Most proposal stories involve things like rose petals, champagne, a fancy dinner, a romantic location and a man on bended knee.
Sometimes there’s a bit of variety. Sometimes, proposals involve picnics and giant love hearts drawn on beaches and flash mobs and Youtube videos. (Perhaps not all at once, although there’s an idea for you fellas).
They do not involve toilets and poos.
Why? Because toilets and poos, along with giant snakes and wedgies, are up there the list of Least Romantic Things On This Planet.
Now brace yourselves… Because we want to share with you the romantic tale of Sara and James.
Sara Barron wrote a post for The Frisky about how her boyfriend, James proposed to her on Christmas morning.
Now, Sara and James have a lovely relationship. The sharing-is-caring kind of relationship. The I-will-tell-you-if-I-need-to-poo-and-you-will-care kind of relationship. In fact, Sara reveals in her article that she and James talk bodily functions as regularly as they utter the phrase ‘I love you’.
Anyway, back to Christmas morning when James wakes up feeling like he really needs to go to the bathroom. He goes back and forth to the loo while Sara drifts in and out of sleep. And then James returns to their bed, all excited about… well… his poo.
Sara explains how it went from there:
“Sara,” he said. “Wake up. I have taken the biggest dump of my life!”
“Congratulations,” I said. “That’s wonderful news.”
“Will you come and look at it?” he asked. “It’s pretty much the most amazing thing I’ve ever done.”
“Do I have to?” I asked.
“Yes!” he said. “It’s Christmas! I thought we could stand beside it, and take a photo, and send it to Jon. It’d be like a Christmas card. C’mon! You know he’ll love it.”
I sighed. He seemed so exuberant, this boyfriend of mine. And it was Christmas, like he said.
“Okay,” I said. “Let’s go.”
He takes her into the bathroom, he opens the lid of the toilet… and the ring is there. INSIDE THE TOILET.
It turns out that James has wrapped glad-wrap over the toilet and placed the ring on top. There is no actual poo involved, just the *illusion* of it. Thank goodness for that. You can all keep eating your lunches now.
Sara says yes, because: “I figured we were probably a match, seeing as how he’d thought it appropriate to pretend an engagement ring was a bowel movement, and I’d thought him all the more wonderful for doing so.”
Well.
The whole proposal is certainly original. We know this because we googled “toilet proposal stories” and while people have been proposed to while sitting on the toilet before, no results involved rings actually INSIDE toilets.
SO: Worst proposal, or best proposal ever?
For the purpose of research, we asked around the office to work out everyone’s best-ever-proposal-idea (just to see if any of them might involve toilets or poos).
Employee 1: “I just want something cute, preferably involving a picnic.”
Employee 2: “I guess a romantic dinner, just the two of us, and then a romantic hand-in-hand walk just chatting about our future (most likely along a coastal walk) and then a very private and intimate proposal.”
Employee 3: “Nothing in public with people I don’t know, I’d be embarrassed. And hopefully at a time where I’ve put some effort into what I’m wearing/hair/make-up.”








Comments
39 Comments so far
Nah, sorry, don’t like it. My 7 year old thinks poo is hilarious, but then he is 7.
loading...
OMG thank god it ended the way it did – I thought he was going to put it IN the poo! I was starting to dry retch while reading!
loading...
Hilarious!! Whatever works for them!
My hubby took me away for a weekend, which I usually take care of as I’m a travel agent but left it to him. Got there, checked in, took me for a lovely walk at Sunshine Coast, cue dolphins and perfect weather and then we rounded a corner and there on the beach 100 metres below was a blazing MARRY ME, he got down on bended knee and had a bottle of champers set up so we could enjoy the view. He’d got his family and best mates to help out so we decided to have a few celebratory drinks back at our apartment. Next surprise was he’d invited my closest friends and family to the same hotel so we could have our engagement party same night! Was a massive surprise. He is not a romantic person at all and tells me the proposal gets him points for 10 years! We’ve been married for almost 9 so I’ll be cashing in on some more romance soon!
loading...
It was my 30th birthday and my boyfriend of 2 years takes me away to a cabin in the hinterland. Nice, cosy and cold. The afternoon we got there he gave me my birthday present which was earrings in a nice aqua blue box
We go to dinner the next night and he is sweating bullets, I ask him if he’s ok and he says he’s not feeling well so we head home early. I head straight from the car to the shower to warm up, I come out in my flannel PJs with face cream on and he says “I have another gift for you” and it was in the same aqua blue box as the earrings, so i was so excited thinking it was a matching necklace or bracelet. I say thanks and open it up and insidee is a locket (not really to my liking but nice enough). I say thank-you and close the lid and he looks at me and says “turn it over” so I turn the box over a bit confused, and he says “no the locket”. and on the back is engraved Will You Marry Me?
He got a YES, but no way in hell was I taking a photo to commemorate the moment. He then took me to the jeweller the next day and we designed by engagement ring together
loading...
Love this. Whatever works for them.
My husband proposed in a fancy Beverly Hills restaurant and I knew it was coming because it was the one and only activity he’d planned for our entire 5 week holiday. And I could see the ring box in his pocket. He’d be planning to do it after the meal, but after about 20 minutes of the most awkward silence we’d ever had, he just did it to get it over with, before our meals arrived. Everyone clapped in the restaurant, but (even though it wasn’t cheap) they probably weren’t accustomed to seeing engagement rings as small as mine, lol. I would’ve loved a proposal that took me completely by surprise, but I am more than happy with the proposal I received.
loading...
Mine always said he didn’t want to get married. I always hoped he’d change his mind. He proposed during an intimate dinner at a small restaurant with our 1 year old. Ring in the champagne, when i finally noticed the ring, he was down on one knee. I was shocked, the staff all cheered, I said yes with tears in my eyes, we kissed and then heard this high pitched keening sound. It turned into little sobs, looked down and our son was crying. Kinda broke the spell (he doesn’t like cheering…or happy birthday singing…funny bubba).
Ps….he proposed on the 21st of December last year…the day the world was suppose to end. How ironic
loading...
My proposal went along the lines of: I want you to come back to Australia, I’ll even marry you if I have to. – this was after I had travelled back to Denmark as I couldn’t be granted residency unless we got married and hubby (23 at the time) was not ready. Six months later he was
My brother did better: on our boat, visiting with his girlfriend, he said he wanted to go outside as he was feeling a bit queasy. Girlfriend goes with him and they lie on the front deck looking at the stars. She says: promise you’ll always be mine. He says: funny you should say that, pulls out a ring and gives her the spiel.
Meanwhile we’d popped the champagne inside the boat.
loading...
my friend’s boyfriend always said they’d never get married, but…. on her 30th birthday in front of all their family and friends, he gave her a set of knives -a humiliating gift until an engagement ring fell out of the box.!!
loading...
This has brought a huge smirk to my face! Love it!
loading...
I think the best proposals are the ones that fit you as a couple, even if no one else will get it. It’s your moment, no one else’s
loading...
My husband is the most unromantic person in history and he proposed to me on a hike in the ottoway ranges, waited til we got to the waterfall we were going to see, got down on one knee and asked with a ring. It was simple and beautiful and I wouldn’t have wanted anything else
Grand gestures are for some people, but I would have guessed and been embarrassed, so it was more us this way, just like the toilet thing was them.
loading...
Hmmm toilet ?? Fail!!!
I loved the way my now husband propsed…
Took me to Melbourne for a 3 day weekend for our 5 year anniversary.
We checked into a fancy room at the Langham and had a nice dinner the first night. The next day he said he had a surprise for our anniversary and we had to be in the foyer at 11am. We were picked up (I didnt know where we were going) and taken to the airport. We went in a helicopter over Melbourne where he popped the question.
We came back to the hotel and rang all our family and had champagne.
We went out for dinner and another surprise, one of my best friends who lives in Melbourne, who I had been told was overseas for work, turned up to the restaurant and we had a lovely boozy, degustation dinner.
Was fabulous!
Then spent all the next day in bed getting room service and watching movies.
Perfect!
loading...
I read this article a few days ago, and in context the poop proposal makes total sense, they have poop history.
I’m not a big fan of proposals because it seems a bit fake. Most couples discuss getting married first, and decide to do it together. Why have this weird, staged moment?
If it makes you happy go for it, but it wasn’t for me. We just decided to over dinner, didn’t make an announcement, just started quietly making plans. That’s pretty much how we roll 10 years of marriage later.
loading...
The knowledge of a future proposal may be there, but the timing and setting can be a surprise and a lot of men (and some women) like to make it a special, memorable moment. Thus the “weird staged proposal”.
loading...
This made me piss myself laughing… I would much rather something cute and funny than a grand display, but each to their own
loading...
I used to work in a restaurant and proposals were common. This one time a guy proposed to his girlfriend before the meal arrived, she said no, he stormed off, she stayed and ate her meal.
All of the staff were amused
loading...
I loved my proposal….
-Organised a surprise day of work from my boss
- took me around town for picnics and walks at our favourite spot
-drove up to the hills to a B&B, where we had private dinner on the deck and danced under the stars
-Woke me at 3am to go hot air ballooning
-proposed as sun was rising (he calls me his sunshine)
-champagne brekkie
-wedding mags waiting in the car (with my favourite lollies) for the drive home
-took a detour during the drive home to the place of our first date…and all my extended family (whom Im very close to) where having a picnic lunch to celebrate!
Husband says after that he doesnt have to do anything romantic for the next 10 years!
loading...
this was beautiful to read….
loading...
Wow. Copying & pasting your comment so that I can send it to my boyfriend for future reference!!
loading...
Make a sign and hold it up next time he does a long deployment. You might even make the cover of the Navy News.
loading...
ooo the magazines are a nice touch
loading...
Wow, that’s a doozy!
loading...
You lost me at “woke me up at 3am”.
Sorry, that is really romantic and klovely, but I am too tired to appreciate it!
loading...
As much as it’s a lovely story/plan/event, the wedding mags in the car would have been the highlight for me… talk about attention to detail!!! Awesome.
loading...
My hubby proposed to me on the goldcoast beach after tea at the Hard Rock Cafe (love that place).It was a massive surprise and the most romantic he has ever been. That said, Ive always fantasized about being taken up in a hot air balloon at sunset and proposed to
. Nightmare proposal would be being asked by someone i didnt want to marry and having to break their heart and boom there goes a perfectly happy relationship!
loading...
A nightmare proposal, to me, is the one where you don’t wish to marry the person asking you, either right then or ever. Eek.
loading...
Well it sounds as if it might suit them as a couple in their whacky way, but for me I rate it like this – Originality: ten. Romance: zero.
loading...
Can I just ask, if you’re not intending to marry the person why are you with them to the point of that person thinking it is a serious enough relationship to want to spend the rest of their lives with you?
loading...
Probably because there’s a continuum of seriousness of relationships, not just all or nothing … and because people have different ideas about when and whether it is the right time … and because we unfortunately/fortunately can’t read each other’s minds.
loading...
Yes. That is exactly right, distracted.
It happened to me (years ago now) when I had been away with my partner of 12mths. He came back from our trip feeling ready to make the relationship more serious and take steps towards that, whilst I came back having realised we were ready to split.
Feelings are complicated, and it is difficult to know really how we arrived at such different points, but either way, the time away had helped us both reflect. We both made leaps, just in different directions, and both of us were caught by surprise by the other.
Ultimately, I’d realised I didn’t love him. Splitting up was the right outcome, so I stopped him actually reaching the point of asking me. He can have that moment with the right partner who wants to say yes to him.
loading...
Lol, I would not be thrilled to be proposed too in such a way but whatever floats your boat! He obviously knew her well enough to know that this would work for her so that’s great! Mine was a picnic by a river that he organised. And yet he still got criticised for doing along a river that is ‘too brown’ and because he didn’t get me a ring (I had told him all along that I did not want an engagement ring). People will always criticise
loading...
I think I was proposed to near this same brown river also without an engagement ring because my now husband, then fiancé knew that I’d probably prefer to choose my own ring. We were on our way to see a show I’d really wanted to see & I spent the first half being quite distracted because we’d just gotten engaged.
Fairly soon after we went to visit a client of my husband’s who was a diamond merchant. I literally sat there while the client held diamonds over my left hand so I could choose which one I liked best. It only took a few, then I was saying, ‘no, too big, throne before was better.’ He looked up at my husband & said, ‘I’d keep this one if I were you’. I then got to choose the setting, metal type etc. Well worth waiting for, my engagement ring.
loading...
I once heard a story about man who proposed by putting the ring on his penis! Apparently this guy had a weirdly flexible penis and his party trick throughout high school (and since) was puppetry of the penis.
He decided to propose to his girlfriend by waking her up 1 morning, and she rolled over to see him standing next to her with the tip of his penis squished through the ring. The worst thing of all… she said YES to this!!
The girl I heard this from swears it’s true (the guy is her boyfriend’s mate) and apparently no one was at all surprised this was the way he proposed as he was quite well known for his party trick! Imagine then ringing your Mum and saying “Mum! I’m engaged!” and then having to explain the proposal to her… Oh geez. Definitely the worst proposal story I have ever heard!
loading...
Why is her saying yes to the proposal the worst part?
loading...
Haha I love it. Sounds like he has gone to just as much effort to come up with an idea that makes sense to both of them as any other guy would, his just involved a toilet! If my boyfriend put in that much thought I’d be happy!
loading...
Haha I think it’s totally weird and cute.
That guy who faked his own death deserved a ‘no’.
loading...
Aww, I actually loved that proposal story! It reflects the nature of their relationship, how close they are, how perfectly matched they are. Each to their own!
loading...
All I can say is that it really must have been a beautiful ring !
If this works for them…that’s fine by me. I would never consider asking anyone to marry me in this fashion and the thought of doing so appalls me. At the end of the day it is about someone else’s relationship, so who am I to criticise if they mutually found the proposal different and romantic.
loading...
I think whatever works for the couple! Toilet, picnic, beach, baseball match, top of the eiffel tower, on a long hike, rock concert, petrol station whatever. As long as the two people involved like it, who are we to judge?
loading...