Meet Elizabeth. She’s 10 years old. She likes colouring, drawing and writing. Her favourite colour is pink and she loves chicken noodle soup and pizza.
Those boys sitting next to her? They’re her brothers. Brian (to the right) is 7 years old and he likes playing with cars. His favourite colour is red. Noah (to Elizabeth’s left) is four. He’s a talkative little boy who loves Batman, Superman and chicken fingers.
Adorable, huh?
There are other ways to identify these kids. Elizabeth is known as 82301628111. Brian is 82301628112 and Noah is 82301628113. Their collective number is S8230216870.
I assume they’re the numbers the state uses to keep track of the siblings who are “very bonded” and want to stay together – according to their profile on the US website, AdoptUSKids.
We found the website yesterday after journalist and author Caroline Overington tweeted this link:
The website is almost reminiscent of an online dating site. Or buying a house. Search for children by gender, and race. Select the number of children you’d like to take (up to 12) and their ages (0 to 21)
An open search yields 234 pages of results for children – some with siblings, some without – looking for homes.
Here are some examples:

Then there this video that also runs on the site. (Warning: after you watch this video you might want to jump on a plane and adopt all the kids. We were halfway to the airport before common sense prevailed)
In Australia the situation in different. We’re a lot less transparent about adoption, according to Dianne Harris, the CEO of National Adoption Awareness Week. Children would never be ‘advertised’ like they are in the US, and if they are it’s only when there are no other options available. If it is done – it’s discreet so kids aren’t recognised.
While she said it’s hard to compare two very different legal systems, she said there is a much greater focus on bringing families back together in Australia. Adoption is only an option when all other avenues have been exhausted.
But this is interesting. Over the past three years, Ms Harris adoption numbers in Australia have been decreasing by an average of 7 per cent per year. Between 2009 and 2010 there were 441 adoptions in Australia. In the last year there were 384 adoptions including 215 from overseas.
But inquiries into adoption are going up. “We’re aware of thousand of people willing and trying to adopt. So the numbers just don’t add up,” she said.
Louise Voigt, CEO and Welfare Director of Barnardos Austalia, says the number of adoptions is “woefully small in Australia compared to Britain and America.”
“This is a disgrace for children who need the security of loving families.” she said. “There are thousands of children in Australia who could benefit from adoption and many people who could provide the secure family life these children need.”
So, could you imagine this that kind of adoption ad in Australia? Probably not. We asked Caroline Overington (who has worked covering family court cases as a journalist for many years and has authored three best-selling fiction books based loosely on some of the tragic situations she’s witnessed) for her thoughts on the US website and how adoption processes differ in Australia. Here’s what she had to say:
Adoption has essentially been phased out in Australia – fewer than 400 children are adopted every year, and the bulk of these children come from overseas (that, too, is slowing to a trickle.)
Yet there are 32,000 children in State care, many of whom will never go home to their families.
There is no doubt that an anti-adoption ethos reigns at both the State and Federal level: the process is monstrously expensive (up to $50,000 per child) and a three-year wait, or even five-year wait is considered normal.
The government is terrified of creating another “stolen generation’’ so it makes adoption as hard as it can. It also forces children home to parents who do not want them, and cannot properly care for them.
Those children who absolutely can’t go home because their parents have beaten them up one too many times are forced into foster care, where they bounce around for years, never finding a place to call home.
I don’t think you’d find anyone advocating an RSVP style site, to advertise local children who need homes, but there is no question that adoption should, and must, be made easier for people.
The faces of the children on the US site tell the story: those kids are desperate for a home. It’s all they want, and yet we deny it to them.









Comments
132 Comments so far
loading...
The website in question is horrifying on a number of levels. Children’s identities should be protected firstly. As an adoptee I’m alarmed at the author’s attitude to adoption and many of the subsequent comments. All children have a right to know their parents, regardless of their circumstances. The assumption that children are (a) unwanted and (b) better off in ‘stable’ adopted homes is basically ignorant and incorrect. Separation from birth mothers has long term emotional consequences for most adoptees. It’s a very complex issue. Surprisingly, the statistics on mental illness among adopting parents is very high. The assumption that these children are better off is simply misguided. This website feels like a child trafficking operation. Who benefits financially from this??
loading...
Thank you for giving my lazy arse the kick it needed. For YEARS I’ve wanted to be a foster parent. I have adult children, one primary school child, years of experience, spare bedrooms and no more excuses.
loading...
those children are removed from caring homes where they are not beaten up i have witnessed this time and time again children belong with their mothers they take the kids and move them around shouldnt the kids have a say in where they want to be they have rights to be with their parents…..never ever interfere in mother nature life is life and there is no such thing as a perfect parent time for men to protect women and children like they were meant to in the first place…..
loading...
This is rubbish:
“The government is terrified of creating another “stolen generation’’ so it makes adoption as hard as it can.”
They don’t even care about the first stolen generation! I think it’s a case of the ‘too hard basket’ actually. No one is prepared to get off their butt and change all this red tape and reduce the $$ because there’s no votes in it. We need to change that.
loading...
I take offence to the following statement:
“Those children who absolutely can’t go home because their parents have beaten them up one too many times are forced into foster care, where they bounce around for years, never finding a place to call home.”
As someone closely linked to a foster family who has taken on foster children permanently, they are NOT always bounced around for years. A lot of these beautiful children are given a home for life by amazing foster parents. I have heard many good things about Caroline, but this rash statement of hers has made me consider whether any of her writings are actually backed up by fact rather than hearsay and emotion. It’s perpetuating the myth of foster families as awful, and if you’d met the foster families that I have, you’d know how inspirational they are and how sad this myth is.
loading...
Couldn’t agree more. Hear hear
loading...
Can I ask if Mamamia would be prepared to lobby this incredibly important issue?
It’s such a fit for the issue and we could all get on board to make noise about much needed changes in fostering and adoption.
I’m sure many of us would be happy to donate some time and our services/skills to help out. I certainly would.
Mia and team????
loading...
Having lived in the USA and worked with Oregon foster care system (there’s a novel in there), they have a great system (or at least they did ten years ago).
In Oregon, the birth family gets ONE YEAR to get their sh*t together – do parenting classes, drug rehab, regular visits/interest – whatever it is that the system deems they need to do. If they do not get it it together, or show very little desire or effort to get it together, the children are made available for adoption. And most foster families are foster/adopt families.
The state payments (not very much, but reasonable) made to foster parents continue to the adoptive parents (as well as State health care – a big deal in the USA) until the kid turns 18, which reduces the financial burden on adoptive families and encourages permanency. This amount is much higher if the child has special needs. Once the children are adopted, the courts and welfare system no longer have to case manage etc etc, which reduces the financial burden on the state system.
