Dear Minister, Please close the loophole putting cosmetic surgery patients at risk.

Dear Minister Sussan Ley

As the Federal Health Minister what are your thoughts on:

A) Doctors being allowed to call themselves ‘cosmetic surgeons’ without surgical training?

B) Doctors who are not qualified surgeons performing surgery?

C) Patients being operated on under a light sedation, instead of a general anaesthetic, which the medical profession says poses ‘an unacceptable risk’ to patient safety?

D) Patients, in the main, being unaware of the above anomalies?

Seems hard to believe, doesn’t it? And yet that is the trap many Australian women are unknowingly stepping into.

At least four women in Australia have been rushed to hospital this year with serious complications following cosmetic procedures at clinics which the Australian Medical Board are investigating. A Sydney law firm is understood to have about 50 clients with complaints relating to cosmetic procedures which have gone wrong.

cosmetic institute feat
22-year-old Amy Rickhuss had a cardiac arrest while undergoing breast augmentation surgery at Sydney’s The Cosmetic Institute.

Earlier this week Krystle Morgan from near Wollongong spoke to Fairfax Media about a breast enlargement procedure she underwent at The Cosmetic Institute in Bondi last year. She woke up from the surgery short of breath.

“I couldn’t breathe and I was told it is normal to be short of breath,” she told Fairfax Media. “This sensation continued to the point where they told me they were calling an ambulance for a routine check and that sometimes it’s normal for tall thin girls to have lungs collapse for no given reason.”

She ended up in the emergency department at St Vincent’s where she was diagnosed with a punctured lung, an ‘unexpected’ complication associated with a breast augmentation. She wants other women to be aware of the risks associated with cosmetic surgery.

All surgery entails risks but, as reconstructive and plastic surgeon Tony Kane told Mamamia last month, the risk is heightened when it is performed by an unqualified surgeon, in a clinic which isn’t subject to the same standards and regulations as operating theatres.


An associate professor in plastic and reconstructive surgery at the University of Sydney David Haertsch told Fairfax Media that “patients are being exposed to that risk by virtue of the fact that they are not having a general anaesthetic which would involve an extra cost.”

And, Minister, the trouble is most patients aren’t aware of this.

“We are conscious that consumers are ill-equipped to discern whether the doctor they choose for their cosmetic surgery is adequately trained to perform their procedure,” Australia Society of Plastic Surgeons president and Associate Professor Hugh Bartholomeusz says.

sussan ley cosmetic surgery legislation
Health Minister Sussan Ley. Image via Facebook

Australians are trusting of the medical profession. How many patients would think to investigate the qualifications of the ‘surgeon’ they’re going to? Or to ask questions about the anaesthetic equipment on hand? Not many. Most are likely to assume in a country like Australia, with a health system as regulated as ours, that qualifications and standards will be rigorously maintained.

A Sydney law firm is understood to have a number of complaints in train against The Cosmetic Institute in particular. In a statement to Fairfax Media the Cosmetic Institute says that “all its surgeons have had formal surgical training including under its director of surgery, Dr Eddy Dona, who is a qualified plastic surgeon.”

On its website The Cosmetic Institute lists 10 “surgeons”. A check of the Australia Health Practitioner Regulation Agency register, shows that only two of these doctors have formal surgical qualifications: Dr Eddy Dona and Dr Jim Kenny. Eight of the surgeons have not undertaken formal surgical training.

Surely, Minister, you will not accept this? Surely you would be inclined to take the advice of an association of qualified surgeons who deem this as unacceptable for patient safety?

00:00 / ???