The best place to be a mother is Norway. If you’re in Australia and Iceland, don’t panic, you’re equal second. Britain, you’re number 10, Canada comes in 20th and America, how times have changed, America, you’re number 31. According to a study released this week, from the 12th Annual Save the Children’s Mothers Index which measures the well-being of mothers and babies.
It seems it pays to be Nordic. Not just because you will no doubt be blessed with long, honey coloured legs and glossy blonde hair, surrounded by Bjorn Borg look-a-likes called Sven, but also because your countries fall in the top ten on the list. After hearing my friend from the Netherlands tell me about her midwife who came to her house after the birth and did her washing and ironing, I’m really not all that surprised.
My current home, Qatar, is on a different list and comes in at number 38, which surprises me as the majority of birth stories here are happy ones. I think they must have spoken to the nurse who gave my friend an epidural and told her it would be “much easier to get this in, if you weren’t so fat”. She wasn’t high on the happiness index of Motherhood at that stage of her 15 hour labour.
I’ve had four babies in four different countries, all were vastly different circumstances, but all had the same outcome. A healthy and occasionally huge baby. The experiences varied from being surrounded by friends and family in Australia, having the woman who cleaned the floor also checking my blood pressure in Malaysia, Mediterranean views in Malta and a small fire breaking out in our overflowing public hospital in Canada.
During every pregnancy and after each birth I have shared stories with fellow Mothers. As parents we speak fondly of the amazing midwife, maybe grumble about the arrogant doctor, the anesthetist that arrived to late, the inedible food. We debate the difference between Private and Public Health or perhaps, depending on where you live, the complete lack of choice.
I’ve discussed whether I’ve had to provide my own nappies/diapers and clothes at the hospital. I’ve become frustrated with contradictory breast feeding advice. There’s been the comparison between the male and female OBGYN (the women have much smaller hands). I feel like I’ve pretty well covered everything, but I haven’t. Not by a long shot.
I have never had to discuss the two day journey that was made walking to the hospital. The fistula I developed after the heartbreaking four day labour and stillborn birth. I’ve never had to think about getting through labour on my own, no doctor, midwife or even someone remotely qualified to help. I’ve never given birth in a camp or walked across a war zone and had a bullet that was three inches away from my womb removed, like a woman in Afghanistan did late last year.
Having a baby can be a terrifying thing the first time around. We worry about so many things that could go wrong, it’s easy to forget that statistically, if we are educated and living in what is commonly known as a “developed country” the odds are in our favour to deliver a healthy, happy baby.
So what’s the difference between coming first, which is Norway, or being last on the list, which is Afghanistan.
Skilled health professionals are present at virtually every birth in Norway, while only 14 percent of births are attended in Afghanistan. Eighty two percent of women in Norway use modern contraception, with Afghan women it drops to less than 16 percent. Women in Norway live to an average age of 83, for women in Afghanistan it’s 45. If I was in Afghanistan, I’d be gone in a few years. How much longer would you have left?
A girlfriend of mine, who is currently working in Afghanistan, told last week of meeting an Afghan MP who explained that some baby girls go nameless for two years after their birth, because of the disappointment.
When I think about the births of all of my children, as much as there was sometimes fear and trepidation, I was so incredibly lucky, there was never despair.
The Save the Children Organization releases its report each year before Mothers Day (the women in the UK have already had their Mothers Day but I think they should push for two). The hope is that we will honour our mothers and maybe think about how lucky we are to be born where we were. If you’d like to donate there are many wonderful and inexpensive ways to do so. Here’s a link…






Comments
31 Comments so far
Insightful, witty and well thought out as usual Kirsty. I have passed this on to my sister who has worked many hours, voluntarily for SCFNZ for a number of years. She also enjoyed the article.
loading...
Whoa there are we getting “giving birth” and “being a mother” confused here? Two completely different things….
loading...
Great article Kirsty. Made me realise again how incredibly lucky I am to live in this country. Thank you x
loading...
I am not a mother but do not think Australia is that great . In a lot of European countries women get over a year of paid leave.Plus daycare is cheaper there too. Australia wants young mums to work or study but they need to support mothers more. We can learn a lot from Europe.
loading...
Sorry didn’t read the whole thing.Yes we are lucky compared to many other countries but could be better too.
loading...
What’s Mother’s Day without children?
Can you remember what Mother’s Day was like when you were a kid?
Maybe you were one of the lucky ones. You gave Mum breakfast in bed, your family had a fun day together and you all slept peacefully that night in the same house.
Imagine what it’s like when you love your Mum and she loves you but you can’t see each other. Not because she’s overseas or in hospital but because orders from the Family Court stop you.
On Mothers’ Day 2011, Justice for Children and Million Mothers’ March honour a forgotten group of loving, brave, strong women – mothers who’ve been separated from their children by the Family Law system. Their right to be a mother and primary carer has been taken away. Their children’s rights to be with the mother they love have been trampled.
Why did this happen? Often because the mother, trying to protect her child from harm and abuse, spoke up in the Court. She was then labelled mad or bad by the ‘experts’ and ultimately, as an unfriendly parent by the Judge. Most of these mothers have never been convicted – or even accused – of harming or threatening their child.
Such mothers may flee the country because the Family Court will not listen to them and insists on handing their child to an abusive parent. What would you do when the justice system in this country – a country that prides itself on the ‘fair go’- lets you and your child down?
Mothers involved with the Family Law system are fighting for justice for their children and for their right to be heard. They are fighting a secretive system which has done its best to destroy them.
Family Court suppression orders will make sure that you’re kept in the dark about all this.
On Sunday 8 May thousands of Australian women and children will be spending yet another Mother’s Day apart. They can’t phone or email, the kids can’t make or send cards or presents.
These mothers know how much their children are suffering and are unable to do anything about it. Children often feel (and are told) that their mum doesn’t care. This is pain difficult for many to imagine, and makes Mother’s Day a day of sadness for many.
Family Law in Australia is not working for children at risk and for many mothers and is often placing them in extremely unsafe situations. Family Law must change now to protect children and mothers and keep them safe and give them meaningful lives together.
Ariel Marguin
Justice for Children 0411 852 452 fixingflaws@gmail.com http://www.justiceforchildrenaustralia.org
loading...
“It seems it pays to be Nordic….After hearing my friend from the Netherlands tell me about her midwife who came to her house after the birth and did her washing and ironing, I’m really not all that surprised.”
Kirsty, the last time I checked, the Netherlands wasn’t a Nordic country.
loading...
Thank you!!
loading...
Thanks Kerrie, “It pays to be Nordic” was more a response to the fact that Denmark, Iceland, Norway, Finland and Sweden are all in the top 10 (as are the Netherlands). I see what you mean though, it sounds like I’ve mooshed them all together. Thanks for pointing that out. I’ll keep an eye on it for next time. Hope you’re having a great weekend.
loading...
Love this post! I lived in Norway for a year and I would say that it’s superiority goes well into motherhood. They have great daycare and education options and the whole culture has a very different approach to workouts balance, helping single parents etc. etc.
We really are so lucky to be living in a developed country and to not have the concerns of women in other parts of the world. What a great week to highlight this MM
loading...
I’m preparing to give birth for the first time soon on the small french tropical island where I live. I’ve got access to world class hospitals and clinics, a wonderful support network in my husband and friends, and won’t pay a cent for the whole thing. I also have a free weekly psychology session until 42 weeks post-partum, generous maternity leave and all sorts of other perks. Even with all that, I’ve been complaining to anyone that will listen about how bad the system here is and freaking out about going through labour in a foreign hospital.
Thanks for putting everything in perspective for me. I should spend more time being grateful for what I have rather than stressing about what language I’ll be going through labour in.
loading...
Thanks Kirsty, great article. Plenty of wit and also food for thought. We have much to be grateful for in Australia.
Lets not forget the indigenous mothers here who suffer unhappy birth outcomes far more frequently than the general population, higher infant mortality, lower life expectancy, higher experience of violence….just for starters. The luck in this lucky country isnt evenly distributed.
loading...
Thanks Kate, I agree, it’s very important to remember that within Australia our experiences can be extremely varied.
loading...
I’m not sure about the stats, but I work in the special ed area in the NT – high rate of cerebral palsy within the Indigenous population. Horrible birth stories and lack on ongoing support.
loading...
Why is that? What cause it all? When it seems like there are resources available
loading...
Causes include trauma during birth, such as lack of oxygen. Within some communities their is little pre-natal care. My private ob volunteers once a month in NT communities and told me that some women have never been seen by a dr until they are in labor. Indigenous children often have low birth rates due to a range of factors.
loading...
And then there are the indigenous mothers here in my suburb, who are in their mid to late teens, smoke through the pregnancy, physically abuse their toddler kids yet are allowed to keep them.
I’ve called DOCS, the RSPCA (it extends to their animals, too), the Aboriginal land council, Police, everyone I can think of., And guess what? The mother still has her kids at home, and the kids are growing up thinking it’s ok to swear at us neighbors, steal from our homes and damage property.
I don’t know what my point is, probably that all Indigenous people should not be lumped together. I’m an Aboriginal woman who holds a job, has not relied on welfare and treats my children with reverence and love. I refuse to be lumped in with those who don’t.
loading...
A great article and full of heplful reminders of what we have to be grateful for, living in such a wonderful country. When we get tied up with the old mums rights versus babies rights regarding the choices available for childbirth we should just remember that the figures speak for themselves. In countries where little or no medical help is available in childbirth, mothers and babies die and Mothers labour for days, their babies die and they become unable to live a normal life afterwards.
loading...
Thanks, Kirsty. Sometimes I get so caught up in how difficult I find my life, and this post has reminded me of how lucky I am.
I am lucky that:
I have two perfect, healthy, charming sons;
I accessed the best healthcare to have them;
I accessed the best healthcare when they got sick;
P-Daddy works very hard, so I can stay home with the boys (and work very hard!).
loading...
I’ll spend the day honouring my grandmothers who I’m very close to, honouring my sister in law who is expecting a daughter in August and honouring my beautiful mum who we lost to cancer in August 09.
one big day of mixed emotions!!
loading...
My Mum offered to work Mothers Day, as she forgot about it. I’m taking her to see Kylie Minogue in June and bought her a shower pack from Lush.
She’s a good mum, we argue, but she always buys me clothes (sometimes frustrating) cooks me dinner, takes care of my puppy. (My puppy, by the way, is so very spoiled by my parents. She sleeps with them, they play with her all day.) So lucky.
loading...
I think you’ve lost your puppy!
loading...
I’ll spend the day with my hubby, other family and maybe some friends and my little boy, almost 18 months old. I will also rub my 24 week preggie belly and be very grateful for all I have – I’m a lucky girl. But I will also visit the grave of my firstborn daughter, stillborn five days past her due date in August 2008. While we do live in the lucky country and things are more likely than not to work out for us in our pregnancies, things can still go wrong. Horribly wrong. I am living proof of that. I was only 28 when I delivered my perfectly healthy, fully formed, eight pound baby girl who did not draw breath at birth. And the pregnancy had been straight forward and extremely healthy. Things just took a turn for the worst once I went in to labour, and we lost her at the final hurdle. It is easy to lose sight of the statistics that one in about 140 pregnancies in this country ends in a stillbirth. Something that most women don’t realise until it is too late, after it has happened to them. It is a shocking statistic and one that is rarely talked about in this country. We need to change that.
I wish all the mums out there a happy Mother’s Day this Sunday. With an extra special hug for those who do not have all of their children here with them.
loading...
So sorry for your loss. It is a heartbreaking statistic, and far too often the cause of stillbirth is unknown. (I’ve heard 1/200 more commonly quoted, but either way, a lot more than people think).
I hope everything goes well for this pregnancy and beyond.
loading...
So sorry for your loss, I can’t even imagine. Although you can never replace your beautiful baby girl, I’m so happy for you that you’ve gone on to have a family. My poor great-grandmother had one baby (my grandad) and then a horrific 4 stillbirths and 3 late term miscarriages! It turned out she had O- blood, her husband 0+, but they didn’t know the effect it had on babies back then. So sad. At least we’ve advanced somewhat since then, but still lots of work to go, it seems. Hope you have a lovely Mother’s Day
loading...
Breaks my heart to think of those ‘nameless’ girl babies
Give them to me please….
loading...
I agree, I didn’t put it in the piece but the other comment made was “sometimes the dog will have a name but the baby will not”. I haven’t been able to stop thinking about those little girls since my girlfriend mentioned it. The despair of the Mothers is unimaginable for most of us. My girlfriend who is based in Afghanistan is a journalist and I know she is planning to do a story on the situation later this year, I’ll make sure there is a link on my blog when it comes out. Kx
loading...
Just gave my beautiful 6-month old baby girl a cuddle.. I can’t imagine poor little bubba’s her age, not getting the bucketloads of love and affection they desrve! It’s heartbreaking.
loading...
This hatred towards girls and women in Afghanistan (and not just Afghanistan obviously) blows my mind. WHAT is it all about? Heartbreaking and horrible.
Look forward to your next article, Kirsty.
loading...
I notice there is nothing in there about WHERE the child is born – Hostipal, home, midwife centre, just that there is a professional in attendence… And only one instance of breastfeeding… interesting article and information, thank you for brining it to our attention!
Mia: I can’t recall if you have bought up the subject of home births (and the govts decision to make homebirths much harder for widwives) yet, I can’t wait to see it and the can of worms that come out!
loading...
I was trying to explain to my children the other night, why Australia is called ‘The Lucky Country’, and how privileged I feel to live here… I will have to add this to the list!
loading...