Yesterday, I got schooled about gender by an androgynous-looking 17-year-old.
I was sitting at my usual table at the local cafe. I like the very back corner of the big communal table because it balances my competing needs for sociability and privacy when I’m writing. However my attempts to get any actual work done on that particular day were in vain. I had my baby in tow and he doesn’t appreciate being ignored in favour of a laptop.
My son is going through a very social stage. A waving stage. And a clapping stage. A high-fiving stage. And a throwing-anything-he-can-get-his-little-hands-on-on-the-ground-stage. So after desperately trying to get the attention of the teenager sitting across from us for almost half an hour, he chucked a lime green wooden car viciously at her head.
“What a lovely looking child, what’s their name?” she asked.
“Oh, he’s a boy,” I said instinctively.
“I didn’t ask about gender, I asked their name,” she replied with a smile.
“Sorry, you said ‘they’ so I assumed you weren’t sure if he was a boy or a girl. It’s hard to tell when they’re this little, isn’t it?” I responded. My son was dressed in a blue t-shirt and dark grey pants with pink stars printed on them; pants that had been a source of confusion for pleasant strangers on previous occasions.
“Yes, I s’pose it is hard to tell,” replied the stranger I was currently conversing with. “But, like, it also doesn’t matter much to me. I was raised male but that’s not how I identify anymore. Anyways, I like your baby, they’re very cute”.
Top Comments
No. Sorry. Not buying it. I will not allow anyone to call my baby girl 'they' or 'their' it is a SHE Ok? I take offence to that manipulation of the majority rules by a minority. A baby with a vagina is a girl. An adult who chooses to be confused can be anything and ask to be called anything but leave babies alone! They can call themselves what they like but not impose it on others. What about the offence it causes to others? I would be very offended if someone referred to my girl or boy as 'they' or 'their' and would request it to stop. I'm offended and upset.
You are being quite offensive and I'm not sure how intentional that is.
Obviously people who are trans, gender fluid, etc are not 'chosing to be confused'. They know who they are and it is not for anyone else to decide for them.
There is no reason to be offended if someone says 'what is their name?'. It's a friendly interaction. It might be a worthwhile endeavor to learn more about the difference between sex and gender. It's easy to be confused and it could help she'd some light on this issue.
As usual, Jamila has made a great and insightful contribution to this website. It is a great writer and I always like to read its posts. Jamilia is always full of wisdom! We should all listen to it, as it is one of my favourite writers on this website and Mia has shown great judgement in employing it on its website.