just as easily been you,’ Unfortunately most people are so lacking in imagination they fail to see this. Next time, for you, Carly, I will speak up. xx
loading...
As I catch the train home and I live in a very dodgy area, I often come across situations like this.I am tiny and only 20, but I always stand up and tell teenagers when they’re being morons. I think it is very embarrassing for them to be told off by a girl. I would stand up for those who deserve it – I once saw a group of boys throw food at a severely disabled man, I was so disgusted that I yelled at them and they got off the train (not before the yelled some obscenities at me though), and the man came up to me and grabbed my hand with tears in his eyes and said thank you. I cannot imagine how he would have felt if everyone had just ignored it
loading...
Carly, you are one amazing woman! That is all.
loading...
My 5 year old boy has erythrokeratadermia variabilis and I had an incident when he was 2 and I was heavily pregnant with my 2nd when a woman told me how unhappy he was (we were eating lunch. After a Wiggles concert ….) and I needed to get my head out of the clouds that he was normal. And how silly I was bringing more children into the world. She actually pointed to children in the playpark and said ‘THEY are happy children’. I was so naive that these people existed!
This absolutely floored me and I ended up having counselling because I thought “I don’t know how to deal with this or teach him to either”!
I wish I had the guts to have put her in her place or thrown my burger at her, but I left and sat in my car and bawled!
He’s lucky that there’s hardly a mark on him now with the right, constant medication and creams. We call them his spots when they do appear. And he is a VERY happy, well adjusted boy.
Stay positive Carly. You are an amazing woman and good on you for saying something xx
loading...
OMG what is wrong with people. It’s easy to forget that arseholes seem to still exist while surrounded by good folk. Glad your son’s treatment is working, and that he’s able to live without the strain of dealing with ‘those people’
loading...
Thank you for having me Mamamia and thank you to everyone for your lovely comments. It can be hard to handle difficult situations in a positive way all the time but I do my best.
loading...
I am so glad you spoke up for yourself with those young people.Sometimes a few words can be enough to make someone go home and think about their actions and hopefully they wont be hurtful like that to anyone again..
I love reading everything you write Carly.You never feel sorry for yourself and always inspire me to be a better more grateful person.Your positive attitude is so uplifting.I hope you feel so very proud of all the good that comes from your posts as you help many people with and without disabilities.xx
loading...
Some people are just arseholes. Good on you Carly for putting them in their place. I hope they felt ashamed.
My son is 12 and his best friend has an autistic brother who is a year older than them. Last year they were at the park on their scooters, filming each other on my son’s iPod touch. Some bullies from their school came along and started picking on the autistic boy, then they took my boy’s iPod and were filming themselves taunting the autistic boy. Not content with that the ring leader started to beat him up while the others filmed it. My son stood up to them and yelled out to an older boy walking passed for help. The older boy sorted them out and got the iPod back. None of the boys told us about this. That night my husban was checking the search history (he always does) and came across the footage. We were horrified but so proud that our son stood by his friend and tried to protect him. When the bullies’ parents were contacted about it thy denied it and said it was our boys picking on them. Best thing was we had footage of it all!
loading...
That is such a great story. You must be so proud of your son. Sometimes modern technology is used for good, not evil!
loading...
I have a friend who has a disability that often causes people to stop and have a second look, and she has sometimes had people whipping out thier phones and filming or taking a photo. She has started doing the same to them – if they take her pic, she does it back. I know two wrongs don’t make a right, but I think it’s helped my friend ‘deal with it’ and hopefully make them think twice… good on you for talking to the teens and standing up to them, you’re very brave!
loading...
I think that’s quite a good comeback, treat others as you wish to be treated.
loading...
What have we become!? Photographing people with disabilities because . . . Isn’t it astounding to learn that there are such people out there? We have a long way to go people. A very long way. Your poor friend. Good on her for finding some way to cope
loading...
Young people, particularly when they are in a group, can be so cruel. I know, because when I was 13 my friends and I sat around the front of a shopping centre and pointed and laughed at every overweight person we saw. Huge joke. Until one lady heard us laughing at her, and started crying. Her husband rushed over to us and gave us a bollocking – he was so mad, and called us a pack of little bitches. Our jaws hit the floor.
I never did anything like that again – and I’ve never forgotten it either. Now that I”ve grown up, I myself am an overweight Mum of three and every time I see a group of teenage girls I feel a embarrassed at my size and know what some of them are thinking. I’m just lucky no one has ever pointed at me and laughed (or that I’ve heard).
My point of this comment is to say that the behaviour of kids when they are with their friends can be at the absolute bottom of the barrel, and they do and say things they wouldn’t have the guts or cleverness to do on their own. So to you, Carly, I am so sorry you were humiliated on the train ride home. I am glad that man stood up for you, and I hope those boys go home and feel ashamed of themselves. I reckon they will. Keep on living your life – you are amazing and special.
loading...
I admire your honesty.
loading...
Carly you are so awesome just FYI!
I stand up for people (and myself) a lot. I used to get in trouble when I was younger for being assertive but I love that I have grown into a strong, independent and unafraid woman.
loading...
Carly, you are absolutely gorgeous! That is all
loading...
Hi Carly.
What a wonderfully written piece. I must admit that as soon as I saw your name and photo in the mamamia newsletter I knew I had to read your article. I live in Albury and I know that in your younger years when you worked in K-Mart you were often the staff member that I would be “served by” for want of a better word. Actually, I am sure I recently read an interview with you in The Border Mail. I have to say that I love your style in fashion and your writing. The last paragraph in your piece sums it all up. You are courageous, smart, positive and beautiful. Without a doubt! Linda x
loading...
I can’t remember the last time but i remember the first time. I was 6 years old it was 1981 and my asian mother was picking up her parents from Adelaide airport. An adult male walked right past my grandparents and Mum pulling at his eyes to make chinese eyes and doing the buck teeth thing. They didnt appear to notice. Eventually he looked down at me and there was a seemingly asian girl but my dad is aussie giving him the finger defiantly! Needless to say he stopped! I thank my Dad for teaching me that gesture.
loading...
Great article Carly.
I experienced a similar thing the other day (from the man’s perspective) – only unlike him, I said nothing because I am a coward. Three irritating teenagers/young men were being really raucous and irritating, but in a nonharmful way. Then they noticed an older Asian couple sitting near them and started yelling “ching chon, hong fong” blah blah – in an extremely intellegent impersonation of the couple. The couple just kept their eyes down and didn’t say anything. My blood was boiling and I opened my mouth to tell them off – but then I remembered it was very dark and late, and I had to walk home by myself from the train station under a bridge, and I just shut up. I would have felt stupid if I’d spoke up and they’d followed me off the train and hurt me – but I also feel bad I didn’t do anything. Tough balance.
loading...
You’re not a coward! You’ve gotta think of you’re own safely too.
Sure it’s a tough balance but some of these people that carry on this way are just as likely to ‘attack’ you if you open your mouth. Good decision I reckon
loading...
Mmm… while I understand that your safety comes first, I know what it’s like to be a victim of racism and all I can imagine is how that elderly couple felt while they were being picked on. I’m 100% not saying that you didn’t do the right thing because you probably did given the circumstances (I wasn’t there so I don’t know). I just feel like I should give my 2 cents about this because it rings close to home for me.
I’m only half Asian so I don’t get the whole stick of it, but I know my poor mother (who, by the way is very westernised!) gets a lot of it from dickheads like that.
Personally I would stand up for a defenceless old couple like that based purely on the fact that I would be SO angry because I know what it’s like.
It’s unfortunate that this is even true, but I think white people underestimate the amount of power they have when standing up for others especially when they’re standing up for people of a different race that are getting bullied.
loading...
An old man with a severely hunched back was doing his shopping at my local supermarket when a group of teenagers starting laughing, pointing and making fun of him. I got out of my car and gave them a very loud and passionate piece of my mind. I cannot stand people making fun of someone over something they cannot help and I will not turn a blind eye to such behaviour. Carly, I’m sorry you had the misfortune to be sitting near people who haven’t yet learned how to conduct their lives in a positive, caring and meaningful way. That is their problem to figure out and their lives are all the poorer until they do. Keep smiling – and keep enjoying those 2pm breakfasts!
loading...
Oh Anna, you sound just like me!
I was once at the cinema with my boyfriend (years ago, we were really young) and there were kids there throwing popcorn at a disabled kid sitting further down.
My boyfriend stood up and blasted each of the bullies, and they quickly shut up. That’s how I knew he was a keeper
loading...
Oh I do love a kind, brave man!! Nothing beats them!
loading...
“I do know, however, that I am courageous, smart, positive, and beautiful enough to rise above their shit.”
This, a million times over Carly. You truly are all these things and more. xxxx
loading...
Carly you have the most amazing style and the bestest choice in little dresses!!!!
loading...
Carly, I remember hearing about your story on Triple J’s Hack program a few months ago and after this, had a new found respect for your condition. You are a strong woman and a talented writer with so many great and wonderful things to come! You should be very proud of your achievements, but also your courage. Good on you for standing up to those kids!
loading...
Carly, I will always depend on the humanity of people like the gentleman who stood up for you to remind me that all is not lost with the world. I have read your blog for ages and think you have a wonderful spirit – I am so sorry for those fools on the train, but it says more about their own lives. How sad and petty and miserable. You are a trillion times better than them. xxxx
loading...
Carly you are beautiful inside and out. You are an example of what I would like my daughters to see as a strong woman and have far more to offer the world than the likes of the Kardasians etc. Great work standing up to those thoughtless brats who need to be taught some manners.
loading...
I have a sister who has a disability who was raised by our parents to believe that she’s ‘different’. They would never tell anyone off who pointed and stared at her but would blush and pretend it wasn’t happening.
Good for you Carly and good for your parents who I’m sure raised you to be brave and courageous and not to let other’s ignorance stop you from leading a useful, happy and productive life.
loading...
Carly, you have guts. Train guy had guts. I am so happy to hear that people like you and him still exist in this world.
Teenagers tend not to see cause-and-effect and can be ego-centric (not so much a criticism as it is a part of natural adolescent brain development). They might not have even thought about what they did, but maybe because you and train guy spoke up, they will remember that in years to come.
loading...
Good on you for saying the things you did. It was really restrained and mature. I would have screamed like I was batshit crazy and swung my handbag at them, which would have not had any impact. I’m sure you made them feel very ashamed of themselves.
loading...
I think you are awesome, so pleased when I hear people taking a stand against bullies (teenagers on public transport seem to think it’s a supermarket for mockery). I’ve meet you a couple of times at gigs and I thought you a most interesting person, now I add a leader to that
loading...
Carly the thing that stood out for me in your piece is not just that a kind stranger stood up for you (which was lovely) but that you stood up for you. As an auntie of 3 beautiful girls (& a gorgeous nephew) if there’s one thing I can pass on to them it’s that we should never let anyone mistreat us. We should always speak up & tell someone when they are doing something to us that we don’t like. But in saying that, it’s often an extremely hard thing to do. I was bullied at work. I never really spoke up – I just left. I’ve had relationships where I wasn’t treated well – I put up with it for too long. So it’s incredibly brave that you did what you did and told someone you didn’t like what they were doing and to stop it. There’s such a great lesson in that for all of us. As difficult as it must have been for you, you should be so proud of yourself. I’m going to make sure my nieces read this story – for two reasons. So they can see how mistreating someone makes them feel and so they can see how hard it can be sometimes to stand up for yourself – but how important it is to do so. Meaghan
loading...