Do You Like This Story?
021951 cadel evans 380x213 Its been a Cadel of a week. Heres what I learned.

.

Timing is everything. On Monday, mine was lousy when Cadel Evans won the Tour de France and I unwittingly became the public enemy of anyone who’d ever ridden a bike.

I didn’t wake up with the intention of offending half of Australia. But by 8am, that’s what I’d done after appearing on The Today Show in my regular What’s Making News segment where Karl Stefanovic asked me to share his intense jubilation over Cadel’s victory.

I replied I was happy for Cadel but ambivalent about the over-the top adulation we lavish on sports stars and the way we’re so quick to laud them as heroes.

Have I mentioned bad timing? Bad. Timing. My first inkling that I was swimming against an almighty tide of patriotic sentiment was when the floor crew – many of whom I’ve known for years – jeered me loudly.

Gamely and somewhat clumsily, I persevered, trying to explain how I wished we afforded the same praise and glory to those doing amazing things in other, non-sporting fields. Karl got huffy at this point, calling me ignorant, demanding I read Cadel’s biography and pretty much accusing me of blowing my nose into the Australian flag.

I huffed back, insisting there were hundreds of unsung Australian ‘heroes’ whose names we’d never know because sport sucked up so much media oxygen.  Names like those two female surgeons who successfully separated Siamese twins Trishna and Krishna in Melbourne.

Who were they again?

Unfortunately, my exasperated eye-rolling and recalcitrant body language was misinterpreted by many as being disrespectful to Cadel and his stunning win. It wasn’t. I was simply exasperated with Karl. Business as usual.

The backlash was immediate. As the waves of online abuse turned into a tsunami, I was in tears before breakfast. By lunchtime, I was physically afraid to go outside. Cyber-bullying is like that. The anonymity makes you paranoid and fearful because you don’t know who your abusers are.

Seeing how shaken I was, some suggested I turn off my computer for a few days and wait for it all to die down. As a website publisher however, the online world is my workplace so I don’t have the luxury of walking away.

The responses fell into a few categories including many who agreed with me and many who politely didn’t. But the overwhelming majority hurled outright abuse. I was called every name you can think of – bitch, dog, skank, mole, idiot, loser, cow, slut – and many you can’t. Hundreds and hundreds of times. They denigrated my parents, my children, my appearance, my voice, my weight, my religion…. it was endless and still hasn’t stopped.

My point was simply this: why do we place such a disproportionate emphasis on sporting achievement in Australia? Why doesn’t success in other fields receive similar attention?

And what about the kids who don’t like playing sport or even watching it? The ones whose dreams, ambitions and interests lie in other areas? Where are their national heroes?

Sport has never been a big part of my life. My family love it but I watch a bit of the Olympics and that’s about it. I don’t barrack for a team. I don’t follow a code. The sporting victory of an individual or group, even on a world stage, has no particular impact on my life. Apparently though, this makes me unAustralian, an insult hurled at me endlessly this week on Twitter, Facebook and talkback radio.

The direct correlation between sport and national identity was highlighted to me this week. Loudly. But are you intrinsically more Australian because you love cricket or cycling or swimming? Nobody told me it was a prerequisite of citizenship (and yes, I was one of those people who thought it preposterous to have questions about Don Bradman as part of the test for new migrants).

Nor did I realise it was a competition – who can be the most Aussie. I didn’t even realise it was something you could measure. I thought you just were Australian. The end.

I’ve spent a lot of time this week trying to understand what it is with Australians and sport, why the connection for many is so deep, almost primal.

Maybe it’s because in a country that prides itself on being egalitarian, sport is intellectually and socio-economically an equal playing field. It’s classless. In fact, the more humble your background, the better; the underdog-turned-champion is a narrative that resonates powerfully in our culture. It’s what our sporting legends are made of.

We’re far less interested in the stories of our best doctors, writers, lawyers, engineers, teachers or social workers. Their triumphs do not capture our collective imaginations. Their names remain mostly unknown.

As for the word hero, it baffles me a little bit. We use it liberally to describe sports stars but few others.

When Margaret Olley died this week, she was not called a painting hero. When Emile Sherman won an Oscar for Best Picture a few months ago, he was not called a filmmaking hero. Cate Blanchett is not called an acting hero.

Professor Ian Frazer, who discovered a vaccine for cervical cancer is not called a medical hero.  Nobody suggested having a ticker tape parade for any of them.

I’ve learned a lot this week. I’ve learned that Cadel Evans is an impressive guy, worthy of respect and admiration for his work on and off his bike. I’ve learned that many Australians turn vicious if you question the role of sport in our culture. I’ve learned that there are still many reasonable people who can disagree without resorting to abuse. I’ve learned that the cycling community are a tightknit group who are intensely passionate about defending their sport. I’ve learned that the Amy Gillet foundation works tirelessly to keep cyclists safe on roads that are often hostile. I’ve learned that many riders feel persecuted for simply doing what they love. I’ve learned that hero is a subjective and often personal word.

More than anything, I’ve been reminded that we need good news, especially in the form of a sporting victory that can be easily understood and widely celebrated.  I now see that Cadel’s win was a welcome bright note after a weekend of depressing world events. If I was a killjoy for detracting from that, I’m sorry, because it was never meant to be about Cadel or cycling.My timing clearly sucked.

The dedication, determination and sheer physical prowess of sports stars cannot be understated and may well be admired.

I just wanted to make a plea for other stories to be told, other achievements to be valued and other kinds of triumphs to be celebrated with the same fervour.

And from everything I now know about Cadel Evans, he’s the kind of humble person who’d be the first to agree.

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

482 Comments so far

  1. Pingback: 12 Posts of Christmas: In Defence of Mia Freedman. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  2. Pharme545

    Hello! cbcakgd interesting cbcakgd site! I’m really like it! Very, very cbcakgd good!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Pharmd88

    Hello! eeekkak interesting eeekkak site! I’m really like it! Very, very eeekkak good!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Kevin

    Hi Mia,

    Your comments above really resonate with me. I’m a proud Collingwood supporter; however, I do not let it get in my way of my pursuits and interests. There is far too much hype surrounding sport and celebrity status as heroes. I ask this to all future young children- Who are your role models or heroes? A standard answer will include: Lady Gaga, Justin Bieber, Superman, 50 Cent, Britney Spears not to mention their favourite footy players.

    Now ask them this question- Name me a notable heart surgeon, brain surgeon or medical scientist. Most likely they will be unable to come up with a name.

    I can name quite a few:
    Don Esmore, Victor Chang, Christian Brizard, Christian Baarnard- heart surgeons
    Charlie Teo, Andrew Kaye, Wirginia Maixner, Kate Drummond, Jeffrey Rosenfeld- neurosurgeons
    Chris O Brien- head and neck surgeon; was on RPA before he died a few years ago :(
    Ian Frazer, Sir Peter Doherty, Sir Frank McFarlane Burnet, Sir Gustav Nossal, Barry Marshall, Elizabeth Blackburn- distinguished medical scientists and researchers
    Sir Fred Hollows- acclaimed opthalamologist
    Fiona Wood- specialist burns surgeon

    Now, does that list sound a lot better compared to the following:

    Brendan Fevola, Matthew Newton, Shane Warne, Tiger Woods and billions of other so-called media personalities that stir up trouble….

    Exception: Roger Federer and Rafael Nadal…terrific tennis players and ambassadors for the game and children at least :)

    In short: give me that first list of medicos and Fed express/Rafa over all others any other day.

    Sorry to hear about those arrogant comments Karl directed to you- I don’t watch TODAY. The production crew and Karl should hang their heads in shame; at least you demonstrate the ability to think before saying something :) - a skill that sadly most people are unable to do.

    Finally, whilst I have nothing against Cadel Evans victory and having an Aussie winning a world title event- well done, I would like to see our newspapers and media outlets provide more substance and variety in giving the above list of scientific people that I mentioned above a fair go :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Sammy

    Hi Mia,
    Wanted to comment to counteract any flack you’re copping for your Cadel comments.
    Completely agree, I am just not that interested and I ride a bike and want to be in the tour down under. Good on him, well done for reaching the pinnacle of his profession. Lets have a parade, and celebrate his achievements, look up to him and admire his dedication but we don’t need to make out he’s the best thing in the world… ever.
    Good on you for coming out with your opinion and don’t let this stop you from doing it again.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. lara

