couples

"Dear everyone. Please stop telling me to not wrap my kids in cotton wool."

Would you let your kid do all the things you did when you were young? This mum wouldn’t.

If I hear one more person tell me to stop wrapping my kids in cotton wool, I will be tempted to shove cotton wool in his (or her) mouth.

The latest is a physicist, Clive Neeson, who grew up rolling down hills in tyres, leaping off waterfalls and jumping from roofs. He believes kids not exploring outdoors is “the biggest thing to threaten our civilisation”.

Right.

Every week or two, I read people reminiscing about their childhoods, when they apparently spent all hours of the day roaming the neighbourhood, climbing trees and riding bikes and swimming. Then they try to suggest that today’s kids should do the same.

“We all survived!” these middle-aged know-it-alls proclaim.

Well, yes. You did. Because the ones who didn’t survive aren’t saying anything. 

When I was growing up, I knew several kids whose brothers or sisters had been hit by cars and killed. I also remember that when I was six - and considered old enough to walk to the school bus stop with my seven-year-old brother - I dashed across the road in front of a car, and the driver braked just in time to avoid hitting me.

There is no way I would let my seven-year-old walk or ride anywhere alone. It's not so much the fear of abduction, it's the fear of her being hit by a car. I'm not sure at what age I will feel ready to let her do it.

People are always moaning that today's playgrounds are too safe. Well, I used to live in South Australia, near a famous, very adventurous playground that drew huge crowds. When it was closed down and replaced with a modern, safe playground, lots of people complained. What they didn't realise was that people were injuring themselves at the old playground, quite seriously, on a regular basis. Broken bones, and worse. At least one person died after falling from the flying fox.

ADVERTISEMENT

I like modern, safe playgrounds, with their cushioned surfaces. I like my kids playing somewhere where they can fall and only end up bruising or grazing themselves, not breaking a limb.

I don't see why broken bones have to be a normal part of childhood. Friends whose kids have broken their arms or legs have been left seriously traumatised by the experience (the parents, not the kids). If I can minimise the chance of that happening to my kids (and me), I would like to.

Look, I agree with these people to some extent. Technology is very addictive, and parents need to make a real effort to make sure their children spend time outside. But I don't think we need to go back to the dangerous old days that people seem to remember so fondly. I think we can find a middle ground. It's not like there are only two options: free-range kids, or kids glued to their iPads.

My kids love climbing on the play equipment in our backyard. But I won't let them climb on the roof like I used to. Sure, I never fell off, but I could have.

I don't know about you, but I don't have a lot of spare kids.

Do you think modern parents are wrapping their kids in cotton wool?

Want more? Try:

The one thing I didn't expect when I took my kids to a play area.

When the police are called to an argument over playground swings.