If you want to support independent women's media, become a Mamamia subscriber . Get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts, articles, videos and our exercise app, MOVE.

They always told us forgiveness was the higher road. The narrow gate. The proof you were one of the good ones. In the church halls of my childhood, forgiveness was spoken about like oxygen. Essential. Mandatory. If you didn't forgive, you'd sour. You'd harden. Unforgiveness was how bitterness got in.

I believed them.

I became good at forgiving. I could excuse almost anything if I loved you — and even when I didn't. I could locate the bruise beneath your behaviour and press around it gently. In my family. In friendships. In love. I wore mercy like a badge, because it was what god wanted, and when I left the church, it was because I knew that sometimes I needed that forgiveness myself.

Watch: All the petty hills we would die on. Post continues below.

Until I met him — and forgiveness stopped behaving like a virtue and started feeling like a threat.

He was twelve years older. Handsome in that sun-browned, deep-eyed way. A grin that bent rooms. He was adventurous — the kind of man who liked life best when it was trying to kill him a little, who made ordinary Saturdays feel like trespass. Funny, too. Quick, sideways humour that made you feel chosen, like you were in on something private.

When he looked at me, I felt seen. Properly.

We fell in love. We moved in together. I became step-mum to his kids — school lunches, bedtime stories, the small domestic intimacies that make a life feel important. I trusted him with the softest parts of me. Trusted him in the way your body only does when it finally stops scanning for exits.

It felt like home. Like I had arrived.

Eighteen months in, I found out he'd been sleeping with his secretary for the entire first year of our relationship.

Not a mistake.

Not a bad night.

A year.

When I confronted him, it was full denial, and then when the evidence came in — tears. He was sorry, he said. He'd do anything to make us work.

Up until then, I had never been cheated on, nor cheated myself. I believed loyalty was the baseline. The pain was enormous and disorienting — like walking into your own house and finding the walls shifted overnight. I replayed everything. The stories of his days I now knew were lies. That slight change in tone I'd ignored. I doubted my instincts, my sanity. If I could be that wrong about the man I loved — the man I was building a life with — what else was I blind to?

Because I loved him, and because I believed forgiveness was what good women did, I stayed. Another year and a half spent trying to twist myself into shapes that resembled grace.

I listened to Esther Perel. Read the books. We talked and fought. I took space. I yelled at him. I said all the right sentences out loud. I told myself smart women rebuild. Evolved women extend mercy. Strong women transcend betrayal.

But something in me had split — and it was not knitting back together.

I had an affair of my own — a decision that felt both calculated and feral. I told myself it was about equality, but really it was about wanting to win. Wanting him to feel what I felt. I lost so much weight I was all sharp edges. Took pills to soften it all. My mind ran hot and mean. I was vigilant, brittle, half-mad with love and humiliation.

And still — forgiveness would not come.

It felt like swallowing glass. Every time I reached for it, my body balked. Not out of stubbornness. Out of self-preservation. Forgiving him felt less like healing and more like erasing the scale of the rupture. Like pretending something sacred hadn't been broken in my own nervous system.

When we finally broke up — properly this time, no half-doors left open — I told myself something that felt almost heretical:

I am not going to forgive him.

Not now.

Maybe not ever.

The relief was almost immediate. Physical. My shoulders dropped. My jaw unclenched. The war inside me went quiet. I didn't have to manufacture grace. I didn't have to spiritualise betrayal. I didn't have to force my nervous system to swallow something it kept rejecting.

I could let the truth stand: I loved him. He betrayed me. That matters.

The unforgiveness sat there like a fence post. Solid. Clean.

And — against everything I'd been taught — it didn't rot me.

It steadied me.

What shocked me most was how much energy came back online. All that time I'd spent trying to forgive him — trying to become the kind of woman who could — had kept me tethered to the injury long after the blow was delivered. Forgiveness, in this case, had become another form of entanglement. Another way of staying emotionally yoked to someone who had not loved me cleanly from the beginning.

Once I stopped reaching for it, I was free to live a proper life.

The performance was over. The constant self-monitoring. The private moral audit. I didn't have to keep asking whether I was being evolved enough, spiritual enough, generous enough. I didn't have to make my body do something that felt like swallowing glass.

In the quiet that followed, I could finally see myself plainly. Not as villain or saint. Just as a woman who had been hurt and who had hurt back. Who had stayed too long. Who had loved deeply. Who had lost herself for a while.

There was no ceremony of absolution. No clean moment where I pronounced myself healed. There was only the slow, unglamorous work of coming back into alignment — eating properly, sleeping through the night, rebuilding muscle, listening when my instincts flickered instead of arguing them down. Then more. Turning outward again. Taking work that steadied me. Letting the wind drag me across water. Camping. Booking flights. Sitting across from new people and learning, despite myself, to trust.

The sharpness softened because it was no longer being constantly pressed. Not because I performed mercy, but because I stopped reopening the wound.

He became what he actually was: a man I loved profoundly. A man who made me feel chosen and alive. And a man who lied to me for a year. A man I never wanted in my life again.

All of that could be true at once.

These days, my theology is simpler and far less polite.

I no longer believe forgiveness is a prerequisite for freedom of mind. Sometimes forcing forgiveness is just another way of abandoning yourself. Sometimes the most honest thing you can say — the thing that lets your nervous system finally stand down — is: that hurt me, and I am not ready to make it smaller than it was.

You don't have to forgive to move on.

Sometimes you just have to stop trying to make your body lie.

Megan is a Western Australian writer interested in illness, belief and the negotiations required to live inside an uncertain body. Her essays explore intimacy and meaning in the spaces where certainty falls away. She lives near the coast, where she works, writes, windsurfs and regularly tests the limits of optimism.

Feature Image: Supplied.