    Mia,
    So refreshing to hear your comments.
    Thank you for saying what you did. I was cheering you on, and think it’s about time that we gave more credit and celebrated others who have achieved great things. I thought the whole ‘celebration’ of Cadel was OTT to say the least. Keep speaking you mind :) x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Anonymous

    I have previously showed a deep respect for Karl, but after watching his ignorance and disrespect I have changed my opinion about him completely. It is fantastic to see Cadel Evans in his brilliant state of victory for Australians, but I however don’t really care, sure I can’t ride a bike all over France and really I don’t think it matters. If you think about the millions of people with cancer over the world we could be spending our time on much more valuable things. The young generation has already started to realise that you may only receive recognition by sports or entertainment. So in say 20 years time, when Karl asks “where is my doctor?” well I will say to him: ” Sorry mate, he’s going city to surf on us”.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Alison

    I totally agree with you on this issue Mia. I’d love to see St Kilda road closed for a parade honouring Tim Costello. The backlash against you is embarassing and a very poor reflection on many Australians.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. fifijean

    Mia, I heard you speak about this on the today show and I was so happy to hear someone else with the same opinion as me. This week my sons school principal sent the weekly newsletter out urging parents to use Cadel Evans as a role model / hero to our kids and going on and on about how much he could inspire our children. Well, my son doesn’t like sport, he doesn’t worship sport people and probably never will but I am expected and encouraged by the school principal to sit my son down and give him a lesson on Cadel Evans amazing life and acheivements. I am a social worker, I am no hero, we are the most low paid of all professions, we carry with us a responsibility that many people never stop to comprehend. Most people couldn’t imagine some of the things we face on a daily basis. Children being abused, dying in front of you, intellectually disabled people living in horrific conditions and the list goes on. I think you are right when you say that Doctors, Social Workers, Teachers and the like are the real heroes of our country. Good on you for speaking up! Sometimes this countries obsession with sporting heroes makes me ill. I felt sick that the principal expected parents to present yet another sporting person to our kids as a role model. I will be making sure my children understand who the real heroes of this world are. The people who sacrafice their own wellbeing and sanity for those less fortunate in our society. Those that educate our children so their futures may be brighter. Those who save lives, most importantly the people who are kind and show their kindness to fellow human beings.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Charlotte

    I Completely agree with you Mia, I have nothing against sport, but am totally not interested in it. Good on them for doing something they love, but I think its so much more important, like you say, to celebrate the people that do it all for others. Sporting people are pretty lucky in that they get paid for their hobby and reep the rewards for themselves and putting everything else on the line for their own victory. Some people say it puts Australia on the map if someone wins big, but I honestly don’t see how important it is in our society, a countries sports achievements never crosses my mind. As said on the can of worms show, 15 minutes of the nightly news is taken up by sport, now I’m not saying we should be ignoring sport but couldn’t they squeeze in 5 minutes of good news such as reporting about people who are doing amazing things for others?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. suemcarthur

    Hi Mia, I didn’t realise how bad this had got until I saw it on Can of Worms tonight. I am ashamed of my fellow Australians that can’t take a differing opinion that is well considered and simply from a different point of view. I received a similar response personally when I refused to wear yellow at work to celebrate his win, as I have no interest in the event, no interest in cycling and had more important things to deal with. I hope that you have been able to put some of this idiocy behind you and realise that you have much support, even from people who disagree with you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Amanda

    Weather the storm. Cadel is a fantastic sportsman and seems like a pretty nice guy. But you are right that there are many eminent Australians in other fields whose successes go unsung. Hang in there. Lots of us agree with you. Good on you for having the courage to voice these views on morning TV.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Albers

    Hi Mia.

    Looks like you hit a raw nerve, the raw nerve of hypocracy that not only surrrounds the achievements of sporting stars, but also the hypocracy that surrounds the ordinariness of the majority of people and their lack of achievements.

    Sports stars are not real “heroes” but are competitive high achievers in a narrow field which requires a strong goal oriented mindset. To my mind real “heroes” are people such as Fred Hollows, Victor Chang, Mother Teresa, Father Chris Reilly, etc who help others in ways that sports star could never hope to match.

    Another sad fact is that this “so called” sporting nation we live in continually vies with the US to be lauded as the most obese coutnry in the world. Many of your critics would fall into this category, the couch dwelling, TV sportsperson whose greatest sporting achievements involve repeated dashes to the fridge for the next beer during the ad breaks!

    Cheers

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Daniel Wayne

    and i base that on all the people you mention in your article. basically all women.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Daniel Wayne

    if a woman had achieved the same feet i have a feeling she would have acted differently

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Anonymous

    I think the problem is that the type of people you consider heroes aren’t given the adoration they deserve. Therefore giving thait to the sporting people seems unbalanced

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. picardie.girl

    Beautifully written, Mia. It’s great to see a ‘what I learned’ post after the storm you’ve weathered. Love your work xx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Ashley

    It’s a fairly sure sign you’re on the right side of the argument when most of your detractors can’t even string a coherent sentence together. Or when their vocabulary seems to consist exclusively of words like “bitch” and “slut” ( or the utterly meaningless “unaustralian”. I think it’s entirely appropriate that achievements in sport, as in any other field, should be recognized. But sportspeople seem to be accorded something beyond recognition; some kind of demigod status where they’re considered beyond any kind of criticism, or even a balanced, level-headed evaluation of their achievements (hence last week’s outcry). It’s seems downright bizarre to me that people seem to be able to help themselves to a sense of vicarious accomplishment based on nothing other than shared nationality. (The same doesn’t work in reverse, of course. I doubt we’d all be collectively beating ourselves up if Cadel had lost). Also observe how, when asked what material difference Cadel’s victory makes in the grand scheme of things, Karl had to invoke the vague notion of “inspiration” (read “nothing tangible”).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. chon

    now that was a beautiful post Mia.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Roger

    Cadel is a nice guy, and a champion. To me hero’s risk their all for the benefit of other/s. I can’t ignore the hard road sports people take to reach their goals, and I admire them, and they are champions, hero’s are different.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • suemcarthur

      Beautifully put Roger. Weary Dunlop and Nancy Wake were heroes, Don Bradman and Dawn Fraser were great Australians.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. masd

    Oh Mia! How anyone could hurl abuse at you for a reasonable and rational point of view???
    Doesn’t that say more about the type of person who exhibits such hysterical behaviour? It’s what turns me off supporting sports events.
    Stick to your guns, your opinion is very valid!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Cathy

    Mia, I was watching the Today Show when you were on and I was both delighted and nervous for you.

    I used to think I enjoyed watching and talking about sport. Hell, I even studied a sport and recreation degree after leaving school! I was a volunteer at the Sydney Olympics!

    However, I now realise that I actually have no interest in sport at all, and possibly even hate it, for the following reasons:

    1. It is really boring.
    2. Elite sportspeople must, to succeed, be selfish and narcisistic.
    3. Performance enhancing drugs make me cynical of what is really behind that broken record.
    4. Boofy, drunken, loutish behaviour by sporting teams / spectators leave me cold.
    5. The countries that spend the most money get the most medals.

    Am I un-aw-stralian? You betcha!

    Mia, I admire you for saying what you truly think. Don’t you go changing now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. El Belle

    Mia, you get to win this round against the haters. You have the power, the readership and the intelligence to make the changes you wish to see in Australian culture. You get to feature the people you want to see and hear about, dang you get a Media pass to meet them! For this, I’m jealous.

    People who hurl abuse at you aren’t going to get very far in life and are simply uninspiring.

    So, Mia what have you done today?

    Published a website that has inspired thousands and encouraged open discourse about changes we wish to see in society.

    And you, abuse hurler, what have you done today?

    Called some chick I never met a mole and abused her family because I like sport.

    P.S I’m so sorry you were subject to so much cyber bullying too, I’d be freaking out, I can’t take insults at all! Good Luck xx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Russell

    to quote a very funny line and to assist in drawing a line in the sand on all of this…’the sea was angry that day my friend….like an old man trying to return soup in a deli’……
    I’m sure of one thing here, having followed the bouncing blogging ball…nice alliteration eh? We respect those we relate to. Have a lovely afternoon.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. L

    oh Mia I don’t think you have learned enough. Why are you wondering if Cate Blanchett should be called a hero? I thought you wanted to celebrate the everyday hero???? This site is based on celebration of celebrity culture I think you need to lead the charge in featuring stories about everyday heroes and their wonderful achievements and stop talking about it!

