
Australian universities can learn a lot from the Australian Defence Force — and not just how to apply the Art of War to the boardroom.
Like the ADF, the universities are about to have to deal with the fallout of damning results of a report by the Human Rights Commission (HRC). Similar to the ADF, the universities also had ample warning of the cultural issues that allowed the abuse to occur and failed to heed the warnings. They will now be faced with impending furore and media frenzy. But with great challenges comes great opportunity.
Even before the results of the HRC survey of 39,000 students into instances of sexual harassment on campuses are released, it has already caused quite the stir. There have been allegations of everything from unconscionable research to the ethics of ‘mining students for stories’.
Watch: There’s a stark difference in how men and women ‘avoid’ sexual violence on a daily basis:
When the HRC said they weren’t going to publicly release the data on individual universities, it was met with uproar. “How dare these institutions shelter behind a commission to protect their funding,” we surmised.
Top Comments
The philosophy of Donaldson law firm sounds like a step in the right direction for SA survivors. The current adversarial, common law criminal court system simply doesn't work for victims. We need to rethink our entire approach.
US universities use preponderance of evidence instead of beyond a reasonable doubt. So instead of being very sure someone is guilty you only need to be 51% sure of them being guilty.
I'm torn on it. Part of me doesn't want to wreck someone's life because of that 1%, but in the other hand it gives victims a better chance of seeing their attacker brought to justice in some way.
Balance of probabilities
Title IX, the order which universities have to follow, uses the term preponderance of the evidence but they are interchangeable.
Let us not forget that the system need not work for the victims alone. It has to work for everyone involved in a case of sexual assault. That's real justice. Know the law (for the literal offence of sexual assault: http://www.furstenberglaw.c..., know the circumstances of the incident, and get help.
I'm happy to hear the unis are going to disclose their own results - so they should!! This was an issue when I was at uni so bet it's been going on forever - enough is enough I say