Do You Like This Story?
Screen shot 2012 10 29 at 11.27.14 AM When your life isnt as shiny as it looks...

Lucy Chesterton.

by LUCY CHESTERTON

My cat was killed last week. My precious little guy, bought for me as a 30th birthday gift by my wonderful boyfriend, he ran away the week we moved house and was crushed by car on the road in our unfamiliar area.

I loved that cat – named Toffee Face but more often known as The Toff- from the moment we saw each other, and with more love than I thought I had in me. To some it won’t sound like a tragedy, because some people just don’t understand about pets. But those who do will know his sudden and brutal death, for me, has been terrible.

This event, many of my friends do not know about… because of my social media smile. Which means, when something heartbreaking happens, you won’t see it on my website.

The Social Media Smile. It’s a term a friend coined when capturing a photo of my two best girlfriends for Facebook one night. She snapped away, and as is habit now, each photo was shown to the group for approval before posting, each being rejected by one or both of my friends.

Finally, the photographer said, “OK, last chance, give me your best social media smile, or that’s it.” And they did. The perfect shot, showing everyone at their best, fit for public consumption. And up it went.

The social media smile goes beyond staging several photos before selecting the best possible one to upload. It includes “checking in” on Facebook -where your location is shown, along with who you’re partying with- when you’re only ever at the latest hot spots with the coolest people, at crazy hours of the night and day.

Melissa Hoyer wrote for news.com.au this week about our new found digital narcissism:

melissa hoyer photo When your life isnt as shiny as it looks...

Is the Happy Life selfie a true reflection?

Publishing houses may be constantly criticised for air-brushing, cropping and making celebrities appear thinner, taller or more youthful than they really are but us mere mortals are also transforming the often ordinary into the, well, extra-ordinary.Sure, we all know smartphones, iPads and tablets are ubiquitous, but with their burgeoning fame we’ve become so self-conscious, realising that anytime, anywhere and at any place, a social media circulated and critiqued picture could just be on the cards.

The percentage of digital snap shooters (yep, I’m part of that crew) is sky-rocketing each year. Just go to a live event, whether it’s a gig, sporting event or school concert and you’ll see hundreds or thousands of smartphone’s held high as their owners click away capturing a chosen “moment” through the frame of a lens.

Meanwhile, the bigger picture often gets lost as we snap away select seconds, even inventing exciting, captioned plotlines to go with relatively bland snapshots.

When was the last time you just took a picture and let it just it “be” as opposed to it potentially being seen by an entire social network? When was the last time you just snapped, let alone printed a picture?

She’s right. When did people knowing what you’ve been doing become as important as doing it? When the amount of fun you look like you’re having exceeds the actual amount. It’s when you don’t post about being made redundant, but you do post when you have a new cool job. At best, it’s putting your best foot forward, all the time, online. At worst it’s all of us creating a false reality where our cats all live forever.

We’re at a point where we have to talk to less and less people each day. Often, we don’t really know what’s going on with someone close to us, relying on their posts to keeps tabs on them. Often, social media allows people to pretend to be someone they want to be, while in reality they’re moving farther away from that person with each post.

Next time your kid comes last in the race, or your boss gives your pay rise to someone else, or you lose $1000 at the TAB, don’t hide it to give a false impression of having it all. Be someone who posts about it. Just take one photo, and post it. With whatever smile you’re wearing.

 Lucy Chesterton is the entertainment reporter for Mornings on the Nine Network and starts work at a ridiculously early hour. You can find her on Twitter here.

Do you post your highs and lows, or just the highs?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

51 Comments so far

  1. Lisa Jensen

    Lucy I am SOO sorry to hear about The Toff – it is absolutely heart-breaking to lose a pet. When my first cat died, I literally could not function for over a week, all I could do was cry :-( So while there are a lot of people out there who won’t understand your pain, please remember that there are a lot of others who DO and who know the horror of losing a fur-baby <3

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  2. jackal

    So sorry to hear about your cat! I haven’t lost a pet before, but I have a cat I’ve had since I was 12, and I know upset I’ve been in the past when he hasn’t come home at night, he’s my special little man :(
    It would be so hard to lose him, and a lot of people don’t understand!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Alice A

    When my cat died, I asked my sister not to post it on Facebook but she’d already done it. I was pretty mad at her because it was a very private thing I didn’t want the world knowing till later. I still haven’t made a post (two months later) about him because it just doesn’t feel right.

    On a lighter note… the amount of people posting about the HSC on Facebook and Twitter is enormous. I enjoy reading through comments, fears, experiences, etc, of students doing the HSC and am comforted that I’m not the only one under such stress!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. That Girl Fiona

    Oh gosh. This is me. My cat was hit by a car less than two weeks ago and it has torn me to shreds. My cat was AWESOME. I too, struggled with wondering whether I should post about it online. I felt like I wanted some of my friends to know what happened, since they knew and loved my cat too… And might want to know if I was upset, but I let it be. I couldn’t even face up to looking at too many pictures of him, it distressed me too much.

    Also, screw cars.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. Clare

    People who don’t know you that well might look at your FB profile and think your life is perfect / you have no real problems. But who really cares? I think thats where your real face-to-face friends come in!

    As long as I have normal, honest, open relationships with people you see in real life, I don’t really think you I need to be airing out my sad stuff on social media.

    I’m sorry to hear about your cat. I too had to get my beloved pet put down over the weekend. I was (and still am) enormously sad, but I haven’t posted this on facebook, and don’t intend to. For me this is a bit too private. Plus its kind of attention seeking when someone posts a big “RIP” status, inviting mass sympathy. But I did tell a few girlfriends who were hugely supportive – in person!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. my thoughts

    I think there is a difference between posting about a sad event in your life & just whinging about nothing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. AJ

    I don’t think Facebook is the place to air stuff like that and I think it’s fishing for sympathy. Surely talking about your problems with close friends/family is the way to deal with sadness in your life. Not putting it out there on social media. I don’t think that is what Facebook is for. As for the checking in thing, I am over it. Nobody can do anything these days without telling the world about it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  8. Haven Maven

    I’m so sorry bout your cat, Lucy :(

    I try and deal with my drama through humour, where I can. My real besties know when stuff is going down with me. Or I tell you guys :P

    I am rather fond of this one, however…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Dawn

    There is something to what you are saying. We don’t know what others are going through, so communicating makes us more aware. And it also makes us realize that we’re not the only ones going through a heartache of some sort.
    There is a great youtube clip that relates to this ….its very powerful, here it is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D38S9o_6qnc&feature=player_embedded

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cora

      wow, thanks for that clip! Amazing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  10. Anonymous

    I don’t post at all but for people who do I don’t think posting negative stuff would go down well. I hear people complaining about other people complaining online: “fishing for sympathy”. I don’t think you can win either way, either you’re a show-off or a whiner.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. Anonymous

    My beloved dog died last year and I most certainly posted on Facebook. Most of my family and friends knew just how sad I’d be and some of them were equally as sad at his death. My circle tend to post the crap days aswell as the celebrations- both are truth. The comments on my bad days usually lift my spirit and are often vety humourous. I enjoy posting the terrible mummy moments – as my friends always comment on them and they result in very funny banter. The celebrations tend to be a ‘like’moment as we all know they are gold and a little more special.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Miss Finance

    So sorry about your cat. I dread the day our dog passes away, he’s a part of our lives and our friend and family member, I adore him more than I do most people I know… it’s not ‘just an animal’. I get that. Make sure you let yourself mourn him.

    With Facebook… I’m torn. On the one hand, I (like many commenters below) can’t stand the attention-seeking ‘vaguebookers’ and find the constant whining updates of some of my friends a real bore…. For the same reason I hate those total downer types who, when you say “Hi, how are you” respond with a long sigh about how tired they are, or how bad the weather is, or how awful the traffic was on the way to work that morning… yawwwwn.

    However, I also hate the thinly disguised bragging from some of my friends who seem to be constantly partying or travelling or doing whatever amazing thing they think makes their life seem wonderful at that moment in time…. it always sounds a bit fake to me.

    There’s a fine balance to be struck I think… probably made easiest by staying off FB altogether! In fact, those who rarely post I sometimes find the most intriguing of all my FB friends… there’s something to be said for having a little mystery about you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. MissV

    I’ve hidden most of my friends from my feed. Mostly because who they are on facebook is too different to who they are in real life.

    I don’t think I post too much on facebook or twitter even. Some of it is stupid mundane stuff but it’s not constant (I hope). I am one of those people who does take a photo of a concert and check myself in but once I’ve done that, the phone goes away and I enjoy myself. I mostly do it for myself so I remember what I’ve done. I used to write it on a calendar but posting it is much easier now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Violet

    Also, sorry about your cat :( I bawled like a baby when my dog was run over. Will never forget the phone call at work from my flatmate that she was missing, then coming home and finding out she’d been run over. Oh, still makes me teary. I get flashbacks when my flatmate calls me at work now! He knows to text unless it’s really important!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Violet

    I completely agree with this post, but it’s a hard one. There is nothing more annoying than those people that constantly complain on social media – hard to find the balance! I try not to post anything boastful, or that is a complaint – just things that might make people laugh or smile.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. Amanda

    I am a Mum of three, yet when our 5 month old puppy got very sick and passed away within 24 hours, I was distraught. It felt like I had lost one of our children. Thank goodness they were still too young to really understand. I did share this loss on Facebook, and got so many sympathetic comments, as I generally do try to limit the “whingebook” factor. Im very sorry for your loss, Lucy x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. beck

    Facebook is purely entertainment and amusement for me also – people who use it to air personal stuff / whinges etc I dont really get – I try to share funny pics / observations with the intention of making my friends smile and entertain them too – the real stuff is for real friends whom I see in person and know the real me. Anyone who really wants to air thier personal lives in such a public forum…hmmm… need to get a real life ….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  18. Indeed

    I find this really hard.

    On the one hand there are two fragile people that I am friends with on Facebook who regularly ‘vaguebook’ (love that term!) their distress and post inanities. Knowing they are both hurting underneath makes me sympathetic but uncomfortable. To one (who’s a young indigenoua girl I met professionally while mentoring her) I want to tell her it would be a good idea to think of Facebook as a press release for her life- mostly because she has so many professional contacts as friends and the life-stream doesn’t do her any favors. But I haven’t said anything for awhile now. Not sure of the best approach.

    The other thing is closer to home. I moved 9 months ago to a rural location with my 3 kids, my husband stayed behind finishing up work. For 8 months Facebook has been a connection to the outside world that I’ve needed through some dark and stressful times.

    My feed however has been full (a few pics a week) with the small moments of joy in the new life. Chickens, horses, veggies and kids- the rural idyll writ large. My friends say they love seeing the pics- but I am putting forward a hopelessly skewed image of the reality of a sea/tree change. Insincere? Misleading? Or a way of finding and sharing the joy in a dark time?

    I think the last- seeing peoples interest and virtual shared joy has reminded me why we made the move in the first place.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. MJ

    I’m so sorry about your cat. I know what you mean, I love, love, LOVE my cat and I am going to be devastated when she goes. She’s my little furry cat soulmate.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. oneofthesarahs

    I try to only keep my Facebook upbeat because I don’t want to sound like some of the drama queen people who fish for sympathy every time they have a “bad” day. If something significantly bad did happen to those people I wouldn’t actually take it in because they complain when the rain held them up from getting their kids home from school and then their kids had to do homework when they wanted to watch TV so they whinged for an hour and their life is just so awful because of this. I try to not whinge in general so I keep to this with Facebook, might mean it seems like I sugar coat my life, but it’s not my intention. I do keep friends informed of my life – the good and the bad, but not using Facebook.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. I have noticed that I do two different things, post my break up on social media. Facebook, I am all positive and happy – to ensure that if Ex Mr W (who I have deleted and most of our mutual friends I have deleted, but on the off chance he see’s that someone has commented on my photo/status or someone we know in real life reports back) sees anything – he thinks I’m TOTALLY OK.

    Twitter, however, I let it all hang out with my sadness and anger. STRANGE.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Violet

      I’m the same! Because twitter is more anonymous, i use it as a bit of a whinge platform if i REALLY feel the need to put something out there! It’s very cathartic.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • guest

        Lol my bestie has a double online life. Herself on fb, code name on twitter- and that’s where she takes airs of her problems.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  22. Becstar

    Lucy I am so sorry to hear about the loss of your cat. Pets are family members too and I’m glad you were able to express yourself.

    And, I do understand and take your point about using social media , but for me I don’t use facebook that way for a few reasons. I’m not going to spill deep secrets or very serious feelings on that platform because facebook friends are not all ‘equal’. I choose very carefully to whom I share what I consider private information; whether that be joyous or sad news.

    I use social media for fun. I write funny posts, sarcastic posts and when odd things or funny situations or conversations occur.

    I treat facebook/twitter as a form of amusement.

    My close friends know the truth. They are deserving of it. Not everyone on facebook is.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • pushing30

      I completely agree!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  23. Anna

    I think it depends how you view your social media. For me it’s an extremely limited snapshot into my life, most of my posts are witticisms from my kids (because that’s what my friends ask for!). The real ups and downs, the “real” stuff is kept for my real friends, to be told about in person because quite frankly I don’t want my general FB community knowing about my raise or my redundancy.

