Do You Like This Story?
playground1 196x300 Take your children to the park and leave them there day.

.

Do you think kids should be wrapped in bubbles? Are you a helicopter parent? Do you “hover” over and around your kids in an attempt to protect them from the odd scratch, some dirt and the “wrong” 3 year old crowd? Well in a bid to get your kids out there playing freely, sans hand-sanitizer, leash and mobile phone, Lenore Skenazy (controversial novelist, columnist and mother) has declared May 22nd “Take your children to the park and leave them there day!”

On her Free Range Kids website, Lenore writes:

If our goal is to get kids back outside (it is), and playing together (it is), and for parents to relax (it is), and to start creating community again (it sure is!!!), then “Take Our Children to the Park… And Leave Them There Day” is a great first step.Across the country — what the heck, across the world — parents will  converge upon local playgrounds and parks with their school-age kids. They will tell them to have fun, make friends and don’t leave with anyone. Then the parents will wave goodbye and the kids will amuse themselves for whatever amount of time they’ve decided with their folks. An hour. A morning. Or maybe even just half an hour, to get used to the whole thing, which, admittedly, sounds radical. But is it?

bubblewrap 229x300 Take your children to the park and leave them there day.

One child. Bubble-wrapped.

The crime rate in America is back to where it was in the early ’70s. Crime was going up then, and it peaked around 20 years later. By the mid ’90s it was coming down and continues to do so.  So the strange fact — very hard to digest — is that if YOU were playing outside in the ’70s or ’80s, your kids today are safer than you were! I know it doesn’t feel that way. In fact, here’s an interesting poll about how the majority of people feel crime is going up when actually its going down. But anyway, the point is:

Most of us used to play outside in the park, without our parents, without cell phones, without Purell or bottled water and we survived! Thrived! We cherish the memories! And if you believe the million studies that I’m always publishing here, kids are healthier, happier and better-adjusted if they get to spend some time each day in “free play,” without adults hovering.

I know there will be shrill voices insisting, “Predators are gonna love this holiday!” but keep a level head. Crime is down. Awareness is up. There is safety in numbers, which means getting kids outside again, together. This won’t happen until we actually start DOING IT.

So spread the word and be not afraid. Free-Range Kids never says there is no risk in the world, only that the risk is small and worth taking, as it always has been. The trade-off is kids who make up games, who solve problems, who discover nature and get moving (to coin a phrase). Kids who don’t need a screen to entertain them. Playing outside, on their own, is what kids all over the world do. We have forgotten how vital and wonderful it is.

Walk around your neighborhood. Do you see empty sidewalks? Empty yards? Empty playgrounds? It’s a waste — of childhood. Let’s bring it back, starting on May 22.

Is old-school parenting really back? Would you describe your own upbringing as free-range? Mine was. Lots of time running around the street and roller skating on the (gasp) road. If my own children tried to do either, I would, of course, freak.

If you have kids, would you describe your approach as being more ‘free-range’ or more ‘helicopter’?

Thanks Chas and thanks Danielle

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine this is a dinner party. Differences of opinion are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. If you're rude or abusive, your comment will be deleted (so will comments responding to other rude comments because they won’t make sense - so save your breath). And if you’re offensive, you’ll be banned. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That's how we're going to be - cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation...

Use your profile to comment:
Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

278 Comments so far

  1. Pingback: My response to Leiby Kletzy’s murder « Cooking with too much salt

  2. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Alisha

    I tend to hoover, but I long to let them run around free-range!

  3. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Kris2040

    There was an ad just on *with ominous music and hazy pics of kids* Channel 9 that they are talking to the woman who suggested this. I think on the Today show? God I hope Lisa injects some normality into it after that awful ad. If its on ACA, I guess we know what to expect…

  4. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Hollyboo

    Such an interesting topic. I wonder if the increase in violence in young 20ish folk, and an increase in serious, horrific traffic accidents could be because they have never had to develop their sense of personal boundaries and judge safety for themselves, because their parents have always been doing it for them?

    I am also an infant teacher, and the amount of ice packs given out a lunchtime for the smallest injury is astounding. Six year olds with barely a scratch seem to get so distressed by their ‘injury’. In our day, we brushed ourselves off, and kept on playing, having learnt that next time to be more careful jumping off the playground equipment. End of story.

    I definitely support the idea of ‘free range’, with a slow release of parental supervision and protection from an early age. Kids (when taught correctly) are more sensible and capable that we sometimes think.

    However, as a Qld resident, the horrific story of Daniel Morcombe (13 yo abducted in 2003 and never found) still haunts me. I see his mother’s face on TV and my eyes fill with tears. No one wants to be the ‘one in a million’.

  5. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    camille

    One in 3 girls is sexually abused in some way and one in 5 (ish) boys.
    Most people are sexualy abused by a trusted friend or member of the family. And perpertrators look for isolated and unconfident children, within those kids they know around them. And they’re charming and fun people (why else would parents let them have access to thier kids?)
    The conclusion? Testing yourself against progressively more challenging tasks breeds confidence. As oppposed to never being challenged cos Mum thinks you won’t cope cause you’re a bit useless.
    And have a close relationship with your kids so that they can tell you that they don’t want to be babysat by Uncle Dave. And if the worst happens, trust thast, like a third of women and a fifth of men you see around you, they’ll recover to have happy productive lives.

  6. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    30dollardatenight

    Um, I don’t have children yet myself but this does not sit well with me. I do have fond memories of roaming alone through my local suburb or with friends, but still…

    And which ‘lowered crime rates’ are we specifically referring to here? And didn’t anyone suppose that the reason the crime rates are lower in regards to children might be because we watch them a little closer these days than what we used to? Harder to kidnap when parents are there, surely!

  7. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Asti

    really? she would leave her kids for the day? who is she going to blame if anything happens to her kids?

    i may read this too literally. i agree ‘free-range’ is good. but within reasons of course. i can never forgive myself if anything happens to my child if it was my decision to leave him/her there.

  8. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    LMM

    My childhood was very free range, walking to and from school from prep. Playing outside with the kids in our street and in summer moving from pool to pool all day, every day, great fun!
    Now, my kids are still little (3 and 1) but gee I find it hard to think of them doing what I did. I want them to have a lovely childhood, but of course as their Mummy I want to keep them safe. I’m not so concerned with the normal falling over and social interactions (good or bad with other kids) but the predators in our community, that worries me. Of course as they get older and are mature enough to be aware, giving them more freedom is good for them.

  9. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    quatro mamma

    Free-Range all the way within reason…does that worK?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Kris2040

      Of course it does. That is life!

  10. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Stella

    I was a free-range kid. I caught to the bus to school without siblings or parents as a little preppy, aged 5! I rode my bike to friends houses after school and came home in time for dinner. We were allowed a small glass of a shandy or whatever at family functions. When we old enough to get a drivers license, my friends would have to ring their parents whenever we got to our destination but I never did. I grew up to be pretty level-headed. Of course our genetic make-up has something to do with the way we turn out, but I never considered drinking a whole bottle of vodka at age 14, never have (to this day, aged 36) even been offered drugs (let alone had the chance to say no to them – I know, I am in a minority here!), had unprotected sex etc etc. Sure, I spent years travelling around the globe and, looking back, did some things that were not so safe or smart (but hell, they were fun!), but I think my general level-headedness (and maybe a bit of dumb luck) got me through those potentially dangerous times.

    Now, I’m a parent of two (still very young girls) and apart from the intense love I feel for them, what struck me most the instant I became a mother, was the overwhelming feeling I had to protect my child. It was so powerful.

    The thought of them being harmed or put in any kind of dangers petrifies me. My husband and I (who seemed to have almost an identical upbringing as me) always talk about how we hope we can find a happy balance with caring and protecting our girls. They already both have a wicked sense of humour and are very gregarious, so our hope for them, along with being happy and healthy, is that they maintain their zest for life and also have a chance to grow into sensible, confident women.

    What a big task…

  11. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    amandarose

    I would like to be a free range parent. But it is hard not to go with the status quo- imagine the finger pointing- bad parent comments etc? and the in built paranoia of being told about all the bad things that happen.
    I´ve been trying- I let my 2 year old hurtle down my friends concrete drive way on a kids trike- many times( I was hovering a bit at first then chilled when I realised he could do it).
    He did fall off eventually but a scappy knee is part of being a kid having fun.
    My friend with the big drive way is of Indian decent and is much much more relaxed about safety and much stricter with behavior then me. He kids are smart, clever good mannered and well behaved. My kids are- less independent and not as clever as hers and I think I need to let them free to learn.
    She doesn´t even have a fence and lets her 18 month old out climb down stairs and play in the yard. And you know what – she never goes near then road and never hurts herself.

    I say lets bring back free range parenting! give kids credit for common sense and figuring things out!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Kris2040

      I remember a couple of years ago being at the beach with my nieces and nephews. I took them out on the rocks to have a look at the rockpools – Rockpools are always interesting, and I thought of how much I loved them and discovering things when I was a kid. I was in a boot following plaster after my ankle reco, so not super mobile. I told the kids that I was the boundary and that they couldn’t go past me. They were totally cool with that, but then would spot stuff, so I extended the boundary. I AM a risk-taker, but I assess the risk and decide. My brother was a bit freaked out, but once he realised the system he was cool. None of us got washed off the rocks, and all the kids got a lesson as to WHY we have to be careful at the beach on the rocks.

  12. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Poodles

    I am not a parent, but a teacher and have taught Preschool and Prep children for 5 years.
    I do find that most parents are extremely over-protective of their children (not all parents). Children not eating every single grape in their lunch box – won’t they starve? Not playing with more than 1 child at lunch – are they a loner? Can’t take a message to another class with a partner – won’t they get lost or hurt by a big kid?

    I had one parent tell me a story about when her son had a friend come over for a play. They were jumping around on one of those trampolines we all had as a kid (no nets). Her son’s friend had a netted tramp at home, so you while the boys were bouncing on the tramp, the friend bounced right off and onto the ground. He was so used to having the net at home that he forgot this tramp didn’t have one and went crashing to the floor. Since when do we put nets on trampolines. Can’t children work out that there is ground down there? If they fall off (like many of us did when we were little) won’t they just learn to be more careful next time? Children learn more through experience than being told what to do.

    Children have hardly any upper body strength nowdays and this has been put down to the ban of monkey bars in playgrounds and schools. Fear of being sued by parents.

    One school has banned children from doing handstands and cartwheels in the playground. Fear of being sued by parents.

    COME ON – let the children learn and know their own boundaries…parents won’t be there forever and they have to learn sometime.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      30dollardatenight

      I often think it must suck being a teacher these days what with all the over-sensitivity!

  13. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Essen

    I guess the thing that holds parents back is that they don’t want to be the one whose kid is the tiny statistic?

  14. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Tom

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dean_Corll this is extremely disturbing especially about the torture, stranger danger doesn’t even work completely because this sick s.o.b. used other kids to bring him victims. kids need a childhood and independence but they gotta be careful there’s a lot of sick evil scumbags out there

  15. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Nomie

    I’m a big believer in free range. It’s all about knowing your kids, knowing their limits, encouraging them to push those limits… giving them the freedom to make mistakes, learn, move forward, all in an environment of support, love and honesty, respect.
    Seriously, no one is suggesting leaving a 2 year old alone at the park.
    My kids cook and have always used the chefs knives we have at home… never cut them selves, we modelled the way to do it, then let them have a go… learning together.
    They walk to our local shops with our dog on their own, and walk the dog on their own after school each day.
    The kids latest accomplishment is – in our full view – navigating the way through the 90,000+ crowd at the MCG to find our seats for the ANZAC day match. The only person who gets lost there is me.
    I know some people have stories of children they know being abused by strangers, I know it happens, but the only people I know who have been abused were by close family members.
    I know accidents happen. But they could happen in your own back yard.
    Later this year they will probably be flying interstate on their own, just like I did as a child… they’ll be signed in one end by me, and signed out the other end by my parents who will have to show their photo ID… they will have $10 each for the plane to buy a drink and chips… will I be worried? Will I count every second till my Mum calls to say they are there? Damn straight I will. Will that worry stop me letting them do it? No way.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      La Petite Chou

      Brava. Can I borrow your children to help me to my seat when I’m at the G?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Miss Kate Daily

      Hi Nomie, can I ask what age your kids are?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anonymous

      you sound just like my mum when i was a kid… well done!

  16. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Kris2040

    I’ve been driving a lot at the 40km/hr zone times the last week or so. I have seen hardly any kids around. How the hell do they all get to school???

    I would seriously like someone to explain to me what is SO different nowadays to when we were kids. And not “It just is and its scary”. I really want to know what it so different.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Apples

      Where I live the 40km zone starts at 2:30pm in the afternoon, waaay before most kids are out of schools. Not saying it’s bad, just annoying when driving down a quiet school street at 40km at 2:35pm on a Monday.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Kris2040

        Yeah, they’re 8 – 9.30 and 2.30 – 4 here too. I’m driving from about 2.45 onwards till past 4, and I pass heaps of schools, and honestly don’t see many kids at all.

  17. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    N/L

    OMG who is this woman? How annoying is she! I feel like taking her on a long train ride and leaving her somewhere dark without the fares to get home. I wouldn’t let her have knee pads or any butter on the stale bread I might give her.

  18. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Flutterby

    I’m a big believer in knowing your kids capabilities and letting them push those boundaries little bit by little bit. Children gain maturity and learn through trial and error, being trusted and then increasing limits.

    This has horrified friends and family a little bit at first. The younger is great climber and I’ve happily let him climb up big trees, knowing I’d break his fall if I have to – never did.

