By JAMILA RIZVI
Yep, you clicked on that headline. We knew that you would…
Because this headline and the controversial article it accompanied (which you can read in full here) was one of last year’s most clicked on articles from US site, The Huffington Post.
That’s right, an article, which tells women why they’re not good enough has been shared a whopping 100,000+ times on via social media and email.
What’s unclear is whether the sharing was done by single women themselves or those who think single women should read it.
The basic argument made by writer Tracey McMillan is this: “if whatever you’re doing right now was going to get you married, you’d already have a ring on it.” She then proceeds to list the reasons why a woman might not be married (and why they’re all HER FAULT).
The reasons include:
You’re a Bitch. Here’s what I mean by bitch. I mean you’re angry. You probably don’t think you’re angry. You think you’re super smart, or if you’ve been to a lot of therapy, that you’re setting boundaries. But the truth is you’re pissed. At your mom. At the military-industrial complex. At Sarah Palin. And it’s scaring men off.
You’re Shallow. When it comes to choosing a husband, only one thing really, truly matters: character. So it stands to reason that a man’s character should be at the top of the list of things you are looking for, right? But if you’re not married, I already know it isn’t.
You’re a Slut. Hooking up with some guy in a hot tub on a rooftop is fine for the ladies of Jersey Shore — but they’re not trying to get married. You are. Which means, unfortunately, that if you’re having sex outside committed relationships, you will have to stop.
You’re Selfish. If you’re not married, chances are you think a lot about you. You think about your thighs, your outfits, your naso-labial folds. You think about your career, or if you don’t have one, you think about doing yoga teacher training.
That’s just a taste. Other reasons include “You’re a liar” and “You’re not good enough”.
Now, I could rant all day about why I think this post is absurd and that the way that it sets up marriage as the paramount goal of every woman’s life is insulting to our intelligence.
But I’m not going to.
Because I actually think there might be something to learn from McMillan’s article.
Why is it that in 2012, when women have access to the WHOLE internet, did this particular article shoot to the top of the ‘most read’ and ‘most shared’ posts? Why did hundreds of thousands of women choose to read this list of reasons why they weren’t married? And why were tens of thousands of them enamored enough by its points to publicly share it with their friends on social media.
I was one of them. I clicked. I read. Something in my brain went ‘this will be relevant to me’. Why?
Well, the reason is kind of obvious: I want to get married.
I don’t want to get married IMMEDIATELY. (My relatively-new boyfriend’s hyperventilating should be slowing a little now. Just breathe babe, it’s going to be fine). But I would like it to happen one day. With the right person. When we’re both ready.
Do I NEED to get married? Of course not.
My parents raised me – and so far the world has continued to teach me - that I really can have whatever I want from life. I have a great job, I live with friends not a partner, I don’t need a bloke to do anything for me other than reach things from the top shelf (and actually I have some excellent and very sturdy chairs for that) BUT…. At some point, I would still like wear a white dress, tell someone I love them and then spend a lifetime together.
And for some reason that has become something I am not supposed to say aloud. And it’s something most of my contemporaries wouldn’t own up to either. If we do so, it is with a real trepidation that other women will think we’ve betrayed the sisterhood or implied that women should live in some mad pursuit of a getting someone – ANYONE – put put a ring on it.
If we state our desire to get married one day, we are terrified that men will run for the nearest Playstation and lock themselves in a room with it forever more, because they think we’re cloying, obsessive and Muriel-esque..
We recently ran a post on Mamamia from a woman who lives with her partner of many years and they have a baby together. She and her partner have a great relationship but she wants to get married and he doesn’t. And the fact that they aren’t married is eating her up.
She asked for Mamamia reader’s advice. Boy, did she get it.
I even received an email explaining the injustice Mamamia had done to the author of the post, to feminism, to the sisterhood and to the WORLD in allowing these ‘backward attitudes that promote marriage as the only thing women should aspire to’ to be published.
Well of course that’s just silly. I also think women should aspire to turn real life into a musical, where ordinary conversation is replaced by boisterous song and rousing chorus. Seriously. I do. It would be fun.
I digress. My point is this: Why does aspiring to marriage have to be a bad thing?
For me, marriage is about finding someone you love so much that you want to spend the rest of your life with them and that by some great fortune and meeting of the moons and all that hoo-ha, they want to do the same thing. Oh and it also means a really big party and a new dress to kick it off. Um, why wouldn’t you aspire to it? Along with a bunch of other things, OBVIOUSLY.
The crux of what causes so much concern though, is the fact that what I’ve just described isn’t about marriage, it’s about love. The marriage bit is simply how our society has traditionally chosen to formalise that love.
Of course I aspire to love. Don’t we all? Love is lovely.
And while McMillan’s headlines are unnecessarily inflammatory, some (emphasis on the some) of her points may be valid. For some people.
We’ve all had moments in our lives, where on reflection, we realise our actions have been selfish, or our first impressions shallow, or we’ve taken our anger out on someone who didn’t deserve it.
I know I certainly have.
In fact I know I’ve had far more than moments, I’ve had full blown chunks of my life dedicated to those realisations. And reflecting on those times, recognising the scale of mistakes made and endeavouring to do better have been important.
Am I still bitchy, shallow and selfish on occasion? Of course. Regularly in fact. But far less so than I was three years ago when I still believed I was the centre of my own world and everyone else’s too.
McMillan’s article, beneath the shock tactics it employs, is really about self reflection and prompting a more deliberate effort to be more chivalrous and giving to people around you.
And in a world that could use a little more kindness, there is some real merit in that.










Comments
139 Comments so far
I love you Jamila. And I appreciate that you are speaking your mind.
But I think the reason it is so hard to own up to is because (on the off-chance) that you do not find that special someone to ‘put a ring on it’ then at least you can turn around and say “marriage is stupid. it’s not for me. I don’t need to officialise my love etc”.
I know a lot of my own friends who are always going on about marriage, kids, future kids names etc are the type who have this life plan and are frankly fine with settling for a life that will be comfortable and go according to plan. This isn’t a bad thing as such, but I know that for me it has never been enough. I want to have adventures and be crazy and not take the road more travelled by. I think this is another reason a lot of people aren’t vocal about marriage. They don’t want to be cast in this traditionalist role, but make it seem like a ‘woops, it happened to me as well’ moment when and if they do.
I think if you’re comfortable with your own decisions, whether that be about wanting to be married or not wanting to or not trying to but having it happen anyway then its fine!
The problem I often find with calling yourself a feminist is that it does feel like a betrayal of the sisterhood to admit that you do want the house, the kids, the husband, the fairytale life where you do want someone else to share a life with and depend on.
I know those girls I mentioned before definitely do not call themselves feminists. Maybe that’s why I have always had such a problem associating myself with them and saying I WANT TO BE MARRIED?
I’m not really sure. I hope all your dreams come true Jamila! xx
loading...
You’re very kind Sasha. You too. xx
loading...
That was EXACTLY what I was thinking. Excellent comment!
loading...
That was EXACTLY what I was thinking. Excellent comment!
loading...
Some of the points are valid though.
For a true partnership to work you need to think about more than yourself. Life should stop being JUST about you and it will start being about you AND your partner. And what is best for you as a couple/family.
A little more compassion, empathy and compromise in this world can’t be a bad thing.
loading...
Jamilla, this piece has really gotten my back up. I don’t think a response in a comment is going to be enough!
As a relatively newly single lady, there is nothing like these articles to make me feel angry that there is such societal pressure and focus to ‘find a man’, roll my eyes at something so ludicrous, and at the same time, to make me feel like I have failed immensely because I couldn’t get Ex Mr W to put a ring on it.
loading...
I can understand that after going through a breakup, articles like this are hard to read.
But I understand her point. I’m in my late 20′s. I went to a selective school where we were told to aim high. I went to uni and then went back to do Masters. I’ve always worked and I’m doing well in my career.
And until last year, I couldnt vocalise the words that I wanted to get married and have a family because I felt I was somehow being anti feminist. Like I’d been given so many opportunities and to say I wanted to have children was somehow taking all that for granted.
Its taken til now for my to have the confidence to say yes, I like working and I value my career, but I want marriage and children as well.
loading...
I want to get married and have children too, Sarah. However, I don’t appreciate it when there are a multitude of articles telling women “this is what you’re doing wrong and why you’re not married” – like it should be our goal in life to be married.
Our goals in life should be to be happy and that’s it. If that involves marriage and children, that is great, but better to be alone and happy than in a marriage with someone who is not quite right for you just for the sake of being married.
loading...
I agree with all of that.
I just didnt think the article added to the societal pressure to ‘find a man’.
All good.
loading...
haha – that even sounds funny “find a man.”
Like an Easter Egg hunt.
I bet you $10 I can walk away from my desk right now and ‘find’ one in the lifts at work.
Eureka!
If only it was that simple, eh? Often my older long-term-partnered female friends look at me in puzzlement, and suggest men are everywhere, just pick one! Crazy logic – they’re not generic terracotta pots at Bunnings and just any old one will do, ya know?!
loading...
Yeah, I bloody get that all the time! People telling me that I just need to ‘get out there’ and find a guy. Where is this magical ‘there’ place where all the men between 30 and 40 who are nice, have a job, promise they won’t ever hit me and don’t repulse me physically inhabit? I’m not looking for a millionaire rock star boyfriend (though wouldn’t knock one back), I’m just looking for a nice guy who has a bit of smarts and looks at least mildly decent. But all of those ones seem to be already taken. I have no shortage of guys who are more than happy to sleep with me and then unfriend me on Facebook a few weeks later, but getting a guy to stick around is a lot bloody harder.
*Rant over*
Maybe
loading...
Reporting back on the man hunt.
So yep, I just got out of my work lift after purchasing a takeaway coffee. And guess what? I absolutely did find a man, and a tall one at that (bonus!). You all owe me $10.
He was at the older end of middle aged and married, though. Strike one.
loading...
LOL!
loading...
I’m the same, Sarah. I’ve done awfully well for myself in terms of my schooling and career. My parents have always encouraged me to work hard so that I could set myself up for a comfortable life.
But… since I can remember… I’ve always wanted to get married and have a family. I’m not in a rush to do so, but it’s been a constant ambition throughout my life.
I can vocalise my other ambitions very easily – I can say “I want to write a novel and get it published!” as many times as I want, and everyone is supportive. But as you said, I can’t quite vocalise the fact that I want marriage and children. Because that’s betraying the sisterhood… right?
loading...
Nnnnnnoooo Nat! It’s not betraying the sisterhood to want to be married and have children!
Of course not, that would be silly. It’s when articles are written about women and why they’re not married that sends the message that a woman’s sole goal in life should be to be married.
I just think people should aspire to be happy and awesome – and just like you say “Oh wow I’d really love to live and work in America one day” you can say “oh yes I’d like to be married with children one day”. It’s something that you would love to do, but it’s not your sole purpose in life!
loading...
So true. I would love to get married, but it really isn’t my sole purpose for existing. I love your above line: “Our goals in life should be to be happy and that’s it.” I very much agree with that
loading...
There are loads and loads of successful women who combine motherhood with amazing careers. Surely there are enough awesome role models around for you to realise that wanting kids is not betraying the sisterhood? I mean, your boss for one right?
(as well as Jane caro, Caitlin Moran, etc. etc.)
loading...
Hi Whippersnapper,
I read all of your comments, I love what you have to say and I really enjoy seeing your take on things. I really hope that what I am about to say to you comes across the right way because I have nothing but love, empathy and respect for you and I hope that you take it in the manner that it is meant.
I was with someone for 7 years, he did put the big diamond ring “on it”. We built a house, got a puppy together, planned the wedding, discussed when we were going to have children. And then he left me 2 months before the wedding… and it was devastating. And I let it define me for a really long time.
In the 4 years between when he left me and when I started a new relationship (which was only about 5 weeks ago) I watched my parents celebrate their 30th wedding anniversary, watched both my sisters get married, watched both my sisters have children. Watched my two closests friends get married and try to start families. Watch my aunt and a dear friend get married for the second time each, well into their 50′s.
As happy as I was for them, watching them have these life events, and reading articles like this one, and gossip mags, and tv shows, and pretty much everything made me feel incomplete without a man. And made me feel like a failure because I was so close to “having it all” and I let it slip away. And it made me angry, made me cry. Made me so depressed that I did not want to live anymore.
But slowly, with time I let it go. It hurt, and I needed help. It was hard and emotional. And it took time. But I processed the grief. I accepted that it didn’t turn out how I wanted it to. I threw out all the reminders of the life we had together. I lost his phone number, I unfriended him from facebook.
I watched the people around me and realised that I would rather be happy alone, than lonely in a loveless marriage.
It wasn’t until all of this happened that I was truly happy again. Any relationships I have now are simply the cherry on top.
I wish you nothing but happiness, I hope you are able to process and accept what has happened and are able to be happy alone, and in a relationship, if that is what you want.
But don’t rush it. Do it in your own time.
loading...
I know exactly what you mean Buggles. The point I was trying to make, is that articles like this tend to throw up a myriad of emotions in women. I don’t like how it can simultaneously make me feel angry with the implication we should “aspire” to get married and make me feel like I’ve some how failed (when intelligently, I know this is not the case).
loading...
I think articles/attitudes like this also over look the situation where you had a very wonderful long term relationship that didn’t work out, or where you’ve had people who’ve wanted to marry you but you didn’t want to.
loading...
Or Option 3 – long term relationship where you thought you were happy, but in hindsight you were actually pretty miserable!
loading...
Haha oh man, have I been there!! Very true WS.
loading...
Oh Buggles, I’m so sorry you went through all of that, how awful. I love what you said though and completely agree – that moment of realising that you are truly happy by yourself, and that any relationships will just be the cherry of top, is such an awesome feeling. And funnily enough, I find that’s always the moment that good relationships come into your life!
loading...
Thanks Bea.
loading...
So true! I met my husband after two days of having this realisation!
loading...
Buggles, just out of curiosity (and feel free to tell me it’s none of my business), whatever did happen to your former fiance?
I’m always interested to know what happens to each person when they respectively end a relationship.
loading...
I went and worked in a job that I ultimately had always wanted to do but didn’t because he didn’t want me away so often. Then came back to Perth, have paid off debt and bought my own house.
He went travelling, then moved to Melbourne. He’s had a few shorter relationships, a year or so. And the girl he is with now that he has been with for just less than a year is 3 mths pregnant with his baby.
That would have destroyed me 18 months ago but now I can say I am genuinely happy for him.
We has about a 2.5 year period where we were always chasing one another. Starting the day we were due to get married and he called me to say he had made a mistake and wanted me back. I told him to bugger off because he had broken my heart.
Then months later I wanted him and he didn’t want me.
Then vice versa.
It wasn’t until we both let it all go and really moved on that we grew as separate people and have gone on to have happy and successful lives.
loading...
I’m so happy for you that you have found happiness!
loading...
WS, I was also in a very serious, long term relationship, where we both (or so he said) planned to get married. After 6 years we broke up, and shortly after he got together we some floozy (fine, fine – she’s probably not a floozy), and 3 years after our break up they got married. Whilst originally the thought of that would have been a stab in the guts, I now realise that she has qualities he needs…which are qualities I wouldn’t want to have (aka she’s his ego stroking doormat). I realise that I wouldn’t have been what he needed, and it ultimately wouldn’t have worked anyway.
Meanwhile, I ‘rebounded’ with the most handsome man I’ve ever met in my life. Cut to three years later and we are blissfully happy still – and I’ve realised that he’s not a rebound at all, but actually the perfect man for me, who I happened to meet straight after the Big Break Up.
My beautiful man has so many qualities my ex didn’t have, which I had never experienced before, so didn’t realise I needed. Now couldn’t live without them. He is selfless, gentle, courageous, perceptive, considerate, always puts me first, blows my MIND every day (often more than once
) with his amazing sex skills – the list goes on. Those qualities are more important (to me, for me) than the *amazing* qualities my ex had – and I realise that he wasn’t what I needed either.
I agree it’s interesting to hear how relationships turn out, and what happens to each person after the break up. I think break ups can only ever make you ‘more’ who you’re supposed to be. They can be extremely affirming in realising that you’re a strong, awesome person who can survive and rise above anything!
loading...
I wouldn’t be surprised if this is what happens to Ex Mr W. He had all the indicators of wanting to settle down – wants to be in Brisbane, wants to buy a house, but said we weren’t yet ready to get married. Well, bud, you probably are, you just didn’t want to marry me.
I’m doing exactly what I tend to do when a relationship ends (Though none have been a patch on how serious I was about Mr W) – I am doing total “Fabulous single lady, I do not want or need a man at all right now” – I DEFINITELY do NOT want to be in a relationship any time soon. I just want time on my own to get to know myself again and just be happy on my own. Besides, I’ve got a big adventure coming up that you can really only do solo
loading...
“The marriage bit is simply how our society has traditionally chosen to formalise that love.”
Actually it’s how society formalises a legal contract.
This is my problem with marriage today. Traditionally marriage has zilch to do with love, and for the majority of the worlds population, that’s still the case. Before feminism, and the realisation that weddings were a money maker, love didn’t factor into why people got married, and if a married couple happened to love each other, well that was just a happy coincidence.
For so many men and women, marriage is a nightmare forced upon them by society. It bothers me that we’ve decided to change the definition of marriage to suit lucky westerners who like the idea of a dress, a ring and party, when the institution still causes so much pain worldwide. From the gay and lesbian people forced into a straight marriage to the young boys and girls who have their life partners picked out for them before they can even spell the word marriage, marriage holds back so many people. It’s a massive part of the reason why women are still seen as a commodity and/or a burden in many cultures.
loading...
And this is why I chose to reject the idea of marriage. Thank you for such a well constructed comment.
loading...
Sorry but i agree with the Huff Post article to a certain degree. I know a couple of women who are exactly as described and men run a mile and then they are bitter and wonder why??!!!
Of course it doesn’t apply to all cases but… let’s stop sugar coating the message. It we are vile, shallow, selfish people (whether male or female) then yes it may difficult to find something to sign up for a life sentence of marriage… Simple.
loading...
but there are so many horrible, vile people out there who are married…
loading...
Of course I aspire to love, but why do I need a marriage certificate to prove it?
I have no problem with people who want or choose to get married. Weddings are fun, I love being a guest at them!
But it doesn’t feel like it applies to me. There are many traditions that don’t fit in with my life (religion, my father being asked before me, being ‘given away’).
Just live your life how it suits you! And don’t judge others for doing so.
loading...
Perhaps the article overall is a little too sweeping and it certainly doesn’t apply to everyone. There are any number of reasons why you might not have met someone you click with and that they click with you in return.
But I daresay there is some truth in some of her observations, and they probably apply to the best of us. We are told that we can have it all, that we can do whatever we want, etc. But does that raise our own expectations? Do we (by ‘we’ I mean ‘society in general’) expect only the best, and feel we are entitled to that? Does that make us more wrapped up in what we want for ourselves? Has convenience and perceived ‘failure’ given us more things to be angry about? When everyone is told they can do anything and be anyone at any time, why are we surprised when they don’t want to settle down?
I don’t know the answers and I don’t know if this is better, worse or just different than it once was. But it’s food for thought.
loading...
I read the article in full and actually think that beneath the tongue in cheek, sarcastic ‘reasons’ for why a woman might find herself unmarried, McMillan has some really valid points. I actually kind of think that she has been quite clever to use some really horrifically, over-generalised, nonsense reasons to draw people into reading her article that is ultimately about valuing yourself.
I particularly love this line:
“Here is what you need to know: You are enough right this minute.”
I think that is something all women should have as their mantra every single day of their lives.
From my experiences personally and those of my friends, I completely believe that we still live in a society that gives women the message they are somehow inferior if they aren’t married. We still tell little girls from a very young age that ‘happily ever after’ involves some form of meeting your prince and having a ring popped on your finger.
I think McMillan’s statements are incredibly valid and true.
“You’re just going to need to get rid of the idea that marriage will make you happy. It won’t. Once the initial high wears off, you’ll just be you, except with twice as much laundry.”
Such an important reminder that we need to value ourselves and look within to be truly happy.
loading...