    It’s facebook, not your actual life.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. lubelle

    Thank you Renae and Phoodie. My mum calls it Fakebook, and it can be just that! X PS great post from you too,Phoodie!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Anonymous

    This article is spot on, and this is exactly why I have started tuning out of FB. You only see a filtered version of everyone’s lives. I’ve decided to use my time ‘living’ rather than ‘posting’.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. mostly

    I keep thinking of a quote I read from Claire Bowditch recently; it went along the lines of ‘don’t compare everyone else’s highlights reel to your cutting room floor’. In other words, keep in mind that everyone is composing a positive, constructed reality. Sage words I think.
    Very sorry about your cat. x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Mary

    I see plenty of people posting all the negative stuff in their and to be honest it becomes tiresome. My SIL and niece are the worst because they’ll ‘check in’ at the emergency at a hospital but not explain why. Comments like “I’m having the worst day. I just want to cry.” The usual suckers will all ask what’s wrong but it’s never explained. Just the occassional, “I’ll pm you.” Too private to post the details but not private enough to miss out on some attention.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Kate

      I call this vaguebooking. I hate it so much!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • chillax

      I hate that too. They’re just attention seekers. They drip feed their information so their ‘friends’ ask for details, which makes them feel popular!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  28. Anna S

    im so sorry about your cat Lucy. losing a beloved family member is so hard especially when its so sudden and so awful . sending you love xx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • lubelle

      Thank you, Anna! Strangely enough I actually feel better now, sharing with this community :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  29. Cath

    I am one of those rare people who lets it all hang out on social media – and no I’m not talking about my assets. If life has thrown me a curve ball my social media friends will know about it. When my Dad died suddenly and I was unable to fulfil a work obligation the next day (photographing a wedding) my social media circle of friends put out the call and I was able to find suitable replacements. Keep it real on Blogs, Facebook and Twitter and people will respect you more.

    Just my 2c anyway.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. LJ

    I don’t usually post overly ‘down’ things on facebook due a now ex-friend’s excessive over sharing. It was depressing as hell, and it was constant. To the point that we are no longer friends (her instigation) because I didn’t join the latest pity party.
    It wasn’t just the depressing content, but more the fishing for validation etc that she was searching for that made it hard to read.
    I’m not saying don’t put anything negative out there, but maybe if it’s a bit more balanced?
    I’m sorry about your cat Lucy, that is devastating. x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anna S

      oh, i forgot about the chronic oversharers when i wrote my post here…..i just deleted one from my facebook too….seriously no less than 3 or 4 status updates a day and all negative… “FML my life is so hard i have a headache/am late for work/broke a nail FML FML poor me everyone give me sympathy NOW” . drove me mad.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • lubelle

      Thank you so much, LJ. It’s such an awful thing. I miss him . I desperately want to get another cat because I’d love to rescue another kitten from the shelter but it is too hard where we’re living now. I hope you haven’t had to go through the same thing, X

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. Reannon

    I think what is worse is when people constantly post about all the bad things in their life! The ones who talk about babies who wont sleep, bills they cant pay, how bored they are. Its ok if that stuff is posted every now & then but not 5 times a day! I try so hard to keep my Facebook stuff positive but still real. I don’t want my friends to read about how sad I am or that I’m stressed out. I keep that for my IRL conversations with my close friends.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. phoodietweets

    I guess that’s why it’s called FACEbook and not LIFEbook…..

    Often it’s just about the appearance….

    Great piece Lucy! :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  33. Kate

    this is an interesting topic, one that has many sides. I think we all, whether via social media or not, put our ‘best foot forward’ in many circumstances. Whether it be in social groups, school pick ups chatting with other parents, work….. we don’t, as a society, often share the negative aspects of our life. Most people have very close friends with whom they talk about most things – relationships, work, things that go wrong. But I think in daily interactions and life, we all like to share the good. And there’s nothing wrong with that. Facebook, indeed, has become a platform for showing our lives in a whole new glossy filter. I guess there’s nothing wrong with that. In the days of photo albums, slide nights of friends holidays, etc, people wouldn’t have put photos in those albums other than happy, fun looking ones either. It’s just all so much more in our faces now. One positive for me, is that I don’t think I’ve ever sat down with friends and looked through each others photo albums, and its great to be able to see some things of my friends lives that we otherwise wouldn’t have shared with each other. For many people, facebook friends are also just that, facebook friends, perhaps not even acquaintances. And like the school pickup, or talking over the water cooler at work, I don’t think we tend to share the negative with people we don’t know really well. I have used facebook to show many happy photos of my life. I even have a kind of ‘blog’, staying within the comfort of my facebook page where i can decide who sees it, trialling it on my friends before I have a go in the real blogosphere. My darling mother in law died last year, and not once have I mentioned that. That time was the hardest our family has faced, with her chemo and very intense illness, watching her die. Facebook, for me, is somewhere that you don’t share those things. Out of respect for my mother in law, my husband, and my family, it would do no honour or respect to her to post any of this on facebook. When she did die, I did not post that had occurred, nor photos of her. Some things are just too personal for facebook. And I think its just so ok to have that in our lives, to share the happy stream of our lives, whether we’re sugar coating it or not…. who cares? I would like to think that if something dreadful had happened to a friend, or even if they were having a hard time, that it would not be through social media that i would find out, but that our community still is such that we are engaging enough with each other to tune it, and facebook can continue to be something people can just get some fun out of…. if we put up photos of the good, really…. so what!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Renae

    I’m so sorry about the loss of your kitty friend, Lucy.

    I totally understand what you are going through. Who cares if they have fur and four legs, they’re still our family (maybe even our kids… and before anyone judges me, I know that pets are not like human children. I do not anthropomorphise my animals – but I love them dearly, I consider their welfare to be my solemn responsibility, and they are my very best friends. Like Lucy, I would be absolutely devastated if they died. If you don’t understand any of that, you’re missing something significant in your life.)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. K.

    I’m so sorry about your cat. Unfortunately on my way to work this morning I saw a car run over a cat and drive away. The poor darling was lying on the street trying to lift it’s head but luckily it wasn’t suffering for long. Luckily a lovely lady stopped to move it to the side of the road – I tried to help but couldn’t bare it :( Take care when driving people :(

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  36. Julia

    Thank you for this post. I’m getting so sick of people portraying fantasy lives on facebook. It’s inauthentic and boring. I think it adds pressure to women and feeds into the idea that women need to act like everything is great all of the time.

    I have a friend who was recently giving almost hourly facebook status updates on how fabulous moving to NYC has been and how much she loves her new job, only to find out through a friend that in reality she is actually miserable and counting the days to when she can come back home. I don’t expect her to be honest about how miserable she is on facebook, but she and so many other people actively project these fantasy versions of their lives.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  37. Jess

    I try not to be one of those people who posts multiple statuses a day “and now I’m doing this” “this is sooo annoying” “ooh I love Ben on Big Brother”… I’ve increasingly stopped sharing too much mundane stuff because I don’t want to be THAT person at all. I just figure people will assume that when I’m not posting, my life is pretty boring. (Read: a lot of the time.)

    That said, I went to Europe earlier this year.. Yeah, I was a little bit guilty of the happy, cheesy grinny tourist photos. I did try to keep it real by posting this status:

    “The less ‘glamorous’ side to travel – scrapes from a fall (while intoxicated), random bruises, swollen foot, heat rash, minor sunburn and the obligatory cold. But it’s so worth it!”

    Was going to post a photo of my heat rash ridden/that-probably-needed stitches-in-hindsight injured arm but figured it was a bit tooo far.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. Anna S

    This article could not have been more perfectly timed. I have just had this realisation in the last few days.

    i had a miscarriage last week after almost two years of trying to conceive, and its so easy to feel so alone, so bitter, and my facebook feed is full of friends and aquaintances announcing their pregnancies, and belly bump and ultrasound pics. on the surface it seems like everyone else can fall pregnant effortlessly, everyone except me.

    and then i was talking to another friend about it, and she has been trying to conceive for almost four years, IUI,IVF,you name it, no success as yet, and she ended up deactivating her facebook account because it was hurting her so much with every pregnancy announcement.

    and then we came to the joint’duh!’ realisation – its not just us who are struggling and fragile, of course not, but nobody posts about their pain, there are never statuses like – ” ANOTHER negative pregnancy test, over a year of still not being pregnant, yay for me, oh and heres a pic of my 87th negative pregnancy test” . people only share their triumphs. and of course this extends to all areas of life, health, jobs, relationships, fertility.

    and then i wondered what the reaction would actually be if we posted our pain, but i wasnt brave enough to do it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon

      I’m so sorry for your loss. Sending hugs xxx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      Sorry to hear about your miscarriage. I started miscarrying over the weekend and went to the walk in clinic for them to have a look and confirm it. There were seventeen other woman in the waiting area all with similar problems. We are not alone.

      Statistically this time next year you are likely to be one of the women announcing her pregnancy or showing off pictures of your new baby. Hang in there, you won’t feel like this forever.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions