Do You Like This Story?
Feng Jianmei1 News: Forced to abort her baby at 7 months

Feng Jianmei

 

 

 

 

Warning: this story may be distressing to some readers.

This woman’s name is Feng Jianmei. She was  seven months pregnant when the Government forced her to have an abortion two weeks ago.

Twenty-seven-year-old Feng is a victim of China’s one-child policy, which restricts the number of children people can have in an effort to control country’s growing population, which is now up to 1.3 billion.

She already has a 5-year-old daughter and so her second pregnancy was considered illegal. The Chinese Communist Party enforce the one-child-per-couple law through birth control, heavy fines and the threat of violence.

But in Feng’s case, that threat became reality.

Last week she had her head covered, her legs beaten and was dragged to a vehicle. She told local media that she was taken to hospital where she was given injections to stop the fetus growing and force her into labour.

Feng and her husband, Deng Ji Yuan could not afford the $6,300 fine for a second child because Deng’s mother “needed money for cancer treatment” and so forced abortion was their only option.

As if that wasn’t horrifying enough, it was also a crime.  Chinese law prohibits abortions beyond six months. So even though Feng’s pregnancy was ‘illegal’, what the authorities did to her was also against the law.

Feng’s sister took this photo (and another more graphic image which we have chosen not to publish but you can view it here if you wish to absorb the full horror of Feng’s situation), which has now gone viral around the world.

The Washington Post reports that while previously Feng’s forced abortion would have received little public recognition, the limited access Chinese nationals have to social media has now finally allowed women like Feng to tell their stories.

As of Thursday (June 14), comments on Feng’s abortion neared 1 million on the Twitter-like microblog site Sina Weibo. Many of the comments were calls to relax the restrictions on births that have been enforced for more than three decades.

The government’s first reaction to the outcry over Feng was that the abortion was merely routine law enforcement. A statement posted Monday on the government website of Zhenping County in Shaanxi province stated that officials, “according to the law, carried out the termination of the out-of-policy second pregnancy of Feng Jianmei” on June 2.

As the fury grew, a preliminary investigation was conducted, after which the government admitted Thursday that it was wrong. The late-term abortion was a “serious violation” of national policies, “damaged the image of family planning work and caused extremely harmful social impact,” said a statement by the Shaanxi Population and Family Planning Commission.

Three officials were suspended Thursday, the China News Service reported. The city mayor delivered $785 as compensation for the loss to Feng’s husband, Deng Jiyuan. It may take much more to calm the storm.

The United States have reaffirmed their opposition to the one-child policy just recently, after activists reported that a five-month pregnant woman was facing a forced abortion.

The case is a tragic one for Feng and her family but it also raises broader issues around the tightly controlled media in China. While access to mainstream social media sites like Facebook and Twitter is banned and the internet and wider media tightly controlled by the government, alternative social media outlets are increasingly popping up so that the Chinese can tell their stories to the world.

Our heartfelt sympathy to Feng and her family….

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

114 Comments so far

  1. Jennifer

    We are told everyday to protect our “choice” & to fight to keep politics off our bodies! How can we demand this within our borders but sit here & condone policies that are destroying our bodies & rights in other countries? How can we not call this hypocrisy at its worst!

    We are all women! It doesn’t matter if we live in Australia or China WE ARE ALL WOMEN! If we condone this than are we not indirectly allowing our government to consider or implement policy that impacts our bodies in such a way? It’s not like we can say “well we will allow this to happen in China because of the number of people in a country but we wont allow anything remotely similar to happen here” or can we?

    This could be our daughters in a generation! This could well be a photo of your daughter & granddaughter in 10 or 15 years time!

    Go & read the stories of Chinese mothers, I can strongly suggest Letters from a Chinese mother.

    I’m horrified by this story but I am more horrified that Australian women can sit here & say this is okay because it is policy!

    Since when do we sit back & allow such unfair & horrid policy to be inflicted upon our bodies? … Ohhhh wait I’m in Australia & she is in China

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ana

      How do you feel about the fact that in China women use their ability to chose to undergo sex-selective abortions? The sex that they are aborting is female…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  2. Pingback: The Things in the World You Can’t Believe Actually Happen. | kloesampson

  3. Nope

    No – I completely disagree with the tone of this article. Was it a terrible thing to happen? Yes.

    But this couple CHOSE to get pregnant again. China’s population is out of control, and this policy is trying to counteract the huge problem they are facing.

    People need to realise we live in a world of finite resources and having more children is not the answer.

    A terrible outcome, but one brought on completely by the couple in question.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • aura

      If you read the article, then you should have seen the point where it says that such action is ILLEGAL even in China (to abort a pregnancy after 6 months) therefore, because it took place it is awful!!! As a student of Chinese history and policy, the chain of comand in china is incredibly corrupt, local officials often do as they please and because of this such cases happen which is just dispicable (especially since if they had more money they would have been able to keep the baby). Yes the world is over populated but that is not the burden that only a few nations have to carry and such policies do not always help. It is because of such policies that gender inequality is so high and causes its own MASSIVE issues.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • aura

        Sometimes I wonder where the empathy and compassion in the world has gone :( You never know what you would do in such a situation and circumstances!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Miss

      Yep. They completely deserved it. So do all those women out there whose husbands beat them – because they married them. And children who are beaten for having messy rooms, spilt food and tears? Totally their fault.

      Having more children is not the answer – for some, like those who make thoughtless comments like these.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  4. kiwichick

    good to see at least some people understand the magnitude of the challenges facing China

    after 33 years of their draconian, disgusting and appalling so called one child policy China is overpopulated by a mere 804 million people

    that’s a mere 34 times Australia’s total population

    no worries, nothing to see here, let’s get back to complaining to about the unbelievably expensive carbon tax which is about to destroy Australia

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Simone

    I clicked on the link. I wish to God I hadn’t. I’m heartbroken.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Charlie's Mama

      same….. it makes me so angry/sad/frustrated/desperate for things to change

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lj

      I agree, I wish I had never opened the other pictures. I can’t even make a proper comment it was so awful. I agree there are too many people in this world but that poor woman and that poor baby. Just awful.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Ladybug

    This is horrific, and I clicked on the link to see the other photos. I read this post before I read our home grown drama of people not eligible for Family Tax Benefits blah blah blah well if this article about this poor lady and her baby doesn’t sit the whiners on their backside, gee well what will. Get some perspective people. We have it too good here, maybe that is our problem.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. lauren91

    I made the mistake of clicking the link to see the more graphic image. You’re right, it is very graphic and disturbing. That poor woman. I will never understand how that country works.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. archie

    Seriously? $785? What a pittance for a truly horrifying experience. She was kidnapped, beaten, and her child was murdered by corrupt officials. How the flip is that supposed to come anywhere near close to compensating her?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ana

      Well, yeah $785 is a small amount of money… if it’s in RMB (CNY), but if that AUD that would be RMB5093.82 and for a farming family that’s about a years wages. So that’s probably not an unreasonable amount of compensation. Nothing will ever bring the child back to the family, but some perspective is probably appropriate.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Ladybug

      Well over on the other post you would think from the carry-on $800 is worth the world.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. Anonymous

    Yes, I wholeheartedly agree that it is atrocious for anyone to have a forced abortion at any time. It is equally terrible for this to be done due to possible corruption by local government officials.

    I would really like everyone who reads this to also reflect why the policy is in place. A government’s job is to ensure the growth and future of it’s nation and it’s citizens. A country like China has a large and exponentially growing population. As much as we like to think resources are limitless, this is not the case. Currently, China has 1.3 BILLION people. The world only has 7 billion. So in one country, under one government, there lies the livelihood for 20% of the world’s population alone (and this is after 30years of the 1 child policy). That is immense pressure on that government. They recongised this problem and realised without extreme measures, the country would not cope. They had to act, and act quicky to control the population within a few generations. If they didn’t control population growth the country would collapse into famine, poverty and other resource related problems.

    With these statistics in mind, I think it answers Mamamia’s question of “why?” the government has this policy and therefore enforces it. Most women in China do not suffer forced abortions. Most women in China comply with either having one child, or having more by applying to the government and paying money, whether they agree or not. If the government did not enforce it’s policy then it’s population would have exploded to unmanagable proportions and this would mean greater strain on the resources and more suffering overall.

    I hope this answers your question.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cathrine

      I believe there are 13 million abortions in China a year. Now just because they were not treated like Feng does not mean some of these women were not coerced. They know forced abortions happen,(so they may choose to go and get the abortion befoire the authorities come to get them) and that there are penalties for having more than one child, so there is more subtle ” force”‘ exerted on Chinese women.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        Yes, Cathrine, there is force. I did not say there was no force, coersion or influence. Maybe I should have said “most women are not physically beaten and drugged to have abortions”.

        I am actually a child born under this policy. My mother, and aunts were directly under this policy. My mother also had abortions under this policy. However, we ALL understand the purpose, goal and necessity of the policy as well.

        Maybe I should also bring some personal experience into this to explain my point. My mother was born in China in 1962, she has 3 brothers. Her mother, my grandmother, was free to have any number of children. However, they were poor. She could not afford an abortion and did not wish to have 4 children, but she did (I would also like to point out, at this time, contraception was basically non-existent). They lived in a one room cottage that is about 25sqm with no heating despite the winters being up to -20 degrees. In light of this, she had to give up her oldest son to relatives otherwise her other children would not survive as they would not have enough food. This was my mother’s childhood, she was poor, hungry and cold because whatever little resource they had was to be shared. She also grew up without her eldest brother. ‘Giving’ children to relatives in times like this was very common.

        I was born in 1988. I did not have siblings, and my mother did not contemplate how many children she would have because she understood and accepted she would only have one, me. I also grew up in a one room dweling, though mine was an apartment and not a cottage. I did not have to share the resources of my parents. I had a happy childhood, with enough to eat.

        I am sorry for the suffering like that is highlighted in this article, but if the policy did not exist, the overall problem would be greater. I don’t agree with a lot of things the Chinese or any government does, but on this point, I understand the “why”.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  10. Amanda

    Well said Jackson. When it comes to reporting global news, Mama Mia can be as bad as 60 Minutes, A Current Affair, Today Tonight etc. How dumb do they think their readers are? Please do your research when reporting on important issues like this, or do not bother at all. Stick to what you are good at. And you are really good at so many things, but this piece is so disappointing. Really disappointing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Sarah in Sydney

      I am fully aware that forced abortions occur all the time in China, that did not stop me being appalled by this story. The story of THIS woman being forced to abort her seven month old, totally viable baby. Just because it happens all the time should we not share this story with the world? If this is the story that gets people’s attention then I say good on MM for doing a piece on it. The bottom line is that this a horrendous practice, even more so because this is not an anomaly. We all need to be educated about this and hopefully enough of us will feel so include to speak loudly about how abhorrent this is. Who knows if our voices will be heard, but I for one want to try.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sarah in Sydney

      Sorry Amanda, I didn’t mean to post this as a reply to you. It was meant to be a separate post.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Anonymous

    I am horrified that this has happened and what disgusts me even more is that actual human beings allowed this to happen… they administered the drugs and forced her birth… How can anyone do this?
    The photo of the baby lying lifeless next to her is just absolutely HEARTBREAKING!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      Some of us chose not to look at that image not to be traumatised even further. I didn’t appreciate you telling me what was in that photo at all.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        I have to say I wish there was a flagging of what the photos were of so I knew whether or not I was prepared to see it. Blood I could handle, the baby…I don’t need to see that. Better to have a warning so people can choose I think.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Ana

          Out of curiosity, what did you expect to see?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  12. Anonymous

    Wow. I had no idea this policy was still in place. Imagine how many other women have been through this trauma. It is something you would never get over. The Chinese government has a lot to answer for when it comes to crimes against humanity.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • femme

      This stuff has been reported since the 80′s, forced abortion I mean.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Ana

      These forced abortions go up to and include partial birth abortions. You should know.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Catherine

    For more information about China’s one child policy and forced abortions check out
    http://www.allgirlsallowed.org/forced-abortion-statistics

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • catherine

      I think Mama Mia staff should have given a bit more background to the story. Forced abortions are commonplace in China, Feng’s is not an isolated case

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Sophie

        I don’t really understand your point. Are you saying that Mammamia shouldn’t report on this story because these kinds of things are so commonplace in China that they aren’t important?? As human beings we must stand up to this kind of horrific policy and put pressure on the Chinese government to end these inhumane practices. It is important that these stories ARE reported.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • femme

          I would have thought catherine’s point was the opposite.
          More that this is a very important And commonplace issue, so it deserves better coverage and better standards of reporting.

          Funny how we all see different things, isn’t it?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Ana

            I so agree. There’s so much important background to this piece that’s been missed out. It’s clear from the comments that people have a very limited knowledge and understanding of China, and it just isn’t right. It’s the worlds most populace country and every decision they make impacts us. That includes what they do about the population issue, because what they do about that will have a great bearing on what happens in the future in regards to first world issues such as climate change, the cost of oil, aims and standards of education, and how electronic goods are produced.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • juetsrey

        The fact that something is ‘commonplace’ doesn’t make it any less horrifying. Or wrong.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • femme

          Yes. I think most of us would agree on that.

          In fact some might say it makes it more horrifying and wrong.

          Which is why some more background would have been good.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  14. pinksparkle

    I’m pretty sure this is not the first of it’s kind to happen in China. It’s simply horrible. I understand the one-child policy, but forcing abortions on women, especially after 6 months is just wrong. I looked at the graphic images of the foetus- i was horrified, it was a fully formed dead baby that could have survived had it been born naturally. It’s the fact that she had no control over this, over her body that really angers me.

    I’m totally pro-choice and would personally have an abortion if i got pregnant now, but i don’t think anything should be forced- whether it be keeping a baby or not

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Anonymous

    i am hard to shock, i truley wish i had not clicked the link. OH MY F##KING GOD!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ana

      Such a beautiful baby, hey :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Luc

        I don’t think a smiley face has any place in this debate.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Ana

          Well, I didn’t realise that it would look like it was on ‘uppers’ when I did it, clearly a smiley on uppers is inappropriate. Never the less, it is a beautiful baby, so perfect and completely formed.

          As the parents of stillborn children learn to do, that mother will one day look at those photos and while she will always feel sad, hurt, traumatised etc, she will also see the beauty of her child and remember the joy of it’s life, short as it was

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  16. Rudge

    Beyond words – the only positive is that the internet is enabling stories such as Fengs to reach the rest of the world. How many other attrocities have been committed in China that we don’t know about?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Petal

    Dear U.N. have you ever heard of this word – SANCTIONS. NOW.

    This is fucking appalling.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ana

      Erm… that wouldn’t do a thing to China. They are entirely self sufficient and actually a fair bit of the western world is dependent on China staying open to foreign trade. Sanctions would only hurt us.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • kiwichick

        hi ana

        just wondering what makes you think that china is self sufficent?

        i suspect that quite a few australian companies would disagree with you

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Ana

          Good question. At the moment China is taking advantage of the work that Aussie companies put into prospecting etc. It would be naive however to assume that they don’t have access to raw materials from other sources. A land mass as large as China has its own raw materials, its currently just easier to source them here. There is historical precedent that if necessary the Government of that country would simply send every citizen out with a shovel to mine the street in front of their dwelling (I jest a little, but the precedent exists that what the government needs it gets. If that means re-skilling and re-settling all of its citizens for a new purpose you bet that will be your next career move)

          It’s also important to note that there will be countries which don’t observe any sort of sanctions/embargo’s. They already trade with China things that our government won’t sanction. They will provide China with what they have/need and thats actually not something that we want – a bunch of rouge states providing stuff to China and receiving payments in kind (thing arms etc)

          In considering all this it is worth noting that China has only been open to outside trade for a few short instances in recorded history, mostly through just one or two ports (Macau and Shanghai). The most recent period of isolationism ended in the late 1980′s/early 1990′s. They are practiced in isolationism and so if sanctions were imposed they would most likely change the national agenda to suit. That is the beauty of a totalitarian state.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • aura

            There’s no way that China has enough of its own raw material to keep its growth advancing (which is what they want). They also have their own oil and gas, but also, not near the amount needed to keep industry afloat. Should they get them from other sources not currently used, they would still be from nations abroad.

            The ONLY reason sanctions wouldn’t work is because china can vetto them.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • Ana

              Sure, China is advancing at the moment, and of course that’s what they want and would like to continue. However we’re talking about the same government that has allowed citizens to die from famine because they refused to accept external assistance (30 million in 1958-61). If they don’t like what’s getting out (or in) they simply close the doors. It’s extremely narrow minded to think that its not possible that it will happen again.

              As for being supplied by nations abroad despite sanctions, yes, that’s what would happen. Goods would still be provided – but probably by rogue states (because not everyone will observes UN sanctions) or they would come through ‘back door routes’ (countries that agree to the sanctions and officially observe them but ignore privateers who act unofficially to supply those things). So what would happen is that the black market economy would get a bit of an economic stimulus package.

              If you’re unconvinced it’s worth doing some reading on the character and behaviour of communist governments, because weather we like it or not, China is still a single party state, and they tend to behave in their own unique way.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
  18. A-Dubbs

    I am totally horried by this. Horrified.

    I just can’t believe it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. MissV

    So once you’ve paid the fine for having a second child, I’m assuming you get to keep him/her?

    Basically it’s a one child policy for those who can’t afford it and have as many as you want so long as you can afford to pay.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • D

      I was wondering the same thing…………

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Petal

      I always thought you were taxed more if you had a second child in China.

      Hey, China, surely that is a better option than forcing a woman to abort. YOU THINK?????????

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • alliekat

      From speaking to a Chinese friend, she said if you do have a 2nd (or more) child, you are fined plus I think that child is not entitled to any govt resources for life (eg school and medical etc)/ So yes, I guess the rich could afford to fund that themselves and the poor cant. Scary stuff… incomprehensible really!! :(

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Ana

        I worked in a private school in china and that was one of the things I noted at the school is it was populated by rich families who only qualified for one child, but because they had money they could afford more children, and to send them to school/have health care etc.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  20. Langlands

    How about everyone (including those who THINK they support abortion) have a look at the D&X methosd of abortion, still used in Australia. I challenge you to not be OUTRAGED and sickened.

    This is in AUSTRALIA.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intact_dilation_and_extraction

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • A-Dubbs

      Sorry, but I don’t see how this is relevant at all.

      For me, the issue that this woman was forced to abort her child. It’s not about the abortion debate at all.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Catherine

        Well I think it is relevant, because if Chinese officials think abortion is Ok, forced abortion may not seem such a bad thing to inflict on people. After all if you think a baby is not a baby until it is born, then you don’t respect its right to life when it is in utero . Whether it is born is up to the mother or in China’s case , the authorities.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • lauren91

        I agree. Such a reliable source, too. Wikipedia…

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • JazzyJ

          For Feck’s sake Lauren…..do the research, there is a Dr in Brisbane that performs the D and X method.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • lauren91

            Not sure why you said that. I’m not saying it doesn’t happen, I don’t doubt that it does. I’m saying that Wikipedia is not a reliable resource, because it isn’t. Anyone can edit it, ANYONE. Not the first place I’d be going for facts.

            Obviously my comment was unnecessary, my apologies. However, the original comment was also unnecessary on a post like this, as was yours, really.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
      • femme

        Absolutely it isn’t about the abortion debate, but I’m not surprised at all to see the anti-choicers/forced pregnancy gang jump on this!

        These people aren’t the smartest cookies in the box.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Catherine

          Femme calling people who disagree with you “” not the smartest cookies in the box”" is not an argument. Put up an argument instead of attacking those who disagree with you

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • femme of pro choice land!

            I’m not arguing, Catherine.
            I have no intention of engaging in a ‘choice’ debate with you or anyone.

            I am Commenting.

            It’s allowed. We all have opinions!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
    • Sweets

      I think it’s pretty disrespectful to use this post to push your agenda. Not cool.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Jess Powell

      I am apalled after reading that… Now THAT method is murder…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      Ok I’ve read the article, right down to the last sentence: “only ever likely to be perfomed in order to reduce maternal mortality or severe morbidity”.
      Do you have a suggestion on what they should do instead, or do you advocate doing nothing and letting the mother die?
      In AUSTRALIA women are able to make that decision themselves, rather than having it made for them by someone like you.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • femme

      de-railment/agenda alert!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • hh

      I think the point that Langlands is trying to make is that if people are pro-abortion then they technically should not have an issue with any type of abortion,it is taking another life without their consent after all.

      Langlands,I commend you showing that link but will warn you that you will not get any well thought out responses,just more of the same mantra”it’s my choice,it’s my choice,it’s my choice”.Keep it up though!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Langlands

        Anyone who does that to a baby is scum.

        There are so many childless ppl, why wouldn’t they give the baby up for adoption. SO cruel.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • femme

        It is still about choice for pete’s sake.
        The mother’s choice!

        Is that a bit tricky for you?

        A pregnant woman should chose to keep her baby or not keep her baby..
        Not the state, not you.

        And really people are generally not pro-abortion they are pro-choice. You are being ridiculous.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Langlands

          Aborting a baby at 7 months +??????

          Why not abort at 2 weeks?

          A fully formed baby???

          Pond scum X 1000

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • femme

            I said:

            The state should not get to chose.

            YOU should not get to chose.

            The pregnant woman should decide what is right for her.

            What are you on about?
            You sound… unsound.

            And I can’t believe I’m debating choice and allowing this ‘derailment’. This article is not about the abortion debate.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • hh

              Just curious about how people would feel if this women hd chosen to have an abortion?It would have been her choice,you really could not be upset……or could we?I believe that the reason there is often so much grief surrounding abortion at any stage of the pregnancy is that the Mother knows that she is not fulfilling her duty to protect her unborn child,deciding instead to eliminate it for what ever reason she has decided was more important.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • hh

              Femme,who is going to be the voice for the unborn though?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • femme

              hh
              this is not the time or place.
              This argument has been done to death.
              Find another site to ‘discuss’ this and your mad ideas.

              All of your questions have been answered ad nauseum in many places.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • hh

              Femme,not sure what “mad ideas”I have expressed,could you point them out please.
              You are willing to try and shut people up in regards to this issue but yet do not seem to want to try and address your contradictions in the argument that you have stated earlier about the only choice that is correct is the one the mother makes.If you really believe that then surely you will have no problem with people choosing late term abortions.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • Catherine

              Femme, I don’t know who gave you the right to dictate the terms of the debate. When did you become the arbiter of what is relevant or not?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
            • femme

              Just my opinion Catherine!

              You get to have yours too!

              Someone else might enjoy having a pointless pro-choice vs anti-choice/forced pregnancy argument with you though.

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
  21. Siata

    Not enough birthzillas in China hey Mia?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Buster

      What a pathetic comment.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Addie1

      What a ridiculous response to this article

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. Ana

    I am agains abortion, forced or chosen, for medical or socio-economic reasons. IT’s all wrong. I wonder if people are outraged because the child was killed or because it wasn’t chosen by the mother?

    I lived in China a while back and while I could never agree with forced abortion, you can’t possibly understand what would push a government to take action like that until you’ve lived somewhere like that. It is madness! Like it or not it really is necessary that the Chinese government have some sort of *enforced* policy over the issue. My greatest concern over this whole thing is that China will again close it’s doors to the rest of the world and it will be even more impossible than it is now to interact with and monitor what’s going on with human rights there.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Kate O

    I understand the need for a one child policy (whether I agree with it or not), but this is ust beyond necessity, this is horrific. I looked at the photos and my heart is breaking for her.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. catherine

    Forced abortions have been happening in China for very long time they just have not received much publicity. Feng’s forced abortion is not an isolated case. I hope Feng can access psychological support and treatment, as having looked at the photo of her baby lying dead in the bed next to her, she obviously is fully aware of what she has lost.

    I worry she and her husband will be punished for highlighting human rights volations in China but hope this helps to stop forced abortions in China

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Hayley

    How is this happening??

    As much as we may complain about our government, the banks, water bills, ect.. this makes you realise we are so lucky to live here…..

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. Mum to be

    I was horrified by this – being 7 months pregnant myself, I cannot imagine the horror this woman and her family have been through.

    I agree with comment by Sarah in Sydney – please include warning that the picture shows the aborted baby, not just that the picture is graphic – I also was not expecting to see that and was quite distressed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Laws for Clouds

    Feng Jianmei was actually permitted a second child as she lived in a rural area, but she failed to submit the paperwork to get permission. Then she was told to pay the money, which she didn’t have, as a fine for failure to submit paperwork.

    She did not get pregnant accidentally knowing about the one child policy, she got pregnant knowing she and her husband were permitted a second child in their area (in China you need a kind of visa to move from area to area) and she is being punished for a paperwork issue.

    http://www.smh.com.au/world/a-forced-abortion-for-a-mother-who-failed-to-sign-a-form-20120615-20eu6.html

    This link contains some images and descriptions that could upset people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Another Anon Guy

      Puts a different light on things doesn’t it. Some corrupt officials asked for a bribe and then kidnapped her and tried to ransom her back to her family. Authorities have acknowledged the abortion was illegal and is investigating. So it was more like a corruption issue.

      Higher authorities will possibly come down very very hard on those responsible.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Ana

        I mean no disrespect but having lived in China you need to know that corruption runs top to bottom and the length and breadth of the system. Most likely what will happen is that they’ll do whatever needs to be done to look good and then they’ll slip the officials some cash under the table later. Or, they’ll execute someone… that’s just how it’ll go

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Another Anon Guy

          No disrespect taken. It wouldn’t surprise me if what you said is precisely what happens.

          The high ups will do whatever they have to do to fix this, not because of the corruption, but to ‘save face’ in the international media. I wouldn’t want to be one of the officials that got caught now the stories out.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  28. Sarah in Sydney

    This is truly horrendous. Appaling. Does MM have any suggestions as to what we can do to show our support for how abhorrent this is? Should we be petitioning our government to respond?

    Also, can I suggest that you also include in your warning that the photos show a picture of the aborted baby, I wasn’t expecting them to be quite that graphic. I know you did warnthey were graphic but I wrongly assumed just more graphic pics of her.

    Thank you for sharing this story. The world need to know about this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Another Anon Guy

    Firstly what she is going through now is horrible and I feel for her.

    That said she knew the laws and could have used birth control or saved for the 2nd child fee before getting pregnant.

    So while what is happening to her now is disgusting, it could have been avoidable by her own actions.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rose

      Accidents happen when it comes to birth control, and it appears they couldn’t make the money because they had to pay for a family member’s cancer treatments.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Jess in Melbourne

      Yes she broke the law – but is that justification for the ‘punishment’?

      I would suggest not.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lily

      Just because laws exist do not mean that they are in any way right. It is troubling for me to think that people blindly follow authority, even when doing so has consequences such as what happened to this woman.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Laws for Clouds

      See my link above, it appears Jianmei was permitted a second child.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Another Anon Guy

      I knew I’d get a response like this. Empathising with the women does you all credit, but there’s more to it than looking at it in isolation.

      Again I’m not saying she deserves this. That would be horrible.

      I’m saying it could likely have been avoided.

      Yes, the laws themselves are harsh, but from a bigger picture point of view it relieves population pressures on China which could otherwise ultimately lead it to invade other countries (including Australia) in a resource grab to supply its populace. Its drawing a long bow, but a larger China could lead to Australian sons and daughters being killed in the future.

      I would prefer to see more planned parenting, higher standard of living and life expectancy along with education as we’ve head in the West which has naturally reduced population growth. Its a lot nicer than hearing about stories like this.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lily

        Let’s say there was no baby to begin with. Beating a woman or man as punishment is wrong enough in itself to illicit a strong reaction.
        This never should have happened. Period. And by saying this I am not trying to “get all the credit” by having empathy for this woman – this is an anonymous forum – but because it is a gut reaction. Your statement is somewhat disturbing to me…it suggests that basic morals and decency must be faked.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Another Anon Guy

          That isn’t how I meant it. I meant it in a way to say that I’m glad you’re empathising with the woman’s pain and its good to see people being human.

          I’d be worried if people didn’t bat an eyelid, especially after seeing the pictures.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  30. Burvy

    Why did I click on the link? Now I want that image out of my head and I can’t get it out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      I’m pregnant, so thought best not to click on the link. I guess I can imagine but I don’t want to know. Her story is so sad.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. Sweets

    Absolutely horrifying and heart breaking.

    I clicked through to the image not shown here and am left a bit speechless to be honest.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Lily

    I am appalled. This poor woman and her dear little lost baby. I cannot think of a word that is strong enough to express my disgust for the Chinese Communist Party.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Lauren

    My heart goes out to this woman and her husband. The picture not published here really drives home how awful this is.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. whatahooha

    I learned the other day that it is not a blanket 1-child per couple policy, but only applies to certain “ethnicities” of Chinese.
    The minority ethnicities are allowed as many children as they like, and indeed will have 7, 8 to get that precious boy child.
    To me, this makes Feng Jianmei’s (political) situation even more bitter, as other people in her country are allowed to reproduce at will.

    The horror of her personal grief is too traumatising for words.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • jess88

      That’s interesting, whatahooha, do you know how they catagorise the different ethnicities to apply this law at all?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • whatahooha

        I don’t know. I have not been to China. I was told by someone who recently visited there.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Ana

        Yup, its really easy. Han (majority of the population) are confined by the one child policy. This means that if they themselves were born under the one child policy (so, people roughly in their late 20′s now) in which case they may have two children. For the “minority people” (about recognised 54 minority groups) and/or those living in a rural are (I believe) you may have two or three.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Anonymous

      Hi whatahoola,

      The Han ethnicity accounts for over 90% of the Chinese population, so the policy is not there to punish the Han, but more a matter of perserving the many other ethnicities that do exist but are grossly under represented and are in danger of disappearing. It’s not a matter of playing favourites but more to do with perserving multi-ethnicity.

      Also, just incase you’re interested, the Han ethnicity being so large has nothing to do with the current Chinese government but was a result of emperial wars, take overs etc, many years ago.

      I just wanted to clarify that for Mamamia readers as I got the impression your comment implies the Government playing some sort of game with it’s application of the policy.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • whatahooha

        Thank you. I understand the policy. I did not mean to infer anything like that.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  35. jess88

    God, this is wrong. So wrong. Lord. I can’t even get the words out. I hope the mayor also compensates for the therapy this woman will need to attempt to deal with her experience.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alexandra

      That’s a nice idea in terms of justice, but somehow I don’t think this poor woman will be given therapy. She will probably be left to try and find a way to live… or not… with this herself. It is disgusting treatment of a citizen by their government. :(

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  36. J

    That is truely horrible! puts a lot of things in perspective for me on a day where all i had to complain about was how cold it was.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Ruth

    Shaking so much I can hardly type. Horrific.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions