Last night on A Current Affair, Bert and Patti Newton talked to Tracey Grimshaw about Matthew’s drug addiction and mental illness. The full 30 minute interview can be seen on the A Current Affair website here.

When Channel 7 announced Matthew Newton as the new host of their biggest show of the year, X Factor, immediately after he left rehab, I expressed some surprise and some disappointment. Today, less than a week before the show’s premiere, Matthew Newton has been sacked from that job, admitted himself back to rehab and his fiance has taken out an AVO after he allegedly assaulted her a number of times in Australia and overseas.

I’ve written about Matthew Newton several times here on Mamamia. Ever since the incident with his former girlfriend Brooke Satchell when he was charged with assaulting her, I have believed he is a troubled individual who should not be working in the entertainment industry until he seeks treatment for his issues. And acting is one thing but a TV host? I always thought that was a mistake.

When Channel 7 gave him the plum job as host of it’s huge new family show X-Factor, I published a piece with full permission by TV writer Andrew Mercado who wrote:

At the time, I strongly agreed. I think it was irresponsible of Channel 7 to hire someone who was, by their own admission, struggling with addiction mere days after he had completed a few weeks in rehab. Anyone with any knowledge of addiction understands that recovery and treatment is a long and complicated process. There are set-backs. And those who are newly ‘clean’ after a period of treatment are (to my understanding), advised to avoid situations of high stress that could see them relapse.

Taking on such an instense, high profile job was always going to be a huge risk for Matthew Newton when it came to maintaining his sobriety. And what about the risk Channel 7 was taking with hiring someone with a past that involved a charge for assaulting his girlfriend and holding him up as one of their biggest new stars?

Many commenters on that first Matthew Newton post insisted I was being judgemental. That everyone makes mistakes. Why shouldn’t he get another chance? they said. Why not indeed. Well, while this is a terrible situation for all involved, I maintain that it was clear to many people that Matthew Newton’s patterns of behaviour were not going to be fixed by a few weeks in rehab and then a huge, high profile gig.

To those who will inevitably say in the comments: it’s the media’s fault, you’re making it worse by writing about it, just give him some privacy? When you sign up to be the host of a big budget TV show, you make that decision and you take that risk. You put your life into play to some degree.

This is clearly a man with a huge number of problems. My question is this: what do Channel 7 do now? What SHOULD they do?

The X Factor is being positioned for the Masterchef and Idol audience as family entertainment. Much of the show has already been filmed and he’s all over it. Will you be watching with your family?

And when will we stop enabling celebrities to behave in utterly unacceptable – and possibly criminal – ways? And rewarding them if we think they’ll bring ratings?

Where are you on this?