    The parents that crack me up are those that wrap their kids up, driven to school say, then expected to catch a bus at 15. Off you go ;)

  19. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    cathc

    I am an Emergency nurse and the mother of 3 sons. It is my opinion that kids need to be exposed to risk in order to define their own boundaries. Over the years we have had trampolines (no cage, no safety pads once they were jumped off!), pools, cubby houses etc. We live across the road from a National Park and at various stages of their lives, they have all wandered around in there with their mates. All in all, none of them has sustained any significant injury.
    For us, safety has been about the following – wearing seatbelts in the car, holding hands (while little)in car parks, direct supervision while in the pool and having open honest discussions about appropriate behaviour from people we know and those we don’t.
    Currently my eldest (who is 19) doesnt exhibit any of those risky teenage boy / bad driving / drug taking / risk taking behaviours and for that Im extremely lucky. We also have taken every opportunity when the TV shows massive motor vehicle accidents, to discuss openly the reason why people are unlikely to survive and how sometimes not dying results in life long consequences such as paraplegia and / or brain injury.
    Im as anxious as every mother that they come to no harm, but sometimes you just have to let ‘em go….

  20. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Miss Kate Daily

    I used to ride my bike in a circuit I created around the house (which included guiding my wheels down a precarious wooden plank down a couple of stairs, that was the fun bit) and then I would shoot down the driveway and straight out onto the road, and do a giant figure 8 on my street and start all over again. It was so much fun! And I admit as a mother now I would be HORRIFIED if my daughter did this. Is the traffic any worse where I live now? Probably not.

    And I can’t imagine being able to relax if I knew she was out in the park behind our apartment WITHOUT ME. I wish it wasn’t that way, but I can’t see my natural reaction to protect her fading any time soon.

    I do try to make sure my daughter has responsibilities, and I can say no to her and I feel like I have a fairly good balance – I try to let ‘natural consequences’ happen etc, but it is really hard to let go in a world where it’s as if us parents have collectively decided that society’s not safe enough for our children. Are we all subconsciously disturbed by experiences we had as free-roaming kids?? I remember being flashed at, followed home by ‘weird’ men from the shopping centre and teased by local bogans who I was terrified of… Not sure. Interesting topic though Mia :)

  21. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Happymum

    Wow, so many different opinions on whether to leave kids at the park by themselves!

    I would not leave my kids as they are likely to try and cross the street and they have no traffic skills whatsoever as they are sheltered little country kids.

    Sheltered because they don’t know how to live in and do things for themselves in town. I let them run wild at home on the farm, although I have a dam behind my house and many other dams on the property and machinery is quite dangerous if you aren’t looking out for the kids.

    My son, who is five came inside breathless as he was running on the dirt road chasing a bird when he ran over the top of a brown snake. He just stepped over it. So close to being bitten it wasn’t funny. I have had both boys close to being bitten by nearly treading on snakes. I just tell them to watch out for them and to never touch them.

    I know everyone says there is more chance of your child being killed in a car crash than being abducted and killed by a paedophile, but I would prefer my children to be car crash victims than that of a disgusting paedophile. I still think of Daniel Morcombe and how he was taken, and he was not a small child – in front of people on a busy highway. I have nightmares about paedophiles taking and killing my children, or even just robbing them of their innocence. Makes me so sick!

    I think if you can minimise the chance of this happening all the better.

    I try to be a middle/balanced parent. Cater to my kids personalities and if they are keen to do something crazy, I try to let them in the safest way possible.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bowerbird

      Reminds of when my boy – then just 2 – came racing into house holding up one chubby little hand and shouting “Snake! Snake! Scared! Finger!”. Oh God. To panic or not to panic? I searched for puncture marks and couldn’t find any. So I very resolutely chose “not panic”. Thankfully all was OK.

      As you say, you could do your head in worrying about snakes, and it wouldn’t do any more good than just teaching your children what to do. Perhaps we could say the same of paedophiles? There’s a lot less of them, after all!

  22. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anna B

    I’m neither free-range nor helicopter. Perhaps somewhere such as heli-range. I dont parent my kids according to what others are doing, but according to my kids’ needs and street smarts. In some situations my kids have it all sussed. In other situations, not so much. I never want to wrap them in cotton wool, but at the same time, I am responsible for their safety. I give myself enough credit to assess what they are and aren’t ready for. Other people’s opinions are not of too much concern to me as they dont know my kids the way I do. Overall, i think we’re going ok.

  23. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Lu

    As a parent of older children (infants school to tween) I think the stance on giving kids freedom can come from 2 very different angles. And this can determine the outcome regarding kids behaviour and attitude.
    There are those parents who want to give their kids freedom to help them learn and have responsibility.
    And then there are parents who give their kids freedom because they cant be bothered supervising them or dont want to pay for adequate supervision if they cant be there with them.
    Big difference.

  24. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    bee

    My daughter is 2 and a half and I really WANT to be a free-range parent – the only problem is I’m finding it’s really frowned upon by my peers so it makes me doubt what I’m doing.

    We let our daughter help set the table – she carries all the cutlery out including steak knives – friends are scathing when they see me letting her do this. I also don’t stop her playing on anything in the big local playgrounds no matter how high she climbs. I also haven’t ued a pram for a while because I want her to be able to come shopping with me and be able to get some exercise and explore her environment (without annoying other people). I also never stop her having a chat to anyone she meets in public or stop her patting dogs.

    The thing is I’m starting to become the butt of friend’s jokes (about neglectful parenting etc) but I just want her to be confident and self sufficient. Anyone else have this problem?

    It’s getting to the point where I’m the butt of friend’s jokes

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      cm

      My two 1/2 year old loves his surrounds and he loves people! I think our kids would be great friends lol. Im the same with him, we enjoy shopping together he has his basket i have mine. occasionally he runs of in a fit of giggles but mostly he is a good boy. Plays on anything. My friend is quite supportive actually she looks after kids as her job and says they only fall once. How else will they learn? My old friends on the other hand strap them leash them tie them down somehow and guess what? they are so bored! poor kiddies let em loose i say : )

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      OneSmallLife

      Perhaps your friends are secretly insecure about how confident and self assured you and your daughter are. I think you sound like you are doing a great job.

      I have a similar view to yours. Try to let my nearly two year old be as independent as possible and am always proud when I take her shopping and she is curious and exploratory but respectful and well behaved. Although she also hasn’t worked out what a tantrum is yet, so I know that is ahead of us!!

      I don’t let her carry sharp implements (yet) or pet unfamiliar dogs (because I think it’s important to be a bit wary of unknown dogs) but she does lots of chores around the house independently and I think it comes down to judging your own childs abilities.

      I would never judge another parents choices in this regard and I think it sounds like your friends are being a bit mean spirited really.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      An Idle Dad

      Bee, that’s how my daughter started at 2. She’s now four (almost five).

      Kids know what sharp is. They aren’t stupid.

      http://web.me.com/katandchris/Cooking_Sausage_Rolls/An_Idle_Dad.html

      The knife is very sharp. So relax. Supervise, yes, cotton wool no.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Secret Water

      I agree with your approach.I also have a 2 and a half year old and if I can I ditch the pram…things take a little longer sometimes but if she pushes the boundaries and starts running a muck i offer (and sometimes implement) the alternative which is back to the car and home or back in the pram. It gives her an understanding that I am letting her have some independence that she shouldnt take for granted.
      Just carry on doing it your way and dont listen to other people’s criticisms. I suggested to my playgroup the other day that we occasionally have a session in the park instead of the church hall and everyone felt it was “too chilly in the shade” for the littlis…what the? They obviously didnt play in a british school yard in December with shorts on!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Grrrrrr

      Hi bee,

      I have three kids, all are confident and happy kids. My theory has been based in letting them take the steps into the world when they are ready, not to push them into independence. This has some Eastern philosophy behind it, you know the type of attachment parenting theory moderated to suit our life here.

      To cut a long story short, there is a huge basis of mutual trust, they learnt to trust that I am meeting their needs and supporting their ideas, interests, etc. They have taken steps into the world knowing that I had their back, any time they want to step back I’m here. The result is three amazing, confident and independent children.

      My youngest is 2.5 and sets the table, is allowed to, shock, horror, touch knives and is very helpful at the shops, just as you’ve described. (Although the old joke is you let your third play with knives :) )

      Communicate to your friends that she is confident, happy and independent because of your care and mutual trust. There is parenting theory to support you and wait until she grows a bit more and you can gloat how wonderful and settled she is in school, life, friendships, etc! :)

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Nomie

      Bee, I think you are doing a great thing, keep it up!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      La Petite Chou

      Can I just say that a blunt knife causes more accidents in a kitchen than a sharp one. True.

      My kids started by using a paring knife, a mini chef’s knife with an 8cm blade, when they were about 5 or 6 under my supervision. Carrying scissors and knives to the table, no problem, just carry them correctly – blades pointing to the ground away from palm of hand. Handling hot pots, making a cup of tea with boiling water? About 8 or 9. Cooking in an electric frypan, about 7. Cooking in a wok, serious heat because he saw Jamie Oliver do it – about 12. Encourage them every step of the way.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Kris2040

        The first badge I think I did at Brownies was my cooking badge. I must have been about 9.

        And yes, a blunt knife is way worse to cut yourself with – it tears your skin and it makes it harder for it to heal.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Sarah

          It also needs a lot more pressure and is more likely to slip

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      amandarose

      I´m the same- I reckon there are heaps of people who want to be more free range but feel we cn´t due to social stigma.
      Good on you for having courage to do what you feel is right. Gives me courage to try too.

  25. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    PixieM

    To all those who are worried about “stranger danger” – don’t. Your child is statistically highly unlikely to be sexually abused by someone they don’t know. The vast majority of sexual assaults are committed within families or by trusted friends. And how many actual kidnappings take place in Australia every year? Most of those, too, are by family members rather than strangers. But if you are still worried, choose parks that are big and well populated, not stuck away in a back street. Make sure your child is confident about what to say if someone does approach them. Research on paedophiles strongly suggests that they leave confident children well alone. Start with small periods of time with you less than 10 mins away and build up. IMO I think 8 is OK if there is a largish group, 10 is fine with a few of them.

    Take them to the local pool once they are confident swimmers – they won’t drown if there is a lifeguard there and most pools have these. They won’t drown also because THEY CAN SWIM!

    So what else is there? Well, the most obvious is roads and cars. Parental supervision is essential up until the age when a child can be assessed as knowing how to cross all sorts of roads safely – IMO that is about 10. The more they walk (rather than drive) with a parent the more they will learn how to do it safely by themselves.

    What else? Getting lost. Travel training is the answer here. On short bus and train journeys, go with them until they understand the route and how to do it each way. Think about the things that can go wrong and role play them. Make sure they know how to charge their phone and they always carry it. IMO about 11 is a good time to commence short public transport journeys. Again, the more times they do it with you, the more confident they will be.

    I guess what I’m saying is that you can engage strongly with your child not to hover and smother, but to teach them gradually the skills to become confident explorers of the world.

    And that’s just the physical stuff. Letting them stuff things up and learn about failure, and disappointment, and betrayal, and even just mediocrity….are, I think, incredibly valuable life lessons. This allows us the time to have those discussions about what hurt us, and how we recovered, and what we learnt from it, and gives them the space to learn how to be emotionally resilient and emotionally mature human beings.

    This is my middle approach. Not saying that it’s always worked; the teen years are a particularly gob-smacking challenge. But for me, it’s the process of parenting – the things you learn as you’re on the journey together – that comes with the most rewards, even when bad things have had to happen first.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Zoey Martin

      I liked this, but then that seemed insufficient to express how much I loved your comment!!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      megan

      couldnt agree more.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anonymous

      I agree with the practice-role model idea. We play “what would you do if….?”. Most of the time they have a good response. Well, the 10 yr old does, the 6 yr old remains relatively clueless, but we’ll work on it.

      When I asked my 6 yr old what to do if a stranger pulled up in a car and offered him lollies to get into the car, he said “oooh, that’s a hard one!”

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Anonymous

        I know it’s not funny but it is funny & I could not stop laughing at “oooh, that’s a hard one”.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      aprils_fool

      Ahh…another voice of reason, we do that here too..consequently my Miss 19 has been overseas twice and travelled independently interstate on a few occasions. In comparison her two best freinds who are forever being chauffeured everywhere are nervous about a 4 day holiday a 3 hour drive away.

  26. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Liv D

    I think we need to consider age appropriateness here. Kids need little chunks of increasing responsibility to be able to manage themselves later in life.

    Eg. A 4yo could ride 4 – 5 houses down the street on the footpath and back again without direct supervision, an 8yo could go to the milk bar, a 10yo to a friends house etc. That is MY comfort zone.

    If my 6 & 8 yr old went to the park with their 9 & 12yr old cousins by themselves, no problem. I would not expect my nephews to also let my 3yo tag along as said three 3yo need a lot more watching.

    In regards to bad people, if you think evil is around every corner you kids will grow up scared.

  27. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Bejazzled

    I was free-range – firstly on a farm, then in country town – we always knew everyone & given my dad was a detective with lots of guns I don’t think anyone would have dared touch us. We were pretty well known.
    We walked to school, I was often told to walk to the local milkbar to buy my dad’s cigarettes….humiliating……walked or rode to netball, tennis, volleyball, walked home at night.
    Was often forgotten to be picked up by parents at various locations at all times of day and early evening, so more walking.
    I swing between free-range & hover depending on the location. Hubby is very free-range, that can be stressful, my kids are 7, 4 & 2. He went to a theme park recently with 7 (boy) & 4 (girl). Girl couldn’t go on slide rides, so in his wisdom he left her at the bottom of every 30 foot slide (ALONE), she can’t swim, and had a great day with his son, going on the slides. Divorce never looked so good at that moment he told me. When I asked my daughter did she have fun and feel okay, she was totally happy & said she was fine. I left it at that. No point creating anxiety. (However I just can’t bring myself to let him take them again without me…..its just a little too much for me). I can rationalise the risks aren’t that great, but I just think 4 is too young to be left at the bottom of a slide.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Ms. Butlertron

      On the theme park thing, the first time I went to Australias Wonderland (now defunct theme park on the outskirts of Sydney) I was too short to go on some of the rides, but that didn’t stop my dad, who just sweet talked the assistants into letting me on. At least your husband didn’t go that far!

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Happymum

        Ha, my husband sweet-talked a carny today into letting master 5 ride the gravitron at our local show today. Master 5 was so stoked that dad got him on the ride even though he was 20cm too short for it.

  28. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Kate

    One of the problems I face in trying to give me kids freedom is that it is seen as socially unacceptable. If I want to let my kids walk to school – she feels like the odd one out because no other kids walk to school. And if I let my daughter walk alone to her friend’s house up the road – I am looked upon as a bad and uncaring parent.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bejazzled

      I can relate to that definately. There are plenty of school moments, with other school mums at parks and if their kid runs even 10 metres away from them in full sight they call them back. Then my little ferals keep running and I feel a bit hmmm should I call them back? I don’t usually, but there is that awkwardness because people get defensive really quick about parenting stuff. I think its better to show your kids consistency & if you are a free ranger, keep having confidence in them, because they will then always have it in themselves.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      S

      I think the key to this ‘social’ aspect is make sure you are OK with it and then it doesn’t really matter what someone else thinks. If you can go through all the fears you would have and even consider fears others would have and you can honestly say that you can manage the risk/outcomes then do what works for you. Nobody can actually make you a bad and uncaring parent and only you can make yourself feel like one. A child who is confident and independent is less likely to be a victim in the long run so I think a few calculated risks will pay off.

  29. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Zoey Martin

    Frankly, I have limited interest in anything that Lenore has to say. Anyone who responds to a research study on the benefits of breastfeeding with “Quit Picking on Mom’s Who Don’t Breastfeed” has lost all kinds of credibility in my book.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Missamoo

      I am really not trying to be inflammatory here but why has she lost credibility?? Are you saying that we should pick on mum’s that don;t breastfeed?? Because my mum had five and four of us were such a nightmare to breast feed and we weren’t putting on any weight. Coupled with the fact that my father had watched his niece die when he was 12 because his sister had no milk and couldn’t afford formula, she caved and bottle fed us. Are you saying she shouldn’t have??

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Zoey Martin

        Absolutely not! I’m saying that to make the leap between scientific research and making mums feel guilty is ridiculous. Some choose to breastfeed. Some choose not to. Neither has anything to do with what kind of parent you are. But to say that the very publication of something outlining the benefits of one way is an attack on women who formula feed is pretty stupid.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Evey Mercedes

        I don’t think that’s what she’s saying. I think she felt that Lenore immediately became defensive at a survey on the benefits of breastfeeding. I think the point is that the survey was not “picking on” anyone; it was simply highlighting the medical benefits of breastfeeding.

        (PS Sorry Zoey if this wasn’t what you were saying…)

        :)

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Zoey Martin

          That’s EXACTLY what I meant, Evey! And because she did that I can’t help but think that she is more interested in controversy than anything else.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Lana

      It has been a pretty torrid week on Mamamia. I ask that in light of this, and just in keeping with the park theme, can we stick to the post topic and not make this a post about breastfeeding. We have covered that before here http://www.mamamia.com.au/weblog/2009/09/are-breasts-only-acceptable-when-theyre-used-for-sex.html here http://www.mamamia.com.au/weblog/2009/10/breasts-are-rude-discuss.html and even here- http://www.mamamia.com.au/weblog/2010/04/this-image-is-offensive.html. We will discuss it again I am sure – but not on this post

      Thank you xxx

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Missamoo

        Sorry Lana i just was wondering why someone was so immediately uninterested in listening to this womans opinion

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Zoey Martin

        No problem Lana. I wasn’t trying to make it about breastfeeding as much as pointing out that the woman in this article has a bit of history of being controversial for the sake of it. But appreciate that it is a trigger topic for many people and possibly I should have used a different example ;o)

  30. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Bowerbird

    Having quickly scanned through the comments, I’m a bit surprised by the extreme examples being used (eg paediophiles on every corner), when surely this HAS to be about degrees?

    I think comments like “you can’t be too careful” and “its not worth the risk” are simplistic. You CAN be too careful, and you can only judge whether something might be “worth” the risk if you actually carefully weigh up the risk.

    Usually the risk of doing something is pretty straightforward, although you do have to consider BOTH consequences and likelihood. Its the risk of NOT doing something that I think we often overlook – because its more subtle and long-term. In this case its not just about the warm nostalgic feeling about the fun we had when we were kids. Its about giving kids the chance to – progressively – develop their own ability to recognise and manage risk. I read recently (sorry, can’t remember an exact reference, but it was Australian) that university sociologists and psychologists are already noticing that their students are less and less capable of this. And they put it down, broadly, to over-parenting.

    We’re not here to keep our kids safe. We’re here to help them learn how to keep themselves safe. And, by definition, that involves exposing them to a level of risk – judged as best we can, cause none of us are perfect.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Apples

      It certainly doesn’t help when some Universities (my example is from the US, not sure if it’s changed here) are allowing parents to take more and more responsibility for doing things for their kids in terms of applications and paperwork and calling the uni up to ask about dorm room changes etc. We’ve always had proxy system where someone could stand in for you on some things if you were away on enrolement day, but now in the US some colleges essentially let you sign away a right to your parents having all your info, your timetables and so forth. They can’t then complain student’s aren’t capable. I hope we don’t go the US way in Aus. My res was very strict on keeping parents at a distance. It’s not just parents who need to take a stand on their kids growing up, banks, phone companies, universities and employers need to resist the amount of parents gaining rights in areas they could previously only advise and hope for the best on.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Elizabeth

        I agree. I remember when I was a Receptionist…and we would put an ad in the paper…some parents of these prospective employees would ring up on their behalf!!! I used to say to them…’I think they would much rather talk to your son/daughter…and then they would get all indignant!!!..I know these kids are only 17 or so…but that’s part of the process….YOU have to pick up the phone and take that first step…if you fall flat on your face…pick yourself up and start again. It’s a learning curve. Mum and Dad can’t do it for you. Anyhow…nevertheless…these people were not considered for an interview.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Kris2040

        When I was working in a bank call centre, I actually got the sack after being threatened with legal action by a bloke (American, oddly) who was going to sue the bank because I wouldn’t tell him anything about his son’s account.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Bowerbird

          Good God, there are so many things wrong in that, I don’t know where to start!!

  31. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Apples

    I also kind of dislike the name ‘free range’ just like ‘helicopter’ implies negative things. Both are extremes. Free range implies just letting them run willy nilly and perhaps unsafely which very few do, helicopter implies massive overprotection which few do. Most parents are just reasonable people struggling with a changing world and responsibilities/expectations and the debate is around when do you let them run free and how? No one, yet, has said ‘I keep them locked in their padded rooms when they are not at school and will do until age 18′ or “has anyone seen my 3 year old? Chubby little guy, last seen playing in traffic?”

    Is there a title that conveys “yes-but-maybe-depends-on-where-i-live-how-confident-my-child-is-helicopter-bad-free-range-also-kind-of-scary-um-somewhere-in-between?”

    I’m so tired of all these ‘versus’ media presentations (not on here, I mean the topic in general, I like to discuss all the ‘vs”s topics, I just object to how I see them portrayed on some site or by some people) where all you get is blindly adhering to one side or another. Single women vs. women with children. SAHM versus. working mothers. Natural birth vs. medical. Pick a side, any side, but it better be a side. When did we lose the middle ground? I was taught to write my Arts essays beginning with “Agree, but” or “Disagree, but” basically. I read the opinion pages or some blogs and feel like I’m being bashed with a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ sign.

