Do You Like This Story?
shoes Are you a shoe or a bag person?

.

 

 

 

 

I don’t like shoes. There, I admitted it. Actually, I have nothing against shoes per se- they excuse me from the tedium of having to get a pedicure more than once a year, and I can’t imagine going to Coles without them (that floor gets so chilly in the dairy aisle!). More correctly, perhaps I should have said that I’m not into shoes. I don’t get shoes. For the life of me I can’t understand how other women become so worked up about the damn things- loopy about Louboutins, manic over Manolos, cuckoo for Choo.

This was first brought home to me years ago when I went out for drinks with a (quite literally) well-heeled friend. She insisted we find a seat at the bar rather than standing, then curled her legs around her in a way that might have seemed girlish and fetching if she hadn’t confessed later that she did so for a reason. Forget diamonds on the soles of her shoes- this woman wanted everyone to notice her trademark red Prada slash instead. “But they’re just, you know, shoes,” I told her, nonplussed, and she looked at me as if I’d spat on her mother.

It gets worse. I’m not into bags either. I’m not into makeup. I’m not- deep breath- into clothes. An online friend visiting my home town of Melbourne once asked me where she should shop. “Shop?” I queried. “Dresses,” she replied. “Something for the races, and something strappy and elegant for summer, and also maybe a leather jacket and some new wedges.” I was, again, nonplussed. If she’d asked for great Turkish bread or artisan chocolate or fabulous books, I was her girl. Heck, I could have helped her if the wedges she was dreaming of were the type that came with sour cream, but as it was it was like asking the Pope to recommend a gay bar.

I didn’t dare tell her that my own wardrobe consisted pretty much of jeans, white t-shirts, presents from my sister and a nice line in polar fleece. If tracksuits suddenly come into fashion as the last word in after-five wear I’ll be set, but until then it’s fair to say that I’m not a shopper.

It’s not- I hope- that I’m unfeminine. I’ve never, ever been a girly-girl, but I have a thing for gorgeous underwear, a penchant for rings and pearls and silver necklaces, a deep secret desire to one day be mistaken on the street for Angelina Jolie (which, admittedly, is unlikely, given you hardly ever see her in polar fleece).

I love looking at spreads of Oscars frocks and Derby day fashions on the field, but the whole thing is more confounding to me than nuclear physics. Actually, physics- both nuclear and garden variety- is a breeze compared to the agonies of accessorising, the mysteries of trans-seasonal wear and what the heck the point of those teensy little shrug things is anyway. I am a professional woman in my early (enough) forties who has to admit that she doesn’t truly know how to put an outfit together. I have a PhD in neuropsychology, but I cannot layer. This is a big admission. Living where I do, the latter would have been more useful.

I can’t blame my gene pool. My mother could shop for Australia, and frequently does. My sister understands what ‘bias-cut’ means, and has the receipts to prove it. Pity, then, my poor ten year old daughter Cameron, who seems to be budding from the same branch of the family tree. The only time Cam will ever deign to wear a tracksuit is before one of her swimming meets, and even then it has to be pink velour with a grosgrain trim set off by ballet flats and a satin head band.

I catch her looking wistfully at other more sartorially-gifted mothers, and though she’s too polite and loving to say anything to me, I know what she’s thinking. She caught me recently heading out the door to a friend’s book launch in a grey wool dress, knee-high suede boots and wearing lipstick, and her little face lit up. “Mummy,” she exclaimed, “I love it when you try.”

What she doesn’t understand is that I do try. I do, I really do- I have a job and a social life and some days it’s just too hot for polar fleece, so every now and then I make the effort and go shopping. But it never works. All that choice overwhelms me; all those styles and colours and things that I might put on backwards by mistake. It used to be that jeans, like milk, came in one variety only, but on a recent trip to Westfield I’d encountered at least ten types before I even made it to the food court: skinny leg, wide leg, low rise, boyfriend, calcium enriched…

Thankfully clothes often find me. That grey wool dress was thrust into my arms as I went to try something else on at (cough) Target in (cough cough) Broome. “Here,” said the woman handing out the security tags, “someone else just tried this, but I reckon it would look good on you.” It was 40 degrees in the shade outside and Broome Target simply had no reason to be selling lovely fitted wool dresses, but my new (and sadly temporary) personal stylist was right- the dress was a find.

Then there was a gorgeous lightly sequinned green top that I discovered hanging on a tree by the local creek, left either by a swimmer or a stylish amnesiac; the mint condition silk shirt that literally fell off its hanger onto my feet at the Camberwell market; my favourite red jacket, which my best friend purchased online then passed on to me when it turned out to be too small for her. I’m grateful for these garments, and I hope they keep turning up. The alternative, I’m ashamed to admit, is a night class in layering or a life of leisure (wear).

Kylie Ladd is a novelist, freelance writer and neuropsychologist. Her novels include  After The Fall, and  Last Summer. Follow her on Twitter here

Beyonce

Are you a shoe person or a bag person?

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

116 Comments so far

  1. Lulu

    I like shoes (particularly boots), but I don’t like high heels – which in the current retail conditions is pretty much the same as hating shoes.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Rach

      Me too!

      Actually, after years as a ballet dancer including a serious metatarsal injury, I simply can’t do heels. It is like someone is inserting pins into my feet.

      Damn, guess I have to buy more sneakers!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  2. May!

    I like the IDEA of bags and shoes. I see fashion galleries and think ‘I should buy more nice bags and shoes. Bags and shoes are fun’. But I just can never bring myself to spend my money on them. It’s not an anti-shopping thing, I quite like shopping I just don’t get the same retail high from a pair of shoes that I do from a new top or dress… is that weird?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. robsmc

    Sigh … me too…
    Being short, with big boobs, bad feet, orthotics, glasses and no confidence might contribute, tho ….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Yeah!

      :-(

      Work on your self-esteem… then your wardrobe. Ironically, a good bra and some flattering clothes might make all the difference!

      Also, if you really hate your breasts (I can relate, in some instances), consider having a breast reduction. My sister had one and has never looked back. I would probably never have one, but I wouldn’t want my boobs to be any bigger (12DD).

      Hope that helps

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  4. Kaz

    “..and some days it’s just too hot for polar fleece”.. Really made me laugh, Kylie. Yup this is me too. I just can’t raise more than the most vague interest in shoes/handbags/make up etc. I can spend money quite easily on books or quirky gourmet foodstuffs but clothes…meh. Like you my mum and sister are quite into clothes shopping etc. I missed that gene, but I don’t miss it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. odette

    Thank you, Kylie! I was actually starting to wonder if there was something wrong with me, because of my lack of interest in fashion and make up. I do like to get dressed up on occasion, but my wardrobe is not extensive, and most of my shoes are black (sensible!).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kylie L

      I get this. I like to get dressed up too on occasion. I’m not anti-fashion, I just don’t understand how it works!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Natalia

    I LOVE SHOES but tend to gravitate towards those that are sparkly and really impractical. I really must attend more parties that call for ridiculous shoes…

    Clothes not so much – I like clothes shopping for about 20 mins and then I quickly get frustrated with the amount of junk that’s out there and wander off to get a donut instead. Is it just me or does the quality of clothing keep going downhill while the prices just go up?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • LaLaLauren

      Spot on Sister with the increase prices and decreased quality.

      I’m sure sparkly shoes would be welcome (and encouraged) in the MM Office :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Natalia

        They would definitely be welcome but it’s a looooong walk to the bus stop and I can never be bothered carrying anything I don’t have to carry (whine whine whine!)

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Fiona

      I gravitate towards everything sparkly! Phone covers, shoes, bags, headbands….everything but the dresses. All I wear is black dresses to set off all that sparkle- and like you I SWEAR they’re getting more expensive for poorer quality!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  7. Melsie

    Kylie, you’re a woman after my own heart! I fear I am going to disappoint my daughter too. She’s only two, but already loves the clothes. I put a new top on her the other day and she patted it down with her hands and then enthusiastically exclaimed ‘I LOVE it!’. Oh dear.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. kellyexeter

    See this is why we are twitter friends ;) I loathe shopping and have no interest in clothes and shoes. I have sartorial friends who drag me out for my one shopping expedition a year and that helps me stay presentable.

    I do however love bags and have like, a million of them. But that’s because you don’t need to try on bags!!

    And I too have heard this one from both my mother and my husband: “I love it when you try.” !!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Mimi

    i love being female for the reasons of Fashion and make-up! i think life without these would be very dull indeed!! i am your typical girly girl and was always playing dress up in my mum’s clothes when i was younger and wore make up since i was 5 for my ballet concerts its been part of me forever and i love looking and feeling great everyday by wearing a brigh lip or statement shoes or fab dress! ^_^

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Yeah!

    I couldn’t give a crap about shoes, bags, clothes or fashion.

    I hate spending/wasting money on it. I see it as an expense. And I find shopping utterly painful – I have to be in the right mood ie. one where I’m not going to lose my sh!t.

    If someone could magically put a few pairs of pants/jeans/tops/skirts/dresses/undergarments/accessories in my wardrobe that look good on me and will keep me warm/cool/well-dressed, that would be ideal. While I don’t have a lot of clothes, I seem to be able to pull together an outfit when I want to look half-decent.

    I really wish I enjoyed the whole fashion thing more, as I know other women get so much pleasure out of it, but I’ve given up trying to force it on myself. When it comes to shopping, I now approach it as I would chores/exercise/going to the dentist: Just do it!

    Ironically, I love malls. I enjoy takeaway coffees, browsing books, CDs and DVDs, testing perfumes, window-shopping, people-watching and cooing at puppies in the pet store window. :-)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Dee of Adelaide

    Me either. I wear a work uniform of black suits and pink shades of shirts (suits my complexion I’m told).

    Don’t care about make up. Wear the same black flats all the time.

    My one weakness is perfume. I wear excrutiatingly expensive perfume every day.

    One of my biggest beefs in life is the ridiculous amount of money clothes and shoes cost, especially for a person who gets no joy out of them!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. HB

    Now Kylie, tell the truth – the real motivation behind writing this article was to use ‘cuckoo for Choo’ – best line ever!!

    I am much the same though – I would love to be into fashion and shoes, but I’m just not wired that way. Love the way it looks, but can’t translate it to looking good on me. And I can’t walk in heels!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kylie L

      Hah! No, it wasn’t, and in fact that line only came to me in a second draft- but when it did, yeah, I punched the air. :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. Elbe

    Me neither. Couldn’t care less about shoes, clothes and stuff.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Oz

    Definitely not a shoe or clothes person!! I just find fashion exhausting and pointless. But I live for skincare and makeup! Could shop the David Jones beauty hall forevermore!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Simone

    I love shoes, but not the towering high heel type. I’m more into cool, comfortable & practical. These boots below are on high rotation with me right now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Deni

    I don’t like shoes either! Finally someone else! Lol. I’m tall already and so high heels are just not my thing. I have a pair of plain black heels that arent too high and thats IT as far as heels. Do like boot shopping in winter though, but only have 2 pairs of those and can only get flat suede ones.

    I however LOVE clothes – too much. Dresses especially – how can anyone not? you just slip them on and you’re done. Sigh. Unlike Jeans – worst.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Lana

    I do love shoes but my reluctance to wear leather makes that love very shallow

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Alicia

      I also love shoes Lana but refuse to wear leather because I am vegetarian.

      Finding nice synthetic shoes that are good quality and don’t make your feet smell is a constant trial.

      I just want some nice pumps in beautiful colours that aren’t made from the corpse of an animal. Is that so much to ask for?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • ClaireBear

      Me too.
      I have a number of pre-vegetarian era leather shoes that with care and respect should last my lifetime. I won’t buy any leather now though.

      There are still cute shoes out there – I’ve found I just have to look harder. Verali and Novo both have some great faux-suede shoes and boots this season. I also love some of the satin heels that are around. And the internet has heaps of non-leather shoes, from cheap to high-end (hello, Stella McCartney!)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  18. Cait

    I adore shoes but I struggle because:
    1) Im terribly picky and specific
    2) my toe surgery has left me with a disfigured toe, so peep toes and strappy sandals are now not options.

    I have dealt comfortably with issue 1 for years, but this new issue 2 is really destroying me :( in a first world way.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • LaLaLauren

      I’m with you on issue 1.

      Too pointy, too round, heel too fat, heel too skiny – Blah blah blah.

      Perfect shoes, please just magically find your way to my doorstep!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  19. Carohutchison

    I’m with you Kylie. My solution is to rope in a stylist friend for help once a year and do as much shopping as I can tolerate (usually about two hours). That’s it until the clothes start wearing out.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. beee

    Ok well I havent even read this post yet and im gathering it is something to do with shoes. That picture was FAR too distracting! I WANT THOSE SPARKLY WEDGES.

    I will now read the post :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. WTE

    I’m exactly the same! Jeans plus Tshirt most days and I live in Colorado shoes because they are so comfy.

    Actually I was reading one of the Mamamia articles last week I think with photos of what everyone was wearing and thinking to myself that I would just not fit in at the Mamamia office with my lack of interest in fashion. And then I came to Rick in his Selk bag and I have been seriously coveting one ever since.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Melsie

      That’s exactly what I was thinking!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. MaryV

    I love bags but have started to cull the number I own as I don’t use them all any more. I have given some to charity and others to my nieces. As for shoes, I go for comfort as I do a lot of walking.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...