Do You Like This Story?

my mother ignored me 290x385 This is what makes a bad mother

 

 

Note: As with many articles about abuse, particularly those that include anecdotes, this may prove triggering for some.

People tell me that there is something about giving birth that makes a woman worried. Not about actually giving birth but about being a bad mother. I don’t have kids, but every woman I know who has been initiated into the ranks of Mummy tells me they worry.

If my child comes home with head lice, am I a Bad Mother? If I let my child sort out their own battles, am I a Bad Mother? What if I step in to level the playing field when  that kid from mother’s group is biting mine?

It’s really hard.

You worry. You worry so much about your kids. You just want to protect them, to see them grow into happy people. This is why I have always been puzzled as to why, when I told my mother that my father was sexually abusing me, she said I was lying.

It seemed so very…un-motherly.

And, if you ask me (and even if you don’t) it was an actual, real-life example, one of the few, of bad mothering. It took me five years to work up the courage to tell my mother what was going on, and then…nothing. No help. No acknowledgment. Just denial.

And instructions to stop giving my father attitude.

I was thirteen when I told my mother about the abuse.

I was fourteen when she found me screaming in my bedroom in the middle of the night with my drunk father in there.

It was then that she suggested we get counselling. Apparently, I refused. Funny that. I was a kid. I needed protection. Not counselling.

I’m thirty-five now, and I can safely say it’s only in the last year that I have really started to come to terms with what my father did.

And what my mother didn’t do.

In my teens and early twenties, I ran the gamut of child-sex abuse survivor behaviours: anorexia, binge drinking, inappropriate relationships, overeating, overspending. Anything I could do to avoid feeling. Anything I could do to punish my body for being so shameful.

If I had grown up somewhere other than South Africa, with its looming threat of HIV/AIDS, I suspect I’d have ended up as a sex worker, as so many abuse survivors do.

Fortunately, I still wanted to live enough that I avoided that particular one.

And then, thank God, I stumbled into a yoga class and found something that made me feel, for the first time in my life, safe. Like my body was under MY control, rather than someone else’s.

That kept me going, more-or-less intact, for the subsequent decade it took me to get strong enough to face my demons.

So folks, the head lice? They don’t make you a bad mother.

But if your kid tells you they are being sexually abused, believe them.

Believe them. It’s not the sort of thing kids make up.

Get them as far from the abuser as quickly as possible. Get the law involved. Make sure he or she can’t hurt any more kids.

And never, never, discount how traumatic the experience will have been for your child.

I’m a cynic, and I don’t believe that abuse can be stopped, because it happens in darkness and secrecy. But no child should have to grow up carrying the shame of a sick adult.

Teach your children about their rights to their bodies.

Teach them to speak up if they are uncomfortable, and if they say something, even if you think it’s not ‘real’, listen. Foster an environment where your children feel heard.

And if they tell you they were abused, believe them.

Otherwise , I’m afraid to say, you are a Bad Mother.

Please note if this post or any of the comments bring up any issues for you, or if you need to speak to someone please call the NSW Rape Crisis Centre on 1800 424 017.  It does not matter where about you live in Australia, they will take your call and, if need be, refer you to a service closer to home.

Nadine Fawell teaches yoga, drinks coffee and has a very good life, despite her childhood. You can find her yoga-ing and raising awareness at www.yogawithnadine.com

Comments

Comment Guidelines : Imagine you’re at a dinner party. Different opinions are welcome but keep it respectful or the host will show you the door. We have zero tolerance for any abuse of our writers, our editorial team or other commenters. So if you’re rude, mean-spirited, snarky, aggressive, defamatory or bitchy, your comment will be deleted (so will any replies to the original comment – so don’t bother arguing with rude people, instead just hit the ‘alert moderator’ button).
And if you’re offensive, you’ll be blacklisted and all your comments will go directly to spam. Remember what Fonzie was like? Cool. That’s how we’re going to be – cool. Have fun and thanks for adding to the conversation…

Use your profile to comment: Or, comment as a guest:
(Max file size is 150kb & jpeg's only - if you need help resizing go here »)

187 Comments so far

  1. Pingback: Does everyone deserve to be a parent – published on Mama Mia 4/5/12 « La Dolce Vita

  2. Faith @ Gracefulfitness

    My mother’s story is similar to yours; raped for years as a child by her mothers brother, denial by her mother, 30 years of repressed memories, coming to terms with her mother on her deathbed. My mom is an amazing mom to 5 children. I have my issues with her but when I am reminded of what she’s been through and dealt with I am blown away by her strength. Her mission as a mom was to stop the cycle of violence and abuse, as she suspects that her mother was also abused by a family member.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  3. Pingback: Barefoot on Frangipanis: an African childhood | Yoga with Nadine

  4. rima

    it took me 3 years to tell my parents what a relative was doing to me. my mum didnt believe me and my dad blamed me, coz i was apparently too clingy to him. i was verbally abused for hours because i refused to let him in the house while i was alone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  5. redqueen

    I got the same reaction from my mum when I told her what my step father had done to me: denial. The I found out he’d molested several other girls including my younger sister that’s went I went off the deep and made his worst nightmare come true. I picked up the phone and told everyone that my family knew exactly what he’d done. He was terrified of people finding out, fortunately for me he was such a despicable, hateful, horrible person that I was believed on the whole. Except for my mum she was in denial and just couldn’t face it.

    Both my sister and I cut her out of our lives and made it very clear that if she wished to have a relationship with us my step father had to go and she had to get counselling which she did. We now have a good relationship with her. My sister now has two girls and is a very good mum. I’m 47 and have never been in a relationship despite years of counselling and I never wanted kids. I hate men.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  6. Ezme

    Been there – six years of being beaten by my sneaky unemployed stepfather while my Mum was at work. When I finally told my Mum when I was 12 that no, I’m not the worst cyclist on earth, and that step dad was responsible, she just shut down. When she finally came around to believing me (thanks to my elderly relatives independently confronting her about it) she was torn apart by guilt. I don’t think our relationship ever fully healed from that.

    I, too, did the years of self-destructive soul searching. Came out OK, or at least, I think I’m OK. Really nice to hear someone tell a similar story. Feels nice to know that I’m not alone.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Oh, you are SO not alone! There are all of us here, and so many more who haven’t spoken up. So many. That’s both comforting and sad, I find. Thanks for reading, Ezme.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  7. Anonymous

    Thank you for sharing your story, and its good to hear you have found a way to gain control.
    I grew up in a hoem where physical and verbal abuse were an everyday occurence and police were present weekly.
    Our mother would throw us back at him if we stepped in to protect her and wash her hands of us..the worst being at 25 when protecting her the police came and said to her ‘either your husband leaves or your daughter and grandaughter’ Guess who my mother chose to leave?
    I have a relationship with my parents today we talk and they see my kids every week.
    The bitterness,hurt and anger is still there though it simmers and it doesnt take much for me to remember something which i push down and ignore.
    All i hope for now is that my kids say to me one day that i was a good mother

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      It’s all any of us hope for, really. That our kids will say we were good to them. It sounds like you had it rough, Anonymous. It’s hard to get out of that cycle, so hard.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Kit

        My sympathies for your trials as a young woman. I truly believe with your consciousness you will make an excellent mother and your children will thank you.
        I grew up with a narcissistic mother (actually she doesn’t deserve that term and I much prefer ‘womb donor’) who did not know how to mother. It made me sure of doing mothering well and with adult sons I am so proud of, the will made the way.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  8. Megan

    The fact that you’re able to talk about this openly on a blog is very admirable.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Thanks Megan :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  9. Anonymous

    This article gives me some strength for today, thankyou. I too found yoga and found it to provide me similar empowerment and sense of integration I was/am sorely missing. I continue however to run through the – although less – “gamut… of behaviours” unable to know how to sit with my experiences. I resonate deeply with the dual (but one) issue of having been victim of sexual/physical/emotional abuse (none of which sits in one coherent picture for me), and feeling effected too by the lack of protection issue. I am trying to be ok with where I am at with all this… some days are a bigger, seemingly endless struggle though… so again, I gather some strength from your article, a distant validation and comfort.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Sending you distance hugs. We all fall back into the behaviours from time to time. It’s a process – we don’t wake up one day perfect. Or, maybe we do, and it just hasn’t happened to me yet! I guess today and here will have to do. It helps me, too, to know there are other people out there who struggle with these tough things. We stand together, Anonymous xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  10. Anon

    My step dad abused me until I was 9. And thankfully died when I was 13. But years of threats kept me from telling my mother until 18-19. But I got another kick to the stomach. Her only comment was ‘I thought something like that was going on’. I can still remember that word for word to this day 20 years on.
    As an only child of a single mum I haven’t severed ties. But I am still bitter. She thinks we are best friends. She’s delusional. My saving grace is my wonderful husband who has suffered himself. He is my rock.
    Together we have 3 beautiful children who have been brought up to know that their bodies are their own and no matter what anybody ever says they can tell me anything and I will protect them. Never taught in a way to scare them or make them think about abuse. But just so they know I am here and will love them no matter what. That they are more important to me than anything.
    My mother may think I’ve forgiven her. I haven’t. I have just come to accept that she has always had low self esteem and sacrificed my innocence for a man who abused her and me. But somehow despite all this ugliness I came out alright. My self esteem isn’t always high but I remind myself to push it up there. I didn’t self destruct for which I am grateful. I can get stressed and angry but I am trying to cope. But then again a lot of mums are stressed. But I will never put my life ahead of my child’s innocence.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      You have a really good approach:I applaud your ability to maintain a relationship with your mother.

      It sounds to me like you are making sure the cycle ends with you by raising your children as you are! It’s such an empowered thing to do xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  11. Anonymous

    I am so sorry for what happened to you.

    I too know the feeling of a mother not protecting me. My father was an alcoholic verbally and physically abusive. On many occasions I begged my mother to leave him but she wouldn’t. It has taken me a long time to forgive my mother and I have a written list of things I will not do as a parent. Protecting your child should be the most important thing ever.

    Thanks for sharing your story.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      And thank YOU for sharing yours – together our voices become powerful.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  12. Its always there...

    So this is coming up again..just when I think I’ve successfully pushed memories to the back of my mind it comes up again…sometimes I think/pretend it never happened!! Sometimes I want to scream so loud!! Luckily my parents believed me when I told them but it was way too late by then (10 years later). My Mum was so heartbroken that she hadn’t protected me from her best friend’s son who was 8 years older (I was 10yo at the time). I am in a loving relationship and have two young boys. I was just so relieved to have boys – not that they are safe either these days – and I will protect them like a lioness protects her cubs. I am crying for all the other people that this has happened to…I want to be the best mother I can!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  13. Kathy

    It’s absolutely heartbreaking to read all these stories of abuse in this forum. The worst evil in my eyes is sexual abuse against young and vulnerable children.

    My hope and prayer for you all is that your life gets better and you find hope, healing and a future much brighter than your childhood. It’s good that you’ve all been so courageous and shared your stories.

    I also believe that you reap what you sow in life and that there is a special place in hell for those who commit these horrendous crimes against children.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  14. Megan

    I was molested by my 2 cousins between age 6 and age 12. one was 2 years older than me, and the other was 6 years older than me. Because we were such a close family with my aunt and uncle, I didn’t say anything to anyone. i acted out at school, etc. I was then raped again at 15, 18 and 21 where I had an abortion due to falling pregnant from the rape. It took until I was 28 where I could eventually sit down with my mom and tell her what happened. She kept on asking me why I didn’t tell her when I was younger. For me, it was that it was a secret and would break up the family and cause my mom grief if she knew. I didn’t want to do that to her. One of my cousins I wrote a letter to and he apologised. I didn’t need it but it was good he acknowledged it. The other one I don’t speak to. He has always changed the subject and avoids me. I am now 30 and just gotten married. I worry every day about how I’m going to protect my daughter (in the future, don’t have kids yet). It still causes issues with my husband when I don’t want sex but he’s wonderful and understanding. I just wish none of us had to go through this. I work now in the social work field with women who’ve been abused so the only thing I can say is it’s made me a strong person and able to empathise with my clients. I’m sending out a huge hug to every woman whose been hurt like this. You’re strong. You’ll survive.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Thank you for sharing your story Megan, and thank you for choosing to do something so positive with your experience! You rock! As to the not wanting sex, I am so glad that you realise you can say no. That’s pretty awesome. Hugs.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  15. Pingback: what is appropriate discipline? | the musings of monique

  16. Old chook

    A bad mother is someone who stands by and does nothing even knowing that these horrible things are happening.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  17. Lou

    Your story and all the others below have been on my mind since I read them yesterday. My heart goes out to all of you and I think you are all very strong people.
    Thank you for writing it and making me realise that I need to start the conversation with my child about child safety. These stories are important to get us as parents thinking about how we can best look after our children and prepare them for the future.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Lou, this is what I was hoping for when I wrote this! Yay!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  18. Guest

    I feel so sorry for those of you who were not believed when you finally conjured up the courage to tell your other parent.
    It’s as if the pain of believing it would be too much to bear, so they take the easy route and choose to turn a blind eye and not face the truth. How sad that is. I understand it would be painful to think this could happen and not have been aware of it. Especially if it is the very person you chose to create a family with. It is just so sickening, which is probably why they find it too hard to contemplate let alone believe. If only these parents have half the strength their children have had to come forward and face the reality.

    My heart goes out to all of you who have shared your story. I commend you.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Guest, I think you are completely right: I suspect that my mother is afraid that if she really looks at what she did, it will destroy her. Strangely, my father is probably further along the road to healing: he has made a public apology and conceded that if I, and other family members, choose not to have contact with him (which we do choose) then that is his consequence to bear. My mom is still calling herself a scapegoat.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  19. toradora

    i was sexually abused when i was in primary school by an older student my parents were told and my stepfather called me a slut and a whore and beat me till i passed out. i was 6 years old the biggest thing i remember from this day is screaming out to my mother who was standing in the doorway watching him beat me. i can remember the dress she was wearing, how she wore her hair. and now she say’s she doesnt remember. my stepfather beat me until i was 13 and my brother stood up to him. he used to force me to the ground and kiss me. i grew up being told i was a slut and a whore. tart was his favorite word. i wasnt alowed to have friends. my mother beat me to. she now says she doesnt remember. my brother was also sexually abused. and so was my youngest brother, all by different people. my mother has since (and this has been confirmed by numerous people) FALSELY accused her (deceased) father of assulting her. she slept in a room with her four sisters. her best friend practically lived there. and they all deny it. the thing is she declared this 3 weeks after i revealed to her (again) how i had been abused in the past and more recently. one year later she declared she had a mental disorder just 1 week after i had spoken to her about mine. my mother has always made herself the center of attention and she does this over and over. its as if she see’s my life views and hears my issues and decides they would better on her like a dress or something.
    so many things she did and just stood by and watched she now said ‘never happened’ or she ‘doesnt remember’ in my family everything is my fault. my brothers (two eldest) are despicable people that i want nothing to do with.
    i’m in disgrace at the moment because i didnt invite my mother to my wedding. she has never come to show support for anything else ive done in my life. but with this. she can get the attention.
    i just dont understand how she can take a big hand in destroying my life. continue to abuse me. encourage my brothers to mistreat me and yet she is still their golden girl. and i was the one in goverment care..
    and in disgrace

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Cait

      A ‘mother’ like that doesnt deserve to be part of your special day. You were so brave, and she was, and is a coward (from what you have said). Your wedding day is about you and your future husband, sharing it with the people that matter.

      Stand your ground and have a divine wedding :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Oh, honey. I think not inviting your mom was the best thing you could possibly have done. And the disgrace? Not yours. It never was. You are clean. And you are sovereign. You can choose now, who you have in your life, and you know what? The ones who hurt you don’t have to be there.

      Sending you hugs.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  20. Anon

    Nadine I am so sorry this happened to you.

    Unfourtunately this story hits close to home.

    My niece (daughter of my half sister) was sexually assulted by my sisters boyfriend (not her father). At first her mum believed her. She kicked him out of the house and they went to the police. Statements were taken and they even spoke to his other 3 kids. They even searched her house and found his unregistered weapons in the roof.

    After a period of 1 or 2 weeks he somehow made is way back into the house and before we knew it my sister was saying that she didnt believe her daughter.

    By this time the police had informed us that they coudnt press charges because the 2 or 3 times my niece had told them what happened some of the details had changed. She was around 11 at the time and was telling them about incidents that had happened many months even years before.

    The police had put in place an AVO which meant the man couldnt not be near my niece, but this meant becuase he was living in the house she couldnt be there. She was to stay with my mum (her grandmother) temporarily. She’s now 16 and still lives with my mum. From what we know my sister now lives 2 hours away and is engaged to that same man.

    My niece is angry and rebelious. She wont go to school, she wont get a job. My mum has saught any help she could get but nothing seems to work. Sometimes she loves her mum, other times she hates her. I wish she could understand the good thing my mum and our family have done for her.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Hi Anon

      I can see how difficult it must be for all of you, having helped this young woman out of a dreadful situation. And I wish I could give you advice, but it seems, no matter how much counselling we get, we get over these things, or learn to cope with them, at our own pace, and in our own ways. Some of us just never quite get it right. I would suggest yoga, of course! With a sympathetic, probably female teacher. It was my lifeline. Bless you all for taking her away from that home xoxo

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  21. Elsie

    Nadine, what a wonderful woman you are! I want to go to your yoga classes, have coffee with you – be your best friend! You’re a hero. I too was abused. And how many times do you read that in these comments? The prevalence is devastating and confronting. It’s hard to revisit – I’m (always) trying to move on, go forward… but I felt it might be important to share an aspect of my story – it was a neighbour and it was once – he came to the house when my mother was out and I was there alone. I tried to tell me mum as she was about to go out and leave me alone again – I was terrified. But I was a kid – I didn’t have the words to describe what had happened. Plus, I was ashamed and embarrassed. I said he ‘teased’ me. My mother didn’t believe me, challenged me in a too angry (un-motherly!) way, threatened to take me over to his house to get to the bottom of it… then went out anyway. I finally told her – again – ten years later when I was depressed and flunking my last year of high school… I’m in my 40s now, mother of a 4 year old. And the story, the conflict, with my mother, with myself continues… years of counselling. It never really goes away. It raises it’s head once in a while. And the thing is, my mother was abused by her stepfather. Her mother didn’t believe her. And this is why I too was terrified of being a bad mother… ‘do you just pass it on? Is it genetic?’ I find it very hard to trust, but also want my son to have a normal life, free from unnecessary fear. I agonise if he doesn’t want to go to kindy one day – ‘does it mean something’s happening there?’ In short, it’s really tough… but I have a supportive husband who is patient with my neurosis. Reading things like this help too. Thanks for sharing, and allowing me to share.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Elsie, I want to have coffee with you too! It sounds to me like you are doing great! And I commend you for continuing a relationship with your mother. I can’t, it’s just too hard for me to remain sovereign when I have dealings with her. You are not alone, and whether it was once or many times, it shouldn’t have happened. I believe you. I see you. Together we stand, and we create a new hope xo

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  22. Mamaoftwotreasures

    It is so late but it’s the first time I have wanted to post a reply in any forum.

    Thank you for being so incredibly brave to share this story.

    I too was abused along with my sisters by our father. He has not been in our lives for many years, nearly 20, I am now 41. My mother believed us but didn’t cope well and still doesn’t cope. She is consumed with guilt, sadly, as it was not her fault.

    I am now a mama of two beautiful souls and trust no one. The statistics are 1 in 4 children are sexually abused. Over the years I have armed my daughter with as much strength and confidence in herself as I possibly can and we talk very openly about our bodies and what is appropriate touch. I will take the same approach with my son when he is old enough to understand. It’s so difficult. My default is always one of non-trust with anyone and everyone in our lives.

    I have talked about it candidly to people in my life over the years as not talking about it allows it to continue so frequently and with devastating effects. I was lucky enough to stop the binge drinking long ago and found strength to heal and move on in my life but I have an ever watchful eye and always will.

    Thank you again for this post.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      This post made me sad for you, and also really for your Mum. It sounds like she wasn’t a bad mother, it sounds like when she found out what was going on she did the right thing by her daughters, but to carry guilt about failing to protect your children must be about the worst hangover in the world.

      Good luck to you and your little family, in finding peace and some joy and learning to trust slowly.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      You are doing the work for us, mama! Thank you for speaking up, speaking up, and educating your kids.

      It is sad about your mom, especially since she believed you: hopefully she will find a path to healing.

      And the trust thing? I so get that.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  23. Katrina

    Nadine, thank you for sharing your story.
    You are truly an inspiring woman.

    As the mother of a 4 month old daughter, I am grateful for the way you have put perspective on the way we define ourselves as a success or failure.

    You have made such a difference by your thoart provoking post, clearly evident by the discussion.

    I wish you well.

    Namaste x

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  24. Nic73

    I was abused by my brother. I told my mother, who believed me, but said I should “lock the bathroom door” as if it was my fault and responsibility. It has been a difficult relationship with her and know I do not speak to her as she has refused to acknowledge this part of our lives. She still speaks to, sees and has a “wonderful” relationship with my brother. Suffice to say, he and I don’t speak. It has made me a stronger person and a mother who will ALWAYS believe and protect her children.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anon for this one

      I wrote the post below you… the same thing happened to me- they put a lock on my bedroom door and it was my responsibility to lock it. It affected me for many years- that if I was abused in my room I felt it was my fault I didn’t lock the door, even at the young 10 years of age when I’d have fallen asleep on the couch and be put into bed. I am also with you as a mother… I have an amazing relationship with my daughter and would do anything for her. Hugs to you, from someone who understands xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  25. Anon for this one

    I was sexually abused for 10 years by my stepbrothers. After 4 years I told my Mum and the whole family went to see a psychologist. He apparently told my Mum that I would suffer too much guilt from breaking up the family if we left, so we stayed and had to work through it. So the abuse continued despite them promising my parents it had stopped. They started threatening that they would hurt my siblings, which kept me from saying anything else until I was old enough to leave home. Its only been in the last few years (I’m in my 30′s now) that I’ve become angry with my mother’s decision. On what planet is the guilt of breaking up a family (which would never have been my fault in the first place) worse than having to live with your abusers?

    I am a mother now, which I am forever grateful for. The injuries sustained as a result of my abuse meant it was incredibly unlikely for me to be able to conceive. It took 10 years. And now I have my beautiful daughter, there is no way I would ever choose a man over her safety… unlike my mother. Never.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  26. lealea

    These stories are just heartbreaking. I cant believe how many people have had to go through this, my heart goes out to all of you.

    I am the mother of a 4 year old and a 2 year old and abuse is my biggest fear, I will always believe them.

    My son’s kinder teacher is wonderful with the secret/surprise thing. Whenever mother’s/father’s day or a special event is coming up and they are making presents for us or preparing a little show, she always tells them to keep it as a surprise because “we never have secrets from our mummy and daddy”. I was so impressed and grateful the first time my son told me this when I asked him what he did at kinder today.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  27. Jessiegirl

    I am devastated by how many people share this story.

    I myself have not been abused; however, it didn’t skip my family. My sister was sexually abused for a few years from our next door neighbour (from ages 8-12) and only came forward and told our mum and dad becuase I got to an age (4) that I was able to go next door and ‘play’ with his daughters as well and she wanted to protect me. Something I didn’t find out about until I was about 18. I am forever grateful to her an also my parents who believed her INSTANTLY and were horrified that this had been happening, to my sister AND his own two daughters. They pressed charges and he was taken to court. A tramatic experience all round.

    Like I said – I am just so so sad that there are so many of these stories. Makes it hard to trust doesn’t it?

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      It does, but stories like yours make it easier to hope. How brave of your sister, and of your parents. Thanks for sharing!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  28. cos

    Not only would I believe my daughter if she told me I would also make it my duty to make sure the offender’s life became as miserable as possible.

    Normally I believe that ‘an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind’ – but when you mess with my kids in that way you’ve made an enemy for life. It is that black and white for me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  29. Anonymous

    My Mum wouldn’t speak to me until I ‘admitted’ I lied! I was 14 and thinking back now it probably started before I was old enough to truly ‘remember’ as such! :(
    I married a man that also suffered abuse from his father and it has taken us 8 years to have a child as we both thought we didn’t ‘deserve’ to be parents!
    We love being parents and we hope we are (& to be!) ‘good parents’ in aspects of the words!
    Thank you for ‘our’ story!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  30. jaybee

    This is the piece of writing that persuaded me never to use the word retarded, however lightheartedly. http://www.theredneckmommy.com/2010/03/05/why-you-shouldnt-use-the-r-word/

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  31. Bruce P

    At last its come to me…….”EVIL TRIUMPHS WHEN GOOD PARENTS DO NOTHING”…Edmund Burke

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  32. Not ready

    I feel like you just told my story. This has really shook me. But unfortunately I wasn’t as brave as you and didn’t tell a soul my father abused me until I was 30 and my brothers wife was due to give birth. I couldn’t stand the idea of any more babies being exposed to him. So I told my sisters and brother, then my mum. My siblings believe me and my sisters experienced incidents such as he would watch them use the toilet or shower to make sure they were doing it “right”, I was the only one that experienced molestation and in a way I am thankful they didn’t experience what I did. However despite being divorced (he would beat my mum) she doesn’t believe me. I feel beyond broken, and what’s worse is he claims I am a drug user and a counsellor has brain washed me, neither is true. But my mother a victim of his abuse also won’t open her eyes. I’m just thankful I have beautiful sisters and a brother to hold my hand through this.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      I believe you. I salute you for being so brave, and making sure your niece will be protected. I am so glad you have support as you move towards healing :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  33. Bruce P

    Nade’s it has been said and will part of your legacy, to fight back against the scourge of child abuse……its a war a cynic may not believe that can be won…..but you can’t win it if you don’t try…..I would like to continue in this vain of PARENTING…..drug/alcohol/sexual/physical/emotional and other abuse you can think of ….is a VERY REAL and PRESENT DANGER to all children…..with 2 sons and 1 daughter, its something that I keep an open forum and discussion with all my offspring about [ok not the 5 month old daughter], I do not lie to them, I do not pretend it will be fine, I can only guide and advise, but my real job is to listen, take heed and as the adult, bring in the relevant interventions [this is dependent on family dynamics]….the underlying MESSAGE Nadine…IS NEVER CLOSE YOUR EARS TO WHAT YOU CHILD IS TELLING YOU….and to always PROTECT your child the best of ones abilities…..OH yes, parents are not perfect, but strive to be……

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  34. Ally

    I told my mother about being sexually abused as child. It wasn’t until I was 16 that I worked up the courage to tell her about what my cousin had done. Her response was to cry, ask a few questions, not talk to me for a few days then not mention it again. It made me feel deeply ashamed and I haven’t told anyone since. My mum and I were never that close and she is very prudish and won’t discuss sex let alone anything awful like sexual abuse. I’m ok with it now but it still hurts that my mother let her 1950′s attitude get in the way of doing the right thing.
    I really hope that anyone who reads this will do the right thing if their child ever comes to them about being abused. I cannot tell you how hard it is to tell someone about it. How you treat them after they tell you is so important.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Anonymous

      i shared a similar story below but my heart breaks for you separate from my own pain. love to you xx

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Nadine Fawell

        Thank you both for joining your voices to mine. Together, we stand, and we become powerful, a wave of change. And that in itself is healing xo

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Ally

        Thanks Anon, I wish you nothing but love and support.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  35. tastebud

    Hi Nadine. Thank you for being so brave to share. It breaks my heart to imagine any child having to endure such pain from both their parents.

    I’m wondering how you navigate a relationship with your parents after such abuse. If you’re in contact with them. I struggle to understand how they could do this but also how you could ever get past it….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      tastebud, in my case, you don’t. My parents violate my boundaries too much.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  36. Mel

    I work with child and adult victims of child sex abuse, not as a counselor but as clients in the welfare field. Believe, believe, believe!!! From my expierence the child or adult abuse survivors has the best chance of dealing with what happened to them and to manage to keep on living if they have a safe place to discuss what happened and if they have the support.

    I believe it is around 70% of mothers whose child is sexually abused in the family home by a family member do not know. But I totally agree with you, you need to believe your child they don’t make this stuff up. From my experience children sometime test the water of disclosure by telling small parts of the story or to them the least scary or confronting part of the story.

    The best thing to do is get the child or adult professional help, like the Center Against Sexual Assault (CASA) in Victoria or a counsellor who specializes in working with survivors of sexual abuse.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      This is great info, Mel! Thanks for sharing!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  37. KateC

    My problem, by the time I was a teenager and ready to tell what my grandfather did to me, was that my relationship with my mother was good. Better in her eyes than mine, but when we were discussing a friend whose abuse was going to court she said to me “I’m so glad I know you’d tell me if that happened to you” . And the big reveal I’d been working up to was busted. I couldn’t do it to her. I think it was 4 more years before I finally did it. I decided it wasn’t MY secret to keep. I hadn’t done anything wrong. And I feel like you can’t really know me till you know this thing which played such a huge part in shaping me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Oh Kate, what a beautiful story. And I hear you – that thing, for the likes of us, is such a big part of who we become – and in some ways, a trigger for the awesomeness we find inside too, hey?

      Namaste sister.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  38. Charlie's Mama

    At first I thought this post was another one about “slapping your kids” (i.e: photo and title)! I wonder sometimes if posts on highly debated topics about motherhood get priority at Mamamia because they draw so many comments and activity to the site ;-)

    Anyhow…. a sad story indeed, and one that I have heard many times already which is an even worse thought. I think this opens up another debate though…. early sex ed. I know this would be contested by some people but I think it is never too early to teach a child about their own bodies (why ignore some functions of the body when they learn about others anyway). There is nothing wrong with a gradual but early approach to sex ed…. like making sure your small child (like a 4 year old) knows that certain parts of their bodies provoke funny sensations and that there is nothing wrong with that, teaching them that though it is not shameful, this part of their body is only for them to have access to… and that it is precious. At later ages, introducing new concepts about this part of their body…. as they grow and ask questions and develop their knowledge of the world (and themselves). As always, and like many have commented on this post, communication is the key and though kids need their privacy, they also need to be able to talk to their parents about ANYTHING without fear or shame. And for that to happen we need to be unconditionally open-minded, ready to sacrifice anything to save our child from a bad situation….

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  39. red shoes

    Nadine, you are very brave. I am so desperately sorry for the 13 year old girl that had to go through all of that, and have huge admiration for the woman you have become because of it.
    The foundations of my world are quite unsteady this evening. I am broken hearted and shell shocked at the amount of people that have gone through situations like these. It destroys me to think that there are people who believe this behaviour to be acceptable, and carry it out.
    I am actually really worn out from reading these stories and crying for the innocence and childhoods lost of many of you.
    Sometimes the world is just a dreadful, dreadful place…

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Charlie's Mama

      i’m with you there….. my boss had told me when i was prgnant that once you have children, you are like an open wound, suffering and injustice just bring you to tears all the time, especially anything to do with children. I thought i understood what he meant… that you could imagine those things happening to your children and thus they felt more real… but it’s way crazier than that lol! I think i come close to crying about 3 times a day just coming across news, articles, ads for charities and the occasional real sight of something sad.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Nadine Fawell

        It is an exhausting thing to read about/deal with, I know :(

        But I figure it’s actually a good thing that so many people are starting to talk about it, because that lifts the blanket of secrecy, and this stuff needs secrecy to continue.

        And never fear, my life is good now, I’m on a good road. There are flowers and coffee shops lining it!

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anonymous

        It’s like that for me to the point where I feel quite depressed. Child abuse stories in the newspaper, news websites, wherever. Children I see being treated badly out and about. It’s not that I worry about those things happening to my children, I just feel really bad for the children who are living with abuse. And I don’t think enough is being done. And I’m not sure what to do myself. Cash donations to charities just doesn’t seem like enough but I’m not sure what else I can do.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • Tania

          The only thing I can suggest is the starfish story – google it, it’s a great lesson – if you can help only one person then you’ve made a difference. Your help might be donating money to Smith Family or Barnados or UNICEF or it may be listening to a friend in need and acknowledging their pain. Or cooking a meal for someone that needs it. You don’t have to solve all child abuse yourself. We can however all do something small to make a difference.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  40. Bonnie

    Thanks for sharing Nadine. Every time my 6yo daughter tells me something – like she ate a cookie without asking – I say ‘Thanks for telling me. You know you can tell me anything’. I hope this stays with her as she gets older, how she can always talk to me and tell me anything and I’ll listen.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Hi Bonnie!

      I love what you are doing with your daughter – such a mindful way to raise her. You really can’t do any more!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  41. LLou

    An old friend was involved with a popular children’s show. Apparently, they had a child psychologist advising the writers and they were forbidden to include anything relating to ‘secret’. When my friend explained this to me, I realised that we had played ‘silly secrets’ when playing games with my daughter. I realised that by making her think of this as normal, she could be vulnerable to somebody who would do the wrong thing. Have always discouraged ‘secrets’ since! In this family, we don’t keep secrets!!!

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      It’s true: my mom taught me that keeping secrets meant you were honourable. It took a lot of therapy for me to realise that this was NOT true :)

      No secrets. A bit of embarrassment is much preferable ;)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Tulipgirl

      I don’t have kids so might be way out of line but I remember reading on a blog or forum that the writer had “surprises” in their family like birthday presents but no secrets. Made sense to me. That way the kid isn’t having to make a decision whether something is a good or bad secret.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • anona

        This is what ‘preventative parenting’ teaches… It’s OK to have surprises, as these will inevitably be revealed, (and sooner, rather than later)… it’s not OK to keep secrets, which have to be kept.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  42. michellewhite

    What a heart renching story….one of many. I have no words really except that no child should have to go through ANY sort of abuse… I have read comments further down about a book available through the NSW and no doubt other family planning websites; called ‘Everyone’s Got a Bottom’. I have also found this on the Huggies website- free postage if your order 2 or more books from their site.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Thanks Michelle! I will have a peek once I have read everyone’s comments :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  43. WillaWay

    So sorry that no one protected you or listened to you. It does make me boil that so many people suffer and then when they find the courage to seek help the would-be helpers turn away because it’s all too hard.

    Really glad you’re strong now and sharing your story. Those who turn away must have a hell of an ability to lie to themselves if they read your story and don’t know what they’ve done. I hope you keep saying it so anyone tempted to be a denier thinks again.

    Thanks for the story.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Thank you WillaWay

      That’s why I am speaking up, even though lots of people would prefer I didn’t.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  44. Lily

    Thank you for putting things in perspective. As a new mother, I have worried about the following things over the last couple of days: bringing my baby into the bed in the morning for an hour (thanks MamaMia and your coverage of that ad for that one), whether she might choke on a watermelon pip, whether I’m irresponsible for not enrolling in gymboree and first steps and baby yoga when all my friends seem to be with their bubs…

    Thanks for reminding me what really matters when it comes to caring for children.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Hi Lily!

      You are so welcome! And frankly, much as I adore yoga (and believe me, I do) I think it really doesn’t matter whether you do it or not. Sound like you are doing all the right things, right now :)

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  45. Guest

    About bad mothering, but not sexual abuse: This is timely for me. I have recently decided not to have children, despite wanting to, because with my mental health condition I know there will be times when I truly would be a bad mother. Lots of women with my condition have babies and most of the time are loving good mothers. But then they have periods of time when they are not, and later try to make up for it with extra loving and care. I don’t believe that makes up for it. A small percentage of women with my condition kill themselves or there baby after birth.

    I think some women are selfish, and see having a child as some god-given right. I consider it that I love my imagined child so much that the best thing I can do for them is not have them, as I cannot give them a good enough life and mother.

    Years ago women with certain disabilities, mental, physical, intellectual, were often told not to have children, and this went too far and included those who would be fine parents. Now it is taboo to tell a woman ‘you shouldn’t have a child, your condition would make you a not a fit parent’ and the pendulum has swung too far the other way. What happened to the rights of the child? Doctor’s shouldn’t play god, and it is ultimately the mother’s choice, it’s her life and body, but some hard-hitting advice wouldn’t go astray when Doctor’s discuss the children issue with someone.

    Bad mothering is out there, and it’s not about head lice or sending your kid to school with money for the canteen not a packed lunch. Next time you are worried about that sort of stuff and being a bad parent try imagining what it is like to weigh up the statistics of those women who kill their babies against your desire to have one. Or the fact that if you have children you may need to walk away from them abruptly for periods of time for your own sanity.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • JosieY

      I think you are so brave. I can’t imagine how heartbreaking that decision must have been. I hope I can be as brave as you when it counts.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Me Myself I

      I have a friend who made the decision not to have children because her own mother handed her and three siblings over to her dad and then left the country. She told them she didn’t really love them and they would be better off with their father. Dad was emotionally stunted as well and she had an appalling childhood. She doesnt want kids in case she might be like her Mum!!! It’s a shame as she is a lovely person and didn’t give herself a chance.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Anonymous

        My sister in law is the same. Her mother was abusive and her father not interested. She decided not to have children because she thinks she would not be a good enough mother. I think she would have been a wonderful mother.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • Darcy

      Bravo, Guest. What an incredibly mature – sad, but mature and thoughtful – decision you’ve made. I hope you’ve given yourself credit in this process and aren’t being overly hard on yourself. No doubt you’ll be a stellar aunt, friend, mentor etc to many generations of kids in your life.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • rachael1260

      Thanks for sharing. You sound truly wonderful and wise. There’s no right or wrong decision, is there? I’m sure you would make a success of it either way (with children or without). I wish you all the happiness in the world!!!!!!!!!!!! Children are not the be all and end all! They don’t make me happier. I’m still me and I still have to ‘choose’ to be happy.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Wow!

      What an interesting thread this one is: I know how you feel, Guest, because I am deeply ambivalent about having kids too.

      I think that you have come to this decision in suchs a conscious way. That’s awesome. And yes, I think sometimes we make the decision not to have kids from fear. But fear can serve a purpose: as a warning mechanism. So it has its place.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Guest

        Thanks for the words of support everyone. It has taken me three years of thinking and research to make the decision. I’m surprisingly at peace with it because it has been such a slow acceptance. I am looking forward to being a great Aunt (3 siblings, the numbers look good!) etc.

        What I’m not looking forward to is how to explain my childlessness. I have read on MM so much about how such women get treated badly sometimes. I don’t really want to say ‘I can’t’ because I don’t want to explain why, I don’t really want to say ‘I don’t want to’ because that’s not true either and I don’t want to seem anti-child or get into some argument over lifestyle choices. And finally I don’t want to be an object of pity as if I made the decision for my boyfriend, if it works out (who in a happy coincidence isn’t really interested in kids). I shouldn’t care about what people think but in all of those situations I come out looking bad for being childless. I’m considering just saying ‘I’m not having kids’ and then refusing to be drawn on the subject.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
      • Anon for this one

        Dear Guest, I think that your decision is a rare act of selflessness, when you acknowledge that your illness and becoming a mother are not compatible. I wish you all the best, I know a few amazing women in their 50′s and 60′s who decided not to have children and enjoy a wonderful life full of travel and adventure, they feel fulfilled and don’t regret a thing. Motherhood is not for everyone, and it shouldn’t be.

        On the other side… Nadine, I wanted to say- being abused does not mean that you will be an abusive mother. When I found out I was pregnant I was terrified that the abused would become the abuser… but I am an absolutely loving mother. I would do anything for her. The surprising part of my journey as a parent is that incidentally I have actually been able to heal by loving her the way I never was. I have been able to create the loving family for her that I never had, even as a single parent. And although that was never the reason for having a child… it brings me a lot of peace. Best wishes for whatever shape your family takes, children or not xx

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
        • archie

          As the daughter of an abusive father, I was terrified of becoming an abusive mother too. Our first child was an accident (a happy accident, like the discovery of penicillin, but an accident nonetheless) and the choice to become a mother was taken from my hands. However I have the found the process immensely healing. I am an excellent mum to both my daughters. And I have stopped blaming myself for being abused, because when I look at the innocent perfection of my two year old, I think “when I was that age, how the hell could it have been my fault?” I was no more than a baby. The blame rests soley on the shoulders of the abuser, and my unresponsive mother.

          GD Star Rating
          loading...
  46. backagain

    My friend was sexually abused by her three older brothers, for about a decade. She tried to tell her Mum many times and her Mum did not, would not believe her. Eventually my friend spoke to a nurse at school and the process of the abuse ending began. But her Mother resented her so much for bringing this shame and focus on the family unit.

    God, it’s caused her so much pain in her life, it’s a tragedy to watch and hear about – she is so brave, and so are you. So, so, so amazing and brave and resilient. Peace. xxx

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Peace to you too :)
      And to your amazing friend.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  47. Lauren

    Check out Bravehearts – an excellent organisation that fights against child sex abuse by doing school programs, amongst other things, that teach children of appropriate touch.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • aleced

      I was seated at a table with the woman who started this organisation (Hetty Johnson I think her name is) at a women in business event last year and she was amazing. She started the organisation after she found out that her daughter was abused by her grandfather and to hear her passion and the way she dealt with the fallout was absolutely amazing. She is such an inspirational woman!

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Nadine Fawell

        Great tip, you guys! Thank you. I hadn’t heard of Bravehearts before. This woman? Is what I wish my mom had been.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
  48. Connie

    Hi,
    Thank you for sharing your story. I wish you much happiness and joy.
    Yes, having your mother not believe you about such an important issue is bad mothering. No doubt.
    Your child getting headline isn’t bad mothering…..but not treating that headlice is bad mothering. There are issues in between that need to be tackled as well. Follow your heart and remember what it’s like to be a child.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  49. Anonymous

    My sister and I were abused by our stepbrother. When I finally worked up the courage to tell my mum she blamed herself. She took us straight to the Police station to make statements. We had to travel to the City (from a small town) to make a video statement. That was the scariest day of my life. Sitting in a room with a stranger, without my mum having to tell in detail everything he did to me. In the end there wasn’t enough evidence to charge him. I can not describe what it feels like to go through all that pain only for him to get away with it.

    As a teenager I rebelled. I cut myself, stopped eating, started drinking heavily at 15, slept with older men, took drugs and shoplifted. When I was 16 I tried to kill myself.

    The abuser now has 3 kids of his own. 2 girls and a boy. I don’t think his girlfriend was ever told of the abuse.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • femme

      Tell her.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Lou

        I agree.,, better that she has that information in order to be watchful.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...
    • zelicat

      please, please please tell her. even if it is an ‘anon’ letter. she might have fears she cannot recognize, cannot confirm… that ‘something is not quite right and I can’t put my finger on it feeling’. but remember you are not responsible for his or her actions afterwards. But if i was her, I would want to know.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • red shoes

      You need to tell her. You could very well stop a child or children from going through exactly what you had to.
      His children have been alone with him, other children have very likely stayed at their house….

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Speaking up is terrifying, I know. I feel for you, so much. But I do agree: if you can find the courage, tell her. At least she will know to be vigilant, and those kids may not have to go through what you did.

      I wish you love, hope, healing xo

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
    • Anon for this one

      I too was abused by my older stepbrothers, and the same as you I ended up drinking heavily, taking drugs and attempting suicide. In my mid 20′s, on the day I was in hospital recovering from surgery to correct some of the damage they had done to my reproductive system, my mother came in to tell me one of them (who had recently married) was expecting his first child with his wife. I had never met her but I got her number, called her and told her. Her flippant response was that she knew about the abuse but that it was “a long time ago, and he was very young” (he was 25 when it stopped!) and it would never happen again. I don’t regret saying what I did. I feel good about it. If it sparks the slightest alarm over future inappropriate behaviour… then I’ve done what I can. Tell her. You have no responsibility or reason to protect him, and every reason to try to protect a child who cannot protect him/herself.

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
  50. roserusso

    I’m so glad to hear that you are living a much better life now Nadine.

    I was sexually assaulted by my stepfather of the course of a year when I was 12. He didn’t rape me but it really made me very confused about my sexuality and how my relationships developed during my teens.

    I didn’t tell my mum until I was 16 and she’d already left him a year ago. She told me as soon as she knew that’s when she started planning our escape.

    I wouldn’t say she “saved” me as I stopped the abuse happening by never letting myself be around him on my own. Sometimes the abuse happened when my mum was in the kitchen cooking dinner.

    She got me away and we moved into our own townhouse with my younger sister. She asked me to tell her what happened all those years ago and I thank her for that because she tried to get me talking so I could put it behind me.

    To be honest I’m not completely over it even now that I’m almost 26 but I know that I won’t let it ruin my life. I won’t let HIM control my life… he abused my trust and he deserves nothing more from me.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • Nadine Fawell

      Beautiful, Rose!

      I don’t know if we ever ‘get over it’, but you know? We can be whole, wholesome, healthy anyway. I hope your relationship with your sexuality continues to heal: it sounds like you are totally on the right track xo

      GD Star Rating
      loading...