Vaginal birth or caesarean? How a “horrific birth” taught Virginia an important lesson.

I had a horrific birth experience with my first born. I’m talking out-of-control blood pressure and early stages of organ failure. Things got very dicey. My son was cut out in a hurry, he went to the neonatal intensive care unit, I went to Intensive Care. We were both very sick and I didn’t hold my baby for 24 hours. Just one big mess of a birth really.

So when we fell pregnant with our second we obviously wanted to avoid that scenario at all costs. I had my heart set on pushing the baby out and started feverishly googling ‘vaginal birth after caesarean’ (VBAC). As the early weeks progressed, I began to experience a lot of head noise at the idea of another caesarean. I’m proud to say that at this stage I strapped on a pair and booked an appointment with a psychologist so I could start dealing with some fairly significant unresolved issues around the first birth. It was a phone call that was well overdue.

successful vaginal birth after caesarean story
As the early weeks progressed, I began to experience a lot of head noise at the idea of another caesarean. Image supplied.

So the next phone call was to book my pregnant belly and I into the best hospital we could afford. We live in a rural area and didn’t feel comfortable attempting a VBAC at any of the local hospitals. In the end we spent a lot of time and money doing 11 hour round trips to John Hunter to give ourselves the best possible antenatal care. It’s called ‘doctor shopping’ and it’s nothing to be ashamed of.


I also wrote a birth plan, and by ‘birth plan’ I mean I wrote down all possible scenarios and then spent six months coming to terms with the fact that I could not actually plan the birth.

Through therapy I was able to identify that a lot of my issues centred around not having my baby directly after the birth and feelings of failure around not being able to spit a baby out my vagina in 1.5 hours. I realised that to give myself the best chance at a vaginal birth I had to make my peace with either a vaginal or caesarean outcome. The birth plan involved speaking to my doctor about some preferences if it ended up in theatre.

We agreed on lowering the curtain for the birth, or at least sighting the baby briefly if it really did need to be taken away. I also elected to have a TV monitor running a live feed of the baby that I could see from my position on the operating table. But still I basically wrote the birth plan and then I kissed it goodbye.

I also had more props planned than a stage production the second time around. Playlists, essential oils, slippers, dressing gowns, an exercise ball. I really went wild compared to the first birth, in which I basically just had, er, the clothes on my back. And I’m here to tell you that no matter how superfluous props may seem, they definitely contributed to feelings of preparedness and an overall more positive experience.

I mean, if I'm going to have contractions that make me vomit, can I at least do it while Michael Bublé is singing me a love song?

I also made sure I had good ‘chemistry’ with my doctors and midwives. It's important to actually like the people who are going to be peering into your nether regions with great interest. For our first birth there seemed to be a revolving door of medical staff and we couldn’t connect with anyone.

So anyway - all my dreams came true and I ended up getting my whisker biscuit torn to shreds on a Tuesday afternoon. After a 7 am induction, one spew on the exercise ball, an epidural, a fun little surgical manoeuvre called an episiotomy and a big ol’ set of forceps - I got to hold my baby at 5.05 pm. And I didn’t take my eyes off her until we both fell asleep.

successful vaginal birth after caesarean story
I got to hold my baby, and I didn't take my eyes off her until we both fell asleep. Image supplied.

But as the dust settled I began to question whether it really was the vagina part that made the birth amazing. The more I thought about it the more I realised that the positive birth experience actually had very little to do with the fact that the baby came out my foo foo instead of the fire exit.

It had everything to do with the fact that I was in a much healthier headspace the second time round and that I was in a comfortable environment surrounded by people I trusted. I had done the legwork required to let go of the outcome.

I’m not saying there isn’t something super special about having a baby come down the birth canal. Cramping all day and then pushing a baby out your foo foo and pulling it into the world is off the chain. And there’s obvious benefits for both mother and baby if major surgery is avoided. But all of the things that made the birth of my second child a much more positive experience are achievable in both caesarean and vaginal births.

Seeing a psychologist regularly, getting a doctor that made me feel secure and confident in the process, writing a birth plan and having all the props. Those things matter. Your birth experience matters. But which hole the baby comes out? Not so much.

Virginia lives off the grid in regional NSW with her husband and two kids. After finishing up as a journalist with the ABC she turned out her hand to freelance writing and mummy blogging. She’s also an Instagram enthusiast and can be found at @bush_bambinos or