by TAMSIN MARSHALL
Since having my daughter I have become something I never thought I would, something that I have always proudly protested against – a proficient liar. So easily do these little white lies slip off my tongue that I’m almost afraid that I’m not going to know when to stop. But clearly that day will come. That day when my daughter no longer takes what I say verbatim and questions everything. And yes, I’m sure, that day will come much faster than I’d like.
Now, I wouldn’t normally admit to this but I have a sneaking suspicion that I’m not the only one. Lying as a mother is a necessary evil. Sometimes, I like to think of it as ‘the creative truth’. I’m sure I’m going to get a barrage of negative feedback but first hear me out. Because what I end up lying about, is pretty silly really. But to a 2-nearly-3-year-old, it’s the damn truth.
Like the time I told my daughter that all the sweets, chocolates and lollies in the bright, sparkly wrapping paper lining the checkout aisle was “yucky and makes our tummy hurt”. How I smiled smugly the next time we were at the supermarket and she pointed at them and said, “yucky”. Don’t get me wrong – she knows what chocolates are, she loves chocolate and sweets, but she doesn’t recognise the packets, and that my friends is the greatest secret.
Or when I’m trying to get her to sit further away from the giant TV screen that dominates our lounge, “your eyes will go square”, I tell her ominously and she shuffles her bum back. She hasn’t yet thought to question the reality of this.
I tell her that blueberries, strawberries and any other fruit we have in the house are “nature’s lollies and a treat”, she loves nothing more than to be served up a delicious fruit platter. I’ve discovered that it’s not what’s on the plate but how I describe it that gets her wanting it. Yes, she’s still young enough to fall for this (although this really is coming to an end as tonight she wanted “a treat, not dinner”), but yes she also genuinely loves fruit. She also loves olives and cheese platters, but that might be more about being ‘with the girlfriends’.
Of course the biggest, most continual fib running in our house at present is the threat of Santa hearing if she’s naughty – if she’s misbehaving I merely have to say, “Santa” with my head tilted towards the window and she stops fast in her tracks. She’s a good kid at heart and doesn’t like to be naughty and she certainly doesn’t want to miss out on her presents. A good friend of mine told her kids that Blackbirds were Santa’s spies and told Santa if little children were being good or bad. She fortunately had a couple of Blackbirds in her garden.
There have also been a couple of times when these little white lies have completely backfired. Like the frustrating time when Coco wouldn’t get out of the bath, she’d just splash and kick and play so I’d walk out and then she’d call me back in saying she wanted to get out, only to splash and play some more. After a few times of this, I pulled the plug and said, “don’t go down the drain!” in a joking manner, to which she SCREAMED and leapt out.
After that she refused to get into the bath for days, like actually nearly two weeks. It was that bad. I was wracked with guilt. I had to get in the bath with her and demonstrate that it was safe. We LIED and told her we had got rid of the drain… no more drains we told her, while dangling her kicking and screaming over the water. I took it slowly and calmly. I told her I understood why she was scared, I told her that Mummy was being silly, that she can’t go down the drain. I had to say this many times over. I told her it was covered up and she was too big. She stood with her little eyes wide and I held onto her while she gently eased her bum down. It helped that there was nearly a bottle of bubble bath concealing most parts of the bath and all parts of the drain. Thank god, she’s no longer scared of drains. And now of course she loves her bath just as much as ever.
I tell her I don’t have any money on me (even if I do) when she insists on yet another ride in another freakin car in the mall. I’ve told her that the ice cream shop has run out and we’ll have to back another day, I might say things are broken or closed if I’m trying to avoid doing something that she is stubbornly insisting on.
I guess I mostly lie when it comes to the daily battles with routine and/or food. Tonight was a great example and I don’t know where I pulled it from. She adores my friend Sarah and her girls, loves them, looks up to them. When she refused to have dinner, shaking her cute little pig tails and running away from me, I told her that Sarah had made exactly the same dinner for her friends Mia and Taylor at their house and they were eating it all up. She sat down and started to eat. It made me think about all the lies I find myself saying to help me get through the day. It’s exhausting.
Of course what I don’t lie to her about is how much I love her, how clever she is, how smart, how cute, how funny. I encourage her to try new things, dance, paint, sing to me, count with me, spell her name (which she can do) and all these funny tricks. She’s so freaking clever this kid that one day she is going to see right through my little white lies and I’m going to be completely and utterly screwed.
Tamsin works at Triumph International New Zealand when she’s not running around after her bossy daughter. She blogs here and here and you can follow her on Twitter @beautygoss
What little secret lies do you tell your kids? What lies did your parents tell you?







Comments
183 Comments so far
I get away with a lot of ” not today”, ” just with daddy” and ” what will nana say if… ( you are not dressed/have dirty hands/dirty clothes/etc). But the biggie here is that Santa visits around Christmas ( you see him in the shops etc) but i never say he is comming to our house, or bringing pressies, the idea freaks me out ( weird old men breaking in at night and leaving gifts but not saying hello)? It sounds crazy to me and always has! It gets awkward when people start asking ” what’s Santa bringing you” but kids get something from a Santa at done stage in dec so I just make out that’s what they are talking about, I don’t bang on about it, and I would never bribe with it.
I was a very suspicious child, and a worrier, and I think my kids are the same, so for me this feels comfortable.
loading...
We told our son that the ice cream van was the broccoli van…
loading...
My mum told me that the rides at the shop only worked when my grandmother put the coins in. Sneaky…
loading...
Ahhhh I love this. I have told every single one of those lies to my 2.5 year old too. It’s how we survive!
loading...
Hey!!I
loading...
Not like I need anymore ideas for posts (still have too many drafts that are not yet completed), but this is nonetheless and awesome post and a great resource for any blogger.I wish I would have thought of this idea
loading...
I’m sorry but I don’t lie to my kids or rather, I try really hard not to and never would intentionally. Nothing wrong with instead just saying no, explaining the real reason or even saying ‘that is not for you to know right now’ rather than telling a lie to a hard adult question – or a hundred other parenting strategies better than lying. sorry but i want my kids to trust me and i dont think all thse ‘fibs’ are doing much to build that trust/
loading...
Does telling my macho grandap its an ‘egg pie’ rather than a quiche count? lol
loading...
I think kids copy the behaviour of parents. If we lie to them, that’s how they learn to lie. I’m reading a book Why We Lie by Dorothy Rowe, full of neuroscience and stories such as … Jenni heard dad use the word “bloody” so she unwittingly used that word …. mum punished her that Jenni had to sit on the bottom step for hours. Jenni sneaked upstairs and from behind the half-closed bedroom door made a horrible face at her vacuuming mum who, with back to the door, could not have seen her ….. mum stormed over to Jenni and [I omit smacks and verbal abuse from the story] told Jenni that “mummies can see every little thing their children do whether they’re with them or not”. It can take awkward decades until the kid realises that a bedroom has a mirror and that was not true.
I also recall a mamamia discussion that anyone who lies a lot, as Keli Lane did, deserves jail, even if she might one day turn out to be innocent of murder. This discussion in which so many say they lie makes me more tolerant of Keli lying.
My life had similarities to Jenni. Aged about 7, I was innocently washing my private parts in the bath. Mum saw me and told me never ever to touch my private parts in any way ever, or the most dreadful things would happen to me. This led to an operation for a pilo-nidal fistula (you don’t want to know) over 10 years later and my very unusual thwarted adolescence.
But I have to admit – I agree with the lie about the monster in the dam.
Some lies can be very destructive and others protective. I think you have to choose carefully.
loading...
All the self-righteous, condescending people criticising these little white lies are welcome to take my toddler and pre-schooler to the supermarket. Good luck reasoning with them in the lolly aisle – THEY WILL HOWL YOU DOWN.
You can say no as many times as you like – I do a thousand times a day. Sometimes the lie avoids the arguments and heartache, that’s why I do it. When they are old enough to fully understand the message and control their response to it I will explain the truth. While they are still capable of tantrums, public screaming and confused frustration, I will tell fibs that make life easier for all of us.
loading...
yes yes yes!
agree 100%
loading...
There are parenting strategies in existence other than just ‘reasoning’ or just ‘lies’ …
loading...
I’m sure I’ve told white lies over the last 25 years, as well as the Santa, Easter bunny, tooth fairy lies.
Generally though, I tell them the truth. If I’m going to include no in the answer I often include only a short explanation/ or none. I don’t want to feel like I’m having to justify my decisions to my kids and the longer you talk, the less they listen.
loading...
The lie I tell children most often is about a mythical creature in my family called ‘gazeekas’.
They live wherever we don’t want little ones to wander – around the sides of houses etc.
They eat children but are terrified of adults so they would never come near an adult (“that’s why it’s so important to stay where we can see you!”).
We’re very vague on the details. Questions like ‘what do they look like?’ are generally met with shudders and “You’ve never seen a gazeeka??? Oh you’re lucky you don’t know what it looks like – it’s horrible!”.
It’s acted up so much that they’re sure we’re pulling their legs – but they’re just not sure enough to risk it!
loading...
I am a prolific liar to children. Usually it’s about food. My son hates gravy but he’s pretty keen on ‘brown sauce’ I whip up especially for him although the rest of us are having gravy that looks EXACTLY the same. My nephew despises chips (can you believe that?) but he is quite accustomed to the ‘potato medallions’ I make him. And so on. I don’t mind these little fibs because it just helps them try food they ‘think’ they hate.
Ironically, hoensty is actually our household priority (hypocrite you say!!). My rule is that you won’t get into trouble for telling the truth- I might be disappointed in what you have done and we will probably have to talk about it but you will NOT be punished for telling the truth. Well, this backfired when my son was 7. He very seriously approached me one day and said “I’m going to ask you something important and I need you to tell me the truth- you won’t be in trouble if you just tell me the truth”. Obviously, I was intrigued so I told him to ask me whatever he wants.
He says “Is Santa real?”
Bugger, dammit, shit.
That was the day he found out that no, Santa is not real. Clever bugger.
loading...
These are all making my laugh so much! I recognise some of them my parents used on me- eg saying the park was shut when I wanted to play there at night
I never watched TV when I was younger (it made me have seizures) and my parents would always say ‘oh the tv’s broken.’ Every time. That worked for a while, until we started figuring out how to reconnect it…
When I was about 11 my godfather went to jail, and I always asked why I never got presents for my bday from him and my sister did. My mum’s response was always “he’s travelling darling” I kind of understand why she would say that, but i think i could have handled the truth at that age
loading...
My great uncle was missing the tip of his finger and when I was small he would tell me it was because he picked his nose and it fell off. I think I was a serial nose picker as a child… Then my Brownie instructor was missing the tip of her finger as well, so I always secretly thought it was because she picked her nose too.
loading...
When my children were young their great uncle LOVED buying them the noisiest toys around (he had no kids of his own). And of course said noisy toys became the most beloved in the house. Until the batteries run out. Those batteries that we, apparently, can’t find ANYWHERE in the correct size to replace
loading...
I think, having read some of the responses, that I can pinpoint what it is that bothers me. It’s the evasion of responsibility. If you lie to your kids, it’s because you don’t want to be the bad guy who says “no” – you defer responsibility for that unpleasant decision to someone else – Santa, a wicked witch, the police, Mr Whippy.
Instead of having the confidence to say to your kids, “No, you can’t have a lolly” you say, “The people at the shops don’t have any more lollies” and you are putting the onus of “no” onto someone else. It’s the same as the old fashioned “wait til your father gets home.”
I don’t understand why there *needs* to be an excuse. If you are the parent and you say no, then surely that should be enough? You should have enough confidence in your authority as a parent to not have to rely on a scary bogeyman to get your kids to accept and respect your decision.
Otherwise, when they get a bit older and wiser and stop believing your lies, what do you have left?
loading...
Sometimes there are so many “nos” in the day thta a lie now and then just makes things easier. I really don’t think there is any harm in that.
loading...
You don’t have anything left. That’s why you enjoy it while it lasts. SO WHAT!
loading...
But if you put in the hard yards early – toddlerhood and preschool years – then you have set down some great groundwork so that your kids respond to YOUR decisions and respect YOUR authority rather than only obeying you because of an imaginary bogeyman. Surely it’s worth the effort?
loading...
you’re welcome to take my 3 year old for a week and after the CONSTANT cacophany of why’s, whining, questions etc, you might be tempted to slip in a few white lies too.
Look, you’re probably right. But the fact that I tell my child white lies doesn’t make me a bad parent, nor am I being irresponsible or lazy. Heck, I’m the least lazy person I know. But I pick my battles. Yes, sometimes I go into a long winded explanation about why lollies are sometimes foods and bad for your teeth etc etc and yes my 3 year old knows all these things.
But some days, when I’m spent…all my energy has gone into getting 2 monkeys/girls dressed, into the car, into the shops, I’ve already dealt with 2 separate tantrums, I’m having to carry the baby who refuses to sit in the trolley (despite MY insistence lol), pushing a heavy load of food to make balanced meals, and my 3 year old who is tired, has low blood sugar and NO tolerance for listening to a well meaning lecture about the evils of sugar, asks for a lolly, I will tell a small white lie. And will continue to do so, regardless of how many judgy mcjudgersons question my parental efforts.
And sometimes, we don’t need our children to know the truth…why can’t we go to the park mummy? Um, because I’m tired and premenstrual and I’D RATHER SHOOT MYSELF IN THE HEAD than spend the afternoon pushing the damn swing and helping you on the slide and chasing after your baby sister who thinks that rocks make a good food, not to mention the palava of getting ready..sunscreen, hats, shoes…gah! Sorry darling, the park is closed, lets do some craft instead
loading...
I have 12 and 9 year olds that respond to and respect my decisions now. They didn’t when they were 2, nor did I expect them to.
loading...
Ahhh confidence. Nailed it.
Most of these anecdotes are pretty funny. Plenty to pilfer! But then, there’s some normalising of regular and completely unnecessary…. lying.
What I don’t understand is how we expect our loved ones to trust us, if we lie to them. Well beyond toddler-hood. Because it’s easier.
loading...
I was thinking the same. It’s easier to educate and influence a kid when they’re still little and trust you implicitly. I imagine trying to sort it all out when their older would be even more difficult when the kid realizes that they can’t always trust you to be truthful.
loading...
And I think opportunities for Education are lost – telling a child from a young age that eating lots of lollies doesn’t leave room for food that makes you big & strong marks the beginning of an important lesson counteracting the very insidious control advertisers have over our children.
loading...
Another really good point that I hadn’t been able to quite articulate, Lynne.
loading...
Trixie Melodian, get over yourself. It is a light hearted piece about the little white lies we have ALL as parents told at some point. Get off your high horse and take it in the spirit it is intended instead of being so bloody critical.
loading...
I agree! It is just taking the easy way out! Just say no! Your kids should learn to respect that no means no and not need to be deterred by endless lies..
loading...
Or explanations. As kids get older, they tune out your explanations anyway.
loading...
My step-daughter has an exhausting supply of foods she won’t eat, including mushrooms and onions which feature quite a lot in my cooking. So I tell her it’s chicken or a new kind of pasta and she’ll eat it without a fuss. I feel kind of mean, but at the same time I’m glad she’s getting some nutritional value in her meals.
loading...
For years my sons told their little sister that milky ways were ‘girls mars bars’. She would want the same as them when they went to the shops but mars bars were too much for a 2 – 4 year old.
Shes now 9 and knows about their subterfuge and thinks its funny.
loading...
My mother told my older brother who didn’t like pumpkin that it was yellow potato & that he quite liked it! I worked it out before he did & he was 5 years older than me!
loading...
Teehee, my friend’s parents told him when the ice cream truck played greensleeves, it meant it was sold out of ice cream.. :p
loading...
Oh, I wish I’d thought of that…
loading...
I did that… it worked for years with my kids.
loading...
My worst bad mummy lie – son wouldn’t stay in bed one night (he was about 4) and it was getting later and later. Finally snapped and told him that he wasn’t asleep by midnight that a witch would come and turn him into a pumpkin and then make soup out of it and eat it. Well he jumped into bed and I finally got to bed then about 10 mins later I heard vomiting noises. He came into my bedroom white as a ghost, bawling and dry retching saying he didn’t want to be eaten by a witch. Shit did I feel lousy!! Never told him anything remotely stupid like that ever again.
loading...
Good grief I wouldn’t sleep for a week if you told me that!!!!
loading...
How awful!!!
loading...
I KNOW!! I was a mean horrible mummy but fortunately he doesn’t remember it.
loading...
Me Myself I –
That’s hilarious. You have to have moments like that sometimes. It’s all part of the journey.
loading...
In our house, the ice cream truck only plays music when its run out of ice cream!! I do think my 6 year old has started doubting me though. It was good while it lasted.
loading...
Hahaha My friend’s little boy found her vibrator and in the heat of the moment she told him it was a rocket!
Probably not a wise idea to choose something that little boys love to play with on a regular basis! lol
loading...
My kids were getting overly confident at the beach in quite rough surf and they had me scared and stressed trying to keep my eyes on them…..so I told them the flags meant there were sharks and we had better go home. They ran.
And then when they did surf skills at school the following year I was sprung.
loading...
We tell our kids (1.5 and 3.5) that the bits of dried fruit Daddy gives them from his muesli in the mornings are “lollies”. Upside – they think dried fruit is lollies. Downside – they tell their daycare teachers they have lollies at breakfast.
loading...
I white lie to my 3 year old all the time. The park is closed, the shop has run out of pink milks, I’m eating a vegetable bar (really a chocolate bar), daddy ate all the lollies, it might rain soon so we have to go etc etc. Just makes life easier.
loading...
Not technically a “lie” but I love to tease my mum with this story…when I was about 4, we learned the Teddy Bear’s Picnic song at kindy. That night I asked Mum “why do they say, “if you go down to the woods today, you’d better not go alone?” What’s wrong with that?”
Mum, exhausted with my baby brother and making dinner, wasn’t really listening and just said absent-mindedly “oh I don’t know, maybe if they catch you alone they’ll kill you.”
I could never sing the song after that without imagining some VERY different teddy bears and wondering just how happy a picnic it was…
(I promise I turned out fine and it always gives us a laugh to remember! Mum swears she doesn’t remember saying it but it didn’t stop her group of friends howling with laughter over a recent boozy dinner)
I also fully believed in the “pool water changing colour” story for years! And when I was about 5, I did so during a school swimming lesson…and afterwards the teacher said she’d seen “*something* bad floating around in the pool” and the culprit should feel very bad, and I was absolutely convinced that she meant me and I never did it again. Assuming now someone had probably gone number twos…eww!
loading...
Until I read your comment I thought the pool water did change colour around you…I’m 26 and feeling rather stupid! Lol
loading...
Same! Haha feeling a little sheepish now.
loading...
So pool water doesn’t change colour?
This is mindblowing!
(I’m 26 and gutted)
loading...
All of that sounds pretty standard to me. I say similar things to my Stepdaughter, or did when she was younger. She’s a bit old for most of it these days.
The only one I’ve heard I suspect will backfire is when my SIL was asked why chicken is called chicken, and she said it’s because it looks a bit like chickens. One day I’m sure my niece is going to find out she’s been eating chickens this whole time and have a panic attack.
loading...
Sorry, I just got distracted by having my name at the top of a Mamamia article. Fellow Tamsins UNITE!
loading...
When I saw the name, I thought you’d written an article!
loading...
I write many! Just not on here (one day though
)
loading...
I lie constantly. It’s called manners.
( I also tell my 4 year old repeatedly that I ‘forgot’ to bring my phone somewhere just to stop him begging to play with it.)
loading...
When our boys were young, my other half (their stepdad whom they adore) told them that when the music is playing on a Mr Whippy tcecream truck, it means he is out of icecream, and plays the music to let everyone know.
They believed it for a couple of years. We would hear that familiar tune, and one or other of the boys would say “Awwww….no icecreams AGAIN already? He never has any when he gets near our street”
They took it well when they twigged though
, and even now have a chuckle, and shake their heads at their stepdad in a grave way…
loading...
Oops!! One of my comments got removed… guess I got a bit carried away and forgot to follow the dinner party etiquette, sorry Mamamia!!
loading...
I have told too many white lies to my children over the years to count! Don’t feel bad- I like to think of it as creative parenting! The lie that has stuck for 12 years in our home now, is that I am allergic to tinsel! I’m not really, I just hate it. I told my small son at the time when he wanted to buy loads of it in every colour pre -Christmas at a David Jones store! It literally flew out of my mouth before I had had time to really think about it! To this day, my children are super protective of me about it pre Christmas every year!…oh dear!
loading...
I wish I’d thought to say that about glitter … I HATE the stuff!
loading...
Oh that is a good one, I am totally using that when I have little ones!
loading...
I gotta say…. I find being white-lied to, quite condescending. Someone below said they lied to their adult kids…. huh? Don’t get that one.
On the other hand, I do agree with monsters in the dam stories for 2 year olds, as one example. As a child I knew Santa etc was not real from the age of four, but I myself keep that story going for my kids. Albeit uncomfortably.
I know there isn’t any real harm occurring with your daughter Tamsin. And my SOH probably isn’t as developed as yours
But I definitely view these examples as opportunities for our nearly 3yr old daughters to learn stuff. Patience, for example. And…. “no”!
I figure they gotta learn about the real world sooner or later.
loading...
That was me who lies to my adult kids. Its called ‘survival!’ I’ve got four of them, plus their partners, plus work, plus a primary school child, plus an elderly mother … It is impossible to remember who’s on night shift when, who’s staying where for the weekend, who’s had dinner with what friend who’s just broken up with random boyfriend who’s the cousin of their other friend’s fiancé who hooked up with someone at a conference, who’s going to what wedding and at exactly what time and venue and what dress, shoes, underwear they’ve decided to wear, who’s car has to be collected from being serviced, who was coming for dinner, who’s passport I was supposed to search for! I can’t remember who’s told me what half the time! I just make out that I ‘knew that.’ I don’t lie about who their father is, or sell their kidneys without telling them! Lighten up!!!
loading...
Anon, I wish I could like this multiple times!!
loading...
I lie to my sons more now that they are teenagers than I did when they were toddlers. It is called survival & I don’t feel at all guilty because they also lie to me. And I have also suggested that they sell one of their organs because I’m not an ATM that can constantly dispense money. This is the reality of life nowadays.
loading...
Nah, still don’t get it.
How fragile (or something) are these people that they couldn’t cope with the truth? i.e that you’re a very busy person who cannot be expected to remember everything…..
I might need to “lighten up” but is there a chance they need to “toughen up”? Or are they even that bothered when things slip your mind?
Honestly not trying to trash you, I just can’t undersand how it gets to that point with adults. Why you can’t just be completely honest / yourself?
loading...
Omg everyone gets it but me….if anyone above could answer my questions I’d be very grateful.
loading...
Adults lie to adults and to children to save time, to save face, to protect people’s feelings, to get ahead, to make life more peaceful, to look good, to make someone else look bad, to avoid getting in trouble.. sometimes they simply lie out of sheer boredom.
It’s really not a stretch to imagine why some people would choose to lie from time to time. What exactly don’t you understand?
loading...
What don’t I understand? How comfortable some people seem to be with lying.
For me, I’d rather put my energy into having relationships based in REALITY.
I’m aware that sounds serious, pious – melodramatic even – but the alternative would be so false I just couldn’t bear it.
loading...
Seriously? You don’t ever tell a lie to protect someone’s feelings? To get out of something? To save your own arse? When your mum gets her haircut and looks like a middle aged lesbian you don’t tell her she looks fantastic? When your kid does a painting that looks like they vomited on paper you don’t tell them they are an artistic genius? When your 18 month old is laying on the ground at Coles screaming for a lolly, you actually sit and talk to them about appropriate times for treats and not that the man from Coles is going to get REALLY ANGRY ABOUT THIS NOISE? When you’ve been up all night with a newborn and your toddler wants to go to the park you don’t tell them it’s international closed park day today? You don’t pretend you’re busy to get out of coffee with someone you find a bit irritating? You just tell them they annoy you and they’d better not be fragile about it?
loading...
Seriously. Am that brutal. And perfect ha ha
Look, I do subscribe to the theory if you can’t say anything nice don’t say anything at all…. and I can also almost always see the positives / silver lining. But if asked a q straight out, I’ll be as sensitive as possible, but I will still answer straight up. If I’ve been as diplomatic and sensitive as possible, and you’re still feeling fragile? My natural position is empathy but still – I’m.not.going.to.lie
When pushed, I am definitely capable of lying. And I too bend the truth from time to time with my small kids. Because of their age. But consequences, reasons (park, lollies) are 99.9% of the time based in reality. I just don’t see the point of pretending.
Why pretend unless one is playing a game? I think lying is a dangerous game, a slippery slope.
Can’t believe I’m Robinson Crusoe on this trust caper sheesh
loading...
you are hilarious! Like, like, like!!!
loading...
Anon, you are gold. I get what you mean and do the same. Not malicious type lies but small lies that save people from having feelings hurt.
loading...
What is wrong with looking like a middle-aged lesbian?
loading...
Best comment I have ever read on Mamamia, thanks Anon. I needed a good laugh and have done nearly ALL those things. Tastebud, you need to lighten up!
loading...
Not that there is anything wrong with looking like a middle aged lesbian!
loading...
tastebud, I can’t reply to one of your later comments, but I wanted to tell you that you sound a lot like one of my best friends. She really can’t lie. She is never malicious, but if I’m wearing something that looks horrible, she’ll tell me. Not in a mean way, but in a way that is trying to help me. On my wedding day she kept my eyes dry by saying “Don’t cry, you’re an ugly crier.” Not one tear was shed for the entire day! I’m sure you’re an awesome person, just like she is.
loading...
Thanks missneriss
She sounds like she’s got a cunning sense of humour.
I once heard that parenthood and marriage require both cunning and subtlely.
Unfortunately, I don’t really have much of either ,eeeek ….. but I’m honest!
loading...
My mother’s aunt lost her pointer finger in a farm accident as a teenager. When I was little, my mum told me it got stuck up her nose when she was picking it, so they chopped it off and left it up there. I never picked my nose again but I DID spend hours sitting on this delightful woman’s knee peering up her nostrils trying to locate the severed finger
loading...
We also had a great uncle who was missing a finger tip. He used to tell us that he was picking his nose one day and a pig ran out of his nose and ate his finger! And I must admit, I believed it!
loading...
OMG this made me snort-laugh – nearly woke sleeping baby (oops!)
loading...
I think the biggest lie my parents told me is that when we moved, they sent the two family dogs to live on a farm. I accepted that, and occasionally asked mum and dad if we could go visit them (I was 4 at the time).
When I was 15, I asked mum ‘ Whos farm did you send the dogs to? Are they still around?’ and mum went white and admitted that it she hadnt the heart to tell me that the dogs were both terminally ill and had to be put down, around the same time we moved.
At 15, with only a vague recollection of the dogs, there was no real harm done.
There was also my Pops gross toenail, which he used to tell all us kids was bitten by a crocodile. We still talk about it as if its a fact, which freaks out any new family members!
loading...
Same dog story!! I started connecting the dots myself when I heard some guy at school saying that he was going to “send that teacher live on a farm” and everybody laughed . Apparently everyone knew what it meant but me !
loading...
My grandparents told 6 year old me that they had sent their beloved golden retriever to live on a farm. There’s no farm is there?
loading...
Yes we had dogs that went to the farm. When my now 14 yo was about 6 we had to have a dog put down so naturally the ‘farm’ was dragged out. The weekend after we went for a drive and just happened to go past umpteen farms. He drove me insane trying to work out which farm it was. Funny how everyone has the same farm even back before we had the internet to communicate such subterfuge. Even the swimming pool lie predates the internet.
loading...
My bunny snowy went to the farm with the plumber. That farm must be packed!!!
loading...
We lived ON a farm so Mum and Dad couldn’t really use that one. Our old dogs quite simply got put down with a rifle…with a very loud unescapable shot ringing out across the paddocks:(
I kind wish we’d had the luxury of being told our dogs were going to live on a farm! I wouldn’t have minded that lie one little bit.
loading...
Oh no! My parents told me this story too when they took my beloved dog away
loading...
I think I’ve only just twigged that an old dog of my aunt’s may not have actually gone to a farm. Oh dear. Poor Rocco…
loading...
I’ve just realised that my friend’s dog who went to live “on a farm” didn’t go to a farm after all. Same with my pet chicken!
loading...
Did anyone else get told that if you did a wee in the pool at swimming lessons then the water surrounding you would change colour? And then everyone would know what you’d done
They used a special kind of chlorine in those pools apparently haha
loading...
You’ve got to be kidding me! Is that not true!?
Kid you not, I thought that was a real thing.
loading...
Hahahahahhaha well maybe it is true after all! Can you duck down to your local public pool for me and ‘test the waters’? Let me know!
loading...
Haha its still told to adults. I have a friend who swears it has happened to him, but I’m also half convinced its an urban legend…
loading...
It’s definitely an urban legend – my mum worked as a swimming teacher to little kids and said if it were true the whole pool would be green!
It’s not nice to think about kiddies weeing in the pool, but there’s enough chlorine in there to neutralise it all.
loading...
I was always told this and at my grand age im still not sure that its a white lie. Im certainly not about to go and piss in the local pool to test it out.
loading...
My naughty fib was that the fishies would run out of water if the kids stayed in the shower too long. Worked every time.
loading...
Lying is just one of the slightly crazy things you find yourself doing as a parent – there are many others… see here http://mumplusmore.blogspot.com.au/2012/04/crazy-sht-you-do-when-youre-parent.html
loading...
Sometimes I comment on things that I’m not actually looking at. Like “put your feet off the table” or “pick up that XYZ that you just dropped on the ground”. Master 5 has recently worked out that I can do this without looking at whatever it is I’m talking about – when he asks me how I know these things I tell him “Mum’s know everything, even things we can’t see”
I’ll probably end up paying for his therapy….
loading...
I’m the mum who knows everything, usually told to the kids with a smile….I thought my seven year old knew I was half kidding when I said it, but when I overheard her whispering to the four year old ‘not to be naughty because Mum knows EVERYTHING’ I figured my work was done
loading...
When my girls refused to wear their school tracksuit pants on a freezing cold day in favour of the school shorts, I told them cold legs stimulate excess hair growth and they’ll end up with really bushy hairy legs. They now wear their trackies as soon as it gets cold.
And I served Moussaka for dinner the other night. One of the girls complained that she hoped it wasnt the one with eggplant because she hates eggplant. Um yes, moussaka has eggplant!! So I told her it was a new recipe with mushrooms instead, and she gobbled it up while eating the eggplant saying ‘yum these mushrooms taste good’.
loading...
I hope you told her afterwards that it was eggplant
When I was a teen I refused to consider ever eating Kangaroo. Ever. So oen day dad served korma, and I didnt catch on to the slightly different taste. He then announced ‘you know what that was? Here skip..here skippy…!’ and he laughed until he cried.
I have no problem with eating kangaroo now
loading...
Hahaha my dad did that exact same thing to me when I was a kid!!!
loading...
Told my fussy four year old boy that the multigrain bread had ‘sprinkles’ in it.
His turned up nose was replaced by the exclamation ‘I LOVE SPRINKLES’ then he devoured the sandwich.
loading...
Love the people who have criticised this article. Wow what’s it like to be a perfect parent that doesn’t ever need to tell a lie to their kids out of desperation because they are so saintly patient? I once tallied that my oldest child when home all day was asking 7/8 questions in a hour. Times that by 12 hours in a day is nearly 100 questions a day. Times that by having 2 or 3 children at home all day some of whom will be high and above that average and that’s a SHIT LOAD OF QUESTIONS!!!! Throwing in the old lie to just MAKE THE QUESTIONS STOOOOOOP (please for the love of God make them stop!) or to get the kids to do something they’re opposing saves my sanity and means that I’ve got more energy to give my kids in other ways. Far out, judge parents who leave their kids in the car while they sit in the pub. Not ones who tell little lies.
loading...
My Ms 6 was pestering me for a sip of coke, I told her that is wasn’t healthy for her, talked about caffiene and sugar and sometimes food and said when she was older she can have some. I spied her stealing a sip out of the can but didn’t say anything as it was one of those “pick your battle” moments and I wasn’t up for the fight. The next day she was complaining of a sore spot on her tongue and I mentioned casually in passing that’s what happens sometimes when you drink coke….cue instant confession to taking a sip and I no longer get pestered when I am having a coke!
loading...
A friend’s little girl told me very seriously one day when I was drinking a Coke that Coke was only for daddies and other adults, that it made children very sick!! Ha! Her dad had her convinced on that one.
loading...
There’s only so much explaining you can do to a child with limited attention span about why they can’t have/do something…that’s when you need to think of something more to their understanding and use that little white lie because the minute you mention Santa or something a little scary, they are all ears!. Its not disrespectful at all. You do what you need to do I say!
To those who say its disrepectful, do you let your child believe in Santa etc? So isn’t that the same?
Being a child is all about magical things and makebelieve so the little white lie fits in perfectly!
loading...
I agree that many parents tell their kids little white lies here and there… But just out of curiosity, do parents who sometimes lie to their kids mind if their own kids do the same to others or to them? Or is that not ok?
loading...
My dad told me that you got ulcers on your tongue for telling lies. He also said that you could kill a man by poking him really hard in the belly button. He used to be in the army so I believed it was some kind of secret army ‘weapon’.
No harm done. I eventually grew up and realised the truth. It hasn’t stopped me from learning right from wrong or distinguishing between the truth and lies, just taught me that my dad has a silly sense of humour.
loading...
When we first migrated to Australia my Dad convinced us that kangaroo’s laid eggs! Dad’s have fabulous white lies
loading...
Our family lives on a farm which has a very pretty dam…. on the surface it’s a picture. But I know for a fact that the walls are near vertical with no shallow shelf near the edge and it’s 4m deep, icy cold with slippery muddy banks that drop off suddenly. So I feel no guilt at all in telling our children aged 6, 4 and 2 that there is a monster living in the lake. But that the monster never goes past the barbed wire fence (which surrounds the lake area) and so long as they stay well and truly outside the barbed wire area then the monster won’t ever get them. A lie? Outright! Will it hurt them? I don’t think so. They’ll laugh about it one day, and in the meantime it might just save their lives. They know not to go wandering around the farm without an adult but one day in the time it takes me to hang up a basket of washing I know this could change especially if they have a friend over for a playd date who persuades them to leave the house compound fence without me knowing. Oh – and if anyone thinks this is going to turn my kids off the water – not so. They’ve all been doing swimming lessons since they were 6 months old and still go every week, and they swim everywhere happily – from swimming pools to rivers and the ocean.
loading...
Damn straight, if it saves their lives, who the hell cares about the fact that it’s a lie!! You’re a good mum
loading...
my parents told us there were crocodiles in the damn, i dont remember but apparently when we were little tackers we would tell ANYONE that came over to stay away from there. worked well!
loading...
I know you don’t need me to tell you, but you are doing the right thing. We lost my 2 year old cousin when he drowned in their farm’s dam.
loading...
My mum used to tell my brother and I that there were sharks and crocodiles in the river near our house. Imagine her surprise when years later, the street was closed down and Australia Zoo had to come in and remove a crocodile. No sightings of sharks yet, but she lives in hope…
loading...
I tell lies to my daughter of course I do I mean I told her about santa brining presents at xmas and the tooth fairy leaving money for her lost tooth etc.
However, Ive always been honest with her about almost everything else. If she wants a lolly at the shop we consider how much sometimes food has been had that day and if its all good then she can have one if not I just say no and she understand why she cant have it and is fine with that.
If she wants more things bought or a ride at the shops and I dont have the cash or change I just tell her I dont have it and thats fine too.
When she was younger if she had any kind of tantrum about it we went home.
If she sits too close to the tv I tell her to move back without giving her a reason why, if she refuses to I turn the TV off.
I dont have any problem with parents telling fibs to help them parent their children I guess Ive just always gone the truthful way mostly and found it works fine for me.
loading...
I was like that with my firstborn. Funny how working 3 days a week and adding a few more children (plus a demanding husband) into the mix makes you accept and even embrace white lies as a parenting method.
loading...