
BY MIA FREEDMAN
Over the holidays I felt really bad about my body. I won’t go into details because I’m not fishing for compliments or reassurance.
I debated even writing this post because I am passionate about promoting body positive messages and saying that I was feeling crap about myself is not exactly true to that philosophy.
Except that my over-riding philosophy, even more than being body positive, is being authentic. Honest. I don’t believe we do each other (or ourselves) any favours by only speaking about how things SHOULD be. Sometimes we need to acknowledge how they actually are. Hopefully we can then try to work out why and fix it but I’ll get to that in a minute.
It’s ironic that I spent some of my summer holidays feeling bad about my body because I was going to the gym almost every day.
I realise this isn’t the way it’s meant to work. On holidays you’re meant to NOT go to the gym. It’s only when you get back to regular life after Christmas that you’re meant to get all resolution-y and start going to Pump classes or lifting weights.
I know. I KNOW.
But I like to exercise because it’s good for my head and it’s actually a treat for me to have the time to do it during the less structured, frenetic pace of holidays. Also, gyms are a novelty for me. I usually exercise alone at home on my treadmill in my pyjamas with a sports bra underneath. I’ll leave you with that sexy mental picture while I tie my laces.
Anyway.
So I’m at the gym on the treadmill and the stepper (I’m a mindless cardio type of girl) for about half an hour a day, listening to podcasts or music on my phone.
In front of me, like at most gyms, is a bank of TVs playing music videos. This too is a novelty because I never watch music videos.

Ever since I had kids, they’ve been banned in my house just like crack and cigarettes.
It was only when I found myself thinking “I feel fat” that I remembered some great advice I once read from a therapist who said you should always answer that bit of internal dialogue with “…but fat is not a feeling. What’s actually going on here?”
And then I realised what was different. What had triggered this unexpected bout of focus on what my body WASN’T (toned, skinny, ‘perfect’) instead of what it was (healthy, strong, the bearer of three children).
The difference was music videos.
Bloody music videos.
Nothing else had changed in my life. I was on holidays, relaxed, happy, unwinding from stress…..I hadn’t particularly gained weight so WHY THESE WEIRD FEELINGS OF FATNESS?
For half an hour every day for almost three weeks I had unwittingly exposed myself to a steady diet of images like these:

The Pussycat Dolls in the video for their song Don't Cha
At first, these videos simply pissed me off due to the appalling way women are portrayed like porn stars. I’ve written about this before, the way this type of imagery is invading public spaces like bars, bowling alleys, restaurants and gyms and how uncomfortable it makes me. Particularly when I’m with my kids.
How has this kind of imagery become wallpaper? How have we allowed a small group of men in the music industry to confuse pop music with stripping and portray women in such a demeaning, one dimensional way? And how did it quietly become a backdrop to our daily lives?
The vast majority of music videos featuring women are as soulless and nasty as bad porn. Girls in their undies faking how insanely pleasurable it is to hump the floor or feel your own boobs? Please.
But at the gym, on the Nightlife video feed that is used by countless pubs, gyms, bars and restaurants, even in the music videos that weren’t that sexually explicit or degrading, there was still an unrelenting depiction of skinny, ‘perfect’, tanned, toned, young, ‘hot’ bodies.
Bodies that are rarely achievable unless it’s your full-time job to keep them looking hot. And that’s after you were born with one-in-a-million genes.
As soon as I realised this, I felt immediately better – and worse. I was relieved to find a ‘reason’ for the way I felt but I was alarmed and depressed to see how easily and subconsciously I had internalised that imagery.
Gah.
If I, as someone who has spent most of my career trying to raise awareness about body image could get sucked into feeling like shit, what hope does some poor young girl have when her world is wallpapered in this stuff?
Not just music videos but all the other media depiction of what constitutes hot: almost exclusively thin, white, young and genetically unattainable.
So you know what I did? I prescribed myself some medicine. Over the next few days, I sat down and re-watched every episode in the first series of my favourite US show: Girls.
You may have heard of it after it’s 26-year-old creator, writer, director and star, Lena Dunham won a Golden Globe for herself and another for her show this week.
It’s revolutionary for so many reasons, not least because the four women it stars have normal bodies. With flesh. That moves.

Lena Dunham in Girls
That’s not the only thing I adore about the show – the premise, the writing, the performances, all of it – but it had a profound effect on me visually the first time I saw it because unlike every other piece of mainstream media, it made me feel normal; good about myself.
I loved Sex & The City but the undercurrent I often had after watching it – especially the later series – was of inadequacy. Similar to how I used to feel after reading a glossy magazine. Like my body, my face, my wardrobe, MY LIFE just didn’t measure up. It wasn’t bright or shiny or cool or perfect enough. Not even close.
Girls is the opposite of that; it DOES the opposite of that. I cannot urge you strongly enough to go download a few episodes from iTunes. You won’t regret it.

The sex scenes in Girls are hilarious, awkward, real and awesome.
And as for the gym? Beware. It’s totally in their interests to make you feel bad about your body – it’s the same philosophy that magazines used throughout the 80s and 90s to great effect: promise you that they hold the key to perfection and then whisper words of angst and inadequacy so you’ll keep coming back in the desperate hope that maybe NEXT time, you’ll reach perfection (you won’t).
By all means join a gym. If you want to lose some weight or get fit in 2013, do it. But just be aware of your OTHER diet – the one women’s bodies in the media, and make sure it doesn’t consume you.
How have you been feeling about your body?



Comments
154 Comments so far
bit late to this discussion and perhaps not quite on topic but two blogs i’ve read recently about looks and weight
http://mum-abulous.com/2013/01/07/the-weight-on-our-minds/ – i agree that we spend way too much time discussing weight and body image, including articles like this which help point out unrealistic role models…
and http://www.rolereboot.org/sex-and-relationships/details/2013-01-you-are-pretty-enough-to-find-love – a realistic look at the fact that we don’t need to be ‘pretty enough’ but it is good for oursleves to be self-confident
I think my aim for this year is to not read to much about body image, just be happy with myelf, realistic about the images around me aand yry my best to make healthy decisions for myself
loading...
Great post Mia, I’m a bit embarrased to admit that I’ve never heard of girls but will downloading it! Thanks
I have a gym membership that never gets used! I dance along to dance routines called ‘The Wiggles’ with my 20 month old and then throw in a walk up a steep hill with a double pram for good measure.
Don’t worry – I had this problem too, after I had my second baby. I wrote about it and it was one of my more popular posts on my blog. I found a lot of woman like you and me, experience it all the time. I felt normal again
http://motherhoodherald.blogspot.com.au/2012/12/so-then-my-vanity-kicked-in-and-i-cried.html
loading...
fabulous post Mia. I always feel like have consumed a bucket of candyfloss after browsing glossy mags….inadequacy and illness!
I love my gym. It’s council run and the machines overlook the pool where all different types of real people swim away – super fit and strong, elderly, young, big and small. It;s great and all that sparkly water to cheer you up on a grey day.
loading...
fabulous post Mia. I always feel like have consumed a bucket of candyfloss after browsing glossy mags….inadequacy and illness!
I love my gym. It’s council run and the machines overlook the pool where all different types of real people swim away – super fit and strong, elderly, young, big and small. It;s great and all that sparkly water.
loading...
Lena Dunham is the bee’s knees. I adore her!
loading...
It’s time women objected to the type of music videos played at gyms. It’s not jut about body image, so well described above. It’s also the representation of women as sex objects. If more women agree with Mia’s comments, then please, lodge a protest at your gym. There will be more than you think.
loading...
Keeping up with the Kardashians.
It’s brainless and trashy escapism, but it also shows that you can be glamorous and attractive and still have a ‘normal’ body.
I also keep a secret board on my Pintrest with pictures of curvy women such as Adele, Robin Lawley and Kim K. I look at them whenever I need to be reminded that my body is ok, you can be curvy and beautiful.
It’s weird though, while the ‘curvy’ girls I naturally gravitate to in pictures and think that they are gorgeous, I still get sucked into the whole ‘I am too fat’ thing, even though ultra thin bodies don’t appeal to me visually.
loading...
You lost me… Right around the time you suggested that you take a “holiday” from living a healthy lifestyle and who goes to the gym over Christmas break? Well for starters, people who actually want to feel good about themselves. Yes, it is possible to work a 50 hour week and still look like one of those girls you see in a rap film clip. Even better, pick up a copy of Oxygen magazine and hear the truly inspirational stories about female fitness models and how they manage to keep their crazy training schedules and juggle life and children and everything else.
Growing up I was a dancer, I spent a lot of time at training and my parents taught me the benefit of eating healthy and looking after my body from the inside out. Now I’m an adult I do competitive cheerleading and I am so proud of the body that I earned in the gym, I used those images that you avoid to motivate me and it worked – I didn’t feel bad about myself but I focussed on setting goals and achieving them and it made me feel on top of the world. I know plenty of people who are the same… If tight, toned bodies send more women into the gym seeking a better version of themselves, what is the issue with that?
loading...
I think you may have missed the point … the gym should be there to inspire and support – these music videos do little (if anything) in this regard. Mia’s point is a fair and reasonable one … we are illserved by these clips. Make no mistake – I love and appreciate my gym community but I do find it disconcerting that these images bombard me on the cardio machines. And the holidays are about using the outdoors as our gym!
These images do not motivate most of us … they are not meant to – they are intended as a product to sell music, unfortunately the by-product is making some of us (who have enough insecurity) feel like we’re on a hiding to nothing – the exact opposite of what we want from the gym. Well done and thanks Mia
loading...
I agree with Mia completely. But wasn’t the mamamia post a while ago about adoring Ryan gosling, just as harmful to a young man reading it, as the videos are to young girls? I think as feminists we should be more thoughtful in trying to protect boys too.
loading...
Love this article
Also love your top in the photo where is it from???
I was like you, I was at the gym at 9amboxing day doing a pump class WTF??
My biggest fear is I’m 26 and trying for a baby and I figure if I don’t get a good body now I will never get it once I have chn yet I see women at the gym who have c,early had kids and look great. I have a friend who can’t do an attack class because of her bladder post baby and the baby is 2 I pray this does t happen to me
loading...
You might want to check out “Hold It Mama” (http://www.holditsister.com/). There are no guarantees with pregnancy and childbirth but at least these books can put you in the best possible shape to come out the other side leak free!
loading...
Its such a scary thing. I have a young daughter who is a ballet dancer. We battle over food. She will eat what I give her but only a bit of everything. She tells me ‘there are NO fat ballerina’s Mum’. I took her to the dr who said that even though she is a little underweight offer quality not quantity…but hang on, isn’t that encouraging her? I started to introduce (where you can FIND them) plus size models and women with curves. I have never let her watch music video’s and I don’t buy magazines. Still it is all around us. I fear for our future and where this is going….
loading...
OMG I have one of those too. My gorgeous daughter is 11, has done ballet since she was 3, is a tiny strong slip of a thing (to quote my grandma) and regularly doesn’t eat lunch at school. She uses every excuse under the sun, but has admitted to me that she doesn’t want to get fat. Her ballet teacher has come down really hard her and said she can’t dance two hours each afternoon if she’s not eating the right foods, Seems to have done the trick so far but I need to constantly monitor her.
loading...
I had my second baby three months ago and I’m struggling.
I’m 36, things don’t sit like they used to, in particular a good lump of fat and skin where my baby used to nest.
It’s only been three months, I have eaten like a horse and not exercised, my body is supposed to look this way, but I still can’t come to terms with it.
I never felt this way after my first baby.
Ironically I’m quite slim too but just not my usual shape.
loading...
i lived in a country town for six months when i was in my mid-20s. i was a bit lonely and depressed but i have never felt better about my body. moving back to the city i watched my self-perception change as i reoriented to life with billboards, tv, magazines etc. it was quite an eerie feeling to see how much impact they had on me.
loading...
My gym is my downstairs rumpus room. I run for 45 minutes while watching my sons play Fast & Furious and Modern Warfare 3. Beats posing music videos any day!
loading...
Hi,
I am a 25-year-old woman currently trying to recover from anorexia. It’s a tough, tough battle.
I didn’t think I had been affected by images of picture-perfect girls in magazines, music videos, on catwalks etc. But once I started to learn more about my illness, and the values that I place on body, I can certainly see that the ‘perfection myth’ has taken it’s toll.
For me, clingy clothes that reveal curves/fat/any kind of womanly shape are impure. When clothes hang, it signals to my head that I am doing something right, I am virtuous, I am pure.
I am a smart woman and I can see through my eating disordered mind. Sadly, my logic rarely prevails to beat this mental illness.
The other day I was skimming through a magazine to find pictures to put on my wall that would make me happy. Sadly, I found all the thin, smiling, toned ladies appealed. The models that had been chosen for their natural body shape simply did not.
The ‘perfect’ body type has been drummed into me for so many years, I feel it is impossible to think anything but what the media have told us women for years.
It is a shame that when I see ‘bigger’ (aka normal) models, I think: “oh, there’s the token plus size” or “that’s the magazine meeting their supposed social responsibility.”
While perusing Facebook a couple of days ago, someone I follow had posted a meme with a pic of Ryan Gosling, captioned: ‘Hey girl, keep running.’
Not only is the beauty myth perpetuated by women towards women, but now we are also supposed to be these perfect little creatures to please our demanding men? I hated the meme so much. I’m sick of crap like this being peddled so we all feel terrible.
I wish SO MUCH that I could be bigger and happy.
I hate my eating disorder with a passion. EDs are not just about food and body. Far from it. They take away lives.
Good on you Mia, for admitting that you can be affected by video clips/media images.
Hopefully someday this nonsense will peter out into oblivion.
xx
loading...
I’m struggling to get on the “real is the new glossy” bandwagon.
I just love the escapism, gloss and general fabulousness portrayed by mags and media.
I don’t want to see people who look like me on TV, i see them all around me every day. And there’s enough ‘real’ in my own life.
TV, movies, mags don’t make me feel bad – they simpy take me to another, shinier, place.
I prefer shinier.
It gives me something to admire, to enjoy, to aspire to. I don’t want to read about or watch someone elses messy, inane, awkward, struggly, ‘real’ life. I’ve living my own!
Over xmas, i saw some comments on PJ’s Lifestyled blog where commenters were complaining her trip to Dubai wasn’t ‘real’ or ‘accessible’ enough for them. How dare she not balance the luxury with budget? In contrast, I loved the sheer brilliance and extravagance of the luxury she lived and wrote about. Why is there an expectation that everything needs to be watered down (ie: made ‘more real’) to make the masses feel better about our own situations?
Anyway, I am rambling. Does anyone get what I’m saying?
loading...
I agree a million percent!
I read mags and blogs and watch music videos and feel inspired!
My body is far from perfect.. But seeing these images makes me feel motivated and even see the magic in my own life.
I know I’m a minority.. But I love it!
loading...
agree 100%
it’s why I love vogue. I can’t afford the clothes or look like the models but hey, i don’t feel bad about it because it’s a fantasy!
It’s like when i first started pole dancing. The bodies of the advanced girls are amazing but it didn’t make me feel bad about mine, it made me want to get to a healthy, toned shape!
loading...
Thank you Mia. Great article!!
I get sucked into this all too often and feel utterly crap afterwards. Comparing is not a good habit. I refuse to watch these music videos for this very reason. It’s demeaning to women to see them portrayed like this. And my life and mood is usually pretty good – and then some crap like this can wreck it – so I’m better off without it.
loading...
And because people like you keep reminding young vunerable girls about body image, talk about poor poor me in this story, Which you also fail to mention when appearing in front of cameras, you have a makeup artist/hairdresser, The worst critic of women isnt music/movies, its the journalists who write for these magazines, high lighting womens flaws. And guess what most of the writers are usually women. We are own worst enemys, as you have just proven with what you have written.
loading...
I want to comment about my gym as well. It’s fantastic, everyone is “real”, different ages, body types etc and honest about diet. Only last week the instructor told us we’d all earned a glass of bubbles or some chocolate because of how hard we’d worked in class. I don’t know how many other gyms would have that attitude. They also play whatever’s on free to air, last time I was on the cross trainer it was the cricket!
loading...
Great article Mia….
… but are you suggesting that (along with musci videos) crack and cigarettes were only banned in your house after kids???
lol.
loading...
Couldnt agree more Mia! I try not to look at the screens at the gym, but they’re hard to ignore.. long gone are the days where Cher singing ‘Turn back time’ in a black bodysuit was “omg” risqué.. music clips today are basically porn. The Trumpet player one pictured (with the green jacketed girls) is one of the worst, their skirts don’t cover their ass, the video is filmed “upskirt” and basically they spend the entire time opening their legs undie-less and or giving fellatio to the trumpet *cue another close up of bare butt & wide open legs. From what i’ve seen it looks like most of the women are doing this to themselves, none of the male clips are anywhere near as pornographic. I read awhile back that a lot of the artists are now hiring directors from the porn industry to shoot their music clips. When I was a girl a “sexy” music clip was Madonna pouring milk down her back in ‘express yourself’ .. these days girls are pole dancing naked or stripping and performing simulated sex in the tackiest way. The male music clips come on and they’re just fine but then anything with females is so incredibly degrading, I think unfortunately it has become so much the norm that women in the industry are now doing it to themselves for the attention, vying to out do one another. Id never let my child watch music videos, its a shame because as a child I loved them (but Mariah crooning “Vision of love” in front of a picturesque window, or Whitney wanting to dance with somebody who loves her was the norm for me, not fellatio performing bare assed trumpeters and such), most of the songs themselves are so gratuitously sexualised (“whistle” & “poker face” for eg) id hate my child to sing their lyrics :-0 I think my friend summed up the videos best when he said “this porn has good music” yup :-/
loading...
Mia THANKYOU for this article. I have been feeling absolutely crap about my body this last two days – PMT + no exercise + a weekend of going out drinking and eating pizza and too much bread has made this 43 year old feel terrible!
It was unbelievably refreshing for me to read this article today, and as a result, I have forgiven myself for the weekend just gone. I’m also planning a run with my dog tomorrow morning.
loading...
Couldnt agree more Mia! I try not to look at the screens at the gym, but they’re hard to ignore.. long gone are the days where Cher singing ‘Turn back time’ in a black bodysuit was “omg” risqué.. music clips today are basically porn. The Trumpet player one pictured (with the green jacketed girls) is one of the worst, their skirts don’t cover their ass, the video is filmed “upskirt” and basically they spend the entire time opening their legs undie-less and or giving fellatio to the trumpet *cue another close up of bare butt & wide open legs. From what i’ve seen it looks like most of the women are doing this to themselves, none of the male clips are anywhere near as pornographic. I read awhile back that a lot of the artists are now hiring directors from the porn industry to shoot their music clips. When I was a girl a “sexy” music clip was Madonna pouring milk down her back in ‘express yourself’ .. these days girls are pole dancing naked or stripping and performing simulated sex in the tackiest way. The male music clips come on and they’re just fine but then anything with females is so incredibly degrading, I think unfortunately it has become so much the norm that women in the industry are now doing it to themselves for the attention, vying to out do one another. Id never let me child watch music videos, its s shame because as a child I loved them (but mariah crooning “Vision of love” in front of a picturesque window, or Whitney wanting to dance with somebody who loves her was the norm for me, not fellatio performing bare assed trumpeters and such), most of the songs themselves are so gratuitously sexualised (“whistle” & “poker face” for eg) id hate my child to sing their lyrics :-0 I think my friend summed up the videos best when he said “this porn as good music” yup :-/
loading...
I have been so hard on myself lately because I need to lose a bit of weight but can’t stop eating. In theory I am completely against feeling this self loathing but in practice I am failing at not allowing myself to feel like I am failing because of some extra fat cells. Totally realate. I hope we all get out of our funks! Xx
loading...
As a trumpet player, the ‘marching band’ pictures really pissed me off.
Brass players don’t wear lipstick! What were the producers thinking????
loading...
It is so funny that you have written this, the other day I was waiting in line at Big W and noticed that every single magazine aimed at females – of all ages – featured stories of amazing weight loss. From 5kgs to people who had lost half their body weight, it was clear weight loss was the thing to aspire to. All I thought was, imagine if they did that with some other aspect of your physical appearance e.g. Every single story being about girls trying to get blonde hair because brunette were somewhat bad. We would never stand for that, yet here we are demonising overweight people and making those who are not even overweight feel they are not skinny enough. It’s disgraceful. As for those music clips, my god where do I even start….
loading...
The most unfortunate thing about this phenomenon is the magazines companies are only supplying demand…
If we as consumers didn’t find interest in these articles, they wouldn’t write them.
Mind you, it is ‘that time of year’ for weight loss stories – New years and all.
loading...
I LOVE this pic of you, Mia! It’s stunning.
I’ve gone the opposite route to most this year. Today I cancelled my gym membership. This year is shaping up to be crazy with lots of competing commitments. I knew I wouldn’t consistently go to the gym and I’m not going to beat myself up over it, or waste the money, for that matter. Instead I’ll get runs in when I can and focus on healthy eating. It’s pretty damn liberating!
loading...
Love this article, Mia. I totally agree; there should be a ban for this type of imagery in public spaces and when children are usually awake and have access to the TV. And I am no prude (ask my husband what I’m like in bed! Sorry, too much information – haha)!
It makes me furious to think my 4yo daughter will be prone to these types of imagery constantly slammed into her wherever she goes. Yes, I will do my utmost to negate them, but that’s no guarantee that the exposure won’t have an effect.
loading...
Yes!!! I wholeheartedly agree with this article. In fact, as I read the first few paragraphs I was already planning to write in a commentbox “Go watch Girls and you’ll feel right again”… scrolled down, and saw I didn’t need to.
Lena Dunham is an amazing writer, director, actor. Trailblazer.
loading...
Great post Mia as always,
I must admit watching ‘Girls’ at first made me feel uncomfortable – all those wobbly bits – is’nt this a hollywood thingo??
But what you say is true – it’s actually exactly why it’s impactful Most of us ARE a few kgs overweight (depending on who you reference) probably not a lovely shade of bronze all over and just living life.
So, suffice to say I learned a lot AND I’m really heartwarmed that the show has received such a reception. That’s the best bit for me.
Thanks for posting.
A x
loading...
No one in that show is “over weight” , they may not have zero body fat but that doesn’t = “over weight”
loading...
The gym I go to is pretty fantastic. They do play music videos but I view them as motivation to get fitter and more toned. But this is, of course, just the way I think.
My favourite aspect off my gym is how friendly everyone is, including every trainer there. For reference I go to Tribe Social Fitness in Taren Point, Sylvania, NSW. It’s a bit pricey for such a small gym but well worth the money!
loading...
What’s bothering me most about the projected ideal body type from tv and media, is what it’s doing to the younger girls. They are growing up with this expectation that they have to be thin to be accepted, and are all obsessed with ‘clean eating’, and ‘shredding’ fat. So many girls in their teens and 20′s are posting half naked photos of themselves on facebook and instagram, showing how skinny they’ve gotten themselves for an upcoming music festival. Usually combined with photos of their ‘clean eating’ meals, which consist of nothing but a few raw veggies and coconut water. These images go viral, and other girls see it and believe they have to do the same to be attractive. I am quite confident with my body, and sometimes even I look at these images and think, gosh, why don’t I look like that – before I snap back into reality! I really feel sorry for that generation, and it makes me so happy I grew up in an era where you could eat a normal meal without guilt, and exercise because it was fun.
loading...
I totally agree, I am a member of a gym and I find it totally insulting that I pay for membership and have to watch such trash on the video channel. I would not want my kids to grow up watching that rubbish. It’s also a bit weird/uncomfortable having to watch something that is almost porn with all of these strangers – I really don’t want to see other people enjoying this while I’m working out – ew.
loading...
You know that weightloss is 80% what you put in your mouth. Forget shelling out for gym membership and take a walk down to your local greengrocers.
loading...
I don’t think we ever completely become immune to images in the media making us feel inadequate because feelings are not based on logic.
I think the sooner we accept that it’s a part of life to feel down sometimes, even when logically we know we shouldn’t, the sooner we can move on and focus on the things that make us happy.
http://ticklishcamel.blogspot.com.au/
loading...
Mia you’re super skinny and YOU feel like this? No wonder those of us at the very top of the healthy weight range feel like blobs
loading...
I’m sorry to say but I am increasingly lumping body image obsession into a major dose of affluent people problems… its like the problem people have when they have nothing better to worry about…
so instead of being grateful for having a job/ roof over your head/ good health/ supprotive family and friends… you look at other people and feel bad you don’t have their genes… I mean really… This is a realisation I came to having once been obsessed with my appearence and being miserable despite the fact that everything was going so well for me… Now that I have no job, home or support network… and ongoing shitty health I tell you… I feel like such an ungrateful idiot for all the times I was ‘miserable’ that my thighs touched… Seriously… if you have the time to sit around and hate your body… count yourself lucky… and privileged…
loading...
I reckon you’re right. We (me, husband and 2 kids) recently moved from a low-income neighborhood to a much more affluent neighborhood and one of the first things I noticed is how thin all the women are here and how much emphasis they put on their appearance. It’s not just that people in our old neighborhood couldn’t afford gym membership/surgery/designer clothes/food from the organic grocer; they just didn’t care as much. Here it’s like a big competition, who can be the thinnest and most plastic. The way some of the mums dress up for the school run when I know they are just spending the day at home, it’s so different to where we used to live.
loading...
Have you heard of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs? Before we can consider anything else, we need our basic needs for food, shelter, etc met, so of course you’re right that body image issues aren’t up there with those concerns. But the way we think about ourselves affects our identity, and that’s core to who we are, so I don’t think you can easily brush it off as a superficial problem.
I hope your situation improves quickly though!
loading...
the point i am making is that our identity should be constructed out of gratitude for the things we have and for the people we are rather than out of a consumerist obsession with what we don’t have…
loading...
Hey there, I can see where you’re coming from but the fact remains that mass media DOES have an effect on people, particularly young people (just look at the research about violent video games). You even acknowledged yourself that you were once affected by the same body image issues which can only be worsened by these types of images. It is great that your life has taken you down a path where you have had positive realisations about what’s really important but some people are not there yet and to criticise them for not catching up with you and ‘seeing the light’ is a little naive in your thinking.
It has been well documented that even in primitive societies there was some focus and emphasis on body image and adornment with a recognised epitome of beauty for each community. It’s kind of part of the complexity of being human. It would be a wonderful ideal if we could just pretend we don’t care at all what we look like, or that we don’t match the society’s ideal, but I think that’s a bit unrealistic for many individuals to achieve. But changing the mass-produced images of women (aimed at susceptible young people in particular) as overtly and singularly sexual is one thing we could lobby for. Maybe less people would have to go through the process of realising they have to care SO much about the shape of their body if the society’s ideal of women was a broader concept than it currently seems to be!
loading...
This may sound ridiculous but I have spent the summer so far thinking how disgusted I SHOULD be with my body, being 20kgs over my ‘healthy weight’, yet I don’t. I am happy, no matter what weight I am. I seem to have no incentive to lose the weight, I never look in the mirror and feel annoyed or disgusted. And the amount of women in my life who constantly make veiled comments to me like ‘join a gym, it’s great ‘me’ time’ and ‘I want to be healthy for my kids’ is constant. Constant.
Everywhere around me are women obsessed with gym and being slim and yet none seem that happy and I am happy. And they have no other interests in their life than how they look. No hobbies, things they like to do. It’s just gym, fashion, shopping and that’s it. They are so uninteresting to spend time with.
Doctors tell me I’m a terrible mother, I am going to cost taxpayers money and will die early. But I can’t get past the thought..isn’t the point of our existence happiness? When did longevity of life override the importance of quality of life?
loading...
Exactly! Thank you! I couldn’t agree with you more!
loading...
GIRLS Is my all time favourite show in the whole wide world.. I love it!!
loading...
Agree. Music videos are like the prelude to porn, but set to music. They were banned in my home when I was a child, and I think I will have to have the same policy now that I have children. But given they are in so many public places today, like wallpaper as you eloquently said, how realistic is that?
loading...
Yes, great point. I’ve seen that ad too and thought exactly the same. It’s really off-putting. I’d hate my 5 year old daughter to see it. Does Fernwood think we’re all aspiring pole dancers??!
loading...
I got to Jetts (24hr gym) and they only play free-to-air TV on their screens – it never occured to me that other gyms to anything different. I’m glad I picked one that plays free-to-air TV as I HATE pop music videos. Added bonus, at the moment you can watch the tennis/cricket while exercising yourself!
loading...
Anytime play a mix of the Foxtel music channels (but it never matches the actual music – weird) and they have free to air and some foxtel channels on the cardio machines. They usually have the cricket/tennis on at least one tv around the place too. I loved getting up early and going to the gym and catching the Olympics/paralympics when they were on!
loading...
I dislike the Ferwood ad whether that PT is grinding her front and back ends to the camera, openign her thighs, arching her back and just thrusting. All that is missing is a tramp stamp above her shorts.
She’s wearing what looks like black latex hotpants. It looks like an ad for Sexpo, and it disappoints me. Almost as if they are targeting men, oddly enough. This one: http://www.youtube.com/user/FernwoodFitnessHQ?v=jpdxbP2Ahvo
The other women in this ad look plain old fit & healthy – those images are the kind that inspire me.
loading...
Really? I love that ad! I don’t find it sexy at all. All those women are sports icons – I know one of them personally – the one in the shorts you are talking about and she is a professional dancer and fitness trainer and is AWESOME at what she does. A massive role model for women. This ad just makes me want to get up and exercise and get fit!!!
loading...
Years ago I took out my first gym membership, (this was before videos were showing in front of treadmills). I found it a great experience even though there were mirrors everywhere and I was post-baby overweight. I watched myself gradually transform from the class fatty to one of the more fit looking ones over about a year, and though there were tough moments along the way, I found the whole experience so positive.
loading...
Ugh – GIRLS.
Tried watching but the main character is so unlikable. Seriously – living off your parents for 2 years so you can be a writer?
I also thought it was pretty terrible how the main character turned her nose up at the thought of working at McDonalds. Newsflash – that’s how most people start out and work their way up. Get a job!!!
The clincher for me was when the main character stole the tip her parents left for the hotel housekeeper. What if the housekeeper was also a writer but who actually got a job to support herself instead living off her parents?
Don’t even get me started on the nepotism and privilege behind the scenes of that show.
I’m all for body love – but Lena Dunham is not the down to earth, warts and all role model the media is playing her up to be.
loading...
You do know that the writer and creater Lena Dunham is not the character she writes and plays, right? You also know that SJP isn’t actually called Carrie and married to Mr Big, right?
You might hate the character – and she’s supposed to be very flawed, that’s the whole point – but that doesn’t have any relation to whether the person who created and writes the character is down to earth or a role model!
loading...
Honestly there’s no need for catty rhetorical questions. We’re each just expressing our own opinions.
It’s well documented that Lena Dunham grew up with an extremely privileged lifestyle and her own foray into writing was subsidised by her wealthy parents. It’s also well documented that all 4 cast members of Girls are daughters of well known and wealthy people. Trying googling “Lena Dunham nepotism” if you want to know more – it’s one of her highest google searches.
I say good luck to Lena and all of them. They obviously struck a chord with white, Gen Y girls. However it pains me when media reports buy into Lena Dunham being a role model who “keeps it real” just because she’s got big thighs and a belly. Aren’t we all meant to be seeing beyond looks?
loading...
The whole reason she’s ‘important’ is that it’s impossible to see beyond looks when almost every main female character on tv looks like a supermodel. The idea being that if you don’t look like that, you’re somehow failing at life.
She’s not trying to be a role model for good citizens or for every minority in the world – she’s just playing a character that a lot of people can relate to – and by creating a popular show with a main “regular” woman, she’s making
making “regular” looking women acceptable. That’s important. Don’t overthink what she’s supposed to represent.
I also don’t see why it’s problematic that she or the other cast members are privledged. The show still wouldn’t have been made or recieved this amount of popularity if it was crap. She’s obviously talented and hard working – and writing about what she knows. Who cares if she wasn’t starving in an alley while penning the show?
I do apologise for the snarkiness of the comment though. I worked in TV for years and you’d be amazed by the number of drongos who genuinely think that the actors are their characters.
loading...
There are a lot of ‘privileged’ artists (writers, actors, whatever) who bust their chops and still never make it. I take my hat off to Lena. She’s truly talented and has some serious lady-balls!
loading...
Do people all have to be poor and struggling to validate that they have any form of talent or that they deserve a chance to put their vision out there? If she is wealthy, she’s wealthy, money doesn’t mean she DOESN’T have talent.
loading...
She is meant to be flawed, that’s why it’s eye-rollingly and cringe-inducingly funny. I dare say she’s poking fun at many girls she grew up with through her character. And how lovely to see flawed female characters who aren’t clean freaks or “trash” – just women with faults like most of us.
In terms of her privilege, good for her – many people are lucky enough to have supportive parents and she’s made the most of that by carving out a fabulous career.
loading...
I know it’s not the main message of the piece (which I totally agree with by the way) but I loved Girls so much I watched the entire first season in 24 hours. Could NOT stop watching it. But for an even better show with an equally (although ENTIRELY different) strong, compelling and honest female character, try Borgen. About the first female prime minister of Denmark. Smart viewing with heart. It is ACE.
loading...
Tried watching Girls, couldnt get into it. Although i found Lena Dunham very clever, i also found her bloody annoying and whiny. So i switched off.
I think the show is just a tiny bit over rated to be honest.
loading...
I can literally remember each single time that I have seen a less than perfectly flat, toned stomach on TV. These are the ones I think of off the top of my head –
* Honey Boo Boo Child exclaiming “look at this big thing” whilst clutching her stomach fat and pointing to it.
* Larry David’s personal assistant in Curb Your Enthusiasm Season 7, Episode 6 called “The Bare Midriff” who shows of her healthy muffin top around the office.
* Rebel Wilson’s character in “Bridesmaids” when she shows of her tequila worm tattoo on her back and proceeds to empty a whole bag of peas on it.
* And of course notably Lena in “Girls” when she does her sex scenes.
And you know what they all have in common – COMEDY. It’s comedy when a woman with a stomach that is NOT flat shows it off. Its only ever used for comedic effect. And we wonder why women hate their bodies?!
And I think of all the women I know in my life and only maybe say 5% have flat stomachs.
loading...
Adding to this, Kimberley Craig and her muffin top in Kath & Kim, displayed bravely by Gina Riley many times. Again – comedy. You raise a valid point.
loading...
I am so over the ‘I hate my body’ sob stories I’m sorry but I just am.. It’s about time women looked at things in music videos, magazines, TV shows and the like as what they are. Magazines as being airbrushed, the girls in the music videos have bodies like they do because its their job to have bodies like that and they work hard at achieving that body and those in TV shows same deal its their job to look healthy! All this skinny bashing is just getting beyond a joke. Those that are a size 6,8 10 ect are NORMAL. We don’t spend all day exercising or not eating we are normal just like everyone else and we just happen to be thin and pushing your insucuritys onto us is not the way to love your body no matter what your size and shape.. I love my body I like the way I look I’m also a mum of 3 kids and have never been so happy in my body.. It’s not perfect but I have never been so comfortable in my own skin. Maybe it’s because I take things for what they are instead of trying to be something else I’m not… Girls no matter what your size nothing is more sexy than having self confidence and portraying that in the way you present yourself to the world..
loading...
fully agree.
on the premise of this article i shouldnt look at art museams because i will never reach that level of talent. dont go to music concerts for teh same reason.
nope confidence is being at peace with yourself.
loading...
Get away from the cardio tv area, hit the weights hard and you will feel fabulous about your body and strong to boot!
loading...