Do You Like This Story?

Hindsight is a wonderful thing when it comes to a relationship break up.  How else can you see that the heart ache you are going through was actually a gift and not a punishment?  Relationship expert (and by expert we mean she’s had several relationships and written a book on the subject so she CLEARLY knows a thing or two about a thing or two) Zoe Foster writes….

Along with Paddle Pops, Frisbee playing and Aeroguard, summer brings with her the deafening roar of relationships collapsing and the quiet, sad whisper of hearts breaking. For some reason when the temperature nudges 27 degrees, a lot of people (the majority of them men) issue a kind of emotional stock take, and make a Big Brutal Decision about where their relationship is.  This can lead to proposals, (there are probably just as many proposals as there are breakups) but a lot of the time it ends in, uh, an end.

200702 omag heart 220x3121 When a break up is the best thing that could happen to you. By Zoe Foster.

.

The exact reason, despite several extensive studies by make believe scientists, remains unknown. Perhaps it’s because humans naturally reflect at the end of the year, and finally take time to really examine things, as opposed to just cruising along on autopilot. Maybe it’s because we like starting a new year feeling like we are On The Right Track, and if a relationship is no longer serving us, we have a firm template (the end of the calendar year) in place that makes us feel we have permission to instigate change. Maybe it’s because people wear less clothes in summer and we realise that if we’re being brutally honest, there is a part of us we can no longer ignore that would like to fool around with those people wearing less clothes. Of course, as with anything pertaining to the heart, the reasons are as unique as the people experiencing them.

But I’m less concerned with the instigators and their motivations, and more with those who have been at the receiving end of this… end, and who are currently nursing wounded hearts and punctured egos. You have my sympathy because break ups suck, flat out suck, but you do not have my pity.

There is a risk I am hurling this advice at you prematurely (and entirely unsolicited), because you’re still dealing with the enormity of your boyfriend choosing to be not with you instead of with you, but ultimately, I wish for you to understand you have been given a gift. Because no matter what happens right in this moment, no matter how spectacularly low you’re feeling as you read this, fighting fears and fighting tears, sometime in the future you will have a better man, or a better version of the man you had before.

I call it the Better Man, Better Dan theory.

While there is a terrific chance your ex-boyfriend’s name is not Dan, it rhymes and we all know things stick better in your head when they rhyme, and trust me, this is definitely something you want to stick in your head.

The Better Man, Better Dan theory takes into consideration the Big Picture, which is the picture we often forget when we’re drowning in upset and rage and devastation post break up, but one which I strongly urge you to keep in mind. Top of mind, even. The crux of the philosophy is that one day you will be with either a better man than the one who just ended things with you, or a better version of the man who ended things with you.

The Better Man part is simple: there are many exceptional men out there and eventually, when you’re willing to let one of them in, one of these men will fall so in love with you that your head will rotate in a delirious, dizzying fashion.

The Better Dan part is less simple. When your ex-boyfriend chose to break up with you, there was a part of him that needed to be free for whatever reason. You must grant him this freedom. It must be unfettered and it must be pure: do not intrude on it. No good comes from trying to lure a person who has made a conscious decision to live their life without you in it back into your life. It’s soul destroying and it’s absolutely futile. Instead, focus on yourself – for while it may very much feel like it, a breakup is not about the person who broke up with you, it’s about you, and how effectively you turn a nasty emotional knock into something powerful and positive.

But back to Better Dan. Better Dan is the guy who has had time to grow and get clarity as a single man, and who then realises he wants to share that new man with you. As Richard Bach so wisely said, “If you love someone, set them free. If they come back they’re yours; if they don’t they never were.” Better Dan is the man who you loved enough to set free, and he came back.

That said, I must point out it’s not helpful to wander through the murky swamp of a breakup hoping your ex will be knocking on your door in his Better Dan get-up in a few months time. He might be gone for good. Be at peace with this; it simply means you’re in store for a Better Man instead.

The exquisiteness of the Better Man, Better Dan theory is that it is a genuinely win-win situation: either way you get a great guy. Keep this knowledge in your metaphysical back pocket like a magical little talisman, and enjoy singledom with your head held high. There is tremendous peace and emotional power living wholly in the present knowing the future will take care of itself.

There is also tremendous peace in choosing the right flavour Paddle Pop for a friend who says ‘surprise me’ when you set off to the corner store to buy ice creams, but that’s probably less relevant.

*About the Author: Zoe is an author and columnist, a relationship and beauty expert. She has her own beauty blog here and is currently the beauty columnist for The Sunday Telegraph, and the dating columnist for Cosmopolitan magazine.  She  has published three books; Air KissesTextbook Romance (which she wrote with her then-friend-now-boyfriend Hamish Blake) and Playing The Field. You can follow her tumblr here and keep up with her on Twitter here.

What’s the best thing that has come out of one of your relationship break-ups?

View more posts on:

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine this is a dinner party. Differences of opinion are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers or other commenters. So if you're rude, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment - so save your breath). And if you’re offensive, you’ll be banned. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That's how we're going to be - cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation...

Use your profile to comment:
Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

97 Comments so far

  1. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    J

    Yep, I subscribe to this belief BUT the trouble is finding that Better Man. And I’m really not quite sure right now what I’d do if Better Dan showed up again.

  2. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Jac

    I was the one that needed a break and became the better dan – thankfully my lvoe took me back after 4 months apart and we’ve never been better, i really ebleive that sometimes in a relationship a break is neccessary to sort your own shit out, sometimes you just can’t do that when you’re attached to someone else

  3. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Justine

    I know this is an old post. But what about just being on your own? Why do you need the reassurance that there’s a great man out there for you? Maybe you can just be happy on your own without one.

  4. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    BuyTrafRu
  5. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Sezzard

    I married my better man and I’m so glad I held out for him! I look back on the other couple of failed long term relationships and think to myself – thank goodness I didnt settle for you at the time! I would be bloody miserable with all of them if we were still together! Instead, My hubby is the best man I have ever come across (we met when I was heartbroken and cynical too) and he has never let me down. :-)

  6. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    auscrawl

    I don’t know what to do with my new man at the moment, he was supposed to be perfect for so many reasons, now I don’t know if he is just snowed under with hassles right now, or just bored with me,

    I have my own money worries, kids and job search hassles myself, so not so easy to be be ms chipper and breezy all the time, but that’s reality.

  7. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anonymous

    Thanks Zoe my boyfriend of 5 and a half years just left me because he wants ‘freedom’ and this article makes me feel so much more hopeful for the future

  8. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Kate!

    This post seems to be saying that getting dumped is ok because it makes room for a better bloke to come along in future. That notion of women being incomplete until a handsome prince comes along to rescue them died out generations ago didnt it?

    I hope that women of today have healthier self-esteem than seems to be assumed in this post, and realise its entirely possible to be happy and complete without having a husband/boyfriend.

  9. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    mimi

    the best thing that happened to me was my bf dumped me and at the time it was heartbreaking bt if he hadnt of done this..i wouldnt of met the man of dreams and the man whom il be marrying on 23 September 2011..

    i believe everything happens for a reason and that it is truely up to fate :O)

  10. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Belle

    I think this article saved my life. Thank you

  11. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    rupoo

    what happens if there is no better man or better dan? and you die alone being eaten by alsatians?

  12. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    AnonyMOUSE

    Oh my gosh, this HAS been written for me right?

    I’ve just broken up with my husband of four months after a whirlwind love affair. We’ve only been together 18 months.

    We broke up last Monday.

    The last eight days have been sheer, unadulterated, living hell. I think I’ve eaten two pieces of Vegemite toast and some rice, plus a million coffees and two million ciggies.

    I haven’t been sleeping properly either.

    I couldn’t handle it anymore and I caved yesterday and rang him, and all I wanted to do was pledge my eternal love and promise him that I’l do anything, electric shock therapy, whatever, if only I could have him back.

    Instead, he answered the phone coolly, so I responded in kind. We talked neutrally about what we’d been doing and I said very lightly that I was feeling absolutely miserable and had had a terrible week. We told each otehr we loved each other and got off the phone.

    I felt worse after I got off the phone.

    We have a problem that I can’t be bothered outlining right now but it means that our marriage is over with no hope of resolution, and fuck me, it’s so fucking hard.

    Breaking up with someone is like having a boulder chained to your heart.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Mum of Two

      Oh Sweety, I wish I could give you a big hug right now.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Louisec

      You poor thing, how horrendous. I hope you have family and friends. Relationships Australia are amazing and reasonably priced too. They would be able to help you a lot.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anonymous

      awww, you post made me feel for you. i really hope you are okay, whether you sort things out with your husband or not. Be strong. !!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      treater

      Dearest Anonymouse, things will get better. I broke up with my long term partner (couple of months short of 20 years) 4 weeks ago. Its still hard, and there will be hard times in the future, but I am getting there – it really truelly does get easier. Ride that rollercoaster, let it wash over you, and you will be fine

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Devastated

      I feel your pain anonyMOUSE. My husband of just short of one year has left me. I am devastated. I’m trying really hard to not contact him and to be cool about it but all I want to do is throw myself at him to get him back. Seriously not cool. Luckily I haven’t done that yet and I know that at this point walking away is the only thing i can do. But it just HURTS. SO. MUCH!

  13. GD Star Rating
    loading...

    I had the “better man” when I was in my late 20′s but the timing was off for me as I had just came out of a failed marriage and had a young child to raise. I felt it wouldn’t be right to rush into another union so quickly with this fantastic guy who wanted to get married and have kids of his own. I told him when we parted “I will regret this one day” but felt at the time it was the only thing to do. My self-esteem was really low after my marriage breakup and I had two abusive relationships during the following ten years. I always dreamed of the “better man” I had given up and regretted not marrying him. I then decided to stay on my own until two years ago when I had the good fortune of having contact with him again after all that time. His marriage had failed (his wife was a heavy drinker and abusive and had no interest in staying in the marriage) and he had two children. He was at the same point I was at when we first met. Now we are together again – he has a lot of angst with his ex but we are forging ahead with our relationship so happy to have been given a second chance. He showers me with compliments and is a truly lovely, kind man.

  14. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anonymous

    How is this? I got the Greyhound bus to Sydney (overnight) to move in with my boyfriend. He picked me up from the depot and dumped me. Hmmmm… Two years later, I applied for a job and got a crap referral from a woman that I hated on sight, and she of me when we worked in the same industry. So, I moved back home, met a fabulous man and am living happily ever after! I see her occasionally at my local shop and I am desperate to say ‘thank you’ to her, but I can’t quite bring myself to do so.

  15. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    ???

    I swear I’ve read this exact Zoe Foster article somewhere else. Was it published in a magazine before Mamamia? Does that need to be acknowledged? Not criticising, just wondering.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Martha

      Criticise away, I say! I totes agree…

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Kitty

      I’ve seen it before too, but on Mamamia – it was published in February. Don’t know why it featured again?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anonymous

      It’s Zoe’s Cosmo column

  16. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    girly

    My ex left me a month ago.. and I have met my Better Man. I met this wonderful man at my brothers 30th, he used to be my brothers roommate. He makes my head spin with all the lovely things he says to me, I am not used to it. I missed so much the romance, the kisses, generally being told how much he misses me.

    My ex would kiss, but if I tried snuggling during a particularly cute scene in a show or movie he would get uncomfortable and say “Get off me, geez do you have to do that every time something like that happens on TV?!” He also used sex as a ‘reward’, like if I was doing the dishes or his washing he would come up behind me and act all coy and want sex. After, he would grab his xbox remote and that was it.

  17. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Roger

    Lots of good things came out of a break up of a long term relationship. I lost 41 kg. This got me so interested in exercise that I left the mining industry & went to uni where I did an exercise science degree. I performed better than I could ever expected & won two awards, including the award for graduating with the highest course average. This lead to an offer to participate in the postgrad program where I did a research Master’s, again in exercise science. In the final semester of this degree I was invited to a ceremony, along with lots of others, & presented with a certificate acknowledging me as one of the top 100 students out of approximately 21 000 at the university. While doing my Master’s I was offered part time employment assisting with a different research project investigating the effects of exercise on a neurological disease which currently has no cure. As a result of this project I’m now doing a PhD in this area. I’m fitter, healthier & happy at 41 than I was at 20. I now do Ironman triathlons for “fun”, something I never thought I would be able to achieve. Her leaving me really hurt at the time but was the best thing that has ever happened to me. I do find it kind of funny that after she left I turned into the man she wanted me to be. I still have her mobile number & I’m often tempted to call her to let her know what I have achieved as she told me I would never be successful at anything. I’ve resisted so far but one day maybe…

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      OssieLeo

      Don’t wait Roger, call her. It’s the only way to know what is in the future.. Either she has been waiting for your call or not. This will free you.

      Good luck X

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Roger

        Hi Ossie. The reason I haven’t called her is I really want to gloat over how well I’ve done. When she & I were together she was doing a nursing degree & while she was an outstanding student she was never quite at the top of the class like I managed to achieve. I kind of think that it would be a bit petty/vindictive to rub her face in it but it would feel good to show her that her predictions about me were very incorrect. I wish her no ill will & certainly don’t want her back.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          sam,

          Arrange to “accidentally” bump into her out in public sometime. That way, you won’t have to phone her but you’ll still get to gloat! :-)

          congrats!

          • GD Star Rating
            loading...
            Roger

            That is a wonderful plan but I don’t know where she lives and haven’t done for a quite few years. We were together in Perth, she let me know she was moving to Melbourne in 2002 & I moved to Brisbane 2 months ago. I do know her mother & step father live in Yeronga not far from the Brisbane CBD. If we do bump into each other it will truly be chance if she is visiting her mum.

            • GD Star Rating
              loading...
              Vee

              Roger, Don’t call her. Delete her number. That is the ultimate satisfaction and letting go and growing as a person. Why bother?! You have achieved everything so far for yourself not for her or to prove something to her! You void everything you have achieved for your own reasons and personal motivations that by ringing her and boasting. Just keep moving on and don’t look back.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Louisec

        No don’t call her! You’ve moved on, keep moving! One day somehow or other she’ll find out herself and that will be much more satisfying.

        By calling her, it’s obvious you would be seeking her approval or similar so don’t do it! Let her find out herself.

        Congratulations to you, it’s a wonderful story, well done.

  18. Pingback: On the (Rest of the) Net. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  19. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Janie

    A few things came to mind when I read this…
    1) I definitely got the better man after many heartbreaks
    2) I wonder if Jennifer Aniston feels like this?
    3) I try to think of it like flavours of ice cream. Some like chocolate, some like strawberry, some would eat strawberry for a while if there was nothing else on offer, some would never eat it and hold out for their favourite. What I mean is often someone leaves you because of their likes and dislikes and just because someone doesn’t like you doesn’t mean you are not a fantastic person, just not the right fit. Personally I love chocolate!

  20. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Sam

    the best thing about my break up was that we broke up. WOOHOO!!

  21. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Cynthia

    love the advice :) please post more!

  22. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    NotOnFacebook

    Started dating a guy when I was 19 who actually ‘dumped’ his girlfriend for me. The relationship lasted 2.5 years and the majority of it was pretty great. He wasn’t the type of guy my strict parents would have approved but like some (or maybe most??) women, I had to give the bad boys a go. So 2 years into it, this relationship turned serious for me and I was starting to see a real future with him – which would have included moving to Malaysia (he was an overseas student) to be with him. I started to picture my life with him in Malaysia and sooo many aspects of it was wrong. I’m not sure if it was stubborn dumb pride (ie. “since I’m clearly smart enough to not date or enter into long term relationships with losers, he must not be a loser”) or some subconscious rebellion against my parents’ ideals (ie. “see mum & dad, my perfect guy has none of the qualities you would deem as perfect for me) but I convinced myself that it would all work out beautifully despite deep reservations that I squashed up into a tiny little ball and kept stashed away in a deep dark spot in my brain.
    And guess what, one day found out (in a pretty bad and embarrassing way) that he had been cheating on me. At the same time his father decided to drag his ass back to Malaysia as the cheater was not performing at uni and decided that to continue would be a complete waste of his money. So the guy was yanked out of my life. I never had the opportunity to confront him about it.
    Fast forward a few years down the track – now married to a wonderful man (who my parents LOVE) with two beautiful kids, I sometimes think about what my life would have been like had I not found out about the cheating (or worse, found out and then forgiven him) and followed him back to Malaysia. Everytime I do, I cannot stop myself from shuddering from the thought. I then thank whoever it is up there who made the decision to abruptly take him out of my life and feel this profound gratefulness for it. Clearly I was too blind to make any good decisions for me at the time.
    So this particular break up changed my life for the better – I have always taken ‘learnings’ from each relationship ending (as what not to do for the next one) but this one significantly changed my views on relationships and most importantly, I learnt a few things about myself.
    And the cheater? Well he went back home and married the girl he allegedly dumped for me…

  23. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Eliska Jeffrey

    But sometimes it is the womans fault.Us women treat men badly as well and then get dumped.

    I was not a good girlfriend for a long time to my boyfriend ( never ever would cheat though ) and he ended it after trying so hard.That was the wake up call that I needed, I was a spoiled brat and thought he would just be there.We are working things out now and I am working on myself, for him and for myself too.

    Some people just don’t meet ‘ the one ‘ or end up being married with children like they want to.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Melissa

      Sometimes men are idiots and we dump them; often it just falls apart and you both see it and decide to go your separate ways.

  24. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Ridin solo

    Going to London solo in 7ish weeks time, I don’t know if it’s the best thing but hopefully it will be

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Mum of Two

      You go girl, I left a horrible relationship and went by myself on a working holiday to the UK, I met my now husband in the first couple of months and we have been together 16 years. Be brave, go with an open mind and just have a ball.
      Plus, English guys are soooo sexy :)

  25. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Dea

    I agree with this. I have been in 3 long term relationships.
    The first – Was cheated on and went through domestic violence. When I left (after the cheating) I was devestated and kept trying to get him back. It took a year to realise that I was better off without him and I worked on making myself happy and finding what I liked to do.
    The second – I thought he was my “Better Man” … nope not my knight in shing armour just a dipstick in tin foil. After moving away from my family I soon realised that I was now in a mental abuse situation. It took the immenent death of my Dad to give me the strength/lick in the ass to leave.

    It took 6 months on my own when I found my true “Better Man”. I am now with a guy who treats me as I should be treated and I treat him likewise. He loves me and I him and we are planning our future together.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      KT

      dipstick in tin foil! love it

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Tara

      Lick in the ass? Now there’s an unfortunate typo!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Mum of Two

      “just a dipstick in tin foil “,I LOVE that saying

  26. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Melissa

    Lol, my (current) better man is called Dan :)

  27. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Punkernickle

    Great advice from the therapist I saw during my divorce:

    “Get yourself out of ‘now’. Write two stories: one with him in your life in 10 years time, one without.”

    I think sometimes we get so caught up in the emotion of a relationship breakdown we don’t know what’s good for ourselves. This technique really worked for me and I use it often in other areas of my life still.

  28. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Free

    Very true — for the most part. I can remember being so despondant and gutted after a particularly harsh dumping and a friend telling me ‘he’s done you a favour’. I struggled to see the truth in those words, but given a little time, boy did they ring true. Life got better and better. And so did I when it came to spotting the kind of man I wanted to be with.
    As for the part about this piece that doesn’t ring true? Those guys (you know the ones — they’re usually going out with a friend of yours who is WAY too good for them) who are constantly breaking up with a girl because they want to see if they can do better, only to come skulking back when they realise that no one else will have them. Zero growth, zero responsability and zero chance of being a Better Man for your long-suffering friend.

  29. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    ineedaname

    nothing like a big break up and a bit of reinvention to head off to the next relationship a better, stronger more resilient person who knows and appreciates a good relationship. helps you to appreciate the next relationship and once you find ‘the one’ helps you with the skills and experience to keep him!

  30. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Flutterby

    I disagree. Never, ever go back.

  31. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Elli

    I think there’s a missing third part to the slogan: Better Me.

    In my case:
    Better Dan = my ex improved a bit, but after cheating on me then persistently lying about it I wouldn’t have taken him back if he’d been gold-plated.
    Better Man = definitely. I’m with a gorgeous, adorable man who woke me with a cup of tea in bed this morning, purely because he was awake first. But I wouldn’t have been interested in him or even met him if it hadn’t been for…
    Better Me. My breakup gave me the opportunity to explore who “I” really was, to extend my horizons and meet new people and interests. I joined a new social/hobby group, had a fling with a colleague (to get back on the horse that threw me), realised I am bisexual, dated a woman from the social/hobby group, broke up with her, had a career change, was invited by the female ex to a party, where I met an ex of hers. As a long-haired, left-wing, martial arts and classical music-loving student he’s a long way from pop music-listening, right wing, suit-wearing corporate financier who left me, and I’m so thankful for that.

    <3

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Me

      AWESOME comment

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Nursee

      Agree with Me above, great comment!!

      I think Better Me trumps better Dan and better man. I agree that break ups present an opportunity to find the real you and what you want/need.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Cressida

        How did you go with your partner and talking to him? Or did you want to leave that for the Best/Worst post at the end of this week?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Melissa

      I have a little of this in my better man story. Got back into acting, scored a lead in a play, met my better man. He’s also completely out of my comfort zone: Christian, non-corporate, creative, musical, compared to me quite conservative. It’s been a wonderful experience and incredibly rewarding.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      kateharris

      I totally agree with the ‘Better Me’ addition. I too have just come out of a long term relationship and feel that the best thing to come out of it is what I have learned about myself for next time around.

  32. Pingback: Tweets that mention When a break-up is the best thing that could happen to you. By Zoe Foster. | Mamamia -- Topsy.com

  33. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Mala

    I have no problem walking away from a flailing relationship or a man who no longer wants what I want. After the first or second heartbreak you realise that you won’t actually die as a consequence of your injuries, even though it feels like you might, but you will actually emerge stronger and wiser as a direct result of the pain you have just experienced. However, I think it is optimistic to suggest that EVERY woman will find her better man, or better dan. Many. just. won’t. I have only just recently accepted that thought myself. Now if the ‘right’ man pops up I’ll be happy. But if he doesn’t I’ll also be happy. I don’t plan to waste my life waiting.

  34. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    cos

    would you believe I have never been dumped!!? It just never happened. I was always the one that got bored quickly and moved on (dumper). When I look back now the way I ended alot of those relationships was just plain cruel and I’m not very proud of myself. I ended up with a really lovely husband too -maybe karma is going to bite me in the arse some other way…..

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      M

      Exactly with you! I have never been dumped and so never have experienced that heartacheI have witnessed my friends going through. i have a fabulous man in my life now. we just passed the four year mark and are still going from strength to strength…..funny though my ex is actually named Dan!
      i always think karma may come and get me aswell, although I did try to break up the kindest way possible…

  35. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Lu

    And if your friends dont think he’s good enough for you, its not because they’re jealous – they care about you and dont like the way he treats you! Move on and find your better man.

  36. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Bradley

    At the time, the break up hurts like hell. Fortunately, as each day passes it hurts a little less. One day, when you happen to meet “The One”, it stops hurting completely.

  37. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Jess

    I once had a man who broke it off with me, after which I had a summer of heart break and agony, then recovery, then flings, then fun – and my confidence in myself and my worth as a person and partner grew. In the middle of the next year, the very same man reappeared in my life and slowly I let him back in. He is my Better Dan now, and it’s been 5 lovely years. I know that as hard as it was, the break up was absolutely necessary and firmly believe that if it hadn’t happened we wouldn’t be so strong today. I grew, he grew, and now we’re two better people together making a good team – rather than two uncomfortable people try to make a whole.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Louisec

      Hi, how long were you apart? Was it hard to trust him again?
      Great story, thannkyou.

  38. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    You can call me Susan

    I am living proof. I’ve been dumped too many times to want to think about it over the fifteen years or so that I was single. I now have my Prince! I tell my daughter, you’ve got to keep kissing (not too many!) frogs until you find your Prince. Fortunately, she recently kissed a toad, so she’s getting the idea…..

  39. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Daisy

    So true I have a few friends who need to read this URGENTLY!! There is nothing worse than a woman or man who keeps trying to hold onto someone whose ditch them big time – so degrading. Where is their pride?? A good friend of mine said to me when I was in a state “alway keep your pride cause if you don’t have that what do you have?”

  40. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Caitlin

    This article makes me think of Better Man by pearl jam.

    True though, as devastating as it is, I found a better man rather than I better dan. I learnt something from the failure of my last relationship, which put a lot into perspective when entering my current relationship.

  41. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Elisha

    Unfortunately, to me, this piece reads like a Cosmo article which, like all fluffy Cosmo articles, tends to treat women like airheads.

    While I agree with Zoe that the end of a relationship can definitely be a good thing, it’s a bit fairytale-bullshit to call what comes ‘a win-win situation’. Who says one of these scenarios will happen? Maybe it will, maybe it won’t. Maybe you are no longer with the guy who was wrong for you, but there’s no guarantee the right guy will come along, or the wrong guy will change. (Very few people change, by the way – I’m a bit suss on the Better Dan theory.)

    What about the girl who grieves over the end of her relationship, heals, throws herself back into dating with an open heart, and… nothing? No better man or better Dan?

    And what about the girl who grieves, heals, moves on… and realises she’s happier without a relationship? I know that’s wierd and everything, but guess what? – life isn’t a stereotype!

    Why are we being fed such a simplistic Rom-Com line by a so-called ‘expert’ who should know, as any modern woman knows, that sometimes life doesn’t ‘end’ with the man of your dreams and all that comes with it?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Emma in Melbourne-land

      Zoe has a regular relationship column in Cosmo, so there you go! :)

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Odina

      i believe this column was actually first published in cosmo.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anonymous

      Yes – this is a ‘standard Cosmo your life will be great’ column. Zoe’s Cosmo columns are all fluff!

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Elisha

        Thanks, that explains it. It’s been so many years since I’ve actually picked up a glossy mag, it just jarred a little reading this style of article here! Not to insult Zoe – she obviously has her audience, and she writes well – I just don’t feel that this is typical MamaMia content or quality.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Perthgirl

          I completely agree. Let’s have some proper content please. This piece is not Mama Mia calibre.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      CB

      I’d be writing a column like this too if I were dating Hamish Blake….. Hmmmmm!

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        redballoon

        haha, he is very hot, isn’t he?!

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      #1

      I guess she just wants to share her optimism (which has obviously works for her ;) ), and generate some hopefulness for others in a perceived dire situation.

      But yes, the article is originally from Cosmo, had it been written specifically for the mamamia audience it may have had a slightly different tone – maybe similar to her Sunday Telegraph column.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        #1

        *worked not works (damn my engrish – cannot edit).

  42. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Jenny Louise Wright

    zoe foster you are one funny chick.
    i love your theory, especially ones that are based on no scientific evidence – just plain good fun.

  43. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Alana

    Thanks Zoe. This post came at a good time for me. I’ve just experienced another guy not returning my call so I went for a walk to clear my head last night. As I was waiting to cross the road I saw a guy I dated years ago drive by who also never returned my call. Instead of feeling upset I felt relieved. Probably relieved that I’d dodged a bullet and didn’t have to travel in his awful beat-up car! I hope I feel relieved in a few years’ time when I run into this most recent non-phone-call-returner.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Commonsensegirlonline

      Slightly off topic but next time leave the phoning to the guy – don’t demean yourself by phoning him. Guys like to do the chasing and they prefer you to play slightly hard to get. Not my personal theory but certainly what I’ve heard my son and his mates saying. Girls phoning them (initially) tells them that she’s desperate apparently – not a good look. (LOL)

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Batman's Cave

        Well why the hell would you want to date a man who doesn’t know how to handle a woman? I disagree about this whole chasing rubbish… its a stupid theory based losely around some scientific research about neanderthals… its an excuse for men to be lazy, and hide their insecurities about dealing and communicating with women and to make women wait around. Cut these losers loose… and then these idiots complain why they are 30+ yo and single!

  44. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Latarche

    I actually think this article is brilliant. Currently in a relationship but go back 2.5 years and the girl this article is directed at was me.

    I ended up with a better man instead of a better Dan but at the time the heartbreak wass just all consuming and I remember actively searching for anything, anyone, something to understand how I felt and to tell me it would be ok. I also needed to be constantly reminded not to ring, sms, email the ex. I wish this article was written back in September 2008 when I needed it so very badly.

    Great article Zoe. Keep up the good work.

  45. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anonymous

    She’s not writing this for all women. She’s writing it for the women who have been dumped

  46. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    bounce

    Ahhh, again the women are being dumped. I would like to see an article looking at the issue from the other side of the fence- how to move forward when YOU are the one who has ended things with your boyfriend/partner/finacee/husband.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anon

      Good suggestion but remember 50% get dumped and the other 50% are the people who did the dumping. At the end of the day it must be easier for the dumper? Aren’t they the ones making the decison? I am not saying it is “easy” for them but just in most cases it is easier because they get to make the decision. The other person isn’t even getting a say.

      I think we sould be thankful that this article might help 50% of those people in a current broken relationship and then maybe request an article for the other 50% to follow soon after?

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        bounce

        My point was more that in the media we are always fed the idea that it is women BEING dumped not vice-versa. Therefore, when women feel they have outgrown or are struggling with their relationship or wondering whether they even want to BE in a relationship, there isn’t much around for them by way of articles like this. Women who have been DUMPED on the other hand have plenty of articles like this to draw on.
        Also, I think it is worth remembering that being the one who ends a relationship can be absolutely heratbreaking and soul-destroying for its own reasons.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      bretts gal

      I have never been the dumper. I have always been the dumpee. I am 30 years old and have never had to break up with a boyfriend, partner or husband. And I have had them all. So I really like this.

      My heart has broken so very many times. But I am in a massively better place now then when I was married.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      #1

      Yeah, I would have liked to have known how to get past the guilt when I ended it with my ex years ago.

  47. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Anonymous

    Yes why are we the ones getting dumped in this article???

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      jojo (with a little j)

      I guess it’s quite simply who the article is aimed at.

      Often if you’re the person being dumped, it hurts a lot more and is harder to believe that it’s a good thing, then when you’re the one doing the dumping.

      I don’t think that Zoe is implying that females are only ever the dumpees, it’s just the topic that she chose to centre this article around. I’m sure she’s written articles about women breaking up with men – not every article needs to include every single possible situation of who breaks up with who.

  48. GD Star Rating
    loading...
    Alexandra

    ‘Relationship expert’? Umm, okay.. Why does this article assume all women are the ones getting dumped and are absolutely devastated they didn’t get a ring on it?

    On a more positive note, ‘beauty expert’ is definitely a title I’d accept for Zoe ‘cos she know her prods.

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anon

      Pretty sure that she isn’t assuming that. She is just writing an article directed at those women who have been dumped recently.

      I think Zoe would be the first to admit the women also can dump guys. We see much less clothes on them at summer too :-)

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Anon

      I’ve had a few relationships myself, does that make me a relationship expert?

    • GD Star Rating
      loading...
      Nicky Champ

      We’ve used relationship expert as a tongue in cheek reference to the books she has written on dating. And relationships.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Daisy

        Of course and it was funny. Some people really need to lightened up ! I loved the article.

      • GD Star Rating
        loading...
        Mistaken Identity

        I read Air Kisses after getting it free at a movie. It’s experiential, like a diary any of us could have written and experienced. It sometimes felt like my own words. That’s ok. It’s not psychological or philosophical. But it’s a reminder that our experiences are normal.

        • GD Star Rating
          loading...
          Single Girl

          I was recently the dumpee and have read this article several times since.

          I didn’t want the relationship to end but it certainly had to – it became unhealthy after many years together. I don’t know if it would have been any harder being dumped as I struggle with knowing I can go back should I want. In time maybe I will should he become the better man.

          However, what the article does give me is the light to feel that either way I will be ok. Not because I need a man to feel better or rely on but because I want one to share my life with. I want to be in love and I have broken out of that relationship to get the road happening quicker so I get either a better Dan or the better man. I wonder why sometimes we fight against being honest and saying – I want to get married, or I want to be in a relationship? Why does that make us any less independent than those woman that say I don’t need a man?

          Either way, this article has been a breathe of fresh air for me in a difficult time. Cosmo style or not.