The Oregonians decided that to drag out placements and shunt kids from one foster family to another for years on end is incredibly damaging to children, and that one year in a child’s life is more than long enough for a child (and potential adoptive parents) to live with such uncertainly…
I say we aught to bring it on here, and while I don’t like the “online market” there’s no reason that such dossiers on available kids shouldn’t be available (on site at an agency) for foster parents looking to adopt.
http://www.oregon.gov/DHS/children/fosteradopt/
loading...
I work in paediatrics and we see so many children in terrible care arrangements. I cannot fathom the idea that a child is better off with a biological parent that sexually abuses them than with an adoptive family. I think if there are any convictions for sexual abuse then the child should be permanently removed from that parent.
loading...
Hi everyone,
I volunteer at NAAW and have enjoyed the discussion this article has provided. Adoption in Australia is very complex and with 15 million orphaned children in our world and 37,000 Australia children in foster-care (called out-of home care now) we as a country should be doing so much more for vulnerable children.
If a family restoration is possible we should do more to support it, but in the case of removal of the child or repeated abuse the child should have a permanent plan for their welfare.
We thank you all for your passion for children, every child deserves a family and at NAAW we focus on families for children every day.
Australian past practices were often poor and children’s needs were not addressed, that has thankfully changed but the legislation and process is far too slow and the child’s permanent care should be a priority.
We have many adult adoptees working with parents and young adoptees and would love some of the adoptees who posted here join us in ensuring adoption is not stigmatized in any way.
About 1 in 6 people are ‘touched by adoption’, that is, they have a close connection to someone who was adopted. Check out our website for resources regarding adoption in Australia
loading...
Can you advise what the adoption process costs around $50,000? That must be very prohibitive to many good families wanting to adopt.
loading...
Can you post the link to your organization?
loading...
what struck me in the video was the maturity, insight and pragmatism of these kids. I’d adopt the lot of them.
AND a reminder to everyone- see how these kids, who have been abused and neglected STILL want their parents? So, don’t torture yourself that your child will hate you if you impose boundaries. Do what you think is right.
loading...
At 44 I had my first child – a gorgeous son who brings us so much joy… fast forward 3 years and no propects of a second. Which while sad and has been frustrating has opened the door to look closer at fostering. can’t even contemplate adoption as I think (correct me if I am wrong) but I would be considered too old (even tho’ I can quite competently cope with our little chap). I didn’t always want kids but when I had one – WOW! Lots of work/not much sleep but WOW what a lot of love there is and I know I have heaps more to give. In a perfect world I would go like to go back to Africa (where hubby is from) and adopt an entire tribe of kids but where he is from adoption is very very difficult. Its a cultural way to keep the kids with their extended family (if their immediate family can’t cope) as much as possible. Anyway, great post and Jodi if you want help lobbying for change…
loading...
Any suggestions where to start? How can I help/lobby for change? As someone interested in social work this issue is heart breaking and eye opening!
loading...
Write to your local MP and say for you child welfare is a vote changer, that is you will vote for whichever party puts the most $ into child welfare. And try to get other people in your electorate to do the same. If everyone did that things would change very quickly. I believe the reason things are the way they are is because kids can’t vote and adults don’t care enough to change their vote based on which party is offering the most for children, they’d rather get tax cuts or whatever.
loading...
Check out Deborra-Lee Furness (Hugh Jackman’s wife), as she is one of the biggest lobbyers for adoptive change in Oz.
She used to have a website called Orphan Angels but it’s not working anymore?? I think she had an article on Mamamia once, and I’m wondering if Mia could help us find out the latest on her battle with Aussie ministers.
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2009-11-16/deborra-lee-furness-pushes-for-more-adoptions/1144566
loading...
What a shambles… we should all be ashamed these kids are lost on every level; as human beings we are all responsible for each other.. Wouldn’t it be nice if instead of all the jibber jabber some direction was actually taken to fix this system… I would adopt in a blink – not that easy…
loading...
Oh and for the same reasons swarms of women head overseas for donor eggs or surrogacy options… Australia, you may as well shut the door; you are soooooo behind the mark!
loading...
Wasnt Debra Lee Furness involved in trying to get our government to change their stringint ridiculous laws on adoption, does anyone know how she went??
loading...
She’s one of the most vocal campaigners of adoption in Australia and does a lot of work with Adoption Awareness Week. Just Google it – there are some great speeches and videos.
loading...
Not a lots changed. She’s still fighting the good fight.
loading...
I grew up believing that one day I would adopt a child. Somehow, as an American child raised in Australia, I was nevertheless far more aware of the US system as I was growing up, the system in which single people can adopt. A system in which – in some states, Queer couples can adopt. And I grew up reading books from the US that seemed, in the 80s, every teen “problem” novel was about adoption. (Was there an adopted character in the Babysitters Club? I’m (w)racking? my brains but can’t recall). I watched and read “Princess Kate” (which was Australian). I read Lois Lowry’s “Find a Stranger, Say Goodbye” – oh, now I remember, Claudia thought she was adopted, that was it!)
Anyway, it wasn’t until I was at university and realised how much more restrictive Australian law was than US law, which was probably around the same time that I was realising that I was never going to be (straight) married anyway. And it was, to be honest, a crushing blow.
I don’t know that I’ve always wanted kids, but I’ve wanted them for quite some time. Then there was the post about abortion on mamamia.com yesterday, and I’m completely pro-choice and would never want someone to feel pressured to bear a child they didn’t want to bear, and yet I couldn’t help but read all the comments from women who’d had terminations and think that if those pregnancies had been carried to term, they might have resulted in children able to be adopted. But of course, GF and I wouldn’t be ALLOWED to adopt, would we? So why do I care?
And then there was this post about adoption, bringing up all my recollections from the past. I remember the time when my mother and I were visiting a friend of hers in Kansas City who was single and considering adopting, and the fact that I always thought that would be a possibility for me. From not realising the massive restrictions that the Australian government place on such things, and that the US system in many places is far more open than here.
And so very much of it all comes back to wanting to be a mother – psychologically, not necessarily biologically, if that’s how it happens. But at the same time, I don’t know that I could cope with fostering. Not the way that fostering works here. With no ability to make any decisions at all for the children. With the likelihood that the kids will be sent back to their biological parents at the slightest “improvement” in the situation.
Every day at the library, I see the children of parents who can’t or won’t actually parent them. And it makes me sad and furious all at once. That there’s no issues about straight people having babies, babies they don’t want, or more babies than they can care for or care about, but there’s so many issues with queer folk looking after or adopting children.
And at the end of it all, I keep wishing that God had taken away my urge to mother and nurture and procreate when God decided to create me lesbian.
Because it gets tiring. It gets exhausting. And it gets infuriating.
And when – out of the blue – I get asked how far along am I, when not only am I not pregnant, I know that I’ll have to pay thousands of dollars for the privilege, with no chance of success, I’m left in a situation where, if I don’t laugh at the absurdity, I’ll cry at the eternal emptiness of my arms, wanting a child but unable to bear one, and not even being able to care for a child whose parents don’t care themselves.
loading...
In answer to your question, I’m quite sure Jesse, the African-American character who was a ballet dancer, in the Baby Sitters Club was adopted.
loading...
Jessie wasn’t adopted, but Kirsty’s (the tomboy-ish president of the club) family adopted a little girl from Vietnam called Emily Michelle.
loading...
In one of the books, Claudia thought she might be adopted, but it turned out that she wasn’t.
loading...
I can understand your frustration. I’m queer and I’m living in the US at the moment and it’s mind boggling how different the adoption rules are. Here in the US, in many states you can be straight or queer, single or in a relationship and you have the right to adopt a child. In one particular Australian state, I can’t remember which, parents who put up their kids for adoption can tick a box so that their child is not able to be adopted by a same-sex couple.
loading...
Hi Rebeck
I think there are no restrictions on same sex couples fostering and there is a big need for carers for children of all ages. Often, if you have cared for an infant, or a toddler, for a period, the fostering can become a long-term situation. It is still vulnerable to the parent coming back into the child’s life eventually, but there are fewer restrictions and the child is with you all of the time.
I know this does not fix the injustice of not being allowed to adopt and not being eligible for the same support heterosexual couples are given, but it is an avenue for you to care for children and really make a difference in their lives.
loading...
I understand your frustration at not being considered eligible to adopt … but I also support that rights of biological parents to opt out of particular adoptive arrangements. If they have religious beliefs, it would be a very real conflict of values to decide whether they should allow a couple of opposing values to raise their child. That conflict might cause them to not choose adoption, which might not be in the best interests of that child. Both parties need to be considered, imo.
loading...
Hi Rebeck. I know nothing about being gay so please excuse me if this question is out of line, but have you thought of engaging the services of a male friend for insemination? Maybe a male gay couple who would also like a child? Imagine having four parents!
I really feel for you and hope that one day your arms are full. x
loading...
fostering is pretty complex in Oz, but kids are either in temporary foster care, and the carers know this, whilst interventions are explored with their families, and only past that stage, if conditions stay detrimental, a choice IS made for permanent, until 18yr old orders in foster care. Obviously, full-time permanent placements are sought. These are rarely rarely altered during the course of a child’s life. Not impossible obviously, but if families do desire or pursue reunification, then there is the investigation and intervention process all over again … which will only be pursued if the child is assessed as capable, and/or willing to participate in it. Many kids are flourishing in foster care, and same sex couples are approved as any other family, as are singles and working couples, grandparents, or aged long term carers. Please consider it. Maybe, go to some information sessions with your state’s foster agencies, and definitely go to the trauma information sessions, as the insight of attachment parenting/caring will truly create a bond that not even parental reunifcation will break. As someone who shares custody of her own children with a violent ex partner, attachment parenting is the only way to bond with an abused child, it means no matter the level of insecurity felt elsewhere, that child always has a home in somebody’s heart. That last little boy on that ad, broke my heart … he does exactly what foster kids do … they test how committed the adults in their lives are, until they realise somebody will stick around and ultimately care unconditionally … then … yay … they can feel love … and reciprocate it. blessings. xxx
loading...
Gays and Lesbians are permitted to adopt in WA. A gay couple successfully adopted a locally-born child around 2007. Most inter country programs exclude same-sex couples but the local adoption is open to same-sex couples.
loading...
i agree with so many of your points. the US system is far better.
I find it bizarre that we consider single parents and gay parents fine as foster families (coz we’re so desperate!!?!) but we won’t allow these same excellent parents to offer a permanent home to a child(ren) in need.
loading...
So true about the powers that be being afraid of developing a new stolen generation, but I cant help but wonder if these children being sent back to parents who dont want them from loving foster homes will maybe grow up and sue (sp?) the governement for TAKING them out of a loving home and sending them back to be abused, neglected and putting them at risk. They could quite rightly argue that DOCS has a duty of care to ensure their safety and sending them back to parents who have had upteen chances and still keep doing the wrong thing with not ensuring their safety. I am quite passionate about this as I used to be a paeds nurse and used to see so many children come into hospital with wounds, fractures and broken bones on their little malnourished bodies, the “parents” would never stay with them or if they did had a whole tribe of children running around the ward disrupting sick patients so sometimes easier they left, but then the child was there all day by themselves. Tell me are these children better off with parents like this after they have had sometimes 10 chances to prove to be fit parents? I think not and in my opinion these children have been failed by a governement to gutless to stand up and say enough is enough, these children deserve more.
loading...
I agree with your comments for the most part, but when you include children forcibly taken from I unmarried/young mothers, I just have to say that these mothers were never given the chance to decide for themselves whether motherhood was really for them… I’m sure some may have eventually decided to give up their children on their own, but that does not warrant or excuse stealing babies from their vulnerable mothers. The idea of it is simply inhumane and I imagine truly traumatic for all involved. My own mother was taken from her 16 year old birth mother in this way. Now that she knows the full story, she is grateful that she did not grow up in her birth mother’s home – she would have been exposed to abuse and domestic violence at the hands of her mother’s subsequent partner. However, she believes that being treated in this way scarred her birth mother for life and made it incredibly difficult for her to form healthy relationships with people, including my mum, who met her at the age of 36. I think there’s a huge difference between stealing children and voluntarily surrendering them for adoption, and this needs to be acknowledged.
loading...
I am so flipping sick of reading about these existential crises apparently brought about by adoption (I’m looking at you, my co-adoptees). Get over it, already! You’re as you as you would be anywhere, it doesn’t matter if blood running through your veins matches that of the family around you. You end up doing more harm than good, carping on about such ridiculousness.
Life is never perfect, no matter what side of the fence you are on – with folk to whom you’re genetically tied, or with folk who just happen to be family. Loving, caring, nuturing surroundings are what matter, either way.
loading...
I think you have a great, positive attitude. Where you came from is not who you are. I think we should be prouder of what we do with our life, how we treat others etc, than how we look. We have much more control over the former!
loading...
I’m glad everything has worked our perfectly for you in your adoption.
This is not the case for everyone. For some of us it does matter that we grew up without our complete identity. Just because someone chooses to adopt rather than give birth does not automatically make them perfect parents.
loading...
Thanks Borogirl for some balance.
No one wants to hear about kids who didn’t have a great time being adopted. Seems to me its always about what the “adults” want and get. Supply and demand, kids as commodities. Sorry I’m cynical but
this rosy picture of all these people who have love to give… Why don’t they foster and/or adopt disabled children. Some do. the real ones.
loading...
Agree about the silly importance placed on blood ties. I have seen my mother become alienated by her own brother and sister over a will and at the same time my own sister (not blood-related) is my whole world.
loading...
Pretty harsh Nicole. Lot of lives have been completely wrecked by adoption. Yours might have gone OK but what about the people who have been abused by their adoptive parents? And what about those that aren’t strong enough to cope with life as an adoptee. In a perfect world everyone would be as tough as you and just soldier on but that’s not possible for everyone. Have some compassion.
loading...
There are very good reasons why adoptions are so low in Australia. Adoption should always be the last resort. Adoptees shouldn’t be cast in a pitied/saviour complex by riched up celebrities.
loading...
Sorry Anon but trying to fix the broken lives of children in situations of neglect, abuse etc. should not be the first thing to happen, when are our politicians and bureaucrats and the “do gooders” going to realise that once the damage is done it is terribly hard to fix.
I would agree that the rich celebrities are not helping the cause however they are the only ones who have the resources to adopt because of the cost involved, if it didn’t cost then more kids would have loving homes and the celebrities would not receive the publicity they do.
loading...
Adoption should NOT be a last resort! I can’t even think where I would be if I hadn’t been adopted. With so many children out there wanting a family and a home, it should be the first option and the people having their own babies should be the last resort.
We all know the importance of having a stable, loving home. What will happen to all these children as they get older? Will they have the support of a mother and father? Will they be able to support themselves?
People can get pregnant without so much as a blink of an eye from the government. Yet adoption is being strangled to death by so many laws and regulations. Yes there is a need for regulation but where is the regulation for people who don’t want their children but have them anyway? What is the reason behind sending children back to their abusive, unloving parents when there are plenty of people who would love and care for a child but can’t have any?
I also don’t think celebrities can be blamed for anything in regards to adoption. We cannot blame them for the cost of adoption. We can’t blame them for having the money to do it. And good on them for adopting, I support anyone who chooses to adopt. Deborah Lee-Furness is famous and adopted two children. Would you also suggest that she is a part of the problem?
loading...
Interestingly the Australian Gov has made it almost impossible to go to the US and adopt these kids. I’m pretty sure it is actually a crime to go and reside in the States for a short time just for the purposes of adopting. If it were all about wanting to preserve a childs culture then why would you put barriers in place to stop the adoption of American kids?!?!?!
Our governments, state and federal, are anti-adoption and what they still don’t realise is that their actions with respect to denying foster children adoption = child abuse. On a completely shallow level if they allowed more of us to adopt foster kids they would save themselves a small fortune in carer’s payments etc etc
loading...
Kudos, then, to DCP WA who sent my husband and I a letter last week asking us to consider fostering a child under their ‘A Home For Life’ (I think that was the name of it) program. As we were screened and approved for adoption in the past (we have a 3 year old adopted son) our file could be reassessed for long-term fostering more easily as they had all our details to hand. The focus was clearly on children that needed long term homes, until they were 18 and beyond.
The adoptions in Australia are, indeed, shrinking in number but demand for fostering continues to rise. We aren’t in a position to consider this, for now, but it’s something we intend to revisit down the track.
loading...
My wife and I foster a beautiful little girl, her mother is a drug addict and totally in capable of caring for her children, whilst I accept that the ideal situation might be to have her grow up in a “normal” family situation, that is not possible and I hope that we can provide her with the best possible loving family relationship she is able to get.
Why is adoption so low in this country, it is because of the system, and our experience is that it should not be that difficult to adopt, however our past history of poor government intervention has led to the reverse now.
Some people just should not be left to care for children and no amount of government intervention will ever change that.
I haven’t looked at the US site and will not because I know that it will make me sad that kids need to be advertised in this way.
We are all responsible for the children and we need to protect and nurture them.
loading...
Unable to have children ourselves, we explored adoption only to find it too prohibitive, expensive and with too many conditions and restrictions ( not to mention the waiting periods). Knowing that we could provide a loving & stable home we became foster carers.
We too have experienced the frustrations of watching the ongoing damage some of these parents have on these poor kids. It seems to us that the system has swung too far back in the wrong direction. We now have a system where these parents seem to have all the rights and no responsibility. These children have been removed from parental care for a reason and whilst we recognize that familial contact is important, there comes a point where in some cases it is obvious that such contact causes more harm than good and that reunification is not going to be possible.Foster carers as a whole are doing their absolute best to bring some normality and stability to these children’s lives only to be hampered by trying to undo the damage done by this contact and an ineffectual dept. who are often too under-resourced and under- funded to be truly fulfilling their duty of care to these children. Is it any wonder that the system is losing carers and caseworkers hand over fist. The average burnout rate for caseworkers is 6 months!!!!! When will our state and federal govts.realise that funding and priority needs to be given to the depts. that are responsible for these vulnerable little people??. Maybe then, intervention will occur earlier, damage minimised, opportunities for reunification increased and maybe even some little lives saved.
Now that I’ve vented my spleen ( sorry, but I get very passionate about these kids and sometimes a girl just needs to get it off her chest!), I would like to take up one more moment of your time to say that fostering is a very rewarding and humbling experience. If you have the space in your hearts and in your home please give it some consideration.
xxx
loading...
Go Gidget Girl !!!!.
Your passion for these vunerable members of our community is to be applauded, my wife and I feel the same way. The only thing I would add to your comment is that some of the damage is done before birth as we have experienced. We cared for our little girls brother initially and he has issues which can almost certainly be attributed to his mothers excessive substance abuse whilst pregnant. We need to do something to stop this from happening as well. As an example of the stupidity of this system this little boy was subjected to 3 years of trauma and neglect after being reported to docs the day after his birth, this sort of thing has to stop. We have met the childrens’ mother and whilst she is not a bad person she is in the grip of drugs and really would not have had a clue how to care for children as despite her age she really only has the insight of a child into what they need.
We have closed our door to caring for more children as we do not trust docs to be truthful when placing children nor supportive once placed. Whilst some of the caseworkers we have dealt with have been supportive and great the system in which they work is fundamentally flawed. It needs fixing so that it encourages more people to become involved in caring and those that are carers are properly supported, because the children need this and soon.
loading...
I have such admiration for foster carers and people that adopt children. I loved the comment from Cordeline about her in-laws adopting three siblings. Gorgeous story. It is so heartbreaking to read the difficulties people have gone through to adopt or even to foster in this country. It’s very sad. Such as the heartbreaking story that Punkie told about. Thanks everyone for yet another great mamamia discussion.
loading...
The adoption system in Australia needs to change, I think it should just be easier and less restrictive. There are so many children who need loving homes, and so many good couples wanting to welcome them into their families! So ridiculous.
loading...
Can we have an article on adoption without people turning it into an anti-ivf debate?
I am adopted. There are both good and bad things to this and whilst I would never deny anyone else the right to adopt, I personally never would – knowing the identity issues that I have had growing up in my own country/culture. I can only imagine what it would be like growing up in a completely different country/culture. I personally try to contribute to children so that they can stay in their own environment and donate to charities that make contraception readily available to women.
I have had fertility issues in the past and now have my son thanks to IVF. For me it is a miracle but it was never an either/or decision. If I hadn’t been able to turn to IVF then I would’ve had to just spoil my nephew and friends’ kids that little bit more – I never would’ve adopted. I wanted a child that was part of me and whilst that makes me selfish, well, it does but life isn’t a dress rehearsal so I’m here to live the best life I can and for some people it may not make a difference – for me as an adopted person I know that having 1 birthmother + 1 adopted mother does not make for 1 whole mother.
It also makes me sad that these things always turn into an attack on fertility treatments as if those who have fertility issues must carry the burden of those who have the opposite problem. We should make things easier for those that do want to adopt but not attack those that seek other avenues to make a family.
loading...
While I understand your experiences were a little different to mine, it really grates me that you said you wanted a child that was ‘a part of you’. I am every bit a part of my mum and dad and they are every bit a part of me. No blood tie would make that stronger.
For me, I only have one mother: the woman who raised me. I have one home: Australia. My parents tried really hard to keep our Korean culture but my sister and I weren’t interested. In our eyes, we were Australian with a little bit of German thrown into the mix.
loading...
I am genuinely pleased that your experience is different to mine and as I said we should make it easier to adopt/foster the kids out there that need it.
I can only speak of my experience – having my son really bought that home for me. Maybe it is a failing on my part, maybe on my parents, maybe on the fact that there was no support structure around at the time that I really needed it (during my teens) but it wasn’t a good time and although it is a much smaller part of me then it was during my teens and my “searching years” (in my early twenties) it is something that I think I will carry with me forever.
loading...
First of all, I WANT THOSE KIDS! My heart is breaking, I wish I could take them all home.
I have some experience with the foster system and I’m telling you it is broken. I really really wish the kids who are in foster care for THEIR WHOLE CHILDHOOD waiting for parents who don’t or can’t care about or for them could go to a forever home – I know that the government wants to keep these families with their parents but when will we draw a line and see that it’s not working?
God be with all those kids – I just wish I could.
loading...
My husband and i dont have fertility problems, we have a 4 year old and i am pregnant with our second child….we have pregnancy issues though. and when is say issues i mean, i suck at being pregnant! I am unwell, i have physical problems and the pain is so bad that i cannot work or walk and crying in pain at night is one of my regular activities! I have been on crutches since 17 weeks and today i found out i have gestational diabetes! I know that i am extremely lucky to be a woman that can actually fall pregnant, and although every day is the hardest time i have been through, My body cant do it again! and i would love to have 2 more kids! My husband and i have always talked about adoption and would love to adopt. But when we looked into it the amount of money that you need to spend and have is simply ridiculous! A crack head can have a baby and the government will support them, yet when a couple who maybe cant have babies or a family like ours that can have babies but we just want to adopt cant adopt due to the governement being ‘scared’ there is seriously something wrong with that!
I think people in Australia actually do want to adopt…i think the government has just made it way to hard to do it! I have room in my heart and my home for more children no matter where they come from, but apparently my bank balance is not big enough! My husband and i own a business and we are comfortable, we are not loaded, but we are more than ok to raise more children!
loading...
Isn’t remarkable, I got hounded last week because I made a comment that not all mothers have the ‘right’ to be mothers. So many awful situations out there for desperate kids, but the government keeps giving these beautiful kids back to awful parents instead of giving them to awaiting, loving adoptive parents. What can we do to change the cycle and give these children a chance???
loading...
You are absolutely right. We need to be extremely careful for all children, they must be safe, loved, cared for. And when they’re not, they must be taken away and good loving homes found for them. We are falling down is these areas so badly and the children are the ones suffering.
loading...
My sister and her husband have a natural daughter and were looking to adopt a child a couple of years ago. They looked overseas and also here. The process seemed very bureaucratic and overwhelming – yes I know the checks have to be thorough to ensure children were matched with suitable parents but from my understanding it was an extremely difficult process. One of the knockout points was that my sister is non-religious and her husband is Jewish. So sad as they are fantastic parents, have strong extended families, they are involved members of their community and are financially secure. They could have given a child such a loving home and great opportunities. In the end the adoption agency lost their original application and to reapply they basically had to start again at the end of the queue. This cost them so much time and it all became too hard.
loading...
Dont you find it ironic that social services do so many checks to make sure the kids are matched with suitable parents but on the other hand keep sending them back with mothers and step-fathers/boyfriends who have no genetic link to the child but are often abusers ?? Why does the stepfather deserve a second chance but a loving willing couple dont even get a first chance??
loading...
We were having fertility issues, so we enquired about adoption. I only got as far as getting all the information sent out to me. When I did further research into exactly how long it would take and the cost, I realised we were better off putting our money into doing IVF.
We now have two beautiful daughters which I feel so blessed by and obviously wouldn’t change for the world. However I still can’t help but think how things might have been different had the adoption process not been so daunting.
I will never understand why they have to make it so hard when there are so many kids in need!
loading...
The Australian child protection, fostering and adoption system is a joke. My mother used to work in the field dealing with wards of the state, coming home each morning/night tearing her hair out with frustration. The department is a shambles.
loading...
A beautiful, kind and loving friend became a foster parent after she and her husband could not have children of their own. She became a carer to a lovely little girl, who had witnessed her father murdering her mother. He had also physically abused his little girl. The little girl did not talk due to the trauma and understandably had significant behaviourial issues. At the age of 7 she had been in about 6 different homes over 2 years. By the time my friend became her carer this little girl was indeed a very difficult, uncommunicative child. But my friend loved her. She played games with her, she included her in every aspect of her life, she treated her with respect, compassion, dignity and love. When I would visit I would slowly see a change in the little girl. After about 18 months, my friend finally had broken down one seemingly insurmountable obstacle, gained the little girl’s trust and she started speaking for the first time in about 5 years. The little girl adored my friend and she was starting to feel loved and secure in a beautiful family. Thanks to the tireless patience of my friend’s husband, the little girl was also becoming less fearful of men. It was looking to become a dream come true for all 3. This little girl’s father was in prison for a life sentence. So one day, my friend contacted the authorities about asking to adopt her “little angel”. An officer was sent out the next day. By the end of the week they had removed the little girl from my friend’s care and forbidden her to see her again. The reason…they had become too attached and should the father ever succeed in gaining parole then it would be too difficult to reunite father and daughter. They thanked her for all the work she had done and left her sitting broken hearted. Four years later we got news that the little girl had committed suicide after failing to find a suitable carer – she was a street kid by 12 and took a drug overdose. My friend? She was so distraught when they took her away she had a breakdown – when she heard the news about her “little angel” she never recovered.
loading...
And that, right there, is the reason I wouldn’t adopt in this country until laws are changed. I have heard many examples of this happening – a baby bonds with a foster carer, they both love and adore one another…the toddler is taken back to a parent that has just got out of jail and gets to have another chance. What happens to the love that the carer and child shared? What happens to those foundations that were laid down?
loading...
That is such a tragic story. The poor little girl was so let down by the “system” as we’re her foster parents. So sad.
loading...
Horrific….
loading...
That story is so sad, and such a disgrace. The priorities of those in ‘the system’ are completely warped. How can anyone with a functioning brain think that the removal of that child was in her best interests? Surely if there was ever a situation where a biological parent shouldn’t get a second chance, that was it?
Makes me so upset and angry, and also reluctant to be a foster carer.
loading...
That is just the saddest story i have heard! It also makes me so mad! Your friend is a great person and i am so sorry this had to happen to her and to the little girl when it could have been such a happy end to the story! it amazes me the rights of the murderous father were put before the innocent child! The government should have revoked his rights as a parent the minute he murdered the childs mother! Im so sorry this happened to everyone involved!
loading...
No. Oh no. Oh God. Why? How can this happen in Australia today? I don’t understand.
loading...
It is even sadder when you consider that story is not a rare occurrence. Our friends had a foster child who was a ward of the state, his early childhood was a nightmare of abuse perpetrated by his mother and her various clients: physical, psychological and sexual. Despite being made a ward of the court he was made to visit his mother when she straightened up enough to demand access to her son. They even talked of returning him to her. The loving family he was placed into was given almost no support in dealing with his psychological and emotional problems.
My partner and I would love to have more children and have often thought about fostering but every time we think about it seriously we hear yet another horrendous account of what the foster system does to children and carers. We couldn’t be party to torturing a child who has already been tortured by their natural parents and the system.
loading...
Such a sad sad story
loading...
This is heartbreaking and so very disgraceful that a ‘system’ caused this pain and loss. Your friend and her husband must be wonderful people to have built this child’s trust and confidence. The fact that this was lost and what had become a family was broken makes me so angry.
I can’t behind to imagine the pain of this but thank you for sharing their story. It is only through knowing about these things that anyone can ever hope the situation may change.
I don’t know how I feel about children being advertised as occurs in the US, butni do believe everything should be done with the child’s best interests at
the top priority. I am so sorry for your friend and her little angel.
loading...
OMG, that is horrendous! I have NEVER understood the reasoning about taking children away when they get “too close” to their foster carers. WHO THE HELL makes these decisions??? Where are the psychologists to say that ripping kids away from a settled, secure and loving family situation is doing even MORE damage?? And how on earth would a child ever be reunited with a father who murdered her mother in front of her? How??? How could he even be considered a suitable parent or guardian? Insanity.
loading...
Unbelievable!!!! What state was this?! How could they be allowed to do this?!
Your poor friend. How incredibly tragic for the couple and the child. It just doesn’t seem possible that this could happen but it obviously does.
loading...
I can’t wait to adopt! I’ve always intended to adopt once I finish my PhD and have a stable income and home, and it terrifies and distresses me that the process in Australia is so complicated and expensive. It looks like I’ve got a lot to (not) look forward to. Everything I hear about it just makes me more and more concerned that I’ll spend years going through a difficult and upsetting system before I can have children. People like Deborah-Lee Furness have been campaigning on this issue for years. I can’t believe we are so behind on something so fundamentally important.
loading...
1 year approval process (understandable) 5 years & still waiting…
loading...
We have one child and would happily adopt, we can find the resources for another child easily, but I am 40 now and can see it would not work age wise. With 6 billion people in the world and counting, there needs to be a lot more adoption options open..I know having children naturally is put on a pedestal in Australia, but It is not that special considering how many humans are being made every year…I would say its out of control globally. What would be much more special is a great culture of adopting and fostering children who need it, I think it takes a lot more effort and god knows there are enough people having babies who aren’t that interested…adoptive/foster parents are motivated parents.
loading...
In Australia we put WAY too much emphasis on “bringing families back together” when there are very good reasons they are apart to start with!!!
It is truly time we started to look at the rights, needs and wants of the kids in foster, why they are there in the first place and stop pandering to pathetic excuses of parents who see these kids as welfare income, not the treasured lives they should be.
Adoption is so difficult in Australia and the biological parents are still given too many rights. its time to change the laws and move into the 21 century!!
May the children in these ads find the loving, nurturing families they deserve.
loading...
fully agree, i have taught students who were in foster care, who were bounced from their “mother ” taken away for problems into a good foster home and then back to mum when she showed some change in her life.
then i have a son who had a very good job, loving home and wanted to adopt, nope too old at 29!!!!
loading...
Too old at 29?? Was that really the only reason? I’m 26 and wasn’t planning to adopt until I was 30-35 (which is the average age for giving birth in Australia if I’m not mistaken?)
loading...
i forget to mention that this happened 10 years ago, now at 40 he is way past it, He and his wife were told that it took so long for all the paperwork that they would be too old by the time etc.
They have been foster parents since then and often have to hand a child back to a bad situation
loading...
I find the fact that he is 29 and considered too old hard to believe?
loading...
Agree – giving birth to a child doesn’t make you a parent. That’s the easy part. Raising one (and raising one well) makes you a parent. The government needs to stop trying to ‘fix’ families and let willing people become parents.
loading...
Strongly agree. Maintain supervised access where appropriate, so kids can be aware of their history and genetic origins, but there should be many more permanent care/adoption orders granted, when it is what the carers and kids want.
I hope politicians & DHS/equivalent staff read articles & comments like this.
loading...
Australia’s Government should be ashamed of denying these children in care the opportunity to be part of a real loving family instead of being shunted from one place to another. These children are part of our community and have a right to a safe home. The old saying, “it takes a village to raise a child” could not be truer and here we have thousands of people wanting to adopt children and the government has simply put the whole issue in the ‘too hard basket’ and ignored it. I understand the fear behind creating another stolen generation, but this is a far different situation. These children are in state care already, having been removed from homes that were deemed to dangerous or neglectful, etc. Each case is different but surely these children should be given an opportunity for a good start to their future with families who want them! Wake up government fools!!!!!
loading...
FYI Mamamia the CEO’s name is Diane Harapin!! She is a friend of mine and I know all too well how much time (unpaid) her and her colleagues put in to trying to change the government legislation into Australian and overseas adoption process. It’s all red tape and rediculous and yes, very much like the asylum seeker issues.
Diane has 4 kids of her own (1 adopted) and works (paid) as well as putting so much time and energy into NAAW
She is amazing. Please correct her name on the article, it’s important in case people need to contact her
loading...
My aunty is in Thailand meeting her new daughter right now – this precise moment – as I type!
For her and her husband (they have been together for 23 years and married for 5, and he has a 32 year old daughter from a previous marriage, but my aunty has never had any children herself) the process has been very long – 4 years – and there are age limits put in place that state that mothers cannot be any more than 44 years older than the child they adopt. This means that they are adopting a 6 year old orphan.
I know that she and he have a lot of love to give, and as a family we will welcome her warmly. But it does concern me that she doesn’t know English, nor they Thai. I hope she doesn’t have too much trouble adjusting to a completely new family, country, language and culture.
They considered Australian foster children but the process was even more difficult than adopting from overseas – and with no “guarantees” that you can remain their parents forever.
I plan to foster children when I have a family of my own, and it needn’t be forever, just children who need some love and care and safety, for whatever length of time <3
loading...
My frIend has adopted twice from Thailand. They will adapt:) the boys are now 18 and 10 and are doing great. Sure there was a language barrier but it’s really no different to learning what a toddler wants. Good luck to your auntie;)
loading...
Thank you
loading...
I find the amount of children on this site needing a home so upsetting but I do hope that these children are able to find homes that provide them the love and support they need.
loading...
I know these ads are heartbreaking, but surely kids that are permanently in foster care should be afforded more respect than having someone become their guardian. Surely it would be possible for DOCS to have an offshoot department handle this, including offering some sort of transitional programs to let prospective families get to know one another. You’d think it would ease some pressure on foster carers and on the workers to find long term homes for these kids. I know a couple of foster carers and if they take on permanent care of a child, that’s one less “spot” for others that might need it. Just some thoughts….
loading...
RE: Foster Care Adoption
I would like to draw your attention to this website and its various ‘information sheets’ In particular read the ‘Foster Care Adoption’ Link.
http://www.community.nsw.gov.au/docswr/_assets/main/documents/oohc_adoption.pdf
Many foster families simply can not afford the extra burdens that are placed on them when they wish to adopt these kids. In the past (up until this year as a foster parent who chooses to adopt long term placement children you still received an allowance, not anymore thanks to the NSW government. I expect that the rates of Post Foster Care Adoptions will now plummet.
Also you will find this link interesting:
http://www.community.nsw.gov.au/docswr/_assets/main/documents/changes_adoption_allowances_oohc.pdf
” What will change and why?
From 1 January 2012 there will be a change in the financial and other assistance available to new adoptive parents who adopt a child in statutory care. Financial assistance will be provided through an annual lump sum payment of $1500 which will replace fortnightly allowances and contingency payments.
Carers who adopt children in their care do so because they love and want to make a formal, legal commitment to their child – not for financial reasons.
How does this affect families that have already adopted a child?
Carers who have adopted a child and have been receiving a fortnightly allowance will continue to receive the fortnightly allowance until their adopted child turns 18 years of age. Payments to existing carers who have adopted will not change.”
loading...
Unfortunately the sad reality is that not all foster parents are great. There are many examples in NSW of people fostering multiple children and not really up to the job. In fact some do take children in for the money. This is a big issue that does not get addressed as agencies are sometimes desperate to place children. Mamamia should do a story on this sad underbelly of fostering in Australia.
loading...
Whilst there are a minority of carers who may not have truly altruistic motives, please do not lump us all in the same basket. The VAST majority of carers are dedicated to bettering the lives of the children in our care. Trust me, the financial allowances are not so great to compensate for the often arduous and emotional journeys we take with these children. Instead Mamamia should be following up on the real sad underbelly of the foster care system – a broken system which is underfunded and lacks the appropriate supports for the children, and for the carers and DOCS workers who are all trying to make a failing system work. Oh the stories I could tell! Maybe the MM community could be a place where we collectively start to pressure our governments to take a long hard look at the system they have created and force them to take action and start repairing the damage – for the love of children!
loading...
Wow! Are you for real? I am a carer to a nine year old boy. He was his mentally ill mother’s carer while his 75 year old father was/is in prison for attempted murder. This boy does not speak, cries most of the night, displays inappropriate sexualised behaviours, self harms, refuses to eat/shower/go to the toilet/brush his teeth, comes home from his forced contact visits traumatised which causes him to withdraw for days. He is depressed.
On top of all if this I have to deal with the department. The case worker hasn’t visited in five months. I have no idea what is happening with this boy’s case so I cannot get too attached as he will likely go to his Dad when he’s released if his Mum is unable to care for him until then.
His mother demands we get his haircut each week. She wants him to face a new school bag of his choice each term. Because he never knew when food was going to be available he now eats double what my husband eats – and then some. He loses his school hats, jumpers etc every day. And them there are school costs, after school care so I can work part time (docs should cover this but it can take months for a reimbursement). He costs a fortune.
Yep as you can see, I do all of this for the money. All $29.00 a day.
loading...
I’ve always seen myself having an adopted child. My husband and I (and our two girls, I’m sure) would open up our home and hearts to a child who needs a loving family without a second thought. Why is it so hard!?
loading...
I think most people would agree with you, it’s the government who make it hard.
loading...
My husband was adopted from Barnados UK over 45 years ago and his parents received a letter to say their baby was ready to collect. Yes, there were a few checks but it was more about getting children out of orphanages and into good homes. Where has it all gone wrong. Can governments stop thinking about making money and help these poor children get out of these institutions. Since living in Australia, I have come across many families who have given up trying to adopt here. Every day that goes by is lost in red tape, is another day of damage to a child’s health & welfare by being away from a family environment. What can we do to help? We are not in a position to adopt just yet however where do we start to get the government to get their heads out of the sand and take this matter seriously. These children are our future and do not deserve to be ignored.
loading...
We would adopt in a heartbeat…have struggled with fertility issues for years. We have one gorgeous boy and would so love another child but sadly, can’t…
Having looked into the adoption process and it’s traumas, we won’t be applying. 5 or even 10 year waits are shameful…and by that time, I’ll be too old to be considered anyway. And $20000-$50000 dollars is something we don’t have…However, if we knew were could adopt within a reasonable time period (2 years, say) and that at the end of the waiting time, an adoption was guaranteed, we’d get a loan tomorrow! Money really isn’t the issue when it comes down to it.
I know a family who adopted after 7 years waiting. They would love to adopt their son’s siblings, but 5 years later, still are in the cue…even though the siblings are in the same orphanage and the family have already gone through all the checks.
We’ll be fostering…but would love to offer more security…
Australia’s adoption policies are a disgrace…somehow it reminds me of our difficulties in accepting asylum seekers…
loading...
That is disgraceful. Imagine being separated from your sibling, who was adopted out, and left in an orphanage despite the family wanting to take you in as well.
loading...
I agree, it’s heart-wrenching.
That’s why my in-laws adopted siblings. The very reason. They couldn’t stand the idea that siblings were separated through the adoption process.
loading...
Adoption and the processing of asylum seekers are really two separate issues
loading...
it’s heartbreaking to know that this happens in a country like Australia when there is so much need! personally I can’t wait until I’m in a position to foster kids – at least then I can help them feel a little more safe .
loading...
We adopted our fourth child and know first- hand the anti- adoption stance the Australian Government takes. Until it becomes a vote winning issue the government attitude towards adoption will not change.
The Australian public are also very polarised about adoption and some of the comments made to us( in front of our child) make us cringe. I can clearly see why the Australian Government feels there isn’t any public pressure to change adoption laws.
loading...
Seachange – really?? What on earth do people say? I am genuinely curious (and incredulous). I simply can’t imagine what negative comments could apply to such a wonderful and generous action as adopting a child. I have only admiration for people who adopt and think children who are adopted by a loving family are very fortunate. So kudos to you.
loading...
How is adoption ‘generous’? Should they child (who has no say) be forever grateful to their benevolent rescuer? And fortunate? Are you for real? No child should be considered ‘fortunate’ to be given a safe and loving home. The ones who should be grateful and considered fortunate are the adopters, not the child.
You clealry understand nothing about adoption.
loading...
Hi Emily – I’m sorry if I have offended you in some way. I wonder if you have misunderstood my comments?
Every child *deserves* a safe and loving home – no question at all. However that is unfortunately not the reality. Even kids who are living with their own families are not necessarily getting the care they need.
I agree that the families who have the opportunity to adopt children are also very fortunate, but I still maintain that they are generous people. Maybe I have a different idea of what generous means – I am thinking that given the difficulty and expense of adopting in Australia, people who follow it through have a great deal of dedication.
From the point of view of a parent, I know how difficult it can be to raise children, even with the benefit of the hormones that help you bond with them at birth. Of course the joys are amazing too, but it would still be a big step to adopt someone else’s child and start that relationship from scratch with a person who has grown up in a different place/space.
Certainly I don’t have first-hand experience of what it is like to be adopted (perhaps you do?) and I understand that not every experience is positive, which is why I said “a loving family”. But I still think that the opportunity to grow up in a loving, stable family environment is far better for a child than either staying in an abusive and insecure home, or being shifted from one foster family to another ad infinitum.
I think that stories like Punkie’s above are just horrendous and I wonder whose interests are being taken into account in situations like that, because it certainly doesn’t seem like it is the child’s.
I would certainly like to know more about the adoption system and why it costs so much money (who does the money go to?) and time (I get that checks need to be done, but how long does that take?) and why the department(s) seem so anti-adoption, where it is clearly in the interests of the child.
I think this is a topic that is always going to raise very strong emotions at both ends of the scale and as with all emotional topics it is very easy to upset people, so again, I’m sorry if I have caused you distress, that was certainly not my intent.
loading...
At school everyone used to ask me questions about my adoption: ‘Do I know my real parents’, ‘are my sister and I blood-related’, ‘Do I want to meet my real parents’, ‘do I mind talking about it’. This didn’t bother me at all as I have always known about my adoption (it’s kind of obvious in my case) and my parents have always been very open about it all.
It did get me thinking about how little everyone knows about adoption. There isn’t this stigma attached but it’s almost a bit of a mystery which shows the need for more information about adoption to be out there. People were afraid to ask questions in case they offended me.
I know the process was long and expensive for my parents. It took 5 years for them to finally get my sister and then three for them to get me (it’s a lot easier if you already have an adopted child). If my mum would have been able to conceive they wouldn’t have been able to adopt at all. Adoption shouldn’t be a last resort, it should be another option. I know there is a need for strict regulation but there has to be a way to make it more commonplace.
While the site makes me feel a bit icky about the advertising side of it, if it increases the number of adoptions that happen is it really a bad thing?
loading...
I have to agree, the advertising side of it is a bit icky but I think if it helps children get adopted then I don’t think it can be a bad thing. Worse things happen to children in orphanages of the developing world.
loading...
Just looking at the website now, so many children with medical and/or behavioural issues. What chance have these poor kids got?
loading...
Adoption probably is their best chance. Remember, there is a *reason* these kids are not with their birth parents, and those reasons are often quite traumatic for the kids. Injuries and trauma from physical and emotional abuse. Their issues will be hugely difficult for their adoptive families to deal with, for sure, but these kids are victims, and need love and support – not low and negative expectations from the outset.
Trying not to give too many details – I have worked with special needs kids, and remember one whose needs were due to horrific physical abuse from his birth mother as an infant. His mother was his adoptive mother, and was known by the school to be wonderful – involved, patient, compassionate. His issues became apparent to me when, still inexperienced with special needs kids myself, the boy on the cusp of puberty – but with a much lower developmental age – asked sexually suggestive / inappropriate questions. I went straight to my supervisor, as I was concerned his remarks flagged him as an abuse victim (I didn’t know he was adopted). She explained his history, and I was relieved to know that a boy with such clear needs and challenges was getting compassionate, long-term care (I was merely on a five-week placement!). To my horror, staff-room discussion the next day painted him as a ‘weirdo’,and me as a victim of sexual harassment. The child’s remark had been as guileless as they would’ve been from an average 3-4 year old, and in my eyes, nothing could be further from the truth!
My point? Yes, loving and working with these kids has its challenges – but they must not be either blamed, or pandered to. They need guidance and compassion, not judgment!
loading...
I didn’t watch the video but I did click through some pics. I am only 28 but I want to adopt several of these kids!
Being afraid of creating a ‘stolen generation’, while understandable, is just not good enough. Kids needing a stable home deserve better.
The justice system isn’t perfect, but it is the best system we have devised and most of us are happy with how it functions. This system is clearly not functioning well at all – surely there is a way to create something better that we can have confidence is doing the best thing in the majority of cases.
A bit of commonsense would go a long way here.
loading...
Agree. It’s not the same as the stolen generation at all. These days kids are only removed from homes when there is serious abuse/neglect, and often after other interventions have failed. The kids are often old enough to express their wishes to stay with a loving, safe and secure foster/adoptive family.
They can also have ongoing supervised access to genetic parents where appropriate.