    Don’t let anyone push you into choosing one extreme or another. Sometimes it’s feels like an election with these ‘vs’ topics (and why is it always women targeted with these vs. arguments?), you end up choosing the one you hate the least. So I reluctantly have to say ‘free range’. The middle ground is just as firm a territory. I want a name for it!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bejazzled

      Apples you need to return to your Simpsons archive for a name for the middle ground!

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Apples

        Sooo distracted over dinner out tonight, giving this grave thought : p I don’t think they have a name for the middle ground, sadly. But in going back over how the kids we know a bit more about are portrayed in the show I think I discovered it isn’t so much about being a ‘free-range’ or ‘helicopter’ parent in what you let your children do, it’s what is happening at home that counts. Take Nelson. He is ‘free-range’ totally does what he pleases. But he is sad and a bully because no-one cares for him (papa went to the store for ciggarettes….and he’s still out. Mum doesn’t give a crap). Milhouse is considered the loser of the group and can’t cope with life. Guess which kind of household he comes from – major helicopter mother. Bart and Lisa come from a loving caring home and are strong, curious and independent. All the kids go out and do reasonably age-appropriate stuff but everything is always fine for Bart and Lisa, they all do the same things but the outcomes for the kids are different. It’s about home and the parents, more so than the age or the activity. Because Bart and Lisa know Mum and Dad are there for them at the end of the day. They often come in to save the day for their kids if things get rough. Give your children a loving, stable home and teach them life skills and you won’t need to helicopter them, they can take care of themselves in age-appropriate settings. As for free-range, go too far, you end up with a Nelson. Children may want to roam but they do like to know someone is worrying just a little bit about them at the same time. At the end of every episode the family is happily together, no matter what crazy stuff happened. They reconnect. And they’ve all learnt something (which they handily forget by the next episode). The Simpsons is supposed to be based on the average American family and I think that pretty much hits bang on the middle for letting your kids go out and play, but still being active and involved in their care and lives. I climbed and fell out of trees with a bunch of kids and we all turned out differently, too much emphasis is being put on this at idea at the moment. It’s just another passing media trend in some ways. Yes we need to get out more but really parenting at home and in general still matters more. Maybe some of those kids I played with were being turned out to play because home wasn’t happy. WHY you are a free-range kid matters more than just being one. If it’s not because your parents want you to grow as a person in a reasonable way, it’s not good.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      PixieM

      I couldn’t agree more Apples, well said.

  32. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Happy and Clear

    I am definately going to the local park on May 22nd to see if anyone actually does this. My kids are far too young, not even 5 yet, so I won’t be, but it would be interesting to see this in action.

    I am a helicopter mum most of the time but try as often as possible to step back and be a free-range parent. Husband is VERY free range. Makes for interesting, heated parenting discussions :)

  33. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Lu

    I think its very personal and individual for each family. What I know some families do with their kids (and honestly believe they are doing an OK job and the best thing for them) I think is slack bordering on neglect. And I’m sure there are other families who think I’m not doing the right thing by my kids either.

    I have decided to become more relaxed about what other people do with their kids. Their kids, their business. If I think its wrong I’m not judging. I do my best for my kids and I am the one who has to live with the consequences if I get it wrong. They do too.

  34. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Mel

    My kids would define me as helicopter but I would see myself as in between – a good balance.
    I let them play outside (12, 10 and 7 yrs) on the street with other neighbourhood kids until dark, just like my Mum let me do. But I don’t want them walking the streets on their onw, though I do let my 12 yr old walk to the shops with a friend and go shopping for a couple of hours on a weekend.

  35. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Dallas

    To Anonymous, because it won’t let me reply to your last comment…

    >> At what age would you think it is OK to let a child leave the house (as an example of ‘free ranging’) or wander off without parental supervision?

    I’d like to point out, by the way, that I live in a small town. I know I wouldn’t let my kids wander off in the city. Particularly since at 22 I still stick close to my parents or someone I’m with if I’m in Sydney, just because I don’t want to get lost. In this environment, I would allow my child to leave the property (because some kids like to play out the front but don’t leave the a specific area) around seven or eight. Though I admit my decision would be entirely based on the maturity of said child at that age.

    >> If a child who you were responsible for, did come to any harm that could have been avoided if you hadn’t let them ‘free range’, would you feel responsible for their danger/harm in any way? And I’m talking bad things here, not just falling off the swing or anything.

    Of course I would. Just as my Mum would likely have felt guilty if my brother hadn’t have come back from one of his bear hunts. But the fear of what could happen is not going to stop me from allowing them to ‘free range’. And to roll with a cliché – I could get hit by a bus a tomorrow, but I’m not going to stay away from roads for fear it could happen.

    I get the whole “a paedophile could be living next door” because frankly we live next door to a day care and the kids shout hello to us whenever we come outside, and when we first moved here one of the carers (male, might I add) would look at us as though he was judging us as because we would say hi back and continue a conversation if the children started one.

    But, in my opinion, you can’t judge others based on the fact that they ‘might be’ a paedophile simply because they smiled at your child. And to people who are going to make those judgements, I like to hope that they won’t be hypocritical in their views. If they think that of one person that smiles at their child funny, I would like to think this means they also wouldn’t take their child to sit on the lap of a guy dressed as Santa or hire a clown for their child’s birthday. Because right there are two common occurrences in the life of a child. Two types of people who disguise their appearance and spend the day with children.

    That’s my opinion on those two questions.

  36. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Apples

    I had a very free range childhood and it was great. Out all day, back by dinner, no mobiles. Mum knew most of the neighbourhood kids and their families who we ran with so had any peer concerns dealt with. But I grew up in a small regional town. As has been mentioned on here, the most dangerous person to your child is you and the child’s other parent, and other people they know. So for me this is really a debate about what has changed that we are more afraid of strangers than before?

    Extra media information is partially responsible, but this isn’t always a bad thing. Reasonable people still trust those who work with children (youth workers, priests, teachers etc) but there is no longer the ‘untouchable’ status where you can’t question them and people in trusted positions got away with hurting kids.

    Thinking back to my childhood and how I would not do the same for my kids if I lived in the city still, I think it is our connectedness to each other that has changed. Crime may be down yes, but stranger numbers are up. Family members may be more likely to hurt your kids, but that doesn’t mean stranger danger isn’t real. And we have more strangers in our lives as we retreat from our neighbours, too tired from work and life, too shy, to make an effort to get to know them. We move more so why bother being part of the community. More of us live in cities where it can be hard to feel apart of a community, especially when it isn’t mostly families, like my town was mostly. That and kindly old people. Now there are so many people, so many strangers. So our danger attenas are up more. Our environment is also bigger in towns and cities that are getting larger, leaving us feeling less in control. In my small town you could only go so far.

    I can see how parents think, who cares if crime numbers are down? I don’t know that person. Or any of the people at this park. Even reasonable people consider the possibility that the rare stranger child abduction could happen to them. And in modern life you now have more suspects, hence more ‘helicoptering’.

    When I was younger we didn’t know the whole neighbourhood but we knew several people, and they knew and vouched for the ones we didn’t know, we had extended family in the town, everyone knew the cops and storeowners and yes we had Neigbourhood Watch safehouses. Anything amiss would be noticed and reported, nowadays people don’t necesarily feel confident they know the neighbours and the area well enough to recognise a concern. There was confidence in the police that they knew there patch, which hardly ever changed anyway. No way can you get that in the city.

    For me I won’t be decieding it on a ‘am I or aren’t I’ a helicopter parent, which I don’t particularly want to be, but sometimes you have to. I will try to reduce the ‘stranger’ feeling of my environment as much as possible and then see what level of confidence I have. I will however try to raise kids that are not afraid and have confidence because it is often kids who are not strong and confident in themselves and their ability to stand up to adults who get hurt as sick people know exactly who to prey on.

  37. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anonymous

    The Mall. Is that where they sell diapers and cookies?

  38. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    La Petite Chou

    Okay, so here are some of the highlights and lowlights of my parenting style.

    Exhibit A Your Honour: Boy, likes sticks, guns, camp fires, riding his bike, Power Rangers, hugs and kisses from his mum, the company of other kids, someone to talk to (even in the supermarket). Prone to injury. Has broken his arm twice.

    Exhibit B Your Honour: Girl, angry she couldn’t shave her legs in Year 5, screams when she doesn’t get her own way, learns by doing (and often making mistakes) has learnt to confide in Mum and know that Mum will support her even when she stuffs up. Impetuous. Head-strong. Gifted athlete.

    1996 – Our first family camping trip. Dad taught the girl, then aged 4 to ride her bike without training wheels. She promptly free wheeled down a huge hill and came to rest in a mud puddle. Two nights later, at 9 o’clock when it was dark, I asked where the kids were. By this time they were roaming from tent to tent. They came home eventually, with a flathead and a bucket of bait.

    2003 – In front of two adults standing next to her, my 18 month old neice jumped into the pool and sunk like a stone. While I was still working out whether I should take my shoes off before jumping in, my son, then aged 11 jumped in after her and presented the indignant baby to her astonished Mum. He was the only one who was thinking.

    2005 – My 11 year old daughter took surfing lessons and got caught in a rip. I watched her, from the beach, swimming across it and over it until she made the beach. She was crying and shaking but only then did I realise there was a surf patrol right next to me. Ooops.

    2007 – London, after 5weeks of travelling. I was hospitalised unexpectedly. My kids were left by themselves in a hotel room for 24 hours while I languished waiting for surgery. My 13 year old daughter hailed a cab on the strength of her mother telling her that London Cabbies know every street in London. She made it to my hosptital room flowers in hand.

    2008 – My daughter got busted for trying to get a drink from a vending machine. In her school. At 3am. I was sleeping and thought she was with hr girlfriend. She was. They just weren’t at the girlfriend’s house.

    2009 – My kids first outdoor concert. Hot day, lots of discussion about self-protection and under-age drinking. Said a friend of ours, “You don’t want to end up like her”, pointing to a young adult who was skulling beer. Said my daughter, ‘oh that’s okay, she’s my cousin”. Daughter ended up holding cousins hair as she puked in the portaloos and made sure she got home that night. True story.

    I’m sure I’m too slack to be a good parent but as a helicopter parent I just can’t be arsed.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      mother of three

      One tick is not enough for your blog. GOLD STAR for you!!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bowerbird

      I’ll take lessons from you any day!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      dramaqueen

      Good on you LPC – you have brought up some resilient, caring, independent young people.

      I aim to do the same, fingers crossed!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Happy and Clear

      Wow! You should write a book.

      What a mum. Well done.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bree

      I hope my kids turn out like yours!!
      You should start a parenting class for those of who…hover.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      TheRealSydney

      Great comment – yep agreed – bad stuff happens but mostly they get through it – I’m sure we could share some war stories!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      OneSmallLife

      ‘oh that’s okay, she’s my cousin’

      HILARIOUS

  39. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Owner of chickens!

    Here is a free range story for you. My chickens escaped. A neighbour (don’t know which) delivered one of them to a close neighbour “because she knows everyone” – and bless her heart, she knows me, the owner of said chicken. Thankfully, the other one made her way home all by herself… That’s what friends and neighbours are for – to look after each other. (and our children, not just chickens!)

  40. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Sarah

    I’m a bit of an inbetweener. There is a nice balance to be found, the SMH article posted by another member was absolutely valid. My own 1970s upbringing was almost neglectful. I aim to give my kids age appropriate freedoms and responsibilities while responsibly protecting them.
    My 11yo can go to the park with a friend (not by himself) and can walk or ride to school(30min walk) or to a friend’s house by himself. But I don’t just let him wander the streets, he has a watch and knows he is expected at places, if he is at the park with a friend he has a time to be back. My 8 and 6 yo are not able to do any of that yet but the three of them can ride their scooters on the street outside our house without adult supervision. I drive/walk all three of them to activities and make sure that I spend quality time with them all, talking, reading, playing, whatever…
    I don’t think anyone thinks it is hovering if young kids are supervised. That said by 10yo they really need to feel they are capable and trusted. At this age they are old enough to cross a road by themselves as they’ve developed peripheral vision and they do start chaffing at the bit. As parents we need to educate our kids about how to be responsible and about protective behaviours.

  41. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Meredith @ thinkthinks

    I let my kids (aged 9 and 11, not little ones – there’s free-range and there’s stupid – and nobody is asking people to be stupid) go to the park or ride their bikes around our suburb alone, catch buses to after-school lessons and walk home from friends’ houses. I started gradually a few years ago, letting them play in the park across the road, then go down to the creek behind our house, and now they are allowed to set off on their bikes with their watches and a time to be home. Every step they take where they show me they can handle the independence leads to them taking another step.

    It is not being suggested above that toddlers be left alone, or even children under 8. But Skenazy is promoting that older children start learning some kind of independence.
    I’m all for free-range , and it hurts when friends say to me “I could never let my child do that” as it seems to be implying that I don’t care about my children, when quite frankly I care a lot. I care that my children will learn to be independent and quick-thinking . To walk with awareness rather than fear.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Missamoo

      Briliant!!!! I was raised with quite a firm hand but with the emphasis on responsible behaviour. Mum expected certain things from us and when we did them we got more freedoms very quid pro quo.
      I sometimes think that it was too much work and she could have let us do a little more but your version seems to be perfect for me i guess i’ll have to find you when i have some kids of my own

  42. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Tracy

    I think I was kinda free range as a kid – my brothers and I were pretty close in age, as were all the other kids in our little suburban Brisbane street in the 80′s. We lived on our bikes and took them everywhere we were allowed to. That was the thing. We all had our boundaries set (all the parents must have had a meeting or something cause we all had the same limits) and we more or less stuck with them. There were about 7 or 8 of us at any given time and we looked out for each other.

    The biggest rules we had was ‘never go off with someone you don’t know’ and ‘be home before dinner’.

    We had some weird things happen – like the time a car pulled over and offered us a lift home – and even though it was scary at the time, we all knew how to handle the situation, ie run home holding hands!!!!

    But I guess that was the thing – there was always a bunch of us and we grew up together from a really young age. Our families all knew and trusted each other. We knew if anything happened to us there was a street full of houses we could run to.

    But I wonder how many kids don’t know what it’s like to grow up in a street like that? I wonder how many kids don’t have siblings or friends of the same age close at hand or other kids in the street they even know? I wonder how many parents these days don’t know anyone else in the street they live in?

    I wonder if you could have a free range childhood if you don’t have all the other ingredients to make it work. My brothers, my friends and me may not have had parents around all the time, but we were never alone in our neighbourhood. I think that is the key. But I wonder if our modern lifestyles let parents form the kinds of relationships that then lead to these kinds of neighbourhoods any more?

  43. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Blah blah....

    Back in the day there were other parents around keeping an eye out for your children and you kept an eye on their kids. Now the house and streets are empty. Back in the day streets were safer. Now people burn around in giant four wheel drives with no regard for pedestrians. That said, the people who annoy me these days are those who won’t supervise their own children and expect bystanders to do it for them. I saw a toddler run at high speed out into traffic while his mother gasbagged over coffee with her friends, oblivious to what was happening. I’ve also seen people plonk their small children into a public pool and then wander off or stick their head in a book. They will be the first to complain about others when their own child is injured or worse.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Alison

      But this is the point – if we all let our (age appropriate) kids run around our (environmentally appropriate) streets, the streets won’t be empty anymore. Parents will be looking out the window to keep an eye on the little rapscallions, or working in the front garden, and there’s genuine safety in numbers in any case.

      My children have been taught road safety, and what to do if a stranger makes them feel uncomfortable (but not to be scared of all strangers, because most people are good). We know many of our neighbours, and they know the streets around here quite well.

      So they’re allowed to play around the streets, walk to a friend’s house, walk to the shops etc, and have been able to for a couple of years if they stay together. For the record, they are 11 and almost 10. Sure they’ve come back with scrapes where they went down the hill a bit too fast on the scooter; big deal. They were patched up and soothed, and they learnt the lesson. In a few years time, they’ll be able to go to the giant nearby shopping centre for a movie or shopping with friends, and I’ll be happily absent. A few years after that, they’ll want to hit some club.

      The rule is – I have to know where they are. If they’re going to the shops by this road, then that’s what they do. If they want to go another way, let me know first. There is a time limit, and they stay together. They’re FINE.

  44. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    claystep

    My children are 6 and 4, they build cubbies, go to the park, play in the yard, dig in the garden ride their scooters/bikes to school and are free to play and create with minimal interference but I am always in the backround keeping an eye on them if thats makes me a helicopter mother then I am proud to be one.

  45. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Nak

    Geez, you could have at least changed the wording a little if you were going to recycle that urban legend! Nice try.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Nak

      OK my post makes no sense now that the urban legend post has been removed! Mods you may wish to remove this post and reply as well (I’m on a different computer now so can’t request it myself).

  46. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Jessica L

    I think parents are more present these days in their kids lives not just because they’re being cautious, but because they care and are truly interested in hanging out with their kids. My parents used to just send us up to the park to play while they had a rest at home or cooked dinner etc. I think it’s great that mums and dads want to be more hands-on than their own parents were.

    Having said that, I don’t have kids yet so I can’t judge, and I do want my future kids to gain independence and maturity by having some freedom. I remember a girlfriend of mine in high school wasn’t allowed to ride her bike on her own to the milkbar when she was 13 and I found this very odd.

  47. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Lulu

    ** typo ***

  48. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Wonderpet

    I would say I’m free-range at home (I’m quite comfy sending the kids out to the yard for an afternoon, and I’ve always tried to be relatively flexible when out – they don’t have to be by my side so long as I can see them and the environment we are in is relatively safe but two episodes in the past 3 weeks have me really questioning my flexible parenting …..last week my 18mo and 4yo were playing around while I had a coffee with a friend. One minute they were 3m away dancing to the music in a jewellery shopfront, the next the 18mo wandered behind a pole, I lost sight of him and he was gone. He’d wandered out of the shop front, across the walkway and behind one of those mid-walkway food booths. Thank God a nice security guard spotted him, swept him up and walked back towards me. It literally took less than 10secs for me to lose sight of him.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Alison

      Yes, but nothing actually happened to him, did it? And a security guard did what he’s there to do, which is to look out. If the security guard hadn’t done it, another parent would have. In any case, Lenore would never advocate any of this for an 18 month old child. She’s all about safety, but safety also includes teaching your children to take care of themselves, then letting them DO THAT. An 18 month old can barely be taught to sit still for 10 seconds.

  49. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Jennifer

    I would love to embrace this day and notion, and whilst I give my children (two children under five years of age) a certain amount of independence, I just would not feel safe in this exercise.
    There was a failed abduction of a fourteen year old girl in broad daylight two blocks from where we live!

    Certainly one would like to believe that a responsible ten yr old would be able to play at a park with her friends without ‘helicopter parents’ but they would certainly need to be alert.

    I hope that I strike a balance between helicopter parent and free range parent!

  50. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Penguin

    I used to bike to school and ballet from the age of 8, usually with a posse of kids in my class. That was over 30 years ago *cringe*

    My children are still young, 6 and 2. I would NEVER leave them in the park alone at this age, no way. Possibly when they are older (like over 12), but not yet. When we go to the park together I don’t hover, unless I’m required for activity (ie. swing-pushing) I sit and keep an eye on them. I get so bored at parks but it’s great for the kids and my 6 yr old is a very chatty individual and will make friends with the gatepost. However I’ve told him about stranger danger and because he’s so gregarious he still needs to learn limits and not to accept food from people unless he asks me, or go with people under any circumstances unless I OK it.

    However we live in a quiet street and my 6 yr old is very fond of the almost-80 yr old gentleman who lives a couple of doors down and I always let my son walk over to his house to chat if he’s in the garden. I give him limits and he sticks to them. If we lived in walking/biking distance of his school I would definitely let him go on his own when he’s a bit older.

    Children are precious. You can’t replace them. We know our kids better than anyone else does, and if we feel we need to be careful, I don’t see why we shouldn’t.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      An Idle Dad

      Lenore is not advocating leaving 2, or even 6 year old kids at the park. I think she puts the minimum age at eight, and only if you are comfortable with that idea.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Posting Girl

        And lots of people are saying here that they AREN’T comfortable with the idea for a whole load of different reasons.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Alison

          And Lenore is asking you to examine the facts and whether or not your reasons are really valid.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Penguin

        Ok. I didn’t watch the video.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      cos

      I bet your elderly neighbour loves having your son come visit -bless him!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Bejazzled

      I love sharing food with other kids & I don’t really have any probs with my kids taking food from other people if its offered, and I’m there. But I once did this with another child, she wanted one of our dried apricots, so she took some, then went happily over to her dad, and he looked at what she had & the idea it came from someone else & had the strangest repulsed look on his face. I mean I don’t get that, what’s the world coming to if we can’t share food with children when we are all with each other in parks or other places?? sigh

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Penguin

        It’s because of allergies, Bejazzled – my son used to be allergic to eggs and peanuts so I’m just careful.