Do You Like This Story?
ali mcgregor 380x570 A manifesto: I will wear short shorts

Ali McGregor

 

 

 

by ALI MCGREGOR

I have spent over 20 years feeling fat. For the last 6 years I have rarely gone to the beach, rarely let anyone photograph anything but my head, rarely shown my knees or arms in public. In that time my weight has gone up and down a lot and each time it goes up it goes up a little more and each time it goes down… well you get the picture.

But honestly, I can now say that during those 20 odd years I have only really been overweight for about 4 of them. And that includes being pregnant and post baby with the extra kilos that I am still trying to shed.

For a lot of that time I have worn baggy black clothes and covered my beach body with sarongs, kaftans and shame. But that has to stop.

When I was growing up I never thought twice about my body. It was a vessel that helped me climb trees and and roller skate and eat and sleep and watch Rage. My mother and father were very present and very hands on and completely disinterested in vanity of any kind… I was a small kid, always the smallest in my class and had a group of close (and gorgeous) friends that are still my best friends today.

I remember in primary school being introduced to the concept of ‘wearing the right clothes’ and ‘looking a certain way’ but it was only in year 11 that I started to think about my weight. I was very little and my school was very into rowing so it was only natural that I became a cox (for those who are unfamiliar with rowing, a cox sits in the stern of the boat, yells at the crew and steers). You had to be around 45-50kgs to be a cox (anymore and you could slow your boat down).

It was all going well as I was very good at telling people what to do and shouting. But then, in year 12  suddenly I shot up and of course, as a result, I put on weight. To try and keep my place in the crew I started to diet, run, make myself sick (which A LOT of people do without thinking of themselves as bulimic) and even though I was tiny, my height meant that I could only really get down to 53kgs which wasn’t ideal. Now I was the same height I am now – 5’6″, and by any estimation 53kgs is tiny at that height. But in my mind I was huge and a failure and a life of poor body image had begun.

Since then I have ballooned (usually when unhappy or bored), lost weight (through diets or once from heartbreak which was scarily effective but not advisable) and have spent far too many hours thinking and worrying about my boomba-ness. I went to a diet doctor who gave little pills laced with amphetamines which made me lose heaps of weight but sent me a bit loopy (feeling speedy during the day when there is no dance floor in sight is very disconcerting). I even went to one nutritionalist who, when I had only lost 1kgs one week told me “you don’t see fat people in concentration camps!”. I left him soon after as looking like I was literally dying was not the visual image I was aspiring towards.

I have stopped eating carbs, got Giardia (also very effective but not advisable) and done Weight Watchers. The latter has been pretty good and I now have the points system in the back of my mind with diet and tend to eat pretty well as a result (nb NOT and advert, just a fact).

I have never been much into sport and LOVE my food. I love eating it, cooking it, sharing it, talking about it, reading about it, taking photos of it (food shots make up a good 10% of my holiday snaps) and thinking about it. But ever since I turned 30 my body doesn’t cope that well with all of this food and no exercise and I have become a little unhealthy in the last few years.

I had a baby nearly two years ago and I LOVED being pregnant. I didn’t care about the fatness because having a baby was all I ever really wanted and I loved eating and drinking chocolate Big M’s and rubbing my big ol’ tummy with glee. When I was breastfeeding I had  a massive appetite and put on heaps of weight (I don’t know how much as every since the ‘rowing period’ I have refused to weigh myself as it does my head in). But then the breastfeeding stopped and the hormones went back to normal and I felt fat and useless again.

But here is the thing. I don’t want my baby girl to ever feel fat or useless. I want to tell her everyday how beautiful she is. I don’t want her to see her mumma worrying about her fat arms or complaining about her McFatty thighs and hips. I want her to see me wearing shorts and skirts and bathers in public. I want her to be happy and love herself and not judge others by their looks. I want her to be everything I have not been in the past 20 years. I look at her little gorgeous chubster legs as they run along the beach and wonder at what point do they become something to be ashamed of?  I hope never.

So I have started running and looking after myself. I have started wearing short shorts and started playing on the beach with my baby wearing only my bathers and dodgy tan lines. I haven’t yet steeled myself to show my upper arms in public but this will come.

orange shorts 380x276 A manifesto: I will wear short shorts

Shorts, anyone?

I have decided to stop buying the trash mags. If I see another article on Miranda Kerr and her amazing post baby body I may slap someone (side gripe: who decided that she was the ideal person to sell clothes to women? She seems like a lovely person but she has the figure of a teenager and actively makes me want to boycott DJs and Grazia mag who both think she is some sort of super-being who can change the world with her little head, long legs and hot husband – MAKE IT STOP).

This is all very personal and probably a little too much information but writing it has been my therapy and I know that so many beautiful woman around me feel very similar. It shocks me when ladies I have known my whole life confess to feeling fat. Even the one friend who has been referred to by every ex boyfriend I have ever had as ‘the pretty one’ and still looks the same as she did when we were 21, worries about her weight. THIS SHOULDN’T BE!

I want my daughter to spend her time thinking about important things like world peace, science, art and cute boys. But I can only shield her until she goes to school. What if the other kids have mothers who are verbally stressing about their weight and their looks? How will she be able to avoid it then? The only answer is if all of us mothers get it together and start loving ourselves a bit more.

I have a husband who is more than happy to take of his artificial foot and hop down the beach, I have been watching Matt Fraser ‘The Freak’ in the ‘Freak and the Showgirl’ act who was a thermaldahide baby and who is glorious on stage stripping and contorting with not a shadow of shame or embarrassment at his ‘less conservative’ limbs. How can I be worried about my slightly pudgy size 12-14 thighs and voluptuous yet wobbly upper arms without being a total dick? Because really, WHO CARES?

Not me. Not any more. I will wear short shorts. The end.

Here is Mamamia’s own positive body image manifesto. Enjoy.

What is a woman *supposed* to look like?

Ali McGregor is a trained opera singer who, after singing for years as a principal soprano with Opera Australia was lured into the dark world of cabaret by La Clique & The Famous Spiegeltent. You can find her blog here.
Will you be wearing shorts this summer?

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

125 Comments so far

  1. Eva

    Hear hear! thank you

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Erica

    thankyou so much for this article! It’s beautiful and sad and funny and true.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. maggie

    I feel very lucky to be an hour glass shape.

    But over the last 2 years my hips have popped out a far bit further and due to lack of exercise, I have a fair little food baby (as I call it). I cant find any short that get over my hips and don’t give me a muffin top, that are flattering also.

    I also have skinny little legs, and combined with the hips, nice jeans have been hard to find to.

    So I will be staying away from shorts, and wearing maxis!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Melissa

    Thank you Ali for sharing your thoughts. I must admit I was a bit shocked that you have such insecurities because you are so beautiful and absolutely mesmerizing as a performer, it’s hard to imagine you could think that you are anything other than magnificent. Why compare yourself to Miranda Kerr? That’s nuts. I’m glad you no longer want to step in for her on the catwalk, she could not step in for you in the Speigeltent. I like to compare myself to the people on Embarassing Bodies, that show is great for making me feel stunning (and then Hoarders to make me feel like my home should be featured in House & Garden).
    I could closely relate to your piece but not necessarily about body imagine. I’m really hoping that my kids will have stronger self esteem and self respect than i have had in the past. I know I’m a role model for them so this desire has forced me to treat myself with the level of self esteem and respect that I want for them. It is confronting and challenging but it is so important to me.
    Thank you again, you are wonderful.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Mimi

    fab post love it!!! we are all beautiful in our unique way ^_^

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. sharoncello

    I love this post Ali – thank you :)

    I don’t wear shorts. I don’t think they enhance my body shape at all (I’m a cello – big boobs, big arse) – but I really rock a dress. Having said that, I’m not going to let another summer pass by covering up at the beach – life is far too short for me to care anymore about what strangers think of my lumpy custard thighs!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. bec22

    would love to wear daisy dukes….if it wasn’t for those pesky stretch mark’s. :( Spent hundreds on creams, and too poor to try anything else. I would love to wear short shorts, but settle for ‘mum’ shorts that will do until someone invents a miracle cure that actually works! but more power to you….I just would like to keep that certain ‘mystery’ about what lerks beneath :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. lunch time shopper

    Literally, just came back from a lingerie excursion to purchase something “a little special” – not something that I’ve done since I became pregnant around 5 years ago! Sheesh. Felt sad remembering what my body used to be like and feeling ashamed about what my hubby will see when I put on what I got…. so it was such a lovely delight to come and open up this post when I got back… just what the doctor ordered!!! Thank you! A few little tears when I flicked through the photo images. :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Tenzi

    Don’t do shorts. It doesn’t matter if you’re size 8 or size 28, shorts look hideous on any adult who isn’t climbing a tree or partaking in a similar activity (in public).

    You shouldn’t need to show more skin to feel good about your body.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Chicken

    Hi Everyone and the Mammamia Team, guys, I’m not sure if you have looked around you but the reality is that many people around us DO look like models in magazines. At least in the city I live in they do. However, they are all probably under 25 years old. I think sometimes the issues get muddled because there are heaps of real live beautiful girls around who look the way that the models do in the magazines. They are just young!!!! Maybe what we should be asking of the mainstream media is to publish pictures of older women and to resist the urge to glorify youth so much…I don’t pretend to have all of the answers but some of this is just to do with accepting the passing of youth. No most of us don’t look like the images we see in magazines but plenty of under 25′s do. We have all had our turn at looking our best (usually when we were younger).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. picardie.girl

    I love this. Well done, Ali.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Sarah

    On Miranda Kerr – YES YES YES!!!!

    “who decided that she was the ideal person to sell clothes to women? She seems like a lovely person but she has the figure of a teenager and actively makes me want to boycott DJs and Grazia mag who both think she is some sort of super-being who can change the world with her little head, long legs and hot husband – MAKE IT STOP”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Anonymous

    i don’t get what the big deal is about not wearing things that are unflattering…
    this is just like the post on leather pants… why do we all need to wear leather pants… or skinny jeans? i don’t wear shorts. i don’t feel bad about it. they just don’t look good on me. do i look at girls with their bum cheeks hanging out shorts and feel bad about myself? no. i own what i’ve got and i rock it out!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Denise Duffield-Thomas

    Beautiful slide show.

    Diversity is good for business.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Caz

    Not sure about the comment that models are usually blonde in slide 8. I am not really up on models but the ones I know (Ie the very famous ones) are not blonde. Miranda, Naomi, Elle, Helena, Chirsty, Linda (showing my age with that list!) Anglo saxon, yes, blonde, no.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Anonymous

    I’m 5″6 and throughout my teens and early 20′s I weighed approximately 56kg. During those years I refused to go to the beach unless I was wearing a pair of board shorts because I thought I was too fat.

    Now I’m probably 10kg heavier but happily wear a bikini to the beach. I’ve found that my confidence has grown as I’ve grown older and I only wish that I didn’t spend so much time before obsessing over every little flaw!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Pingback: On the short shorts manifesto: Mamamia and body image |

  18. 1984

    I’m 6 months pregnant at the moment and as guilty as I feel for thinking this way – I HATE my body right now. Obviously, I love that I have a healthy little baby in there and that I am nourishing and supporting her, but from a purely aesthetic perspective, I find my shape so repellent right now. I will certainly not be wearing shorts for a while!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Rose

    “Thermaldhyde…”? Must have been administered by the “nutritionalist”
    Do you perhaps mean thalidomide? nutritionist?

    It’s Monday, and my inner Grammar Terrorist is having a brief outing :)

    And by the way, I LOVE La Clique and the Spiegeltent, have seen both shows – you rock!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ali McGregor

      Rose,

      I am an awful speller and didn’t even notice this although both scream out to me now of course! I have corrected these mistakes on my blog and will ask the kind people at Mamamia to change them also! I like grammar terrorists and find myself doing the same (although with general grammar – obviously not with spelling) so I thank you! xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. chelle

    I think it’s important to be happy with your body (whatever shape/size that may be), but I also think it’s important to be healthy. I’m a wife and mum of 2, and with a history of heart disease and diabetes in my family – I want to be around for quite a while longer.
    It has taken a while after my 2nd daughter – but I have decided now is the time to shed the weight and get into shape.
    My goal is to be able to run – and you know what, I will wear lycra at the gym! ;)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Teacup

    Test post.

    I am having no luck trying to post on this thread. So frustrating!

    Please MM can you find my post!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Shorts for all!

    Great article Ali!

    Now I’ve got that “who wears short shorts” song with Homer Simpson singing “I wear short shorts” stuck in my head…

    BTW can anyone reccomend a good place to buy shorts?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Cathy

    Great article! I think I remember Mia writing in an article once that ones legs are not getting any younger so probably not going to ever look any better than they do now – so embrace above the knee attire!
    As an aside – you are up on a pedestal in my eyes – you’re married to that spunky Adam Hills!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Niconic

    Ali, you are so gorgeous. But more importantly, you are sensible and smart and obviously a fantastic role model for your daughter. Oh, and your husband is ace too!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Anna

    At the end of the day I hear it’s Face or Arse… I’ll take Face any day. I think.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      The arse girls are all having botox to fill out their wrinkles.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  26. Anna

    I loved your story, probably as it is almost identical to my own including the Big M! The only way we differ is that my mother had me on a diet for as long as I can remember. She’s a wonderful mother and amazingly supportive but will certainly tell me if I’ve piled on the kgs. I still feel fat at a size 10 – 12 this probably eon’t change but at least I now reAlise I’m being a bit crazy!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Essen

      Mine was the same.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  27. Alice

    I am size 6-8 with nice big boobs, and I’m pretty happy with my body. I’m very fit and toned and eat well. I get that my size or shape isn’t included in “real women” spreads most of the time…but I also get that that’s because my size is much more highly represented in ads, on tv etc anyway. The larger women represented in “real women” categories are featured because it’s one of the few forums where they gain representation and acknowledgemet. Not because they’re the only type of real women (which would make us skinny girls…fairies? I’m not sure).

    So for the small girls griping that they’re excluded from “real women” shoots/clothes/articles, are you really insulted? Do you really feel it implies you’re not real? Or do you think they’re aiming it at a large but underrepresented group of women? I don’t say that snarkily, it’s a real question. Surely you’re just happy to have what is closer to the ‘ideal’ body (according to media etc), rather than having to battle perceptions of beauty to gain acceptance?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • rebecca

      I dont think that smaller women were getting snarky at the advertisers but rather some of the comments on here made by other women saying that they look unsexy, immature etc. I understand why women think its ok to be nasty to others.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • rebecca

        oops I don’t understand why

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Shannon

      If you’ve got nice big boobs, I doubt you’ve ever been told to get meat on your bones because you look like a 12yo boy.

      I don’t mean that in a snarky way, but by the sounds you’re far closer to the ‘ideal’ body than I am, even if we wear the same size. Actually, I’d probably be smaller as many size 6s are too big for me. You seem really confident in your body and that’s great!

      I have frequently been bullied for my small size and having some girls in vogue who are similar to me is not going counteract the negative effect of being accused of having an eating disorder and told I’d only be sexy to a paedophile.

      That’s why people like me don’t like getting excluded from these campaigns, because our struggle for positive body image is ignored and, to top it off, we’re frequently criticized in those campaigns.

      Because of having such negative body image as a teen, my self-perception is totally whack. I can feel like a skeleton one day, fat the next, then back again without changing weight. But even when I feel fat I feel too skinny in the arms and legs, boobs too small etc. It’s a fucked up relationship to have with your body, to be so critical that you don’t even know if you see what everyone else sees anymore.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Alice

        I’m sorry you’ve had such horrible things said to you! What is wrong with people?? Thanks for the reply, that makes things a lot clearer.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  28. Jess

    You do look like a teenager-but a very sexy one! It’s not a criticism-lots of teenagers have gorgeous adult bodies, but just super taut and toned. Good on you for being healthy :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • rebecca

      No she doesn’t she looks like a fit, healthy WOMAN. I think some of you need to get over the teenager=slim and woman=curvaceous and maybe a bit overweight. Teenagers AND women come in many shapes and sizes.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • rebecca

      And lots of adults have trim taut, slim bodies Jess. Calling an adult woman is insulting, its a back handed insult!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  29. Yippee!

    Absolutely loved this Ali. I’ll remain anon for this as we’ve met many many times through your hubby, but I just wanted to say you’ve always looks gorgeous, well put together and sexy. I’ve always thought of you as a very beautiful, talented, warm and intelligent woman and have never ever noticed anything to do with you weight. Goes to show that we’re our own worst critics! Much love to you and your gorgeous family xx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Lucinda

    I like this article. I wear short shorts anyway – I live in the tropics and it is just too hot to be too modest. I am not overweight, but still often look for the flaws in my body. This is a good sentiment. In saying that, I have decided to start tomorrow cutting back the amount of processed sugar in my diet because I know from previous experience that when I get rid of it I feel better, if for no other reason than I stop craving it. I think reducing sugar is good for my mental health as well. If we can combine body acceptance with promoting healthy lifestyles we will all be on to a win I think!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. D

    Something that I’ve noticed is when magazines promote photo shoots with ‘real’ women they’re often a size ten plus, with ‘curves’ and a tummy. I’m a size six or eight and the last time I checked I was a ‘real’ woman too… Does anyone else feel that the body image drive often errs on the side of larger women? It’s a little odd feeling excluded from photographs of ‘real women’.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • sarahdaisy

      Last time I checked, size 10, 12 or even 14 women didn’t fit into the ‘larger’ category, but yes, photos should represent the wider population more accurately.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Shannon

      I know how you feel. As much as people of our size are popularly represented, even then it’s with a lot of photoshop, stretching, chicken fillets etc. etc.

      At 5’4 and size 6, I don’t want to be excluded; I want to represented alongside a diverse range of women with minimal photo-editing.

      Sadly, many people use others as stepping stones to their own self-esteem. They have to call others fat or stick-insects, point out a lack of womanly curves etc. in order to establish their own positive self-image, instead of joining forces with each other.

      Example: Miranda has “the body of a teenager”.

      No, she has the body of an adult woman, who is an ectomorph and who, because of genetics, does not have large breasts or hips. And that is nothing to be ashamed of. It should not been put forward as an “ideal”, but that is because if we really want to pursue positive body image for all women, we should shun the idea of an ideal and stop placing so much value in looks.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • rebecca

        I agree, you can read alot of these type of comments on here. Apparently, according to some women, unless you are hourglass, curvaceous and have big boobs your not sexy, attractive and look like a pre-pubescent girl. And worse stil they seem to think that they’re sticking up for real women. Thin women are real women too. You’re not doing anyone any favours by insulting them.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • MissMin

        Ha – wish I had her boobs :) Completely agree though!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • sharoncello

        Excellent comment – my size 20 cello-shaped self would also like to be represented alongside a diverse range of women with minimal photo-editing :)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Shannon

          Maybe we should just do our own campaign, sharoncello?

          I think we’d do it way better! I’d join forces with you in a heartbeat :) xo

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • sharoncello

            We would be awesome Shannon :)

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  32. jo

    Fantastic article Ali – your looks are absolutely gorgeous, and from reading this it appears your personality is even more beautiful.
    Get those short shorts on and enjoy x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. sarahdaisy

    Ali McGregor – thankyou, thankyou, thankyou!

    You just made my … life, I think. I have rigorously and religiously hated my body since I was 14, and now at 30 I still can only see the flaws, rather than the amazing piece of machinery and aesthetics I have been provided with. If only the whole world thought the way you do – you and my fiancé, by the way – that it’s the smile on your face, not the gap between your thighs, that people will remember you for.

    I look forward to joining your army of short-short wearing hotties this summer!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Anon

    Love this article (and you!) Ali.

    The thing I struggle with is, if I ‘drink 8 glasses of water a day’, have my ’2 fruit, 5 veg’, drink less than 1 standard drink’ of alcohol and do ’30mins of exercise’… and eat cake in ‘moderation’, I am naturally a size 8 (this probably has to do with my metabolism and only being 21yrs old).
    So it kind of annoys me when people say ‘you look thin’ or something similar, when I’m just doing all the recommended healthy stuff.
    I also have small breasts so if I lose my waist I have zero curves, Im never going to look like Marilyn whether my thighs touch or not.

    Everyone is different, that’s what we need to embrace.

    Here’s a photo to add to that gallery:

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • D

      I’ve had overweight people tell me “you’re too thin” or “you need to get some meat on those bones”. I take it politely, but often wonder how they would feel if I told them they’re too fat and need to do some exercise.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  35. Mrs M

    I’m a 14 sometimes 16 and in Kmart the other day I was an 18……..I don’t really mind what’s on the tag, a number isn’t going to stop me pulling on my cossies and having fun down the beach with my two kids and hubby. If someone wants to think my thighs look an bit jiggly, my boobs a bit droopy of my tummy a bit soft I don’t care. The fact is that most people are too busy worrying what they look like to notice your “imperfections”.
    Smile, be happy and have fun – you will look fab in those short shorts. And if you catch other women having a perve at you, they’re probably thinking “I wish I could get away with wearing those…….”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Nina Funnell

    Ali- So many up-votes for this! This is fantastic. As Danni Miller says, the best way to innoculate our girls against self-body-hate is to love our own bodies. It’s a hard prescription to fill, I know. But huge ups to you for taking the leap.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Sarah

    Ali, I’m so sad read that you’ve felt like this. I’ve always admired you, thought you incredibly beautiful, and thought you seemed so comfortable in your voluptuousness. I’m so glad you’ve come to this new realization – you go girl!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. JessB

    Ali, you rock my world. I can’t tell you how fabulous I think you are. I will make a similar pledge to move more and get into some shorts. Maybe even short shorts.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. Care

    I am 130kgs and only now at the age of 30 have I decided I don’t care what people think…I am going to swim in public in Bathers and I am going to love it. Life is too short to miss out on wonderful things because you are worried what other people think of you. Thanks for this wonderful article and insight.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      It’s good to accept yourself with all your imperfections but life will be even shorter if you don’t think about your health as well.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kerrie

        Hi Anon, Ali IS looking after her health – eating well and exercising – as she said in this great article. Please remember that the old ‘Thin = healthy” is rubbish. Take a look at Linda Bacon’s book ‘Health at Every Size’, it’s brilliant.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          I was responding to “Care”, not Ali. I do agree there can be health at many sizes. I do not believe anyone is at optimal health when they are obese.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Phillips

            Perhaps before commenting on someone else’s health, you might think about getting some more information to make a more informed judgement. Weight alone is not a good indicator of health, fitness is AND it is possible to be fit and fat. Might I politely suggest that you avoid the judgments about health when you don’t have all of the information necessary to make accurate ones?

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
            • a-nonny-nonny

              I think you are being a little harsh. Yes, there can be all sorts of healthy sizes and shapes, but 130kgs?

              GD Star Rating
              loading...
      • Mum of 2 cheeky monkeys

        Yeah, not sure why so many comments are along the lines of “it’s fine to be happy but you should look after your health/ don’t celebrate obesity. This article has nothing to do with that- being a size 14-16 may be perfectly healthy on particular people. There is no mention of diet or exercise, it’s not a lifestyle piece. It’s about being comfortable with yourself. No one is saying obesity is healthy.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  40. Kate from Seduced by Beauty

    What a well written honest post Ali. I am regularly having discussions with my girlfriends about this issue of body image.

    I look at photos of myself in my late teens and early 20′s and get really angry at myself because I know I had a great body, but all I wanted to do was hide it.

    I had big boobs, tiny waist and a small bottom but was regularly put down by my boyfriend of the time. His nickname for me was ‘big bum’. I will add that I was a size 6 at the time! If only I had the strength to realise I looked great and disregard his hurtful comments.

    I am trying to embrace my 43 year old figure and to remember that I will be kicking myself when I am in my sixties for not flaunting what I have now just like when I look back at myself in my 20′s.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Kate Leaver

    This is a really, really lovely post.

    Ali, I’ve seen you perform live many times and I’ve always thought you were drop-dead gorgeous. It’s always fascinating and terribly sad, how we can appreciate beauty in other people, and not see it ourselves.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. leiah2006

    I am SO GLAD someone echoes my feelings about Miranda Kerr. She is a beautiful girl but looks like a child playing dressups when she is in the DJ catalogues wearing women’s gowns or business women’s clothing. It has put me (and my family and friends) off buying from DJ’s or even going into the store. She has the body of a teenager, how can she successfully market mature women’s clothes??? This is nothing personal, I am just disappointed and frustrated that clothes I am supposed to be appealed to are being advertised in this way.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      Oh God, me too! I thought it was just me as well.
      Sure in swimmers and underwear she looks very sexy. But there is nothing sexy or even remotely attractive about a woman wearing clothes that are designed to be fitted that are hanging off her body, with no body shape visible because its so small under the clothes…it just looks silly, especially when she’s doing the sexy walk but her silhouette is hidden under the baggy clothes!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • rebecca

        I’m quite slim, not as much as MK, but I get sick of people saying that thin people are not sexy, real or appealing. I like the way I look. My partner thinks I’m sexy. Yes, companies should show more variety in the people they get to represent women but you can make this point without insulting those of us who are smaller sizes. Surely a slim women with out a curvaceous figure and a smaller bust is every bit as much a women as one with an hourglass figure and size DD breasts!!!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • anon

          Rebecca, I wasnt saying slim people are not sexy! I said Miranda looks very sexy in her swimmers and underwear because they fit her. She doesnt look sexy in many of the clothes she models for David Jones because they are too big for her. They probably dont make them small enough for her, which is a shame because she is a beautiful woman and would look hot in clothes that fit her. So my point is, if these designer clothes arent small enough for her why arent they using models who do fit their sizes, rather than a super model who is too small for them?

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  43. lbx

    LOVED THIS. Thank you!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. Willow

    I feel like doing a decent workout everyday really keeps me ‘up’ about my own body perspective. I feel good so therefore I see myself right and positively!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Teacup

    Argh..my comment didn’t post. Can MM please retrieve it from the spam filter?
    I tried to repost but I got a duplicate post message.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  46. Jane

    Ali is unreal!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  47. Sienna

    This topic has been done to death! Sooooo over it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • bridget

      I don’t think this topic will ever been ‘over done’ as every second woman has insecurities, so when someone like Ali McGregor has the guts to publish her own insecurities it gives women a little boost. Not only to say they’ll change their habits as well, but also to acknowledge that someone else is in the same position.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • becsparrow

        I agree Bridget!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Elizabeth

        i agree too! it’s amazing when you learn to love yourself how the image that you see in the mirror changes… good on you Ali for taking steps in the right direction!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  48. bridget

    What a wonderful article! I haven’t worn shorts since the compulsory PE class in grade 10. I was bullied by a girl who said (and this one of the more ‘nicer’ things) that I had ‘fat, chunky, telephone pole legs’. I don’t actually, but it still really hurt to have someone say that. So, I haven’t worn shorts since the summer of 2006. Even though I have really wanted to, I just haven’t had the confidence. I might change that this summer.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jensta

      Bridget, I encourage you to wear short shorts. I feel for you because I was the overweight girl in high school. Tipping the scales at 90kg- i blame the jam donuts at the canteen. The amount of boys who thought it was okay to refer to me as ‘fat b!7ch’ was really heartbreaking. But then I left, and got real friends who built me up instead of bringing me down. And I remember wearing my first pair of shorts that actually showed my knees. I felt AMAZING! Each summer, they’ve got shorter. And I continue to not care what I look like. These days I don’t wear board shorts. Last summer I wore a bikini, and it was then I realised no one else cares what I look like, but me. Sounds simple, but it actually changed my life!
      Wear the short shorts. Please wear the short shorts! And tell yourself you look amazing, because you will!

      Great article, Ali. Thanks for giving a voice to what so many of us feel.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kirri

      Yesss! I was 11 when told I had ‘thunder thighs! By my ‘friend’. All my other mates laughed. I probably weighed 2kgs more than any if them, 35kg probably. That commenburnt into my brain! I still don’t wear shorts or short skirts…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  49. Helen

    I don’t think ‘fat’ is the problem it is your image of yourself, perhaps you would still have had image problems even if you were/ had been of a different build. Even ‘skinny’ people have issues with their bodies. I have never been over weight does that mean I love every part of my body, no, but I accept this is who I am. To ‘bag out’ Miranda Kerr and others of similar body type is completely unfair. She is who she is, I am who I am, you are who you are. Let’s celebrate our differences and get out there and wear our short shorts with pride! :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ali McGregor

      Hi Helen,

      That is actually the point of my blog – it isn’t about being ‘fat’ at all – as I say in the post it is about my body image and how even when I was slim I still felt ‘fat’. That is the problem. My manifesto was something I wrote for myself to say out aloud what I want to to from now on – be proud of who I am and healthy in both mind and body. And as for Miranda Kerr – I have no intention of ‘bagging her out’. It is the media’s portrayal of her as some sort of ideal that we should all be looking up to that I have a problem with…

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Helen

        I’m surprised you feel the need to defend/ explain what you wrote in your article. Like you said you wrote it for yourself but in saying that you then published it for all to see.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  50. BeaG

    I always post on these body image posts and I always say the same thing… Where is the fit, strong and athletic female? We just had the Olympics. The female athletes have bodes girls and women should aspire to have. A body made by lots of healthy food and lots of physical activity. You could have thrown in a photo of one of them to show a bit more diversity. Or even someone like Michelle Bridges. It is definitely important for young girls to see that being athletic and fit is something it is ok for them to be – that that is still feminine and beautiful. If they get into good habits young, they will hopefully never have to deal with eating unhealthy and being overweight.

    http://thefitandhappylife.blogspot.com.au/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions