This is Brendan Maclean’s opening speech given at the Sydney Equal Love rally which gathered at Town Hall despite protestors attempting to shut it down. It marched up Oxford St with over 700 people:
My name’s Brendan Maclean.
I work at triple j, I’m a musician, I hate Lady Gaga’s new songs but I know every lyric and when I was 15 my dad picked me up from a police station under a banner that said ‘Gay and Lesbian Youth Services.’ Hi Dad!
On Tuesday, the 17th of May, we celebrated International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia. We came together to say no to bullying, no to discrimination in schools, in our work places and in our social lives. I spent the day at RMIT University in Melbourne hearing students talk about what they felt had been achieved to combat hate in others and fear in themselves, and there was a lot of good things; the laws that have changed, the opinions shifted, but what we agreed was missing is why we’re here today.
If marriage is just a word, give it to me. If marriage is just a piece of paper, give it to me. We want Equal Love and we want the symbols and language that applies to everybody else, as equals.
Today is something we fight for, for most of our lives. When students threw rocks at you, when you were denied work, when you battled depression bought on because you were being told it was wrong to be who you were. When you lost friends because they didn’t win that fight. You were fighting for Equal Love.
I don’t for a minute believe that when Tim Mathieson turns to Julia Gillard and pops the question, she’ll proudly declare her Atheism and say ‘no Tim we’ll have Civil Union’. But because she is a woman and he is a man they are free to stroll in and out of the boundaries and many meanings of the word Marriage. But not us.
The double standards are obvious and the arguments against us are just a few twisted words away from: ‘It’s just not normal’. There is a lot left to fight for all around the world; from recent atrocities against civil rights in Uganda to hate crimes that go unnoticed in rural Australia. But we as a community, throughout generations, have been battling for too long to not overthrow this baseless idea that after you fight through high school, after you fight through the work place, after we fight through bigoted talk-back radio hosts and narrow minded politicians, after you fight the fear to let go of your lover’s hand when you walk down the street, when you finally find that person you want to marry, after all that, you can’t.
I can only tell my own stories. Many of you, probably most of you, grew up in a culture where a rally like this may not have existed. Every generation assumes the next one has it easier, but so they should, it’s what we want. So today we stand together to send a message, a clear, confident message, whether we’re young or old, gay or straight, whatever gender or sexuality you are and whether or not you choose to get married yourself, we stand together to say it’s time for our country to move into the modern world, to demand Equal Love.







Comments
80 Comments so far
There needs to be a few things changed. I don’t believe that gay people should be able to join together under the umbrella of ‘marriage’. Marriage has been throughout history a religious ceremony, and even though in today’s day and age, the religious side doesn’t have the same meaning, it still somewhat belongs to the church.
Two things need to be done. Separate church and state. Civil Union for EVERYONE. Everyone has the right to be together with the one they love. They have the right to be at their bedside when they’re sick in hospital. They have the right to be the rightful heirs to their joint estates after death. They have the right to everything a current day married couple have come to expect.
In this separation, the church, as much as it might anger a lot of people, have the right to decide who is ‘married’ under their religious laws. It sucks balls that they disagree with the idea of two same gendered people being married, but once all legal power behind ‘marriage’ is removed, they should have the right to choose. It’s part of their belief system, and Australia is all about freedom of speech and religious practice.
Maybe with this change, and the movement towards a more accepting society in terms of homosexual unions, the church might start making moves in ‘keeping up with the times’, so to speak.
Just my two cents.
loading...
The other day when there was a forum in Queensland discussing this the agenda was packed with religious spokespeople. Since when do religions decide on our laws? What happened to separation of church and state?
Personally I think religious marriage should have no legal standing. If you are married in a church, mosque or whatever, that is fine, you have performed your religious duty, but you are no more or less legally ‘married’ than when you walked in. Civil marriage is then open to any partners who wish and totally separate to religious marriage. If you are married in a church you will still have to get the marriage certificate, but the priest (or whoever) cannot preside over this as it currently done, it will be done by the government department.
loading...
The fight for equal marriage rights is a hot topic in Australia at the moment. I am a staunch supporter of gay marriage. I have heard the pros and cons. I have seen religious people hurl abuse at gay people. I have seen gay people hurl abuse at religious people. I have felt the pain of members of my family and close friends feeling ostracised. I have seen the hate. But I have also seen the love. I have seen a heterosexual couple on their wedding day walk out in a march for equal marriage rights and tell them ‘One day we will be standing with you on your wedding day’.
What is so wrong about two people that are in love getting married? What is so offensive? Homosexuality isn’t contagious. It isn’t a disease. It is a choice. It is a right.
I know of some heterosexual couples who are certainly breaking nearly every commandment in the Bible, yet are still allowed to marry in a church. I know of many christians who are having sex before marriage, yet still marry in a church. Who decides which sins are forgivable? Last time I checked it wasn’t the government.
So, you don’t want gay people to get married in churches, yet you will allow criminals, pedophiles, liars and rapists get married in one? Personally, I would much rather be sitting at a wedding in a church with 2 gay people in love who desperately want to publicly declare their love for each other than in a wedding where 2 people are getting married just so they can finally justify their pre-marital sex.
I have complete respect for the individual church’s right to accept or decline the option of gay marriages. There are many progressive churches out there that will gladly fling open their doors for gay marriages to occur. Heck, let people get married wherever they want. Just let them call it a marriage. I don’t think that when a same sex couple gets married it should be called a civil union. If that be the case, then every non-active member of a church who gets married should only be entitled to a civil union.
All you need is love for a marriage. Is that so offensive that sometimes this love occurs between same sex couples? Gay, Straight, Black or White. Marriage is s civil right.
loading...
Remember when black people weren’t allowed to marry white people? How LUDICROUS does that seem? No doubt we will feel the same when we look back at the time when gay people weren’t allowed to marry. RIDICULOUS.
loading...
Brendan’s speech did make me sensationally happy – but do you know what else does? The fact that so many people in the Comments below agree.
That really is something to be proud of Australia. If we band together, we can make this happen.
loading...
What a fantastic speech. I want more Brendan MacLean articles.
Nodding along with the comments about “why are we still having this debate.” SO many social justice fights seem to take so long, and we have to be ever-vigilant. But at least with this one, we have come pretty far in a short period of time.
20 years ago, my mother was homophobic. Now she sits around having cups of tea with friends of mine who are gay and talking about conception/adopting/co-parenting options. While so many young people still have a really hard time and there is a lot of ugly and harsh prejudice/discrimination, there are more of us who couldn’t care less what sexuality our children have, as long as they live happy meaningful lives.
This debate, at least, has the feel of a winner. It’s just a matter of time. Makes the hanging-in-there feel so much more worthwhile and hope-building. The corner is set to be turned. So exciting. And makes me so glad to be alive now, and not in the 1950s.
loading...
Fabulous speech, and like so many commentors I can’t believe it is one that even needs to spoken.
loading...
How frustrating that this debate continues…..that we haven’t evolved beyond it. Our children will look back and baulk at us like we did at the society in which suffragettes were jailed in their fight to vote.
How can the arguments against be anything but bigoted??
loading...
Fantastic speech! I couldn’t agree more.
One of my best friends, Lee*, is gay and is in a really hard situation, due to the awful situation because of discrimination and bigoted viewpoints.
Her girlfriend is bisexual and comes from a very devout Christian family – she told her parents she was bi and they refused to accept it.
Now she has to hide her relationship and be very selective in telling anyone about Lee*. It sucks. Because of this they can’t act like other couples, they have to be affectionate in private – hiding their relationship.
I cannot even think of how frustrating this would be.
If you’d like to read about Lee’s story, you can find it here: http://silencingthemirror.blogspot.com/2011/02/day-in-life-for-gay-teen.html
Anyone can comment and I’d love to here from you.
Also, this is a fantastic website: http://www.thisisoz.com.au/
loading...
Amen.
loading...
I was at RMIT Uni when Brendan came for IDAHO. He was brilliant, and funny. His music was great. I talked to him as well, he is very sweet. We had a great day! Lots of fun. I spent it with my gay boys and we told everyone and had cupcakes!
loading...
Brendan, this speech gives me goosebumps…..you have expressed your sentiments wonderfully.
This issue upsets me so much and I hope that in the very near future it will be merely an embarassing fact of history. Until then, we must all keep fighting for what is right – Equal Love
loading...
Wow… so many people here echoing my exact thoughts!!!
My sister has been with her partner now for about 17 years. They had a Committment ceremony 10 years ago. They have two beautiful little 5 year old girls.
It makes me so angry that my relationship with my Husband seems to mean so much more to our government and so many people in this world, than that of my sister & sister-out-law. It makes me angry. It makes me fume. I have actually lost friends over this issue, or rather, decided not to persue a friendship because some people can be so closed minded about this.
loading...
I’m happily married but my younger sister is gay and it pisses me off that she doesn’t have the same rights I do to be married. She didn’t decide to ‘be gay’ just like we don’t choose a lot of things but yet this discrimination still continues! What if one of my potential future children are gay? I’d want them to be able to pursue a marriage if they wanted it. When will this nonsense end?
loading...
Remember the sisters post the other day? Well, my sister is a lesbian. I love her dearly, and it pains me that we are so unequal in this arena. We were raised together, the same way, the same rules and boundaries. Nothing happened that CAUSED one of us to be straight, and the other gay, we just are. A quirk of genetics, perhaps.
And since it’s just genetics that determines sexual orientation, to prevent gay couples from marrying is as crazy as preventing redheads from marrying. Or people with big noses. Or tall people. Imagine the outcry if we tried to outlaw any of those things!
Let’s get moving on this issue, and make it a non-issue.
loading...
Beautifully written Brendan and it is hard to believe we’re still having this discussion and it’s not just a given!!
loading...
“Make equal love, not war”. A cool banner or T-shirt slogan for the next election!!
loading...
Love, love, love this post. I’m planning my wedding at the moment. Totally not on that my gay friends are prevented from doing the same thing should they want to. I can have many marriages, they can have none. I can legally use the word ‘husband’, why can’t they be ‘wife and wife’. I’ll sign any petition, send any email, to fix this stupid and outdated law based on prejudice.
loading...
Here’ s a good place to start:
http://www.australianmarriageequality.com/wp/
loading...
Just went and sent my email. Thanks, Two Mummies.
loading...
Just sent my email too. Thanks Two Mummies.
loading...
Hell yes! nothing else
loading...
Hi Brendan. I’m with you all the way on this issue, as are many of us.
Purely out of interest….I note that whenever we read your writings on this site it is always about gay issues. Yes, I find what you write interesting and informative and I agree with your sentiments.
Do you ever write about other issues ? I would like to see if there is more than just the one string to your bow.
loading...
Mamamia reminds me of Glee. I like it but some days it just about the gay kid.
loading...
I suppose I’ve become quite an expert on being gay after all these years of study.
Just quietly, I get a little intimidated by all the fantastic writers on the MammaMia, I think now my writing muscle is back on track I can start branching out!
BM
loading...
I look forward to reading your thoughts on a variety of topics.
Thanks.
loading...
I don’t think anyone has the right to tell another what they can and can’t do.
I was fortunate enough to be born straight, so I know what it’s like to have all options available to me if I want them.
It is not fair that another human being, made up of the same stuff as me, but who is attracted to the same sex, should be denied the same opportunities.
Most of these people have been through enough shit in the school yard, the work place and the social scene, they do not deserve to also be bullied by a narrow-minded government.
Give them the fricken piece of paper!
PS- Fantsastic speech by Brendan. What an inspiration.
loading...
What an excellent speech… I fully agree with that, it’s ridiculous that non-religious marriage still adheres to religious ideas of marriage. As one of my religious friends says “I’m all for gay marriage, just don’t call it marriage and don’t have it in a church.” Somehow, it doesn’t sound like you’re pro-gay marriage mate. Such utter stupidity and nonsence. That sort of religious “I’m right you’re wrong la-la-la I can’t hear you” bullshit is up there with anti-choice in outdated “values” that have no place in a secular society, none whatsoever.
loading...
I was outraged when our wedding celebrant told me we legally had to include in our service: “Marriage, according to law in Australia, is the union of a man and women to the exclusion of all other, voluntarily entered into for life.”
We asked her (and were confronted with a bit of resistence on her part) to add: “And further, X and X have the sincerest hope and belief that the law will someday be changed to recognise that marriage is and should be a voluntary and full commitment of two people who love each other, regardless of gender.”
loading...
Hi mostly,
You rock!!
loading...
I have only recently found out that celebrants legally have to say that, and was wondering if the law would change by the time I get married in a few years.
Thanks for the extra part of the speech, I was trying to think of ways I could get around the line because I have a few gay friends who I hope can get married themselves one day.
loading...
I think Julia would personally want to support Equal Love, however she and her party are to scared of the backlash from the religious right and the religious public. From the comments posted here I think most people support Equal Love. However once again religious belief trumps anti discrimination legislation leaving many a politician to scared to act!
Please don’t cut me down for expressing that. I believe this is fact.
It begs the question, is this country genuinely politically secular?
loading...
I’ve often thought the same. But if that were the case, all she has to do politically is stick to the ‘this is the party’s position and I support the party’s position’. Instead, she’s gone out of her way to not only say that but also ensure people know that this is also her personal preference. Which I find really odd. Really odd. She has a political deflector, but she chooses to use her personal opinions as well. Which is fine, that’s her choice, but it makes me wonder what she truly believes…
loading...
Maybe I’m wrong, she may not personally believe in Equal Love…I just find it difficult to accept that people without religious persuasion (I disagree with the religious rationale) do not support gay marriage and equal rights. What is so difficult about this debate…it’s a non brainer. JUST LEGISLATE.
loading...
Just replying to myself. I realise what is difficult about this debate. It is that not enough people like myself (married hetrosexual) effectively lobby parliament for change! It is out of our everyday life. It does not effect us directly.
Time to change this. Time to act.
Thanks for the wake up call Brendan and Rick.
loading...
What Julia Gillard believes would depend entirely upon whether you are asking the “real” Julia or just Julia.
I may not approve of Tony Abbott’s position on the matter, but giving credit where credit is due…his opinion remains the same and is up front regardless whether it be written down or an off the cuff comment.
loading...
Totally fair point, and I agree. Although he did the same thing with climate change…they’re all the same, right?
loading...
I would agree.
loading...
Here’s a stop and hold your breath moment….perhaps when it comes to the issue of equal rights for gays and lesbians Julia Gillard might just be a bigot and she’s able to hide her bigotry behind party lines ?
loading...
I watched a lot of coverage in the lead up to the last election, where people in the street would say “I don’t trust her, because she doesn’t believe in God” – even Labor voters would say this, while acknowledging her Labor values and roots (all now betrayed, but that’s the by and now).
People actually think Atheists in Australia are secretly child-murdering cannibals. Forget mild rebukes to Christians, Atheists get it full barrel from the media.
So our brave PM has adopted the persona of “I may not believe in God, but I believe everything Catholics believe”. She thinks it’ll get her votes, when really the Christian Right are saying “Sweet, nothing will change until we can get Abbott in, then watch us get our agenda in”.
There is no way gay marriage will be approved under a Gillard PM. She isn’t actually a Labor politician, she’s a focus group politician.
There’s a great scene in the West Wing (the unachievable benchmark for left politics) where they discuss focus group results for a gun control measure… and please forgive me for posting it.
JOEY: It tested well nationwide.
JOSH: Yeah.
JOEY: 58%.
JOSH: I didn’t need nationwide. I needed those five districts. Now we’re gonna have to dial down the gun rhetoric in the Midwest.
JOEY: Why not dial it up?
JOSH: Because these numbers just told us that…
JOEY: You don’t know what these numbers just told you. I’m an expert. I don’t know what these numbers just told you.
JOSH: We know.
JOEY: Really?
JOSH: Numbers don’t lie.
JOEY: They lie all the time. They lie when 72% of Americans say they’re tired of a sex scandal, while all the while, newspaper circulation goes through the roof for anyone featuring the story. If you polled a hundred Donnas and asked them if they think we should go out, you’d get a high positive response. But, the poll wouldn’t tell you it’s because she likes you. And she’s knows it’s beginning to show and she needs to cover herself with misdirection.
JOSH: Believe me when I tell you that’s not true.
JOEY: You say that these numbers mean dial it down. I say they mean dial it up. You haven’t gotten through. There are people you haven’t persuaded yet. These numbers mean dial it up. Otherwise you’re like the French radical watching the crowd run by and saying “There go my people, I must find out where they are going so I can lead them.”
****
Just in case you missed it – Gillard is the French radical in this story. And those five districts are Queensland and Western Sydney.
I’m going to dial it up with my local MP. Equal love baby.
loading...
Perfect.
loading...
This country is absolutely NOT politically secular! The French may not be particularly tactful, respectful, or correct in their enforcement of secular ideals, but at least they practice what they preach (ie. secularism)! Mind you they don’t allow same sex marriage either, which is both ironic and hypocritical. The Australian Government shows it’s religious bias in a multitude of ways. What I can’t believe is that people are still talking about same sex marriage as though it is some weird, unnatural thing. Let’s just make it legal already and move on!
loading...
Correct. The constitution only prevents a test of office based on religion and prevents the parliament from nominating one religion as Australia’s state religion.
There is no mention of the separation of state and religion.
loading...
While there is no doubt that some religious leaders are vocally opposed to gay marriage, that is not the sole source of resistance to gay marriage. You only have to look at other demographics, such as some older people, some of the blokes in your local country pub, some outspoken AFL footballers to find that homophobia is not the exclusive domain of the religious.
I’m Christian and supportive of gay marriage. It may be more politically achievable to get civil unions established, and change the wording later. I think I’m quoting Mia, “when I grow up I want to get civilally unionized”, it should be called marriage in the end.
loading...
I agree, maybe the civil union is achievable, at first.
loading...
Another argument has been that if we get civil unions first – then there will be more of a push back saying.. ‘well you have civil unions – they’re no different.’
So all the progress made in the push for equal marriage laws over the last several years could end up being pushed back. Then we’ll have to fight even harder still to prove why having two distinct schemes is still not good enough.
My partner and myself have thought about using the ACT’s civil partnership scheme.. but it really does feel like a bit of a cop out. Don’t get me wrong, it’s better than nothing, and I’m proud of the ACT government for introducing it, but it’s not the same as marriage.
The laws will change, I just hope it’s sooner rather than later.
loading...
i am really at odds with julia gillard on this one. i just cannot get why people have an issue with this.
what are the libs saying? or is it just the greens that support this.
as others have said, i want all my children to have equal access to marriage if they want it. i don’t want their sexuality to determine their access.
another great piece by brendan. i heard you on triple j the other day too, i was most excited to put voice to writing.
loading...
I look forward to the day a future Prime Minister stands up in Parliament and says how embarrassed they are that there was a time in Australia’s history where two people, no matter what sex, who were in love could not marry due to irrelevant and outdated laws held up by backwards bigots.
loading...
I absolutely agree, Claudia. I really hope there will come a day when the Australian community acknowledges that it was nonsensical there was ever a time when the freedom of a person to express (and have acknowledged by others) their love for another person was determined by whether that other person was of the same sex or the opposite sex. I think we are getting there, but hopefully one day it will simply be accepted as fact.
loading...
Well said. It’s about time Australia embraced all Australians and had equal rights for all.
loading...
Bravo for Equal Love…
loading...
Great speech Brendan! When I was explaining to my kids what being gay meant I said to them “you know how Mummy and Daddy got married cause they were in love, and Dad is a boy and I am a girl? Well gay people are the same except boys who are gay want to marry other boys and girls want to marry other girls” My kids think love equals being married – I tried to keep it simple. Too bad our government isn’t as smart as my kids and doesn’t realise that being in love is enough of a reason to be getting married.
loading...
What a beautiful speach. I can only say I was overcome by the upmost apprication for Brendan and so greatful that we have people like him at the forground of our battle. Thank you
loading...
Honestly I would have thought by now gay marriage would be legal in Australia since the start of campaigning years ago.
It’s so overdue. You can’t pick and choose levels of equality, it should be across the board in all facets of life.
loading...
Bravo Brendan! It’s so fantastic to see so many young people willing to stand up and be out and proud about being gay and fighting not just for themselves but for our whole community!
The National Labor Conference will be held in Sydney on the 2nd to the 4th of December, 2011 and at this conference The Labor party will be voting on adopting marriage equality as party policy or not. Even if it is adopted as party policy the government is likely to call a conscience vote and if that happens every letter, every email, every conversation you can have with an individual politician between now and then will be so important.
Our daughter (Miss 5) wants to be a flower girl at our wedding, we are hoping that can happen next year on our 10th anniversary and with the help of people like Brendan there is hope it can happen.
loading...
Ok! So you just made me cry with the “Miss 5 want to be a flower girl at our wedding”
I too have a Miss (almost) 5 and if we wanted to get married (again!!) she would be front and center with Miss 2.5!
I hope all you girls get your wishes!!
It is just insane that for all we are the same, in this we are so different.
Fingers Crossed that those that can change it do.
XX oh and X for Miss 5!
loading...
She’s hoping to have two turns at flower girl as her Daddy and his partner want to get married too
loading...
Too beautiful!
loading...
Beautiful.
Well said.
loading...
I have two kids if one of them is gay, the other will have different rights and will be treated different. What a horrible possibility.
I really like the idea of ‘straight’ people saying they will not get married until gay people equal rights in this and other areas (superannuation). Wish I had thought of it.
loading...
I also love that idea! Brilliant.
loading...
That possibility is my mum’s reality, and while I’m hopeful that I’m going to be able to go to my brother’s wedding one day it’s hard to reconcile with the fact that while I could easily marry and have children without ‘love’ even coming into the equation, it’s not the same for him. But I won’t be giving up on dreams of parenthood and marriage for him.
loading...
“I really like the idea of ‘straight’ people saying they will not get married until gay people equal rights”
The marriage boycott idea has been around for a while, & I don’t want to rain on anybody’s rally, but I don’t think it would be effective. The only people likely to use it are “single-but-involved-heterosexual progressives”, who don’t make up a high percentage of the population. You’d be leaving marriage to the conservatives, which is probably how they want it.
I think it would be better to do something more active, some kind of direct campaigning which can involve everyone (hetero/not, married/not, etc) who is interested.
loading...
my heart swells with love at this speech about equal love. that’s what we need more of in this world – love.
loading...
Sensational speech. *Applauds*
loading...
Bravo, Brendan. Bravo. Two very enthusiastic thumbs up.
loading...
I totally agree. We teach our children to love, not to fight, we teach our children not to be racist, we teach our children to treat everyone as equal, we teach our children that bullying is bad…. so why is it that the the politicians and some one track minded bigots deny what is natural to EVERY human being….. to express their love in the highest form, to show the world and make it official to be married! This should be every person’s right whether they are hetrosexual, homosexual, bi-sexual, transexual etc.
Also we ALL deserve the right to be in a relationship or marriage and be recognised as that persons partner, husband, wife, defacto whatever sexual orientation. Lets all recognise equality for everyone!
Well said Brendan!
loading...
I wanted to stand up and cheer when I finished reading this.
Well said!
loading...
I read this as we were loading the post and maybe, maybe, got a little bit of face water. Says everything I’ve ever wanted to say on the subject.
loading...
It’s like I’ve been cutting onions in here. . .
loading...
Beautiful speech. I agree with every single word. I hope our politicians can get their act together soon, and look forward to when gay marriage is no longer an ‘issue’ or subject of debate.
loading...
As a teen that has been victimised for not identifying with just one sexual preference, this speech hit home for me especially; “When students threw rocks at you, when you were denied work, when you battled depression bought on because you were being told it was wrong to be who you were. When you lost friends because they didn’t win that fight. You were fighting for Equal Love.” I can’t put into words the amount of respect I have for Brendan, this speech, this movement and our fight for equal love. Thank you Brendan Maclean.
loading...
You deserve Equal Love Lilly, and I sure as hope this recognition for your generation, unlike other generations, won’t be far off. It must occur. I have a niece who’s coming out, she too is a teenager and has been bullied for who she’s perceived she isn’t. You do have MANY in the community who support you and love you for Who You Are.
I personally want to see an end to all these heinously base behaviours from those bigoted, narrow-minded little individuals out there – I too was bullied at school (yet for other reasons). Because I love my niece for Who She Is, I really want that authentic life for her that she so deserves.
Don’t give up girl!!!
loading...
Love is love. Go Brendan!
loading...
Damn Right Mate.
Freedom for all, it’s about time.
loading...
Excellent speech. Very moving as well. I agree with Amy: I would have been part of the hug riot.
loading...
If I was a hat person, I’d take my hat off to you. Had I been there, I probably would have incited a riot and run on stage and hugged you.
loading...
He / They / The whole movement has my support. And may I say what a brilliantly written speech. It had the perfect balance of reason and emotion. His parents should be so very proud that they raised such a child xx
loading...
Great speech. Spot on.
loading...
I agree 100% with this…what more can I say!
loading...