Good morning one and all. Tired. Oh so tired. Stayed up last night to watch the inquiry into the News of the World phone hacking scandal and it was, umm, weird viewing to say the least. Like watching somebody sit a test you knew they were going to fail. Anyhow, catch up on the gist of it here:
1. Murdochs appear before inquiry, attacked by shaving cream wielding comedian
It was a night of high drama and awkward scenes as both Rupert and James Murdoch appeared before the Culture, Media and Sport select committee of Parliament. Yup, awkward. James appeared like a school boy who had made a grave error, apologising repeatedly and in myriad ways. “What happened at the News of the World was wrong,” he said. Mr Murdoch senior said it was ‘the most humble day of my life’. But neither accepted ultimate responsibility.
Mr Murdoch senior said he had been betrayed by people he trusted. When asked if it were a financial decision to close the News of the World, he answered: “Far from it.” But his tone wavered considerably between what were obviously his scripted lines (I am sorry, this is a humble day) when he spoke spontaneously about the BSkyB bid and why it was abandoned. He spoke of many critics: “They caught us with dirty hands and built an hysteria around it.” Otherwise the inquiry was punctuated with a lot of ‘I do not knows’ and ‘I do not recalls’ and ‘not to my knowledge’. As if to round of a highly bizarre evening, comedian Johnnie Marbles lunged at Rupert Murdoch with a plate of shaving cream, screaming ‘you naughty billionaire’.
Rupert’s wife Wendi Deng leapt to protect him before falling over. As he was led away under arrest, Mr Marbles said: “As Mr Murdoch himself said, I’m afraid I cannot comment on an ongoing police investigation.” Rebekah Brooks was also questioned, again rescinding statements she made before parliament in 2003 that police had been paid for information in the past. Instead, she said, ‘in my experience, the information we get from police has always been free’. She said she was not, when she was editor of News of the World, responsible for payments that might have been made to private investigators or phone hackers but that was the remit of the managing editor.
Of the murdered schoolgirl Milly Dowler and the fact her phone was hacked, Ms Brooks said: “The idea that Milly Dowler’s phone was accessed by someone being paid for by the News of the World, or worse being authorised by someone at the News of the World, is as abhorrent to me as it is to everyone else.” Here is a video of the pie incident. Wendi Deng is in the pink jacket:
2. Review of BBC says it should devote less time to climate changer sceptics.
An independent review of the BBC’s news coverage in Britain has found it was not biased. But the review also found where there was a widely held scientific consensus on issues such as Genetically Modified crops, vaccinations and climate change, the BBC should not give airtime to ‘critics of the scientific consensus’. Should we do the same here?
3. World leaders celebrate Nelson Mandela’s 93rd birthday
The former leader of South Africa, once jailed during his fight against apartheid, turned 93 this week. In what has become known as Mandela Day, July 18 became a day for good. The United Nations recognises it as a global call to volunteer for a good cause for 67 minutes – one minute for each year Mandela spent active in politics.
4. I wanted to show this picture off: the Aurora Australis lights from space
This. Is. Beautiful. And it’s quite the send-off for astronauts aboard NASA’s last shuttle mission, on Atlantis. The shuttle has now undocked from the International Space Station on its way back to Earth for the last time. Sadface.
5. Teens reminded they can go to jail for sexting
Turns out pictures of boobs being bandied about among minors can land a young person in jail. For up to 10 years. The Australian Communications and Media Authority is asking teachers to remind students of the implications because it says not enough know. The images of minors are considered child pornography and anybody in possession of sexted images could be held to account. Just sayin’.
6. Rebecca Black has a new song! My Moment, for the haters.
You might remember Rebecca Black as that YouTube sensation who came from nowhere with the song ‘Friday’ which was one of the most universally panned songs in music history. It was a video clip made by one of those production companies where parents hand over a few grand so their kid can sing for a bit and look professional. You can listen to it here Well, whatever you think of the song (I personally think it’s kind of catchy and cannot get it out of my head) it launched her career. This is her second song, for all those doubters …








Comments
63 Comments so far
I think we should always give fair (and proportional) airtime to the critics of scientific consensus. I have researched a lot of the history and philosophy of science and there are endless examples of when the consensus is wrong. This has both been to political, social and scientific limitations.
This is a hugely important question – investigate the abundance of stories like Rachel Carson and DDT or Clair Patterson and tetra-ethyl lead and it becomes apparent how wrong science and scientific consensus can be and how much power and politics factor into the subject.
When poor old Boltzmann tried to convince the scientific community about the statistical basis of thermodynamics – No respectable scientist would have a bar of it. It was unimaginable that the vaulted laws of physics could be statistical in nature. Some say Boltzmann committed suicide because of the stress of being ostracised so severely by his peers (others posthumously diagnosed him as bipolar) . The statistically based second law of thermodynamics is now considered the most incorrigible law of phyics. I could go on ad infinitum.
One of the most fundamental aspects of the most generally accepted model of scientific knowledge and methodology is that it is based on the idea of refutability. Every theory must continually be subjected to rigorous and critical attempts to refute it. Science is not dogma – The current environment of science is hugely problematic. There should always be room for scientific dissent. Respect and time for scientists who go against the consensus. Debate should always be open and respectful.
It is the media’s role to be just as critical and skeptical. The public should always be treated as intelligent enough to be given all sides of the debate. If the science is valid and solid – community understanding and support will follow eventually.
What the BBC is doing is hugely wrong and dangerous and does not reflect the basic philosophy and logic of what science actually is. The adulation of supposed *scientific fact* by some people has simply substituted the unthinking, uncritical acceptance of religious dogma with a new *God* – ‘science’ – but is quite divorced from the formulation of the scientific method and theory. It can and often has been manipulated by those with an agenda and power.
We should most certainly not do it here. Ideally journalists should be challenging the scientists, seeking to prove them wrong, questioning them, making them accountable. Like they are supposed to do with government. I could go into considerable depth about this topic but this is just a quick post of my thoughts. I’m not saying give skeptics equal airtime but they should always be given a voice in the media.
And the Aurura Australias is sublime – I hope to see it one day with my own eyes.
loading...
Good on Rebecca Black for having a go and making the most of her opportunities. I think she has a terrible voice and I want to slap her because her facial expressions are so annoying, but if people keep watching her clips and buying her songs why should she stop?!
loading...
Rebecca Black defines everything I hate about mainstream music. No quality, all hype, and very average music. Ugh.
loading...
Who’s Rebecca Black?
loading...
Whenever there is a big issue, requiring a scientific explanation, in Australia that explanation becomes highly politicised. The Government of the day trots out their “experts” who produce their “reports” and findings, and any critics are roundly castigated, and any requests for explanations are sneered at for being stupid. I can give a number of examples, but would ask, are there any scientists left who can give an impartial opinion, and then tell the Government to use that opinion? Unfortunately, most top-level science is Government-funded and projects are skewed to secure the money. Shame really.
loading...
I’m not taking any side but full marks to Wendi Deng for rushing to help poor Rupert from a pie throwing ratbag. that’s the kind of partner we all need beside us!
loading...
I’m no fan of News Ltd or Murdoch, but a young guy doing that to an 80 year old bloke is not cool. Everyone’s commenting on Wendi’s awesome reaction, but I thought James was pretty good too – he (rightly) looked like he was ready to rip the idiot’s throat out when he reacted!
loading...
That song was OK. Not amazing, but not bad. A bit auto-tune.
I’m with you, Rick, I was singing Friday for weeks.
One thing I found really interesting (if a little left field and a lot off the topic of this article) was how Rebecca Black looks like a perfectly normal sized, thin even, teen and looks healthy. I always thought Katy Perry was curvy, fit but fairly normal sized. When you see Rebecca Black standing next to Katy Perry (in the video clip for Last Friday Night) suddenly Rebecca looks big.
It just really stood out to me that even when a celebrity looks a bit curvy and looks like they’re fit and healthy, they are still so much smaller than your average person.
I was also surprised at how short Katy is (or is it how tall Rebecca is?).
If you haven’t seen it, you can watch it here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KlyXNRrsk4A
loading...
Aahhhhh there you are Wendi – was wondering where you were during the last few days. I guess the fact that you had to rescue your aged husband explains your stoney faced expression throughout the hearing….or is it that you believe that he and the rest of the family are above the law??
While Rupert might not have known – he is afterall running the US operation and that disgusting ‘news’ outlet Fox News – I’m waiting for the US public to find out that his organisation hacked 9/11 victims phones and then see them lynched for it. Even though he’s denied it, I can’t believe that if it happened in the UK it doesn’t happen in the US….
James and Rebekah definitely knew. Why would you sign off a payment for $1m without knowing exactly what it was for?? Seriously.
And the Police Commissioner who couldn’t remember which bureaucrat told him not to tell the PM about the hacking….YAH…sure….someone gives you advice that goes against your judgement (and as you yourself said: your colleagues and your wife’s advice) but you don’t remember their name? Ok then.
loading...
“You naughty billionaire”… sorry I couldn’t help but laugh at that.
Let’s hope they get to the bottom of this – they all just seem to be blaming other people and not taking full responsibility for the phone hacking scandal. It is just shocking but boy does it make for some compelling TV viewing.
I wonder how they feel now being the headline… rather than the other way around. What goes around comes around.
loading...
If the guy was arrested for putting the pie in Murdoch Snr’s face why was Wendy not arrested for assaulting him???
loading...
Are you kidding? He deserved a slap after that!
loading...
No I’m not kidding! Bit hypocritical and all that guy did was put a cream pie in Rupert’s face and she actually hit him with her open hand! She was not the victim so it was not self-defence.
loading...
No I’m not kidding! She was not assaulted so it was not self defence and she slapped him with an open hand. She looked ridiculous in my opinion.
loading...
I was wondering the same thing, LPlates! The whole fiasco makes me cranky. At the end of the day the buck should stop with the ‘top dog’ who has no doubt fostered an environment of getting the job done ‘no matter the cost’.
loading...
Rebecca Black – good on you! She looks so sweet, like she is having the time of her life. Enjoy it while you can! Couldn’t believe it when she appeared in Katy Perry’s video clip of TGIF. Talk about Katy cashing on in the latest fad!
Whoo hoo to this! http://hasrebekahbrooksbeenarrestedyet.com/.
The whole NOTW saga just keeps getting more fascinating, not the least of which is Wendi Deng doing the slapdown! Excellent!
loading...
What I find really interesting about Murdoch is how he and his son have been coached in how to approach this.
He suddenly has white hair again after years of dyeing it per Wendi’s insistence.
He sits there, the frail old man “I know nothing, it wasn’t me”
Monty Burns couldn’t have given such a great performance.
loading...
So glad someone else noticed going from brown hair to white. With shock no doubt!
loading...
I’m sooo not following this news of the world scandal or the carbon tax. Does that make me abit ignorant? Probably! Neither of them affect me so I’m more interesting in reading about Kate Middleton to be honest.
Hence why I watch Sunrise in the morning, I need something light to watch over my morning coffee. I tell myself it is to keep my brain rested until I have to use it full throttle every day lawyering, but it’s probably because I just like light *generally* feel good news!
loading...
While I follow news, it is kinda vague. My mum did a course helping her to cope with her cancer treatment & recovery, the counsellors suggested they keep away from lots of heavy news as we take on the stress of things we cannot change/control. I’ve kept that idea with me for some years now.
loading...
Or even “some years now”!!
loading...
The news upsets me. It has since I was a little child. I refuse to watch it. I will have it on in the house but I don’t look or listen to most of it. I also won’t watch war movies, anything with hate crimes that’s based in reality or documentaries like that one about the cows recently.
I used to have people accuse me of blocking it because I don’t care, but it’s quite the opposite, I care too much and I get really distressed about it. Especially about things that I perceive to be so obviously wrong (like inequality based on gender or sexual orientation).
Don’t get me wrong, I will act against it. I’ll attend rallies, I’ll sign petitions, I just don’t want to hear the details because I’ll cry.
loading...
My favourite part was Rupes repeatedly saying that he had “come in the back door” of Downing Street because the Prime Minister had requested it.
Oh, and most interesting (of what I could stay up for) was him stating that he had lost 200000 paper sales for supporting the Labor Government years ago. No, of course the media is never biased and money-orientated! Ha
loading...
the NOTW scandal is fascinating, and appalling of course.
what i don’t understand is if these people didn’t know about any of the illegal activity, will the inquiry continue to question people further down the ranks to find out who did know, or will they just accept that and move on.
also, is there any plans for people to sue the company? i am sure milly’s family would be entitled to. not that i suggest it would lessen their pain at all, just that they would have the right to do so.
loading...
I can’t decide whether or not I like My Moment. Infinitely better than Friday. She does, I think, have the potential for a career in the kiddy pop market and that would be a good thing. It’s not the hyper sexualised crap of late so I’d back it.
loading...
Absolutely agree! She is at least singing of things she knows about while fully clothed – I think it should be encouraged! Just look how much she has improved with some professional help. Wasn’t it just a few weeks ago we were reading a post how music videos have basically become porn?
loading...
I think a pie to the face is little compensation for what those people went through…you can’t have all the money and glory without the responsibility at the end of the day.
loading...
Couldn’t disagree with you more. I found it extremely rude and disrespectful. No one deserves to be slammed in the face like that, if Murdoch has done wrong then he should get whats coming to him in the courts.
loading...
You should believe that he knew. Absolutely. If this was from left field, completely out of the blue then *possibly* but since 2003 (publicly) there have been issues w NOTW and don’t think for a minute Mr Murdoch would have turned a blind eye. The phone hacking has been going for YEARS and they have been publicly questioned about it.
Mr R Murdoch knows what is going on in his companies. He does, he is across it all. There is no need to “hide it from the boss” as an PP has suggested.
loading...
I guess “This is my moment” was a bit catchier than “This is my 15 minutes of fame”
loading...
I think banning ‘critics of the scientific consensus’ from tv etc would be one of the worst things we could do! What happened to free speech and democracy? I think the censorship of scientific debate would be another step towards dictatorship in Australia. Plus, since when did we as a race decide to stop questioning and investigating. People thought the world was flat once.
loading...
Not banned but more balanced would be good. Skeptics are getting way too much air time because it suits the agenda of certain media’s political persuasions (and parties’).
Being a skeptic is convenient because you can avoid the truth.
loading...
If you give equal time to a minority view it lends it credence ot the casual viewer. That said I agree that we need to keep an open mind!
loading...
“People thought the world was flat once.”
Some people probably still do.
And there are definitely still some people who disbelieve evolution. Doesn’t mean they should get equal airtime in science programmes.
loading...
‘I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it’
- Voltaire
loading...
I believe Rupert when he says he had no idea about the phone hacking. However, as the company head, he is responsible for the corporate culture, and I believe he should publicly accept responsibility. He’s the one counting the piles of gold, after all. The same goes for politicians who claim innocence when their department stuffs up. You accept the paycheck, you also accept responsibility. Otherwise, you’re accepting money under false pretences.
As for Rebecca Black – the autotune is making my ears bleed.
loading...
I watched the Rupert Murdoch clip a number of times.
Initially, I couldn’t stop laughing at Wendi Deng leaping up and open handed slapping the pie man, before falling down.
Laughed and laughed I did.
Then noticed something telling about the clip.
It was the *women* in the room that reacted.
I noticed that there was a woman in grey between the pie man and Rupert.
I noticed that the woman at the back of the room (not at the U shaped table) reacted first and stood up.
Then the woman to the left, seated at the table stood. The the woman next to the chairman reached for the phone. A woman in a tuxedo came running in from somewhere (along with the bobby) and shoved people out of the way.
Not to mention Wendi’s heroic sideways-leaping slap.
I also noticed that Rupert Murdoch barely moved, whilst people fell down around him.
He did nothing.
Says it all really!
ML
xx
(watch it again – it’s hilarious)
loading...
Excellent observation, Maximum Light! I noticed the same ting in the incident room photo of Obama, etc… during Bin Laden’s killing. Hilary Clinton’s face was the only one that showed a reaction.
Wendy Deng has a mean right slap!
loading...
I, too, would take a cream pie for my husband. Especially if it had a nice crumbly base and fresh berries on the side
loading...
You naughty naughty girl!
loading...
What?! I meant on a plate! WIth a fork! Sitting at the dinner table!!!!!
AGHHHHH!!!
loading...
I reckon that would have been a fair trade for my x husband.
loading...
You can’t overstate the satisfaction from a good dessert, eh?
loading...
That Rebecca Black video clip makes me feel kind of ill. The whole “ha ha in your face” theme, plus the “look at me look at me I’m famous with hair & make-up & fans & glamorous events to go to”… that’s not what being an artist is all about. Or maybe it is these days.
loading...
I thought it was more about turning the fact that she got crucified by the public into an opportunity – instead of hiding under the blankets like most of us would for the rest of her life.
At her age, I don’t think she really fits into the artist category yet, and most manufactured pop isn’t art anyway.
loading...
I don’t mind the media giving time to people sceptical of the scientific consensus, but what the media shouldn’t do is use these people to try and appear fair-and-balanced…but there also comes a point when you need to draw a line in the sand and accept that people like Monckton are just plain wrong…so I think the BBC is doing the sensible thing.
loading...
We need a Pastafarian movement of climate change to highlight the silliness of Monckton’s argument.
loading...
Oh Holy Flying Spaghetti Monster…we beseech thee to eat the evil demons of greenhouse gasses and spread thy love and chocolate ice-cream to all!
loading...
Who are you to say that they “are just plain wrong” I think we all need to accept that really, we know nothing, and that we should always continue to study and strive to understand more.
loading...
I’ll say it again. Monckton is just plain wrong.
http://www.stthomas.edu/engineering/jpabraham/
http://www.skepticalscience.com/How-Monckton-got-his-IPCC-predictions-wrong.html
http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2006/11/cuckoo-science/
And they are just the ones I can be bothered to post…
What have you go tin reply? Some opinion pieces from Andrew Bolt maybe? An interview with Alan Jones?
loading...
I cannot believe Rupert Murdoch does not take responsibility of it all. Fair enough that he was betrayed by people he trusted, but in the end he’s the boss and he is responsible. President Obama has a dollar framed in his office with a saying “the buck stops with me” and that’s something I as a manager abide by. So should Rupert/James…
Love the aurora borealis photo, so beautiful! I grew up above the artic circle and had the northern light outside every winter & midnight sun in summer. They are such beautiful natural phenomenoms.
I’ll reserve the right not to listen to Rebecca’s song as I don’t want it stuck in my head like Friday did…
Have a nice day Rick=)
loading...
Rupert Murdoch has 52,000 employees. How could he possibly know what they were all doing each day?
I have no idea what my receptionist us doing right now. If you work, look around and see if you could be responsible for the actions of 10 people in your environment, every single day for years.
loading...
I think the real test of any leader / chairman / CEO is how they respond to these issues once they know about them. And whether they had tried hard enough in the first place to carve out a dignified corporate culture.
loading...
Not to mention as we all know, decisions come from top down with the inherent understanding you do whatever it takes to follow through the top’s orders, as long as the top is kept clean of the methodology used.
I don’t buy Murdoch’s proclamations of innocence at all. He rules his companies with a tight fist and there isn’t anything he doesn’t know or isn’t at least aware of with regards to how people are getting these scoops.
I just hope this doesn’t go away as I fear it will – a mere blip on news corp’s radar before they’re back to having politicians and constabulary in their pockets.
loading...
This is not a receptionist we are talking about though is it? This is an editor, a CEO, a deputy editor.
We are talking a culture of shifting the blame, denying all knowledge.
loading...
i think the company can take professional responsibility without Murdoch taking personal responsibility …
loading...
i could actually believe that Rupert Murdoch didn’t know what was going on. If you were doing dodgy crap like that at work, wouldn’t you try and make sure the boss didn’t find out? also, he’s not based at the News of the World office, he wouldn’t know what’s going on every single day there.
loading...
Isn’t it his *job* to know? If something like this turned up in the US, at some important government department or a branch of the Democratic Party, does anyone really think that FoxNews wouldn’t count President Obama as one of those responsible?
loading...
Where did you grow up that was above the Arctic Circle??
PS Rick loving these newsbites although I’m sensing they kinda suck for you because you have to write them so early… Don’t know how you do it!
loading...
I grew up in Norway. Very cold but very beautiful.
JS – I don’t think you can compare not knowing what a receptionist does to what has happened here – he gets the big bucks, he is responsible for what happens in his company. That’s part of what being a CEO is.
loading...
I discovered Rebecca blacks new song last night on IMDb. It’s, ok. I don’t think she has a strong voice, it’s quite synthesized in this song. Catchy though.
News of the world are obviously back peddling pretty fast, surely they can’t get away with this.
And I love the idea of Nelson Mandela day. 67 minutes if doing something charitable toward others can’t be that hard. Can it?
And Rick I feel your pain of being tired. No cream pies for me though, just a sick baby.
loading...
Did you notice that Rebecca Black is in Katy Perry’s “last Friday night” film.clip.
loading...
Oh wow what happened to Rebecca Black’s voice she sounds slightly better in this new song lol was she faking the other one?
loading...