    It is not about timing and not about Karl – it is about you and the disrespect you displayed. I am a great fan of your work but you are digging yourself into a deeper hole on this one. I suggest you move on

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. Jane

    One of those neurosurgeons was Wirginia Maixner, I can’t recall the other one right now. Wray, maybe? But I’ve met Dr. Maixner and I think she would be a great candidate for a feature on this site. She was a single parent when she studied to become a neurosurgeon and is just an amazingly strong, intelligent woman!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Carmen

    Hi Mia

    As a long time reader let me start by saying that i have enjoyed your articles and comments over the years. I have laughed ,cried and support you in everything you do. More power to you girl!! :)

    BUT (and don’t hate me for this), I was a little dissapointed in your comments regarding Cadel. I find most sports silly and cannot stand football, but as an Australian I was genuinely happy for him to win what cyclists regard as the hardest contest in their field.

    Whether or not he is a “hero” is just a matter of opinion. I don’t think he is a hero like a war hero or a surgeon who saves lives. But he is a sporting hero. And that’s fine isn’t it. Let him have his little moment and let us enjoy it.

    We all know that Australians hero worship sportspeople. All I have to do is look at my husband! But he’s harmless and it keeps him out of my hair most weekends, LOL!! I just accept it and move on. Let them have their silly games. They aren’t hurting anyone.

    I think now is a great opportunity for you to really focus on some of the people who we all think are under represented in our community. It would be fantastic if Mama Mia could really be the groundswell that makes a difference to the world!! Let’s start it here. C’mon guys!!!! As Mia said, let’s see more heart surgeons, social workers, refugee advocates, indigenous leaders, youth workers, disability workers, nurses and many more great Australians on Mama Mia!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Dougle

    Just wondering if you ever read this quote from Cadel, Mia?

    Before or after your rant?

    “Trying to bring awareness of the Tibet movement is something someone in my position can do. I just feel really sorry for them. They don’t harm anyone and they are getting their culture taken away from them. I don’t want to see a repeat of what happened to Aboriginal culture [in Australia] happen to another culture.”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. mel

    I agree with everything you said right up until health and beauty. this blog is more than that. belittling it doesn’t strengthen your argument it weakens it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Asianplumb

    It’s true what you said to Karl..we do put too much emphasis on sporting heroes and forget the real guns in our lives like Gabby +Fred Hollows, Victor Chang ect..What wasn’t pointed out was the deliberate newspaper/tv/radio push to keep the general public’s eye on some sporting stuff rather than on the length of the queue at hospitals/railway stations/freeways and help desks all over the country.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Thomas Paine

    I agree with Mia pretty much 100% and I think she said it way better than I ever could.

    The pouring of emotion into one’s chosen team – whether it’s rugby, baseball, soccer or something else – is not for me. Eels vs Manly? I don’t care who wins. It doesn’t matter. Somebody has to win; somebody will win the Premiership. How many times have these two teams played each other? It must be hundreds. I doubt the same team won each time. Whatever hard-fought competition goes on this year, the whole thing will be repeated next year. And so on, ad infinitum.

    It’s enough to give a person the impression that the strong bonding of individuals to sporting teams is being exploited for pecuniary gain.

    I can appreciate a good performance or a lot of effort put into an achievement. I can appreciate the effort and sacrifice. But why should I be euphoric because Cadel Evans won the TDF? Because he’s Australian?

    If Cadel didn’t win it, somebody else would have. Somebody else who would have put in about as much effort and sacrifice as Cadel. They might be French, or British, not Australian – so what? Winning a race is not heroism. Somebody’s got to win it. If effort and sacrifice is heroism, then all the riders are heroes. But I agree with Mia; being able to run really fast or jump really high or ride a bike really hard is really a selfish accomplishment and not on the same level as hard working scientists or nurses who help humanity or teachers who inspire the young. Those are the people we should be celebrating, precisely because they’re not in a competition for which there is guaranteed to be a winner.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. DAL

    I have often wondered if it possible to direct some of the attention, money and resources that go into sport into something more worthwhile than putting a ball in a net etc. Could we invent an exciting sport, with large sponsorship dollars, worldwide television audience and genius participants which has an outcome that is useful to society? Competitive bridge building anyone….?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Aden

    I agree that the extent to which we idolise sports stars in this country can at times get ridiculous. Sports are great and we have a strong sporting tradition in this country but we can tend to go overboard at times. At the end of the day he won a bicycle race people… a bicycle race!?! He is a hero for his sport but not really for the whole country. A hell of a lot of Australians could not give a rats arse about the Tour de France.What about scientific achievements? Consider these relatively unknown Australian inventors for e.g.
    * David Warren invented the black-box flight recorder
    * Earl Owen pioneered microsurgery
    * Graeme Clark developed the bionic ear
    * Sir Howard Florey shared a Nobel Prize in 1945 as co-discoverer of the antibiotic penicillin
    * James Harrison devised the sulphuric ether refrigerating system for a brewery in 1860
    * Ralph Sarich engineered the orbital engine.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. vanessayoung

    You are right Mia, the word “hero” is very overused. It was clever of Cadel Evans to win the Tour de France. But he is a professional sportsperson and was, to a degree, just doing his job. I think Karl is paid to create controversy and he did it in an unecessarily nasty way by calling you UnAustralian. I have always considered excessive patriotism dangerous, see where it has lead us in the past. And I agree that there are so many unsung heroes in our community, and I am sure that Cadel Evans, Ian Thorpe, Cathy Freeman et al, would balk at being labelled heroes. It is also unfortunate that Cadel will follow others into oblivion and, next week, Karl will be calling someone else a hero. I am calling myself a coward because I wanted to comment during the storm last week, but I was overwhelmed by the hatred and dwonright meaness directed at you. If I felt that way, I can only imagine how you all felt at Mamamia.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. whatahooha

    Does Karl always give you the shites Mia? I have no time for him ever since his ‘interviews’ of bushfire victims, during which he came across as heartless, arrogant, and so full of his own important deadlines and live crosses he didn’t notice the tragedy laid at his feet.
    Perhaps Karl, too, is incredibly selfless and caring, but surely on live tv it is more important to _appear_ caring than to actually _be_ caring.???

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Sue

    Bravo Mia! I liked your comment and it in no way disparages Cadel. He is an articulate, dedicated professional. Aussies don’t appear to value much other than sport. How can we teach our young ones about the value of all endeavour and achievement?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Anon for this

    Mia, hope the abuse stops soon… same thing happened when JTynan said ‘motherhod’s a breeze’ (and yes, I did lambast her into space only later in a moment of clarity to realise that all mothers are different … just like our beautiful babies!) I digress… your comments were badly timed and delivered but honest and I don’t actually disagree. Its a shame it was Cadel Evans and not some thick necked football player! Sports in Australia is part and parcel of our culture but the heriosm and worship of sports people I find distasteful and uneccesary. Melbourne’s worship of the AFL players is abhorrent. Every boring story of these overpaid, under educated, knuckle heads is front page news… really? And everytime one of them goes up in front of a judge/jury for a ‘misdemeanor’ they get off scott free! Ludicrous. Appalling. Wrong. And these players are treated like Gods. Disgusting. Mia, I hope those who have been hurling abuse at you recover their sense of humour soon. No doubt there will be some coming my way now. LOL

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. David

    I agree totally with your article. I didn’t see the television programme but according to your account, you didn’t need to apologise, although I can understand why you did so. Things are out of balance when all the oxygen, funding and support goes to sport and sports people; ask any artist, in any field practically, how difficult it is to make a mark. What you said was very, very important.

    Best wishes

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. bec

    Mia, I think it’s really unfortunate the amount of abuse sent your way for expressing your opinion. I think you made some good points, even if they could have been expressed a bit better, and you didn’t deserve such horrible treatment. However, if you really cared about the ‘heroes’ you speak of such as surgeons, researchers and all the rest then perhaps you could take some leadership and devote more of your blog space to opening people’s minds and less to beauty and pop culture. On the hero scale, Cadel sits far higher than Miranda Kerr in my opinion and look how much more worship she gets!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Gerald

    Hi very agree with your sentiments, not that there is anything wrong with celebrating sporting success, but Australians don’t seem to do the same for other great people – scientists, doctors etc. A great shame

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Anne

    I agree with you about sport. Those people who abused you (the majority) are proof of the attitude of most human beings: me, me, me and bugger everyone else!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. Trudi Counsell

    Great response to a week to forget Mia. I love social media & all the great connections it allows us to make – however the abuse you were subjected to shows the dark side. Nobody should be subjected to such a response. Just chalk it up to experience & think how prepared you’ll be next time!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Elizabeth Cooper

    I’ve thought the same thing as you about sport for years. Well done for saying something.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Catherine

    Yep, it was poor timing – but explained like the way you have above, I do agree with you. Though perhaps one of the reasons we don’t celebrate the lives and achievements of many is that we don’t have the chance to follow their story in the same way. There’s Australia’s next great author, Nobel laureate, or social justice hero out there, but we can only learn about the trials and tribulations of their story after they’ve achieved. With our sports stars, we can witness their failures, their comebacks, their setbacks in real time.

    In other matters, I am appalled to hear the way you were bullied online. Your comments may have been mis-timed, but I can’t understand people who get vicious like that. I hope you’re feeling safer now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. John Garrett

    Mia, your comments were entirely appropriate, no apology necessary. I am a cyclist, a sometimes racing cyclist, a participant and follower of other sports, and I enjoy and admire but do not adulate the success of Australian sportspeople. For many of them after all it’s their job, and they should be good at it. By all means let’s celebrate and share their successes, but in proportion. The abusive comments you received say more about the senders than they do about you: what shallow lives and values they have, what poor substitutes for true patriotism.
    You and I know true heroes, not from the battlefields of war or sports but from the very difficult challenges of daily life: the disabled, the single parents, etc. and in particular those who help them. Just one example:
    I recently heard of a young woman with two children 3 & 5, recently widowed, who has gone back to studies to become a teacher while working part-time and caring well for her children. That is true heroism, she is an Australian to be proud of.
    Keep up the good work.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Dan

    What a load of rubbish Mia, don’t listen to these people. Your comments were spot on. The word ”Hero” is seriously overused, I love my sport but he is just an exceptional athlete, nothing more, nothing less. and any success is primarily for self satisfaction and national pride an added bonus! Definately not a ”Hero”!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. A

    I love your point about kids that don’t like sport. growing up I hated all ball sports, most team sports and the whole idea of competitive sport. did that make me an overweight, unmotivated kid who couldn’t work well with others? no. I stayed fit by swimming with my friends (for fun) skiing with my family (for fun – we lived near the snow) and dancing multiple times a week. I learnt about teamwork and leadership through dance, playing in lots of different bands and orchestras, and student council at school. I was motivated to do well academically and in my music exams. I got outside in the fresh air on family camping trips and duke of edinburgh expeditions. despite having such a well-rounded childhood I still felt somehow inadequate because I couldn’t catch a ball or run fast.
    Australians (and particularly Australian schools) place far too much importance on being good at sports. I’m not saying that sports are bad, but kids should feel like there are more options out there for them.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. JosieY

    You are so graceful and lovely Mia, especially when compared with some of the abuse thrown your way. You can be my hero!

    (tongue in cheek here people…)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Carole

    At the risk of being called un-Australian too, I don’t follow sports or a team either. I too only really watch the Olympics. But I did think it was great what Cadel did. But the abuse you copped is appalling and definitely not deserved. People need to lighten up and not take sports so seriously.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. mayberry

    I do agree with this – sports gets such an over-representation in our popular media, and it shits me that things like medical research (my personal bugbear), education, science in general, even financial stuff, has to play second fiddle to people who (essentially) play games for a living.

    pursuing pro sports has always struck me as a peculiarly selfish pursuit – they go on about “oh the sacrifices i make and how hard i train” when a lot of the time, it’s their parents and other siblings who cop the brunt of the hard slog required to get to elite athlete level – early morning trainings, weird diets, all the energy and focus on that one child

    and it’s their choice to pursue this career – i don’t do press conferences about how much it sucks that i’m on a microscope till 1am all week, because it’s my choice, my career, and i love what i do without banging on about how much i’ve given up to do so!

    _rant_

    anyway, it also shows in popular culture’s attitude towards children. from a very early age, the sporty kids are popular, whilst those of a less athletic nature are “nerds, losers and geeks” which is really sad! we should celebrate and popularise ALL people who are passionate and good at what they do, not just those who are at the top of physical pursuits, and then maybe kids who aren’t athletic won’t be bullied as badly!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions