This post was originally published on Role/Reboot Role/Reboot and has been republished with full permission.
by TINA TRASTER
Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt make it look easy. They adopt kids from all corners of the world and the media broadcasts images of perfect Kodak moments. They’d have you believing families bond and blend instantaneously.
They don’t. Not always. Not in my experience, or in the experience of many others. Sometimes the road to loving your adopted daughter is long and twisted and scary. You know something is wrong—but is it her? Is it you? You drown in shame and confusion, hiding your feelings from the world. It can’t possibly be that you’ve gone to the other end of the world to get this baby and you’re not bonded after a month, six months, two years.
I knew something wasn’t right early on. We adopted Julia from a Siberian orphanage in February 2003. She didn’t clutch to me or gaze in my eye. She never rested her head on my shoulder or relaxed into a warm embrace. She didn’t respond if I sang or read to her. It was like she was there, but wasn’t.
For a while, weeks, maybe months, I sank deeper and deeper into depression, thinking I’d made a terrible mistake. Maybe I wasn’t cut out to be a mother?
Julia was a little more responsive with my husband, but only somewhat. For the first 10 months, I suffered guilt, shame, and sadness. After traveling 10,000 miles, twice, to bring home this child, I was unwilling to let anyone know how I really felt. Then the revelations began.
I hired a day-time nanny in early 2004. Anna was 21, experienced and energetic. She’d come with a glowing review from the mother of her last charges. When she mentioned Julia was having trouble warming up to her, a ding went off in my head. Why? Why isn’t Julia connecting to this lovely young lady who took her daily to the park, to playdates, to “mommy-and-me” classes. I thought for sure that Anna might be able to give her what I couldn’t.
A year later, I enrolled Julia in pre-school, and saw more of the same: A child who was not bonding with teachers or other children. She was as much an enigma to others as she was to us. Everyone agreed she was gregarious, vivacious, friendly, and outgoing. Yet at the same time, she was aloof, hard to figure out. When I picked her up at the end of the day, she was always by herself, sometimes sitting under a desk. Worried, I mentioned her odd behavior to her pediatrician.
That was the first time I’d heard of Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD). The doctor, who worked with foreign adoptees, explained RAD was common among institutionalized children. The early break from birth mothers causes trauma that makes it difficult for the child to trust or attach to another adult. This, he explained, is why Julia recoils when she is held. Why she doesn’t have a favorite teddy. Why she won’t make eye contact.
I wasn’t ready to hear this. I told myself we just need more time. I stored the doctor’s explanation in the back of my mind but pieces of it drifted out now when I watched Julia fight naps or wander away from me constantly. Finally, when she was 4, I was ready to face her demons, our demons. It was during a nursery school recital that I broke down and sobbed because I realized how lonely and displaced and isolated my daughter was. Julia was unable to sing along with the group. Her disruptive behavior forced a teacher to take her off the stage and leave the room. This may not sound like the most unusual event for a young child—but put in context, I understood right then and there, I needed to intervene.
My husband and I banded together to read everything we could on the syndrome. We made a dogged effort and a conscious commitment to help our daughter and make ourselves into a family. It was our daily work. We learned that parenting a child who has trouble bonding requires counter-intuitive parenting instincts—some that disturbed and surprised family and friends. People could not understand that we’d respond to Julia’s fussing with a passive poker face rather than indulge her. We’d laugh during her tantrums until she abandoned them, and moved on as though they’d never happened. They didn’t understand that Julia wasn’t willing to give hugs and we didn’t ask her to do so.
With the help of research and case studies, we had a tool box. Some advice was invaluable, some failed. Some techniques worked for a while. We were living inside a laboratory. I knew how lucky I was to have a partner like Ricky because so many marriages and homes are ravaged by the challenge of adopting difficult children.
Over time, there was more engagement with Julia. It wasn’t necessarily loving and warm at first but it was moving in the right direction. We were drawing her out. She became more capable of showing anger rather than indifference. As her verbal skills developed, we had the advantage of being able to explain to her that we loved her and would never leave her. That we understood how scary it was for her to be loved by an adult and that she was safe.
Progress took time—and the work of staying bonded with a wounded child is a life-long endeavor. That’s OK though because Julia has stepped out of the danger zone. She’s taken off her helmet and armor. She has let me become her mother. And I honor that trust by remembering, each and every day, how she struggles with subconscious demons and how mighty her battle is and always will be.
This post was originally published on Role/Reboot here, and has been republished with full permission.
Tina Traster is a New York Post columnist, a Huffington Post blogger and an essayist. She is writing a memoir about her adopted Russian daughter that is due out next year. You can visit her website here.








Comments
33 Comments so far
How ungrateful you are to your adopted mother who raised you and you treat her with such disrespect but give your mother who abandoned you and did not raise you all the love. So disrespectful. What a shame she was not able to adopt a child who would have loved being a part of a family who wanted them.
loading...
Lovely article, Tina is doing a great job and fights a very worthy fight for her family. Julia is so lucky to have such a hard working mum.
loading...
To me, what this comes down to is parenting. There are examples below of people saying they have RAD and someone in the exact same sitituation saying they dont…
I struggle to believe that babies can remember that they were abandoned.
Sounds more like Tina’s daughter has autism.
loading...
What a brave and wonderful family. We adopted a little boy this year and have been so lucky. There have been no issues with bonding. The process we went through prepared us and we were expecting it. But I am not sure how my heart would have coped if we had to face the issues that you had to face Tina. I wish your family so much joy and happiness.
loading...
i wish my adopted parents had one half of the understanding of what it is to raise an adopted child,like the mother in the article.a lotof adopting parents have no clue.
loading...
I was adopted 50 yrs ago and I still suffer with Rad i cannot stand my Amother to touch me never have.. As an adult i know that I have to cuddle and kiss her to say goodbye for example but it makes me gag and want to vomit. I dread it , but on the other hand i dont really mind hugging a friend or kissing them goodbye.. I guess it affects us in different ways i guess as a baby she tried to cuddle me etc but I would scream … .I can honestly say even though I had to live there till I could leave at 16 I never bonded or loved her in anyway.. I just wanted my real mother and finally when i was 30 I got to meet her.. No vomiting or gagging at her cuddles.. First time i felt safe and home in my life…
loading...
I feel sorry for your adopted mother! She just wanted a child to love & nurture.
loading...
This was a very insightful article. Thank goodness this little girl had this set of parents to grow her trust.
loading...
If you can get past the cheesy title, ‘My Family, A Symphony’ is a really interesting memoir, which gives the biological child’s perspective when his parents adopt several kids with special needs.
Really glad this was published here. I think it’s so important that different stories are told (not just the Jolie-Pitt version!) and that our children, however they come into our lives, will always have their own unique suite of challenges. None of these stories scare me off the idea of fostering/adopting/having a biological child (well, not any more than articles about autism/Downs Syndrome/any other conditions that my future bio child could have), but will hopefully make me better prepared.
loading...
You know, as an adopted person myself I am a bit sceptical about all this. It has never bothered me – or my family – one jot that I am not flesh-and-blood related. We are as family as family can be, and no big old deal is ever made about it. I suspect any impact the process has (unless the child is seriously abused prior to adoption, of course) is perhaps to amplify certain of the child’s innate characteristics.
To any prospective adoptive parents out there I say ignore the haters, go forth and do it. My life is all the better for having been adopted. My parents’ lives are all the better for having had the opportunity to build a family. So there might be problems – but there can be problems with anything in life, that’s just the way it is. But there probably WON’T be any problems – how would you feel if you never gave it a shot?
loading...
“To any prospective adoptive parents out there I say ignore the haters, go forth and do it. My life is all the better for having been adopted.”
Really Nicole? And you know this how? You have no test case whatsoever (i.e. a you who was not adopted standing next to you to compare with). You may very well be happy and good for you though as an adoptee who understands the process I can’t help but suspect you are just the classic compliant adoptee doing everything they think is expected of them so as not to be abandoned again. Even if not it does not give you the right to make blanket statements about the effect of separation of the child from it’s mother at birth when you clearly have no comprehension of the trauma this creates. I met my Bio family over two years ago and I can assure you the ptsd issues that i have had over my life are in no way genetic characteristics. People need to understand that when a child is adopted the worst possible thing that could have happened to it already has.
loading...
“People need to understand that when a child is adopted the worst possible thing that could have happened to it already has.”
I’m sorry but quite frankly that last line is the biggest load of bollocks I have ever read. I do not for one moment want to take away from the personal trauma you believe you feel at the situation, but to paint every situation like that is ridiculous.
I can assure you I am not a “classic compliant adoptee” doing everything I can “not to be abandoned again”. What a load of rubbish. Blood is not what makes family – it’s love and actions that make family. And my parents drive me up the wall sometimes, just like everyone else’s. And I drive them nuts, too. We disagree on many issues. I am an independent woman who is perfectly capable of living life on her own, not some clingy kid wishing the world was made of rainbows and butterflies.
The attitude your final line expresses it precisely the one which does the most damage. Why on earth would I have been better off with a mother who couldn’t have cared for me? She probably would have resented me for ruining her life, and accordingly she would not have been able to bond – not the other way around.
It goes without saying that a child who is wanted will be better off than a child who is not.
loading...
I have seen my mother and her (blood-related) siblings fall out over a will and yet, I can say with all conviction that my sister and I – despite both being adopted and not blood-related – would and will never ever fight over more than who has to wash the dishes.
Blood doesn’t make a family, and in my experience, it doesn’t hold any value at all. My sister and my parents are my world and I’m so happy that I am adopted not only because I have such a loving family but because I have been given so many opportunities that I wouldn’t have been able to have had I stayed with my birth parents or grown up in foster care. For one, my birth parents were quite young, poor and not married. I would have grown up with relatives who would have scorned me and resented my birth, and I would have been a huge financial burden to people who would not have been able to give me the life I have now. I know for a fact my life is better.
I went to a great school, a great uni and now I have a great job. And I wouldn’t have been able to do any of that without my parents sacrificing everything and working hard to give their children the best out of life. That is what it means to be a parent.
I am not being compliant as you say, boxon. I am not waiting to be ‘abandoned’ again – in fact, I was never abandoned. My birth parents made the difficult decision to give me up so I could have a life and a loving family that they couldn’t give me. And I am forever thankful that they made that decision.
loading...
To you, ‘a’, I say this: Precisely! This mirrors my experience exactly.
loading...
And mine!! I know from reading there are many adoptees who haven’t had happy experiences, but my “adoptive” parents are my parents, just as much as anyone elses, they have been my family since I was 2 weeks old. I feel extremely lucky that I have the family that I do, happy to be chalked up as one of the adoption success stories.
loading...
Well at least you realise that money is the most important thing in every adoption
loading...
It doesn’t affect all adopted children, just those who have been institutionalised from a very young age usually.
loading...
Wow – people are ‘haters’ because they’ve raised awareness about possible risks to vulnerable children?
I’m glad your experience has been wonderful. Not every child is as lucky as you have been – let’s do what we can to make sure these kids get all the care they need, eh?
loading...
what a great article.
My friend has had to take on the children of her husband’s drug addicted sister, and the struggles are ongoing…. a honeymoon period then a hard, hard slog of the little ones learning to trust that this woman really does love them, won’t abandon them, and will be their mumfigure forever.
So much heartache.
loading...
Thank you Tina for sharing your story.
As a baby I was adopted into a family that already had 3 biological sons. My mother wanted a princess and began to resent me from a very early age for not fulfilling that role. I was labeled difficult and ungrateful and did not bond with any of my adoptive family.
Because my adoptive family made no effort to understand the signs, our relationships continued to deteriorate. I’m now in my 40’s and my adoptive family refuses to have any contact with me and I still struggle with relationships.
It’s my opinion that adoptive children being placed into families with existing biological children simply does not work.
If only the knowledge and resources were available in the 60’s & 70’s things might be very different for many of us ‘lost souls’.
loading...
Janelle, I’m sorry you had this experience with your adopted family. I too was adopted in the 70′s into a family with biological children. I never felt ‘different’ from them and even though I now know my biological mother, my adoptive parents are and will always be my parents and have always been loving and supportive and treated my brothers and I equally. I guess I lucked out when the authorities placed me.
loading...
I’m so sad to hear that your childhood was so unhappy and I also wish your family had been better prepared. As someone who intends to foster (ideally to adopt permanently, if possible) in future, I don’t think that people with biological children already shouldn’t adopt, though.
In fact, I think adoption should be less restricted, not more. I know of families where it has worked well, and I think that it’s a matter of managing expectations from the outset. A parent with no existing kids could be equally likely to have unrealistic hopes for their adopted child, and the pressure could be just as intense. A willingness to access ongoing professional counselling and support (plus an open mind) is what prospective adoptive parents need, I think.
loading...
As an adoptive parent my heart goes out to Tina. As part of our compulsory educational seminars we attended during our application/assessment stage we were fully briefed on possible attachment disorders and, most importantly, we were told where to go for help if we felt that applied to us when/if we had a child allocated to us.
I can’t say enough about the thoroughness of our assessment process. The Australian adoption process has many, many pitfalls, but lack of education and full disclosure isn’t one of them.
And, Tina, you’re an awesome parent.
loading...
Now that is a loving mother, biological or not!
loading...
I was recently diagnosed with this as an adult (I’m 38). I was adopted back in the 70′s but spent the first few months of my life parentless, alone in a hospital, with only nurses looking after me, which is believed to be the cause of it.
I spent my entire childhood avoiding attachments with people including my adoptive parents. My adoptive mother actually said I was the “perfect” toddler, because I never cried and I never had a tantrum! I think that is weird…what toddler doesn’t have tantrums?
I spent my school years hiding in the bushes that surrounded the school grounds observing the other kids and could never form friendships. I also became a self-harmer.
The thing is, I turned out alright in the end! I have struggled with relationships, but have had counselling which has helped and have now been in a wonderful stable relationship for 7 years and I’m now trying to have my own child.
I feel for my adoptive parents who never got the support they needed to bring up adopted children, but I’m glad this is now a condition that is being recognised and dealt with.
loading...
Wow Misforme. What a massive thing to have overcome. I’m in awe at what you’ve managed to achieve xx
loading...
Thanks Tan!
I’d also like to say, I love my parents enormously and I’m so glad they picked me! I think we taught each other a lot about life!
loading...
Misforme, Snap! Our circumstances are identical. Watch for post natal anxiety/depression. Bringing your own child into the world can bring up soooo much about your own experience of abandonment.
loading...
Hey tmac…yes will certainly watch for post natal…I think I’ll be alright though! I’m learning to reach out.
loading...
My son, who is now 16 months old, has been diagnosed with an avoidant attachment disorder. This stems from my severe PND which necessitated a protracted stay in a Mother Baby Unit and the effects of my illness on my ability to bond with my baby.
I kept telling people that there was something wrong with ‘us’ – my baby and I – and people just kept telling me I was an overly anxious Mum with PND. But he didn’t look at me, he actively avoided my touch, he would arch away from me if I tried to hold him. I knew none of these things were right and so I kept at it and a referral was made to a relationship therapist specialising in attachment disorders.
Our hard work began.
I took the whole family on the road to the nearest capital city (Adelaide 4.5hrs drive one way). We stayed there for a while and participated in intensive therapy. Exhausting.
Improvements have been made but it’s a slow process. We are lucky in that my baby bonded normally with his Dad and older sister – it was just me he didn’t trust or want to form an attachment to. It was like a double blow, the PND and then the knowledge that MY illness had affected my baby in such an adverse way.
Phew, that hurts to revisit. Help is out there but sometimes you need to advocate for yourself to get it.
loading...
wow- what a brave lady you are. Hats off to you and the super-human efforts. Thats love. He’s a lucky boy to have you as a mother.
loading...
I’m so immensely moved by your courage and love for him. Thanks for sharing your story. xx
loading...
What an amazing story and outcome. The journey Tina & her partner are on is inspiring. I love that she echo’s one of my sentiments, that you can never give up on a child!
made my day.
Thanks for sharing
loading...