Her name is Thylane Lena-Rose Blondeau. You may not immediately recognise her name but chances are you’ve seen her face before. She appeared in an issue of French Vogue that was edited by Tom Ford reclining on a tiger rug, wearing make-up and adult-size high heels earlier this year.
Those images caused plenty of controversy at the time, yet the pre-teen model’s portfolio hasn’t slowed down, in fact judging by the amount of images that can be found of her on the internet, it has dramatically expanded. She now has her own Facebook page and a dedicated Tumblr – which has been renamed from “F–k Yeah Thylane Blondeau” to “Thylane Blondeau Pictures,” the owner of the Tumblr explains the name change was due to the large volume of emails she received when the controversy hit the media three days ago, which were one of two reactions, “either messages about how much [people] love her or that she’s a prostitute.”
The daughter of former French international football player Patrick Blondeau and Véronika Loubry, an actress and television presenter, her first foray into fashion was on the runway at age 4 for Jean Paul Gaultier. She has already been compared to Bridgette Bardot, who incidentally appeared in Elle at age 15.
The fashion industry has always celebrated pretty young things, but it’s current thirst for younger and younger models is now bordering on creepy. 13-year-old Elle Fanning is the current face of the Marc by Marc Jacobs autumn/winter campaign and 14-year-old Hailee Steinfeld has also signed a deal with fashion label, Miu Miu.
Admittedly I momentarily let myself get swept up in these compelling images. I let my mind drift off to this seemingly beautiful life and wondered where I could buy that grey beanie. But by the time I got to the second page of her Tumblr fan site, I was sufficiently creeped out.
The most unsettling thing about these images of Thylane is that there is no joy, little smiling and no spontaneous laughter or shots that you might find in other child modelling photographs. I find the vacant stares and coquetteish looks over her bare shoulder while her long tousled hair covers her chest particularly disturbing, like I need a shower disturbing.
Jenna Sauers, editor of Jezebel, offers another perspective and one that blames the fashion industry juggernaut rather than her parents or modeling agency.
“It’s just that so many of the tropes of fashion photography—the focus on the long limbs, the aestheticization and objectification of these young bodies, the preference for blank expressions and softly opened mouths—are inherently sexualizing,” Sauers writes.
“But something about some of these pictures, on a level almost deeper than language, creeps me out. And for that, I blame fashion, not the child or her parents.”
Lets cast our minds back to our childhoods. When I was 10, my life revolved around riding my purple four-speed bike, watching the Henderson Kids and selling pet rocks to unsuspecting commuters in order to buy more lollies. Life was simple. My early brushes with fashion consisted of Mum taking me to the local Kmart to buy a few new outfits every year and rifling through Rosie’s mums fabric box in an attempt to sew our own 10-year-old version of haute couture (tartan waistcoats, if you must know).
I was not being photographed with only beads covering my bare chest staring vacantly into a camera.
What were you doing at 10? And what do you think of these images?











Comments
170 Comments so far
I personally feel that the image is an unnecessary contribution to what is already considered to be a controversial industry, the fashion industry. Tom Ford designs are targeted towards a late teen plus market, there for I believe that the image should have been portrayed using an age appropriate model. Although I do not find this images to be of a sexual behaviour, I think it is important to protect the innocent against predators in today’s society. I also think that it is unfair to dictate that the young girl is being robbed of her childhood just because some of her images do not show her smiling displaying a blank expression and a softly open mouth.
I’m sure if we all think back to our childhood behaviours or even look through some past photos, minority would be able to identify with these images. I myself remember several occasions dressing up in mum’s clothes wearing makeup and prancing and posing around in a pair of heels, taking photos in model like poses. The only real dangers I worry about for this young girl is the pressure the industry may have on her as she grows up, particularly body image pressures. But in saying that maybe starting out in the industry at such a young age may prepare and better equip her to deal with those issues.
I believe that it is up to her parents and her agency to protect the young girl from out side pressure of the industry and to have a balance between work and fun. It is also important that parents whom allow their young children to view these images educate them on what they are looking at. Just because she has professional photographs does not dictate that the young child does not have a happy and healthy life style where she participates in activities that society considers to be of child like behaviour.
loading...
OMG this has to be some form of child abuse. She should be modelling for a childrens brand like pumpkin patch or something, I know I am not going to race out a buy high heels because a pretty 10 year old girl is advertising them…..shame shame shame, poor little girl
loading...
She’s clearly a beautiful child, and loads of these photos are amazing. However the one where she’s topless and has her hair covering herself is way too sexualised for a 10 year old girl…
loading...
Some of the photos are fine, and beautiful. An absolutely stunning girl and I have no problem with her using her spare time to model, if that’s what makes her happy.
BUT – the photos in high heels really frighten me … stiletto heels are definitely an ADULT woman’s weapon of allure and sexuality, not something that a child should ever wear except mucking around with mummy’s shoes in the privacy of their own home, and dreaming of the day when they will be old enough to wear them ‘for real’.
I have twin 17 year old boys who are both partnering girls doing their debuts in a couple of months. Both girls are16, and both are beautiful. However, both their mothers have told me (and I agree totally) that their daughters are too young to wear stiletto heels, and both will be wearing lower heels – 3 cm or so. This is absolutely appropriate for the age, and is exactly what I did when my 22 year old daughter had her first school formal when she was 16.
What is left for children to look forward to when they are wearing stilettos and sexy dresses and makeup at 10? And yes – unfortunately – this is paedophile territory.
loading...
She is clearly a beautiful young thing, but something about these photos make me feel so sad in side and fearful for the next few years for her.
What happens when she hits puberty and gains a little puppy fat? She has been groomed to be beautiful, when she goes through that akward teen stage how will her self esteem cope and will she have undue pressure on her to stay beautiful?
The fashion industry has alot to answer for?
loading...
Call me crazy but there’s something kind of magical about these images. The photos are gorgeous, I don’t think they’re oversexualised, but I’ve seen other images of children that have scared me.
But this collection reminds me of childhood, dressing up as my mum and putting on her heels and lipstick. I especially love the pics where you can see the shoes are miles too big and the pic where she’s applying lipstick.
loading...
She is absolutely beautiful but not at all like a ten year old – at least not like I was at 10 or 20 or 30!
loading...
I agree totally creeped out by these pics, where is the laughter and fun – it is all too serious for a 10 year old but at the end of the day aren’t we as parents supposed to monitor what our kids get into? some of the responsibiltiy for these images has to stop with the parents cause aren’t they the ones signing off on these images and accepting the payment??
loading...
Why do we expect all children to be the same? That we were all whizzing around on purple bikes enjoying our youthful exuberance? There are some children who are serious and don’t smile 24/7 – and it doesn’t mean they’ve been abused or anything else, that’s just them.
I think the photos are beautiful.
loading...
she has to keep her mouth shut because her teeth give away her age.
loading...
I am a 13 year old boy and i do not understand what the fuss with this issue is about.
what is so sexual about these pictures? for me, not at all.
if your child was asked for a photo shoot with vouge i’m pretty sure that you would proudly take that opportunity. i understand the people who think that these pictures may seem a little distasteful but don’t you think that saying they are fodder for pedophiles is going a little overboard?
there are much worse child violations in the world compared to a little french girl trying to do her job. perhaps one that she truly enjoys and won’t be able to do if this gets any more media attention.
loading...
A ten year old shouldn’t have a job to do.
loading...
so it’s all right for Natalie Portman, Dakota Fanning, the Harry Potter crew etc to have jobs because they want to and for us to applaud them on their maturity etc, but not for a girl to want to be a model?
loading...
Not much difference between this and child beauty pageants…..but it’s ok cause it’s Vogue?… I would not let my daughter do some of those jobs, but agree some are not at all creepy…but most are?
loading...
How the hell do they get a 10 year old to sit still long enough to have their hair and make up done and then have their photograph taken?
loading...
A pedphile’s target and excuse. Frightening.
loading...
She is without a doubt a very attractive child, but I believe the fashion industry is the wrong environment to raise a child in. Thylane Blondeau will grow up believing that her beauty is her top priority and I think it wrong to raise a child like that. Childhood is for enjoying and when some of our most joyful memories occur, she shouldn’t be robbed of that. We make such a big deal about little girls in beauty pageants- due to the fact that they are sexualised and tampered with until they conform to someone else’s view of perfection… how is this any different?
loading...
this has got to be a joke… how can any fashion house take themselves seriously parading a child around as a adult? Boycott boycott boycott.
loading...
I’d be more inclined to buy the clothes if she were posed in them as a little kid doing dress up. I don’t understand the purpose of the photography and her ability to get that completely vacant look is very disturbing.
I hope her real life is full of silliness, play and learning.
At 10, I was travelling with my parents, going to school, making things, making mess, learning and exploring.
loading...
She is absolutely beautiful, but I don’t get the need for her to be dressed up that way, and whats with the heels? Are women going to look at a 10 year old wearing 5 inch heels and think ”yup, she looks great in them so I’ve gotta have a pair!’ What designer thinks of using a 10 year old child to promote clothes that are obviously meant for an older customer base? It doesn’t make any sense.
As a parent, there’s no way I would let my 10 year child be photographed made up that way, makes me wonder why her parents would agree to it. If modelling is something she truly enjoys then why not have her model children’s clothing?
loading...
Hmm – the power of the internet rears its head – the viral spread of Thylane’s story has led to her mother shutting down her Facebook page yesterday to protect her daughter from the negative,creepy publicity that has been generated.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2022979/10-year-old-Vogue-models-mother-shuts-Facebook-fan-site-response-outrage-daughters-career.html
Shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted methinks. Poor Thylane.
loading...
What a beautiful little girl. But these photos are so inappropriate, I just dont get why parents would want to dress their children in clothes like that!! I like to dress my little girl in clothes that are cute and comfy!!
I just hope that Thylane parents are protecting her.
loading...
I am not sure who these pictures are for? As a 35yr woman am I suppose to look like a 10 yr?. I showed my nieces these pictures they are 10 and 12 and they didn’t “get” why she was dressed the way she was.
Pictures like these hurt our children.
loading...
This makes me so sad. How can Vogue / her management / her parents agree to represent a 10 year old girl like this Its such an unrealistic representation. I have a 6 year old girl, and she is still so young, so happy, so beautiful and so innocent. I dont want her to grow up before she has too. I dont want her to see images like this and aspire to be anything anywhere what this represents. It really is awful. There is no other way to describe it.
loading...
I think its wrong- but really she would see it as having fun & dressing up. Also, if she has great parents that keep her grounded, she will be fine.
loading...
Sadly, this is just wrong on so many levels. Pictures like these fill the computers of paedophiles, and they too argue that “it’s art” or “it’s fashion”.
Let the kid be a kid, not an adult’s reflection of her own inadequacies.
These sorts of pics are even worse than the child pageant stuff.
loading...
Child pornography comes to mind. I just read Jaycee Duggard’s book and she mention how her captor used to get his wife to get photos’ of kids in play grounds doing cart wheels or pictures of shorts on girls.Him flicking the channels to see young girls in shorts to masturbate to.
Just because they are clothed doesn’t mean they are not sexual.
loading...
Yes I also read the book and that was just so chilling to think a woman would take part in something so sinister ,some people are evil and the more we can do to protect our kids the better..
loading...
Just so disturbing. The pouty, suggestive lips and come hither eyes, smack of her being told to pose that way, not a natural smile or childlike look.
It more than a little worries me that the examples we are seeing of children growing up before their time without the capacity for their brains, hearts and bodies to cope, are now at tsunami like proportions. As consumers we have to vote with our wallets here and not support brands that think it’s hot and cool to use 10 year old girls in this way.
loading...
The girl, and the photos are beautiful. Just as Bill Henson’s photographs of a naked 13 year old were beautiful. Doesn’t make either instance right.
Perhaps I’ve had too many conversations with those who work with convicted pedophiles, but I agree with those who say this is pedophile fodder. I don’t understand why it’s considered a cool thing to portray an innocent 10 year old as a vamp.
loading...
Fodder for paedophiles, pure and simple.
loading...
she is so beautiful ! I think most of the shots show her in an amazing beautiful type of child way… i also think that its a shame that vogue totally missed the mark dressing her as a grown-up model because all i see is a 10 yo playing bad, provocative dress-up… i don’t know why they went for that sort of “shocking”… well, they did get us all talking about it… as i said before, i hope she is getting loads of play time as well…
loading...
Sick, and smacks of parental manipulation. Don’t even get me started on child beauty pageants. Wrong, wrong, wrong……..
loading...
At ten i was competing in irish and scottish dancing and also horseriding carnivals things that were suitable for a kid, not dressed like a thirty year old with a seductive look on my face , maybe the parents just want to show the world how beautiful there CHILD is and i only see her as sexualised because that seems to be the way of the western world these days and the younger you can cash in the better.Just the thought of some sicko looking at those photos would make my skin crawl if that was my child.!
loading...
She is beautiful. And while, in many shots, she still looks child-like, I feel so uncomfortable with a kid in the role of fashion model. All of a sudden, one notices the full lips and the bare skin and it’s no longer innocent and pretty and celebrating childhood, but sultry, contrived, and celebrating aduthood and consumerism. This stunning young person has plenty of years ahead of her to pursue modelling if she so chooses. At ten years old, it’s just so unnecessary.
loading...
Looks like I can’t resist commenting on her name….thought they were extinct & last seen in Tasmania ??
loading...
Yes, it is hard to see ‘Thylane’ and not think ‘Thylacine’.
loading...
I hear 4 is the new 10…
Seriously, she just looks like a child to me in most of those. Does not entice me to purchase. Some photos were artistic/interesting but not really seeing a place for this in the fashion mags.
loading...
How did they get her to sit still for long enough to get all that make-up on. She must have no spirit at all: explains the deadpan eyes.
loading...
Personally I don’t find these images nearly as offensive as the multitude of parents who think it is ok to dress their daughters in Playboy logo clothing and items of that ilk.
loading...
agreed: went to get my 4yo some new togs, and she wanted the hot yellow bikini with “Roxy” written across the arse (yes, made in her size). I respectfully disagreed.
loading...
Honestly, I don’t see the problem. In all of those photo’s she looks like the 10 year old she is. The Tom Ford photo’s are just ultra heightened pictures of little girls playing dress-ups. She looks like a child playing at being an adult, which is a totally normal thing to do. Children imitate their elders. They always have. I have a ton of photo’s of me doing sexy faces as a kid.
I really don’t get what people’s issue with the topless photo is. It would be weird if you made a child cover up in a situation they normally wouldn’t. She’s on the beach, she’s 10 years old, why would she be wearing a top?
loading...
When I was 9 I took off my top in the bus on a school excursion so that I could take my singlet off (I was hot) then put the t-shirt back on again. All the other kids stared. 10 year girls were definitely self-conscious about being topless back then (despite most of us being flat-chested) so I imagine it’s still the case today. I wonder how Thylane felt about being photographed topless?
loading...
Remember she is French. They aren’t so shy about nudity there. You never see a little girl wearing a bikini top or one piece swimsuit on a French beach, nor do you see many grown women covering up. As I said, it would be weird if she was wearing a top, when any other little girl like her wouldn’t be.
loading...
“Ultra heightened??” What does that mean exactly? To me it’s a nice way of talking about the exploitation of something that SHOULD be innocent, but is NOT, once in the hands of people in an industry who make money from the increased attention they get, from sexualising a child (aka creating controversy). The more we’re repulsed and the more we talk about it, the better it is for them. A really twisted loop, if you ask me. But effective marketing for sure. And great for pedophiles who don’t want to work too hard to find photographs for their collection.
loading...
Actually, she’s French, and French little gils are not made to cover up their ‘boobs’ on the beach, no more than boys. They wear bottoms or a one-piece. The whole baby in a bikini thing is ridiculous.
I was never aware of my ‘boobs’ on the beach until, at 8.5 yo, I moved to Sydney from France and realised I was the only girl without a bikini top to hide myself..
loading...
Can’t agree more, Camille.
loading...
on a side note she is also WAAAAAAYYY to young to be in pointe shoes even for a photo
loading...
Beautiful girl, obviously. I know the article says she’s 10 years old, but wow, they’ve managed to make her look so adult-ish in some of these photos. Exposed legs and shoulders and sexy poses. And that’s disturbing. What a creepy message this sends. For goodness sake, let the child be a child. There’s plenty of time for her to strut her stuff when she’s older. Yikes.
loading...
No doubt that this little girl is absolutely stunning. But what freaks me out is that she pretty much looks like an adult model at first glance – especially the Tom Ford shot. And I’m not saying she necessarily looks a lot older, but rather most of the high fashion models used these days look pre-pubescent, even if they actually aren’t.
loading...
Gorgeous girl, no doubt about that, but it definitely isn’t necessary for her to participate in adult advertising, that’s just disgusting. If images like these actually sell products, then there’s something seriously wrong with the customers!
Can’t wait to see Thylane in 6-7 years provided a ‘rock and roll’ lifestyle doesn’t get to her before then.
loading...
There is no doubt she will knock it outta the park when she is a teen model but really there is no reason why her parents coudn’t wait another 6-7 yrs for this to happen…….
loading...
Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!
She should be in a Pumpkin Patch catalogue, not Vogue.
She is absolutely beautiful, abeit very made-up, and I have no doubt she will be a very successful adult model. But at age 10 she does not belong in Vogue.
loading...
I feel very uncomfortable about these photos. As the mum of a 7 year old daughter I feel that society is making little girls grow up way too fast. These types of photos are disturbing in that young girls don’t understand what appeal these images have to pedophiles. Let girls be girls and leave these types of photos to adults, not even older teens…adults.
loading...
most of those images are really beautiful – it’s the french vogue editorial and a few others that pushed it over the edge. the vogue enfant cover is divine. i found australia’s witchery kids campaign more controversial than this.
loading...
Sure she’s a naturally beautiful kid. But the key word is KID. I find this sick!
loading...
All I can say is wrong, wrong, wrong, just plain wrong
loading...
I think a lot of the images are just beautiful, arty photographs. The only ones that I find genuinely creepy are the ones that look like they were for an ad and she is posing in an adult situation… with the heading “Cadeau” (e.g. this one:http://www.mamamia.com.au/wp-content/gallery/thylane/tumblr_locrihrbvr1qmlbgwo1_500.jpg). They seem like they are really trying to make her look like an adult in those photos, whereas the others I see as being art (though I do understand that they are probably selling a product).
I tend to have a pretty strong view on people* that claim any photograph of a child is pornographic or inappropriate if the child is topless, or even naked (e.g. the Bill Henson case)… because in most cases people are causing a fuss over nothing. If the child is comfortable, the parents are keeping their interests in mind, and they feel comfortable around the photographer, then who cares. They aren’t being sexualised or asked to pose in provocative positions. It is art.
*definitely not having a go at Nicky or any previous commenters.. just giving my opinion.
loading...
I agree – some of these photos have a lovely freedom and naturalness to them. What’s the difference between being a successful child model and a successful child actor/actress? She is clearly very good at her job.
loading...
I agree. After reading the article an some of the comments I have to say I was expecting a lot worse. I think the majority of the photographs are beautiful and I can’t see anything wrong with them, except the ads where she is heels and has been covered in make up. Thats where I draw the line. Whats wrong with the topless photo’s? They have been done very tastefully IMO. I would love to have my children photographed in such a natural way.
loading...
Not bordering—we crossed the border into creepyville a long, long time ago. It’s twenty years since Ab Fab featured the joke about ‘soon they’ll be chucking foetuses down the catwalk.’ And I remember fashion models of 13 and 14 when I was 13 or 14 (back in the ’80s).
The difference with Thylane is that no matter how she is dressed and styled, she looks like a little girl. Just like the beauty queen infants from American pageants. The 13 and 14 year olds chosen for these type of fashion shoots have grown just enough (barely enough) to pass for a young adult once they’ve been styled up. Thylane’s presence in the world of adult fashion is about grabbing attention; a gimmick and nothing more. Sad that she’s being used this way.
loading...
well she is obviously a very photogenic child and she is beautiful. Takes after her mother who is also beautiful. There is nothing wrong with pics of children who are beautiful, even if they do have no top on if it is depicting child like behaviour and is completely innocent. I do not see that here. The pics are just the same as any glossy mag editorial and are trying to be sexy. A big no no for a 10 year old. It is really sad that her parents are trying to push her into a career fast tracked like this instead of her developing and blossoming naturally.
Sad that this will be taken up and she will have a big career. This industry just seems to work that way.
loading...
The photos are fairly provocative poses for a ten year old girl. And the clothes are certainly not geared to the average young miss. But then I thought of another young girl who caused a furore as a 13yr old prostitute in Taxi Driver. That girl is now one of the worlds finest actresses…Jodie Foster. So there are two things to muse….will this affect the future of this ten yr old girl, and what effect could it have on other ten year old girls.
loading...