by VICTORIA BIRCH
The music contained in the following clip may not be your thing. You may not appreciate apoplectic guitars or vocals spat out like bullets. It doesn’t matter.
The music may not interest you but the fate of the women in this video matters to each and every one of us.
The women in the acid bright balaclavas form the feminist punk band Pussy Riot. Over the last few weeks the band has dominated global news cycles as three of its members stood trial in Russia for “hooliganism motivated by religious hatred or hostility”.
On February 21 this year, Pussy Riot staged an unauthorised performance of their anarchist song ‘Hail Mary, Expel Putin’ in Moscow’s Cathedral of Christ the Saviour. Subsequently, band members Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, Yekaterina Samutsevich and Maria Alekhina were arrested.
The three women have since been convicted and sentenced to two years in a penal colony.
At first glance it may appear as if Pussy Riot’s subversion of Russia’s authoritarian conservatism amounts to little more than youthful insurrection; kids sticking their fingers up at the system through shock and awe tactics.
Pussy Riot is so much more than that.
Using flash-mob style performances, the women shake public spaces with day-glo colours, flags, smoke and noise. The performances are never aimless attention seeking exercises. These eye-popping exhibitions (videoed and posted on the web) are designed to make the world take notice, designed to ensure as many people as possible hear the women’s politically charged message.
That message is primarily focused on undermining Russia’s Prime Minister, Vladimir Putin. His re-election earlier this year was dogged by suspicions of carefully managed corruption and there is disquiet about his ties with the Russian Orthodox Church. In a supposedly secular country, Putin’s favour with the influential head of the church, Patriach, Krill I, is what drove Pussy Riot to perform their ‘punk prayer’ at the Moscow cathedral.
Russia is rattled by the huge global interest in the band. Pre-trial, Putin stated that he hoped the women wouldn’t be treated too harshly, a sure sign he was nervous about the potential fall-out from women’s sentencing. Pussy Riot scored a political body blow and reminded Putin any abuse of power would not go unchecked.
If you’re wondering why all of this matters, here are a few reasons why the Pussy Riot trial should keep you awake at night:
1) The women have been convicted on grounds of religious hatred, despite their ‘punk prayer’ containing zero references to the Russian Orthodox Church, its teachings or its followers. At worst, the women offended churchgoers by dressing in bright clothes and making a bit of a scene.
2) Two of the women have children. Their conviction will unjustly deprive young children of their mothers for two years (devastating for all concerned).
3) The women’s imprisonment on highly questionable charges suggests Putin’s desire to clamp down on political protest and freedom of expression is readily supported within the judicial system.
4) Acceptance of the sentence means acceptance of the implicit warning being issued by Putin and Russian authorities regarding the consequences of future political protest.
If that isn’t enough, it’s worth remembering this isn’t just a foreign issue in a far away land. Yes, Australia enjoys a robust democracy where the judicial and political processes are largely fair and transparent. However, Australia’s reluctance to help Julian Assange avoid extradition to Sweden (and possible persecution by the US) suggests we’re not averse to punishing political dissent either.
This is why we all have a vested interest in doing what we can to help secure freedom for the women from Pussy Riot. Not only is it a good thing to help those who have been unjustly treated, we should also be making a noisy song and dance about the importance of free and vigorous political discourse.

Pussy Riot members on trial – Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, left, Maria Alyokhina and Yekaterina Samutsevic
OK, so what can we actually do?
A big issue the women face is waning interest in their predicament. Two years is an eternity in the churn of global news and nothing would help the Russian authorities more than everyone forgetting about Pussy Riot.
So, for anyone (and this means everyone, right?) who cares about political freedom, the right to express political dissent, miscarriages of justice, false imprisonment and the need of a child to be with his or her mother – keeping Pussy Riot at the forefront of discussion is paramount.
There’s lots of activity happening all over the world right now in support of the band: activist days, music events, readings and demonstrations. Find the thing that floats your boat, get involved and keep doing it.
If you’ve spent plenty of time navel gazing and chit-chatting about injustice and inequality but done very little to actually make a change (and that’s probably 99% of us) – here’s your chance.
I’ll be tweeting something about Pussy Riot every day the women are in prison (under #730days). What will you do?
Victoria Birch is a writer and music obsessive living in Sydney. She is the proud owner of two small children and an extensive collection of pre-loved leather handbags. You can follow her on Twitter here.







Comments
36 Comments so far
Pussy Riot is the most exciting band to emerge in…well…a really long time!! I feel motivated and fired up, I feel like the teenage riot grrrl in me woke up from a long slumber…it’s time for action and change…Pussy Riot reflect the true punk ethos…it’s revolutionary on so many levels. Good on you Victoria and good on MM for publishing the story!!! #freepussyriot
loading...
Brilliant post. Maybe the best thing I’ve read on mamamia in a long time (I say that with love!!). Please MM team, keep this kind of incisive writing coming. A welcome break from the usual celebrity/motherhood/tear-jerker stories that, it seemed, had become the norm. Have to say, since Jamila has taken the reins, I’m starting to see a side of MM that I really love. Well done guys for posting this great story and well done to Victoria for breaking down a rather complex subject into something coherent but still resonates.
loading...
Totally agree Angela.
loading...
Why’s it any worse for a mother to go to prison (unjustly or otherwise) than it is for a father?
loading...
I believe the point the author was making is that two little kids are the real victims suffering from political/religious persecution. The fact that they are mothers rather than fathers has nothing to do with it.
loading...
I know it’s probably open to interpretation, but I inferred that the author somehow considers the fact that they’re female parents to make it their situation all the more dire.
And while I can’t cite every article on unjust imprisonment ever, I don’t recall reading of the wrongful or questionable imprisonment of any male being worse because there were children involved.
I agree with Bradley; it might be a very different article if the three were male.
I don’t think the author is saying the children are the real victims; the imprisoned band members are the real victims. The children are used emotively in the context of this article.
The situation is wrong because people’s right to free speech seems to have been infringed. It’s no more wrong just because they’re women.
loading...
Drew – I totally agree with your point. I made reference to the women as mothers because, well, they’re women. But ‘parent’ may have been a better choice. I really wanted to avoid making issue of the women’s gender because this is entirely a human rights issue – not specifically a feminist issue.
loading...
Thanks, sincerely for saying that.
I’m a devoted Dad to two daughters and I know if I were in the unfortunate position of being detained away from home, it would be hard on them—just as hard as it would be if it were my wife.
I probably read this site and The Good Men Project in equal measure, so as a dad who’s proud of my role as a parent and co-contributor, the nuance of how you worded that particular point did jar with me a little. (You reinforced it with “…the need of a child to be with his or her MOTHER” [emphasis mine])
The danger in making it too much about them being mothers (as opposed to parents) is that you invite victim-blaming, in a “why are they fighting political oppression when they should be home with their kids” kind of way.
I’m sure the suffragettes copped a lot of that. A hundred years later, a woman should have as much right to voice political dissent as a man has to nurture his children.
Let’s hope they’re reunited with their kids soon.
loading...
I believe that had the band in question been called “Penis Riot” and been three males, this article would not have been presented.
loading...
@Bradley, your comment is gratuitous. Do you realise you are on a site called Mamamia – AKA strong female audience (and some males too). Sheesh! Get over it.
The real victim here is Russia – they are being let down by a quasi-dictatorship led by the hubris Putin. The women here are poster-children for an expose into what it’s really like to live in an undemocratic society. So sad
loading...
I agree with your sentiments about Russia being the victim.
loading...
Oh my god bradley, if I have to read another comment from you about men being victims (ignored/overlooked/discriminated against) I will punch myself in the face.
If you want an article on a male band or male centric politics go read…anything. Rolling Stone mag, the newspaper, whatever you want. Men are not underrepresented – whether they’re political bands or not. So when a female band finally FINALLY gets paid attention to, it would be lovely if you just read the article rather than taking the opportunity to freak out that men weren’t (as they usually are) the centre of attention.
I know this comment comes off as harsh but please, please try to get a grip and realise that an article focusing on or promoting women does not mean that men suddenly need to be mentioned or protected. Women are allowed to exist, without their existence effecting or correlating with male existence.
loading...
If you stick to your promise….I’ll make another comment !
And that is all I have to say on the matter. I shall take all remarks on board for consideration.
loading...
Haha sarah agree! Get over it Bradley! There’s no conspiracy theory – women just happened to do something that got reported on. If this happened to men it would have been reported on too. Sorry that no men were in the band to be mentioned- I’m sure that would have made you feel less victimised and discriminated against!
Next time women do anything I hope they remember to include men so that articles written them aren’t offensively just about women. That would be so sexist.
loading...
I find the sentencing of these women to “two years in a penal colony” a little strange. This is 2012 not 1882!!! I’d like to know if penal colonies still exisit and if so whatn defines a place as one??
They could just send the ladies here to Australia as a ‘former’ penal colony to serve thier sentences??
loading...
Agree it’s a rather archaic term, but penal colonies exist in Russia. Ostensibly they are prisons in very remote areas. Cut off from the rest of society they inflict punishment through exile. Mikhail Khodorkovsky (the Russian billionaire convicted of fraud) was imprisoned in YaG 14/10 – a penal colony 3,000 miles from Moscow in Siberia near the Chinese border.
loading...
Australia isn’t a colony of Russia though. It was a penal colony of Britain. While it might be lovely to send these women here, it will never happen. The Russians “do punishment” exceedingly well.
loading...
@ FaybianI – I am well aware that Australia was a penal colony of Britain and not of Russia. In fact my ancestors were former naughty prisoners sent here to serve sentences many years ago. But anyway, I digress…
My point about sending them here was said sarcasticly (I REALLY wish someone would invent a sarcastic font!) – It seems absurd that this day and age penal colonies actually still exist and I was merely trying to add to this ridiculousness by suggesting something even more crazy that if they need to go to a penal colony, send them here – they never said if it had to be active one or or not….
loading...
I saw a web page dedicated to ‘Free Pussy Riot’ protest all over the world and Australia wasn’t on there. Is anyone doing something? Anything (other than Victoria’s tweeting)? I’d like to get involved if they are
loading...
Yes! There are plenty of people in the midst of organizing things for Australia, last week there was a protest in Sydney and many of us have been putting our heads together to come up with something. More shortly!!!
loading...
I find this interesting. We are asked to be concerned because the members of Pussy Riot have been locked up for criticising the government of Russia while the ALP/Greens are doing all that they can to silence voices of dissent in this country, granted, without sending anyone to a Siberian concentration camp.
Hi Victoria. I get it that you are concerned about freedom of speech in Russia. Where do you stand on freedom of speech in Australia ? Does this issue of the Russian women concern you because they are women first and foremost ? There are quite a number of men rotting away in the gulags for daring to openly voice opposition. Will you be Tweeting on their behalf each and every day until release in confirmed ?
loading...
The ALP/Greens are advocating people be imprisoned in penal colonies for years at a time for voicing views opposed to their own? Really, Bradley?
loading...
Obviously you didn’t get what “without sending anyone to a Siberian concentration camp” meant ?
Really, inc ?
loading...
Apologies Bradley. My bad, I will practice my reading.
loading...
Bradley – I thought my point about Julian Assange underlined the fact I don’t believe freedom to express political dissent should be taken as a given in this country (or any other western nation).
And no the issue doesn’t concern me first and foremost because they are female. I admire them very much and think their actions are remarkable and brave – but nowhere in the article did I say the women deserve special attention because of their gender.
Of course the women from Pussy Riot aren’t the only ones to be imprisoned for dissent. I see their issue as highlighting the plight of very many people around the world – something I will be tweeting about in relation to this particular issue.
loading...
I’d say that the fact they sang punk songs in neon clothes and balaclavas in churches has more to do with how much attention they are getting than the fact they are women.
And, as always, this is a female interest blog so women are always going to be featured more than men. If you want to talk about men or male issues then it’s illogical to expect it on a women’s blog.
loading...
How can you make a statement like “ALP/Greens are doing all that they can to silence voices of dissent in this country” as though it’s the same as what’s happened to these women, then qualify it with “granted, without sending anyone to a Siberian concentration camp”, like that is not an important part? That is the critical part.
If the ALP/Greens were sending Aussies off to concentration camps I’m pretty sure there might be a bit of an outcry, whether they were male or female!!
Guess what Bradley – the world does not generally overlook and discriminate against men. In fact, they the dominant gender in most societies. So an article about women doesn’t mean that men are some how being oppressed. I’m sure mankind appreciates you having their back and looking out for them, but I think they’ll probably survive if you turn it down a notch and stop with the witch hunting.
loading...
Ahhh, yes those naughty voices of dissent! Considering some of Rupert’s closest are about to face court in the UK, I don’t think they’re as lily-white as you’re making out Bradley….
loading...
Sorry B. I don’t believe that I mentioned Rupert or any of his colleagues, formerly of News Of The World. It is quite clear that what they have done is illegal.
However, these people are in an entirely different category to the Australian journo’s who the ALP/Greens are trying to silence for daring to disagree rather than any presumed illegality committed.
loading...
It’s both scary and ironic that Putin has the support of all the major religions in this. It seems he’s more than happy to embrace ‘the opium of the masses’ when it serves his purpose. Krill in particular is a very sinister figure, he was quoted as saying: “secularism is diseased – “infected with the bacillus of self-destruction”. Secular countries allow women to control their fertility and tolerate homosexuality. They are nominally free “but defenceless against evil”. *shudder*
loading...
* Kirill
loading...
Great article.
Sorry for the off-topic, but what’s happened to yesterday’s Julian Assange piece?
loading...
We are trying to work out where it’s disappeared to
loading...
Maybe it is the hacktivists from Anonymous?
Actually, I’d love to see a peice in Mamamia on them. Awesome article about them recently in mindfood mag.
loading...
Mia posted on another story that the Julian Assange piece has disappeared mysteriously and their tech guys are trying to retrieve it.
loading...
Maybe WikiLeaks hacked the site
loading...