Do You Like This Story?

School kids aren’t good looking enough. Well, that’s the sentiment of one photography company in Western Australia which has offered parents the option of re-touching their child’s portrait using Photoshop for the princely sum of $15.

Andrea Mayes wrote in the West Australian:

“A spokesman for Fotoworks said the company was not doing anything wrong. He said the airbrushing only corrected minor skin issues and the company did not enhance photographs to remove braces or add missing teeth, for example.

“It’s mainly for pimples or other marks,” he said. “We leave it up to the parents and it’s a very minimal thing that we do.”

He said only a handful of parents each year chose the option.

Fotoworks photographers made every effort to fix imperfections during the photo shoot, such as asking children to face a different way or getting them to smile without showing their braces. “We would rather fix these things in camera than we would post-camera with photoshop and things like that, he said.”

This is about finding flaws in the school yard, but even already beautiful celebrities are having their ‘wrinkles’ Photoshopped away on the covers of magazines around the world. And they’re only in their 20s!

Emma Watson (Age 20)

Perfect children. Flawless people. Is this what we’re aspiring to? Even female celebrities in their teens and twenties are being heavily digitally altered on magazine covers all over the world every month. So if a 20 year old actress is too ‘flawed’ to appear without extensive air-brushing? What hope is there for the rest of us? And who sets this ideal anyway?

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

63 Comments so far

  1. Mango

    I must admit, I have edited out a snail trail from one of my kids’ noses!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. Anne

    We just paid an insane sum for professional family photos to send to grandparents and family around the world. My son badly cut his head the day before – the photos were stunning but the red cut detracted completely from his gorgeous smile. We didn’t even hesitate when they asked if we wanted it air brushed out!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Vanessa

    I thought my son’s school photo this year seemed airbrushed. Not a blemish to be seen and oh so perfect skin for a teenage boy. I commented to a few people who agreed. Is it possible they airbrush them without our permission?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. banjo

    when me and my freinds go out we take a thousand pics to capture the fun, then the two photographers in our group will airbrush the photos before they go up on face book. The other week i snagged a copy of the unedited photos and put them up(only nice pics). Two of my freinds requested that all unedited photos be taken down. I did, but bugger, Im thinking denial is setting in about those wrinkles/un even skin tone/fat rolls etc…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Alison

    I’m in America, and when I was in school our photos were always “enhanced.” My parents would never have paid extra for something so stupid, the school did it without even asking. I think because these were the early days of digital alteration, the photography company the school hired was so excited to use the new software they didn’t even think about the implications. One of my best friends had chicken pox when he was little, and then acne later, so his face is pretty scarred, and in our senior yearbook photo he has this weird, perfect skin, he looks like a completely different person! Somehow I managed to look ridiculous even with digitally perfect skin – even photoshop can’t fix high school fashion. (I feel a little bit like I beat the system.)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. nonametoday

    I would have LOVED it..I have made my husband photoshop 1 or 2 reasonably good, but not great photos of me over the years. It is dishonest but when you always look shite in photos it gets boring.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. vicky

    in one of my school photos a girl in my class had her eyes shut so they decided to take some eyes and put them on her face. she looked ridiculous. at least she had a good sense of humour about it and didnt mind too much.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Chris

    Don’t shoot me but I Photoshop every photo of my kids. I take out small marks of food on their faces, small scratches, sometimes freckles if I feel like it. My kids are beautiful, my photos are beautiful = no problem. I don’t soften their skin and I don’t liquify them, Photoshop is not the enemy people.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • anon

      As OMO’s slogan says: ‘Dirt is good’

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. Faybian

    The same magazine names keep cropping up, over an over. The Kate winslet ones are scary. I think she’s gorgeous naturally. I guess I can understand airbrushing pimples and scars from school and formal photos, but anything else, neh. They may not be gorgeous (and some of mine certainly weren’t), but they do represent a moment in time, like it or not.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. KateMC

    My high school started doing this in my final two years, and that was AGES ago. This isn’t exactly news.

    I don’t see a problem if all they are doing is removing zits and the like. I had a face full of acne as a teenager. My school pictures showed a miserable girl doing her best to hide from the camera. I threw them all out.

    I think school photo’s should be stopped for high school students, or at least made voluntary. I remember so many girls crying, skipping school, hiding in the toilets etc. on photo day. For a lot of us it was the worst day of the school year. Then when the photo’s came a few weeks later there were more breakdowns because hardly any of the photo’s were flattering, but there was nothing anyone could do about them as everyone had a copy of the group pictures and the school used the individual pictures in yearbooks, newsletters etc.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Ileeyah

    My worst school photos aren’t the ones where I have blemishes on my face or bad hair, they’re the two years that were photoshopped by the company without prior knowledge. (Of course, the entire grade looked atrocious so it’s not really an issue). In one, my skin was turned a sallow olive colour when I’m normally quite pale, my blue eyes were made to stand out in a seemingly endless few pixels of pure white and I think they made me a bobble head. The other gave me incredibly white teeth, skin like terrible porcelain, again, that weird olive colour and lovely soft, greasy looking hair.

    Thankfully, the school changed photographers and my senior portraits are much more appealing and are the ones that sit proudly on my grandparents mantles. I think I managed to hide the multiple copies of the others before my parents could share their pride with coworkers, friends and family.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Elouise Byrne

    On our individual school portraits parents had the option to have them airbrushed for an extra sum. They were trying to airbrush me at 5!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. GiGi

    A friend of mine has a “hideous scar” that she used to get photoshopped away in school photos. And another friend whose mother insisted he get his year 12 photo fixed after faceplanting a few days before it. Scabs all over his face.

    It annoys me whe magazines like “health smart” photoshop people. Especially when they’re advertising ways to get fit and look great. (But not as great as the girl on the cover cos she’s fake!)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Alison Campbell Rasheed

    My son’s school photo was photoshopped because he was pulling a silly face – they super-imposed his head from another photo! How embarrassing …

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kris2040

      Pfft. What’s a class photo without one kid looking the wrong way or scratching their head or pulling a face???

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  15. Angela

    I’ve never been offered airbrushing on my school photos, and I’m in the group that needs it the most – the teachers!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. nic

    This is interesting. Being a teacher in WA, I have noticed that in the last couple of years, my blemishes have been strangely absent from school photos. I was sure they were being photoshopped, now I know.

    I would have liked them to OK it with me first, to be honest. I have blemishes and spots on my face and I resent the fact that these are seen as things that need to be ‘corrected’ and that my face isn’t good enough on its own. I really think that people should be able to accept their face as it is, rather than being “fixed” without their knowledge. It’s made me quite cross actually!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Holly

      I can understand why! It’s like being human isn’t good enough anymore. We’ve got to look like superhuman, digitally altered droids.

      Scary.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  17. Ellie

    They airbrushed all the school photos I got after probably 2004/2005 even though I never got a pimple until I began using oral contraceptives recently. They did it quite poorly too … I think the work experience kid just turned up the exposure on photoshop and clicked print! But it wasn’t me they were singling out – they did it to all the pictures.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Janese Boots

    Companies here in NSW have also been offering this service for 3 or 4 years too. Very few of the students at my school use the option.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. Kate

    I think there should be a Law that Publishers must print a notice underneath the cover photo(s) and any inside photography accompanying an interview etc and even in ads for bikini’s, clothing etc. if a photo has been retouched we should be told that its been retouched. I think young girls and even young boys don’t realise the celebrities they idolise have imperfections and even then magazines will digitally alter that person, even if they are naturally beautiful my case in point is the new Rimmel London magazine ad with Zooey Deschanel, its been so retouched it doesn’t even look like her. This blog has a Rimmel London photo of Zoeey and a normal photo of Zoeey you can clearly see the Rimmel London photo has been massively retouched, if I didn’t know about this retouching I’d not even know it was Zoeey!

    http://thegloss.com/beauty/photoshop-disasters-zooey-deschanels-rimmel-ad-is-ridiculous/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jenna Shenton

      I just checkout out that link to Zooey… OMG! She looks HIDEOUS in the PhotoShopped ad!
      What makes me sad is that even though I know she doesn’t look like that because I’ve seen her movies, and know that level of flawlessness can only come from a computer program, my 16yo sister may not necessarily, and take that as the norm. Sigh.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Kris2040

      I often have to look at ads for make-up to see who it actually is in them. Aside from the fakery of make-up anyway, there is also the photoshopping to contend with. Why do they think naturally great looking people need to be “fixed”???

      Mia said in her AWW story the graphic design types were fanging to photoshop, but I couldn’t see what there was to alter!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. Bradley

    They were discussing this issue on TV this morning. Had it been around when some of my high school photos had been taken, I may have considered it to hide some of the zits.

    But now, all these years later AND with a face a smooth as a new born bub’s behind, I can look at these facial imperfections in the old photos and smile knowing that moisturiser, moisturiser and more moisturiser worked wonders…and that I was a metrosexual before they invented the word. :)

    But Amanda Seyfried ? There’s a young lady who will never need to airbrush !

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • WillaWay

      Amanda Seyfried is surely gorgeous, but how would we really know what she looks like? Have any of us seen her un-retouched? It’s not just still photos that get re-touched.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. Friday

    Removing scratches and major pimples fine by me. I have done that myself on photos of my kids. Not changing anything permanent.

    As for the Emma Watson pic. She just looks like every other cover photo. It’s like a caricature to me these days. I certainly never think they are real. Ho hum.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Anonymous

    Im thinking be cautious of the overkill on this subject.

    Changing major things in photos is not cool, but airbrushing shadows, skin blemishes, pimples etc is ok in my book.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Shelly Stone

    The only high school photo that I am NOT totally humiliated by is the one that I took a hair straightener and a bag of cosmetics to school to do myself up before the picture was taken. I would, and still do, have loved to have that shit airbrushed.

    Damn, I was gross!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. catie

    My Year 12 photo will be proudly displayed in my parents’ home for another good thirty years or so. I am forever grateful that on the day that photo was taken, 17 year old me actually had clear skin, pretty hair and nicely applied makeup. Thank god I finished Year 12, because my Year 11 photo was a shocker. So to be honest, in some ways I don’t have a problem with this. I think there is a difference between removing impermanent marks and totally changing their face.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alison Campbell Rasheed

      make-up?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • clarinette

        lol I had to read catie’s comment again (3 times) before I understood what you were getting at….I think you meant that you grew up in a time when 17 y old girls were not wearing makeup? If so, is that your granddaughter on your pic?

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  25. Jo M

    I agree with some of the comments below that airbrushing an injury would be fine, as long as they’re not changing a child’s face. I was in a major car accident two weeks before I graduated with my Bachelor’s, and I refused to have any photos taken because I was already so self-conscious about the cuts on my face (and knew I’d have another graduation for my MA and PhD later down the track). So, if I’d been a kid at school and the same thing had happened: I would probably have kissed the photographer if they said they could take the cuts out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. Eloise

    I noticed my daughter’s kindy photos last year had been airbrushed, to remove 2 huge mosquito bites from her cheek.

    It wouldn’t have occurred to me to ask for it to be done, but I did think the morning of the photos that it was a shame she’d been bitten right before photos day, and I was quite pleased they’d taken them out.

    To me, there’s a huge difference between removing the bites, and changing my daughter’s face.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. MBK'sMum

    I like to see my children just as they are on the day. Having said that, I don’t have a problem with offering a service to remove temporary imperfections if that is what other parents want. As long as it’s an *option*, as I would always sign in the negative thanks.

    Personally though, I’d not like to tell my children that I’m getting their photos ‘improved’ as I suspect that would rightly make them think that they are ‘supposed’ to look perfect.

    I always make sure my children are wearing their least stained (!) uniform on the day, and encourage them to wipe their faces extra carefully in case their photos are after morning tea or lunch, but that’s about the extent I go to.

    My children told me this year, with their family photo of the two of them, the lady showed them how they looked in the camera after the photo was taken to ensure *they* were happy with the shot. I like that :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  28. Deb H

    when my son was 2, the day before daycare photos i tripped whilst holding him, he badly grazed his cheek and chin. the photo company offered to remove those marks from his individual photo, which i was grateful for as i wanted a “nice” photo of the 3 kids for the grandparents as a gift. i don’t think there is anything wrong with that. teeth whitening, etc etc on kids photos is a bit over the top though

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. georgie

    damn when are they going to let you photo shop your drivers lic and passport!!! id be up for that hehe

    But come on school photos – i have daycare photos of my girls in fancy dress, mismatched shoes and paint smeared faces with the biggest grins on their faces should i opt to photoshop these???????????

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. Alexia

    How ridiculous. Amanda Seyfried’s (?) head looks like it isnt attached to her neck. Doesn’t anyone at the magazine look at these pictures after they have been photoshopped?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Girly

    I would hate to be the re-toucher if they were around when my ex had his school photo taken. I am not being mean, but he had acne bad.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Angela

      That’s not nice. :/

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Girly - chasingamy87.blogspot.com

        I seriously wasn’t being nasty, just stating his acne was bad. Sorry if it sounded mean, I am still good friends with him. He even admits he had bad acne and it got him down at school.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  32. Anna

    Even with 3 kids in school I do not purchase school photos. I find them to be so boring and not reflective of my kids at all. Even the ones I take myself have a much nicer feel to them.
    For a special treat we have family photos taken by professional photographer each year that reflects who we are, a much better investment of our money as far as we are concerned.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. JFK

    My boys have that bed hair look 24/7. Doesn’t matter what we do it is thick and unruly (?). Yet every year they do I am not sure what and flatten their hair for the photo so it looks “neat”. Only problem is they no longer look like my kids !!

    Take the photo as they are – that is who they are and that is how I want to remember them – not how some stranger thinks they should look !!!!!

    Vent all over now …. I feel alot better :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Anna

    The pcitures look so fake (um, does anyone think skin looks like that?) you would have to be quite a fool to think they hadn’t been touched up. That’s the only positive I can see.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Poppy

      And they kinda all look the same when you start going through the photos.

      It scares me what the world will be like when my daughter turns 18 (she is currently 2)!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  35. Evil Cupcake

    It would break my heart, if I found out my mum wanted my school pics retouched. I had enough issues myself as a teen, without having the added pressure of knowing my mum wasn’t happy with my appearance.

    I think though if I had wanted to be airbrushed myself, then that’s a different thing.

    Just for the record, no I would never want a photo of me airbrushed. I’m not exactly Elle MacPherson, but what you see is what you get with me, and if you aren’t happy with the way I look in the photo, you can a) bite me, and b) don’t post a photo of me. Simple as.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Amanda Quick

    This is certainly not new. I worked for a photography company that photographed schools, childcare centres, and kindergartens. While we would not offer such a service for schools (way too much work considering the amount of students to a school) but we offered it for childcare centres and kindergartens – removal of snot, scratches, etc.

    We weren’t the problem though – you should have heard some of the requests we got from parents! Whitening teeth, removing hair in places, even ‘fixing’ eyes and replacing teeth if they didn’t like the way their child looked on photo day. The problem isn’t the photography company, it’s what parents expect. Your children are just that – children! Love them the way they are!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. CaitlinsMummy

    about 7 years ago right during class photo time 2/3 of my preschool class came down with chicken pox. the un retouched class photo looked just AWEFUL and i am really glad they did some air brushing to remove some of the scabs off these otherwise beautiful little kids faces.

    in an extreme case like that i think it is fine to do – but not for every little imperfection.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. May

    With school photo’s being photoshopped, it depends on the extent. I would hate for kids to look like they’re on the cover of a magazine but I think if a kid has a scratch on his/ her face or something like that there’s no harm in making to go away. I had a massive pimple on my chin for my year 12 photo and I think it would have been nice if it could have been airbrushed, because it was the last one! (That picture is still sitting in my parents living room!) To be honest I have more of a problem with a photographer telling kids with braces to smile with the mouth shut! Braces can make kids self conscious as it is. If they are lucky enough confident enough to smile broadly why intentionally make them feel like its something they should hide? I think that’s really terrible.

    On a side note, I saw a mag cover with Courtney Cox the other day and she looked weird. When I pointed it out to my boyfriend he was like “She’s 40. WHY are they trying to make her look like she’s 18? Do they think we don’t know how old she is? Do they think that we’re stupid enough to believe she actually looks like that? and doesn’t have a single wrinkle? Why would a 40 year old want to look like a barbie doll anyway?” Agreed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. AlyssaKT

    I thought Kate Winslet was vocally anti all of this airbrushing and fakeness? Disappointing.

    Regarding the school photos, I’m sure at 16 I would have liked some foto-shopping of mine, it’s only now with maturity I can see that it would have been wrong.

    However, we switched from laminated student ID cards to electronic when I was in year 12 (in ’97) and the terrible result was that we all ended up looking like Japanese cartoon characters after they’d been hit over the head: with one eye sticking out, bigger than the other. ALL of us. Funny now – not so much then!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Illuminate

    Ho Hum yet another airbrushing story.
    Move on, nothing new to see here.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. Kate Hunter

    Gee, if a re-toucher had been engaged to clear up my skin when I was 15 they’d have had their work cut out for them.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. Lulu

    The current cover of Woman’s Day has a colour picture of Elizabeth Taylor which is so obviously airbrushed that it’s silly. No, not a picture of older Liz; young Liz, in her 20s, possibly the most beautiful woman in the world. WD thinks she needs airbrushing, & in the process wipes the specialness from her face.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  43. Anonymous

    The reason they air brush even the young is that NO ONE looks like that, at any age!

    The question isn’t why are they photoshopping 20 year olds, but, why are they photoshopping at all? Celebrities (for example) look pretty darn good when they have all their professional make-up/hair/styling, no touch-ups needed.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  44. MO5

    My kids’ school photos are photoshopped to make their skin smooth and pimple free! I hate it. I have made a complaint but nothing will be done…what a shame.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Miss Newcastle

      Gosh, I wish they could have done that to some of my high school photos haha!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • ClaireC

      That’s awful – and they won’t let you opt out? Do they do it with the whole school, even primary?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      I remember one year at school (this was maybe 2006/2007) EVERYONE’S photos were extremely airbrushed. we all looked quite weird and abnormal, but everyone just found it hilarious. I imagine some people were quite pissed off though. We all had weird coloured “perfect skin” and our eyes looked all funny

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Lu

      All I ask is that they make sure my kids hair is neat and their hair ribbons are done up.
      Last year the photo guy combed one of my sons hair and he had a hideous ‘comb down’ hairdo like one of the kids in the Adams Family! And my daughter had wild messy hair hanging out of her ponytail.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • vicki from in.cube8r

        Isn’t that what kids are all about at that age though? My son had his day care shots complete with his superman cape when he was 4, cause that’s all he wore then – I’d like to think that photos capture a moment in time – and regardless of perfection or flaws, it produces memories for us rather than how we HOPED they looked like

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Lu

          I dont think neat and tidy for school photos is too much to ask for!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Happymum

        I agree Lu, I have had one son’s Kinder photos look so abnormal as the photographer did something weird to his hair.

        Surely when you pay for school photos they could make sure your kids have their hair straight and face clean.

        I don’t want airbrushing, just common sense applied.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions