Do You Like This Story?
 Confessions of an emotional eater.

Rebecca Sparrow

By REBECCA SPARROW

I couldn’t take my eyes off her.

Last week, I saw myself at Coles. Well, in the carpark outside to be exact.

I was loading groceries into my boot when I saw her.  A woman, a mother, thirty-something years old, sitting behind the wheel of her blue Honda Civic  silently eating what looked like a Snickers.  And it was the look on her face — not of enjoyment or pleasure but numbness – that caught me.  Caught my breath for just a moment.  Because I used to do that — secret eat — nearly every single day.

I am what you would call an emotional eater. For the last 30 years, stuffing food into my cake-hole has pretty much been my coping mechanism for everything.

My best friend will be in town this weekend!  WOO!  I’ll celebrate by eating two of my daughter’s TIny Teddy packets!  I have to finish those edits by 10am tomorrow? Pass the leftover lasagne.  Ava’s starting her first day at kindy and doesn’t know a soul.  Excuse my while I stand at the fridge and eat a cheesestick, last night’s fried rice, and six spoonfulls of Nutella. Okay, seven.

If I’m scared, bored, depressed, nervous … yep. I eat. I’m a non-descriminatory eater.

secret eating Confessions of an emotional eater.For years, you could take a look through the hidden zipped compartments of my handbag and without fail see the glimmering pink of a Turkish Delight wrapper.  Under my car seat?  It wouldn’t take CSI to find a rogue fry as evidence of my I’m-just-going-to-tune-the-world-out-and-eat-these-hot-chips moments.

Not surprisingly my weight has fluctuated by three dress sizes over the past fifteen years.

I’ve tried to go all Oprah on myself and figure out why I behave the way I do. Was I just, er, greedy? Possibly. Food obsessed? Entirely possible. ( You know those poeple who casually remark, “I totally forgot to have breakfast this morning.”  Yeah. I’m not one of them. I have never ‘forgotten’ to eat.  Put it this way, I haven’t been hungry since 1984, the year I did the 40 Hour Famine).

What I have always known is that food is my drug of choice. Potato chips are my heroin. Where others reach instinctively for the glass of wine,  a cigarette,  or take their credit card for a whirl around Witchery, I’ll soothe my soul with a spoon and a jar of peanutbutter. Which is why this passage from Caitlin Moran’s How To Be A Woman, struck a chord with me:

Caitlin Moran Confessions of an emotional eater.

Caitlin

People overeat for exactly the same reason they drink, smoke, have serial one-night stands or take drugs. I must be clear that I am not talking about the kind of overeating that’s just plain, cheerful greed—the kind of Rabelaisian, Falstaffian figures who treat the world as a series of sensory delights and take full joy in their wine, bread and meat. Those who walk away from a table—replete—shouting, “That was splendid!” before sitting in front of a fire, drinking port and eating truffles, don’t have neuroses about food. They aren’t “fat,” they are simply…lavish.

No—I’m talking about those for whom the whole idea of food isn’t one of pleasure, but one of compulsion. For whom thoughts of food, and the effects of food, are the constant, dreary background static to normal thought. Those who walk into the kitchen in a state bordering on panic and breathlessly eat slice after slice of bread and butter—not even tasting it—until the panic can be drowned in an almost meditative routine of chewing and swallowing, spooning and swallowing.

In this trancelike state, you can find a welcome, temporary relief from thinking for 10, 20 minutes at a time, until finally a new set of sensations—physical discomfort and immense regret—make you stop, in the same way you finally pass out on whiskey or dope. Overeating, or comfort eating, is the cheap, meek option for self-satisfaction, and self-obliteration.

In a nutshell, then, by choosing food as your drug—sugar highs, or the deep, soporific calm of carbs—you can still make the packed lunches, do the school run, look after the baby, stop in on your parents and then stay up all night with an ill 5-year-old—something that is not an option if you’re regularly climbing into the cupboard under the stairs and knocking back quarts of scotch.

Overeating is the addiction of choice of “carers,” and that’s why it’s come to be regarded as the lowest-ranking of all the addictions. It’s a way of screwing yourself up while still remaining fully functional, because you have to. Fat people aren’t indulging in the “luxury” of their addiction, making them useless, chaotic or a burden. Instead, they are slowly self-destructing in a way that doesn’t inconvenience anyone. And that is why it’s so often a woman’s addiction of choice.

Okay. Wow.

Moran’s words (combined with visits to a nutritionist and me reading I Quit Sugar and Sweet Poison over and over) were enough to inspire me to finally get a handle on my eating habits. Plus, you know, it’s hard to secret eat with a three-year-old in the house. They are TOTAL snitches.  Ava is not averse to greeting her kindy teacher with “Mummy ate all the Freddo Frogs”  while I’m in the background making the universal STOP TALKING sign behind the kindy teacher’s back.  It’s like living with Cindy Brady (who was such a dob-artist she wouldn’t be out of place on Homeland).

But more seriously I started to realise that Ava is soaking it all up. Watching her mother comfort eat her way through life.  She’s learning from me that you navigate your days  – the joys and the anguish and even the boring bits – with a jar of peanut butter in your hand.

There are many legacies I hope to leave my daughter.  But I’ve finally decided eating Kitkats in the car won’t be one of them.

 Are you an emotional eater?  What do you do when you’re stressed? 

 

 

 

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

188 Comments so far

  1. Pingback: Kate Winslet and the lesson I’ll never forget | bird's eye view

  2. Anon

    I used to too, until one day I realised that a piece of cake or block of chocolate wouldn’t make everything ok. At first it was hard I had to physically stop myself, but I got used to it. I found chanting “food won’t change anything” really helped.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Mel

    This post really hit home for me. I am an emotional eater who is learning to navigate through my issues so I can one day soon count this as an issue Ive overcome. Its tough and it really is a day by day achievement not to stand aimlessly in front of the open fridge wondering what I can eat to curb [insert here] emotion. So thanks Rebecca for writing so honestly and pointing me in the direction of Caitlin Moran’s book.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  4. Anon today

    This post, and all the responses below, have really touched me. I went to visit my Mum a little while ago and while looking for a bandaid in the bathroom I found a block of chocolate, hidden in the guest medicine cupboard. I never fully considered what that meant until now. I know she struggles with feelings of inadequacy and poor self esteem – she shouldn’t, she is a fantastic person with lots of talents and people who love her.

    I am going to visit my Mum this weekend and I will ask her how she is going and tell her I love her no matter what.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. adoreyoga

    I work with women with compulsive eating habits and my findings back up studies that show yoga and meditation make a big difference to women who are struggling to find a more balanced relationship with food.

    A study published in Psychology of Women Quarterly demonstrated that yoga is associated with greater body satisfaction and fewer eating disorder symptoms than regular exercise programs. Why? Jennifer Daubenmier, the author of the study says that the effects of yoga create a ““heightened sensitivity and responsiveness to bodily sensations (which) is associated with less preoccupation of physical appearance, more positive views of the body, and more healthy regulation of food intake”.

    Now, not all yoga classes are going to achieve this (I’d be cautious of hot yoga styles), but a class that emphasises mindfulness and is taught by an experienced teacher is a very good place to start if you are keen to make some changes to your eating habits.

    Nikola Ellis
    http://www.adoreyoga.com/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • amyspeak

      Interesting that you would mention mindfulness Nikola, I was just talking to a friend yesterday about how important it is for health. Not just diet, but also stress levels because being mindful can help you “switch off” from problems that can’t be dealt with right away (ie the possibility of something happening tomorrow etc).

      I used to practise Ashtanga yoga a lot and find the asanas really helped me be more present, so it’s good to know there are yoga instructors like you out there.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  6. Rachel

    Where do you start to change? How do you start to change?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  7. Tricia

    Thank you …

    I think the part of this eating in quiet, hidden places is that we are alone in it … on every level, we know something is horribly askew … but how can we speak of it when we do it in secret and in shame? When in every other respect, we appear to be keeping it together and we have worked so hard to keep functioning. Sometimes it feels it is a choice between eating a sneaky two chocolate bars (it long ago stopped being one) on the school run, or sobbing on our knees outside the school pick up line. And we feel foolish because we should be coping but there are just so many balls to keep in the air and no-one ever stops and says, this is just too, too bloody hard at times and I feel so lost in it.

    So, thank you for speaking of it … and for every other commenter who also raised your hand …

    it seems that I have company, and compassion, and the possibility that one day soon I could quietly turn to a friend and say “sometimes I find it all so overwhelming” … instead of shoving my body full of numbness.

    Someday, soon, I may accept that I am more than a number and that I can be a good mum, a good wife, a good businesswoman who sometimes needs to sit in a corner, have a little weep and cut myself some slack.

    Someday, soon …

    but today, today I cheer because today I am not alone in this.

    So, thank you …

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Chellebelle

      Beautifully said Tricia.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  8. anon

    As someone who was previously eating disordered throughout my teenager years (and even up to 2 years ago) it took a major health scare (AI related) for me to completely change my attitude to my body and food in general.

    I now have a fairly healthy relationship with food, and I only hope that other people struggling are able to find the same peace with food and their bodies that I have.

    Quitting sugar was also the best thing i’ve ever done-I now eat healthy, real food (which is surprisingly simple and easy to prepare, and I’m no cook) and I don’t have cravings or uncontrollable urges to emotionally eat. Sarah Wilsons blog has some great articles about the effects of sugar on the body for anyone looking for more information.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  9. Aquamarine

    OMG – reality check here – mother of 3 – carer of 2 kids with special needs – reading about myself. Family issues going on in the background with extended family – had to distance myself from them as I really have enough on my plate with my own family. Have recently been diagnosed with my own medical problems that will not go away but will be positively affected by some weight loss. Love this story – has opened my eyes to what I need to do for me and my family – thanks for writing it Bec.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  10. Teacup

    I really feel for everyone on here who are sharing their stories and their struggle with overeating.

    I too am a quit sugar convert – totally changed my life. It’s not just added sugar to cereal and coffee or obvious sugar like sweets and chocolate. I stopped eating anything that had more than 3 gm/100 sugar. It pretty much cuts out all processed food, low fat food and opened me up to eating real food.
    In my experience carbs make me hungry. Reducing carb intake by cutting out sugar, rice, pasta, bread, flour, potatoes etc completely changed my appetite. I’ve never restricted how much I eat just what I eat so I don’t feel deprived. I think it’s important not to have stuff in the house to tempt you though. And just as important to always have something in the house that you can have and like to eat. That way when you are craving, you eat, just not sugar/carbs.

    I’m genuinely curious about how the habit of overeating started for people. Even as adults it seems like we still need a parent to oversee what we eat- remember Mum “controlling” how many bikkies we had..not just free slather at the bikkie tin. I read somewhere below someone said something about eating like an adult. I think that’s what I mean.

    Good luck everyone with coping with it all. I genuinely hope you can find the mental shift that I think it takes to start on the road to healthier eating.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  11. luce

    In the words of the American comedian Louis CK – “”The meal is not over when I’m full. The meal is over when I hate myself.”

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  12. Snippy gal

    Bec you are brilliant, such an honest piece.
    I have been a secret eater my whole life and always been overweight. I’ve always been physically active but my weight never shifted because of my eating. It’s only in the last year that I have made diet changes and I have lost 17kgs to date. I realise not every emotional eater is overweight but I sure am.
    I have tried everything to stop this crazy eating merry-go-round.
    My personal opinion is it is 100% state of mind and will power. I used to look at people who said things like “I can’t have a heavy dinner it will sit in my stomach all night and I’ll feel uncomfortable” or “that is so awfully sweet I can’t eat that” I’d hear these statements and thing yeah right! I’m one of those people these days. And I can’t remember the last time I ate McDonald’s (my poison of choice) when I knew I would be eating a meal when I got home.
    Who woulda thought ?
    Not me !!
    Sure I fall off the wagon every now and then but it’s rare and hope I am able to keep not that way !
    Oprah once said, “if your eating in your car then you probably shouldn’t be eating it !” Smart lady!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Ems

      Sounds like you are doing a great job darl, well done. I reached the heaviest I’ve ever been today and its due to emotional over-eating and total lack of restraint. I’ve booked a gym session tomorrow morning and just threw out all the crap in my kitchen. Got to start somewhere!! Hope I can report back after losing 17kg in a few months :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  13. kate

    Great article Bec. I wrote an article about binge eating for mamamia last year. If anyone out there is struggling with overeating please read this, it will help to know you’re not alone.

    http://www.mamamia.com.au/health-wellbeing/eating-and-eating-and-eating-when-you-just-don%E2%80%99t-stop/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Carbophile

    This is me to a tee.

    I don’t have kids (yet), but I use food as a way of processing emotion. If I’m happy, I celebrate by eating. If I’m sad, I comfort myself by eating. If I’m working too hard, I take a break by eating. If I have nothing to do, I occupy myself with eating.

    It’s literally insane, and I don’t know how to control it.

    Tonight, for example, I worked late. Literally all alone in the office, last one to leave, hammering through piles of reporting and documentation, I somehow ordered Dominos online… 2 pizzas (one on a cheese-burst crust and one on a puff-pastry crust), a garlic bread, a 1.25L bottle of Coke and something called chicken kickers.

    Even though I knew it was extreme, and way too much food, I still made the driver return to wherever he came from to bring me the garlic bread and Coke he’d forgotten. It was almost a blessing in disguise, but I just couldn’t let those calories escape my monstrous cake-hole (or in my case, carb-hole).

    The entire cost for the delivery was over $50, which is money I can’t afford to spend right now, but it’s like I’m on auto-pilot – there’s no way to reason with myself, because at the time I have tunnel vision. It doesn’t even occur to me to not go all in.

    My eating gets in the way of personal relationships too… Sometimes I’ll come home late because I’ll stop for a sneaky pre-dinner dinner that I don’t tell my partner about, or I’ll hurry somebody off the phone because I’m in the middle of eating.

    I know I need to change. I hate leaping out of bed in the middle of the night to vomit because I’ve overeaten. But where do I even start? Thinking about eating like a regular person makes me feel overwhelmed and panicky… (and kinda makes me want to eat something).

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  15. Anonymous

    Yes, the Nutella!! I’ve banned myself from having that in the house. I’ve only recently let icecream and chocolate in the house as I used to inhale them…

    Thanks for this Bec – I haven’t read all the comments, but I guess there’s plenty of ‘yes, I do that’ comments below. It’s something we are generally brilliant at hiding from other, although our bodies so often tell a story.

    Here’s to health – all tiers of it :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  16. ozlicious

    I’ve been overweight my whole life and am seriously considering surgery to beat it. I actually have a consult booked with the surgeon. I’m also planning on seeing a psychologist to discuss and uncover why I have this desparate need (and desire, and obsession, and addiction) to stuff myself until my stomach hurts.

    I just want to get to a point where food doesn’t control me. I think my food obsession is probably akin to alcoholism on some level — whenever I go out to a party or dinner, I don’t care about the free drinks, all I care about is what food is on offer. When I give a dinner party, I give scant consideration to the wine but great consideration to dessert. My favourite thing about getting out of bed is breakfast. And my favourite time at work is lunch. And my favourite feeling at night is being stuffed full and tired after dinner. How bad is all that!

    I must be able to beat it somehow, right?!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. JustMum

    This is me absolutely. I have know it for along time that I am a secret eater who uses food in the same way as I would alcohol or drugs, the food just allows me to remain functional.(I don’t eat a lot of sweets but McDonalds is my binge food of choice).
    Even though I have this realisation, I have no idea how to stop. I wish I could overcome it and just be HAPPY with being me. I am in my late 30′s now and have been overweight since I fell pregnant at 23. I feel as though I have wasted the best years of my life on this problem yet I still don’t know how to stop.
    Is there something that has worked for other people?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Liz

      I used a psychologist who was trained in hypnotherapy & NLP counselor to get to the bottom of the issues which were at the core of my eating and body image issues. That was a confronting but great journey.

      I also use distraction. If I feel like having a binge on food, I’d go and water the garden, or go for a walk, put on some music that I like to sing to – just do something that makes me feel good and takes my mind off it. I distract myself especially when shopping and have learned to not shop on impulse, I avoid icecream, chips and chocolate isle’s too. Eating before shopping is a good idea. Hope this helps – good luck with your journey x

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • JustMum

        Thank you Liz, for your advice and kind words.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  18. twin mum

    I ate a kit kat in the car today…and when I opened the bit between the seats to stash the wrapper I saw a swarm of other coloured wrappers.

    I don’t know why…I think I do it because I can.

    But the idea of ‘slowly self destructing in a way that doesn’t inconvenience people’ sounds like such a mum thing to do.

    Think I’ll start stashing the 2 bucks that buys the kitkat instead…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  19. MissNeriss

    Holy shit. Caitlin has it. Now I see it, now I understand it, can I change myself?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  20. Rachel

    You are a gem. Finally someone who writes about it with honesty and understanding. And I love that you admit it’s taken time to get used to it. And thank you for sharing the sorts of things you do eat. Sometimes it’s all too confusing!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  21. Mug

    OMG I could have written this article because it describes me perfectly. I have just been to bootcamp, eaten a healthy dinner and even though I’m not hungry at all I’m trying to refrain from eating the cookie dough I have stashed in the freezer. I am a bit glad I’m not the only one though.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  22. Jo

    Ive just read the article, agreed with everything, continued to read all the comments and have again agreed with everything… And all I can keep thinking about is the urge to eat the two bags of lollies I bought at the shops today whilst I was picking up dinner. And I know I’m full. But they are calling to me!

    I have had a problem with over eating and emotional eating for a while. But haven’t ever really thought about it in that sense before. I managed to get a bit of motivation to get a bit healthier and started weight watchers and discovered I stated to lose weight just by cutting out the numerous snacks I was having during the day. Shock horror! Unfortunately I have fallen into my bad habits again and am snacking an awful amount (hence the lollies) – but this article has definitely reminded me I need to get my act into gear. Although I may have to finish the lollies in the house first…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  23. Cel

    Yes, food has always been my drug of choice and notably more so when I gave up the cigs four years ago. I’m lucky that I havent piled on the kilos, but certainly enough to make my clothes uncomfortably tight and basically feel quite sluggish. I find that if I have enough sleep i tend to eat less the next day as Im not trying to prop myself up with sugary foods. However, I have this terrible habit of eating whilst Im preparing food! Ill be getting dinner ready and have already been consuming food in between the car trip from work and picking up two kids and then munching on in the kitchen.Before the main meal is cooked- I have already eaten half a tub of hommus, dry biscuits, an apple, a tim tam… then I am full before I cook dinner! Yes, stress from whiny kids, working, trying to do dinner on the hop!! For me its more than just dealing with will power. its a whole lifestyle change. Ideally I wouldnt work back so late. I would pick the kids up earlier and have time to rest and cook dinner thoughtfully. I realise that I am often mimiking how my mum did things when we were growing up. I need to look at the whole picture and gradually change my lifestyle.

    Yes, as a teen I binged on cheeses on toast after school-carbs carbs carbs!
    But I am in my late 30′s and have to start eating like ‘a grown up’. So true!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Em

    I can so relate! My weight has fluctuated so much over the last ten years. I’m talking me gaining losing gaining losing, over and over around 15kgs. Can’t be great for my body. I use food as a reward, when I’m tired, angry, stressed and depressed. I’ve been a size 12-18, had one child and pregnant at the moment.

    Not that I’m one to give advice about getting my weight in control (biggest yoyo dieter out!) but I’ve been able to lose weight and get healthier when I’ve had something to work towards. Not groundbreaking but friends weddings where I’ve been in the bridal party is a huge incentive for me to shape up. Funnily enough, both times I have fallen pregnant after losing 13-15kgs, amazing how losing that extra weight can kick start things for me and some people. Also talking to someone about triggers has helped. But when you’ve got something to work towards, it really keeps me going!

    Thanks for the story Bec, I think you’re wonderful! You don’t realise how many people struggle with these things.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  25. Shannon

    I’m the opposite. I’m naturally very thin and I have to work really hard to maintain my weight as I lose it so easily. But when I am stressed, sad, angry, anxious, I starve. Not intentionally, I just lose all appetite. I will walk around the kitchen at looking at all the stuff I have, not want any and think, “Okay, I’ll come back in 10 mins. I’ll want something then” and I just can’t bring myself to eat, even when I make something simple like toast.

    What’s worse is that when I can’t eat, I feel guilty because all I think about is how I could lose weight and that stresses me out even more. One skipped meal and I convince myself that I look like I’ve lost a couple of kilos. So then that stresses me out and upsets me, which, again, makes me physically not want to eat.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Jo

      And what’s the bet that you get lots of people commenting about how lucky you are.

      This is just as much a problem as over eating, which so many people don’t recognize. If this is a really significant problem for you, I would recommend finding a psychologist that you feel comfortable with to help in managing the anxiety/stress first, because if this is causing the weight loss then addressing this is the best option :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        great reply Jo.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  26. Kasey

    Its articles like these that cause me to love Mamamia!

    I comfort ate from age 16-21. The guilt of overeating is the worst thing… You throw away all of your discipline and eat even more to punish yourself!

    I broke the cycle unintentionally when I got chronic tonsillitis and was hospitalised. I couldn’t eat much, obviously. When I returned to health, I made a conscious decision to break the habit. I did not diet but i only ate when I was hungry and stopped eating when i was full (which was easy at first because my stomach had shrunk from the illness). I decided that I would force myself to stop binging, no matter how guilty I felt. When i put this into practice, i found it was always better to stop partway through a binge, rather than let it slide into a coma! You do the stop things a couple of times and it gets easier the third and fourth times…

    The illness I wouldn’t wish on anyone but it gave me a good turning point opportunity. I totally broke the emotional connection with eating. And it has been easy ever since. I eat to fuel my body, but stop when i feel myself eating empty-mindedly. Bec you probably have more insight on how to break the habit without a major health crisis! But you are proof that it can be done.

    Loved this article & applaud your honesty.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • phoodietweets

      Good on you Kasey!

      You say the illness was a trigger to your recovery but don’t take ANY credit away from your incredible strength, courage and determination! Well done!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kasey

        Thanks phoodietweets! :) Good point!

        I should add (for any body who is wanting to break the cycle) that, like any addiction, the first step is becoming aware that there is a problem. Its important to realise that it is a mental addiction, not a personal failing. That’s why I think this article is so great for so many women (and men too!) because people realise that its a common affliction.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  27. elle

    Ohh Yes. Food is certainly my drug of choice. I use food to soothe, comfort, relieve boredom and try to ‘fill’ the emptiness. I am a bit better these days (at 23) but still really struggle with the balance. I am always trying to give up sugar and too many carbs not even for weight reasons but because I know it makes me feel so much better avoiding these foods. However as soon as it gets too much..straight to the cupboard/fridge/cafe! I eat out LOTS and use this as a coping mechanism..I try to eat quite healthily but obviously eating out all the time isn’t the best for health or budget!

    From childhood into my late teens I used to binge eat at night time to soothe anxiety and stress. This got really bad after finishing school when I would binge eat a ridiculous amount of food, just mindlessly eating carbs until I felt extremely sick and would sometimes throw up or take natural laxatives etc. It was scary and I felt so trapped to the addiction and out of control.

    These days I don’t really binge but sometimes overeat. I would love to be disciplined and have a much healthier relationship with food. It is a constant struggle to be ‘balanced’ and not ‘all or nothing’. Does anyone have any tips?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Em

      I’m with you on the all or nothing. I find it very hard to allow myself just one row of chocolate. When I’m trying to lose weight it’s easier for me to just abstain completely or eat really well for the majority of the week and just allow myself one or two cheat meals on the weekend.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • elle

        YEP! It has to be NO sugar/junk rather than a small amount/keeping it in balance because I have one bite and that’s it!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • little jojo

        But is abstaining completely from chocolate (or any other food) something you can maintain for the rest of your life? If not, then would you consider learning new types of eating behaviours that do allow you to eat just a square or just a row of chocolate (or the whole block on the odd occasion that you genuinely feel like it)? This might take longer and not result in instant weight loss but overtime you’ll be likely to develop manageable behaviours in relation to food and be able to sustain a healthy and happy body weight.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  28. Emma Grey

    Great article, Bec!

    Something I’ve found that may work to break this cycle (and is wonderfully relaxing anyway) are some hypnotherapy apps from a Scottish hypnotherapist called Andrew Johnson. He sounds like Sean Connery… DIVINE to listen to!

    At the very least, you’ll have a wonderful night’s sleep!

    https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/get-fit-with-andrew-johnson/id421090663?mt=8

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Anna sparkle

    I deal with my emotions with food too….always have. In 2009 we were up to year 2 of trying to conceive….I was frustrated, despairing, miserable…. I hated my job, found it so stressful on top of trying for a baby, and every month as the negative pregnancy tests piled up…so did the kgs . I was hitting large big mac meals on the way to work, potato chips and chocolate at work, then would sit at home late at night clearing my cupboards while on facebook reading yet another pregnancy announcement and feeling rubbish.

    of course, stress, excess weight etc can all hinder your attempts to fall pregnant so it was a vicious cycle. By the time I Finally fell pregnant I was 26kgs larger than I’d ever been in my life.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. roseability

    you are brave bec to share your story.

    i am 31 and have overeaten my whole life. i feel a desperate need to ‘fill’ myself with whatever i can get my hands on. it is disgusting but it seems completely out of my control, almost like another person is doing it. i make trips to the shop on the way home to work to buy packets of biscuits, chips etc. to stuff myself with before my partner got home. i have done this for as long as i can remember… sneak in drive-thru visits when i’m alone, stash things in secret places at home. i am so ashamed of it but i can’t seem to help myself.

    2 years ago i managed to lose 60kg with weight watchers, and as embarrassed and ashamed as i am to admit it, i have now put 45kg of that back on. just today i almost sped to the shops after my shift to buy some food i could prepare and eat before the boyfriend got home from work. my weight is out of control and my self esteem is non-existent.

    i know i need help and i need to address the issues as to why i do this. i just don’t know where to start.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Chellebelle

      I hear you roseability. I’ve put a lot of effort into hiding food in the past. I hated lying (both overtly and by omission) to my husband and the horrible feelings of guilt. But it’s the out of control feeling that frightened me the most. I had quite a lot of counseling and confronted my food cheating. My husband was shocked but supportive, and although there’s been a few set backs, for the most part I’ve come through it. Can I suggest a counsellor as a first step?

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Jo

      I would also recommend seeing a psychologist. It’s more than ‘losing weight’, it becomes a psychological addiction and we need help to break these cycles. Very few of us can do it by ourselves – so please, look into seeking help with a psychologist (preferably one with experience in dealing with addiction or eating issues).

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • ozlicious

      Roseability, you’re not alone…I’ve done this too for as long as I can remember. :(

      Ever since I was a kid, I have hidden and sneaked food. Ever since I’ve been with my partner, it’s been even worse. It’s like I’m having an affair with food. I’ve even bought drive-thru meals and disposed of the wrappers in a public bin…before going home to cook dinner! And – God – the number of entire biscuit packets I’ve chomped my way through while unpacking the groceries before my partner got home! And that’s only the tip of the iceberg. It’s out of control and it’s such a cycle.

      I actually have had my GP do up a mental health care plan so I can see a psychologist to try and overcome whatever it is that is making me do this…I just haven’t had the balls to make my first appt yet.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  31. florally

    Bless you little cotton socks Bec Sparrow. I find it so hard to believe that someone with your openness and honesty could ever sneak a cheeky little sweet morsel. In sharing your story you have stopped me in my tracks. I have an unnecessarily complex relationship with food. Most of the time I can sort of maintain an OK weight and attitude to food, but gosh it is a struggle.
    There have been times when I have caught myself slicing off a thin wedge of cake and mindlessly gobbling it as I do school lunches. I can’t tell you how I hate it when I find myself doing that at it is just such a pointless act that I get cross with myself for being so stupid. Then there are times when I am at an OK weight and I completely sabotage myself by letting up on the vigilance required to maintain weight. I am at least 10 – 15 kg heavier than i was in my fit and foxy 20’s and i despise it.
    Caitlin Moran’s insights in to food as compulsion are really interesting, but the greatest thing I get from this article is the fact that I am not alone.
    X Thank you for bringing me back in foucs as I wander along the never ending path to health and inner happiness one size 14 step at a time.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Suki

    But I want to drink red wine. And I love that Meredith Dairy goats cheese on a cracker. And a Pimms, with half lemonade and half dry ginger. Dark chocolate. Ice cream with milo on it. Banana bread with marscapone for breakfast. Mmmmm.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      Me too!

      And I still have all that stuff, just not all at once!!!!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. jackal

    I’m slowly taking control of my food consumption by planning everything, every meal and only having healthy snacks in the house. I’m that girl that will eat whole blocks of chocolate in a sitting, and go through three litres of ice cream over the course of a weekend. I just adore food, all food but especially the sweet stuff. I’m relatively slim and I exercise everyday but that’s not the point. It’s these bad habits that will lead me to an unhealthy middle age, which I’m consciously aware of and striving to change!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Kate

    So yesterday I was slightly hungover. I had a hash brown with brekky, two large McDonalds fries, Noodle Box at lunch, fried rice at dinner. Notice the trend? Carbs and salt galore. Knew it was bad. Told myself it was fine, I’ll get on track tomorrow.

    Except I want to eat the leftover fried rice. And I have three assignments due in the next three weeks and surely I need some sort of incentive to get them done? And you mean one serving of pistachios is not the whole bag?

    I so hear you Bec.

    Believe it or not I am one of those people who goes to the gym and likes to call myself healthy. But I’ll go through months at a time of eating what I want because hey, I’m not overweight, it doesn’t matter. Need to get out of that mindset and remember being healthy on the inside is just as important.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  35. Chellebelle

    This post and the comments have rung so true for me. I’m sitting here feeling numb and bewildered and overwhelmed and exhausted and guilty and scared after reading and thinking about it. It’s all me. I am not sure where to begin to make a change. I know I need to. I’m about 30kg overweight and want to be healthier and set a good example for my kids. But every day I ell myself I’m going to, and every day I stuff myself. Gah, so hard!

    I saw a podiatrist today and got a treatment plan for my plantar fasciitis – I’d love to be able to exercise again. I also just ordered the Geneen Roth book a few people mentioned. I’ll read David Gillespie again. I did really well quitting sugar at first but have really struggled with it lately. So I guess I do have a start point. wish me luck everyone – I’m gonna need it!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      Oh Chellebelle,

      Can you afford to see a nutrionist? Or can you set yourself a small goal at first?

      Can you cut out softdrink (if you drink it)? That alone will probably lead to weight loss and is also going to lead to better health for you.

      PS Don’t beat yourself up. I’ve quit sugar in the past and gone back too. But this time I’ve just made ‘adjustments’ — I haven’t gone hard core. So be kind to yourself. xxx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Meltie

        Its not about cutting things out and dieting – its an addiction.
        Its a mindset.

        Its about looking at the deeper issues that make us feel like there is a ‘hole’ that needs ‘filling’, just as a drinker, smoker, shopper, drug addict does.

        It is a psychological illness and food is such an easily obtained and socially acceptable ‘drug’.

        It takes a wholistic approach and you need to have things ‘right’ internally before you can make it happen. It can’t just be about losing weight because I know from personal experience, that the pain is still there even when I’m a size 10. (Im currently bursting out of 16)

        Food obsession is a huge aspect of it; whether you’re obsessing about eating healthily, exercising, counting calories or abstaining from certain foods/food groups. You’re still obsessing about food.

        When I say ‘you’ I mean ME.

        I am about 35kgs overweight and I am miserable.

        I have blamed every possible obstacle there is. I have truly tried EVERY diet there is.

        What I haven’t addressed is my inner pain.

        Because its too hard.

        I have just shared this with my husband. He wants to help and support me. My dear sweet amazing Mum recently wrote me a letter asking me to stop hurting myself.

        Right now, I can’t. I want to, but there is an invisible obstacle and I need to delve into what it is.

        I am sick and I want to get better. I just need to get to a place where I can.

        I feel for those of you who are suffering in this silent hell with me. x

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Chellebelle

          I wish you all the luck and joy there is Meltie
          Xx

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Chellebelle

        Thank you Bec for your lovely response. I cried when you said to be kind to myself. I haven’t had kind reactions from my mum about my weight over the years and I think that’s affected me more than I realised.

        I will try again re the sugar as it really helped last time. I’ve seen a nutritionist in the past and know all the stuff about portion control and what is good for me to eat etc. it’s just so hard getting started doing it though. I feel like I keep letting myself down – saying I’m going to do things differently and then not changing. Maybe the small goal should be to try and do one little thing differently each day.

        Thanks again for your kind words (there’s that word again – made me cry again thinking about it).

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • becsparrow

          Oh God, Chellebelle. Me too. Do you know how many times I’ve said “Tomorrow I’m going to …..”

          And I NEVER stick to it.

          But for some reason, something clicked in me about 6 weeks ago. And I’ve just changed my eating habits. Seriously, I’m not dieting. I hate diets. But I’m just creating better balance in my life with WHAT I eat. I cannot be 40 years old and not exercising and eating chocolates every day (or oven chips or numerous huge bowls of cereal with sugar).

          But please remember two things:

          1. You are not alone. Look at all the comments on this page. There are thousands of us!!

          2. You are not your weight. There is so much more to you than what is on the scales. You are fabulous just as you are.

          xxxxxxxx

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Chellebelle

            Heh heh, except with me it’s not tomorrow I’ll be better, it’s today, and then I still don’t listen to myself!

            I’m so glad for you Bec that something clicked for you. You go, girl!

            I love the idea that I’m not alone in this – I’ve always felt so isolated. Although I wouldn’t wish thison anyone else of course!

            And you’re right – I AM fabulous. I’m a fabulous friend and mother and wife and employee and sister. I just need to channel that fabulousness onto myself for a change.

            Thanks Bec, you’ve helped a lot
            xx

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • jo

          Chellebelle, have you thought of trying hypnotherapy? I have been in a similar situation for most of my life – emotional eating for stress, boredom, nervous, self-congrats when something good happens, overwork, etc. I felt I had no control, as my rational mind knew to stop but I couldn’t. And then I would end up feeling guilty and start again to punish myself.
          Hypnosis work for me, and in a slow way so didn’t drop 20 kgs in one short stint but am close to this amount and it’s taken 18 months.
          Worth a try, and maybe give it a few sessions. Good luck with this – you deserve success and happiness!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Chellebelle

            Thanks for taking the time to reply Jo. I have used hypnotherapy in the past and it was very useful. I’m actually a qualified hypnotherapist – such a bummer I can’t hypnotize myself, I’ve just never been able to do that! If I can work out how to fit some sessions in, I will.

            I have resonated strongly with a comment someone made on here about “eating like a grown up” – I’m going to think about that one and how I can apply it to me.

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
  36. Denise Greenaway

    Whether food has become the enemy or the best friend, our relationship with it often mirrors our relationship with ourselves and (m)others. I”m a psychologist working in ED’s and my experience tells me that anxiety is the common factor (some people don;t recognise anxiety-thinking it’s excitement etc) Work on the anxiety and the fear of food or the use of it to stuff down emotions will lessen. Good wishes…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Chellebelle

      Oh. Wow. I hadn’t considered the anxiety aspect. I am slowly coming to realize I spend a lot of my time being anxious. Thank you for this comment Denise, you’ve given me much to think about. Xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. Claire

    Yep totally get your post. In fact, I finished off a chocolate cookie whilst reading this all in an attempt to make me feel ‘better’ after a crappy day.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  38. At long last

    Hi Bec, thank you for this article. This was me. I have also read David Gillespies “Sweet Poison” and it really changed my life. I had always thought I was an emotional eater but it is amazing once you give up the sugar, you really truly don’t feel compelled to be eating all the time. I have lost over 20 kilos in 6 months and for the first time in my life feel in control. I could write a whole lot more but I know it would sound like I have a mental health problem, I’m a true believer now.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      YESSSS!

      That’s what finally clicked for me. Eating all that sugar early in the morning was setting myself up to crave it ALL DAY.

      So that was literally life changing when the penny dropped.

      I’m not obsessive with the sugar thing. But I’ve stopped having it in my tea, on my cereal .. and that in turn has helped me stop craving chocolate and biscuits all day.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • At long last

        For me I found going cold turkey was the easiest way to deal with going sugar free. I also don’t eat gluten so one day the planets aligned and I decided today was the day, and I stopped eating both sugar and gluten. At the end of day 1 I just felt a little bit lighter in spirit and I felt like I could breathe. The day after I managed to do it all again and in 3 month, 10 kilos had literally fallen off me and for the first time in my life dieting didn’t feel so hard. Now it’s 6 month later and I have lost 20 kilos which seems unbelievable even to me as I have spent a lifetime struggling with this and I did not do any exercise.
        However something interesting happened to me just a few days ago. Last Friday night (day 186 and I am feeling pretty smug) I decided to make Steak Diane for dinner. I thought this would be fine. However afterwards on Saturday I was feeling a bit scratchy and suddenly not so determined and i knew something was different. Sunday I wanted to eat all day. I was even planning a secret trip to the supermarket to buy Nutella. What was happening. Then I discovered that the worcestershire sauce I had used on Friday night was 49% sugar and this had been enough to really trigger something in me (I also had leftover sauce on Saturday). That’s why the everything in moderation philosophy doesn’t work for me. With sugar it’s like those pathways in my brain are so strong, from years of overindulging, that for me it’s just like a lock and a key that seem fit together perfectly. Sugar feels so good, I definitely get a boost in mood, that is until the shame and self loathing kick in.
        So now to be able to resist sugar feels like a miracle. As long as I don’t eat it I don’t want it. I really, really don’t want it. I’m sure there are people out there who haven’t overindulged and who eat moderate amounts of sugar and it doesn’t affect them. That’s not me.
        One of the many reason’s Davids book is so good is because despite the fact that I was eating sugar all day, every day, I didn’t really recognise sugar for the addictive substance that it is. I thought it was more likely to be a moral flaw on my behalf. If only I had more control, if only I could show some willpower. Well guess what, I now see sugar for the chemical addiction that it is and this has changed my world.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Sydgel

      I will have to get the book. Do you have to cut out fruits? What did you cut out?

      I’m a total emotional eater. It’s a nightmare for me. I will try cutting out sugar. I don’t take sugar in tea or coffee and I never drink softdrinks. But I am a chocoholic like your wouldn’t believe.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • sweettooth

      I am slightly over weight and definitely addicted to sugar. 29 days ago I decided to go sugar free for 30 days and I am amazed at the difference it has made to how I feel. It wasn’t easy but as the days went by it got easier. I can get through the day without feeling hungry. Its really worth giving it ago.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  39. picardie.girl

    Geneen Roth helped me with this. She was the first person I had ever heard of that acknowledges the huge emotional side to eating and deals with it. After the ‘food is fuel’ brigade (mostly personal trainers), it is so good to have this acknowledged so that people can confront their disordered eating. Food is more than fuel but it should not be a method of comforting ourselves when we are stressed/down/whatever else.

    We need to develop healthy coping mechanisms that do not involve food (or alcohol, or shopping) and until we do, we will not be able to change the behaviour that is holding us back. You can’t just stop an addiction, you need to replace a bad habit with a good one.

    I would recommend this post for people struggling with food addiction: http://zenhabits.net/foodaholic/.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  40. Ann

    There is a 12 Step program for anyone with food issues (over or under eating, and bulima) – Overeaters Anonymous (http://www.oaregion10.org/).

    OA has been around since 1960 and I can vouch for its effectiveness. It’s the only thing which has given me any freedom from the food. No fees or charges, no scales – give it a try.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  41. AT

    I really, really love the point you make about not wanting to pass on your eating behaviour to your children. I realise, now in my 30s, how much of my eating behaviour was subconsciously copied of my mother. Secret eating, hoarding – I did way too much of this in my 20s, till my boyfriend pointed it out. I grew up with my mother hiding food so it seemed almost normal behaviour.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  42. Lolly

    Totally relate Bec. My weight has gone up and down by about 8kg in the past 20 years. Every time I get to my ideal size, I seem to sabotage myself.

    I had my 3rd (and last) baby in March. The weight came off pretty easily in the first 2 months, and I was only about 4kg from my goal weight. Then when the baby was 2 months old, I had a massive falling out with my parents. With 3 little ones, it was the last thing I needed, and I turned to food as a comfort. This situation went on for weeks and weeks. And when the baby began sleeping through the night at 4 months, I was using food during the day, and alcohol at night (nothing too excessive, but 3 or 4 glasses of wine EVERY night does bad things for your waist line!).

    My jeans got tighter and tighter, and I was so angry with myself, but I was in a rut, and so busy with 3 kids under 4, I just wasn’t making my health a priority.

    One night my husband came home from a boozy long lunch, and as we were talking, he said that he wasn’t finding me attractive anymore, and it might be time to think about getting back to my pre-pregnancy weight. OUCH!!!! I was sad/angry at first. Geez buddy, I’ve had 3 babies in 4 years, my body is never going to be the same again.

    But then I got over that a bit, and knew deep down that he was right. I needed that big jolt of reality to shake me into gear. So 4 weeks ago I started Lite N Easy, as it was recommended by a friend. OMG!!!! This is the best thing I have ever done. (This is not a shameless plug, I have no affiliation with the company), but it’s just so good. I’m eating real, delicious food, portion controlled, and delivered to my door. I am so busy, but each day a beautiful brekkie and lunch and snacks takes only a few minutes in the microwave. For dinners, my husband agreed to eat Lite N Easy as well, so there is no cooking for me, and the taste is great. Even he thinks so, and he is fussy.

    My emotional eating and drinking is under control. I’ve actually decided to go off alcohol for October, then allow myself a few glasses on a Fri and Sat night as xmas approaches. My jeans are looser, I have cheekbones again, and I feel great. I’m really proud of myself so far, and can see this being a long term solution for me. In December, we will probably not use the dinner options, and go back to making our own. But I will definitely be keeping the breakfast, lunch and snack order, as it is the perfect solution for a SAHM of 3 littlies.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      Cheekbones! Yay!

      I totally hear you. And it’s hard to exercise when you have three little kids.

      Sounds like you’ve come up with a solution that really works for you. And I think if you can find something that works for your whole family (eg your husband is doing it too) – that’s the key. Otherwise you’re preparing separate meals etc etc Everyone needs to be on the same page.

      xxxxx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  43. Twisted Sister

    Geneen Roth has written a fantastic book that might help everyone. it is called “Breaking Free from Emotional Eating”. :)

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • picardie.girl

      I began that book, and the first few pages were such a revelation, they changed my life. I haven’t read the rest – I’d like to, but the first part was enough to get me started. I’ve since lent it to my mum, who also has trouble with overeating.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Chellebelle

      Ive just ordered it. Wish me luck!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. tanlee

    What isn’t widely recognised is that you can also overeat due to body chemistry. There’s a whole lot of nutritional science coming out of the states now that shows some foods can throw the body’s hormones out of whack so that you don’t recognise when you’re full. Some people are more sensitive to this than others. Just thought peeps might like to know. Google away if you’re interested.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  45. Tripitaka

    This is more in response to some of the below comments than the article..

    Are carbs really that bad? I grew up learning that bread and pasta are great for energy and they help you grow. They used to be the largest section of the food pyramid! Robyn Barker lists them as the number 1 food group that kids need (from memory). Wholegrain bread is full of vitamins and fibre as well, right? Is eating a sandwich, a bowl of weetbix, oats or pasta really something to feel guilty about? I sort of thought the whole carbs thing was a bit of a diet fad, rather than something to take too seriously. (I can understand that white flour = not great, but wholegrain carbs?) And for weight loss, shouldn’t you just think in terms of calories/kilojoules, regardless of weather or not they come from carbs? Would love it if someone could explain this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • becsparrow

      I’m not sure!

      I think it’s just all about moderation. And also, maybe if you’re not doing much exercise (like me) — you need to just not over-do it on the carbs like bread and pasta????

      I agree it’s confusing!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Twisted Sister

      All I can tell you is that whenever I have needed to lose weight I have logged calories and stuck to 1200 calories per day and it has ALWAYS worked even with NO exercise!

      So in my experience it has made NO difference where the calories have come from: fat, protein, carbs etc, as long as I stuck to the overall calorie intake it has dropped off me :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

        Hi twisted sister,

        Recent studies have shown that very low calorie diets with no exercise are doomed to fail. The body adapts to lower energy intake by reducing energy requirements through lowering your metabolism. the only way to combat this is through exercise, which tricks your body into thinking you need more energy, thereby unceasing your basal metabolic rate. You may have had some success this way, but since you have had to do it more than once it appears this success is temporary.

        Calorie counting is a good thing to do in many respects- weight watchers points system is the simplest, but I always advocate that clients just start reading labels in order to understand the caloric and nutritional value of food.

        And Tripitaka, no carbs are not bad. They are just not equal. To understand nutrition, you need to know that there are only three types of energy- protein, fat, or carbohydrates. Protein is very rarely used as an energy source unless you are literally starving to death, so you need both fats and carbohydrates in your diet. Try reading Joanna Macmillan prices book about the GI revolution- she is a world leader in nutritional research and it is very easy to read. She is a wannabe dinner party guest for me!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • little jojo

          I completely agree with your comments re low calorie diets. They are very difficult to sustain in the long term and the majority of people will re-gain the weight, plus more. Not to mention the effects this has on their self-esteem when losing and gaining weight, trying to count calories and not experiencing freedom from thoughts about food.

          It seems that many people can ‘diet’ but few engage in ‘normal, healthy eating’ with a mindful approach that is focussed on satisfying each individuals nutrient, energy and psychological (pleasure) needs…

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
          • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

            little jojo, this is absolutely the topic I am most passionate about. I have had so many clients that have become obese BECAUSE of these terrible diets. Although its great for trainers and nutritionists, (a very prominent trainer I once spoke to used to say that fad diets and McDonalds paid for his Ferrari – he now has an extremely sucessful fitness business), they actually really upset me because I know these people are doomed to fail, will almost certainly be far worse off than when they started, and will suffer the health risks from it. Drives me crazy!!

            GD Star Rating
            loading...
        • Twisted Sister

          Also, yes I have had to do this more than once. I have had two children :) Pregnancy tends to, you know, increase your body weight!

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
      • Twisted Sister

        I didn’t actually say that I don’t exercise! I have two children which has meant at time my usuasl one hours exercise and weights work out has gone by the wayside and I have STILL lost weight. That was my point.

        AND for all the armchair critics out there, 1200 calories per day for my very petite height and frame are more than adequate! It is NOT low calorie at all! I usually find that I am eating more than I would if I wasn’t logging my intake.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • little jojo

      Hi Tripitaka,

      No, carbs aren’t bad at all. They are your body’s primary source of fuel, they have the lowest kJ/gram of the macronutrients, they help your brain produce ‘happy’ hormones, wholegrain carbs are packed with fibre and vitamins. They are great for you.

      And yes, reducing carbs is unfortunately the latest diet fad. The diet industry used to promote low fat, because that didn’t work (no surprises there because diets don’t work), they now need to promote something different to continue making money from people. And guess what, when this no carb diet fails people will again blame themselves and assume it’s because they have no will power when they give in and eat carbs, rather than realising that the body needs carbs to function at it’s optimum level and if you choose to eliminate them sooner or later the body will start screaming and often ends up with you bingeing on carbs.

      Like you said, eating in moderation and choosing wholegrain over refined carbs is better for good health – which is what has been suggested by the Australian Guide to Healthy Eating for many years. Unfortunately, very few people eat this way, instead they eat what diet companies suggest (which is designed to make money, not to provide optimal health).

      Does that help clarify? I’m writing in a rush so I hope I’ve made sense :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Tripitaka

        Thanks little jojo, it makes very good sense. :)

        I am glad to hear it too. I don’t know how I would cope without eating bread, rice, cereal, potatoes, etc. I would have to completely change the food that our family eats, and I think it would be very difficult to cut them out, and like you say, I would absolutely crave them.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • elle

        I disagree. It is not a ‘fad’ at all. You can get adequate carbs from vegetables & fruits. It is not necessary to eat grains and for many people it causes heaps of issues to eat a high grain diet. For many years our ancestors ate fat and protein as their main energy sources as well as some carbs from vegies and berries etc. New research is emerging about the dangers that eating loads of grains can have and the health benefits of switching to a diet based mainly on meat, vegies, fats and some fruits.
        It isn’t true that eating a diet without grains means that your body will start screaming and you’ll end up binging. Quite the opposite! If you eat enough fat and protein to satisfy then you’ll find you are more in control and cravings for carbs will disappear. Your body will be getting all the energy and nutrients it needs without the grains/carbs which can often be very addictive and easily eaten in large amounts.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Eternal Caterpillar

      No carbs aren’t that bad. Everything Mum to 2 cheeky monkeys has said below is right. Yes, weight loss is just kj in v. kj out (which is as complex as it is simple).
      But, protein will keep you fuller for longer. A steak with exactly the same kj as say wholegrain bread (yes, that would be a lot of slices of bread) will keep you feeling fuller for longer.
      That is why some people try to avoid carbs.
      For most people, overeating isn’t about how many kj go in or out. It’s so many complicated things, from “Better not throw that out, I’ll eat it instead” right through to not wanting to refuse a friend’s proffered goodies and absolutely the eating from sheer habit/boredom/frustration etc I could go on and on…

      Great article (again) thanks Bec – and that passage of Moran’s was one of the highlights for me from her book.

      And I wholly admire you for being brave enough to admit to something so few women will. You done good, girl ;-)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • M

        Hiya, I definitely agree some things keep you fuller for longer but wouldn’t recommend anyone choose a steak or any meat for that matter over bread/carbs etc if their main aim was weightloss. This video is worth a look. Draws on peer reviewed research too :)
        http://nutritionfacts.org/video/meat-and-weight-gain-in-the-panacea-study/

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Eternal Caterpillar

          Hi M,
          Thanks for the link. I wasn’t familiar with the EPIC-PANACEA study and have just spent some time googling and seeing what I could learn.
          The finding that a decrease in (even lean) meat consumption, especially poultry, may improve weight management, goes against much of the research published by the CSIRO and other scientific bodies, so it’s certainly interesting food for thought/research.
          Thank you! :-)

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • AT

      It’s all about balance. Mentally divide your dinner plate into three: a third should be carbs (best wholegrain carbs), a third protein, a third vegetables.
      Of course having a higher proportion of the plate vegetables is never a bad thing.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Miss Finance

      Carbs may not be the enemy but I find when I cut out most carbs (not all) and limit sugar (another carb) I lose weight very easily without really trying.

      By ‘most carbs’ I mean I don’t eat pasta, rice, bread or potatoes and choose to get my carbs from other vegetables, fruit and the odd grain (such as quinoa or porridge).

      I do find I eat a bit more meat, fish and dairy as a result but find it is very filling so my portions are naturally smaller. I also find that I rarely crave sugar or other snacks when I eat this way. With me (not necessarily for everyone), carbs (bread and pasta in particular) trigger further carb cravings, I find it difficult to eat only small amounts of pasta or bread and so over-indulge or else crave sugar or more carbs shortly afterwards. I find it’s actually far easier to not demolish the free bread at a restaurant or the entire plate of chips that comes with a steak if I don’t even have a single bite to begin with. So, as much as I love it, it’s all or nothing for me.

      As a result I almost never eat pasta or bread anymore. I rarely eat rice and potato and instead eat loads of lean meat, fish (heaps of tuna), vegetables and salad. It’s not as hard as it sounds… a curry or stir fry without rice is yummy, pasta sauces beefed up with extra meat, tuna or vegies is actually delicious without the pasta, breadless burgers are great, salads with turkey, tuna or chicken are nicer than a sandwich.

      As a result I’m almost never hungry, hardly ever feel the urge to snack and am the same weight at 30 that I was at 17.

      So… whilst you do need some carbs in your diet in order to function, I personally believe that cutting the majority of them out is a good way to maintain weight and healthy eating.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • sweettooth

        I totally agree

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Twisted Sister

        Amen to that!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Kate

      Carbs are great if you’re an athlete or very, very active in your day to day life. My grandparents for instance ate a lot of bread, but they had a farm and were on their feet 16 hours a day. They needed that energy and burnt those calories easily. These days most of us are far less active (that includes people who exercise for 30min-1hr a day) so we don’t need all the carbs. What we do need we can get from vegies, a piece of fruit, yoghurt and so on.

      Bread, pasta etc. isn’t evil, but it’s not something I’d recommend eating everyday, and certainly not with every meal as a lot of people do. Having a carb focused meal a few times a week is more than enough.

      A lot of the information surrounding carbs and wholegrains comes from studies from the 40′s, 50′s and 60′s that were paid for by companies like Kelloggs. This idea that wholegrains are the golden ticket is false. Our bodies aren’t designed to consume many grains as relatively speaking they are a new addition to our diets.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Mum of two cheeky monkeys

        “Carbs are great if you’re an athlete or very, very active in your day to day life.”

        That’s not entirely accurate. Weight loss is about calories in and out. Not to mention, vegetable and fruit are carbohydrate and nobody should be limiting them, let alone cutting them out. It doesn’t really matter whether you are active or not, (if you are an athlete it would strictly speaking depend on the type of exercise you are doing as to which type of carbohydrates or fats would be best to implement in your diet depending on the energy systems you are using at different working intensities). But in reality, any excess calories, regardless of what type they are, are stored as fat. Similarly dietary carbohydrates aren’t the same as stored carbohydrates. The body can convert fat to carbs and vice versa depending on what it needs.

        So in short, carbohydrates are absolutely essential for absolutely everyone that wants a fully functioning body, particularly your brain. Don’t cut them out no matter what level of activity your daily routine includes. Sugar, starch and general carbohydrates are all different, and not all carbs are equal.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Anonymous

          Um, nowhere did I suggest cutting carbs out and I actually made the same point as you, that carbs are in vegies, yoghurt etc.

          The latest studies are actually showing it’s not as simple as calories in calories out. It certainly isn’t that simple for me. I used to eat about 1100 calories a day. Low calories\ intake but lots of carbs, sugar etc. I wasn’t overweight but I had a bit of a gut that I just couldn’t shift. Now I eat about 1600 calories a day, lot’s of protein, vegies, very little sugar and only rarely eat things like bread and pasta. I’ve lost around 7kg and I actually exercise less now.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
    • elle

      I find the issue is mostly with grains. Bread, pasta, rice, cereal etc I find very addictive and it is easy to eat large quantities. Although the dominant idea in nutrition (and in the food pyramid) for many years has been a high wholegrain diet there are recent studies to show this may not be the ideal diet. Many of us eat cereal for breakfast, sandwich for lunch, pasta for dinner type diets which are extremely high in carbs especially grains.

      Many people (including myself) find eating this way unsatisfying and craving more carbs & sugar. I also feel bloated and uncomfortable from all the grains.

      I have been following a ‘Paleo’ type approach to eating which advocates fat and protein being the main energy sources. A diet that is mostly meat, vegies and healthy fats. I find eating this way I am much more satisfied and don’t feel hungry every 2 hours or crave sugary things as much. Sarah Wilson writes about eating this way on her blog http://www.sarahwilson.com.au/. My father has been eating this way for a few years after being diagnosed with Diabetes and it has completely revolutionised his life. His doctor says he is his healthiest Diabetic patient by far.

      On the other hand my grandmother who eats very healthily according to the food pyramid is obese and has been that way for many years. Of course it works for some people eating this way but I find the high grains diet is quite detrimental for many of us.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Teacup

        I agree elle. I think part of the trouble these days is that the typical diet is a very high carb diet which is now associated with metabolic disease.

        The low carb “fad” isn’t really a fad, so much as a wakeup call bringing to light just how high in carbs the standard diet is these days. So many people can’t tolerate grains very well either and feel bloated and unwell. IMO the food pyramid has way too much emphasis on grains and carbs.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  46. Lizi

    My problem is that I have two addictions: eating and reading. And they compound each other becuse doing either on its own is anywhere near as satisfying as doing both at the same time. When I have a book in hand, it’s ‘hmm, where’s the chocolate?’ And if I’m eating dinner alone, it’s ‘where’s that book, or newspaper…’ etc.

    Does anyone else out there have this multi tasking approach to comfort eating?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • distracted

      Oh yes, I used to adore eating peanut butter toast in bed with a book! It’s like I can’t concentrate on the book unless I’m doing something mindless with my body at the same time.

      Now I get most of my “reading” from audiobooks, and I walk while I’m listening to them. It wasn’t a conscious change, but it works well now that it’s happened!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Sarah W

      Yes but mine is crap tele and crap food…I cant help it. I watch the biggest loser with maltesers. Its compulsive and shameful but I have connected the two in my head for so long that I cant separate them. Caitlin is right, it is a carers compulsion because I find myself doing this at about 730 every night. The time when I finally get ‘me’ back

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • amyspeak

      I often eat and read, but I’ve got into the habit of making sure I enjoy both separately so that I don’t over do it. Even just taking the first bite before opening the book/newspaper/magazine is usually enough to help me appreciate both. I think the key is to stay mindful, so that you are aware of when you’ve eaten enough and when it’s time to do something else :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • lurline

      I do have the need to read whenever I eat, fortunately I don’t feel the need to eat whenever I read. That hasn’t stopped professionals telling me I shouldn’t read when I eat though in case it occurs. I think if it was going to happen, it would have happened sometime in the last 45 years.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anonymous

      Not just when I’m alone, in our family we read at the dinner table even if there is company. A few days ago I made my 4 year old daughter a sandwich and sat her at the table to eat it. She said to me “where’s the newspaper” and then went and found that days paper and very seriously laid it out on the table in front of her plate and then sat and ate her sandwich. She can’t even read yet, she just thought it was the done thing to have the newspaper laid out in front of you when you eat!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  47. MissV

    I’m an emotional/boredom eater. And it’s gotten worse since I quit the gym a couple of months back.

    I actually wrote about this a couple of weeks ago- http://xxxmissvxxx.wordpress.com/2012/10/04/comfort-and-boredom-eating-how-to-get-it-under-control/

    It’s interesting when you take note of how much I boredom/comfort eat. Kind of disgusting too!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  48. Jo Abi

    I was eating Red Vines when I came across this. Reading it felt like a huge hug Bec. So many of us struggle with over-eating and I do every day. I love the sound of the plan you are on too. It sounds so sensible. Having a daughter makes me more determined to eat better. Drinking water before meals is such a good tip. Keep us posted.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Jacki

    I can relate 100% to what you’re saying in this piece. And I love that except from Caitlin Moran (in fact, I love the whole book). Thanks for sharing.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  50. Chloe

    Bec, thank you for writing this. I have been a secret eater f

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Chloe

      Bec, thank you for writing this. I have been a secret eater for most of my adult life and the particular brand of shame and self-loathing that it invokes is difficult to describe to most people. I have spent a significant amount of time silently berating myself for being so greedy but actually, I think it goes deeper than that. Thanks for making me realize that I really need to address this problem head on and for giving me the courage to do so xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • becsparrow

        Wow, Chloe. I couldn’t have read a better comment today. Thank you. xxx

        GD Star Rating
        loading...

So, we have $1000 to give away... oh, would you be interested? Well step right this way.

To go in the draw to win, just LIKE us on Facebook, enter your email address and tell us in 25 words or less why you love reading Mamamia.

Close this popup



Full Terms & Conditions